I've griped about this issue before, but once again I find myself annoyed.
I was reading "Robots and Empire", by Isaac Asimov. This is possibly the >worst novel Asimov ever wrote. As a story it's mostly well-told, but the >padding and waffle are enough to irritate the most patient reader.
Let me quote from Chapter 45. "I think you must either get to the point,
Dr Mandamus, or leave." This is not the only such case. Many of the >characters in the book are incapable of getting to the point. They take
half a dozen pages to say something that could be put in one chort
paragraph. Get to the point, Dr Asimov. It's so bad that even the
characters in the story are complaining about the padding.
A competent editor could have made this a much better book by cutting it
to about one third of its length.
I wonder whether this hurt Asimov's reputation. I've certainly seen
comments that his later (thick) books are not as good as his earlier
writing.
It's not all his fault. Many other authors are as bad. They're used to
being paid by the page, and publishers are letting them get away with
it. Maybe publishers don't employ editors any more, and have given up
any attempt at quality control. There are some authors that I refuse to
read because their books are too thick.
But surely, I tell myself, the publishers must have noticed that books
don't sell as well as they used to. Or do they? Am I the only person to >complain about this?
Oh, and before Athel has a hissy fit, I've crossposted to a few
literary ngs as well, because it may be of interest to some people
there and so could liven them up a bit, and may even bring some
fresh blood into aue, though that might endanger the cliquishness
that some seem to prize.
It was in the 1980s that popular fiction books started getting fatter
and fatter, and I thought at the time that it must be because
publishers demanded it it. It was also the time when I think many
publishers also demanded an obligatory fuck in every book. It usually
had nothing to do with the story, and I got the impression that some
authors deliberately tried to make it look as though it didn't belong,
and they were only including it because the publishers demanded it.
On Wed, 14 Oct 2026 15:18:22 +1100, Peter Moylan <peter@pmoylan.org>
wrote:
I've griped about this issue before, but once again I find myself annoyed.
I was reading "Robots and Empire", by Isaac Asimov. This is possibly the >worst novel Asimov ever wrote. As a story it's mostly well-told, but the >padding and waffle are enough to irritate the most patient reader.
Let me quote from Chapter 45. "I think you must either get to the point,
Dr Mandamus, or leave." This is not the only such case. Many of the >characters in the book are incapable of getting to the point. They take >half a dozen pages to say something that could be put in one chort >paragraph. Get to the point, Dr Asimov. It's so bad that even the >characters in the story are complaining about the padding.
A competent editor could have made this a much better book by cutting it
to about one third of its length.
I wonder whether this hurt Asimov's reputation. I've certainly seen >comments that his later (thick) books are not as good as his earlier >writing.
It's not all his fault. Many other authors are as bad. They're used to >being paid by the page, and publishers are letting them get away with
it. Maybe publishers don't employ editors any more, and have given up
any attempt at quality control. There are some authors that I refuse to >read because their books are too thick.
But surely, I tell myself, the publishers must have noticed that books >don't sell as well as they used to. Or do they? Am I the only person to >complain about this?
No, you are not the only one to complain about this.
My wife and I have a custom, on birthdays and anniversaries, of going
to a second-hand bookshop and buying each other a number of books.
I find that I automatically choose the thinner book, partly because it
is not as heavy to hold when reading in bed, and partly because, as
you point out, it is likely to have less padding.
But now I hear that many publishers have stopped producing mass-market paperbacks, and trade paperbacks are a lot heavier to hold.
It was in the 1980s that popular fiction books started getting fatter
and fatter, and I thought at the time that it must be because
publishers demanded it it. It was also the time when I think many
publishers also demanded an obligatory fuck in every book. It usually
had nothing to do with the story, and I got the impression that some
authors deliberately tried to make it look as though it didn't belong,
and they were only including it because the publishers demanded it.
Someone recommended the books of Gene Wolfe to me, and the only one I
could find was "The Wizard Knight", which took me 5 months to read --
it was so fat and heavy I could only read a chapter at a time. It
could easily have been edited down from 920 to 420 pages without the
loss of anything but padding. I had to keep going back to find
essential story points I had missed because they were buried in
interminable empty waffle.
Oh, and before Athel has a hissy fit,
literary ngs as well, because it may be of interest to some people
there and so could liven them up a bit, and may even bring some fresh
blood into aue, though that might endanger the cliquishness that some
seem to prize.
It was also the time when I think many publishers also demanded an
obligatory fuck in every book. It usually had nothing to do with the
story, and I got the impression that some authors deliberately tried
to make it look as though it didn't belong, and they were only
including it because the publishers demanded it.
Steve Hayes <hayesstw@telkomsa.net> posted:
Oh, and before Athel has a hissy fit,
Why might I have a hissy fit? I don't have any feelings one way or the other >about what you've written qbove? Are you still upset that I pointed out that >five seconds on the Internet would tell you what sort of football the Newcastle
Knights play?
On Wed, 14 Oct 2026 09:21:00 +0200
Steve Hayes <hayesstw@telkomsa.net> wrote:
It was also the time when I think many publishers also demanded an
obligatory fuck in every book. It usually had nothing to do with the
story, and I got the impression that some authors deliberately tried
to make it look as though it didn't belong, and they were only
including it because the publishers demanded it.
I have long wondered whether Larry Niven's penchant for dry, sexless
sex was due to inability on his part, or a disinclination to put much
effort into something he was only doing at the publisher's behest :/
On Wed, 14 Oct 2026 13:04:33 GMT, athel.cb@gmail.com <user12588@newsgrouper.org.invalid> wrote:
Steve Hayes <hayesstw@telkomsa.net> posted:
Oh, and before Athel has a hissy fit,
Why might I have a hissy fit? I don't have any feelings one way or the other
about what you've written qbove? Are you still upset that I pointed out that >five seconds on the Internet would tell you what sort of football the Newcastle
Knights play?
That wasn't my question. What I wanted to know was what Peter Moylan's default usage of unqualified "football" was. I know he lives about the
middle of the eastern coast of Australia, but different parts of
Australia have different default understandings of "football".
On Wed, 14 Oct 2026 08:02:47 -0700, John Ames
<commodorejohn@gmail.com> wrote:
On Wed, 14 Oct 2026 09:21:00 +0200
Steve Hayes <hayesstw@telkomsa.net> wrote:
It was also the time when I think many publishers also demanded an
obligatory fuck in every book. It usually had nothing to do with the
story, and I got the impression that some authors deliberately tried
to make it look as though it didn't belong, and they were only
including it because the publishers demanded it.
I have long wondered whether Larry Niven's penchant for dry, sexless
sex was due to inability on his part, or a disinclination to put much
effort into something he was only doing at the publisher's behest :/
I haven't read much of Larry Niven's oeuvre, but such gratuitous sex
scenes began to appear from the mid 1970s, and continued for about the
next 20-30 years. If they appeared in Larry Niven's books published in
that period they might well have been included at the behest of the
publisher and described in that manner for that reason.
You may recall "Watership Down", a book in which the main characters
were rabbits. Another author, William Horwood, wrote "Duncton Wood," a similar story about moles.
Ten years later he wrote a sequel, presumably under pressure from his publisher. It wasn't as good as the first one. Then came a third.
He was presumably pressured into writing a second trilogy, and he
wrote each one worse than the last, trying to make the sex scenes as repulsive as possible. It certainly looked as though he was hoping
that the publishers wouldn't ask him for any more after this one.
Steve Hayes <hayesstw@telkomsa.net> posted:
On Wed, 14 Oct 2026 13:04:33 GMT, athel.cb@gmail.com
<user12588@newsgrouper.org.invalid> wrote:
Steve Hayes <hayesstw@telkomsa.net> posted:
Oh, and before Athel has a hissy fit,
Why might I have a hissy fit? I don't have any feelings one way or the other
about what you've written qbove? Are you still upset that I pointed out that
five seconds on the Internet would tell you what sort of football the Newcastle
Knights play?
That wasn't my question. What I wanted to know was what Peter Moylan's
default usage of unqualified "football" was. I know he lives about the
middle of the eastern coast of Australia, but different parts of
Australia have different default understandings of "football".
OK, and now perhaps you can answer my question: why did you think I might have a hissy fit?
On Wed, 14 Oct 2026 08:02:47 -0700, John Ames
<commodorejohn@gmail.com> wrote:
I have long wondered whether Larry Niven's penchant for dry, sexless
sex was due to inability on his part, or a disinclination to put much >>effort into something he was only doing at the publisher's behest :/
I haven't read much of Larry Niven's oeuvre, but such gratuitous sex
scenes began to appear from the mid 1970s, and continued for about the
next 20-30 years. If they appeared in Larry Niven's books published in
that period they might well have been included at the behest of the
publisher and described in that manner for that reason.
You may recall "Watership Down", a book in which the main characters
were rabbits. Another author, William Horwood, wrote "Duncton Wood," a similar story about moles.
Ten years later he wrote a sequel, presumably under pressure from his publisher. It wasn't as good as the first one. Then came a third.
He was presumably pressured into writing a second trilogy, and he
wrote each one worse than the last, trying to make the sex scenes as repulsive as possible. It certainly looked as though he was hoping
that the publishers wouldn't ask him for any more after this one.
On 14/10/26 18:21, Steve Hayes wrote:
Oh, and before Athel has a hissy fit, I've crossposted to a few
literary ngs as well, because it may be of interest to some people
there and so could liven them up a bit, and may even bring some
fresh blood into aue, though that might endanger the cliquishness
that some seem to prize.
Unlike some recent cross-posted threads, you haven't included
sci.relativity, so it's less likely to bring crazy people into the >conversation.
Recent cross-postings did bring fresh blood into AUE, but he's turned
out to have some annoying habits, so my bit bucket might need to grow.
On Wed, 14 Oct 2026 18:31:12 +1100, Peter Moylan <peter@pmoylan.org>
wrote:
On 14/10/26 18:21, Steve Hayes wrote:
Oh, and before Athel has a hissy fit, I've crossposted to a few
literary ngs as well, because it may be of interest to some people
there and so could liven them up a bit, and may even bring some
fresh blood into aue, though that might endanger the cliquishness
that some seem to prize.
Unlike some recent cross-posted threads, you haven't included
sci.relativity, so it's less likely to bring crazy people into the
conversation.
Recent cross-postings did bring fresh blood into AUE, but he's turned
out to have some annoying habits, so my bit bucket might need to grow.
A quick test is to scan for the string "the fact that..." that might indicate poor writing, padding and a boring read,
On 10/16/2026 3:53 AM, Peter Jason wrote:
On Wed, 14 Oct 2026 18:31:12 +1100, Peter Moylan <peter@pmoylan.org>
wrote:
On 14/10/26 18:21, Steve Hayes wrote:
Oh, and before Athel has a hissy fit, I've crossposted to a few
literary ngs as well, because it may be of interest to some people
there and so could liven them up a bit, and may even bring some
fresh blood into aue, though that might endanger the cliquishness
that some seem to prize.
Unlike some recent cross-posted threads, you haven't included
sci.relativity, so it's less likely to bring crazy people into the
conversation.
Recent cross-postings did bring fresh blood into AUE, but he's turned
out to have some annoying habits, so my bit bucket might need to grow.
A quick test is to scan for the string "the fact that..." that might
indicate poor writing, padding and a boring read,
Until some writer reads your Usenet post, and decides to make it a
dialog of a boring, snoring character. So when you do, check if it's
a dialog or narration, and decide from there.
literary ngs as well, because it may be of interest to some people
there
On 14/10/2026 20:21, Steve Hayes wrote:
snippage > Oh, and before Athel has a hissy fit, I've crossposted to a few
literary ngs as well, because it may be of interest to some people
there
Thank you. I think that Peter Moylan's original post would have been
welcomed in r.a.sf.written as well.
On 16/10/26 17:40, Titus G wrote:
On 14/10/2026 20:21, Steve Hayes wrote:
snippage > Oh, and before Athel has a hissy fit, I've crossposted to a
few
literary ngs as well, because it may be of interest to some people
there
Thank you. I think that Peter Moylan's original post would have been
welcomed in r.a.sf.written as well.
Hmm. Do you think I should repost it there? I still have a copy.
On 14/10/2026 20:21, Steve Hayes wrote:
snippage > Oh, and before Athel has a hissy fit, I've crossposted to a few
literary ngs as well, because it may be of interest to some people
there
Thank you. I think that Peter Moylan's original post would have been
welcomed in r.a.sf.written as well.
On Fri, 16 Oct 2026 19:40:16 +1300, Titus G <noone@nowhere.com> wrote:
On 14/10/2026 20:21, Steve Hayes wrote:
snippage > Oh, and before Athel has a hissy fit, I've crossposted to a few >>> literary ngs as well, because it may be of interest to some people
there
Thank you. I think that Peter Moylan's original post would have been
welcomed in r.a.sf.written as well.
Thank you, and apologies for not having posted it there, I only
thought of it afterwards.
On 17/10/2026 20:27, Steve Hayes wrote:
On Fri, 16 Oct 2026 19:40:16 +1300, Titus G <noone@nowhere.com> wrote:
On 14/10/2026 20:21, Steve Hayes wrote:
snippage > Oh, and before Athel has a hissy fit, I've crossposted to a few >>>> literary ngs as well, because it may be of interest to some people
there
Thank you. I think that Peter Moylan's original post would have been
welcomed in r.a.sf.written as well.
Thank you, and apologies for not having posted it there, I only
thought of it afterwards.
Your attributes are incorrect as it was Peter Moylan's post that began
above with "Thank you,....".
On Sun, 18 Oct 2026 09:40:43 +1300, Titus G <noone@nowhere.com> wrote:
On 17/10/2026 20:27, Steve Hayes wrote:
On Fri, 16 Oct 2026 19:40:16 +1300, Titus G <noone@nowhere.com> wrote:
On 14/10/2026 20:21, Steve Hayes wrote:
snippage > Oh, and before Athel has a hissy fit, I've crossposted to a few >>>>> literary ngs as well, because it may be of interest to some people
there
Thank you. I think that Peter Moylan's original post would have been
welcomed in r.a.sf.written as well.
Thank you, and apologies for not having posted it there, I only
thought of it afterwards.
Your attributes are incorrect as it was Peter Moylan's post that began
above with "Thank you,....".
Peter Moylan was thanking himself?
On 2026-10-16, Steve Hayes wrote:
On Thu, 15 Oct 2026 12:46:04 +0100, Adam Funk <a24061@ducksburg.com>
wrote:
Do you mean sex scenes involving moles? I imagine that's an unusual >>>interest.
Probably no more unusual than those involving rabbits in "Watership
Down".
I don't recall actual sex scenes in that book, although there was a
quite a bit about perpetuating the species (for which rabbits have a >reputation).
The awkward thing about both these is that the more you do something, the less >it takes out of you, the fewer incremental new neuronal connections you need >for learning in that area.
My rule of thumb on preventing cognitive decline, which is mostly the loss of >ability to retain new memories, is to constantly practice storing new memories,
learn something difficult that yourCOre bad at.
So a couple of months of DOOM, then Kant in German with some assessment by an >external party that yourCOve understood it, then learn 500 Kanji with flashcards
until yourCOre happy yourCOve retained them, then join Toastmasters for six months
and get to the point you and your audience are happy with your speeches, then, >then, then ...
I donrCOt phrase it in quite as daunting a way to patients.
On 16/10/26 17:40, Titus G wrote:snippage
I think that Peter Moylan's original post would have been
welcomed in r.a.sf.written as well.
Hmm. Do you think I should repost it there? I still have a copy.
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 60:37:54 |
| Calls: | 1,265 |
| Calls today: | 1 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
4 files (9,632K bytes) |
| Messages: | 286,219 |