• Why sd storage is less needed today, in 2026, than on January 14, 2021

    From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to comp.mobile.android,misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Wed Nov 18 15:45:32 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Why SD storage is less needed today, in 2026, than it was on
    January 14, 2021

    That's the date Samsung removed the microSD card slot from its
    S21 flagship lineup.
    a. S21: 128GB or 256GB (no portable storage slot)
    b. S21+: 128GB or 256GB (no portable storage slot)
    c. S21 Ultra: 128GB, 256GB or 512GB (no portable storage slot)

    Notice the size of the baseline storage.
    It's "big enough" for most people, right?

    So, from the perspective of increasing storage, it's reasonable
    to argue that an SD card slot wouldn't have been immediately
    necessary when someone purchased one of those phones five years
    ago, when they first went on sale.

    But there's an important distinction here.

    Not needing expandable storage doesn't mean not benefiting from
    having the option.

    A phone without expandable storage has fewer capabilities and
    fewer options than an otherwise equivalent phone with expandable
    storage.

    And no, the evidence doesn't support the usual justifications
    for removing it:

    a. Making the phone thinner.
    b. Making the phone more waterproof.
    c. Making more room for a bigger battery.

    Plenty of phones have all those things AND an SD card slot.

    And, as a case in point, the S21 lineup wasn't particularly
    remarkable in any of those respects compared with many other
    phones that had the sd slot at that time.

    Those were simply "believable" marketing excuses for removing
    functionality which many people, even today, unthinkingly parrot.

    The observation that any one person might not need or use an
    option doesn't somehow make its removal an improvement.

    We can hammer a nail into wood with a rock, but if we really
    want the standard accepted option of removing that nail easily,
    we need a hammer with a claw (or, an extra nail-removal tool).

    A phone without portable storage choices is like using a rock
    to hammer nails instead of using a claw hammer as it might accomplish the immediate task, but we've clearly lost portable-storage functionality and options.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From bixbox@noreply@example.invalid to comp.mobile.android,misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Wed Nov 18 19:23:43 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Maria Sophia <mariasophia@comprehension.com> writes:

    Those were simply "believable" marketing excuses for removing
    functionality which many people, even today, unthinkingly parrot.

    You remove functionality that give you more control of your data, so the consequence
    is that from the people prospective the only viable and convenient way
    is to be forced to use "cloud" storage.

    so instead of having a removable SSD where I can keep my data private
    I am force to use those cloud service.

    Fuck those corporation.

    bix
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Your Name@YourName@YourISP.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,comp.mobile.android on Thu Nov 19 15:35:55 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 2026-11-19 00:23:43 +0000, bixbox said:
    Maria Sophia <mariasophia@comprehension.com> writes:

    Those were simply "believable" marketing excuses for removing
    functionality which many people, even today, unthinkingly parrot.

    You remove functionality that give you more control of your data, so
    the consequence is that from the people prospective the only viable and convenient way is to be forced to use "cloud" storage.

    so instead of having a removable SSD where I can keep my data private
    I am force to use those cloud service.

    Fuck those corporation.

    bix

    You don't have to use cloud storage at all. Plus, there are ways to add
    an SD card if you really need one, but 99% of people simply don't need
    one nor can be bothered fiddling about with the easily lost silly
    little cards anyway.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Frank Slootweg@this@ddress.is.invalid to comp.mobile.android,misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Thu Nov 19 13:34:05 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    bixbox <noreply@example.invalid> wrote:
    Maria Sophia <mariasophia@comprehension.com> writes:

    Those were simply "believable" marketing excuses for removing
    functionality which many people, even today, unthinkingly parrot.

    You remove functionality that give you more control of your data,

    [Rewind/repeat:]

    Followup-To: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    You're clearly trolling. It's a tad hard to 'remove' something which
    was never there.

    so the consequence is that from the people prospective the only viable
    and convenient way is to be forced to use "cloud" storage.

    You don't have to use "cloud" storage. Just use the computer you used
    to write and post your post. And read on.

    so instead of having a removable SSD where I can keep my data private
    I am force to use those cloud service.

    It's not an SSD, but a microSD card, but I digress. (BTW, you *can*
    have a removable SSD, no problem).

    But you can still have [micro]SD card storage (or/and memory sticks),
    just put them in a [micro]SD card-reader which you plug in your phones'
    USB port. 'Problem' solved.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,comp.mobile.android on Thu Nov 19 15:43:39 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Your Name wrote:
    You don't have to use cloud storage at all. Plus, there are ways to add
    an SD card if you really need one, but 99% of people simply don't need
    one nor can be bothered fiddling about with the easily lost silly
    little cards anyway.

    I've always been reasonable and wholly logical in decades on Usenet, no
    matter what the facts were about any given phone or product line.

    The whole point of this thread, which "mostly" agrees with what "Your Name" just said, is the sd slot was clearly needed when Apple introduced the
    iPhone and when Samsung started revoking the industry standard sd slot.

    Apple's marketing strategy, clearly, was to cause pain that they could
    solve with extra-cost options, which Apple has been very successful at.

    Every OEM would love to copy Apple's marketing genius, so Samsung did.

    In 2007, the first iPhone launched with 4GB or 8GB internal storage, and
    the 2010 Galaxy S launched with 8GB or 16GB, all of which was "too small".

    In the Apple case, people flocked to the iCloud, which made Apple money.
    Cloud solutions were added for Android also, but sd cards took up demand.

    But, by the time Samsung dropped the microSD slot more than a decade later,
    in January 2021 with the Galaxy S21 lineup, flagship base storage had
    reached 128GB (and up to 512GB on the Ultra), and flagship base capacities
    have continued climbing to 256GB+ since then. Which is the point here.

    That growth is why people can successfully argue TODAY, that an SD card
    slot is less necessary for basic capacity on most phones of today (which
    have at least 128GB of internal storage).

    Still, there's a difference in not needing extra space from losing the
    option of portable storage (i.e., the claw part of the carpenter's hammer).

    Given I'm always logically sensible, and given most people who post to this newsgroup (particularly Apple owners) decidedly illogical, it defies logic
    when they claim that their "solution" is "better" than the sd card was.

    Losing a capability is always a loss in functionality if it can't be fully replaced for free, and nobody can fully replace what sd does w/o that slot.

    To put it bluntly, people who claim a replacement, are all illogical.
    Because it's impossible.

    Even so, a partial replacement, today, with 128GB storage being normal,
    greatly lessens the need for sd cards in a mobile device, that I agree.

    I'm always logical to the core.
    Most people, are not.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Nuno Silva@nunojsilva@invalid.invalid to comp.mobile.android,misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Fri Nov 20 01:24:11 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 2026-11-19, Frank Slootweg wrote:

    bixbox <noreply@example.invalid> wrote:
    Maria Sophia <mariasophia@comprehension.com> writes:

    Those were simply "believable" marketing excuses for removing
    functionality which many people, even today, unthinkingly parrot.

    You remove functionality that give you more control of your data,

    [Rewind/repeat:]

    Followup-To: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    You're clearly trolling. It's a tad hard to 'remove' something which
    was never there.

    ... wait, so iPhones never had -|SD slots?
    --
    Nuno Silva
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Your Name@YourName@YourISP.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android on Fri Nov 20 18:29:34 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 2026-11-20 01:24:11 +0000, Nuno Silva said:
    On 2026-11-19, Frank Slootweg wrote:
    bixbox <noreply@example.invalid> wrote:
    Maria Sophia <mariasophia@comprehension.com> writes:

    Those were simply "believable" marketing excuses for removing
    functionality which many people, even today, unthinkingly parrot.

    You remove functionality that give you more control of your data,

    [Rewind/repeat:]

    Followup-To: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    You're clearly trolling. It's a tad hard to 'remove' something which
    was never there.

    ... wait, so iPhones never had |SD slots?

    Yep. Apple has never put SD card slots in any iPhone or iPad device.
    There has been a card slot in some of Apple's laptop and desktop
    computers (sometimes ridiculously on the back, making putting the cards
    in even more fiddly). The reality is that most users do not use silly
    SD cards at all.

    As usual, Smasung and other Android device makers mad a big fuss about
    Apple not having a card slot ... and then those other manufacturers
    quickly started taking the card slot out of their devices too (while
    not lowering the prices). The only Smsung smartphone models that still
    have an SD card slot are apparently the A-series models.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Arno Welzel@usenet@arnowelzel.de to misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Fri Nov 20 13:32:22 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    bixbox, 2026-11-19 01:23:

    Maria Sophia <mariasophia@comprehension.com> writes:

    Those were simply "believable" marketing excuses for removing
    functionality which many people, even today, unthinkingly parrot.

    You remove functionality that give you more control of your data, so the consequence
    is that from the people prospective the only viable and convenient way
    is to be forced to use "cloud" storage.

    so instead of having a removable SSD where I can keep my data private
    I am force to use those cloud service.

    Usually people do not remove the microSD card of their phone all the
    time since this often requires tools to open the slot and the contacts
    are also not design to withstand card removals on a weekly or even daily
    basis.

    The better solution is to do external backups using USB or Wifi. You
    also don't need a cloud server from Google etc. - Nextcloud is for free
    and can be used on your own computer. And even if you don't want to
    maintain this on you own - Hetzner offers Nextcloud with 1 TB storage
    for about 5 USD monthly:

    https://www.hetzner.com/storage/storage-share/
    --
    Arno Welzel
    https://arnowelzel.de
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Nick Charles@none@none.none to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android on Fri Nov 20 15:43:05 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Your Name <YourName@YourISP.com> wrote:
    On 2026-11-20 01:24:11 +0000, Nuno Silva said:
    On 2026-11-19, Frank Slootweg wrote:
    bixbox <noreply@example.invalid> wrote:
    Maria Sophia <mariasophia@comprehension.com> writes:

    Those were simply "believable" marketing excuses for removing
    functionality which many people, even today, unthinkingly parrot.

    You remove functionality that give you more control of your data,

    [Rewind/repeat:]

    Followup-To: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    You're clearly trolling. It's a tad hard to 'remove' something which
    was never there.

    ... wait, so iPhones never had -|SD slots?

    Yep. Apple has never put SD card slots in any iPhone or iPad device.
    There has been a card slot in some of Apple's laptop and desktop
    computers (sometimes ridiculously on the back, making putting the cards
    in even more fiddly). The reality is that most users do not use silly
    SD cards at all.

    As usual, Smasung and other Android device makers mad a big fuss about
    Apple not having a card slot ... and then those other manufacturers
    quickly started taking the card slot out of their devices too (while
    not lowering the prices). The only Smsung smartphone models that still
    have an SD card slot are apparently the A-series models.

    Which brings us to Arlen starting this absurd topic.

    TL;DR

    Now that Samsung no longer has antique SD card slots, it is OK now.
    Because Arlen defends Samsung to the death.

    Next up from Arlen will be the missing rCLindustry standardrCY, 100 year old socket for wired headphones.

    Hint: That too is gone because no one uses it.

    Hint2: That too will be acceptable now because Samsung is removing it.





    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Fri Nov 20 12:58:25 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Nick Charles wrote:
    defends Samsung to the death.

    Since this thread has both sides of the mobile phone market on it, it's
    notable that the Apple nutcases would say I "defend Samsung to the death".

    Anyone on the Android (or Windows) newsgroup will find it amusing for sure
    that I would be accused of defending any OEM mothership to the death.

    Let alone Samsung.
    Yet, this belief system of the Apple nutcases proves my point about them.

    The fact that their main rebuttal to the fact Apple has never provided an iPhone/iPad sd slot is that I "defend Samsung to the death" shows us how
    absurd they are when it comes to their defense of Apple to the death...no matter what.

    What's happening is the Apple nutcases can't fathom the argument that Apple never provided the basic hardware almost two decades ago, when it was
    sorely needed, because Apple's overarching strategy has always been three steps.

    1. Lock the user into the ecosystem (as that is the necessary 1st step)
    2. Then, cause pain (e.g., in this case, by not providing the sd slot)
    3. Finally, sell an extra-cost solution to solve the pain Apple caused

    For almost two decades, only the Apple user felt that immense pain to spend more money purchasing iCloud accounts because of the lack of storage slots.

    The Apple nutcases can't believe that's Apple's strategy, which is fine,
    but to claim that I "defend Samsung to the death" is patently absurd.

    What's different was stated in the opening post, which is that phones
    typically have the necessary 128GB of storage now, two decades later.

    Do rational folks agree?
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to comp.mobile.android,misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Fri Nov 20 22:54:27 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Arno Welzel wrote:
    so instead of having a removable SSD where I can keep my data private
    I am force to use those cloud service.

    Usually people do not remove the microSD card of their phone all the
    time since this often requires tools to open the slot and the contacts
    are also not design to withstand card removals on a weekly or even daily basis.

    Hi Arno,

    I always strive to be perfectly reasonable so as to accept any logically sensible argument where I must easily agree with you that most people
    remove the sd card only a few times in the ~5-year life of the device.

    Mostly I removed mine, for example, to double the storage, or, in some
    cases, to populate a second phone with all the APKs from the first phone.

    Since I upgraded by additional storage from 32GB to 64GB to 128GB to 256GB
    over time, that's only, what... um... 4 card insertions since April 2021.

    Of course, that's four more card changes than if my 64GB phone didn't come
    with the sdcard, because it's 100% impossible to do w/o that card slot.

    BTW, those who claim losing functionality is a 'tradeoff' don't understand
    that you have to actually "trade something" for a tradeoff to occur.
    Newsgroups: misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy
    Subject: Stop calling missing hardware a "tradeoff" when it's really a loss in functionality!
    Date: Fri, 20 Nov 2026 17:58:22 -0400
    Message-ID: <11dqfpu$166b$1@nnrp.usenet.blueworldhosting.com>

    There is nothing to "trade" if the phone with the sd card already does everything that the phone w/o the sd card does (which they all do).

    Hence, there is no actual advantage to losing the sd slot, although there
    are a list of "theoretical" advantages which we've shown don't actually
    happen, such as the potential for a...
    a. slimmer phone
    b. more waterproof
    c. lower cost
    d. bigger battery
    These things, while theoretical, have never been shown to actually exist,
    and certainly they don't exist in the flagship phones we are speaking of.

    The better solution is to do external backups using USB or Wifi.

    I disagree that it's the "better" solution because it matters greatly what
    the starting point storage is. If you start with 64GB, the "better
    solution" might very well be the sdcard but if you start with 128GB, then
    that can easily change what the "better solution" might be.

    Still, people seem to ignore that there is no downside to the sd slot.
    None. (see theoretical above)

    Since it's basically free, and since it does stuff that is impossible to replace, why not get it?

    Anyway, with storage habitually being 128GB or greater, I agree that the
    cost advantages to sd don't matter that much 'cuz you can't get a cheaper
    128GB phone than the baseline.

    Although 1024GB sd cards cost a *lot* less than 1024GB of internal storage!

    You
    also don't need a cloud server from Google etc. - Nextcloud is for free
    and can be used on your own computer. And even if you don't want to
    maintain this on you own - Hetzner offers Nextcloud with 1 TB storage
    for about 5 USD monthly:
    https://www.hetzner.com/storage/storage-share/

    Arno, remember that I'm eminently logical, so there's zero chance you'll
    ever be able to make a case purely on costs, compared to sd card storage.

    It's illogical to the core since sd storage is so damn cheap.

    Randomly, I googled for a sandisk 512GB sd card. It's $43.99 (call it $50). <https://vip688.shop/products/sandisk-512gb-extreme-pro-uhs-i-sdxc-memory-card>

    How much is iCloud storage for the 5 to 7 year life of the phone?
    It's $599.40 over five years.

    How much is Google cloud storage for 512GB for 5 years?
    It's $599.40 (because of the way Google tiers these things).

    What about your suggestion above?
    It's $300 over five years.

    Anyone who argues any storage is "cheaper" than sd storage is illogical.
    Am I wrong?

    Remember the key fact that the people who claim there are 'tradeoffs' don't understand is you can still do everything with an sd card phone that a
    phone without an sd card, so you can always pay thru the nose for storage.

    Still, the main point of this thread is that with phones habitually having 128GB as the minimum configuration, there's less of a need for sd storage.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2