• Proposed new group: comp.ai.chatgpt

    From Phil Carson@phil@emailphil.com to news.groups.proposals on Fri Aug 7 14:07:58 2026
    From Newsgroup: news.groups.proposals

    I would like to discuss creating a new unmoderated Big-8 newsgroup, comp.ai.chatgpt, devoted specifically to ChatGPT.

    I searched the current newsgroup list and did not find a group dedicated
    to ChatGPT. ChatGPT-related discussion can take place in broader AI
    groups, but those groups cover much larger subject areas and do not
    provide an obvious home for practical user-to-user discussion of
    ChatGPT as a service and platform.

    My proposed scope would include:

    practical use of ChatGPT;
    ChatGPT features, models, and changes affecting users;
    prompting techniques and workflows;
    troubleshooting and unexpected behavior;
    comparisons among ChatGPT models and features;
    integrations and applications involving ChatGPT;
    reliability, limitations, privacy, and other issues directly related
    to using ChatGPT;
    OpenAI developments when they directly affect ChatGPT users.

    General artificial-intelligence discussion unrelated to ChatGPT would
    remain better suited to existing AI groups. General OpenAI API
    programming that is not specifically related to ChatGPT would likewise
    be outside the intended scope.

    I am proposing the group as unmoderated.
    A possible newsgroups description line would be:
    comp.ai.chatgpt Practical use of OpenAI's conversational AI service.

    I am open to suggestions about the group name, its placement within the
    Big-8 hierarchy, and the proposed scope. In particular, I would be
    interested in hearing whether comp.ai.chatgpt is preferable to a
    broader generative-AI group or whether a different name would fit the
    existing hierarchy better.

    Most importantly, I would like to know whether there are Usenet users
    who would actually read or post to this group if it were created. If
    you would use the proposed group, please say so in this thread.

    If there is sufficient interest, I am willing to act as proponent and
    develop a formal RFD for submission to news.announce.newgroups.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Marco Moock@mm@dorfdsl.de to news.groups.proposals on Fri Aug 7 15:44:44 2026
    From Newsgroup: news.groups.proposals

    Am 07.08.26 um 20:07 schrieb Phil Carson:
    I would like to discuss creating a new unmoderated Big-8 newsgroup, comp.ai.chatgpt, devoted specifically to ChatGPT.

    Is there a special reason to stick that to ChatGPT?What about other with similar functionality?

    Most importantly, I would like to know whether there are Usenet users
    who would actually read or post to this group if it were created. If
    you would use the proposed group, please say so in this thread.

    I would read and maybe also post, but not much, as I currently do not
    use AI.
    --
    Gru|f
    Marco

    Junk-Mail bitte an trashcan@stinkedores.dorfdsl.de

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From The True Melissa@thetruemelissa@gmail.comNOSPAM to news.groups.proposals on Sat Aug 8 05:13:27 2026
    From Newsgroup: news.groups.proposals

    Phil Carson wrote in article <11555li$rars$1@dont-email.me>:

    I would like to discuss creating a new unmoderated Big-8 newsgroup, comp.ai.chatgpt, devoted specifically to ChatGPT.

    I searched the current newsgroup list and did not find a group dedicated
    to ChatGPT. ChatGPT-related discussion can take place in broader AI
    groups, but those groups cover much larger subject areas and do not
    provide an obvious home for practical user-to-user discussion of
    ChatGPT as a service and platform.

    comp.ai already isn't busy. Why not just use that?


    I am open to suggestions about the group name, its placement within
    the
    Big-8 hierarchy, and the proposed scope. In particular, I would be
    interested in hearing whether comp.ai.chatgpt is preferable to a
    broader generative-AI group or whether a different name would fit the existing hierarchy better.

    As long as Usenet is as small as it currently is, IMO it makes more
    sense to keep all the AI discussion in comp.ai. I'm subscribed to that,
    and there's usually nothing in it.


    Most importantly, I would like to know whether there are Usenet users
    who would actually read or post to this group if it were created. If
    you would use the proposed group, please say so in this thread.

    I suppose I'd read a new one, but there are enough very-low-traffic
    groups already, IMO. We need more people, not more groups.
    --
    The meek shall inherit, we're told,
    But I'm not so easily sold.
    For supposing they should,
    It would do them no good --
    They'd lose it at once to the bold.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Phil Carson@phil@emailphil.com to news.groups.proposals on Sat Aug 8 05:13:48 2026
    From Newsgroup: news.groups.proposals

    On Fri, 7 Aug 2026 15:44:44 EDT, Marco Moock wrote:

    Is there a special reason to stick that to ChatGPT?What about other with similar functionality?

    There is. My reason for proposing a ChatGPT-specific group is that I think ChatGPT is a large enough subject in its own right to justify focused discussion.

    There are a lot of things that are specifically relevant to ChatGPT users
    rCo its features and models, changes to the service, prompting and
    workflows, troubleshooting, privacy issues, integrations, and so on. If Claude, Gemini, Copilot and every other similar service were included, I
    think the group would become a general conversational-AI group rather than
    the ChatGPT user group IrCOm proposing.

    That broader subject could certainly be worthwhile, but I see it as a different group with a different charter.

    I would read and maybe also post, but not much, as I currently do not
    use AI.

    Thanks for the feedback, and especially for saying you would read the
    group and might post to it.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Phil Carson@phil@emailphil.com to news.groups.proposals on Sat Aug 8 15:30:08 2026
    From Newsgroup: news.groups.proposals

    On Sat, 8 Aug 2026 05:13:27 EDT, The True Melissa wrote:


    comp.ai already isn't busy. Why not just use that?

    As long as Usenet is as small as it currently is, IMO it makes more
    sense to keep all the AI discussion in comp.ai. I'm subscribed to that,
    and there's usually nothing in it.

    I suppose I'd read a new one, but there are enough very-low-traffic
    groups already, IMO. We need more people, not more groups.

    ThatrCOs a fair concern, and I agree that creating another empty newsgroup would serve no purpose.

    My reason for not simply using comp.ai is that comp.ai is a general artificial-intelligence group, while what IrCOm proposing is specifically a user group for practical discussion of ChatGPT as a service and platform. Those seem like substantially different subjects to me.

    At the same time, IrCOm not assuming that simply creating comp.ai.chatgpt would magically produce traffic. ThatrCOs one of the reasons I started with
    an informal proposal rather than going straight to an RFD. I want to find
    out whether there are actually enough Usenet users who would read and participate in a ChatGPT-specific group to make it worthwhile.

    If that interest isnrCOt there, then creating another empty group obviously wouldnrCOt make sense.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Big-8 Management Board@board@big-8.org to news.groups.proposals on Sun Aug 23 12:39:30 2026
    From Newsgroup: news.groups.proposals

    In article <11555li$rars$1@dont-email.me>, phil@emailphil.com says...

    If there is sufficient interest, I am willing to act as proponent and
    develop a formal RFD for submission to news.announce.newgroups.

    Hi Phil,

    You wrote up an RFD and submitted it a few days ago. However, all the
    line breaks were missing for some unknown reason, so it was one big unformatted wall of text. We thought you'd want to fix that before
    publishing it, so we rejected the submission.

    However, we think you might not have received the email telling you
    this, because it turns out that your mail server is rejecting mail from
    our IP range.

    Please feel free to resubmit your RFD whenever you're ready.

    Kind regards,
    Big-8 Management Board

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From noel@deletethis@invalid.lan to news.groups.proposals on Mon Aug 24 18:36:12 2026
    From Newsgroup: news.groups.proposals

    On Sun, 23 Aug 2026 12:39:30 -0400, Big-8 Management Board wrote:

    In article <11555li$rars$1@dont-email.me>, phil@emailphil.com says...

    If there is sufficient interest, I am willing to act as proponent and
    develop a formal RFD for submission to news.announce.newgroups.

    Hi Phil,

    You wrote up an RFD and submitted it a few days ago. However, all the
    line breaks were missing for some unknown reason, so it was one big unformatted wall of text. We thought you'd want to fix that before
    publishing it, so we rejected the submission.

    However, we think you might not have received the email telling you
    this, because it turns out that your mail server is rejecting mail from
    our IP range.

    Please feel free to resubmit your RFD whenever you're ready.

    Kind regards,
    Big-8 Management Board

    if your mail server is rejected Marco, you should at lest tell them why.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Marco Moock@mm@dorfdsl.de to news.groups.proposals on Tue Aug 25 14:01:55 2026
    From Newsgroup: news.groups.proposals

    Am 25.08.26 um 00:36 schrieb noel:
    On Sun, 23 Aug 2026 12:39:30 -0400, Big-8 Management Board wrote:

    In article <11555li$rars$1@dont-email.me>, phil@emailphil.com says...

    If there is sufficient interest, I am willing to act as proponent and
    develop a formal RFD for submission to news.announce.newgroups.

    Hi Phil,

    You wrote up an RFD and submitted it a few days ago. However, all the
    line breaks were missing for some unknown reason, so it was one big
    unformatted wall of text. We thought you'd want to fix that before
    publishing it, so we rejected the submission.

    However, we think you might not have received the email telling you
    this, because it turns out that your mail server is rejecting mail from
    our IP range.

    Please feel free to resubmit your RFD whenever you're ready.

    Kind regards,
    Big-8 Management Board

    if your mail server is rejected Marco, you should at lest tell them why.

    It wasn't me who wrote the message, although I found the bounce:

    Action: failed
    Status: 5.0.0
    Remote-MTA: dns; redbull.mxrouting.net
    Diagnostic-Code: smtp; 550-Unauthenticated mail not allowed from this
    range to
    protected domain, 550 nonspam senders request whitelisting at
    esf.mxroute.com

    We have SPF and DKIM, I do not know why they reject it anyway.
    --
    Gru|f
    Marco

    Spam bitte an abfalleimer2001@stinkedores.dorfdsl.de

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Ray Banana@rayban@raybanana.net to news.groups.proposals on Wed Aug 26 03:01:48 2026
    From Newsgroup: news.groups.proposals

    Thus spake Marco Moock <mm@dorfdsl.de>

    It wasn't me who wrote the message, although I found the bounce:

    Action: failed
    Status: 5.0.0
    Remote-MTA: dns; redbull.mxrouting.net
    Diagnostic-Code: smtp; 550-Unauthenticated mail not allowed from this
    range to
    protected domain, 550 nonspam senders request whitelisting at
    esf.mxroute.com

    We have SPF and DKIM, I do not know why they reject it anyway.

    "Expert Spam Filtering Whitelist Request" looks to me like
    "We don't care about what everybody else does, we know better".

    https://esf.mxroute.com/
    --
    -f-a|U-e-u-+ rCo -a-a-|-+-+|U
    https://www.eternal-september.org

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From noel@deletethis@invalid.lan to news.groups.proposals on Wed Aug 26 08:30:14 2026
    From Newsgroup: news.groups.proposals

    On Tue, 25 Aug 2026 14:01:55 -0400, Marco Moock wrote:

    if your mail server is rejected Marco, you should at lest tell them
    why.

    It wasn't me who wrote the message, although I found the bounce:

    Action: failed Status: 5.0.0 Remote-MTA: dns; redbull.mxrouting.net Diagnostic-Code: smtp; 550-Unauthenticated mail not allowed from this
    range to
    protected domain, 550 nonspam senders request whitelisting at
    esf.mxroute.com

    We have SPF and DKIM, I do not know why they reject it anyway.

    LOL, they deserve all the radio silence they get, I haven't seen crap
    like since since early 2000's, they, as Ray points out, expect their
    senders to request whitelisting, theres a reason that rubbish lasted
    barely months with next to no uptake back then, because nobody was going
    to play those games, you're not doing anything wrong Marco (this time :P )

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Marco Moock@mm@dorfdsl.de to news.groups.proposals on Wed Aug 26 10:10:11 2026
    From Newsgroup: news.groups.proposals

    Am 26.08.26 um 14:30 schrieb noel:
    LOL, they deserve all the radio silence they get, I haven't seen crap
    like since since early 2000's, they, as Ray points out, expect their
    senders to request whitelisting, theres a reason that rubbish lasted
    barely months with next to no uptake back then, because nobody was going
    to play those games, you're not doing anything wrong Marco (this time :P )

    A large German email service (T-Online) does the same crap.
    --
    Gru|f
    Marco

    Spam bitte an abfalleimer2001@stinkedores.dorfdsl.de

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Adam H. Kerman@ahk@chinet.com to news.groups.proposals on Wed Aug 26 17:58:37 2026
    From Newsgroup: news.groups.proposals

    Marco Moock <mm@dorfdsl.de> wrote:
    Am 25.08.26 um 00:36 schrieb noel:
    On Sun, 23 Aug 2026 12:39:30 -0400, Big-8 Management Board wrote: >>>phil@emailphil.com says...

    If there is sufficient interest, I am willing to act as proponent and >>>>develop a formal RFD for submission to news.announce.newgroups.

    You wrote up an RFD and submitted it a few days ago. However, all the >>>line breaks were missing for some unknown reason, so it was one big >>>unformatted wall of text. We thought you'd want to fix that before >>>publishing it, so we rejected the submission.

    However, we think you might not have received the email telling you
    this, because it turns out that your mail server is rejecting mail from >>>our IP range.

    Please feel free to resubmit your RFD whenever you're ready.

    if your mail server is rejected Marco, you should at lest tell them why.

    It wasn't me who wrote the message, although I found the bounce:

    Action: failed
    Status: 5.0.0
    Remote-MTA: dns; redbull.mxrouting.net
    Diagnostic-Code: smtp; 550-Unauthenticated mail not allowed from this
    range to
    protected domain, 550 nonspam senders request whitelisting at
    esf.mxroute.com

    We have SPF and DKIM, I do not know why they reject it anyway.

    Please reply by postal mail. Whitelisting isn't required.

    No spam at all is getting through as communication is being prevented
    entirely. The perfect setup!

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From noel@deletethis@invalid.lan to news.groups.proposals on Thu Aug 27 07:13:59 2026
    From Newsgroup: news.groups.proposals

    On Wed, 26 Aug 2026 10:10:11 -0400, Marco Moock wrote:

    Am 26.08.26 um 14:30 schrieb noel:
    LOL, they deserve all the radio silence they get, I haven't seen crap
    like since since early 2000's, they, as Ray points out, expect their
    senders to request whitelisting, theres a reason that rubbish lasted
    barely months with next to no uptake back then, because nobody was
    going to play those games, you're not doing anything wrong Marco (this
    time :P )

    A large German email service (T-Online) does the same crap.

    I'd think most of T's customers would use a freemailer then (wonder if T
    in USA does it too) wouldn't they...

    Either way, that's still crazy, most German mail received here has always
    been gmx, see them in the logs everytime i've had to look at them.

    Anyways, I hope, Phil was it, has sorted his mail problems out and chimes
    in to let you know.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Marco Moock@mm@dorfdsl.de to news.groups.proposals on Thu Aug 27 08:27:33 2026
    From Newsgroup: news.groups.proposals

    Am 27.08.26 um 13:13 schrieb noel:
    On Wed, 26 Aug 2026 10:10:11 -0400, Marco Moock wrote:

    Am 26.08.26 um 14:30 schrieb noel:
    LOL, they deserve all the radio silence they get, I haven't seen crap
    like since since early 2000's, they, as Ray points out, expect their
    senders to request whitelisting, theres a reason that rubbish lasted
    barely months with next to no uptake back then, because nobody was
    going to play those games, you're not doing anything wrong Marco (this
    time :P )

    A large German email service (T-Online) does the same crap.

    I'd think most of T's customers would use a freemailer then (wonder if T
    in USA does it too) wouldn't they...

    In the past the mail service was part of the ISP offer, but nowadays it
    is a freemailer that gains money by serving ads in the web interface and
    news portal.

    Although, many people still use their old addresses from the time when
    they were bound to the internet access offer.

    Anyways, I hope, Phil was it, has sorted his mail problems out and chimes
    in to let you know.

    They whitelisted the IP of the big-8.com server.
    --
    Gru|f
    Marco

    Please send unsolicited mail to dustbin12@stinkedores.dorfdsl.de

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From ReK2 Hispagatos@rek2@usenet_reborn.tui to news.groups.proposals on Sun Sep 20 14:52:31 2026
    From Newsgroup: news.groups.proposals

    [in reply to Phil Carson <<11555li$rars$1@dont-email.me>>]

    I would like to discuss creating a new unmoderated Big-8 newsgroup, comp.ai.chatgpt, devoted specifically to ChatGPT.

    I searched the current newsgroup list and did not find a group dedicated
    to ChatGPT. ChatGPT-related discussion can take place in broader AI
    groups, but those groups cover much larger subject areas and do not
    provide an obvious home for practical user-to-user discussion of
    ChatGPT as a service and platform.

    My proposed scope would include:

    practical use of ChatGPT;
    ChatGPT features, models, and changes affecting users;
    prompting techniques and workflows;
    troubleshooting and unexpected behavior;
    comparisons among ChatGPT models and features;
    integrations and applications involving ChatGPT;
    reliability, limitations, privacy, and other issues directly related
    to using ChatGPT;
    OpenAI developments when they directly affect ChatGPT users.

    General artificial-intelligence discussion unrelated to ChatGPT would
    remain better suited to existing AI groups. General OpenAI API
    programming that is not specifically related to ChatGPT would likewise
    be outside the intended scope.

    I am proposing the group as unmoderated.
    A possible newsgroups description line would be:
    comp.ai.chatgpt Practical use of OpenAI's conversational AI service.

    I am open to suggestions about the group name, its placement within the
    Big-8 hierarchy, and the proposed scope. In particular, I would be
    interested in hearing whether comp.ai.chatgpt is preferable to a
    broader generative-AI group or whether a different name would fit the existing hierarchy better.

    Most importantly, I would like to know whether there are Usenet users
    who would actually read or post to this group if it were created. If
    you would use the proposed group, please say so in this thread.

    If there is sufficient interest, I am willing to act as proponent and
    develop a formal RFD for submission to news.announce.newgroups.



    Hmmm I think this is to particular about one platform
    many many many people uses open source LLM's on their
    home or work with llama.cpp just to name some and models
    from huggingface and other places, calling this chatgpt
    is not fair, this in my opinion should be more generic to
    all models, propietary and open source, local and not from a
    single platform until there is more traffict and usage

    comp.ai.generic or similar will take my vote.
    later on comp.ai.<whatever model> will be better than a company

    ReK2
    Happy Hacking
    --
    {gemini,https}://{,rek2.}hispagatos.org - mastodon: @rek2@hispagatos.space [https|gemini]://2600.Madrid - https://hispagatos.space/@rek2 Reticulum Laptop: lxmf@c6dc6bb3a6b0955d102fde5e7613e2af
    Reticulum PC: lxmf@46f7530c35cd9cb2e8e6cf6d39064810

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Dr Engelbert Buxbaum@engelbert_buxbaum@hotmail.com to news.groups.proposals on Wed Sep 23 08:59:10 2026
    From Newsgroup: news.groups.proposals

    In article <118p9vj$2st7g$2
    @matrix.hispagatos.org>, rek2
    @usenet_reborn.tui says...

    [in reply to Phil Carson <<11555li$rars$1@dont-email.me>>]

    I would like to discuss creating a new unmoderated Big-8 newsgroup, comp.ai.chatgpt, devoted specifically to ChatGPT.


    Hmmm I think this is to particular about one platform
    many many many people uses open source
    LLM's on their home or work with llama.cpp

    comp.ai.generic or similar will take my
    vote. later on comp.ai.<whatever model
    will be better than a company

    I agree. At the height of Usenet, many groups
    were split into subgroups to restrict
    traffic. This had two disadvantages:
    1) Some topics fit into several of these
    subgroups, resulting in cross-posting
    2) As the traffic became smaller, most of
    these subgroups went dead.

    I would suggest at most staying with the
    general method, e.g., comp.ai.llm, to
    differentiate from SVM and other methods of
    computer learning.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2