• Re: How does "moderation" work with privacy in user Usenet posts?

    From Thomas Hochstein@thh@thh.name to news.admin.peering on Sun Feb 1 15:18:53 2026
    From Newsgroup: news.admin.peering

    Maria Sophia wrote:

    Presently are nntp-related threads in the Windows & (free) newserver
    related newsgroups, along with separate software-related threads in the Thunderbird & newsreader newsgroups, folks are discussing how the moderated newsgroup process really works from both the user and nntp server perspective.

    If a newsgroup is marked as moderated, the newsserver will not post the article, but mail it to the moderator.

    As it is not feasible to maintain a database of moderators on each and
    every server, most servers will sent these mails to newsgroup-name (with
    dashes instead of dots) @moderators.isc.org, and it will be forwarded from there to the real moderator account. (There is a central database of
    moderator addresses that is shared between the mail servers that accept
    and relay mail for moderators.isc.org.) Some local, regional or foreign language hierarchies will have their own "central database", but most (if
    not all) fall back to moderators.isc.org.

    The moderator will (modify and) post the article to the moderated
    newsgroup, adding an Approved: header. Postings with such a header will
    not be mailed to the moderator, but posted.

    You can mail your article to the moderator address (or the
    moderators.isc.org forwarder) instead of posting it, but then you'll have
    to add the necessary headers needed in postings, but not in mails, for
    example Newsgroups: and Followup-To:. So it's easier to just post to the
    group as you would normally do.

    One specific question we have is whether a user can "email" directly to a moderated newsgroup (when privacy is involved),

    You can, but your mail must also be a valid posting, i.e. containing the relevant headers. You'll have to add them manually as a typical mail
    client won't set them.

    Your mail will also contain more trace headers than a posting.

    When you post to a moderated group, the newsserver won't add any more identifying information as it will do when posting to an unmoderated
    group. So if it won't add a "posting-host" item to Injection-Info: with
    your host name or IP address, it won't do so for the mailed posting
    etiher. The mail will identify the newsserver you used, but that is
    identified anyway.

    Your mail to the moderation address will, on the other hand, contain information about the path the mail took from you to the recipient. That
    may include your hostname or IP address with a much higher probability;
    you'll have to check for the mail provider you are using.

    Q1: Can users email a post to a moderated newsgroup with email privacy?

    They can, as privately as their other emails are.

    Q2: If using throwaway mail servers, what additional headers are required?

    All headers necessary for a posting, i.e. Newsgroups, Followup-To: where appropriate.

    Please keep in mind that due to the large number of unsolicited mail
    (spam, malware, ...), mail is more or less heavily filtered, so mail from "throwaway mail servers" may not reach their recipient.

    Q3: How does "typical" moderation work when the nntp header email is bogus?

    It doesn't. The moderator can't contact the sender (and the sender won't
    know if there was a problem delivering the mail). Some mail servers won't accept non-existent sender addresses. Some mail servers will filter them
    as spam. (You'll have a slightly better chance when posting to a moderated group with an invalid address, as at least the envelope-from will be
    mostly be valid.) If the mail reaches a moderator, (s)he can't check back
    with the submitter and may or may not decide to post the article.

    Best regards,
    -thh
    --- Synchronet 3.21d-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to news.admin.peering on Sun Feb 1 10:38:23 2026
    From Newsgroup: news.admin.peering

    Thomas Hochstein wrote:
    Maria Sophia wrote:

    Presently are nntp-related threads in the Windows & (free) newserver
    related newsgroups, along with separate software-related threads in the
    Thunderbird & newsreader newsgroups, folks are discussing how the moderated >> newsgroup process really works from both the user and nntp server
    perspective.

    If a newsgroup is marked as moderated, the newsserver will not post the article, but mail it to the moderator.

    As it is not feasible to maintain a database of moderators on each and
    every server, most servers will sent these mails to newsgroup-name (with dashes instead of dots) @moderators.isc.org, and it will be forwarded from there to the real moderator account. (There is a central database of moderator addresses that is shared between the mail servers that accept
    and relay mail for moderators.isc.org.) Some local, regional or foreign language hierarchies will have their own "central database", but most (if
    not all) fall back to moderators.isc.org.

    The moderator will (modify and) post the article to the moderated
    newsgroup, adding an Approved: header. Postings with such a header will
    not be mailed to the moderator, but posted.

    You can mail your article to the moderator address (or the
    moderators.isc.org forwarder) instead of posting it, but then you'll have
    to add the necessary headers needed in postings, but not in mails, for example Newsgroups: and Followup-To:. So it's easier to just post to the group as you would normally do.

    One specific question we have is whether a user can "email" directly to a
    moderated newsgroup (when privacy is involved),

    You can, but your mail must also be a valid posting, i.e. containing the relevant headers. You'll have to add them manually as a typical mail
    client won't set them.

    Your mail will also contain more trace headers than a posting.

    When you post to a moderated group, the newsserver won't add any more identifying information as it will do when posting to an unmoderated
    group. So if it won't add a "posting-host" item to Injection-Info: with
    your host name or IP address, it won't do so for the mailed posting
    etiher. The mail will identify the newsserver you used, but that is identified anyway.

    Your mail to the moderation address will, on the other hand, contain information about the path the mail took from you to the recipient. That
    may include your hostname or IP address with a much higher probability; you'll have to check for the mail provider you are using.

    Q1: Can users email a post to a moderated newsgroup with email privacy?

    They can, as privately as their other emails are.

    Q2: If using throwaway mail servers, what additional headers are required?

    All headers necessary for a posting, i.e. Newsgroups, Followup-To: where appropriate.

    Please keep in mind that due to the large number of unsolicited mail
    (spam, malware, ...), mail is more or less heavily filtered, so mail from "throwaway mail servers" may not reach their recipient.

    Q3: How does "typical" moderation work when the nntp header email is bogus?

    It doesn't. The moderator can't contact the sender (and the sender won't
    know if there was a problem delivering the mail). Some mail servers won't accept non-existent sender addresses. Some mail servers will filter them
    as spam. (You'll have a slightly better chance when posting to a moderated group with an invalid address, as at least the envelope-from will be
    mostly be valid.) If the mail reaches a moderator, (s)he can't check back with the submitter and may or may not decide to post the article.

    Wow. Thank you. That was so beautiful, I can't think of adding additional palpable value. Since I delight in adding value, I can't, that was so good.

    I wouldn't even respond given how complete your kind reply above was, but I will try to add one tidbit is I found this FAQ which confirms what you
    said, which is good because we had Adam deprecating the smtp method which matters to anyone writing their own newsreader because the home-grown newsreader needs to know how the smtp headers/body need to be arranged.

    *Usenet Big-8 Management Board - Moderated Newsgroups*
    <https://www.big-8.org/wiki/Moderated_Newsgroups>
    --
    Every Usenet post should strive to add palpable additional value
    so that we can all delight in dissemination of useful knowledge.
    --- Synchronet 3.21d-Linux NewsLink 1.2