• Rudiments of the 2026 Special Votes

    From wn@wn@nosuch.com (Willy Nilly) to nz.general on Sun Nov 8 04:15:17 2026
    From Newsgroup: nz.general

    Journalists are beyond dumb with their proclamations that National
    will lose 2 seats when the special votes are counted "because that's
    what happened the last 3 times". Um, National had list seats to lose
    last time, but in 2026 they have 0 list seats so cannot lose any, duh.

    Instead NZF is likely to lose a list seat and so will Opportunity.
    The Greens will pick up one, and the other to Labour or the Greens.

    This election will be settled FPP-style in the arenas, er, electorates
    of Hamilton East, Mt Roskill, and Wairarapa. All of these feature
    National gains in vote share in 2023. But in turn:

    Hamilton East: currently Nats +456 votes. In the 2023 specials the
    Nats picked up an extra 1079 votes margin. Hamilton East stays Nat.

    Mt Roskill, currently Labour +262 votes. In the 2023 special vote the
    Nats picked up only 135 extra margin, but Labour increased their vote
    share. Labour will do better this time -- Mt Roskill stays Labour.

    Wairarapa, currently Nats +139 votes. In the 2023 special votes the
    Nats & Labour equally increased their votes, so the percentages did
    not change. Look for the same thing to happen this time. However,
    the special voters are probably not as aware of the "split your votes" campaign, so say less of NZF electorate votes go to Butterick, about
    100 less. Willy's call: Nats to hold Wairarapa but by less than 50
    votes. As a PS, in 1979 Labour won this seat by one vote --
    subsequently overturned in a judicial appeal.

    Everybody enjoy this FPP election, and be sure to laugh at the
    journalists' predictions.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Average Joe@average.joe@maildrop.ue to nz.general on Sun Nov 8 21:08:42 2026
    From Newsgroup: nz.general

    Willy Nilly wrote:

    Journalists are beyond dumb with their proclamations that National
    will lose 2 seats when the special votes are counted "because that's
    what happened the last 3 times". Um, National had list seats to lose
    last time, but in 2026 they have 0 list seats so cannot lose any, duh.

    In 2023, It was 2 electorate seats which National lost when the special
    votes were counted. National could still lose electorate seats in 2026.

    2023 preliminary count: National 45 electorate, 5 list, 50 total
    2023 official results: National 43 electorate, 5 list, 48 total

    The journalists do know their facts. If anyone is "beyond dumb", it
    would be the one who thinks it was list seats lost last time.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From wn@wn@nosuch.com (Willy Nilly) to nz.general on Sun Nov 8 19:12:39 2026
    From Newsgroup: nz.general

    On Sun, 8 Nov 2026, Average Joe <average.joe@maildrop.ue> wrote:
    Willy Nilly wrote:
    National had list seats to lose last time,
    but in 2026 they have 0 list seats so cannot lose any, duh.

    In 2023, It was 2 electorate seats which National lost when the special
    votes were counted. National could still lose electorate seats in 2026.
    2023 preliminary count: National 45 electorate, 5 list, 50 total
    2023 official results: National 43 electorate, 5 list, 48 total

    Interesting point, could you be so kind as to identify which 2
    electorates flipped in 2023?

    Separately, RNZ has an article today which is actually informative: https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/politics_election-2026/2448587/how-399-000-votes-could-cost-christopher-luxon-his-majority

    They lead of with words like "shambles" and "near-farcical" but
    haven't as yet identified that it is their hallowed MMP which is the
    cause of the mess -- they need more time to awaken to that. And there
    is a nice discussion of how various possible changes will alter the
    size of Parliament as well, meaning an outcome switch can end up being
    just half-a-switch. All very funny for those whose eyes don't cross
    whilst trying to keep it all straight in their minds.

    Luxon has said he would introduce a new plebiscite about our voting
    system. This reconsideration is gonna have a lot more popular support
    than previously supposed, after this clown-show election of 2026.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From wn@wn@nosuch.com (Willy Nilly) to nz.general on Sun Nov 8 20:26:46 2026
    From Newsgroup: nz.general

    On Sun, 08 Nov 2026, wn@nosuch.com (Willy Nilly) wrote:
    On Sun, 8 Nov 2026, Average Joe <average.joe@maildrop.ue> wrote:
    Willy Nilly wrote:
    National had list seats to lose last time,
    but in 2026 they have 0 list seats so cannot lose any, duh.

    In 2023, It was 2 electorate seats which National lost when the special
    votes were counted. National could still lose electorate seats in 2026.
    2023 preliminary count: National 45 electorate, 5 list, 50 total
    2023 official results: National 43 electorate, 5 list, 48 total

    Even so, it was still list seats they lost. If it were not so, then
    National, upon losing 2 electorate seats, would have gained 2 list
    seats to compensate. They would have ended with:
    2023 hypothetical results: National 43 electorate, 7 list, 50 total

    But they lost 2 list seats due to reduced list vote percentage.

    We'll see if they lose any electorate seats this time around. As I
    wrote elsewhere, it's looking like they will retain their 42 seats.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2