• Stop calling missing hardware a "tradeoff" when it's really a loss in functionality!

    From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Fri Nov 20 17:58:22 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Stop calling missing hardware a "tradeoff" when it's simply a loss of functionality.

    Imagine buying a claw hammer with the claw sawed off, even though you still need to pull nails.

    Now you have to purchase a separate attachment just to restore
    functionality that a normal claw hammer already has built in.

    Meanwhile, someone who bought a normal claw hammer can use that exact same attachment if they want to, while still retaining the ability to pull nails without it.

    Q: What exactly was traded?
    A: Nothing.

    The normal claw hammer can do everything the crippled hammer can do,
    plus it can pull nails without requiring an additional accessory.

    The missing-claw hammer hasn't gained a capability. It has lost one.
    That's not a tradeoff. It's a loss of functionality.

    Phones work the same way.

    If Phone B can do everything Phone A can do, but also includes an SD card
    slot and a headphone jack, the buyer of Phone A hasn't necessarily made a tradeoff.

    Phone A is missing functionality that Phone B retains.

    And it's not as though Phone B loses the ability to do something simply
    because it includes those additional hardware features. It can still do everything Phone A can do.

    The buyer of Phone A may have other reasons for choosing it, but those
    reasons don't magically transform missing hardware into a tradeoff.

    Having to purchase adapters, accessories, subscriptions, or additional
    devices to compensate for functionality that could have been built into the phone is an additional expense. It's a cost incurred to work around a limitation.

    And let's be clear about something:

    An accessory that restores missing functionality doesn't make the original omission a tradeoff. It makes the accessory a workaround.

    A tradeoff requires an exchange. Something must be gained in return for something surrendered.

    If one phone does everything another phone does, while also offering
    additional hardware functionality, what exactly did the first phone gain by lacking those features?

    Nothing.

    You can prefer the phone without those features. You can justify buying it.
    You can even consider its other advantages worth the additional limitations
    and expenses.

    But stop pretending that a loss of functionality is somehow a tradeoff
    simply because you've decided you're willing to accept the loss.

    You didn't trade anything. You just accepted less functionality .
    Or, you paid to get the missing functionality back.

    Neither way is it a tradeoff.
    It's always bad.

    Note: A tradeoff would be if the missing functionality enabled the phone to
    be cheaper, thinner, more waterproof, bigger battery, etc., but we've long
    ago proven that this is just their 'excuse' for removing the functionality.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Alan@nuh-uh@nope.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Fri Nov 20 15:09:49 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 2026-11-20 14:58, Maria Sophia wrote:
    Stop calling missing hardware a "tradeoff" when it's simply a loss of functionality.

    Imagine buying a claw hammer with the claw sawed off, even though you still need to pull nails.

    You wouldn't buy it.


    Now you have to purchase a separate attachment just to restore
    functionality that a normal claw hammer already has built in.

    Which attachment may work better for you.


    Meanwhile, someone who bought a normal claw hammer can use that exact same attachment if they want to, while still retaining the ability to pull nails without it.

    But pay more for the hammer with the claw they don't want to use.


    Q: What exactly was traded?
    A: Nothing.

    The normal claw hammer can do everything the crippled hammer can do,
    plus it can pull nails without requiring an additional accessory.

    The missing-claw hammer hasn't gained a capability. It has lost one.
    That's not a tradeoff. It's a loss of functionality.

    Phones work the same way.

    If Phone B can do everything Phone A can do, but also includes an SD card slot and a headphone jack, the buyer of Phone A hasn't necessarily made a tradeoff.

    Phone A is missing functionality that Phone B retains.

    You're assuming that all else remains equal when it clearly does not.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Nick Charles@none@none.none to comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Fri Nov 20 22:32:51 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On Nov 20, 2026 at 4:58:22rC>PM EST, "Maria Sophia" <mariasophia@comprehension.com> wrote:

    Stop calling missing hardware a "tradeoff" when it's simply a loss of functionality.

    Imagine buying a claw hammer with the claw sawed off, even though you still need to pull nails.

    Imagine buying a house without a TV antenna mounted on the roof.

    Imagine buying a car without the crank starter on the front of the car.

    Imagine buying an AM radio today.

    Imagine buying a computer/phone/tablet without a network cable connector.

    Why are you such a doofus? Things change. Hardware comes and goes. Electronics comes and goes.

    The facts are, no one cares about "industry standard" SD cards and "industry standard" wired headphones in 2026. Thus, both are no longer "industry standards" when only 25% of phones/tablets have them.

    Get OVER it already. How many times are you going to whine about this? If you MUST have these, then buy a phone that still has them.

    Meanwhile, the rest of world has moved on. Just like we moved on from TV antennas on the roof and hand crank cars and AM radios and wired networks.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Fri Nov 20 22:59:22 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Nick Charles wrote:
    Get OVER it already.

    The point I was making was people who claim it's a 'tradeoff' are making
    that absurd claim out of ignorance of what a 'trade off' means in English.

    It means you had to actually trade something.
    Which isn't the equation when a phone completely lacks basic functionality.

    In the case of the phone sans the sd slot, there's *nothing* to trade!
    Since the phone with a slot already does everything the phone w/o it does.

    When people claim it's a 'tradeoff', it means they're proving me correct
    that they defend Apple's decisions to the death, no matter what, using the first absurd excuse that happens to pop into their heads at that moment.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Fri Nov 20 23:00:50 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Nick Charles wrote:
    Get OVER it already.

    The point I was making was people who claim it's a 'tradeoff' are making
    that absurd claim out of ignorance of what a 'trade off' means in English.

    It means you had to actually trade something.
    Which isn't the equation when a phone completely lacks basic functionality.

    In the case of the phone sans the sd slot, there's *nothing* to trade!
    Since the phone with a slot already does everything the phone w/o it does.

    When people claim it's a 'tradeoff', it means they're proving me correct
    that they defend Apple's decisions to the death, no matter what, using the first absurd excuse that happens to pop into their heads at that moment.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Nuno Silva@nunojsilva@invalid.invalid to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android on Sat Nov 21 13:15:51 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 2026-11-20, Alan wrote:

    On 2026-11-20 14:58, Maria Sophia wrote:
    Stop calling missing hardware a "tradeoff" when it's simply a loss of
    functionality.

    Imagine buying a claw hammer with the claw sawed off, even though you still >> need to pull nails.

    You wouldn't buy it.


    Now you have to purchase a separate attachment just to restore
    functionality that a normal claw hammer already has built in.

    Which attachment may work better for you.


    Meanwhile, someone who bought a normal claw hammer can use that exact same >> attachment if they want to, while still retaining the ability to pull nails >> without it.

    But pay more for the hammer with the claw they don't want to use.

    It is unrealistic to expect that this will really lead to a decrease in
    the price tag for the consumer, when, for new releases and
    relatively-new models, the approach seems to be more of staggered system
    of pricetag steps, where front-line models get very-expensive prices,
    then you have some steps e.g. at EUR 600 and EUR 300, and then lower
    prices are likely non-front-line models that are also not "new enough".

    And who are we kidding, if actual savings are made by removing -|SD slots
    or by choosing nano-SIM instead of mini-SIM or by ditching the audio
    jack, which manufacturers will not funnel that to bonuses or the like?

    (Actual question, if you know which ones would be above this, that'd be
    a good thing to know. Otherwise, it's pretending Ronald Reagan had a
    point with his tricke-down propaganda...)

    For cutting features to make it so that rising costs fit in the existing pricing model, the same question applies: which manufacturers won't just increase prices if it comes to that?
    --
    Nuno Silva
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Nuno Silva@nunojsilva@invalid.invalid to comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Sat Nov 21 13:55:32 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 2026-11-20, Nick Charles wrote:

    On Nov 20, 2026 at 4:58:22rC>PM EST, "Maria Sophia" <mariasophia@comprehension.com> wrote:

    Stop calling missing hardware a "tradeoff" when it's simply a loss of
    functionality.

    Imagine buying a claw hammer with the claw sawed off, even though you still >> need to pull nails.

    Imagine buying a house without a TV antenna mounted on the roof.

    Uhm... yes, that'd be a big deal. If you don't have an antenna
    installed, you'll have to install it, and if it's not present, what
    chances are there that the *wiring* is present? That does sound like the
    sort of relevant thing if you're picking a place to rent or buy, it may
    mean more work for you, more expenses to hire someone else to do it, or
    even the inability to use TV if you can't do these.

    It's not like terrestrial television has ceased to exist.

    And the same could still apply to the coax wiring, be it for an OTA
    antenna, or for distribution of cable or EDFA-amplified GPON TV
    spectrum.

    Imagine buying a car without the crank starter on the front of the
    car.

    Imagine buying a car without a steering wheel, imagine buying a car
    without a "lighter" power socket.

    Imagine buying an AM radio today.

    Uh... isn't that actually something you expect to be present for
    emergencies? I was under the impression "medium wave" had certain
    benefits in this regard.

    Imagine buying a computer/phone/tablet without a network cable
    connector.

    *Mobile* phone and tablet are more understandable, even then there are
    cases where it surely would be convenient to have an 8P8C socket. But
    here I think you're pulling things that have never had 8P8C sockets as a
    habit? Unless you're including some tablet model that existed well
    before Apple claimed to have invented tablets, of course.

    Computers... are you serious? Sure, not all motherboards come with an
    onboard NIC, and for a long time around the turn of the century it
    wasn't common at all. But, in this age of Internet and networking, not
    having a built-in LAN NIC can easily be a show-stopper.

    Not having a 10base-2 network connector I can understand, and, were that
    your example, it'd make sense. For 10\+base-T, not so much...

    Some laptops have pulled this, and, well, the same applies, even if
    nowadays USB dongles can deliver a better-than-nothing solution with
    acceptable performance, it can still be a nuisance.

    (Also, a non-mobile phone without a 6P4C would raise serious questions,
    I'm actually surprised that's not one of your examples :-P )

    Why are you such a doofus? Things change. Hardware comes and goes. Electronics comes and goes.

    Yeah, but you can't just handwave everything with that justification.

    The facts are, no one cares about "industry standard" SD cards and "industry standard" wired headphones in 2026. Thus, both are no longer "industry standards" when only 25% of phones/tablets have them.

    Get OVER it already. How many times are you going to whine about this? If you
    MUST have these, then buy a phone that still has them.

    Meanwhile, the rest of world has moved on. Just like we moved on from TV antennas on the roof and hand crank cars and AM radios and wired networks.

    I think you need to go look these things up, because if you think we've
    "moved on from TV antennas on the roof", I'd love to know what the
    replacement is. To my knowledge, terrestrial television is still relying
    on antennas being high enough and clear of obstacles to receive
    broadcasts?
    --
    Nuno Silva
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Frank Slootweg@this@ddress.is.invalid to comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Sat Nov 21 20:58:47 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Nuno Silva <nunojsilva@invalid.invalid> wrote:
    [...]

    I think you need to go look these things up, because if you think we've "moved on from TV antennas on the roof", I'd love to know what the replacement is. To my knowledge, terrestrial television is still relying
    on antennas being high enough and clear of obstacles to receive
    broadcasts?

    Yes, some of Nick Charles's comments are generalizations, probably
    from his perspective.

    But for example this "we moved on from TV antennas on the roof" is
    fully true in our country.(The Netherlands). We have cable/fibre
    (digital) TV nearly everywhere and where/when it's not available or not possible, there's DVB-T (Terrestial) TV, which uses a small antenna, not
    one "on the roof". And for most people, TV (both live and on-demand) is available via the Internet.

    Similarly for AM radio, being replaced by DAB+ (and yes, still FM).
    And yes, my emergency radio has both.

    And no, my laptop doesn't have an Ethernet port. (Don't need it (1200
    Mbps is fast enough), but can get a dongle if I would need it.)

    And no, my car does not have a crank starter, but *does* have a
    'cigarette lighter' socket. :-)
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Sat Nov 21 17:21:03 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Frank Slootweg wrote:
    And no, my car does not have a crank starter, but *does* have a
    'cigarette lighter' socket. :-)

    The TV antenna is a different issue than the crank starter.

    So anyone putting them both in the same category, is simply illogical.
    a. A TV antenna is on my home right now for example
    b. And yet, my home does everything a home w/o it can do too
    c. So where's the tradeoff?
    Q: What does a home without a TV antenna do that a home with it can't do?
    A: Nothing.

    There is no tradeoff.

    These "tradeoff" arguments fail the basic test that the missing hardware is still useful, which, in the case of TV antennas, is certainly the case in
    my own neighborhood which still has not been served with Internet cable.

    We use WISP, as everyone on this newsgroup is well aware, where that's for
    our Internet, but if we wanted terrestrial TV, we'd have to use antennas.

    The endless discussion on this topic is due mostly to people who lack any logical thought processes who are merely defending Apple to the death.

    They feel that removing the aux jack was actually a "courageous" thing.
    And, they strongly feel that we were actually "holding it wrong" too.

    What is really happening, which is beyond most people to comprehend, is
    that marketing provides folks with a believable excuse which they parrot.

    The parroting is purely rote. Purely mechanical. It's unthinking.
    Anyone who claims the loss of functionality is a "tradeoff" is a parrot.

    They're unthinkingly parroting what turns out to be a believable excuse.

    To bring in politics, although I shun the topic, when we ask the highest
    level Republicans in our government why they lost, they are telling us what
    to parrot which isn't too damaging to them, such as "it was the Iran war".

    Q: Why did you lose the mid-term election so badly?
    A: It was the "Iran war".

    While certainly the "Iran war" is a believable excuse, any well-informed logical person *knows* it was tremendously more than that lame excuse.

    It's an intelligence test to ask someone to think about an answer.
    Without parroting the propaganda of the believable excuse they're fed.

    Interestingly, there are many such "intelligence tests" we can ask of
    people, because those that parrot the "believable excuse" are, well, dumb.

    Q: What's the difference between "regular" 89AKI gas and "premium" 91AKI?
    (and why is it ten cents or more per gallon different in price?)

    If they tell us the "believable excuse", they flunked the intelligence
    test, right? Because none of the believable excuses hold up to logic.

    When someone tells us that the missing functionality was "outdated",
    it's almost always they're simply parroting the believable excuse.

    Which is what the prior posters all did.
    Not one of their "believable excuses" stand up to well-informed logic.

    Particularly because there is no 'tradeoff' since a home/device
    without that stuff can't do what a home/device with the stuff can do.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Sat Nov 21 17:23:11 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Frank Slootweg wrote:
    I think you need to go look these things up, because if you think we've
    "moved on from TV antennas on the roof", I'd love to know what the
    replacement is. To my knowledge, terrestrial television is still relying
    on antennas being high enough and clear of obstacles to receive
    broadcasts?

    Yes, some of Nick Charles's comments are generalizations, probably
    from his perspective.

    But for example this "we moved on from TV antennas on the roof" is
    fully true in our country.(The Netherlands). We have cable/fibre
    (digital) TV nearly everywhere and where/when it's not available or not possible, there's DVB-T (Terrestial) TV, which uses a small antenna, not
    one "on the roof". And for most people, TV (both live and on-demand) is available via the Internet.

    Similarly for AM radio, being replaced by DAB+ (and yes, still FM).
    And yes, my emergency radio has both.

    And no, my laptop doesn't have an Ethernet port. (Don't need it (1200
    Mbps is fast enough), but can get a dongle if I would need it.)

    And no, my car does not have a crank starter, but *does* have a
    'cigarette lighter' socket. :-)

    The TV antenna is a different issue than the crank starter.

    So anyone putting them both in the same category, is simply illogical.
    a. A TV antenna is on my home right now for example
    b. And yet, my home does everything a home w/o it can do too
    c. So where's the tradeoff?
    Q: What does a home without a TV antenna do that a home with it can't do?
    A: Nothing.

    There is no tradeoff.

    These "tradeoff" arguments fail the basic test that the missing hardware is still useful, which, in the case of TV antennas, is certainly the case in
    my own neighborhood which still has not been served with Internet cable.

    We use WISP, as everyone on this newsgroup is well aware, where that's for
    our Internet, but if we wanted terrestrial TV, we'd have to use antennas.

    The endless discussion on this topic is due mostly to people who lack any logical thought processes who are merely defending Apple to the death.

    They feel that removing the aux jack was actually a "courageous" thing.
    And, they strongly feel that we were actually "holding it wrong" too.

    What is really happening, which is beyond most people to comprehend, is
    that marketing provides folks with a believable excuse which they parrot.

    The parroting is purely rote. Purely mechanical. It's unthinking.
    Anyone who claims the loss of functionality is a "tradeoff" is a parrot.

    They're unthinkingly parroting what turns out to be a believable excuse.

    To bring in politics, although I shun the topic, when we ask the highest
    level Republicans in our government why they lost, they are telling us what
    to parrot which isn't too damaging to them, such as "it was the Iran war".

    Q: Why did you lose the mid-term election so badly?
    A: It was the "Iran war".

    While certainly the "Iran war" is a believable excuse, any well-informed logical person *knows* it was tremendously more than that lame excuse.

    It's an intelligence test to ask someone to think about an answer.
    Without parroting the propaganda of the believable excuse they're fed.

    Interestingly, there are many such "intelligence tests" we can ask of
    people, because those that parrot the "believable excuse" are, well, dumb.

    Q: What's the difference between "regular" 89AKI gas and "premium" 91AKI?
    (and why is it ten cents or more per gallon different in price?)

    If they tell us the "believable excuse", they flunked the intelligence
    test, right? Because none of the believable excuses hold up to logic.

    When someone tells us that the missing functionality was "outdated",
    it's almost always they're simply parroting the believable excuse.

    Which is what the prior posters all did.
    Not one of their "believable excuses" stand up to well-informed logic.

    Particularly because there is no 'tradeoff' since a home/device
    without that stuff can't do what a home/device with the stuff can do.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Carlos E.R.@robin_listas@es.invalid to comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Sat Nov 21 22:26:00 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 2026-11-20 23:32, Nick Charles wrote:
    On Nov 20, 2026 at 4:58:22rC>PM EST, "Maria Sophia" <mariasophia@comprehension.com> wrote:

    Stop calling missing hardware a "tradeoff" when it's simply a loss of
    functionality.

    Imagine buying a claw hammer with the claw sawed off, even though you still >> need to pull nails.

    Imagine buying a house without a TV antenna mounted on the roof.

    Imagine buying a car without the crank starter on the front of the car.

    Imagine buying an AM radio today.

    My car has an AM radio and is not yet 8 year old. :-)

    It works in the mountains, where FM does not.
    --
    Cheers, Carlos.
    ESEfc-Efc+, EUEfc-Efc|;
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Nick Charles@none@none.none to comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Sat Nov 21 21:28:09 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On Nov 21, 2026 at 3:58:47rC>PM EST, "Frank Slootweg" <this@ddress.is.invalid> wrote:

    Nuno Silva <nunojsilva@invalid.invalid> wrote:
    [...]

    I think you need to go look these things up, because if you think we've
    "moved on from TV antennas on the roof", I'd love to know what the
    replacement is. To my knowledge, terrestrial television is still relying
    on antennas being high enough and clear of obstacles to receive
    broadcasts?

    Yes, some of Nick Charles's comments are generalizations, probably
    from his perspective.

    But for example this "we moved on from TV antennas on the roof" is
    fully true in our country.(The Netherlands). We have cable/fibre
    (digital) TV nearly everywhere and where/when it's not available or not possible, there's DVB-T (Terrestial) TV, which uses a small antenna, not
    one "on the roof". And for most people, TV (both live and on-demand) is available via the Internet.

    Which was my point. Most houses don't have TV antennas on the roof today.

    Similarly for AM radio, being replaced by DAB+ (and yes, still FM).
    And yes, my emergency radio has both.

    Yes, that was my point.

    And no, my laptop doesn't have an Ethernet port. (Don't need it (1200
    Mbps is fast enough), but can get a dongle if I would need it.)

    Yes, that was my point. Lots of SOTA electronic stuff is gone in 30 years or so.

    And no, my car does not have a crank starter, but *does* have a
    'cigarette lighter' socket. :-)

    LOL yeah, most cars call those "12 volt power socket" now. Do any new cars today still have actual cigarette lighters?

    The point is, whining about "missing" 30 year old SD cards and 100 year old wired headphones is just pointless.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Sat Nov 21 17:29:13 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    CrudeSausage wrote:
    Maria Sophia wrote:
    In the case of the phone sans the sd slot, there's *nothing* to trade!

    It's important to understand that when an intelligent logical person tries
    to understand the absurd excuses which are endlessly repeated by the Apple religious zealots, that well-educated people try to UNDERSTAND what it is
    that goes on inside the minds of these strange religious zealot nutcases.

    You have to question the "logic" when someone terms lost functionality, a
    *tradeoff*
    *How, exactly, is losing functionality a tradeoff?*

    How is losing basic functionality ever a good thing?

    Apple removed the aux jack, claiming they did it to be "courageous".
    Well. OK. But how is losing the aux jack functionality a good thing?

    Apple never supplied an sd slot, even when it was desperately needed.
    Again, OK. But how is not having basic useful functionality a good thing?

    Most users immediately claim that they went out and purchased the missing functionality, which, of course, was the clever marketing goal all along.

    But a user with a phone that had the hardware could have done that also.
    So it's not a 'trade off' at all. It's simply an expensive workaround.

    Now, a use with the expensive workaround can easily claim that their choice
    of expensive workaround "works better" than the missing hardware ever did.

    And that's likely true in almost all cases.
    But it's still not a "trade off". It's just an expensive necessary fix.

    Now, there "could" have been real engineering/cost tradeoffs for sure:
    a. Bigger batteries
    b. Better ingress protection
    c. Thinner form factors
    d. More reliable product
    e. Cheaper sales price
    etc.

    But we can easily show those things didn't happen.
    They were just excuses.

    There was no tradeoff.

    Hence, an intelligent person looks deeper than the believable propaganda in order to understand more fully, why hardware was removed when it was.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Nick Charles@none@none.none to comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Sat Nov 21 21:30:22 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On Nov 21, 2026 at 4:26:00rC>PM EST, ""Carlos E.R."" <robin_listas@es.invalid> wrote:

    On 2026-11-20 23:32, Nick Charles wrote:
    On Nov 20, 2026 at 4:58:22rC>PM EST, "Maria Sophia"
    <mariasophia@comprehension.com> wrote:

    Stop calling missing hardware a "tradeoff" when it's simply a loss of
    functionality.

    Imagine buying a claw hammer with the claw sawed off, even though you still >>> need to pull nails.

    Imagine buying a house without a TV antenna mounted on the roof.

    Imagine buying a car without the crank starter on the front of the car.

    Imagine buying an AM radio today.

    My car has an AM radio and is not yet 8 year old. :-)

    So do my cars. But that's not what I said.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Brock McNuggets@brock.mcnuggets@gmail.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Sat Nov 21 14:30:14 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 21 Nov 2026, Maria Sophia wrote in <11dt23v$35t$1@nnrp.usenet.blueworldhosting.com>:
    Frank Slootweg wrote:
    I think you need to go look these things up, because if you
    think we've "moved on from TV antennas on the roof", I'd love to
    know what the replacement is. To my knowledge, terrestrial
    television is still relying on antennas being high enough and
    clear of obstacles to receive broadcasts?

    Yes, some of Nick Charles's comments are generalizations,
    probably from his perspective.

    But for example this "we moved on from TV antennas on the roof"
    is fully true in our country.(The Netherlands). We have
    cable/fibre (digital) TV nearly everywhere and where/when it's
    not available or not possible, there's DVB-T (Terrestial) TV,
    which uses a small antenna, not one "on the roof". And for most
    people, TV (both live and on-demand) is available via the
    Internet.

    Similarly for AM radio, being replaced by DAB+ (and yes, still
    FM). And yes, my emergency radio has both.

    And no, my laptop doesn't have an Ethernet port. (Don't need it
    (1200 Mbps is fast enough), but can get a dongle if I would need
    it.)

    And no, my car does not have a crank starter, but *does* have a
    'cigarette lighter' socket. :-)

    The TV antenna is a different issue than the crank starter.

    Right. And you ignore the distinction. Maybe a better analogy is the
    clutch pedal. It is a trade-off. Some want it. Some do not. You
    whine about cars without it (by analogy).

    <snip>
    --
    You can't find peace with someone at war with themselves.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Carlos E.R.@robin_listas@es.invalid to comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Sat Nov 21 22:27:52 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 2026-11-21 14:55, Nuno Silva wrote:
    On 2026-11-20, Nick Charles wrote:

    On Nov 20, 2026 at 4:58:22rC>PM EST, "Maria Sophia"
    <mariasophia@comprehension.com> wrote:

    Stop calling missing hardware a "tradeoff" when it's simply a loss of
    functionality.

    Imagine buying a claw hammer with the claw sawed off, even though you still >>> need to pull nails.

    Imagine buying a house without a TV antenna mounted on the roof.

    Uhm... yes, that'd be a big deal. If you don't have an antenna
    installed, you'll have to install it, and if it's not present, what
    chances are there that the *wiring* is present? That does sound like the
    sort of relevant thing if you're picking a place to rent or buy, it may
    mean more work for you, more expenses to hire someone else to do it, or
    even the inability to use TV if you can't do these.

    I believe they are mandatory over here. :-)
    --
    Cheers, Carlos.
    ESEfc-Efc+, EUEfc-Efc|;
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Brock McNuggets@brock.mcnuggets@gmail.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Sat Nov 21 14:35:57 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 21 Nov 2026, Maria Sophia wrote in <11dt2f9$l47$1@nnrp.usenet.blueworldhosting.com>:
    CrudeSausage wrote:
    Maria Sophia wrote:
    In the case of the phone sans the sd slot, there's *nothing* to
    trade!

    It's important to understand that when an intelligent logical
    person tries to understand the absurd excuses which are endlessly
    repeated by the Apple religious zealots, that well-educated people
    try to UNDERSTAND what it is that goes on inside the minds of
    these strange religious zealot nutcases.

    You have to question the "logic" when someone terms lost
    functionality, a
    *tradeoff*
    *How, exactly, is losing functionality a tradeoff?*

    You have been told: size, weight, water / dust resistance, battery
    life.

    How is losing basic functionality ever a good thing?

    I still have headphones -- wired and wireless. No loss of "basic functionality".

    Apple removed the aux jack, claiming they did it to be
    "courageous". Well. OK. But how is losing the aux jack
    functionality a good thing?

    For the reasons you have been told.

    <snip>
    --
    You can't find peace with someone at war with themselves.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Sat Nov 21 17:46:06 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Nick Charles wrote:
    Which was my point. Most houses don't have TV antennas on the roof today.

    This is basic logic. Intelligence. Understanding.

    The point is that losing H/W functionality is not a tradeoff unless you
    gained something in return for that lost functionality. That's the point!

    I'm in the Santa Cruz mountains overlooking the Silicon Valley.
    We have no cable or fiber so we have to get everything over the air.

    So I have a TV antenna on my roof.
    Everyone knows that who is on these newsgroups.

    But even if mine didn't have a TV antenna, how is that missing hardware
    a "tradeoff" in functionality?

    Do you even realize *that* is the question being discussed in this thread?

    Q: *How is losing something, and gaining nothing in return, a tradeoff?*
    A: *It's not.*


    Similarly for AM radio, being replaced by DAB+ (and yes, still FM).
    And yes, my emergency radio has both.

    Yes, that was my point.

    People who lack intelligence always failed the 'venn-diagram' association
    tests in school, where intelligent people can see distinctions in groups.

    Q: How is a vehicle w/o an AM radio any more functional than one with it?
    A: It's not.

    There is no tradeoff.

    And no, my laptop doesn't have an Ethernet port. (Don't need it (1200
    Mbps is fast enough), but can get a dongle if I would need it.)

    Yes, that was my point. Lots of SOTA electronic stuff is gone in 30 years or so.

    As noted, unintelligent people fail "object association' tests, which, by
    the way, is a key marketing point that is drilled into us in college
    classes.

    Associate your product with something people want, like sex or excitement.
    *If you drink this soda, you'll have all these babes on the beach!*

    And yet, only illogical people fall for those marketing tricks, which,
    let's be fair to humans, is almost everyone when it comes to such things.

    Pepsi-generation marketing associated their soda with youth, energy and
    being part of the new generation, which is an absurd venn diagram, right?

    Yet it works.
    Marketing works.

    Marketing told Apple zealots it was a "tradeoff" that they lost basic functionality early on in the life of the iPhone, & they believed it.

    But where is the tradeoff?

    Q: What can a laptop with the Ethernet port do that one w/o it can't do?
    A: A lot!

    There is no tradeoff, unless.... and let's get this very clear, unless the laptop w/o the Ethernet port is cheaper, more reliable, thinner, bigger battery, better ingress protection, etc., DIRECTLY as a result of that
    loss.

    Is it?

    The answer is that it's almost never the case. But Nick didn't make that
    case. He jut said it was "outdated", which is the believable excuse.

    And no, my car does not have a crank starter, but *does* have a
    'cigarette lighter' socket. :-)

    LOL yeah, most cars call those "12 volt power socket" now. Do any new cars today still have actual cigarette lighters?

    Q: Is a car with that socket any less functional than one that lost it?
    A: No.

    Q: Is a car w/o that socket more functional than the one that lost it?
    A: No.

    There is no tradeoff.

    The point is, whining about "missing" 30 year old SD cards and 100 year old wired headphones is just pointless.

    Well, that may be "your point" but the point of this thread was clearly
    that it's not a tradeoff when you lose basic H/W but get nothing in return.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Sat Nov 21 17:46:51 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Nick Charles wrote:
    On Nov 21, 2026 at 3:58:47rC>PM EST, "Frank Slootweg" <this@ddress.is.invalid>
    wrote:

    Nuno Silva <nunojsilva@invalid.invalid> wrote:
    [...]

    I think you need to go look these things up, because if you think we've
    "moved on from TV antennas on the roof", I'd love to know what the
    replacement is. To my knowledge, terrestrial television is still relying >>> on antennas being high enough and clear of obstacles to receive
    broadcasts?

    Yes, some of Nick Charles's comments are generalizations, probably
    from his perspective.

    But for example this "we moved on from TV antennas on the roof" is
    fully true in our country.(The Netherlands). We have cable/fibre
    (digital) TV nearly everywhere and where/when it's not available or not
    possible, there's DVB-T (Terrestial) TV, which uses a small antenna, not
    one "on the roof". And for most people, TV (both live and on-demand) is
    available via the Internet.

    Which was my point. Most houses don't have TV antennas on the roof today.

    Similarly for AM radio, being replaced by DAB+ (and yes, still FM).
    And yes, my emergency radio has both.

    Yes, that was my point.

    And no, my laptop doesn't have an Ethernet port. (Don't need it (1200
    Mbps is fast enough), but can get a dongle if I would need it.)

    Yes, that was my point. Lots of SOTA electronic stuff is gone in 30 years or so.

    And no, my car does not have a crank starter, but *does* have a
    'cigarette lighter' socket. :-)

    LOL yeah, most cars call those "12 volt power socket" now. Do any new cars today still have actual cigarette lighters?

    The point is, whining about "missing" 30 year old SD cards and 100 year old wired headphones is just pointless.


    This is basic logic. Intelligence. Understanding.

    The point is that losing H/W functionality is not a tradeoff unless you
    gained something in return for that lost functionality. That's the point!

    I'm in the Santa Cruz mountains overlooking the Silicon Valley.
    We have no cable or fiber so we have to get everything over the air.

    So I have a TV antenna on my roof.
    Everyone knows that who is on these newsgroups.

    But even if mine didn't have a TV antenna, how is that missing hardware
    a "tradeoff" in functionality?

    Do you even realize *that* is the question being discussed in this thread?

    Q: *How is losing something, and gaining nothing in return, a tradeoff?*
    A: *It's not.*


    Similarly for AM radio, being replaced by DAB+ (and yes, still FM).
    And yes, my emergency radio has both.

    Yes, that was my point.

    People who lack intelligence always failed the 'venn-diagram' association
    tests in school, where intelligent people can see distinctions in groups.

    Q: How is a vehicle w/o an AM radio any more functional than one with it?
    A: It's not.

    There is no tradeoff.

    And no, my laptop doesn't have an Ethernet port. (Don't need it (1200
    Mbps is fast enough), but can get a dongle if I would need it.)

    Yes, that was my point. Lots of SOTA electronic stuff is gone in 30 years or so.

    As noted, unintelligent people fail "object association' tests, which, by
    the way, is a key marketing point that is drilled into us in college
    classes.

    Associate your product with something people want, like sex or excitement.
    *If you drink this soda, you'll have all these babes on the beach!*

    And yet, only illogical people fall for those marketing tricks, which,
    let's be fair to humans, is almost everyone when it comes to such things.

    Pepsi-generation marketing associated their soda with youth, energy and
    being part of the new generation, which is an absurd venn diagram, right?

    Yet it works.
    Marketing works.

    Marketing told Apple zealots it was a "tradeoff" that they lost basic functionality early on in the life of the iPhone, & they believed it.

    But where is the tradeoff?

    Q: What can a laptop with the Ethernet port do that one w/o it can't do?
    A: A lot!

    There is no tradeoff, unless.... and let's get this very clear, unless the laptop w/o the Ethernet port is cheaper, more reliable, thinner, bigger battery, better ingress protection, etc., DIRECTLY as a result of that
    loss.

    Is it?

    The answer is that it's almost never the case. But Nick didn't make that
    case. He jut said it was "outdated", which is the believable excuse.

    And no, my car does not have a crank starter, but *does* have a
    'cigarette lighter' socket. :-)

    LOL yeah, most cars call those "12 volt power socket" now. Do any new cars today still have actual cigarette lighters?

    Q: Is a car with that socket any less functional than one that lost it?
    A: No.

    Q: Is a car w/o that socket more functional than the one that lost it?
    A: No.

    There is no tradeoff.

    The point is, whining about "missing" 30 year old SD cards and 100 year old wired headphones is just pointless.

    Well, that may be "your point" but the point of this thread was clearly
    that it's not a tradeoff when you lose basic H/W but get nothing in return.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Sat Nov 21 17:58:34 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Carlos E.R. wrote:
    Uhm... yes, that'd be a big deal. If you don't have an antenna
    installed, you'll have to install it, and if it's not present, what
    chances are there that the *wiring* is present? That does sound like the
    sort of relevant thing if you're picking a place to rent or buy, it may
    mean more work for you, more expenses to hire someone else to do it, or
    even the inability to use TV if you can't do these.

    I believe they are mandatory over here. :-)

    Hi Carlos,
    Every example given was not a 'tradeoff' as it's not a tradeoff when we
    lose basic H/W functionality but get nothing directly in return for it.

    It's just a loss of H/W functionality.

    Notwithstanding that there is no tradeoff involved when you lose basic
    hardware and get nothing in return, in the USA, with respect to TV
    antennas, there's one on my roof right now, where had I been renting, the
    USA law forbids landlords from preventing a renter from installing one.

    Around 2009, our entire neighborhood had to move to ATSC so we had people
    going door to door to help the less technical housewives who needed
    converter boxes (where we even made use of a government coupon program).

    Keeping up with progress, there's even ATSC 3.0 NextGen TV rolling out now.
    --
    Asking important questions on Usenet is what I do to get people to think.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Your Name@YourName@YourISP.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,comp.mobile.android on Sun Nov 22 11:13:18 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 2026-11-21 21:30:14 +0000, Brock McNuggets said:
    On 21 Nov 2026, Maria Sophia wrote in <11dt23v$35t$1@nnrp.usenet.blueworldhosting.com>:
    Frank Slootweg wrote:
    I think you need to go look these things up, because if you think we've >>>> "moved on from TV antennas on the roof", I'd love to know what the
    replacement is. To my knowledge, terrestrial television is still
    relying on antennas being high enough and clear of obstacles to receive >>>> broadcasts?

    Yes, some of Nick Charles's comments are generalizations, probably from >>> his perspective.

    But for example this "we moved on from TV antennas on the roof" is
    fully true in our country.(The Netherlands). We have cable/fibre
    (digital) TV nearly everywhere and where/when it's not available or not >>> possible, there's DVB-T (Terrestial) TV, which uses a small antenna,
    not one "on the roof". And for most people, TV (both live and
    on-demand) is available via the Internet.

    Similarly for AM radio, being replaced by DAB+ (and yes, still FM). And >>> yes, my emergency radio has both.

    And no, my laptop doesn't have an Ethernet port. (Don't need it (1200
    Mbps is fast enough), but can get a dongle if I would need it.)

    And no, my car does not have a crank starter, but *does* have a
    'cigarette lighter' socket. :-)

    The TV antenna is a different issue than the crank starter.

    Right. And you ignore the distinction. Maybe a better analogy is the
    clutch pedal. It is a trade-off. Some want it. Some do not. You
    whine about cars without it (by analogy).

    <snip>

    I would ... I detest automatic cars. :-p I especially hate automatic gearboxes in so-called "sports cars", which are made for lazy posers
    and those who think 0.5 seconds quicker to change (into the wrong gear)
    is an advantage. Equally as stupid are the auotmatic cars with faked
    gear changes (flappy paddles, rocking the gear stick up / down, or even
    more useless when in electric cars). :-\





    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Your Name@YourName@YourISP.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,comp.mobile.android on Sun Nov 22 11:22:51 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 2026-11-21 21:28:09 +0000, Nick Charles said:
    On Nov 21, 2026 at 3:58:47rC>PM EST, "Frank Slootweg" <this@ddress.is.invalid>
    wrote:
    Nuno Silva <nunojsilva@invalid.invalid> wrote:
    [...]

    I think you need to go look these things up, because if you think we've
    "moved on from TV antennas on the roof", I'd love to know what the
    replacement is. To my knowledge, terrestrial television is still relying >>> on antennas being high enough and clear of obstacles to receive
    broadcasts?

    Yes, some of Nick Charles's comments are generalizations, probably
    from his perspective.

    But for example this "we moved on from TV antennas on the roof" is
    fully true in our country.(The Netherlands). We have cable/fibre
    (digital) TV nearly everywhere and where/when it's not available or not
    possible, there's DVB-T (Terrestial) TV, which uses a small antenna,
    not one "on the roof". And for most people, TV (both live and
    on-demand) is available via the Internet.

    Which was my point. Most houses don't have TV antennas on the roof today.

    New-build houses maybe, but older houses often do have anntennas on teh
    roof simply because it's not worth the time / money taking them down.
    :-)

    Around here there are lots of houses still with roof antennas, and many
    with a Sky TV / Freeview satellite dish. Our roof antenna no longer
    works, but I've never bothered to look into it since we use the Sky box
    via the satellite dish - it could be a detached cable, it could be they
    shut down teh signal the particular antenna type uses, etc.



    And no, my car does not have a crank starter, but *does* have a
    'cigarette lighter' socket. :-)

    LOL yeah, most cars call those "12 volt power socket" now. Do any new cars today still have actual cigarette lighters?

    It's usually called an "accessory socket". I doubt' any car ships with
    a cigarette lighter itself these days, but you can still buy third
    party cigarette lighters to fit the socket.

    My car is just over 30 years old, so does have a cigarette lighter and
    it's ortiginal AM / FM casette radio. :-)




    The point is, whining about "missing" 30 year old SD cards and 100 year old wired headphones is just pointless.

    Wired headphones are reportedly making a bit of a comeback, especially
    among the younger generation apparently. :-) <https://tech.yahoo.com/audio/articles/wired-headphones-making-major-comeback-210500752.html>

    <https://edition.cnn.com/world/wired-headphones-comeback-spc>




    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Brock McNuggets@brock.mcnuggets@gmail.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,comp.mobile.android on Sat Nov 21 15:34:03 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 21 Nov 2026, Your Name wrote in <11dt51u$faab$1@dont-email.me>:
    On 2026-11-21 21:30:14 +0000, Brock McNuggets said:
    On 21 Nov 2026, Maria Sophia wrote in
    <11dt23v$35t$1@nnrp.usenet.blueworldhosting.com>:
    Frank Slootweg wrote:
    <snip>

    The TV antenna is a different issue than the crank starter.

    Right. And you ignore the distinction. Maybe a better analogy is
    the clutch pedal. It is a trade-off. Some want it. Some do not.
    You whine about cars without it (by analogy).

    <snip>

    I would ... I detest automatic cars. :-p I especially hate
    automatic gearboxes in so-called "sports cars", which are made for
    lazy posers and those who think 0.5 seconds quicker to change
    (into the wrong gear) is an advantage. Equally as stupid are the
    auotmatic cars with faked gear changes (flappy paddles, rocking
    the gear stick up / down, or even more useless when in electric
    cars). :-\

    I have nothing against manual cars... and of course having such a
    pedal makes sense in them. But for an automatic it generally does
    not. Some prefer one type. Some the other.

    I am very happy with using USB-C headphones (or wireless). I have no
    need or desire for the old AUX style (for my phone). I like that it
    allows the phone to be smaller and more water / dust resistant and
    have better speakers.

    Would I be crying if it did? Nope. It is a small issue. And there
    was minor "pain" in the transition (buying new headphones). Welcome
    to tech.

    Maria struggles to understand this simple concept.
    --
    You can't find peace with someone at war with themselves.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,comp.mobile.android on Sat Nov 21 18:54:51 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Your Name wrote:
    And no, my car does not have a crank starter, but *does* have a
    'cigarette lighter' socket. :-)

    The TV antenna is a different issue than the crank starter.

    Right. And you ignore the distinction. Maybe a better analogy is the
    clutch pedal. It is a trade-off. Some want it. Some do not. You
    whine about cars without it (by analogy).

    <snip>

    I would ... I detest automatic cars. :-p I especially hate automatic gearboxes in so-called "sports cars", which are made for lazy posers
    and those who think 0.5 seconds quicker to change (into the wrong gear)
    is an advantage. Equally as stupid are the auotmatic cars with faked
    gear changes (flappy paddles, rocking the gear stick up / down, or even
    more useless when in electric cars). :-\

    Like you, I have a 30-year old car, and mine is a manual transmission.
    I've even written DIYs on how to replace the clutch & flyweel on r.a.t.

    It has 300K miles, where I replaced the clutch at 100K and at 200K.
    What I love is the CONTROL we have on the drivetrain of the vehicle.

    Especially as I live in steep twisty mountain terrain above Silicon Valley.

    The fundamental point here is that calling something a 'tradeoff' is
    incorrect when you get nothing in return for the missing functionality.

    The case in point is there is no tradeoff when we don't get an sd slot. Likewise with the loss of the aux jack hardware.

    The parrots on this newsgroup often try to explain their distorted logic.
    Which is that they buy a replacement for the missing functionality.
    And, that extra-cost replacement, has functionality the lost H/W didn't.

    Fine. But that's not a tradeoff.

    The aux jack phone can do everything that the non-aux jack phone can do.
    While the non-aux-jack phone can't do what the aux-jack phone can do.

    It's not a tradeoff when you lose basic H/W but get nothing in return.
    --
    Being on Apple newsgroups, I've heard every excuse people can think of.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Brock McNuggets@brock.mcnuggets@gmail.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,comp.mobile.android on Sat Nov 21 16:14:40 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 21 Nov 2026, Maria Sophia wrote in <11dt7fr$2o65$1@nnrp.usenet.blueworldhosting.com>:
    Your Name wrote:
    <snip>

    Right. And you ignore the distinction. Maybe a better analogy is
    the clutch pedal. It is a trade-off. Some want it. Some do not.
    You whine about cars without it (by analogy).

    <snip>

    I would ... I detest automatic cars. :-p I especially hate
    automatic gearboxes in so-called "sports cars", which are made
    for lazy posers and those who think 0.5 seconds quicker to change
    (into the wrong gear) is an advantage. Equally as stupid are the
    auotmatic cars with faked gear changes (flappy paddles, rocking
    the gear stick up / down, or even more useless when in electric
    cars). :-\

    Like you, I have a 30-year old car, and mine is a manual
    transmission. I've even written DIYs on how to replace the clutch
    & flyweel on r.a.t.

    It has 300K miles, where I replaced the clutch at 100K and at
    200K. What I love is the CONTROL we have on the drivetrain of the
    vehicle.

    Especially as I live in steep twisty mountain terrain above
    Silicon Valley.

    The fundamental point here is that calling something a 'tradeoff'
    is incorrect when you get nothing in return for the missing
    functionality.

    The case in point is there is no tradeoff when we don't get an sd
    slot. Likewise with the loss of the aux jack hardware.

    The parrots on this newsgroup often try to explain their distorted
    logic. Which is that they buy a replacement for the missing
    functionality. And, that extra-cost replacement, has functionality
    the lost H/W didn't.

    Fine. But that's not a tradeoff.

    The aux jack phone can do everything that the non-aux jack phone
    can do.

    How can it work with a USB-C headphone?

    While the non-aux-jack phone can't do what the aux-jack
    phone can do.

    It's not a tradeoff when you lose basic H/W but get nothing in
    return.

    You are actively clueless.
    --
    You can't find peace with someone at war with themselves.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From CrudeSausage@crude@sausa.ge to comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Sat Nov 21 19:20:52 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 2026-11-21 8:55 a.m., Nuno Silva wrote:
    On 2026-11-20, Nick Charles wrote:

    On Nov 20, 2026 at 4:58:22rC>PM EST, "Maria Sophia"
    <mariasophia@comprehension.com> wrote:

    Stop calling missing hardware a "tradeoff" when it's simply a loss of
    functionality.

    Imagine buying a claw hammer with the claw sawed off, even though you still >>> need to pull nails.

    Imagine buying a house without a TV antenna mounted on the roof.

    Uhm... yes, that'd be a big deal. If you don't have an antenna
    installed, you'll have to install it, and if it's not present, what
    chances are there that the *wiring* is present? That does sound like the
    sort of relevant thing if you're picking a place to rent or buy, it may
    mean more work for you, more expenses to hire someone else to do it, or
    even the inability to use TV if you can't do these.

    It's not like terrestrial television has ceased to exist.

    And the same could still apply to the coax wiring, be it for an OTA
    antenna, or for distribution of cable or EDFA-amplified GPON TV
    spectrum.

    I don't know about where you are, but OTA has become worthless around
    here in Montreal. We were still able to get the Saturday Canadiens game
    last year, but that's gone too. In the place of Hockey Night in Canada
    on CBC, Canadians are getting curling... presumably to please the
    increasing number of stinky Hindis scamming their way into the country.

    Imagine buying a car without the crank starter on the front of the
    car.

    Imagine buying a car without a steering wheel, imagine buying a car
    without a "lighter" power socket.

    Imagine buying an AM radio today.

    Uh... isn't that actually something you expect to be present for
    emergencies? I was under the impression "medium wave" had certain
    benefits in this regard.

    Here in Montreal, the only AM radio stations worth listening to are now
    being broadcast simultaneously on HD airwaves on FM. Admittedly, I would
    have held on to AM myself, but there is no doubt that the sound quality
    is usually lacking. It's fine for talk radio and sports broadcasts, but listening to music is just a pain.

    Imagine buying a computer/phone/tablet without a network cable
    connector.

    *Mobile* phone and tablet are more understandable, even then there are
    cases where it surely would be convenient to have an 8P8C socket. But
    here I think you're pulling things that have never had 8P8C sockets as a habit? Unless you're including some tablet model that existed well
    before Apple claimed to have invented tablets, of course.

    Computers... are you serious? Sure, not all motherboards come with an
    onboard NIC, and for a long time around the turn of the century it
    wasn't common at all. But, in this age of Internet and networking, not
    having a built-in LAN NIC can easily be a show-stopper.

    Not having a 10base-2 network connector I can understand, and, were that
    your example, it'd make sense. For 10\+base-T, not so much...

    Some laptops have pulled this, and, well, the same applies, even if
    nowadays USB dongles can deliver a better-than-nothing solution with acceptable performance, it can still be a nuisance.

    (Also, a non-mobile phone without a 6P4C would raise serious questions,
    I'm actually surprised that's not one of your examples :-P )

    Admittedly, I prefer the performance of Ethernet to wireless. My old
    gaming laptop didn't have an Ethernet port which I found fairly counterintuitive since you want the best connection possible if playing multiplayer titles. Fortunately, every dongle comes with one, so the
    omission is not a big deal. In fact, people enjoy the improved
    portability removing it allows.

    Why are you such a doofus? Things change. Hardware comes and goes.
    Electronics comes and goes.

    Yeah, but you can't just handwave everything with that justification.

    Agreed. Of course, people can just buy hardware that includes the ports
    they need if it's a big deal. If you don't like that a Mac only has thunderbolt ports, don't buy a Mac. If you insist on getting one anyway,
    feel free to get yourself a dongle.

    The facts are, no one cares about "industry standard" SD cards and "industry >> standard" wired headphones in 2026. Thus, both are no longer "industry
    standards" when only 25% of phones/tablets have them.

    Get OVER it already. How many times are you going to whine about this? If you
    MUST have these, then buy a phone that still has them.

    Meanwhile, the rest of world has moved on. Just like we moved on from TV >> antennas on the roof and hand crank cars and AM radios and wired networks.

    I think you need to go look these things up, because if you think we've "moved on from TV antennas on the roof", I'd love to know what the replacement is. To my knowledge, terrestrial television is still relying
    on antennas being high enough and clear of obstacles to receive
    broadcasts?

    It is. ATSC 3 is supposed to have incredible reception past 80km from
    the antenna, removing the hurdles older antennas faced. However, this increased reception appears to be the result of Internet connectivity.
    Either way, the new standard allows broadcasters to block signals,
    presumably to allow for paid content, so people aren't too excited about it.
    --
    CrudeSausage
    MacBook Air M4 Sky Blue
    iPhone 13
    Friendly Apple zealot
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Nuno Silva@nunojsilva@invalid.invalid to comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Sun Nov 22 10:47:04 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 2026-11-21, Frank Slootweg wrote:

    Nuno Silva <nunojsilva@invalid.invalid> wrote:
    [...]

    I think you need to go look these things up, because if you think we've
    "moved on from TV antennas on the roof", I'd love to know what the
    replacement is. To my knowledge, terrestrial television is still relying
    on antennas being high enough and clear of obstacles to receive
    broadcasts?

    Yes, some of Nick Charles's comments are generalizations, probably
    from his perspective.

    But for example this "we moved on from TV antennas on the roof" is
    fully true in our country.(The Netherlands). We have cable/fibre
    (digital) TV nearly everywhere and where/when it's not available or not

    Yes, but cable TV or EDFA over GPON aren't replacements, except perhaps
    if it's mandated to be free for everyone in the same fashion terrestrial television is, and even then it's questionable whether it's actually a replacement.

    possible, there's DVB-T (Terrestial) TV, which uses a small antenna, not
    one "on the roof". And for most people, TV (both live and on-demand) is available via the Internet.

    I didn't know DVB-T was supposed to be *that* good. Granted, the one
    deployment I did see (.pt) was marred by bad choices which meant less
    than stellar coverage, at least initially.

    Similarly for AM radio, being replaced by DAB+ (and yes, still FM).
    And yes, my emergency radio has both.

    I thought digital broadcasting in radio wasn't as power-efficient or
    simple as AM and FM on the receiver side. Or is that a non-issue now?
    And is it as resilient at least on the broadcasting side? (Power
    requirements for battery- and generator-backed operation, for example.)

    And no, my laptop doesn't have an Ethernet port. (Don't need it (1200
    Mbps is fast enough), but can get a dongle if I would need it.)

    And no, my car does not have a crank starter, but *does* have a
    'cigarette lighter' socket. :-)
    --
    Nuno Silva
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Frank Slootweg@this@ddress.is.invalid to comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Sun Nov 22 15:38:51 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Nick Charles <none@none.none> wrote:
    On Nov 21, 2026 at 3:58:47?PM EST, "Frank Slootweg" <this@ddress.is.invalid> wrote:
    [...]
    And no, my car does not have a crank starter, but *does* have a 'cigarette lighter' socket. :-)

    LOL yeah, most cars call those "12 volt power socket" now. Do any new cars today still have actual cigarette lighters?

    Probably not in most countries where smoking in cars is frowned upon
    or even forbidden.

    My current 2009 car just has a plastic stub, not an actual cigarette
    lighter. Don't remember what my 2003 one had.

    "12 volt power socket" might be a bit ambiguous, because AFAIK, some
    vehicles have a 12VDC power socket which is different from a 'cigarette lighter' socket, i.e. a real socket/connector, instead of the 'cigarette lighter' socket kludge.

    The point is, whining about "missing" 30 year old SD cards and 100 year old wired headphones is just pointless.

    I'd better not tell you that I 'miss' a SD card slot in another of my
    devices and that - as others have mentioned - wired headphones are
    becoming popular again (but indeed not with a shaky 3.3mm plug)! :-)
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Frank Slootweg@this@ddress.is.invalid to comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Sun Nov 22 15:41:26 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Maria Sophia <mariasophia@comprehension.com> wrote:
    Frank Slootweg wrote:
    And no, my car does not have a crank starter, but *does* have a 'cigarette lighter' socket. :-)

    The TV antenna is a different issue than the crank starter.

    I didn't bring them up, so why respond to me?

    [...]
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Frank Slootweg@this@ddress.is.invalid to comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Sun Nov 22 15:55:12 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Nuno Silva <nunojsilva@invalid.invalid> wrote:
    On 2026-11-21, Frank Slootweg wrote:

    Nuno Silva <nunojsilva@invalid.invalid> wrote:
    [...]

    I think you need to go look these things up, because if you think we've
    "moved on from TV antennas on the roof", I'd love to know what the
    replacement is. To my knowledge, terrestrial television is still relying >> on antennas being high enough and clear of obstacles to receive
    broadcasts?

    Yes, some of Nick Charles's comments are generalizations, probably
    from his perspective.

    But for example this "we moved on from TV antennas on the roof" is
    fully true in our country.(The Netherlands). We have cable/fibre
    (digital) TV nearly everywhere and where/when it's not available or not

    Yes, but cable TV or EDFA over GPON aren't replacements, except perhaps
    if it's mandated to be free for everyone in the same fashion terrestrial television is, and even then it's questionable whether it's actually a replacement.

    We have very few free channels, but those which are free are available
    both on cable/fibre and DVB-T.

    And it *is* a replacemwent, because there isn't anything else, i.e. no
    TV broadcast 'over the (non-DVB-T) air'.

    possible, there's DVB-T (Terrestial) TV, which uses a small antenna, not one "on the roof". And for most people, TV (both live and on-demand) is available via the Internet.

    I didn't know DVB-T was supposed to be *that* good. Granted, the one deployment I did see (.pt) was marred by bad choices which meant less
    than stellar coverage, at least initially.

    Similarly for AM radio, being replaced by DAB+ (and yes, still FM).
    And yes, my emergency radio has both.

    I thought digital broadcasting in radio wasn't as power-efficient or
    simple as AM and FM on the receiver side. Or is that a non-issue now?

    Already with FM you have more - but less powerful - transmitters (than
    with AM). AFAIK, with DAB+ you have still more - and still less powerful
    - transmitters. But I have not been keeping tabs. For me, DAB+ just
    works, with a ~15cm (non-extended) antenna.

    And is it as resilient at least on the broadcasting side? (Power
    requirements for battery- and generator-backed operation, for example.)

    It should be. Our emergency stations depend on it (and FM).

    And no, my laptop doesn't have an Ethernet port. (Don't need it (1200 Mbps is fast enough), but can get a dongle if I would need it.)

    And no, my car does not have a crank starter, but *does* have a 'cigarette lighter' socket. :-)
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From -hh@recscuba_google@huntzinger.com to comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Sun Nov 22 12:49:27 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 11/21/26 08:55, Nuno Silva wrote:
    On 2026-11-20, Nick Charles wrote:

    The facts are, no one cares about "industry standard" SD cards and "industry >> standard" wired headphones in 2026. Thus, both are no longer "industry
    standards" when only 25% of phones/tablets have them.

    Get OVER it already. How many times are you going to whine about this? If >> you MUST have these, then buy a phone that still has them.

    Meanwhile, the rest of world has moved on. Just like we moved on from TV >> antennas on the roof and hand crank cars and AM radios and wired networks.

    I think you need to go look these things up, because if you think we've "moved on from TV antennas on the roof", I'd love to know what the replacement is. To my knowledge, terrestrial television is still relying
    on antennas being high enough and clear of obstacles to receive
    broadcasts?


    Google: as per Nielsen (May 2026), only 18.7% of US households still
    have OTA TV. That means that 81.3% do not have OTA TV antennas.

    Similarly, "Horowitz Research (2025): 19% of surveyed homes have a TV
    antenna (81% do not), down from 32% in 2020."

    What's replaced OTA:
    * Cable TV
    * Satellite TV
    * Internet TV


    -hh
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Alan@nuh-uh@nope.com to comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Sun Nov 22 11:03:26 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 2026-11-22 08:41, Frank Slootweg wrote:
    Maria Sophia <mariasophia@comprehension.com> wrote:
    Frank Slootweg wrote:
    And no, my car does not have a crank starter, but *does* have a
    'cigarette lighter' socket. :-)

    The TV antenna is a different issue than the crank starter.

    I didn't bring them up, so why respond to me?

    [...]

    Details like that don't matter to a narcissist such as Arlen.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Frank Slootweg@this@ddress.is.invalid to comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Sun Nov 22 18:18:32 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Alan <nuh-uh@nope.com> wrote:
    On 2026-11-22 08:41, Frank Slootweg wrote:
    Maria Sophia <mariasophia@comprehension.com> wrote:
    Frank Slootweg wrote:
    And no, my car does not have a crank starter, but *does* have a
    'cigarette lighter' socket. :-)

    The TV antenna is a different issue than the crank starter.

    I didn't bring them up, so why respond to me?

    [...]

    Details like that don't matter to a narcissist such as Arlen.

    It was one of them rhetorical thingies, but thanks anyway! :-)
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Sun Nov 22 14:43:21 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Frank Slootweg wrote:
    And no, my car does not have a crank starter, but *does* have a
    'cigarette lighter' socket. :-)

    The TV antenna is a different issue than the crank starter.

    I didn't bring them up, so why respond to me?

    [...]

    Details like that don't matter to a narcissist such as Arlen.

    It was one of them rhetorical thingies, but thanks anyway! :-)

    It is a group thread that someone defending the iPhone's lack of
    functionality to the death started about how embarrassed they are that it's
    so easy to show they fell for every Apple marketing trick in the book.

    The Apple religious zealots *hate* that their beloved "god-like" iPhone has these obvious flaws, which crippled its functionality versus that of
    Android.

    Bear in mind this topic went through three stages this week.

    1. First, we discussed how crippled the iPhone was in basic hardware
    2. Being desperate to defend Apple, they claimed it was a "tradeoff"
    3. And yet, losing everything & gaining nothing isn't a tradeoff at all

    That's the point.

    It's not a tradeoff when we gained nothing by losing basic hardware.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Sun Nov 22 14:50:42 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Frank Slootweg wrote:
    LOL yeah, most cars call those "12 volt power socket" now. Do any new cars >> today still have actual cigarette lighters?

    Probably not in most countries where smoking in cars is frowned upon
    or even forbidden.

    Remember the days when an 'ash tray' was a normal part of the vehicle?

    My current 2009 car just has a plastic stub, not an actual cigarette lighter. Don't remember what my 2003 one had.

    I remember on business trips in the 80s and 90's the rental cars would
    remove the cigarette lighter, and left just a plug in its place.

    "12 volt power socket" might be a bit ambiguous, because AFAIK, some vehicles have a 12VDC power socket which is different from a 'cigarette lighter' socket, i.e. a real socket/connector, instead of the 'cigarette lighter' socket kludge.

    I keep an emergency air compressor in the trunk which runs off the
    cigarette lighter socket, although, if the socket wasn't there, with clips,
    it could run off the battery just as well I guess.

    For my older cars (built in the 1990's), it's the USB charger of course.

    The point is, whining about "missing" 30 year old SD cards and 100 year old >> wired headphones is just pointless.

    I'd better not tell you that I 'miss' a SD card slot in another of my devices and that - as others have mentioned - wired headphones are
    becoming popular again (but indeed not with a shaky 3.3mm plug)! :-)

    When I looked up the Samsung phones with the basic hardware, I ran across a bunch of articles saying "the wired headphone is back!", but I didn't read them.

    Most people are can't comprehend the main point.

    Dunno why.
    I guess hte propaganda makes people parrot all this silly stuff.

    What matters when basic hardware is removed is what you get in return.
    And the answer of what we got in return, is we got NOTHING in return.

    a. We didn't get a lower sales price
    b. We didn't get a slimmer phone
    c. We didn't get a bigger battery
    d. We didn't get better water protection
    etc.

    What we got was the opportunity to buy something to replace only some of
    the missing functionality (as the main functionality cannot be replaced).

    That's not a "tradeoff".
    Which was my point.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Sun Nov 22 14:56:49 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    To the people who think losing something is a 'tradeoff'...
    I guess the propaganda makes people parrot all this silly stuff.

    What matters when basic hardware is removed is what you get in return.

    And the answer of what we got in return, is we got NOTHING in return.
    a. We didn't get a lower sales price
    b. We didn't get a more reliable device
    b. We didn't get a slimmer phone
    c. We didn't get a bigger battery
    d. We didn't get better water protection
    etc.

    Those are simply the "believable excuses" that marketing spewed.
    And, people believe that propaganda so much that they parrot it.

    What we got was the opportunity to buy something to replace only some of
    the missing functionality (as the main functionality cannot be replaced).

    That's not a "tradeoff".
    Which is my point.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Brock McNuggets@brock.mcnuggets@gmail.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Sun Nov 22 12:30:37 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 22 Nov 2026, Maria Sophia wrote in <11dvdtg$1ttl$1@nnrp.usenet.blueworldhosting.com>:
    To the people who think losing something is a 'tradeoff'...

    Literally nobody said that.

    You make things up.

    I guess the propaganda makes people parrot all this silly stuff.

    What matters when basic hardware is removed is what you get in
    return.

    And the answer of what we got in return, is we got NOTHING in
    return.

    Literally nobody said that. You make things up.

    a. We didn't get a lower sales price
    b. We didn't get a more reliable device

    More resistant to dirt and moisture.

    b. We didn't get a slimmer phone
    c. We didn't get a bigger battery

    Model Year Battery (mAh) Headphone jack ---------------------- ---- ------------- --------------
    iPhone 6 2014 1,810 Yes
    iPhone 6 Plus 2014 2,915 Yes
    iPhone 6s 2015 1,715 Yes
    iPhone 6s Plus 2015 2,750 Yes
    iPhone SE (1st gen) 2016 1,624 Yes
    ---------------------- ---- ------------- --------------
    iPhone 7 2016 1,960 No
    iPhone 7 Plus 2016 2,900 No

    CHANGE, SAME-SIZE MODELS (6s -> 7)

    iPhone 6s -> iPhone 7 1,715 -> 1,960 +14.3%
    iPhone 6s Plus -> iPhone 7 Plus 2,750 -> 2,900 +5.5%

    d. We didn't get better water protection
    etc.

    Those are simply the "believable excuses" that marketing spewed.
    And, people believe that propaganda so much that they parrot it.

    What we got was the opportunity to buy something to replace only
    some of the missing functionality (as the main functionality
    cannot be replaced).

    That's not a "tradeoff".
    Which is my point.

    --
    You can't find peace with someone at war with themselves.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2