• Another Design Flaw in MMP Exposed

    From wn@wn@nosuch.com (Willy Nilly) to nz.general on Sun Nov 8 19:54:48 2026
    From Newsgroup: nz.general

    The MMP election system is bad enough without additional flaws being
    built into it, but that's what's been done. The Maori seat overhang is
    an absurd flaw which could/should have been hermetically sealed off.

    The Maori seats (which should be abolished but that's another matter)
    represent a separate electoral roll. Only the Maori roll can elect
    those electorate MPs. But TPM's shananigans have exposed that the
    Maori roll party votes cross over into the General roll party votes --
    the party votes are all in one unified roll. But why is that?
    Clearly, the Maori roll should have their own electorate MPs and their
    own list MPs. Instead of 7 electorate MPs they should have, say, 4
    electorate MPs and 3 list MPs. Then TPM's antics are contained within
    their own 7-MP roll and they cannot get up to their overhang tricks.

    Without the TPM overhang tactic, the countering General-roll
    split-vote overhang campaign would not have happened (mind you, I've
    been splitting my vote for a few elections already).

    MMP is a crap electoral system which has been implemented even
    crappier. The Aussie preferential system is soooo much simpler and
    better.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From wn@wn@nosuch.com (Willy Nilly) to nz.general on Sun Nov 8 21:49:08 2026
    From Newsgroup: nz.general

    ... aanndd now RNZ is doubting MMP too. Interesting article at https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/politics_election-2026/2448753/election-results-was-the-overhang-artificially-caused

    But at the end they say: "He said all the international solutions
    could be all be on the table. "We could look at all of them and see
    which one works out for New Zealand"."
    Sound familiar? We're heading back to Square Zero. Let's see what
    the media endorse next time around. Whatever they pick, go with one
    of the other ones.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Gordon@Gordon@leaf.net.nz to nz.general on Sun Nov 8 23:34:47 2026
    From Newsgroup: nz.general

    On 2026-11-08, Willy Nilly <wn@nosuch.com> wrote:
    ... aanndd now RNZ is doubting MMP too. Interesting article at https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/politics_election-2026/2448753/election-results-was-the-overhang-artificially-caused

    Well they need something for the next three weeks until the final results
    come in.

    But at the end they say: "He said all the international solutions
    could be all be on the table. "We could look at all of them and see
    which one works out for New Zealand"."

    I think any review would have a very large table to put all options on it.
    And a great deal of time and money to do the review.

    Sound familiar? We're heading back to Square Zero. Let's see what
    the media endorse next time around. Whatever they pick, go with one
    of the other ones.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Gordon@Gordon@leaf.net.nz to nz.general on Sun Nov 8 23:58:38 2026
    From Newsgroup: nz.general

    On 2026-11-08, Willy Nilly <wn@nosuch.com> wrote:
    The MMP election system is bad enough without additional flaws being
    built into it, but that's what's been done. The Maori seat overhang is
    an absurd flaw which could/should have been hermetically sealed off.

    The Maori seats (which should be abolished but that's another matter) represent a separate electoral roll. Only the Maori roll can elect
    those electorate MPs. But TPM's shananigans have exposed that the
    Maori roll party votes cross over into the General roll party votes --
    the party votes are all in one unified roll. But why is that?
    Clearly, the Maori roll should have their own electorate MPs and their
    own list MPs. Instead of 7 electorate MPs they should have, say, 4 electorate MPs and 3 list MPs. Then TPM's antics are contained within
    their own 7-MP roll and they cannot get up to their overhang tricks.

    Without the TPM overhang tactic, the countering General-roll
    split-vote overhang campaign would not have happened (mind you, I've
    been splitting my vote for a few elections already).

    If one looks at the voting at/on https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/election-2026-results/electorates

    There is alot of vote splitting going on.

    Voters are not voting for the candidate and also they party they like. Some voters are seening the candidate as their MP, and the party as another vote which is separate.

    New parties four of them have broken the 5% barrier and are now altering Government of the FPP days. No longer can a party rule without 50.1% of the vote, and a coalition.



    MMP is a crap electoral system which has been implemented even
    crappier. The Aussie preferential system is soooo much simpler and
    better.

    There is not perfect system to get proportional representation, so iy comes down to wahat is the best, which is a matter of personal opinon.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2