• Re: dizum is still down

    From Gab_Virebent@gabriel1@virebent.invalid to alt.privacy.anon-server,news.software.readers on Mon Sep 21 22:24:41 2026
    From Newsgroup: news.software.readers

    Alex de Joode wrote:
    I line with the Unix philosofy:

    A m2n-gw sends messages form email to usenet. It does not perform any other functions. (so it takes the MessageID and uses that)

    A remailer/mixmaster anonymizes mail messages.

    Both have their own function and complement each other:)

    TCPResetrCOs Message-ID rewriting was intended as a privacy precaution for direct email submissions, which do not necessarily pass through a remailer.

    However, I accept that this choice can interfere with
    duplicate suppression when the same message is submitted through
    multiple gateways...

    RFC 5537 explicitly describes multiple injection as an unusual case,
    although a supported one. I hadnrCOt accounted for that workflow.

    How widely is it actually used outside OmniMix?

    To settle the matter once and for all, i hace changed the Message-ID generation behavior but that *does not address that issue*.

    The relevant question is whether the same original message retains a consistent identity across those paths.

    Your point about preserving an existing Message-ID in a remailer-to-news workflow is fair.

    Best Regards

    Gabx
    --
    https://contact.virebent.art
    gemini://contact.virebent.art

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Fritz Wuehler@fritz@spamexpire-202609.rodent.frell.theremailer.net to alt.privacy.anon-server,news.software.readers on Tue Sep 22 01:44:27 2026
    From Newsgroup: news.software.readers

    Gab_Virebent <gabriel1@virebent.invalid> wrote:
    Alex de Joode wrote:

    A m2n-gw sends messages form email to usenet. It does not perform any other >> functions. (so it takes the MessageID and uses that)

    To settle the matter once and for all, i hace changed the Message-ID >generation behavior but that *does not address that issue*.

    For remailer users it's easy to settle that matter once and for all by continuing to ignore your deliberately incompatible, thus broken services.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Gab_Virebent@gabriel1@virebent.invalid to alt.privacy.anon-server,news.software.readers on Tue Sep 22 02:19:16 2026
    From Newsgroup: news.software.readers

    Fritz Wuehler wrote:
    Gab_Virebent <gabriel1@virebent.invalid> wrote:
    Alex de Joode wrote:

    A m2n-gw sends messages form email to usenet. It does not perform any other >>> functions. (so it takes the MessageID and uses that)

    To settle the matter once and for all, i hace changed the Message-ID
    generation behavior but that *does not address that issue*.

    For remailer users it's easy to settle that matter once and for all by continuing to ignore your deliberately incompatible, thus broken services.


    :)
    --
    https://contact.virebent.art
    gemini://contact.virebent.art
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Nomen Nescio@nobody@dizum.com to alt.privacy.anon-server,news.software.readers on Tue Sep 22 07:28:55 2026
    From Newsgroup: news.software.readers

    On 21 Sep 2026, Fritz Wuehler <fritz@spamexpire-202609.rodent.frell.theremailer.net> posted some news:3bf12b3c4833aecfb11d8506cf1c1b6e@msgid.frell.theremailer.net:

    Gab_Virebent <gabriel1@virebent.invalid> wrote:
    Alex de Joode wrote:

    A m2n-gw sends messages form email to usenet. It does not perform
    any other functions. (so it takes the MessageID and uses that)

    To settle the matter once and for all, i hace changed the Message-ID >>generation behavior but that *does not address that issue*.

    For remailer users it's easy to settle that matter once and for all by continuing to ignore your deliberately incompatible, thus broken
    services.

    Which came first, the chicken or the egg?

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Joe Fretzl@jfretzl@nowhere.invalid to alt.privacy.anon-server,news.software.readers on Tue Sep 22 08:43:53 2026
    From Newsgroup: news.software.readers

    On 21 Sep 2026, Fritz Wuehler <fritz@spamexpire-202609.rodent.frell.theremailer.net> posted some news:3bf12b3c4833aecfb11d8506cf1c1b6e@msgid.frell.theremailer.net:

    Gab_Virebent <gabriel1@virebent.invalid> wrote:
    Alex de Joode wrote:

    A m2n-gw sends messages form email to usenet. It does not perform
    any other functions. (so it takes the MessageID and uses that)

    To settle the matter once and for all, i hace changed the Message-ID >>generation behavior but that *does not address that issue*.

    For remailer users it's easy to settle that matter once and for all by continuing to ignore your deliberately incompatible, thus broken
    services.

    I've tested with both. They work, haven't seen any dupes yet.

    We need to recruit some remailers.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Librarian2025@librarian2025@cock.li to alt.privacy.anon-server,news.software.readers on Wed Sep 23 10:35:40 2026
    From Newsgroup: news.software.readers


    Gab_Virebent <gabriel1@virebent.invalid> writes:

    Alex de Joode wrote:
    I line with the Unix philosofy:

    A m2n-gw sends messages form email to usenet. It does not perform any other >> functions. (so it takes the MessageID and uses that)

    A remailer/mixmaster anonymizes mail messages.

    Both have their own function and complement each other:)

    TCPResetrCOs Message-ID rewriting was intended as a privacy precaution for direct email submissions, which do not necessarily pass through a remailer.

    However, I accept that this choice can interfere with
    duplicate suppression when the same message is submitted through
    multiple gateways...

    RFC 5537 explicitly describes multiple injection as an unusual case, although a supported one. I hadnrCOt accounted for that workflow.

    How widely is it actually used outside OmniMix?

    To settle the matter once and for all, i hace changed the Message-ID generation behavior but that *does not address that issue*.

    If you insist on having such feature as replacing original Message-ID
    with your own, then why not have two mail2news services?

    mail2news@mail2news.tcpreset.net - replaces Message-ID m2n@mail2news.tcpreset.net - preserves Message-ID

    Document it on your website and let users decide.

    The relevant question is whether the same original message retains a consistent identity across those paths.

    Your point about preserving an existing Message-ID in a remailer-to-news workflow is fair.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Librarian2025@librarian2025@cock.li to alt.privacy.anon-server,news.software.readers on Wed Sep 23 10:53:34 2026
    From Newsgroup: news.software.readers


    Also, I noticed that your mail2news service inserts this line:

    Comments: This message did not originate from the Sender address
    above. It was posted by the mail-to-news gateway at news.tcpreset.net.

    This is not correct. This line should be inserted by anonymous
    remailers, mail2news services themselves do not provide anonymity
    (unless you also replace From header). My email address is where my
    message originated from. I don't use mail2news service for "anonymity",
    I'm just too lazy to register anywhere.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Gab_Virebent@gabriel1@virebent.invalid to alt.privacy.anon-server,news.software.readers on Wed Sep 23 19:51:34 2026
    From Newsgroup: news.software.readers

    Librarian2025 wrote:

    Also, I noticed that your mail2news service inserts this line:

    Comments: This message did not originate from the Sender address
    above. It was posted by the mail-to-news gateway at news.tcpreset.net.

    On the substance you were right, so the header is gone. The gateway no
    longer adds a Comment: line. If you want one on your own articles, put
    it in your own client and the filter passes it through untouched.

    This is not correct. This line should be inserted by anonymous
    remailers, mail2news services themselves do not provide anonymity
    (unless you also replace From header). My email address is where my
    message originated from. I don't use mail2news service for "anonymity",
    I'm just too lazy to register anywhere.


    Nothing about this gateway ever claimed to provide anonymity, and it
    does not. Your From: goes out byte for byte as submitted, which is why
    your real address sat on that article.

    The deleted Comments: line was a canned string inherited from the
    Nym-mixnet injection path, where From: is legitimately rewritten and the posting genuinely is anonymous.
    It should never have been applied to ordinary mail submissions.

    Corrected.

    As for From: handling itself, the tool already gives you the
    conventional Usenet mechanism: the _nospam recipient variant, documented
    in crooks/mail2news (github.com/crooks/mail2news) and used across
    mail2news installs for decades. Address the gateway as
    mail2news_nospam-...@ and it rewrites your From: into a sentinel address
    and moves your real one to Author-Supplied-Address. An anti-spam
    convention, not anonymity, and always the poster's opt-in, never a
    gateway default.

    Best Regards
    Gabx
    --
    https://contact.virebent.art
    gemini://contact.virebent.art
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2