• Re: Apple's iPhone Duo Repair Prices Are Out, and Dropping This $2,000 Foldable Could Be a Financial Disaster

    From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Tue Oct 20 13:06:19 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Chris wrote:
    Why can't you ever find any of these zealots you talk about?

    Oh but he can. They're *everywhere*! I'm one, you're one, everyone is!

    Since there are people reading this who are NOT religious zealots, when you make an absurd excuse for Apple's crappy capacity by saying one of the most important specifications for a battery is, in your words "brain dead", that
    is an indication that you'll defend Apple to the death, no matter what,
    using the first absurd inanely idiotic excuse that pops into your head.

    Snit does it (aka Brock McNuggets). Alan Baker does it. nospam did it.
    Lewis did it. Jolly Roger does it. JF Mezei did it. Your Name does it.

    Even Alan Browne did it, although at least he often tried to find an Apple white paper or marketing blurb that seemed to back up his excuses.

    To a lesser extent, Haemactylus, -hh, Tom Elam and Tyrone do it, but
    they're actually sensible some times, so they're on the nutcase fringe.

    When you stop claiming the most important specification for a battery is
    "brain dead" just because Apple's iPhone batteries suck on that spec, then
    we can remove you from that list of known Apple religious zealot nutcases.

    Here is your first chance, Chris, to say something sensible on this ng.

    Q: What are the most important top 3 specifications for any battery?
    A: ?

    Capacity is not irrelevant. Capacity by itself is a poor stand-in for
    battery life, and treating it as the only measure is ignorant.

    Correct.

    Again, you Apple religious zealot nutcases so very much hate that Apple has chosen to put the crappiest batteries they can get away with into the
    iPhone, to the point that you claim the most important specification for overall battery life is "irrelevant" simply lends credence to my claim.

    You zealots come up with the first absurd excuse that pops into your head.

    HINT: Battery capacity is NOT "irrelevant" simply because Apple's sucks.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Tue Oct 20 13:13:18 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Chris wrote:
    The most important spec for a battery, you call "a brain dead definition". >> *What kind of person does that?*

    Someone who can think.

    It's like arguing that the most important spec for a car is the size of the petrol tank. No one cares about that. They care about mpg and range, especially for EVs.

    Chris,

    If we said a car was degraded to the point of trade in after 1000 fill
    cycles, and if most cars get about the same miles per gallon, then the size
    of the gas tank would be one of the most important related specifications.

    When overall lifetime is the metric we are discussing, for you to claim
    that the initial capacity is a "brain dead" specification, is absurd.

    I get it you defend Apple to the death.
    I get it you use the first absurd excuse you can think of to do so.

    But please come up with a better (i.e., more logical) excuse for why Apple
    puts the crappiest batteries they can get away with in the iPhone.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John Bokma@contact@johnbokma.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Tue Oct 20 19:13:18 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 20/10/2026 19:06, Maria Sophia wrote:

    Q: What are the most important top 3 specifications for any battery?
    A: ?

    1) How safe is it (don't want an exploding battery),
    2) How long it keeps my device up & running during the day,
    3) After how much time do I have to replace it (see 2).
    --
    Static tumblelog generator: https://github.com/john-bokma/tumblelog/
    Available as Python or Perl. Example tumblelog: https://plurrrr.com/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Alan@nuh-uh@nope.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Tue Oct 20 10:18:47 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 2026-10-20 10:13, Maria Sophia wrote:
    Chris wrote:
    The most important spec for a battery, you call "a brain dead definition".
    *What kind of person does that?*

    Someone who can think.

    It's like arguing that the most important spec for a car is the size of the >> petrol tank. No one cares about that. They care about mpg and range,
    especially for EVs.

    Chris,

    If we said a car was degraded to the point of trade in after 1000 fill cycles, and if most cars get about the same miles per gallon, then the size of the gas tank would be one of the most important related specifications.

    Equally important would be the mileage of the car, dimwit.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Tue Oct 20 13:26:40 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    John Bokma wrote:
    Q: What are the most important top 3 specifications for any battery?
    A: ?

    1) How safe is it (don't want an exploding battery),
    2) How long it keeps my device up & running during the day,
    3) After how much time do I have to replace it (see 2).

    For the Windows newsgroup, I'm testing all the free no-registration LLMs,
    where I am scheduled to test easemate today, so this is the first query:
    <https://www.easemate.ai/webapp/chat?from=ai-chat>

    Pops this query into that LLM and tell us what you get as the output?

    "When mobile device battery overall lifetime (in years) matters most,
    what are the most important specifications for the battery, in order
    of most important to least important, at purchase time of the device?"

    Here's the response (verbatim):
    <https://i.postimg.cc/8P3vhfCc/battery-lifetime.jpg>

    When considering the overall lifetime of a mobile device battery, several specifications play a crucial role. Hereos a list of the most important specifications, ranked from most important to least important, at the time
    of purchase:

    1. Battery Capacity (mAh): Measured in milliampere-hours (mAh), this
    indicates how much charge the battery can hold. A higher capacity generally means longer usage time between charges.

    2. Battery Chemistry: The type of battery chemistry (e.g., Lithium-ion, Lithium-polymer) affects longevity, performance, and safety. Lithium-ion is
    the most common due to its balance of capacity, weight, and lifespan.

    3. Cycle Life: This refers to the number of complete charge and discharge cycles a battery can undergo before its capacity significantly diminishes.
    A higher cycle life means the battery will last longer overall.

    4. Self-Discharge Rate: This is the rate at which a battery loses its
    charge when not in use. A lower self-discharge rate is preferable for maintaining battery life over time.

    5. Charging Speed: Fast charging capabilities can be convenient but may
    impact battery lifespan if not managed properly. Understanding the charging technology (e.g., fast charging, adaptive charging) is important.

    6. Operating Temperature Range: Batteries have optimal temperature ranges
    for performance and longevity. Specifications that indicate how well the battery performs in extreme temperatures can be crucial for durability.

    7. Battery Management System (BMS): A good BMS helps monitor and manage
    battery health, charging cycles, and temperature, contributing to the
    overall lifespan of the battery.

    8. Warranty and Manufacturer Reputation: A longer warranty and a reputable manufacturer can indicate confidence in the battery's longevity and performance.

    9. Physical Size and Design: While not directly affecting longevity, the
    design can influence heat dissipation and overall device efficiency,
    impacting battery life indirectly.

    10. Environmental Impact and Recycling: Consideration of how the battery is made and its recyclability can be important for sustainability, though it
    may not directly affect the battery's performance.

    By focusing on these specifications, you can make a more informed decision about a mobile device's battery longevity at the time of purchase.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Brock McNuggets@brock.mcnuggets@gmail.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Tue Oct 20 10:27:41 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On Oct 20, 2026 at 10:06 AM, Maria Sophia wrote in 11b872b$1qe5$1@nnrp.usenet.blueworldhosting.com:
    Chris wrote:
    Why can't you ever find any of these zealots you talk about?

    Oh but he can. They're *everywhere*! I'm one, you're one, everyone
    is!

    Since there are people reading this who are NOT religious zealots,
    when you make an absurd excuse for Apple's crappy capacity by saying
    one of the most important specifications for a battery is, in your
    words "brain dead", that is an indication that you'll defend Apple to
    the death, no matter what, using the first absurd inanely idiotic
    excuse that pops into your head.

    Snit does it (aka Brock McNuggets). Alan Baker does it. nospam did it.
    Lewis did it. Jolly Roger does it. JF Mezei did it. Your Name does it.

    Why not try to be honest?
    --
    It's impossible for someone who is at war with themselves to be at
    peace with you.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Tue Oct 20 13:39:27 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    CrudeSausage wrote:
    Additionally, some of those Chinese brands don't exactly use the best quality metal on the batteries they sell you. That's part of why the
    Apple or ASUS ones wear out a lot more slowly than the ones by brands
    like MSI. However, even with good quality batteries, x86-64 drains way
    more than an ARM processor does. From my research, Apple silicon devices
    use between 3w and 15w under load whereas PCs rarely use less than 9w
    and usually closer to 25w an hour.

    You Apple religious zealot nutcases have a very short memory since we
    covered the fact Apple puts crappy batteries in the iPhone long ago.

    Newsgroups: misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy
    Subject: Did Ming-Chi Kuo ever report Apple puts cheap components in batteries, or not?
    Date: Sat, 11 Apr 2026 13:04:43 -0700
    Message-ID: <10re9gr$2dlv$1@nnrp.usenet.blueworldhosting.com>

    That thread has over 100 posts from (in order of appearance):
    Tom Elam
    Chris
    Crudesausage
    Brock McNuggets (aka Snit)
    YourName
    TheLostPacket@comcast.org
    badgolferman
    Alan Baker
    Jolly Roger

    Here is the opening post, to remind you Apple uses crappy materials.

    Years ago I reported that Apple puts purposefully cheap components in their crappy iPhone batteries, but iPhone enthusiasts have denied that for years.

    It's not often we get proof of Apple's cost-cutting strategy of putting
    crappy batteries in their iPhones, but in this one case, we have it.

    FACT:
    *Kuo: iPhone 12 5G components will cost Apple around $75-$125 per unit*
    <https://9to5mac.com/2020/08/21/kuo-iphone-12-5g-component-cost/>
    Benjamin Mayo, Aug 21 2020

    SPECIFICALLY:
    a. Kuo names the battery printed circuit board as one area where
    *Apple is downgrading its specifications*.
    b. Kuo says that the *cost cuts on internal parts* will have
    *almost* no noticeable effect on user experience.

    Obviously I reported that to this Apple newsgroup six years ago, but it
    bears repeating this fundamental fact that Apple uses cheap batteries for reasons that are purely profit oriented, and not for performance reasons.

    Here's the full text of that article because the other articles that I
    reported along with the original reports six years ago, have gone 404.

    1. The Verge: "Apple is reportedly using cheaper battery tech to offset
    the cost of 5G in the iPhone 12" (August 21, 2020)

    2. 9to5Mac: "Kuo: iPhone 12 5G components will cost Apple around $75-$125
    per unit" (August 21, 2020)

    3. MacRumors: "Kuo: Apple Slashing iPhone 12 Component Costs to Offset 5G,
    Moving to Simpler Battery Board" (August 21, 2020)

    -----< begin verbatim article text >-----
    In the latest TF Securities report from Ming-Chi Kuo, the Apple analyst estimates the cost of adding 5G to this year's iPhone. Kuo believes it will cost Apple about $75 per unit for sub-6GHz 5G support, and up to $125 for millimeter wave 5G.

    Kuo does not expect Apple to pass on all of the cost increases to the
    consumer sale price of the iPhone 12. That means Apple is looking to offset
    5G component costs by looking for cost savings elsewhere in the phone. Kuo names the battery printed circuit board as one area where Apple is
    downgrading its specifications.

    Kuo says that the cost cuts on internal parts will have almost no
    noticeable effect on user experience. Apple is also aggressively applying
    price pressure on its suppliers to source the best deals for components.
    -----< end verbatim article text >-----
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John Bokma@contact@johnbokma.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Tue Oct 20 19:43:41 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 20/10/2026 19:26, Maria Sophia wrote:
    John Bokma wrote:
    Q: What are the most important top 3 specifications for any battery?
    A: ?

    1) How safe is it (don't want an exploding battery),
    2) How long it keeps my device up & running during the day,
    3) After how much time do I have to replace it (see 2).

    [..]

    1. Battery Capacity (mAh): Measured in milliampere-hours (mAh), this indicates how much charge the battery can hold. A higher capacity generally means longer usage time between charges.

    Generally. It depends a lot on the hardware *and* software it runs.
    Hence, why I stated "How long it keeps my device up & running during the
    day" and not "A large capacity".
    3. Cycle Life: This refers to the number of complete charge and discharge cycles a battery can undergo before its capacity significantly diminishes.
    A higher cycle life means the battery will last longer overall.

    This is my 3)

    [ rest snipped ]

    I do miss 1).

    Just focusing on capacity is not smart, IMO.
    --
    Static tumblelog generator: https://github.com/john-bokma/tumblelog/
    Available as Python or Perl. Example tumblelog: https://plurrrr.com/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Alan@nuh-uh@nope.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Tue Oct 20 10:46:36 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 2026-10-20 10:26, Maria Sophia wrote:
    John Bokma wrote:
    Q: What are the most important top 3 specifications for any battery?
    A: ?

    1) How safe is it (don't want an exploding battery),
    2) How long it keeps my device up & running during the day,
    3) After how much time do I have to replace it (see 2).

    For the Windows newsgroup, I'm testing all the free no-registration LLMs, where I am scheduled to test easemate today, so this is the first query:
    <https://www.easemate.ai/webapp/chat?from=ai-chat>

    Pops this query into that LLM and tell us what you get as the output?

    "When mobile device battery overall lifetime (in years) matters most,
    what are the most important specifications FOR THE BATTERY, in order
    of most important to least important, at purchase time of the device?"
    Lying by omission...

    ...and thinking you're too clever for anyone to notice?

    Here's a clue for you, Arlen:

    You're not that clever.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John Bokma@contact@johnbokma.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Tue Oct 20 19:52:36 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 20/10/2026 19:46, Alan wrote:
    On 2026-10-20 10:26, Maria Sophia wrote:
    John Bokma wrote:
    -a-a Q: What are the most important top 3 specifications for any battery? >>>> -a-a A: ?

    1) How safe is it (don't want an exploding battery),
    2) How long it keeps my device up & running during the day,
    3) After how much time do I have to replace it (see 2).

    For the Windows newsgroup, I'm testing all the free no-registration LLMs,
    where I am scheduled to test easemate today, so this is the first query:
    -a <https://www.easemate.ai/webapp/chat?from=ai-chat>

    Pops this query into that LLM and tell us what you get as the output?

    -a "When mobile device battery overall lifetime (in years) matters most,
    -a-a what are the most important specifications FOR THE BATTERY, in order
    -a-a of most important to least important, at purchase time of the device?"
    Lying by omission...

    ...and thinking you're too clever for anyone to notice?

    Here's a clue for you, Arlen:

    You're not that clever.

    Yup, asking the same question to Github Copilot (gpt-6-luna):

    "
    When mobile device battery overall lifetime (in years) matters most,
    what are the most important specifications FOR THE BATTERY, in order
    of most important to least important, at purchase time of the device? Thought for 10s
    Thought for 2s

    For battery lifetime in years, prioritize these at purchaserConot just how long one charge lasts:

    1. Published cycle life to a stated capacity-retention level rCo Look for
    a figure such as rCLat least 1,000 full-equivalent cycles to 80%
    capacity,rCY and check the test conditions. A cycle-life number without a retention target or test details is hard to compare.
    2. Battery replacement options rCo Check whether the battery can be
    replaced, whether parts and service are available, and the likely cost.
    A replaceable battery can extend the devicerCOs useful life more reliably
    than a small difference in battery chemistry.
    3. Temperature management rCo Heat accelerates battery aging. Reviews that report sustained charging or heavy-use temperatures can be more useful
    than a processor or charging-speed spec alone.
    4. Charging controls rCo Prefer a device that lets you set a charge limit
    (for example, 80%) or has effective adaptive charging. Spending less
    time hot and fully charged generally helps a lithium-ion battery last
    longer.
    5. Chemistry, if clearly disclosed rCo Chemistry affects cycle life, but
    phone makers often provide little detail. DonrCOt assume rCLlithium-polymerrCY or a particular marketing label guarantees longer life.
    6. Capacity (mAh) rCo A larger battery may require fewer full-equivalent cycles for the same daily use, but capacity by itself does *not* tell
    you how many years the battery will last.

    Bottom line: prioritize a credible cycle-life rating, then battery
    replacement support and evidence of good temperature and charging
    management. Treat fast-charging wattage and mAh as poor indicators of
    battery longevity on their own.
    "


    Especially notice the *not* by 6. (Emphasis Copilot, not me).
    --
    Static tumblelog generator: https://github.com/john-bokma/tumblelog/
    Available as Python or Perl. Example tumblelog: https://plurrrr.com/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John Bokma@contact@johnbokma.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Tue Oct 20 19:55:51 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 20/10/2026 19:52, John Bokma wrote:
    On 20/10/2026 19:46, Alan wrote:
    On 2026-10-20 10:26, Maria Sophia wrote:
    John Bokma wrote:
    -a-a Q: What are the most important top 3 specifications for any
    battery?
    -a-a A: ?

    1) How safe is it (don't want an exploding battery),
    2) How long it keeps my device up & running during the day,
    3) After how much time do I have to replace it (see 2).

    For the Windows newsgroup, I'm testing all the free no-registration
    LLMs,
    where I am scheduled to test easemate today, so this is the first query: >>> -a <https://www.easemate.ai/webapp/chat?from=ai-chat>

    Pops this query into that LLM and tell us what you get as the output?

    -a "When mobile device battery overall lifetime (in years) matters most, >>> -a-a what are the most important specifications FOR THE BATTERY, in order >>> -a-a of most important to least important, at purchase time of the
    device?"
    Lying by omission...

    ...and thinking you're too clever for anyone to notice?

    Here's a clue for you, Arlen:

    You're not that clever.

    Yup, asking the same question to Github Copilot (gpt-6-luna):

    "
    When mobile device battery overall lifetime (in years) matters most,
    -a-a what are the most important specifications FOR THE BATTERY, in order
    -a-a of most important to least important, at purchase time of the device?

    [..]

    6. Capacity (mAh) rCo A larger battery may require fewer full-equivalent cycles for the same daily use, but capacity by itself does *not* tell
    you how many years the battery will last.

    Bottom line: prioritize a credible cycle-life rating, then battery replacement support and evidence of good temperature and charging management. Treat fast-charging wattage and mAh as poor indicators of battery longevity on their own.
    "


    Especially notice the *not* by 6. (Emphasis Copilot, not me).

    And ChatGPT gives item 7 as:
    "
    7. Battery capacity (mAh or Wh)

    A larger battery generally provides longer runtime per charge, but *does
    not necessarily last more years*.

    A larger capacity can be useful if it means fewer full-equivalent charge cycles for your daily usage. However, actual battery aging also depends
    on temperature, charging habits, cell design, and the device's power consumption.
    "

    Again, emphasis by AI, not mine.
    --
    Static tumblelog generator: https://github.com/john-bokma/tumblelog/
    Available as Python or Perl. Example tumblelog: https://plurrrr.com/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John Bokma@contact@johnbokma.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Tue Oct 20 20:10:08 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 20/10/2026 19:26, Maria Sophia wrote:
    John Bokma wrote:
    Q: What are the most important top 3 specifications for any battery?
    A: ?

    1) How safe is it (don't want an exploding battery),
    2) How long it keeps my device up & running during the day,
    3) After how much time do I have to replace it (see 2).

    For the Windows newsgroup, I'm testing all the free no-registration LLMs,

    The one I used [1] concluded: "Treat fast-charging wattage and mAh as
    poor indicators of battery longevity on their own". That's what
    everybody, except you, have been saying.

    [1] Github's Copilot CLI with gpt-luna-6, see also my other post.
    --
    Static tumblelog generator: https://github.com/john-bokma/tumblelog/
    Available as Python or Perl. Example tumblelog: https://plurrrr.com/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Brock McNuggets@brock.mcnuggets@gmail.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Tue Oct 20 11:36:25 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On Oct 20, 2026 at 10:52 AM, John Bokma wrote in
    11b89p7$387jb$1@dont-email.me:
    On 20/10/2026 19:46, Alan wrote:
    On 2026-10-20 10:26, Maria Sophia wrote:
    John Bokma wrote:
    <snip 6 lines>

    For the Windows newsgroup, I'm testing all the free no-registration
    LLMs, where I am scheduled to test easemate today, so this is the
    first query: <https://www.easemate.ai/webapp/chat?from=ai-chat>

    Pops this query into that LLM and tell us what you get as the
    output?

    "When mobile device battery overall lifetime (in years) matters
    most, what are the most important specifications FOR THE BATTERY, in
    order of most important to least important, at purchase time of the
    device?"
    Lying by omission...

    ...and thinking you're too clever for anyone to notice?

    Here's a clue for you, Arlen:

    You're not that clever.

    Yup, asking the same question to Github Copilot (gpt-6-luna):

    "
    When mobile device battery overall lifetime (in years) matters most,
    what are the most important specifications FOR THE BATTERY, in order
    of most important to least important, at purchase time of the device?
    Thought for 10s
    Thought for 2s

    For battery lifetime in years, prioritize these at purchaserConot just
    how long one charge lasts:

    1. Published cycle life to a stated capacity-retention level rCo Look
    for a figure such as "at least 1,000 full-equivalent cycles to 80%
    capacity," and check the test conditions. A cycle-life number without
    a retention target or test details is hard to compare. 2. Battery
    replacement options rCo Check whether the battery can be replaced,
    whether parts and service are available, and the likely cost. A
    replaceable battery can extend the device's useful life more reliably
    than a small difference in battery chemistry. 3. Temperature
    management rCo Heat accelerates battery aging. Reviews that report
    sustained charging or heavy-use temperatures can be more useful than a processor or charging-speed spec alone. 4. Charging controls rCo Prefer
    a device that lets you set a charge limit (for example, 80%) or has
    effective adaptive charging. Spending less time hot and fully charged generally helps a lithium-ion battery last longer. 5. Chemistry, if
    clearly disclosed rCo Chemistry affects cycle life, but phone makers
    often provide little detail. Don't assume "lithium-polymer" or a
    particular marketing label guarantees longer life. 6. Capacity (mAh) rCo
    A larger battery may require fewer full-equivalent cycles for the same
    daily use, but capacity by itself does *not* tell you how many years
    the battery will last.

    Bottom line: prioritize a credible cycle-life rating, then battery replacement support and evidence of good temperature and charging
    management. Treat fast-charging wattage and mAh as poor indicators of
    battery longevity on their own. "


    Especially notice the *not* by 6. (Emphasis Copilot, not me).

    He gets ideas in his head and they will not go away with evidence.
    --
    It's impossible for someone who is at war with themselves to be at
    peace with you.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Tue Oct 20 15:02:10 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    John Bokma wrote:
    1. Battery Capacity (mAh): Measured in milliampere-hours (mAh), this
    indicates how much charge the battery can hold. A higher capacity generally >> means longer usage time between charges.

    Generally. It depends a lot on the hardware *and* software it runs.
    Hence, why I stated "How long it keeps my device up & running during the day" and not "A large capacity".
    3. Cycle Life: This refers to the number of complete charge and discharge
    cycles a battery can undergo before its capacity significantly diminishes. >> A higher cycle life means the battery will last longer overall.

    This is my 3)

    [ rest snipped ]

    I do miss 1).

    Just focusing on capacity is not smart, IMO.

    Hi John Bokma,

    THANK YOU!

    For being sensible.

    You do NOT seem to be an Apple religious zealot, because what you said is logical, and I never disagree with any logically sensible viewpoints.

    Nobody, not me for sure, would disagree with your logically sensible
    statement that there is much more to battery life than just capacity.

    Among my degrees is an EE graduate degree, so of course I've studied
    batteries extensively, where there are many specifications for them.

    As you noted, capacity is just the starting point specification.
    That's why the EU benchmarks require more than just initial capacity.

    But my point to Chris, who said it was a "brain dead" specification, is
    that it's still the most important starting point for overall life.

    And Apple has always put crappy batteries in the iPhone, starting with
    absurdly laughable initial capacities, but, let's be fair to Apple that
    after they were so embarrassed by their poor ratings in the initial EU benchmarks, Apple did raise the initial capacity of the iPhone batteries.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John Bokma@contact@johnbokma.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Tue Oct 20 21:05:38 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 20/10/2026 20:36, Brock McNuggets wrote:
    On Oct 20, 2026 at 10:52 AM, John Bokma wrote in 11b89p7$387jb$1@dont-email.me:

    [snip]

    Bottom line: prioritize a credible cycle-life rating, then battery
    replacement support and evidence of good temperature and charging
    management. Treat fast-charging wattage and mAh as poor indicators of
    battery longevity on their own. "


    Especially notice the *not* by 6. (Emphasis Copilot, not me).

    He gets ideas in his head and they will not go away with evidence.

    I like the "Treat fast-charging wattage and mAh as poor indicators of
    battery longevity on their own.".

    I asked Claude.ai the same question:

    "
    When mobile device battery overall lifetime (in years) matters most,
    what are the most important specifications FOR THE BATTERY, in order of
    most important to least important, at purchase time of the device?

    When you're optimizing specifically for how many years a battery will
    remain usable (not just how long it lasts per charge), the specs that
    matter most rCo and the order in which they matter rCo look different from what most buying guides emphasize. Here's the ranking:

    1. Charge cycle rating (rated cycle life)
    This is the single most predictive spec. Manufacturers (or third-party teardown sites) often state something like "rated for 800 cycles to 80% capacity." A battery rated for 1000+ cycles will outlast one rated for
    500, all else equal. This number directly reflects the chemistry and
    cell engineering quality, so it's the most direct proxy for longevity.

    2. Battery chemistry type

    LFP (LiFePOrea) rCo significantly longer cycle life (often 2000rCo3000+ cycles) and much better tolerance of full charges/heat, at the cost of
    lower energy density (bulkier for the same capacity). Rare in phones,
    common in some e-readers, power banks, and increasingly some
    budget/rugged devices.
    Standard Li-ion (NMC/NCA/LCO blends) rCo what's in nearly all phones
    and laptops; typically 300rCo800 rated cycles depending on quality.
    Li-poly rCo essentially a packaging variant of Li-ion, not a separate chemistry; doesn't meaningfully change longevity on its own.

    Chemistry sets the ceiling that the cycle rating above is drawn from, so
    in practice these two specs are closely linked rCo but chemistry is worth checking separately since it's sometimes disclosed when cycle count isn't.

    3. Charging/discharge voltage range and depth-of-discharge tolerance
    Batteries that are chemically designed or firmware-limited to charge to
    a lower peak voltage (e.g., capped at 4.0V instead of the typical
    4.2rCo4.45V per cell) degrade far slower, at the cost of lower usable capacity. Some devices expose this as a "battery health" / "optimized charging" / "80% charge limit" feature rCo if a device offers
    hardware-level charge-limiting as a built-in option, that's a meaningful longevity-relevant spec, not just software fluff.

    4. Nominal capacity (mAh) relative to device power draw
    A larger battery for the same workload cycles less often per day rCo fewer cycles consumed per year of real-world use extends calendar lifespan,
    even with identical cycle-life chemistry. This matters less than #1rCo3 because it only shifts when you hit the cycle count, not how many cycles
    the cell can take.

    5. Fast-charging wattage supported (inversely important rCo lower is often better for longevity)
    Higher-wattage fast charging generates more heat and current stress per
    cycle, accelerating degradation slightly faster than slow charging, all
    else equal. This is a secondary factor rCo manufacturers increasingly compensate with better thermal management and charge curves, so it
    matters less than it used to, but very high wattages (100W+) on poorly
    managed systems can meaningfully shorten lifespan.

    6. Battery capacity density/form factor claims (Wh/L, Wh/kg)
    These relate to thinness and weight, not longevity rCo denser batteries
    are sometimes (not always) pushed to tighter tolerances that slightly
    reduce cycle life, but this is a minor, inconsistent effect compared to
    the specs above. Worth knowing about, but not something to weight
    heavily in a purchase decision.

    Why "mAh capacity" alone (which most buyers fixate on) ranks lower here:
    raw capacity affects how long a charge lasts per day, but says nothing
    about how many years of daily charging the cell can sustain before
    degrading rCo which is a separate, chemistry/engineering-driven property.

    Practical note: cycle-count ratings and charge-voltage specs are rarely printed on spec sheets or marketing pages rCo they're usually found in teardown reports (iFixit), manufacturer sustainability/repairability disclosures, or battery health documentation (especially for Apple
    devices, which publish this). If a listed spec sheet only gives you mAh
    and nothing else, that alone tells you very little about multi-year
    longevity.
    "



    Again, in the practical note we read: *If a listed spec sheet only gives
    you mAh and nothing else, that alone tells you very little about
    multi-year longevity.*

    And of course, this gem: *Why "mAh capacity" alone (which most buyers
    fixate on) ranks lower here: raw capacity affects how long a charge
    lasts per day, but says nothing about how many years of daily charging
    the cell can sustain before degrading rCo which is a separate, chemistry/engineering-driven property.*

    (Emphasis mine, in both cases)
    --
    Static tumblelog generator: https://github.com/john-bokma/tumblelog/
    Available as Python or Perl. Example tumblelog: https://plurrrr.com/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Chris@ithinkiam@gmail.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,comp.mobile.android on Tue Oct 20 19:10:40 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Maria Sophia <mariasophia@comprehension.com> wrote:
    total lifetime is what
    I'm always talking about, where Apple's iPhone batteries simply die sooner.


    An assertion you've *never* been able to substantiate beyond vague hand
    waving.

    Got anything concrete, this time?

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John Bokma@contact@johnbokma.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Tue Oct 20 21:10:48 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 20/10/2026 21:02, Maria Sophia wrote:

    [capacity]> But my point to Chris, who said it was a "brain dead" specification, is
    that it's still the most important starting point for overall life.
    "raw capacity affects how long a charge lasts per day, but says
    *nothing* about how many years of daily charging the cell can sustain
    before degrading rCo which is a separate, chemistry/engineering-driven property."

    According to Claude, emphasis mine.
    --
    Static tumblelog generator: https://github.com/john-bokma/tumblelog/
    Available as Python or Perl. Example tumblelog: https://plurrrr.com/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Nick Charles@none@none.none to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Tue Oct 20 19:11:45 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Brock McNuggets <brock.mcnuggets@gmail.com> wrote:
    On Oct 20, 2026 at 10:52 AM, John Bokma wrote in 11b89p7$387jb$1@dont-email.me:
    On 20/10/2026 19:46, Alan wrote:
    On 2026-10-20 10:26, Maria Sophia wrote:
    John Bokma wrote:
    <snip 6 lines>

    For the Windows newsgroup, I'm testing all the free no-registration
    LLMs, where I am scheduled to test easemate today, so this is the
    first query: <https://www.easemate.ai/webapp/chat?from=ai-chat>

    Pops this query into that LLM and tell us what you get as the
    output?

    "When mobile device battery overall lifetime (in years) matters
    most, what are the most important specifications FOR THE BATTERY, in
    order of most important to least important, at purchase time of the
    device?"
    Lying by omission...

    ...and thinking you're too clever for anyone to notice?

    Here's a clue for you, Arlen:

    You're not that clever.

    Yup, asking the same question to Github Copilot (gpt-6-luna):

    "
    When mobile device battery overall lifetime (in years) matters most,
    what are the most important specifications FOR THE BATTERY, in order
    of most important to least important, at purchase time of the device?
    Thought for 10s
    Thought for 2s

    For battery lifetime in years, prioritize these at purchaserConot just
    how long one charge lasts:

    1. Published cycle life to a stated capacity-retention level rCo Look
    for a figure such as "at least 1,000 full-equivalent cycles to 80%
    capacity," and check the test conditions. A cycle-life number without
    a retention target or test details is hard to compare. 2. Battery
    replacement options rCo Check whether the battery can be replaced,
    whether parts and service are available, and the likely cost. A
    replaceable battery can extend the device's useful life more reliably
    than a small difference in battery chemistry. 3. Temperature
    management rCo Heat accelerates battery aging. Reviews that report
    sustained charging or heavy-use temperatures can be more useful than a
    processor or charging-speed spec alone. 4. Charging controls rCo Prefer
    a device that lets you set a charge limit (for example, 80%) or has
    effective adaptive charging. Spending less time hot and fully charged
    generally helps a lithium-ion battery last longer. 5. Chemistry, if
    clearly disclosed rCo Chemistry affects cycle life, but phone makers
    often provide little detail. Don't assume "lithium-polymer" or a
    particular marketing label guarantees longer life. 6. Capacity (mAh) rCo
    A larger battery may require fewer full-equivalent cycles for the same
    daily use, but capacity by itself does *not* tell you how many years
    the battery will last.

    Bottom line: prioritize a credible cycle-life rating, then battery
    replacement support and evidence of good temperature and charging
    management. Treat fast-charging wattage and mAh as poor indicators of
    battery longevity on their own. "


    Especially notice the *not* by 6. (Emphasis Copilot, not me).

    He gets ideas in his head and they will not go away with evidence.

    LOL. rCLIdeasrCY in his rCLheadrCY. You are assuming facts not in evidence.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Tue Oct 20 15:11:45 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    John Bokma wrote:
    6. Capacity (mAh) iX A larger battery may require fewer full-equivalent cycles for the same daily use, but capacity by itself does *not* tell
    you how many years the battery will last.

    Hi John Bokma,

    I never disagree with anyone who makes a logically sensible statement.

    Keep in mind, this side discussion is mainly because the Apple religious zealots try to defend Apple's decisions to the death, no matter what, using
    the first utterly absurd inanely idiotic excuse that they can think of.

    Just like Apple did when the first EU benchmarks pointed out that Apple's batteries were complete crap, and where Apple spewed 44 pages of excuses.

    In this case, Chris claimed that the initial capacity was a 'brain dead' specification, where I doubt you can find a single LLM that will NOT put
    the initial capacity on the list when you ask the question about lifetime.

    And rest assured, nobody on the planet, least of all me, would claim that capacity all by itself tells you how many years the battery will last.

    Remember, we've had this discussion about the crappy batteries Apple puts
    in iPhones for something like a decade, so it's only the starting point.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John Bokma@contact@johnbokma.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,comp.mobile.android on Tue Oct 20 21:16:03 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 20/10/2026 21:10, Chris wrote:
    Maria Sophia <mariasophia@comprehension.com> wrote:
    total lifetime is what
    I'm always talking about, where Apple's iPhone batteries simply die sooner. >>

    An assertion you've *never* been able to substantiate beyond vague hand waving.

    Got anything concrete, this time?

    I just asked Claude:

    "
    Do apple batteries die sooner?
    Searched the web

    Short answer: not really rCo not systematically. There's no good evidence
    that Apple batteries inherently die faster than Android ones at the cell-chemistry level. The differences people notice come from somewhere
    else. A few caveats on my sources first: several of these are
    SEO/content-mill sites (not primary sources), and they disagree with
    each other on specific numbers, so treat exact figures loosely and look
    at the pattern across them rather than any single stat.

    What the data actually shows:

    Apple states that iPhone 15 series batteries are designed to retain
    80 percent capacity after 1,000 charge cycles rCo that's actually a higher rated cycle life than what many sources cite for older iPhones (Apple officially rates iPhones 12rCo15 at 500 cycles to 80% capacity), and
    Apple's 2026 official cycle-life guidance remains 1,000 full cycles for
    iPhone 15 and newer, 500 for 14 and earlier. So Apple itself has been
    raising its rated cycle life on newer models, not falling behind.
    iPhone lifespan analysis: Software support, battery health and iOS
    26 performance +2
    On the Android side, premium Android devices generally perform
    similarly to iPhones in battery longevity (2rCo3 years before significant degradation), while mid-range Android shows noticeable decline at 18rCo24 months and budget Android at 12rCo18 months.

    So the real divide isn't "Apple vs. Android" rCo it's premium vs.
    budget, on both platforms. A flagship Samsung or Pixel and a flagship
    iPhone are roughly in the same ballpark; it's cheap Android phones with lower-grade cells and simpler battery management systems that fall off
    faster.

    Where Apple does have a real, documented edge:

    Transparency tooling. iPhones expose a built-in "Maximum Capacity"
    health metric and cycle-aware performance management in Settings;
    Android's native battery usage stats show app-level drain but don't
    track actual cell degradation, requiring third-party apps like
    AccuBattery to estimate it. This doesn't mean Apple batteries last
    longer rCo it means it's easier to see an iPhone's battery aging than a typical Android's.

    Software longevity, not battery chemistry, is often what actually
    drives the "iPhones feel like they last longer" perception: Apple's
    robust hardware and industry-leading software update cycle provide a functional lifespan of four to seven years, with battery degradation
    being the primary bottleneck rather than the phone becoming obsolete.
    Many Android phones get shorter official OS-update windows (though this
    varies a lot by manufacturer and tier), so the device feels "outdated" independent of the battery.


    What actually drives degradation more than brand, per these sources:

    Heat exposure during charging causes more degradation than cycle
    count alone rCo this is platform-agnostic.

    Frequently fast-charging to 100% or letting a device sit at 100%
    for extended periods pushes effective cycle-equivalent stress higher
    than the nominal cycle count, again regardless of OS.

    A one-year-old battery with 150 cycles will almost always
    outperform a five-year-old battery with the same 150 cycles, because the chemistry degrades slowly over time regardless of use rCo calendar aging happens on both platforms too.

    Bottom line: the "Apple batteries die sooner" impression, if you've
    heard it, isn't well supported by current rated cycle-life specs or degradation data rCo Apple's newer-model ratings are actually competitive-to-better than many Android counterparts in the same price
    tier. What is true is that Apple's battery health reporting is more
    visible and standardized, which paradoxically can make iPhone battery
    decline feel more noticeable/discussed, simply because people can
    actually see the number dropping.
    "

    :-D
    --
    Static tumblelog generator: https://github.com/john-bokma/tumblelog/
    Available as Python or Perl. Example tumblelog: https://plurrrr.com/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Brock McNuggets@brock.mcnuggets@gmail.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Tue Oct 20 12:17:17 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On Oct 20, 2026 at 12:11 PM, Nick Charles wrote in oMucnSdo3uZsIUr3nZ2dnZfqn_SdnZ2d@supernews.com:
    Brock McNuggets <brock.mcnuggets@gmail.com> wrote:
    On Oct 20, 2026 at 10:52 AM, John Bokma wrote in
    11b89p7$387jb$1@dont-email.me:
    On 20/10/2026 19:46, Alan wrote:
    On 2026-10-20 10:26, Maria Sophia wrote:
    John Bokma wrote:
    <snip 6 lines>
    <snip 20 lines>

    Yup, asking the same question to Github Copilot (gpt-6-luna):

    "
    When mobile device battery overall lifetime (in years) matters most,
    what are the most important specifications FOR THE BATTERY, in order
    of most important to least important, at purchase time of the
    device? Thought for 10s
    Thought for 2s

    For battery lifetime in years, prioritize these at purchaserConot just
    how long one charge lasts:

    1. Published cycle life to a stated capacity-retention level rCo Look
    for a figure such as "at least 1,000 full-equivalent cycles to 80%
    capacity," and check the test conditions. A cycle-life number
    without a retention target or test details is hard to compare. 2.
    Battery replacement options rCo Check whether the battery can be
    replaced, whether parts and service are available, and the likely
    cost. A replaceable battery can extend the device's useful life more
    reliably than a small difference in battery chemistry. 3.
    Temperature management rCo Heat accelerates battery aging. Reviews
    that report sustained charging or heavy-use temperatures can be more
    useful than a processor or charging-speed spec alone. 4. Charging
    controls rCo Prefer a device that lets you set a charge limit (for
    example, 80%) or has effective adaptive charging. Spending less time
    hot and fully charged generally helps a lithium-ion battery last
    longer. 5. Chemistry, if clearly disclosed rCo Chemistry affects cycle
    life, but phone makers often provide little detail. Don't assume
    "lithium-polymer" or a particular marketing label guarantees longer
    life. 6. Capacity (mAh) rCo A larger battery may require fewer
    full-equivalent cycles for the same daily use, but capacity by
    itself does *not* tell you how many years the battery will last.

    Bottom line: prioritize a credible cycle-life rating, then battery
    replacement support and evidence of good temperature and charging
    management. Treat fast-charging wattage and mAh as poor indicators
    of battery longevity on their own. "


    Especially notice the *not* by 6. (Emphasis Copilot, not me).

    He gets ideas in his head and they will not go away with evidence.

    LOL. "Ideas" in his "head". You are assuming facts not in evidence.



    If he has evidence, he should show it.
    --
    It's impossible for someone who is at war with themselves to be at
    peace with you.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Brock McNuggets@brock.mcnuggets@gmail.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Tue Oct 20 12:18:32 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On Oct 20, 2026 at 12:05 PM, John Bokma wrote in
    11b8e23$3a0uq$1@dont-email.me:
    On 20/10/2026 20:36, Brock McNuggets wrote:
    On Oct 20, 2026 at 10:52 AM, John Bokma wrote in
    11b89p7$387jb$1@dont-email.me:

    [snip]

    Bottom line: prioritize a credible cycle-life rating, then battery
    replacement support and evidence of good temperature and charging
    management. Treat fast-charging wattage and mAh as poor indicators
    of battery longevity on their own. "


    Especially notice the *not* by 6. (Emphasis Copilot, not me).

    He gets ideas in his head and they will not go away with evidence.

    I like the "Treat fast-charging wattage and mAh as poor indicators of
    battery longevity on their own.".

    I asked Claude.ai the same question:

    "
    When mobile device battery overall lifetime (in years) matters most,
    what are the most important specifications FOR THE BATTERY, in order
    of most important to least important, at purchase time of the device?

    When you're optimizing specifically for how many years a battery will
    remain usable (not just how long it lasts per charge), the specs that
    matter most rCo and the order in which they matter rCo look different from what most buying guides emphasize. Here's the ranking:

    1. Charge cycle rating (rated cycle life)
    This is the single most predictive spec. Manufacturers (or third-party teardown sites) often state something like "rated for 800 cycles to
    80% capacity." A battery rated for 1000+ cycles will outlast one rated
    for 500, all else equal. This number directly reflects the chemistry
    and cell engineering quality, so it's the most direct proxy for
    longevity.

    2. Battery chemistry type

    LFP (LiFePOrea) rCo significantly longer cycle life (often 2000rCo3000+ cycles) and much better tolerance of full charges/heat, at the cost of
    lower energy density (bulkier for the same capacity). Rare in phones,
    common in some e-readers, power banks, and increasingly some
    budget/rugged devices. Standard Li-ion (NMC/NCA/LCO blends) rCo what's
    in nearly all phones and laptops; typically 300rCo800 rated cycles
    depending on quality. Li-poly rCo essentially a packaging variant of
    Li-ion, not a separate chemistry; doesn't meaningfully change
    longevity on its own.

    Chemistry sets the ceiling that the cycle rating above is drawn from,
    so in practice these two specs are closely linked rCo but chemistry is
    worth checking separately since it's sometimes disclosed when cycle
    count isn't.

    3. Charging/discharge voltage range and depth-of-discharge tolerance Batteries that are chemically designed or firmware-limited to charge
    to a lower peak voltage (e.g., capped at 4.0V instead of the typical 4.2rCo4.45V per cell) degrade far slower, at the cost of lower usable capacity. Some devices expose this as a "battery health" / "optimized charging" / "80% charge limit" feature rCo if a device offers
    hardware-level charge-limiting as a built-in option, that's a
    meaningful longevity-relevant spec, not just software fluff.

    4. Nominal capacity (mAh) relative to device power draw A larger
    battery for the same workload cycles less often per day rCo fewer cycles consumed per year of real-world use extends calendar lifespan, even
    with identical cycle-life chemistry. This matters less than #1rCo3
    because it only shifts when you hit the cycle count, not how many
    cycles the cell can take.

    5. Fast-charging wattage supported (inversely important rCo lower is
    often better for longevity) Higher-wattage fast charging generates
    more heat and current stress per cycle, accelerating degradation
    slightly faster than slow charging, all else equal. This is a
    secondary factor rCo manufacturers increasingly compensate with better thermal management and charge curves, so it matters less than it used
    to, but very high wattages (100W+) on poorly managed systems can
    meaningfully shorten lifespan.

    6. Battery capacity density/form factor claims (Wh/L, Wh/kg) These
    relate to thinness and weight, not longevity rCo denser batteries are sometimes (not always) pushed to tighter tolerances that slightly
    reduce cycle life, but this is a minor, inconsistent effect compared
    to the specs above. Worth knowing about, but not something to weight
    heavily in a purchase decision.

    Why "mAh capacity" alone (which most buyers fixate on) ranks lower
    here: raw capacity affects how long a charge lasts per day, but says
    nothing about how many years of daily charging the cell can sustain
    before degrading rCo which is a separate, chemistry/engineering-driven property.

    Practical note: cycle-count ratings and charge-voltage specs are
    rarely printed on spec sheets or marketing pages rCo they're usually
    found in teardown reports (iFixit), manufacturer
    sustainability/repairability disclosures, or battery health
    documentation (especially for Apple devices, which publish this). If a
    listed spec sheet only gives you mAh and nothing else, that alone
    tells you very little about multi-year longevity. "



    Again, in the practical note we read: *If a listed spec sheet only
    gives you mAh and nothing else, that alone tells you very little about multi-year longevity.*

    And of course, this gem: *Why "mAh capacity" alone (which most buyers
    fixate on) ranks lower here: raw capacity affects how long a charge
    lasts per day, but says nothing about how many years of daily charging
    the cell can sustain before degrading rCo which is a separate, chemistry/engineering-driven property.*

    (Emphasis mine, in both cases)

    Left the long quote... AI is not something to rely on blindly... but
    more reliable than he is. :)
    --
    It's impossible for someone who is at war with themselves to be at
    peace with you.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Tue Oct 20 15:19:52 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    John Bokma wrote:
    For the Windows newsgroup, I'm testing all the free no-registration LLMs,

    The one I used [1] concluded: "Treat fast-charging wattage and mAh as
    poor indicators of battery longevity on their own". That's what
    everybody, except you, have been saying.

    [1] Github's Copilot CLI with gpt-luna-6, see also my other post.

    I never disagree with anyone who makes a logically sensible statement.
    Yet, I'll vehemently disagree with idiotic statements like that one, John.

    Keep in mind, this side discussion is mainly because the Apple religious zealots try to defend Apple's decisions to the death, no matter what, using
    the first utterly absurd inanely idiotic excuse that they can think of.

    Bear in mind I never said that battery capacity was the only metric for longevity, so what you're doing is classic for Apple religious nutcases.

    You can't argue the point on logic.
    So you distort what I said, so that you could attack your fabrication.

    I repeat, I have higher degrees in electrical engineering and I would never have said that the only specification that matters for long life is a
    single capacity metric, but, I would say it's certainly an important
    metric.

    For Chris to claim it's a "brain dead" specification is my evidence that
    the Apple religious zealot nutcases try to defend Apple to the death, no
    matter what, using the first inane idiotically absurd excuse they think of.

    In your case, you're creating a false strawman to defend Apple decisions.

    Why don't you explain why all Apple iPhones failed to achieve an A rating
    when the first EU benchmarks came out? We predicted that for over a decade.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John Bokma@contact@johnbokma.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Tue Oct 20 21:21:29 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 20/10/2026 21:11, Maria Sophia wrote:

    In this case, Chris claimed that the initial capacity was a 'brain dead' specification, where I doubt you can find a single LLM that will NOT put
    the initial capacity on the list when you ask the question about lifetime.

    Each, so far, has given a warning that it's more or less meaningless to
    look at capacity by itself.

    Remember, we've had this discussion about the crappy batteries Apple puts
    in iPhones for something like a decade, so it's only the starting point.

    According to Claude:

    "
    the "Apple batteries die sooner" impression, if you've heard it, isn't
    well supported by current rated cycle-life specs or degradation data rCo Apple's newer-model ratings are actually competitive-to-better than many Android counterparts in the same price tier. What is true is that
    Apple's battery health reporting is more visible and standardized, which paradoxically can make iPhone battery decline feel more
    noticeable/discussed, simply because people can actually see the number dropping.
    "

    So, newer-model ratings are actually competitive-to-better. I don't care
    that 6 years ago they used less good parts. Ten years ago batteries
    exploded in Samsung devices... And the replacements, too...
    --
    Static tumblelog generator: https://github.com/john-bokma/tumblelog/
    Available as Python or Perl. Example tumblelog: https://plurrrr.com/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Tue Oct 20 15:28:39 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    John Bokma wrote:
    [capacity]> But my point to Chris, who said it was a "brain dead" specification, is
    that it's still the most important starting point for overall life.
    "raw capacity affects how long a charge lasts per day, but says
    *nothing* about how many years of daily charging the cell can sustain
    before degrading iX which is a separate, chemistry/engineering-driven property."

    For a moment, I thought you weren't an Apple religious zealot nutcase.
    But this shows that you resorted to bullshit to defend Apple's decisions.

    Seriously. Don't waste our time with idiotically absurd inanely childish defenses of Apple's decision to put crappy batteries in the iPhone.

    Show me a screenshot of what you exactly asked and what it exactly said.
    Make sure you asked about mobile devices. Not flashlight batteries.

    Because nobody with any knowledge of batteries would claim that the initial capacity isn't one of the most important specifications for overall life in
    a mobile device.

    Nobody.

    Specifically, we're not talking about car batteries. We're not talking
    about batteries used in toys. We're talking about mobile device batteries.

    What Apple religious zealot nutcases do to defend every Apple decision is
    they come up with the first absurdly inane excuse they can think of.

    Why not ask the LLM why Apple puts crappy batteries in the iPhone, John?
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Brock McNuggets@brock.mcnuggets@gmail.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Tue Oct 20 12:32:07 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On Oct 20, 2026 at 12:28 PM, Maria Sophia wrote in 11b8fd8$2c42$1@nnrp.usenet.blueworldhosting.com:
    John Bokma wrote:
    [capacity]> But my point to Chris, who said it was a "brain dead"
    specification, is
    that it's still the most important starting point for overall life.
    "raw capacity affects how long a charge lasts per day, but says
    *nothing* about how many years of daily charging the cell can sustain
    before degrading -iX which is a separate, chemistry/engineering-driven
    property."

    For a moment, I thought you weren't an Apple religious zealot nutcase.
    But this shows that you resorted to bullshit to defend Apple's
    decisions.

    Seriously. Don't waste our time with idiotically absurd inanely
    childish defenses of Apple's decision to put crappy batteries in the
    iPhone.

    Show me a screenshot of what you exactly asked and what it exactly
    said. Make sure you asked about mobile devices. Not flashlight
    batteries.

    Because nobody with any knowledge of batteries would claim that the
    initial capacity isn't one of the most important specifications for
    overall life in a mobile device.

    Nobody.

    Specifically, we're not talking about car batteries. We're not talking
    about batteries used in toys. We're talking about mobile device
    batteries.

    What Apple religious zealot nutcases do to defend every Apple decision
    is they come up with the first absurdly inane excuse they can think
    of.

    Why not ask the LLM why Apple puts crappy batteries in the iPhone,
    John?


    Why don't you try to back ANY of what you say on this?
    --
    It's impossible for someone who is at war with themselves to be at
    peace with you.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Tue Oct 20 15:36:22 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    John Bokma wrote:
    In this case, Chris claimed that the initial capacity was a 'brain dead'
    specification, where I doubt you can find a single LLM that will NOT put
    the initial capacity on the list when you ask the question about lifetime.

    Each, so far, has given a warning that it's more or less meaningless to
    look at capacity by itself.

    Duh.

    Seriously. If that's your entire argument, stop wasting our time.

    You're being an Apple religious nutcase when the ONLY argument you have
    (and which you repeat like Alan Baker or Snit does endlessly) is to distort what others said by fabricating that they said something they never said.

    Remember, we've had this discussion about the crappy batteries Apple puts
    in iPhones for something like a decade, so it's only the starting point.

    According to Claude:

    "
    the "Apple batteries die sooner" impression, if you've heard it, isn't
    well supported by current rated cycle-life specs or degradation data iX Apple's newer-model ratings are actually competitive-to-better than many Android counterparts in the same price tier. What is true is that
    Apple's battery health reporting is more visible and standardized, which paradoxically can make iPhone battery decline feel more noticeable/discussed, simply because people can actually see the number dropping.
    "

    So, newer-model ratings are actually competitive-to-better. I don't care that 6 years ago they used less good parts. Ten years ago batteries
    exploded in Samsung devices... And the replacements, too...

    Jesus Christ. Apple loses (almost?) every apples-to-apples benchmark.
    There's a *reason* Apple puts the crappiest batteries then can in iPhones.

    Look this one up. Guess who lost by a mile?

    Newsgroups: misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,uk.telecom.mobile Subject: EU standards compare Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max & Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra battery lifetime
    Date: Thu, 16 Apr 2026 23:30:04 -0600
    Message-ID: <10rsggs$2vhk$1@nnrp.usenet.blueworldhosting.com>

    The EU now requires manufacturers to declare the number of cycles a battery
    can withstand while maintaining $80% capacity. This is the "kill time".

    In a recent thread on the Apple newsgroups, we proved that Apple is known
    to purposefully cheapen out on battery system component hardware, e.g.,

    Newsgroups: misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy
    Subject: Did Ming-Chi Kuo ever report Apple puts cheap components in batteries, or not?
    Date: Sat, 11 Apr 2026 13:04:43 -0700
    Message-ID: <10re9gr$2dlv$1@nnrp.usenet.blueworldhosting.com>

    Ming-Chi Kuo claimed Apple cheaps out for pure profit motives alone.

    But Apple also cheaps out on battery capacity.
    Only one iPhone ever made has met the standards set in 2014 by Android.

    Other than that one iPhone, no iPhone has ever reached even close to 5AH. That's important to note since it's a battle between efficiency & capacity.

    We've been observing crappy iPhone battery capacity since at least 2018.
    But Chris argues, rightfully so, that capacity is only the starting point.

    Overall efficiency matters too.

    In the end, what matters to all is how many YEARS a battery will last.
    The definition to use is how many charge cycles before it drops below 80%.

    So let's run the math.
    We'll use the *best* possible competitive devices we can find today.

    Let's mathematically compare overall life between these two flagships:
    Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max
    Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra

    We will use only EU standards to derive the kill time.
    I don't know the answer yet, as I'm just now replying to Chris.

    Who will win given these competing mathematical claims?
    a. Samsung has presumably higher capacity but lower efficiency
    b. Apple has presumably lower capacity but higher efficiency

    Which will win in overall charge cycle lifetime based on EU standards?
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John Bokma@contact@johnbokma.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Tue Oct 20 21:38:08 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 20/10/2026 21:19, Maria Sophia wrote:
    John Bokma wrote:
    For the Windows newsgroup, I'm testing all the free no-registration LLMs, >>
    The one I used [1] concluded: "Treat fast-charging wattage and mAh as
    poor indicators of battery longevity on their own". That's what
    everybody, except you, have been saying.

    [1] Github's Copilot CLI with gpt-luna-6, see also my other post.

    I never disagree with anyone who makes a logically sensible statement.
    Yet, I'll vehemently disagree with idiotic statements like that one, John.

    Yes, I got that. Yet it's true: relying only on capacity is silly.

    I repeat, I have higher degrees in electrical engineering

    Higher than whom?

    and I would never
    have said that the only specification that matters for long life is a
    single capacity metric, but, I would say it's certainly an important
    metric.

    It's way less important than you make it sound.
    --
    Static tumblelog generator: https://github.com/john-bokma/tumblelog/
    Available as Python or Perl. Example tumblelog: https://plurrrr.com/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,comp.mobile.android on Tue Oct 20 15:42:57 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    John Bokma wrote:
    Got anything concrete, this time?

    I just asked Claude:

    Stop it with your Claude crap, John Bokma.

    We studied this in detail. Look it up.

    Newsgroups: misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,uk.telecom.mobile Subject: Re: EU standards compare Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max & Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra battery lifetime
    Date: Sat, 18 Apr 2026 09:18:37 -0600
    Message-ID: <10s07cd$td$1@nnrp.usenet.blueworldhosting.com>

    If any numbers are wrong, I ask the team to point them out please.

    The Samsung lasts 1-1/2 years *longer* than the "efficient" iPhone
    (proving, yet again, that this bogus "efficiency" proffers no value).

    The discussion regarding the EU Ecodesign Regulation (EU 2023/1670)
    provides the first standardized 'Kill Time' metric we have ever had.

    Note: Kill-time is a term chosen to make the point, much like an LD50
    is for drug companies, that it's a calculated value to a detrimental state.

    I'll ignore the insults and focus on the facts because it's important
    to parse the (admittedly brilliant) marketing propaganda surrounding this bogus amorphous "efficiency" that has never once resulted in actual value.

    To that end of forcing the OEM's hand at actually defining that
    (admittedly brilliant but bogus) "efficiency" claim, we have to all
    thank God for the UK & for the EU forcing OEMs to common benchmarks!

    Even I'm learning more about it every day, where I belatedly realized I
    had misquoted the numbers from the EPREL/EU certified test profile, which
    is a rigid, simulated "day" that every phone must run to get its label.

    It turns out that it's much worse than I had previously calculated in
    that the Galaxy S26 Ultra delivers ~24.5% more total standardized battery
    life to 80% capacity than the iPhone 17 Pro Max.

    That's roughly 542 extra days, or about 1.5 years of calculated use.
    So much for that bogus amorphous (yet admittedly brilliant) "efficiency". .

    Among other things, under these UK/EU European rules, manufacturers must declare the cycles a battery withstands before dropping to 80% health.

    They could have picked any percentage.
    They picked 80%.
    So that's what we will use.

    1. The specifications (EU certified)
    A. Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max
    a. Capacity: 4800 mAh
    b. EU Endurance (Single Charge): 53 hours
    c. EU Cycle Rating (to 80%): 1,000 cycles
    d. Daily Cycles (24h/53h): 0.45283 cycles/day

    B. Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra
    a. Capacity: 4855 mAh
    b. EU Endurance (Single Charge): 55 hours
    c. EU Cycle Rating (to 80%): 1,200 cycles
    d. Daily Cycles (24h/55h): 0.43636 cycles/day

    2. 'Kill Time' = Total Life Cycles / Daily Cycles
    A. Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max:
    1,000 / ~0.453 = 2,208.33 days (approx 6.05 years)
    B. Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra:
    1,200 / ~0.436 = 2,750 days (approx 7.53 years)

    3. Analysis of the data
    A. Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max
    Total Life: 2,208 days (approx 6.05 years)
    Efficiency Calculation: 53 hours = 4.8 Ah = 11.04 hours per Ah
    Efficiency: 11.04 hours per Ah

    B. Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra
    Total Life: 2,750 days (approx 7.53 years)
    Efficiency Calculation: 55 hours = 4.855 Ah = 11.33 hours per Ah
    Efficiency: 11.33 hours per Ah
    Margin: 542 Days (approx 1.49 years)
    Lifespan Advantage: +24.5%

    4. Summary of the facts:
    a. Efficiency:
    Samsung wins. It gets 55 hours out of 4.855Ah,
    while Apple gets 53 hours out of 4.8Ah.
    b. Capacity:
    Samsung wins, though Apple has finally started closing the
    historic battery-capacity gap (but only recently).
    c. Durability:
    Samsung wins. The 1,200 cycle rating on Samsung's 2026 chemistry
    provides the Kill-Time victory despite the claimed iPhone efficiency.

    REFERENCES:
    a. EU Regulation 2023/1670 (Ecodesign requirements)
    <https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2023/1670/oj>
    b. EU Regulation 2023/1669 (Energy Labeling)
    <https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2023/1669/oj>
    c. EPREL (European Product Registry for Energy Labeling)
    <https://eprel.ec.europa.eu/screen/product/smartphonestablets20231669>
    d. Bitkom Compliance (June 2025 Implementation Details)
    <https://bitkom-compliance-solutions.com/en/news/new-eu-requirements-ecodesign-and-energy-labelling-smartphones-and-tablets-june-2025>
    --
    One out of about ten million people know what we know about smartphones. `
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John Bokma@contact@johnbokma.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Tue Oct 20 21:42:55 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 20/10/2026 21:28, Maria Sophia wrote:

    Show me a screenshot of what you exactly asked and what it exactly said.
    Make sure you asked about mobile devices. Not flashlight batteries.

    I copy pasted *exactly* what you used:

    "When mobile device battery overall lifetime (in years) matters most,
    what are the most important specifications FOR THE BATTERY, in order of
    most important to least important, at purchase time of the device?"

    Was the prompt.

    Part of the reply:

    "
    Why "mAh capacity" alone (which most buyers fixate on) ranks lower here:
    raw capacity affects how long a charge lasts per day, but says nothing
    about how many years of daily charging the cell can sustain before
    degrading rCo which is a separate, chemistry/engineering-driven property.
    "
    --
    Static tumblelog generator: https://github.com/john-bokma/tumblelog/
    Available as Python or Perl. Example tumblelog: https://plurrrr.com/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John Bokma@contact@johnbokma.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Tue Oct 20 21:54:35 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 20/10/2026 21:36, Maria Sophia wrote:
    Let's mathematically compare overall life between these two flagships:
    Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max
    Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra
    1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6.
    Apple iPhone 18 Pro Max 19:20h 31:23h 17:13h 26:12h 12:09h 19:20h
    :
    Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max 17:58h 24:26h 15:33h 25:41h 12:08h 17:58h
    :
    :
    :
    :
    Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra 16:23h 37:44h 13:01h 24:48h 9:42h 16:23h

    Columns:
    1. Active use score
    2. Calls
    3. Web
    4. Video
    5. Game
    6. Your score

    Source: <https://www.gsmarena.com/battery-test-v2.php3>
    --
    Static tumblelog generator: https://github.com/john-bokma/tumblelog/
    Available as Python or Perl. Example tumblelog: https://plurrrr.com/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Chris@ithinkiam@gmail.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Tue Oct 20 20:54:02 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Maria Sophia <mariasophia@comprehension.com> wrote:
    John Bokma wrote:
    Q: What are the most important top 3 specifications for any battery?
    A: ?

    1) How safe is it (don't want an exploding battery),
    2) How long it keeps my device up & running during the day,
    3) After how much time do I have to replace it (see 2).

    For the Windows newsgroup, I'm testing all the free no-registration LLMs, where I am scheduled to test easemate today, so this is the first query:
    <https://www.easemate.ai/webapp/chat?from=ai-chat>

    Pops this query into that LLM and tell us what you get as the output?

    Lol. Asking an LLM is the refuge of those who can't support their own arguments.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Alan@nuh-uh@nope.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,comp.mobile.android on Tue Oct 20 13:56:36 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 2026-10-20 12:16, John Bokma wrote:
    On 20/10/2026 21:10, Chris wrote:
    Maria Sophia <mariasophia@comprehension.com> wrote:
    -a total lifetime is what
    I'm always talking about, where Apple's iPhone batteries simply die
    sooner.


    An assertion you've *never* been able to substantiate beyond vague hand
    waving.

    Got anything concrete, this time?

    I just asked Claude:

    "
    Do apple batteries die sooner?
    Searched the web

    Short answer: not really rCo not systematically.
    Shortly, Arlen/Maria will conclude that Claude is an "Apple religious
    zealot".

    :-)
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Alan@nuh-uh@nope.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Tue Oct 20 14:12:07 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 2026-10-20 13:54, Chris wrote:
    Maria Sophia <mariasophia@comprehension.com> wrote:
    John Bokma wrote:
    Q: What are the most important top 3 specifications for any battery?
    A: ?

    1) How safe is it (don't want an exploding battery),
    2) How long it keeps my device up & running during the day,
    3) After how much time do I have to replace it (see 2).

    For the Windows newsgroup, I'm testing all the free no-registration LLMs,
    where I am scheduled to test easemate today, so this is the first query:
    <https://www.easemate.ai/webapp/chat?from=ai-chat>

    Pops this query into that LLM and tell us what you get as the output?

    Lol. Asking an LLM is the refuge of those who can't support their own arguments.


    And to make it extra hilarious, now that others have used AI agents to contradict him...

    ...suddenly they're not to be trusted!

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From CrudeSausage@crude@sausa.ge to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Tue Oct 20 17:33:51 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 2026-10-20 3:10 p.m., John Bokma wrote:
    On 20/10/2026 21:02, Maria Sophia wrote:

    [capacity]> But my point to Chris, who said it was a "brain dead" specification, is
    that it's still the most important starting point for overall life.
    "raw capacity affects how long a charge lasts per day, but says
    *nothing* about how many years of daily charging the cell can sustain
    before degrading rCo which is a separate, chemistry/engineering-driven property."

    According to Claude, emphasis mine.

    I don't need technical data because I have my own experience: the nearly five-year-old iPhone I own lasts me all day, not one Android I've ever
    owned has been able to do the same. Similarly, my MacBook Air can easily
    last a day or two for my kind of work, not one PC I've ever owned has
    been able to do the same, and neither has any Android device or Linux installation. I know that they are now making PCs with battery life that competes with what Macs offer, but if you are going to buy devices with
    a long-lasting battery, why the heck would you want it to run Windows?
    --
    CrudeSausage
    MacBook Air M4 Sky Blue
    iPhone 13
    Friendly Apple zealot
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Tue Oct 20 17:45:44 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    CrudeSausage wrote:
    According to Claude, emphasis mine.

    I don't need technical data because I have my own experience: the nearly five-year-old iPhone I own lasts me all day, not one Android I've ever
    owned has been able to do the same. Similarly, my MacBook Air can easily last a day or two for my kind of work, not one PC I've ever owned has
    been able to do the same, and neither has any Android device or Linux installation. I know that they are now making PCs with battery life that competes with what Macs offer, but if you are going to buy devices with
    a long-lasting battery, why the heck would you want it to run Windows?

    Why is iPhone battery life substantially shorter than the similar Samsung?

    Newsgroups: misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,uk.telecom.mobile
    Subject: EU standards compare Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max & Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra battery lifetime
    Date: Thu, 16 Apr 2026 23:30:04 -0600
    Message-ID: <10rsggs$2vhk$1@nnrp.usenet.blueworldhosting.com>
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Your Name@YourName@YourISP.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,comp.mobile.android on Wed Oct 21 10:47:28 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 2026-10-20 17:13:18 +0000, John Bokma said:
    On 20/10/2026 19:06, Maria Sophia wrote:

    Q: What are the most important top 3 specifications for any battery?
    A: ?

    1) How safe is it (don't want an exploding battery),
    2) How long it keeps my device up & running during the day,
    3) After how much time do I have to replace it (see 2).

    4) How long it takes to recharge it. :-)

    There's no point in having a battery that lasts six weeks, when it
    takes two days to charge back up to 10%.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Tue Oct 20 17:50:02 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    John Bokma wrote:
    I never disagree with anyone who makes a logically sensible statement.
    Yet, I'll vehemently disagree with idiotic statements like that one, John.

    Yes, I got that. Yet it's true: relying only on capacity is silly.

    The fact your ONLY argument is a gross distortion of what was said is why
    you Apple religious zealot nutcases have the reputation that you have.

    You're proving me right that you Apple religious zealot nutcases use the
    first absurd inanely idiotic excuses to defend your Apple God to the death.

    I repeat, I have higher degrees in electrical engineering

    Higher than whom?

    The funny thing is that was actually funny, which is funny because it's
    clear that all you Apple religious zealot nutcases have no education.

    You're proving me correct that you have no education since your only
    response to facts is a cut-and-paste of idiocy you copied out of an LLM.

    and I would never
    have said that the only specification that matters for long life is a
    single capacity metric, but, I would say it's certainly an important
    metric.

    It's way less important than you make it sound.

    You know what's important?
    Facts are important.

    Why don't you explain why all Apple iPhones failed to achieve an A rating
    when the first EU benchmarks came out? We predicted that for over a decade.

    Explain this:

    Newsgroups: misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,uk.telecom.mobile
    Subject: EU standards compare Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max & Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra battery lifetime
    Date: Thu, 16 Apr 2026 23:30:04 -0600
    Message-ID: <10rsggs$2vhk$1@nnrp.usenet.blueworldhosting.com>
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Tue Oct 20 17:52:51 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Chris wrote:
    For the Windows newsgroup, I'm testing all the free no-registration LLMs,
    where I am scheduled to test easemate today, so this is the first query:
    <https://www.easemate.ai/webapp/chat?from=ai-chat>

    Pops this query into that LLM and tell us what you get as the output?

    Lol. Asking an LLM is the refuge of those who can't support their own arguments.

    And yet, I've been proving this claim for a decade, well before LLMs Chris.

    The point of asking you uneducated Apple religious zealot nutcases to pop
    the query into the LLM was you'd see it's *always* in the main criteria.

    Since you're uneducated, you didn't realize that was the point of the LLM.
    It was for you Apple religious nutcase zealots, not for me.

    I know the answer.
    You need to learn it.

    Claiming that the capacity is a "brain-dead" specification was absurd.

    You proved my point that you Apple religious zealot nutcases will use as an excuse to protect Apple the first idiotically absurd thing you think of.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Tue Oct 20 17:55:21 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    John Bokma wrote:
    Source: <https://www.gsmarena.com/battery-test-v2.php3>

    Jesus Christ.

    Did you have to prove to everyone that you nutcases have no education?

    You Apple religious zealot nutcases don't even know the difference between hours and years, which is further proof that you have no education at all.

    Again you prove me correct that the first idiotically inane excuse that
    your uneducated brain can think of, is what you type in response to facts.

    HINT: We're talking years. Not hours.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Alan@nuh-uh@nope.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Tue Oct 20 14:55:57 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 2026-10-20 14:45, Maria Sophia wrote:
    CrudeSausage wrote:
    According to Claude, emphasis mine.

    I don't need technical data because I have my own experience: the nearly
    five-year-old iPhone I own lasts me all day, not one Android I've ever
    owned has been able to do the same. Similarly, my MacBook Air can easily
    last a day or two for my kind of work, not one PC I've ever owned has
    been able to do the same, and neither has any Android device or Linux
    installation. I know that they are now making PCs with battery life that
    competes with what Macs offer, but if you are going to buy devices with
    a long-lasting battery, why the heck would you want it to run Windows?

    Why is iPhone battery life substantially shorter than the similar Samsung?

    Newsgroups: misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,uk.telecom.mobile
    Subject: EU standards compare Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max & Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra battery lifetime
    Date: Thu, 16 Apr 2026 23:30:04 -0600
    Message-ID: <10rsggs$2vhk$1@nnrp.usenet.blueworldhosting.com>

    From GSM Arena:

    'When it comes to battery life, it's easy to answer which one has a
    better endurance, and that's the iPhone 17 Pro Max. Despite having a
    smaller battery, it outperforms the Galaxy S26 Ultra with a higher
    Active Use Score overall.'

    https://www.gsmarena.com/samsung_galaxy_s26_ultra_vs_iphone_17_pro_max_review_battery_camera_price_compared-news-72101.php#battery
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Alan@nuh-uh@nope.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Tue Oct 20 14:56:53 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 2026-10-20 14:50, Maria Sophia wrote:
    John Bokma wrote:
    I never disagree with anyone who makes a logically sensible statement.
    Yet, I'll vehemently disagree with idiotic statements like that one, John. >>
    Yes, I got that. Yet it's true: relying only on capacity is silly.

    The fact your ONLY argument is a gross distortion of what was said is why
    you Apple religious zealot nutcases have the reputation that you have.

    You're proving me right that you Apple religious zealot nutcases use the first absurd inanely idiotic excuses to defend your Apple God to the death.

    I repeat, I have higher degrees in electrical engineering

    Higher than whom?

    The funny thing is that was actually funny, which is funny because it's
    clear that all you Apple religious zealot nutcases have no education.

    You're proving me correct that you have no education since your only
    response to facts is a cut-and-paste of idiocy you copied out of an LLM.

    and I would never
    have said that the only specification that matters for long life is a
    single capacity metric, but, I would say it's certainly an important
    metric.

    It's way less important than you make it sound.

    You know what's important?
    Facts are important.

    Why don't you explain why all Apple iPhones failed to achieve an A rating when the first EU benchmarks came out? We predicted that for over a decade.

    Explain this:

    Newsgroups: misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,uk.telecom.mobile
    Subject: EU standards compare Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max & Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra battery lifetime
    Date: Thu, 16 Apr 2026 23:30:04 -0600
    Message-ID: <10rsggs$2vhk$1@nnrp.usenet.blueworldhosting.com>


    'When it comes to battery life, it's easy to answer which one has a
    better endurance, and that's the iPhone 17 Pro Max. Despite having a
    smaller battery, it outperforms the Galaxy S26 Ultra with a higher
    Active Use Score overall.'

    <https://www.gsmarena.com/samsung_galaxy_s26_ultra_vs_iphone_17_pro_max_review_battery_camera_price_compared-news-72101.php#battery>
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Chris@ithinkiam@gmail.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Tue Oct 20 22:30:51 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Maria Sophia <mariasophia@comprehension.com> wrote:
    Chris wrote:
    For the Windows newsgroup, I'm testing all the free no-registration LLMs, >>> where I am scheduled to test easemate today, so this is the first query: >>> <https://www.easemate.ai/webapp/chat?from=ai-chat>

    Pops this query into that LLM and tell us what you get as the output?

    Lol. Asking an LLM is the refuge of those who can't support their own
    arguments.

    And yet, I've been proving this claim for a decade, well before LLMs Chris.

    A genuine proof only needs doing once. You've spent a decade proving
    nothing. The EU now has the data which evidences why you're wrong.

    Take a Class A 5,000 mAh phone and compare it to a Class C 5,000 mAh model. What do you get?

    Hint: about 15-20% less endurance.

    Comparing best with worst - just within the 5,000 mAh models - is about 50% different.

    Using battery capacity as the main criterion is one dimensional thinking
    aka "brain dead".
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Chris@ithinkiam@gmail.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Tue Oct 20 22:30:52 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Maria Sophia <mariasophia@comprehension.com> wrote:
    I would never
    have said that the only specification that matters for long life is a
    single capacity metric, but, I would say it's certainly an important
    metric.

    Rowing back your original claim, I see. You stated that it was *the most* important metric.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Tue Oct 20 20:56:43 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Chris wrote:
    And yet, I've been proving this claim for a decade, well before LLMs Chris.

    A genuine proof only needs doing once. You've spent a decade proving
    nothing. The EU now has the data which evidences why you're wrong.

    Take a Class A 5,000 mAh phone and compare it to a Class C 5,000 mAh model. What do you get?

    Hint: about 15-20% less endurance.

    Comparing best with worst - just within the 5,000 mAh models - is about 50% different.

    Using battery capacity as the main criterion is one dimensional thinking
    aka "brain dead".

    Hi Chris,

    You saw the results in this thread below, Chris. yet, you say they're wrong.

    Newsgroups: misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,uk.telecom.mobile
    Subject: EU standards compare Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max & Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra battery lifetime
    Date: Thu, 16 Apr 2026 23:30:04 -0600
    Message-ID: <10rsggs$2vhk$1@nnrp.usenet.blueworldhosting.com>

    There is an intelligent reason I refer to you as a religious zealot, Chris.

    Your firmly held belief system is built on Apple's marketing claims & nothing else.

    There is no way to prove anything factual to you religious zealot nutcases.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Tue Oct 20 20:56:58 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Chris wrote:
    I would never
    have said that the only specification that matters for long life is a
    single capacity metric, but, I would say it's certainly an important
    metric.

    Rowing back your original claim, I see. You stated that it was *the most* important metric.

    It's not a "brain-dead" specification, Chris, which is what YOU said.

    It's fine that Apple religious zealots defend all of Apple's decisions.

    But you do it using the first absurd excuse that pops into your head.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Chris@ithinkiam@gmail.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Wed Oct 21 07:09:37 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Maria Sophia <mariasophia@comprehension.com> wrote:
    Chris wrote:
    And yet, I've been proving this claim for a decade, well before LLMs Chris. >>
    A genuine proof only needs doing once. You've spent a decade proving
    nothing. The EU now has the data which evidences why you're wrong.

    Take a Class A 5,000 mAh phone and compare it to a Class C 5,000 mAh model. >> What do you get?

    Hint: about 15-20% less endurance.

    Comparing best with worst - just within the 5,000 mAh models - is about 50% >> different.

    Using battery capacity as the main criterion is one dimensional thinking
    aka "brain dead".

    Hi Chris,

    You saw the results in this thread below, Chris. yet, you say they're wrong.

    Yes. As per usual you're making invalid assumptions.

    Newsgroups: misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,uk.telecom.mobile
    Subject: EU standards compare Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max & Samsung Galaxy
    S26 Ultra battery lifetime
    Date: Thu, 16 Apr 2026 23:30:04 -0600
    Message-ID: <10rsggs$2vhk$1@nnrp.usenet.blueworldhosting.com>

    There is an intelligent reason I refer to you as a religious zealot, Chris.

    Your firmly held belief system is built on Apple's marketing claims & nothing else.

    There is no way to prove anything factual to you religious zealot nutcases.

    Projection. You wouldn't recognise a fact if it shat on your bed.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Chris@ithinkiam@gmail.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Wed Oct 21 07:20:39 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Maria Sophia <mariasophia@comprehension.com> wrote:
    Chris wrote:
    I would never
    have said that the only specification that matters for long life is a
    single capacity metric, but, I would say it's certainly an important
    metric.

    Rowing back your original claim, I see. You stated that it was *the most*
    important metric.

    It's not a "brain-dead" specification, Chris, which is what YOU said.

    Correct. Which I stand 100% behind. It is factually accurate.

    You, on the other hand, have the conviction of a dead fish.

    It's fine that Apple religious zealots defend all of Apple's decisions.

    The only zealot here is you. You're just too old and blinkered to see it.

    But you do it using the first absurd excuse that pops into your head.

    Remind me. Who has regulatory data covering over 1000 mobile phone models
    on their side? Hint: it's not you.




    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Chris@ithinkiam@gmail.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,comp.mobile.android on Wed Oct 21 07:20:41 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Alan <nuh-uh@nope.com> wrote:
    On 2026-10-20 12:16, John Bokma wrote:
    On 20/10/2026 21:10, Chris wrote:
    Maria Sophia <mariasophia@comprehension.com> wrote:
    -a total lifetime is what
    I'm always talking about, where Apple's iPhone batteries simply die
    sooner.


    An assertion you've *never* been able to substantiate beyond vague hand
    waving.

    Got anything concrete, this time?

    I just asked Claude:

    "
    Do apple batteries die sooner?
    Searched the web

    Short answer: not really rCo not systematically.
    Shortly, Arlen/Maria will conclude that Claude is an "Apple religious zealot".


    ROFL

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Chris@ithinkiam@gmail.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Wed Oct 21 07:29:20 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Maria Sophia <mariasophia@comprehension.com> wrote:
    CrudeSausage wrote:
    According to Claude, emphasis mine.

    I don't need technical data because I have my own experience: the nearly
    five-year-old iPhone I own lasts me all day, not one Android I've ever
    owned has been able to do the same. Similarly, my MacBook Air can easily
    last a day or two for my kind of work, not one PC I've ever owned has
    been able to do the same, and neither has any Android device or Linux
    installation. I know that they are now making PCs with battery life that
    competes with what Macs offer, but if you are going to buy devices with
    a long-lasting battery, why the heck would you want it to run Windows?

    Why is iPhone battery life substantially shorter than the similar Samsung?

    It isn't.

    Newsgroups: misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,uk.telecom.mobile
    Subject: EU standards compare Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max & Samsung Galaxy
    S26 Ultra battery lifetime
    Date: Thu, 16 Apr 2026 23:30:04 -0600
    Message-ID: <10rsggs$2vhk$1@nnrp.usenet.blueworldhosting.com>

    Because you're massively over-interpreting the data. The cycle count is a manufacturer-provided *minimum* to meet the EU requirement. To be in spec
    in needs to be at least 1000 cycles. That it. No-one checks whether it's
    real or not. They could, but it would likely take months of continuous
    testing and would be challenged as being unrealistic.

    You're using this number as some kind of quantifiable variable. It isn't.
    It's just marketing. Samsung have made their number bigger than Apple for
    the lolz. They got caught using an unbelievably high number last year and
    so reduced it significantly it this year.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Wed Oct 21 12:33:32 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Chris wrote:
    Why is iPhone battery life substantially shorter than the similar Samsung?

    It isn't.
    Newsgroups: misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,uk.telecom.mobile
    Subject: EU standards compare Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max & Samsung Galaxy
    S26 Ultra battery lifetime
    Date: Thu, 16 Apr 2026 23:30:04 -0600
    Message-ID: <10rsggs$2vhk$1@nnrp.usenet.blueworldhosting.com>

    Because you're massively over-interpreting the data. The cycle count is a manufacturer-provided *minimum* to meet the EU requirement. To be in spec
    in needs to be at least 1000 cycles. That it. No-one checks whether it's
    real or not. They could, but it would likely take months of continuous testing and would be challenged as being unrealistic.

    You're using this number as some kind of quantifiable variable. It isn't. It's just marketing. Samsung have made their number bigger than Apple for
    the lolz. They got caught using an unbelievably high number last year and
    so reduced it significantly it this year.

    You can't just say all math that doesn't make Apple look good is wrong.

    And, it's hilarious that you, of all people, claim "It's just marketing".

    The chemistry is *different* so cycle count differences are plausible.

    Here's the relevant post for others to read, given it's from April.

    Newsgroups: misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,uk.telecom.mobile Subject: Re: EU standards compare Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max & Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra battery lifetime
    Date: Sat, 18 Apr 2026 09:18:37 -0600
    Message-ID: <10s07cd$td$1@nnrp.usenet.blueworldhosting.com>

    Chris wrote:
    Maria Sophia <mariasophia@comprehension.com> wrote:
    Chris wrote:
    Maybe, for once, you'll engage with empirical data.

    Thank God

    Sadly it seems not. Time to put you back in your box.

    If any numbers are wrong, I ask the team to point them out please.

    The Samsung lasts 1-1/2 years *longer* than the "efficient" iPhone
    (proving, yet again, that this bogus "efficiency" proffers no value).

    The discussion regarding the EU Ecodesign Regulation (EU 2023/1670)
    provides the first standardized 'Kill Time' metric we have ever had.

    Note: Kill-time is a term chosen to make the point, much like an LD50
    is for drug companies, that it's a calculated value to a detrimental state.

    I'll ignore the insults and focus on the facts because it's important
    to parse the (admittedly brilliant) marketing propaganda surrounding this bogus amorphous "efficiency" that has never once resulted in actual value.

    To that end of forcing the OEM's hand at actually defining that
    (admittedly brilliant but bogus) "efficiency" claim, we have to all
    thank God for the UK & for the EU forcing OEMs to common benchmarks!

    Even I'm learning more about it every day, where I belatedly realized I
    had misquoted the numbers from the EPREL/EU certified test profile, which
    is a rigid, simulated "day" that every phone must run to get its label.

    It turns out that it's much worse than I had previously calculated in
    that the Galaxy S26 Ultra delivers ~24.5% more total standardized battery
    life to 80% capacity than the iPhone 17 Pro Max.

    That's roughly 542 extra days, or about 1.5 years of calculated use.
    So much for that bogus amorphous (yet admittedly brilliant) "efficiency". .

    Among other things, under these UK/EU European rules, manufacturers must declare the cycles a battery withstands before dropping to 80% health.

    They could have picked any percentage.
    They picked 80%.
    So that's what we will use.

    1. The specifications (EU certified)
    A. Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max
    a. Capacity: 4800 mAh
    b. EU Endurance (Single Charge): 53 hours
    c. EU Cycle Rating (to 80%): 1,000 cycles
    d. Daily Cycles (24h/53h): 0.45283 cycles/day

    B. Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra
    a. Capacity: 4855 mAh
    b. EU Endurance (Single Charge): 55 hours
    c. EU Cycle Rating (to 80%): 1,200 cycles
    d. Daily Cycles (24h/55h): 0.43636 cycles/day

    2. 'Kill Time' = Total Life Cycles / Daily Cycles
    A. Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max:
    1,000 / ~0.453 = 2,208.33 days (approx 6.05 years)
    B. Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra:
    1,200 / ~0.436 = 2,750 days (approx 7.53 years)

    3. Analysis of the data
    A. Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max
    Total Life: 2,208 days (approx 6.05 years)
    Efficiency Calculation: 53 hours = 4.8 Ah = 11.04 hours per Ah
    Efficiency: 11.04 hours per Ah

    B. Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra
    Total Life: 2,750 days (approx 7.53 years)
    Efficiency Calculation: 55 hours = 4.855 Ah = 11.33 hours per Ah
    Efficiency: 11.33 hours per Ah
    Margin: 542 Days (approx 1.49 years)
    Lifespan Advantage: +24.5%

    4. Summary of the facts:
    a. Efficiency:
    Samsung wins. It gets 55 hours out of 4.855Ah,
    while Apple gets 53 hours out of 4.8Ah.
    b. Capacity:
    Samsung wins, though Apple has finally started closing the
    historic battery-capacity gap (but only recently).
    c. Durability:
    Samsung wins. The 1,200 cycle rating on Samsung's 2026 chemistry
    provides the Kill-Time victory despite the claimed iPhone efficiency.

    REFERENCES:
    a. EU Regulation 2023/1670 (Ecodesign requirements)
    <https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2023/1670/oj>
    b. EU Regulation 2023/1669 (Energy Labeling)
    <https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2023/1669/oj>
    c. EPREL (European Product Registry for Energy Labeling)
    <https://eprel.ec.europa.eu/screen/product/smartphonestablets20231669>
    d. Bitkom Compliance (June 2025 Implementation Details)
    <https://bitkom-compliance-solutions.com/en/news/new-eu-requirements-ecodesign-and-energy-labelling-smartphones-and-tablets-june-2025>
    --
    One out of about ten million people know what we know about smartphones. `
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Wed Oct 21 12:44:08 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Chris wrote:
    It's not a "brain-dead" specification, Chris, which is what YOU said.

    Correct. Which I stand 100% behind. It is factually accurate.

    You, on the other hand, have the conviction of a dead fish.

    WTF? What are you babbling about? Seriously. What are you saying, Chris?

    We're talking overall lifetime of a smartphone battery, which happens to be charged frequently (often daily for an iPhone, less so for larger-capacity Androids) and whose overall lifetime happens to be judged by how many full-charge cycles it will take under normal use for the battery capacity
    to drop to 80% of the original battery capacity.

    Given that's the EU-established specification, for you to call it "brain
    dead", is akin to Apple spewing 44 pages of excuses why no iPhone ever made achieved even close to an A rating on efficiency when the EU benchmarks
    came out.

    I get it that you hate Apple's decision to put crappy batteries in the
    iPhone causes you to have to defend that decision, to the death, Chris.

    But don't defend everything Applke does using the first absurd excuse that
    you can think of, because that's a hallmark of the Apple religious zealot.

    It's fine that Apple religious zealots defend all of Apple's decisions.

    The only zealot here is you. You're just too old and blinkered to see it.

    Yet, you call the spec everyone uses, "brain dead" simply because it's the first excuse you can think of to defend why Apple uses crappy batteries.

    But you do it using the first absurd excuse that pops into your head.

    Remind me. Who has regulatory data covering over 1000 mobile phone models
    on their side? Hint: it's not you.

    We're talking about battery capacity, Chris, which you claimed is a "brain dead" specification, when you only did so to defend Apple to the death, no matter what, using the first inanely absurd excuse you could think of.

    That's the classic hallmark of Apple religious zealots, Chris.
    You prove me right every time.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John Bokma@contact@johnbokma.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Wed Oct 21 18:47:37 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 21/10/2026 18:33, Maria Sophia wrote:

    [..]

    Note: Kill-time is a term chosen to make the point, much like an LD50
    is for drug companies, that it's a calculated value to a detrimental state.

    It's a dumb, pointless value...

    [..]> 1. The specifications (EU certified)
    A. Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max
    a. Capacity: 4800 mAh
    b. EU Endurance (Single Charge): 53 hours
    c. EU Cycle Rating (to 80%): 1,000 cycles
    d. Daily Cycles (24h/53h): 0.45283 cycles/day

    B. Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra
    a. Capacity: 4855 mAh
    b. EU Endurance (Single Charge): 55 hours
    c. EU Cycle Rating (to 80%): 1,200 cycles
    d. Daily Cycles (24h/55h): 0.43636 cycles/day

    2. 'Kill Time' = Total Life Cycles / Daily Cycles

    ... because it ASSumes that a battery can be fully charged, and then
    depleted to 0% repeatedly over 7.5 years.

    Again, you show you have no clue.

    [snip]
    --
    Static tumblelog generator: https://github.com/john-bokma/tumblelog/
    Available as Python or Perl. Example tumblelog: https://plurrrr.com/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John Bokma@contact@johnbokma.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Wed Oct 21 18:55:43 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 21/10/2026 18:33, Maria Sophia wrote:

    2. 'Kill Time' = Total Life Cycles / Daily Cycles

    "
    Here's what's wrong with the "Kill Time = Total Life Cycles / Daily
    Cycles" calculation when it comes to real-world battery usage:

    1. It ignores calendar aging entirely
    Batteries degrade even when not being used rCo the chemistry inside the electrolyte and electrodes breaks down over time regardless of cycle
    count. As we discussed earlier: a 1-year-old battery with 150 cycles
    will almost always outperform a 5-year-old battery with the same 150
    cycles. Your formula (1,200 cycles |+ 0.436/day ree 7.5 years) implicitly assumes only cycles matter rCo but by 7.5 years, the battery will have
    aged chemically regardless of whether it ever actually reaches 1,200 cycles.

    2. "Daily cycles" derived from the EU endurance test is an unrealistic
    proxy for real usage
    The 55-hour figure comes from a standardized lab test (continuous use
    until full depletion in one go). Nobody uses a phone for 55 hours
    straight and then charges once. Most people charge daily, often
    overnight, with a partial discharge (say, 60% down to 100%, not 0% to
    100%). That shifts real-world cycle accumulation in two opposing ways
    the formula doesn't capture:

    More frequent partial charges can be less stressful per cycle than one
    deep full discharge (partial cycles count only partially toward a "full" cycle).
    But sitting at 100% overnight more often increases degradation from high state-of-charge exposure rCo something the formula doesn't account for at all.

    3. 80% capacity isn't "death" rCo it's an arbitrary industry threshold
    "Kill time" implies the battery stops functioning at that point. It
    doesn't rCo the phone keeps working fine well past 80%, often for years,
    just with noticeably shorter battery life per day. There's no hard
    "death" cliff at cycle 1,200; degradation is continuous, not a sudden drop-off.

    4. Degradation isn't linear
    The cycle rating (1,200 to 80%) reflects an average under controlled
    test conditions (fixed temperature, fixed charging protocol). In
    practice, degradation often accelerates past a certain point rCo
    especially from heat and fast charging rCo rather than proceeding evenly
    the way the formula implies.

    5. Usage patterns vary significantly over a device's lifetime
    A new device often gets heavier use (novelty effect), seasons change
    heat exposure, and software updates shift power draw rCo so "daily cycles" isn't the constant the formula treats it as.

    Bottom line: the formula treats battery wear as a simple, linear, time-independent cycle problem, when in reality it's a combination of
    cycle wear and calendar aging and temperature/charging behavior rCo three factors that compound each other, not cleanly divide into one tidy number.
    "

    Back to school with you!
    --
    Static tumblelog generator: https://github.com/john-bokma/tumblelog/
    Available as Python or Perl. Example tumblelog: https://plurrrr.com/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Wed Oct 21 13:04:29 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Chris wrote:
    There is no way to prove anything factual to you religious zealot nutcases.

    Projection. You wouldn't recognise a fact if it shat on your bed.

    These are facts using similar phones which we chose blind in April, before
    we ran the calculations based only EU specifications, which we agreed on.

    iPhone 17 Pro Max hrs of runtime per charge cycle = 18.87 hours
    Samsung S26 Ultra hrs of runtime per charge cycle = 21.82 hours
    *Winner = Samsung (+15.6%)*

    iPhone 17 Pro Max endurance per charge = 53 hours
    Samsung S26 Ultra endurance per charge = 55 hours
    *Winner = Samsung (+3.8%)*

    iPhone 17 Pro Max efficiency (hrs/Ah) = 11.04
    Samsung S26 Ultra efficiency (hrs/Ah) = 11.33
    *Winner = Samsung (+2.6%)*

    iPhone 17 Pro Max calendar life (calculated) = ~6.05 years
    Samsung S26 Ultra calendar life (calculated) = ~7.53 years
    *Winner = Samsung (24.5%)*

    Why do you think, given Apple's brilliant marketing spews efficiency 12
    times in every 9-page iPhone datasheet, that this iPhone sucks compared to
    this comparable Samsung?

    Where exactly did Apple cheap out?
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John Bokma@contact@johnbokma.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Wed Oct 21 19:12:35 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 21/10/2026 19:04, Maria Sophia wrote:

    iPhone 17 Pro Max hrs of runtime per charge cycle = 18.87 hours
    Samsung S26 Ultra hrs of runtime per charge cycle = 21.82 hours
    *Winner = Samsung (+15.6%)*

    However, in the real world and not the back of a napkin:

    Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max 17:58h 24:26h 15:33h 25:41h 12:08h 17:58h
    Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra 16:23h 37:44h 13:01h 24:48h 9:42h 16:23h

    For shit and giggles, let's add the more recent model as well:

    Apple iPhone 18 Pro Max 19:20h 31:23h 17:13h 26:12h 12:09h 19:20h
    --
    Static tumblelog generator: https://github.com/john-bokma/tumblelog/
    Available as Python or Perl. Example tumblelog: https://plurrrr.com/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Wed Oct 21 13:33:00 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    John Bokma wrote:
    Back to school with you!

    1. The specifications (EU certified)
    A. Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max
    a. Capacity: 4800 mAh
    b. EU Endurance (Single Charge): 53 hours
    c. EU Cycle Rating (to 80%): 1,000 cycles
    d. Daily Cycles (24h/53h): 0.45283 cycles/day

    B. Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra
    a. Capacity: 4855 mAh
    b. EU Endurance (Single Charge): 55 hours
    c. EU Cycle Rating (to 80%): 1,200 cycles
    d. Daily Cycles (24h/55h): 0.43636 cycles/day

    2. 'Kill Time' = Total Life Cycles / Daily Cycles
    A. Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max:
    1,000 / ~0.453 = 2,208.33 days (approx 6.05 years)
    B. Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra:
    1,200 / ~0.436 = 2,750 days (approx 7.53 years)

    3. Analysis of the data
    A. Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max
    Total Life: 2,208 days (approx 6.05 years)
    Efficiency Calculation: 53 hours / 4.8 Ah = 11.04 hours per Ah
    Efficiency: 11.04 hours per Ah

    B. Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra
    Total Life: 2,750 days (approx 7.53 years)
    Efficiency Calculation: 55 hours / 4.855 Ah = 11.33 hours per Ah
    Efficiency: 11.33 hours per Ah
    Margin: 542 Days (approx 1.49 years)
    Lifespan Advantage: +24.5%

    4. Summary of the facts:
    a. Efficiency:
    Samsung wins. It gets 55 hours out of 4.855Ah,
    while Apple gets 53 hours out of 4.8Ah.
    b. Capacity:
    Samsung wins, though Apple has finally started closing the
    historic battery-capacity gap (but only recently).
    c. Durability:
    Samsung wins. The 1,200 cycle rating on Samsung's 2026 chemistry
    provides the Kill-Time victory despite the claimed iPhone efficiency.

    REFERENCES:
    a. EU Regulation 2023/1670 (Ecodesign requirements)
    <https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2023/1670/oj>
    b. EU Regulation 2023/1669 (Energy Labeling)
    <https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2023/1669/oj>
    c. EPREL (European Product Registry for Energy Labeling)
    <https://eprel.ec.europa.eu/screen/product/smartphonestablets20231669>
    d. Bitkom Compliance (June 2025 Implementation Details)
    <https://bitkom-compliance-solutions.com/en/news/new-eu-requirements-ecodesign-and-energy-labelling-smartphones-and-tablets-june-2025>
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Wed Oct 21 13:35:13 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    John Bokma wrote:
    Again, you show you have no clue.

    These are facts using similar phones which we chose blind in April, before
    we ran the calculations based only EU specifications, which we agreed on.

    iPhone 17 Pro Max hrs of runtime per charge cycle = 18.87 hours
    Samsung S26 Ultra hrs of runtime per charge cycle = 21.82 hours
    *Winner = Samsung (+15.6%)*

    iPhone 17 Pro Max endurance per charge = 53 hours
    Samsung S26 Ultra endurance per charge = 55 hours
    *Winner = Samsung (+3.8%)*

    iPhone 17 Pro Max efficiency (hrs/Ah) = 11.04
    Samsung S26 Ultra efficiency (hrs/Ah) = 11.33
    *Winner = Samsung (+2.6%)*

    iPhone 17 Pro Max calendar life (calculated) = ~6.05 years
    Samsung S26 Ultra calendar life (calculated) = ~7.53 years
    *Winner = Samsung (24.5%)*

    Why do you think, given Apple's brilliant marketing spews efficiency 12
    times in every 9-page iPhone datasheet, that this iPhone sucks compared to
    this comparable Samsung?

    Anyone care to run the same task but against the folding flagships?
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John Bokma@contact@johnbokma.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Wed Oct 21 19:38:27 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 21/10/2026 19:33, Maria Sophia wrote:
    John Bokma wrote:
    Back to school with you!

    [ Same flawed calculations ]

    I really do wonder about your education. You remind me of a class mate
    who had high grades in the theoretical area but managed to connect a transformer the wrong way around, blowing up a circuit board.

    Another class mate fell sorry for him, and borrowed his circuit board.
    And he managed to connect it the wrong way around once more.

    Later, I heard that he had several mishaps during his internship.

    We joked that he would become a manager. Maybe he even did.

    Well, you actually don't remind me of him; he was good at theory. You
    seem to suck at both theory and the real world.
    --
    Static tumblelog generator: https://github.com/john-bokma/tumblelog/
    Available as Python or Perl. Example tumblelog: https://plurrrr.com/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John Bokma@contact@johnbokma.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Wed Oct 21 19:43:26 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 21/10/2026 19:35, Maria Sophia wrote:
    [..]
    Anyone care to run the same task but against the folding flagships?

    "Bottom line: the formula treats battery wear as a simple, linear, time-independent cycle problem, when in reality it's a combination of
    cycle wear *and* calendar aging *and* temperature/charging behavior rCo
    three factors that compound each other, not cleanly divide into one tidy number."
    --
    Static tumblelog generator: https://github.com/john-bokma/tumblelog/
    Available as Python or Perl. Example tumblelog: https://plurrrr.com/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Wed Oct 21 13:58:45 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    John Bokma wrote:
    iPhone 17 Pro Max hrs of runtime per charge cycle = 18.87 hours
    Samsung S26 Ultra hrs of runtime per charge cycle = 21.82 hours
    *Winner = Samsung (+15.6%)*

    However, in the real world and not the back of a napkin:

    Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max 17:58h 24:26h 15:33h 25:41h 12:08h 17:58h Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra 16:23h 37:44h 13:01h 24:48h 9:42h 16:23h

    For shit and giggles, let's add the more recent model as well:

    Apple iPhone 18 Pro Max 19:20h 31:23h 17:13h 26:12h 12:09h 19:20h

    For some strange reason, even after discussing this topic on the Apple and Android newsgroups for about a decade, some people just can't get into
    their heads that battery lifetime is measured in years, not in hours.

    Sigh... they prove me right every time...

    Apple religious zealot nutcases defend Apple to the death, no matter what, using the first inane excuse that they can possibly think of, even when
    their argument is the wrong metric (i.e., hours versus years).

    What's no longer astounding, you can explain that an hour isn't the same as
    a year for a decade, and still, the Apple religious zealots don't get it.

    Reminds me of when Snit claimed a megabit was the same as a decibel, simply because he saw a moving graph, so, to Apple zealots, that's the same thing!

    *Snit video purportedly proving that a decibel is a megabitperseconde!*
    <https://youtu.be/7QaABa6DFIo>
    *It's a fact iOS devices can't even graph Wi-Fi signal strength over time*
    <https://groups.google.com/g/misc.phone.mobile.iphone/c/PZuec56EWB0>

    <https://groups.google.com/forum/#!topic/misc.phone.mobile.iphone/PZuec56EWB0> --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Chris@ithinkiam@gmail.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Wed Oct 21 19:06:38 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Maria Sophia <mariasophia@comprehension.com> wrote:
    Chris wrote:
    It's not a "brain-dead" specification, Chris, which is what YOU said.

    Correct. Which I stand 100% behind. It is factually accurate.

    You, on the other hand, have the conviction of a dead fish.

    WTF? What are you babbling about? Seriously. What are you saying, Chris?

    We're talking overall lifetime of a smartphone battery,

    Nope. This subthread is talking about how battery capacity is (not) the
    most important aspect when buying a phone.

    That's brain dead and the facts support that.

    You want to change the subject, because you lost the argument. Again.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Brock McNuggets@brock.mcnuggets@gmail.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Wed Oct 21 12:26:01 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On Oct 21, 2026 at 10:58 AM, Maria Sophia wrote in 11baugk$22l6$1@nnrp.usenet.blueworldhosting.com:
    John Bokma wrote:
    iPhone 17 Pro Max hrs of runtime per charge cycle = 18.87 hours
    Samsung S26 Ultra hrs of runtime per charge cycle = 21.82 hours
    *Winner = Samsung (+15.6%)*

    However, in the real world and not the back of a napkin:

    Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max 17:58h 24:26h 15:33h 25:41h 12:08h 17:58h
    Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra 16:23h 37:44h 13:01h 24:48h 9:42h 16:23h

    For shit and giggles, let's add the more recent model as well:

    Apple iPhone 18 Pro Max 19:20h 31:23h 17:13h 26:12h 12:09h 19:20h

    For some strange reason, even after discussing this topic on the Apple
    and Android newsgroups for about a decade, some people just can't get
    into their heads that battery lifetime is measured in years, not in
    hours.

    Both matter.

    I want my phone to go all day, and not have to replace the battery
    often.

    Simple.


    Sigh... they prove me right every time...

    Apple religious zealot nutcases defend Apple to the death, no matter
    what, using the first inane excuse that they can possibly think of,
    even when their argument is the wrong metric (i.e., hours versus
    years).

    What's no longer astounding, you can explain that an hour isn't the
    same as a year for a decade, and still, the Apple religious zealots
    don't get it.

    Reminds me of when Snit claimed a megabit was the same as a decibel,
    simply because he saw a moving graph, so, to Apple zealots, that's the
    same thing!

    Yet you cannot quote me saying such a thing.

    *Snit video purportedly proving that a decibel is a
    megabitperseconde!* <https://youtu.be/7QaABa6DFIo>
    *It's a fact iOS devices can't even graph Wi-Fi signal strength over
    time*
    <https://groups.google.com/g/misc.phone.mobile.iphone/c/PZuec56EWB0>

    <https://groups.google.com/forum/#!topic/misc.phone.mobile.iphone/PZuec56EWB0>

    Look at the video. It says no such thing. You simply fail to understand
    what you see and hear and read.
    --
    It's impossible for someone who is at war with themselves to be at
    peace with you.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Alan@nuh-uh@nope.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Wed Oct 21 12:30:17 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 2026-10-21 09:33, Maria Sophia wrote:
    Chris wrote:
    Why is iPhone battery life substantially shorter than the similar Samsung? >>
    It isn't.
    Newsgroups: misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,uk.telecom.mobile
    Subject: EU standards compare Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max & Samsung Galaxy >>> S26 Ultra battery lifetime
    Date: Thu, 16 Apr 2026 23:30:04 -0600
    Message-ID: <10rsggs$2vhk$1@nnrp.usenet.blueworldhosting.com>

    Because you're massively over-interpreting the data. The cycle count is a
    manufacturer-provided *minimum* to meet the EU requirement. To be in spec
    in needs to be at least 1000 cycles. That it. No-one checks whether it's
    real or not. They could, but it would likely take months of continuous
    testing and would be challenged as being unrealistic.

    You're using this number as some kind of quantifiable variable. It isn't.
    It's just marketing. Samsung have made their number bigger than Apple for
    the lolz. They got caught using an unbelievably high number last year and
    so reduced it significantly it this year.

    You can't just say all math that doesn't make Apple look good is wrong.

    And, it's hilarious that you, of all people, claim "It's just marketing".

    The chemistry is *different* so cycle count differences are plausible.
    Did you just recently admit that there was no difference in chemistry,
    Arlen?

    That the only way in which iPhone batteries were supposedly "crappy" was
    their capacity?
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Alan@nuh-uh@nope.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,comp.mobile.android on Wed Oct 21 12:48:04 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 2026-10-21 00:20, Chris wrote:
    Alan <nuh-uh@nope.com> wrote:
    On 2026-10-20 12:16, John Bokma wrote:
    On 20/10/2026 21:10, Chris wrote:
    Maria Sophia <mariasophia@comprehension.com> wrote:
    -a total lifetime is what
    I'm always talking about, where Apple's iPhone batteries simply die
    sooner.


    An assertion you've *never* been able to substantiate beyond vague hand >>>> waving.

    Got anything concrete, this time?

    I just asked Claude:

    "
    Do apple batteries die sooner?
    Searched the web

    Short answer: not really rCo not systematically.
    Shortly, Arlen/Maria will conclude that Claude is an "Apple religious
    zealot".


    ROFL


    Thank you, thank you!

    I'm here all week!

    EfyL
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John Bokma@contact@johnbokma.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Wed Oct 21 21:56:17 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 21/10/2026 19:58, Maria Sophia wrote:

    For some strange reason, even after discussing this topic on the Apple and Android newsgroups for about a decade,

    You still don't have a clue... That's not a strange reason, that's just
    plain ignorance on your side.
    --
    Static tumblelog generator: https://github.com/john-bokma/tumblelog/
    Available as Python or Perl. Example tumblelog: https://plurrrr.com/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Wed Oct 21 17:06:07 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Chris wrote:
    This subthread is talking about how battery capacity is (not) the
    most important aspect when buying a phone.

    That's brain dead and the facts support that.

    You want to change the subject, because you lost the argument. Again.

    Every post from you proves me right, Chris.

    You religious zealots come up with the first absurd excuse that pops into
    your head to defend every Apple decision to the death, as you did here.

    Previously the absurd excuse that popped into your head was to claim that
    the initial capacity was a "brain dead" specification, which is just nuts.

    And now, the latest absurd excuse that popped into your head is you
    fabricated that someone (certainly not me) said that battery capacity is
    the "most important aspect when buying a phone".

    WTF, Chris.
    Must you always prove me right about you Apple religious zealot nutcases?


    Note: The reason I know you have no education is your argument is absurd.
    You first denied a critical specification, and then you fabricated a
    statement that NOBODY said, just so that you could attack the fabrication.

    You Apple nutcases prove me right every time.
    Nobody (but Joerg Lorenz or s|b or Vanguard) on the Android ng does that.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Wed Oct 21 17:10:48 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    John Bokma wrote:
    For some strange reason, even after discussing this topic on the Apple and >> Android newsgroups for about a decade,

    You still don't have a clue... That's not a strange reason, that's just plain ignorance on your side.

    Only you Apple nutcases can't comprehend an hour isn't the same as a year.

    And you only make that absurd mistake when defending Apple to the death.

    Using the first absurdly inane excuse that pops into your head.

    You prove me right about you with every post.

    Sigh...
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Chris@ithinkiam@gmail.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Wed Oct 21 21:21:24 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Maria Sophia <mariasophia@comprehension.com> wrote:
    Chris wrote:
    There is no way to prove anything factual to you religious zealot nutcases. >>
    Projection. You wouldn't recognise a fact if it shat on your bed.

    These are facts using similar phones which we chose blind in April, before
    we ran the calculations based only EU specifications, which we agreed on.

    Problem is this data is out of date. The 17 Pro Max is no longer for sale. Let's compare with the 18 Pro Max

    iPhone 17 Pro Max hrs of runtime per charge cycle = 18.87 hours
    Samsung S26 Ultra hrs of runtime per charge cycle = 21.82 hours
    *Winner = Samsung (+15.6%)*

    No idea how you got these numbers. That's not EU data.

    iPhone 18 Pro Max endurance per charge = 62 hours
    Samsung S26 Ultra endurance per charge = 55 hours
    *Winner = Apple (+12.7%)*

    iPhone 18 Pro Max efficiency (hrs/Ah) = 11.50
    Samsung S26 Ultra efficiency (hrs/Ah) = 11.33
    *Winner = Apple (+1.5%)*

    iPhone 18 Pro Max calendar life (calculated) = ~7.08 years
    Samsung S26 Ultra calendar life (calculated) = ~7.53 years
    *Winner (of an unreliable metric) = Samsung (6.3%)*


    The 18 Pro Max is clearly the best Flagship model when it comes to battery
    life and efficiency. The Pixel is pretty bad.
    https://imgpile.com/p/F4eCpUZ

    It's possibly the Samsung S27 might leapfrog to the top, or maybe not.



    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Chris@ithinkiam@gmail.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Wed Oct 21 21:36:08 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Maria Sophia <mariasophia@comprehension.com> wrote:
    Chris wrote:
    Why is iPhone battery life substantially shorter than the similar Samsung? >>
    It isn't.
    Newsgroups: misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,uk.telecom.mobile
    Subject: EU standards compare Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max & Samsung Galaxy
    S26 Ultra battery lifetime
    Date: Thu, 16 Apr 2026 23:30:04 -0600
    Message-ID: <10rsggs$2vhk$1@nnrp.usenet.blueworldhosting.com>

    Because you're massively over-interpreting the data. The cycle count is a
    manufacturer-provided *minimum* to meet the EU requirement. To be in spec
    in needs to be at least 1000 cycles. That it. No-one checks whether it's
    real or not. They could, but it would likely take months of continuous
    testing and would be challenged as being unrealistic.

    You're using this number as some kind of quantifiable variable. It isn't.
    It's just marketing. Samsung have made their number bigger than Apple for
    the lolz. They got caught using an unbelievably high number last year and
    so reduced it significantly it this year.

    You can't just say all math that doesn't make Apple look good is wrong.

    I'm not saying that.

    And, it's hilarious that you, of all people, claim "It's just marketing".

    You should appreciate it, then.

    The chemistry is *different* so cycle count differences are plausible.

    You're assuming the chemistry is different. Do you have any evidence that
    isn't a tautology.


    If any numbers are wrong, I ask the team to point them out please.

    I have done many, many times. Yet you still claim that day is night.

    The Samsung lasts 1-1/2 years *longer* than the "efficient" iPhone
    (proving, yet again, that this bogus "efficiency" proffers no value).

    The discussion regarding the EU Ecodesign Regulation (EU 2023/1670)
    provides the first standardized 'Kill Time' metric we have ever had.

    Note: Kill-time is a term chosen to make the point, much like an LD50
    is for drug companies, that it's a calculated value to a detrimental state.

    No drug company would use LD50. A toxicology or research lab might. What
    you're thinking about is EC50 which requires experimentally validated data.
    The claimed battery cycle count is not validated data so can't be used in
    your tortured argument.

    I'll ignore the insults and focus on the facts because it's important
    to parse the (admittedly brilliant) marketing propaganda surrounding this bogus amorphous "efficiency" that has never once resulted in actual value.

    Yet you've calculated efficiency values yourself and very happy to quote
    the EU's efficiency classes. You can't argue it both ways.

    It can't be bogus and something you've calculated yourself. So which is it?

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Wed Oct 21 17:50:41 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Chris wrote:
    These are facts using similar phones which we chose blind in April, before >> we ran the calculations based only EU specifications, which we agreed on.

    Problem is this data is out of date. The 17 Pro Max is no longer for sale. Let's compare with the 18 Pro Max

    Do it.
    I'd love to see the results. I'm sure all of us would love to see them.

    As before with the iPhone 17 Pro Max, I have no idea how it will turn out.

    I suspect the iPhone will suck, but Apple got a bruising with the first EU benchmarks proving the crappy batteries, so maybe Apple fixed that problem?

    I don't know if Apple learned anything from being shown to be liars all
    these years about their supposed "efficiency", so maybe they fixed it?

    Dunno.
    Like any normal person, I WELCOME you calculating & reporting the result.
    To help you, I provided a working template on the bottom of this article.


    iPhone 17 Pro Max hrs of runtime per charge cycle = 18.87 hours
    Samsung S26 Ultra hrs of runtime per charge cycle = 21.82 hours
    *Winner = Samsung (+15.6%)*

    No idea how you got these numbers. That's not EU data.

    We explained in gory detail many times EXACTLY how we got those numbers.
    Stop using the first absurd excuse you can think of because you hate 'em.

    The explanation is provided for you in the bottom of this article.

    iPhone 18 Pro Max endurance per charge = 62 hours
    Samsung S26 Ultra endurance per charge = 55 hours
    *Winner = Apple (+12.7%)*

    iPhone 18 Pro Max efficiency (hrs/Ah) = 11.50
    Samsung S26 Ultra efficiency (hrs/Ah) = 11.33
    *Winner = Apple (+1.5%)*

    iPhone 18 Pro Max calendar life (calculated) = ~7.08 years
    Samsung S26 Ultra calendar life (calculated) = ~7.53 years
    *Winner (of an unreliable metric) = Samsung (6.3%)*


    The 18 Pro Max is clearly the best Flagship model when it comes to battery life and efficiency. The Pixel is pretty bad.
    https://imgpile.com/p/F4eCpUZ
    It's possibly the Samsung S27 might leapfrog to the top, or maybe not.

    Unlike you Apple nutcases, Chris, normal people, like those on the Android newsgroup, don't defend any mothership to the death. Just you do it.

    So we WELCOME your comparison of the total battery life (in years, not
    in daily hours) between the top-of-the-line Samsung and iPhone.

    The Pixel isn't generally considered fair competition to either, but if you want to add the Pixel, nobody on the Android newsgroup will complain.

    Here is the template for the comparison you will be making for the team.
    1. The specifications (EU certified)
    A. Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max
    a. Capacity: 4800 mAh
    b. EU Endurance (Single Charge): 53 hours
    c. EU Cycle Rating (to 80%): 1,000 cycles
    d. Daily Cycles (24h/53h): 0.45283 cycles/day

    B. Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra
    a. Capacity: 4855 mAh
    b. EU Endurance (Single Charge): 55 hours
    c. EU Cycle Rating (to 80%): 1,200 cycles
    d. Daily Cycles (24h/55h): 0.43636 cycles/day

    2. 'Kill Time' = Total Life Cycles / Daily Cycles
    A. Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max:
    1,000 / ~0.453 = 2,208.33 days (approx 6.05 years)
    B. Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra:
    1,200 / ~0.436 = 2,750 days (approx 7.53 years)

    3. Analysis of the data
    A. Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max
    Total Life: 2,208 days (approx 6.05 years)
    Efficiency Calculation: 53 hours / 4.8 Ah = 11.04 hours per Ah
    Efficiency: 11.04 hours per Ah

    B. Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra
    Total Life: 2,750 days (approx 7.53 years)
    Efficiency Calculation: 55 hours / 4.855 Ah = 11.33 hours per Ah
    Efficiency: 11.33 hours per Ah
    Margin: 542 Days (approx 1.49 years)
    Lifespan Advantage: +24.5%

    4. Summary of the facts:
    a. Efficiency:
    Samsung wins. It gets 55 hours out of 4.855Ah,
    while Apple gets 53 hours out of 4.8Ah.
    b. Capacity:
    Samsung wins, though Apple has finally started closing the
    historic battery-capacity gap (but only recently).
    c. Durability:
    Samsung wins. The 1,200 cycle rating on Samsung's 2026 chemistry
    provides the Kill-Time victory despite the claimed iPhone efficiency.

    SUMMARY:
    iPhone 17 Pro Max hrs of runtime per charge cycle = 18.87 hours
    Samsung S26 Ultra hrs of runtime per charge cycle = 21.82 hours
    *Winner = Samsung (+15.6%)*

    iPhone 17 Pro Max endurance per charge = 53 hours
    Samsung S26 Ultra endurance per charge = 55 hours
    *Winner = Samsung (+3.8%)*

    iPhone 17 Pro Max efficiency (hrs/Ah) = 11.04
    Samsung S26 Ultra efficiency (hrs/Ah) = 11.33
    *Winner = Samsung (+2.6%)*

    iPhone 17 Pro Max calendar life (calculated) = ~6.05 years
    Samsung S26 Ultra calendar life (calculated) = ~7.53 years
    *Winner = Samsung (24.5%)*

    REFERENCES:
    a. EU Regulation 2023/1670 (Ecodesign requirements)
    <https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2023/1670/oj>
    b. EU Regulation 2023/1669 (Energy Labeling)
    <https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2023/1669/oj>
    c. EPREL (European Product Registry for Energy Labeling)
    <https://eprel.ec.europa.eu/screen/product/smartphonestablets20231669>
    d. Bitkom Compliance (June 2025 Implementation Details)
    <https://bitkom-compliance-solutions.com/en/news/new-eu-requirements-ecodesign-and-energy-labelling-smartphones-and-tablets-june-2025>

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Wed Oct 21 18:23:25 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Chris wrote:
    The chemistry is *different* so cycle count differences are plausible.

    You're assuming the chemistry is different. Do you have any evidence that isn't a tautology.

    The last time I *looked* at that Samsung claim was April 2026, so I don't remember what's different, but what you're doing is absurd, Chris.

    Let's say Samsung claims 1,200.
    Let's say NOBODY disputes that, not the EU, not Google, not even Apple.

    Then, let's say, Chris disputes it.
    Chris thinks it should be, oh, take a swab. Say 958 instead.

    That way, if Chris fabricates any number that NOBODY ELSE backs up, then Chris can claim better results in the overall battery-life calculations.

    My point?

    That's not how science works, Chris.
    You can't just say you don't like the numbers & then fabricate a number.

    Just because it's better than Apple's numbers.
    That's not how science works in the real world, Chris.

    You have to find someone reputable, publicly claiming different numbers.
    We'll accept any number you can prove is reputably backed up in cites.

    What we won't accept is Chris' made up number of, oh, say, 958.
    Just so that his Apple iPhone stands a chance of competing on overall life.

    If any numbers are wrong, I ask the team to point them out please.

    I have done many, many times. Yet you still claim that day is night.

    Which numbers in the calculation are you saying are wrong Chris.
    You can't just say they're all wrong, 'cuz they came from EU documents.

    To help you, I repeated the calculation below.
    Don't say they're all wrong.

    That's an absurd excuse all you Apple religious nutcases use.
    Tell us which number, exactly, you think is wrong.
    And tell us exactly what you think it should be.

    And back it up with cites.
    Like I did.

    See below, where I make it VERY EASY for you to pick out the number
    you think is wrong, and then you show us a cite showing what you think
    it should be, but you can't just use "Chris' 958" swag as the number.

    The Samsung lasts 1-1/2 years *longer* than the "efficient" iPhone
    (proving, yet again, that this bogus "efficiency" proffers no value).

    The discussion regarding the EU Ecodesign Regulation (EU 2023/1670)
    provides the first standardized 'Kill Time' metric we have ever had.

    Note: Kill-time is a term chosen to make the point, much like an LD50
    is for drug companies, that it's a calculated value to a detrimental state.

    No drug company would use LD50. A toxicology or research lab might. What you're thinking about is EC50 which requires experimentally validated data. The claimed battery cycle count is not validated data so can't be used in your tortured argument.

    As you know, I have higher degrees, one of which is in the biological sciences, so that's why I used the LD50 as an example, but it was just an example so people could understand the point that the battery will die.

    Again, you harp on Chris' 958" number, as if your fabrications of Samsung's "actual" number is more accurate than the one Samsung publishes openly.

    Find someone, anyone, reputable who disputes Samsung's number, and find
    what they claim the real number is, Chris. Otherwise cut the crap.

    Find Apple, for God's sake, complaining about Samsung's number.
    Or Google. Hell, there are plenty of OEMs that compete with Samsung.

    If NONE of them dispute Samsung's number, what basis do you have doing so?

    I'll ignore the insults and focus on the facts because it's important
    to parse the (admittedly brilliant) marketing propaganda surrounding this >> bogus amorphous "efficiency" that has never once resulted in actual value.

    Yet you've calculated efficiency values yourself and very happy to quote
    the EU's efficiency classes. You can't argue it both ways.

    It can't be bogus and something you've calculated yourself. So which is it?

    Chris,
    Here is a template of how the calculations came about.

    A *normal* person would either agree, or, find something wrong.
    If they find something wrong, they back it up with cites.

    You can't just say every fact that doesn't flatter Apple is wrong.
    that's what nutcase Apple religious zealots do, Chris.

    Be sensible.
    a. Tell us exactly which figure you think is wrong below.
    b. Tell us exactly what you think it should be
    c. And provide a reputable cite to back up your claim

    HINT: That's what normal people would do.

    1. The specifications (EU certified)
    A. Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max
    a. Capacity: 4800 mAh
    b. EU Endurance (Single Charge): 53 hours
    c. EU Cycle Rating (to 80%): 1,000 cycles
    d. Daily Cycles (24h/53h): 0.45283 cycles/day

    B. Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra
    a. Capacity: 4855 mAh
    b. EU Endurance (Single Charge): 55 hours
    c. EU Cycle Rating (to 80%): 1,200 cycles
    d. Daily Cycles (24h/55h): 0.43636 cycles/day

    2. 'Kill Time' = Total Life Cycles / Daily Cycles
    A. Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max:
    1,000 / ~0.453 = 2,208.33 days (approx 6.05 years)
    B. Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra:
    1,200 / ~0.436 = 2,750 days (approx 7.53 years)

    3. Analysis of the data
    A. Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max
    Total Life: 2,208 days (approx 6.05 years)
    Efficiency Calculation: 53 hours / 4.8 Ah = 11.04 hours per Ah
    Efficiency: 11.04 hours per Ah

    B. Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra
    Total Life: 2,750 days (approx 7.53 years)
    Efficiency Calculation: 55 hours / 4.855 Ah = 11.33 hours per Ah
    Efficiency: 11.33 hours per Ah
    Margin: 542 Days (approx 1.49 years)
    Lifespan Advantage: +24.5%

    4. Summary of the facts:
    a. Efficiency:
    Samsung wins. It gets 55 hours out of 4.855Ah,
    while Apple gets 53 hours out of 4.8Ah.
    b. Capacity:
    Samsung wins, though Apple has finally started closing the
    historic battery-capacity gap (but only recently).
    c. Durability:
    Samsung wins. The 1,200 cycle rating on Samsung's 2026 chemistry
    provides the Kill-Time victory despite the claimed iPhone efficiency.

    REFERENCES:
    a. EU Regulation 2023/1670 (Ecodesign requirements)
    <https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2023/1670/oj>
    b. EU Regulation 2023/1669 (Energy Labeling)
    <https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2023/1669/oj>
    c. EPREL (European Product Registry for Energy Labeling)
    <https://eprel.ec.europa.eu/screen/product/smartphonestablets20231669>
    d. Bitkom Compliance (June 2025 Implementation Details)
    <https://bitkom-compliance-solutions.com/en/news/new-eu-requirements-ecodesign-and-energy-labelling-smartphones-and-tablets-june-2025>
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Brock McNuggets@brock.mcnuggets@gmail.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Wed Oct 21 15:32:11 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On Oct 21, 2026 at 2:10 PM, Maria Sophia wrote in 11bb9on$1kr$1@nnrp.usenet.blueworldhosting.com:
    John Bokma wrote:
    For some strange reason, even after discussing this topic on the
    Apple and Android newsgroups for about a decade,

    You still don't have a clue... That's not a strange reason, that's
    just plain ignorance on your side.

    Only you Apple nutcases can't comprehend an hour isn't the same as a
    year.

    You are the only one who seems confused about that. Seriously, quote
    ANYONE else who showed any confusion. If you cannot, well, then it is
    you.

    And you only make that absurd mistake when defending Apple to the
    death.

    But you cannot quote it.

    Using the first absurdly inane excuse that pops into your head.

    You prove me right about you with every post.

    Sigh...

    --
    It's impossible for someone who is at war with themselves to be at
    peace with you.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John Bokma@contact@johnbokma.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Thu Oct 22 12:51:58 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 21/10/2026 23:10, Maria Sophia wrote:
    John Bokma wrote:
    For some strange reason, even after discussing this topic on the Apple and >>> Android newsgroups for about a decade,

    You still don't have a clue... That's not a strange reason, that's just
    plain ignorance on your side.

    Only you Apple nutcases can't comprehend an hour isn't the same as a year.

    Once again, your so called kill time ASSumes that a battery is perfect.
    It isn't.
    --
    Static tumblelog generator: https://github.com/john-bokma/tumblelog/
    Available as Python or Perl. Example tumblelog: https://plurrrr.com/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From mummycullen@mummycullen@gmail-dot-com.no-spam.invalid (MummyChunk) to misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Thu Oct 22 08:17:46 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    rLa RE: THE EU BATTERY FIGURES, rCLKILL TIME,rCY AND SAMSUNGrCOS RECORD rLa

    A valid number is not necessarily a valid conclusion.

    rLa rYo rLa

    Maria, there are good reasons to examine the EU figures, but your reply to Chris keeps treating two different questions as if they were the same: whether SamsungrCOs published battery rating is genuine, and whether your calculation proves that a Samsung phone will last a year and a half longer than an iPhone.

    They are not the same question. And by the time we get to your claim about SamsungrCOs superior long-term value, thererCOs something else worth remembering: what Samsung actually did to remaining Galaxy Note7 phones in 2016.

    1. BATTERY CHEMISTRY: CHRIS ASKED A FAIR QUESTION

    Maria Sophia wrote:


    The chemistry is different so cycle count differences are plausible.




    Chris replied:


    YourCOre assuming the chemistry is different. Do you have any evidence that isnrCOt a tautology.




    Of course different lithium-ion cell designs can have different cycle lives. Different electrodes, electrolytes, manufacturing processes, charging limits and battery-management systems can all matter.

    But seeing two different ratings doesnrCOt identify a specific difference in chemistry, let alone prove which difference caused the result. If yourCOre claiming to know the chemistry is different in a way that explains the numbers, show the technical evidence.

    You donrCOt need that claim to acknowledge SamsungrCOs higher published cycle rating. ItrCOs unnecessary speculation in an otherwise straightforward comparison.

    rLa rYo rLa

    2. CHRIS DIDNrCOT GIVE YOU A rCL958-CYCLErCY FIGURE

    Maria Sophia wrote:


    LetrCOs say Samsung claims 1,200.
    LetrCOs say NOBODY disputes that, not the EU, not Google, not even Apple.

    Then, letrCOs say, Chris disputes it.
    Chris thinks it should be, oh, take a swab. Say 958 instead.




    Where did Chris actually claim SamsungrCOs battery should be rated at 958 cycles? In the exchange yourCOve supplied, thatrCOs YOUR imaginary example, not his competing measurement.

    Maria Sophia also wrote:


    You canrCOt just say you donrCOt like the numbers & then fabricate a number.




    Agreed. But thatrCOs not what is required to challenge your argument. Chris can accept SamsungrCOs 1,200-cycle declaration completely and still reject your formula as a real-world lifespan prediction.

    Likewise, Apple or Google not publicly objecting to SamsungrCOs declared number doesnrCOt validate the prediction yourCOve constructed from it. Silence from competitors is not a scientific test.

    You donrCOt disprove a criticism of your method by demanding that the critic invent replacement inputs.

    rLa rYo rLa

    3. WHICH ACTUAL NUMBERS ARE WE DISCUSSING?

    Maria Sophia wrote:



    1. The specifications (EU certified)
    A. Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max
    a. Capacity: 4800 mAh
    b. EU Endurance (Single Charge): 53 hours
    c. EU Cycle Rating (to 80%): 1,000 cycles
    B. Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra
    a. Capacity: 4855 mAh
    b. EU Endurance (Single Charge): 55 hours
    c. EU Cycle Rating (to 80%): 1,200 cycles




    Most of that matches the European energy-label figures. One correction: the European iPhone 17 Pro Max is listed at 4,823 mAh, not precisely 4,800 mAh.

    Both models are rated A for EU energy efficiency. ApplerCOs label reports 53 hours and at least 1,000 cycles. SamsungrCOs reports 55 hours and at least 1,200 cycles. The cycle figures are reported as minimum bands rounded down to hundreds, not as predictions of failure on an exact numbered cycle.

    ApplerCOs published EU product information: https://www.apple.com/ie/iphone-17-pro/specs/

    EU labeling rules:
    https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg_del/2023/1669/oj/eng

    Another distinction: figures in the official EPREL database are declared by suppliers under regulatory rules, with market-surveillance enforcement. They are not proof that the European Commission personally tested every device or endorsed every interpretation made later by a forum participant.

    https://eprel.ec.europa.eu/screen/legaldisclaimers

    The official figures are useful. But they donrCOt answer every question about calendar lifespan.

    rLa rYo rLa

    4. YOUR ARITHMETIC IS NOT THE SAME AS AN EXPERIMENTAL RESULT

    Maria Sophia wrote:


    rCyKill TimerCO = Total Life Cycles / Daily Cycles
    A. Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max:
    1,000 / ~0.453 = 2,208.33 days (approx 6.05 years)
    B. Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra:
    1,200 / ~0.436 = 2,750 days (approx 7.53 years)




    I can follow the math:

    * Apple: 1,000 |u 53 / 24 = about 2,208 days.
    * Samsung: 1,200 |u 55 / 24 = 2,750 days.
    * Difference: about 542 days, or 1.48 years.

    So the arithmetic is substantially correct. The problem is the claim you attach to it.

    Maria Sophia wrote:


    The Samsung lasts 1-1/2 years longer than the rCLefficientrCY iPhone (proving, yet again, that this bogus rCLefficiencyrCY proffers no value).




    No. YourCOve calculated a theoretical time to a specified battery-health threshold using the initial EU endurance figure as though it establishes each ownerrCOs long-term daily rate of cycle accumulation.

    It doesnrCOt.

    People have different workloads. Batteries undergo calendar aging even when not cycled. Temperature, charging practices, depth of discharge and battery management affect degradation. And a batteryrCOs runtime changes as its capacity declines. Your equation does not model those things.

    If someone uses one full equivalent cycle daily, 1,000 cycles take about 2.74 years and 1,200 cycles about 3.29 years. At half a cycle per day, accumulating those counts takes about twice as long. Neither exercise is a real-world battery lifespan forecast, but both expose how much your conclusion depends on assumed usage.

    A precise-looking answer from a calculator is not proof that the model describes reality.

    rLa rYo rLa

    5. EIGHTY PERCENT IS NOT rCLDEADrCY

    Maria Sophia wrote:


    Kill-time is a term chosen to make the point, much like an LD50
    is for drug companies, that itrCOs a calculated value to a detrimental state.




    Chris replied:


    No drug company would use LD50. A toxicology or research lab might. What yourCOre thinking about is EC50 which requires experimentally validated data. The claimed battery cycle count is not validated data so canrCOt be used in your tortured argument.




    LD50 is a toxicological measure of a dose lethal to half a defined population under specified circumstances. EC50 concerns a specified effective response. Neither makes your homemade rCLKill TimerCY metric a scientific standard.

    And ChrisrCOs blanket suggestion that no drug company would use LD50 is too strong; the concept exists in toxicology. But the important distinction remains: the EU cycle test measures battery endurance to a capacity-retention threshold, not a devicerCOs death.

    A phone battery at 80 percent of its original capacity can still charge and work. It usually provides less runtime between charges; that is not the same as failure of the entire phone. Battery replacement is also possible.

    Maria Sophia wrote:


    As you know, I have higher degrees, one of which is in the biological sciences, so thatrCOs why I used the LD50 as an example, but it was just an example so people could understand the point that the battery will die.




    Academic credentials donrCOt change the measurement. A battery-health threshold and the death of a phone remain two different events. Calling one rCLKill TimerCY encourages readers to confuse them.

    rLa rYo rLa

    6. CHRISrCOS POINT ABOUT EFFICIENCY IS WELL TAKEN

    Maria Sophia wrote:


    IrCOll ignore the insults and focus on the facts because itrCOs important
    to parse the (admittedly brilliant) marketing propaganda surrounding this bogus amorphous rCLefficiencyrCY that has never once resulted in actual value.




    Chris replied:


    Yet yourCOve calculated efficiency values yourself and very happy to quote the EUrCOs efficiency classes. You canrCOt argue it both ways.

    It canrCOt be bogus and something yourCOve calculated yourself. So which is it?




    Chris has a point. You canrCOt dismiss efficiency as meaningless and then invoke your own efficiency calculations as proof that Samsung wins.

    Maria Sophia wrote:


    Efficiency Calculation: 53 hours / 4.8 Ah = 11.04 hours per Ah




    Hours divided by ampere-hours is not a complete measure of energy efficiency. Ampere-hours measure charge, while energy also depends on voltage. The EU energy-efficiency index accounts for more than the simple ratio yourCOve used. And BOTH models are classified A under the EU labeling scheme.

    Independent active-use testing can also produce a different winner from the EU endurance test. ThatrCOs exactly why testing conditions, regional battery variants, and the measurements being compared matter.

    You may prefer SamsungrCOs performance under the EU protocol. Fine. But that does not make engineering efficiency rCLbogus,rCY nor does it justify declaring ApplerCOs approach worthless.

    rLa rYo rLa

    7. WHICH NUMBER IS rCLWRONGrCY? SOMETIMES ITrCOS THE MODEL

    Chris wrote:


    I have done many, many times. Yet you still claim that day is night.




    Maria Sophia replied:


    Which numbers in the calculation are you saying are wrong Chris.
    You canrCOt just say theyrCOre all wrong, rCOcuz they came from EU documents.




    And later:



    a. Tell us exactly which figure you think is wrong below.
    b. Tell us exactly what you think it should be
    c. And provide a reputable cite to back up your claim




    HererCOs an exact answer: your conclusion that the formula establishes a 542-day real-world lifespan advantage is unsupported. The initial numbers do not need to be fabricated or discarded for that criticism to be valid.

    A model can take completely accurate inputs and still make a bad prediction. If I know a carrCOs fuel tank size and test-cycle fuel economy, I can estimate range under those conditions. I canrCOt use those two numbers to prove exactly how many years the car will survive.

    The burden is on the person proposing the model to show that the model predicts what they claim. Where does the EU regulation validate YOUR rCLKill TimerCY equation as a prediction of calendar years of smartphone service?

    rLa rYo rLa

    8. rCLSAMSUNG WINS DURABILITYrCY? THE NOTE7 LESSON

    Maria Sophia wrote:


    Durability:
    Samsung wins. The 1,200 cycle rating on SamsungrCOs 2026 chemistry
    provides the Kill-Time victory despite the claimed iPhone efficiency.




    A long-lasting phone is about much more than a cellrCOs published cycle rating. There is hardware reliability, support, repairability, access to personal data, and what the manufacturer does when a problem arises.

    ThatrCOs where SamsungrCOs handling of the Galaxy Note7 still matters to me.

    In December 2016, Samsung announced software intended to stop remaining U.S. Note7 phones from charging and prevent them from continuing to function as mobile devices. ThatrCOs not rumor or anti-Samsung folklore. ItrCOs SamsungrCOs documented policy.

    SamsungrCOs announcement: https://news.samsung.com/us/samsung-taking-bold-steps-to-increase-galaxy-note7-device-returns/

    The Note7 had a genuine battery fire hazard, and the recall included replacement devices. But the fact that the product required a recall does NOT answer every question about the consequences of disabling customersrCO means of communication and access to their data.

    I personally knew Note7 owners who told me their phones had shown no signs of overheating, that they had had them checked, and that they did not wish to give them up at that time. Some tried to prevent automatic updates. Nonetheless, they told me their phones eventually would not charge, and after the remaining power ran out, would not turn on.

    IrCOm describing what people I knew experienced, not pretending I can reconstruct the exact update path for every device. The charging-disabling program itself, however, is documented beyond dispute.

    Several of those people were traveling or otherwise in circumstances where losing their phone was particularly serious. Imagine being away from home, relying on a phone for directions, family contacts, reservations, or emergency communication, and discovering it can no longer be recharged.

    And Verizon itself raised that very concern.

    When the update was announced, Verizon initially opposed deploying it during the holiday travel season because people without replacement phones could lose contact with family, first responders, or medical professionals. Verizon later agreed to deploy it after the holidays.

    Contemporary reporting containing VerizonrCOs statement: https://www.androidauthority.com/verizon-wont-roll-galaxy-note-7-shutdown-735185/

    That warning matters. The potential communications consequences werenrCOt an imaginary concern invented years afterward; a major carrier identified them at the time.

    rLa rYo rLa

    9. A REFUND DOES NOT SOLVE THE PERSONAL-DATA PROBLEM

    HererCOs the issue that especially bothers me. Some people I knew could not power on their phones to transfer remaining files or perform a normal factory reset before returning them.

    A phone can contain family photographs, private messages, contacts, financial information, authentication details, medical information, and files that were never backed up. A refund replaces the money spent on the hardware; it doesnrCOt retrieve irreplaceable data or give the owner back the chance to erase a device through its normal controls.

    Encryption may protect information on a locked device. That is a separate question from whether the owner can retrieve, back up, or erase it before surrendering the phone.

    What was the practical plan for customers whose phones had already become inaccessible? How were they supposed to preserve their data or verify that returned devices were securely handled?

    Those are serious ownership questions, and they matter whether the name on the phone is Samsung, Apple, or anyone else. I am not suggesting a dangerous recalled product should have remained in use indefinitely. I am saying that disabling a purchased device has consequences beyond issuing a refund, and those consequences deserve scrutiny.

    rLa rYo rLa

    10. BACK TO THE ACTUAL ARGUMENT

    Maria Sophia wrote:


    4. Summary of the facts:
    a. Efficiency:
    Samsung wins.
    b. Capacity:
    Samsung wins, though Apple has finally started closing the
    historic battery-capacity gap (but only recently).
    c. Durability:
    Samsung wins.




    Samsung has the slightly larger rated battery in the cited European variants, the higher declared cycle band, and two more hours on the EU standardized endurance label. Those are valid specific advantages.

    But both phones are efficiency class A. Other battery tests can favor Apple. And your equation doesnrCOt establish that Samsung will actually outlive Apple by 1.5 calendar years.

    Nor do those three measurements decide the entire ownership experience. Repair costs, software support, personal-data access, long-term reliability and manufacturer conduct count as well.

    For my own purchasing priorities, IrCOd lean toward the iPhone 17 Pro Max. That isnrCOt blind loyalty to Apple or a claim that Samsung makes universally bad products. ItrCOs a judgment about the evidence available, the performance I value, and my own experience of how Samsung handled a major product crisis.

    MY QUESTIONS TO YOU, MARIA

    * Where does EU Regulation 2023/1669 validate your rCLKill TimerCY formula as a prediction of calendar years of useful phone life?
    * Why do you present the 80-percent capacity threshold as the death of the battery or phone?
    * How do you account for calendar aging, charging habits, temperature, declining runtime and replacement batteries?
    * Why call efficiency meaningless while using efficiency calculations yourself? * Why insist Chris supply a made-up competing cycle count when he can reasonably challenge your interpretation without disputing SamsungrCOs declared figure?
    * And if werCOre talking about long-term value, why ignore what happens when the manufacturer exercises its power over customersrCO devices, communications and personal data?

    rLa rYo rLa

    Chris, I wouldnrCOt reject SamsungrCOs regulatory cycle declaration without evidence. But I agree with the essential methodological objection: a published rating is not proof that MariarCOs extrapolated lifespan is real.

    Maria, the numbers arenrCOt the issue you keep claiming they are. The issue is what yourCOre trying to make those numbers establish.

    You have a calculation. You havenrCOt demonstrated a real-world 542-day lifespan advantage.

    And SamsungrCOs Note7 history is a reminder that the value of a smartphone canrCOt be reduced to how many charging cycles a manufacturer advertises.

    Specifications matter. Scientific reasoning matters. So do consumer trust, communications, and control over onerCOs own data.

    rLa rYo rLa


    View the attachments for this post at: http://www.jlaforums.com/viewtopic.php?p=712706619#712706619
    --
    Via JLA Forums web gateway for misc.phone.mobile.iphone
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Thu Oct 22 12:00:45 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    John Bokma wrote:
    Only you Apple nutcases can't comprehend an hour isn't the same as a year.

    Once again, your so called kill time ASSumes that a battery is perfect.
    It isn't.


    You prove me right every time you Apple religious zealots defend Apple.

    Every absurd excuse is the first inane thought that pops into your head.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,comp.mobile.android on Thu Oct 22 12:02:24 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Chris wrote:
    ROFL

    Why don't you Apple religious zealots respond to the facts, with facts?

    Use this template to compare the iPhone folding flagship.
    To the Samsung folding flagship.

    Then, let's see how funny the results are.

    Here is the template for the comparison you will be making for the team.
    1. The specifications (EU certified)
    A. Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max
    a. Capacity: 4800 mAh
    b. EU Endurance (Single Charge): 53 hours
    c. EU Cycle Rating (to 80%): 1,000 cycles
    d. Daily Cycles (24h/53h): 0.45283 cycles/day

    B. Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra
    a. Capacity: 4855 mAh
    b. EU Endurance (Single Charge): 55 hours
    c. EU Cycle Rating (to 80%): 1,200 cycles
    d. Daily Cycles (24h/55h): 0.43636 cycles/day

    2. 'Kill Time' = Total Life Cycles / Daily Cycles
    A. Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max:
    1,000 / ~0.453 = 2,208.33 days (approx 6.05 years)
    B. Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra:
    1,200 / ~0.436 = 2,750 days (approx 7.53 years)

    3. Analysis of the data
    A. Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max
    Total Life: 2,208 days (approx 6.05 years)
    Efficiency Calculation: 53 hours / 4.8 Ah = 11.04 hours per Ah
    Efficiency: 11.04 hours per Ah

    B. Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra
    Total Life: 2,750 days (approx 7.53 years)
    Efficiency Calculation: 55 hours / 4.855 Ah = 11.33 hours per Ah
    Efficiency: 11.33 hours per Ah
    Margin: 542 Days (approx 1.49 years)
    Lifespan Advantage: +24.5%

    4. Summary of the facts:
    a. Efficiency:
    Samsung wins. It gets 55 hours out of 4.855Ah,
    while Apple gets 53 hours out of 4.8Ah.
    b. Capacity:
    Samsung wins, though Apple has finally started closing the
    historic battery-capacity gap (but only recently).
    c. Durability:
    Samsung wins. The 1,200 cycle rating on Samsung's 2026 chemistry
    provides the Kill-Time victory despite the claimed iPhone efficiency.

    SUMMARY:
    iPhone 17 Pro Max hrs of runtime per charge cycle = 18.87 hours
    Samsung S26 Ultra hrs of runtime per charge cycle = 21.82 hours
    *Winner = Samsung (+15.6%)*

    iPhone 17 Pro Max endurance per charge = 53 hours
    Samsung S26 Ultra endurance per charge = 55 hours
    *Winner = Samsung (+3.8%)*

    iPhone 17 Pro Max efficiency (hrs/Ah) = 11.04
    Samsung S26 Ultra efficiency (hrs/Ah) = 11.33
    *Winner = Samsung (+2.6%)*

    iPhone 17 Pro Max calendar life (calculated) = ~6.05 years
    Samsung S26 Ultra calendar life (calculated) = ~7.53 years
    *Winner = Samsung (24.5%)*

    REFERENCES:
    a. EU Regulation 2023/1670 (Ecodesign requirements)
    <https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2023/1670/oj>
    b. EU Regulation 2023/1669 (Energy Labeling)
    <https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2023/1669/oj>
    c. EPREL (European Product Registry for Energy Labeling)
    <https://eprel.ec.europa.eu/screen/product/smartphonestablets20231669>
    d. Bitkom Compliance (June 2025 Implementation Details)
    <https://bitkom-compliance-solutions.com/en/news/new-eu-requirements-ecodesign-and-energy-labelling-smartphones-and-tablets-june-2025>
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John Bokma@contact@johnbokma.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Thu Oct 22 18:06:54 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 22/10/2026 18:00, Maria Sophia wrote:
    John Bokma wrote:
    Only you Apple nutcases can't comprehend an hour isn't the same as a year. >>
    Once again, your so called kill time ASSumes that a battery is perfect.
    It isn't.

    [nothing]

    Still foaming at the mouth, I see. And still wrong.
    --
    Static tumblelog generator: https://github.com/john-bokma/tumblelog/
    Available as Python or Perl. Example tumblelog: https://plurrrr.com/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From mummycullen@mummycullen@gmail-dot-com.no-spam.invalid (MummyChunk) to misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Thu Oct 22 15:02:44 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    RE: THE BATTERY NUMBERS " AND YOUR FOLDING iPHONE CHALLENGE

    Since you keep asking for facts, Maria, letrCOs examine the arithmetic and then accept your challenge using the actual EU figures.

    rLa rYo rLa

    Chris wrote:


    ROFL




    Maria Sophia replied:


    Why donrCOt you Apple religious zealots respond to the facts, with facts?




    Maria, the problem isnrCOt that nobody is responding to your numbers.

    The problem is that you continue repeating the same fundamentally flawed conclusion while refusing to address the distinction between a published specification and a scientifically demonstrated prediction.

    And now yourCOve introduced an entirely new calculation that has an obvious problem with its units.

    Since yourCOre so insistent on scientific rigor, letrCOs start there.

    1. YOUR NEW 15.6% ADVANTAGE DOESNrCOT MEASURE WHAT YOU CLAIM

    Maria Sophia wrote:


    iPhone 17 Pro Max hrs of runtime per charge cycle = 18.87 hours
    Samsung S26 Ultra hrs of runtime per charge cycle = 21.82 hours
    Winner = Samsung (+15.6%)




    Where exactly did those numbers come from?

    They donrCOt appear as battery endurance measurements in the EU regulations.

    But I can reproduce them perfectly:

    Apple:

    1,000 / 53 = 18.87

    Samsung:

    1,200 / 55 = 21.82

    ThatrCOs clearly what yourCOve calculated.

    However, yourCOve divided a number of battery cycles by a number of hours.

    Cycles divided by hours gives cycles per hour, NOT hours per cycle.

    YourCOve reversed the dimensional relationship and then labeled the result as something it isnrCOt.

    Your own original figures already state the EU-rated endurance per full charge:

    Apple: 53 hours.

    Samsung: 55 hours.

    Those are the endurance measurements.

    Dividing battery-cycle ratings by those endurance figures doesnrCOt magically produce another measure of runtime.

    And hererCOs a simple way to expose the flaw.

    Suppose two batteries are both rated for 1,000 cycles.

    One phone lasts 50 hours per charge.

    The other lasts only 25 hours per charge.

    Your new formula produces:

    1,000 / 50 = 20

    1,000 / 25 = 40

    According to your new calculation, the phone with HALF the battery endurance would receive TWICE the score!

    Surely you can see the problem.

    The worse the single-charge endurance becomes, the larger this supposed performance figure can become, even with the same cycle rating.

    Your claimed 15.6% Samsung advantage is therefore an advantage in a ratio that yourCOve mislabeled and have not shown to represent any meaningful battery-performance metric.

    The arithmetic is reproducible.

    The interpretation is not defensible.

    rLa rYo rLa

    2. YOUR ORIGINAL rCLKILL TIMErCY ARGUMENT IS STILL UNPROVEN

    Maria Sophia wrote:


    iPhone 17 Pro Max calendar life (calculated) = ~6.05 years
    Samsung S26 Ultra calendar life (calculated) = ~7.53 years
    Winner = Samsung (24.5%)




    WerCOve already discussed this, but you keep presenting these figures as though theyrCOre experimentally established battery lifespans.

    They arenrCOt.

    YourCOre multiplying a published cycle rating by the EU endurance per charge and converting the resulting hours into calendar years.

    That produces a mathematical extrapolation under an assumed usage pattern.

    It does not establish when either battery will actually reach 80% capacity in everyday ownership.

    And that 80% threshold isnrCOt the death of the battery or the phone.

    Actual battery degradation depends on calendar aging, temperature, usage, charging behavior, and other factors that your calculation doesnrCOt adequately model.

    Nor does your calculation account for the practical possibility of battery replacement.

    Where does the EU regulation validate your formula as a prediction of actual calendar lifespan?

    IrCOm still interested in that answer.

    The regulation defines battery endurance and cycle testing. It doesnrCOt establish your personally invented rCLKill TimerCY metric as a scientifically validated method for predicting how many years a smartphone will remain useful.

    https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg_del/2023/1669/oj/eng

    And a final mathematical result cannot be more reliable than the assumptions on which it depends.

    rLa rYo rLa

    3. NOW LETrCOS ACCEPT YOUR FOLDING-FLAGSHIP CHALLENGE

    Maria Sophia wrote:


    Use this template to compare the iPhone folding flagship.
    To the Samsung folding flagship.

    Then, letrCOs see how funny the results are.




    Fair enough, Maria.

    LetrCOs do exactly that.

    Apple announced its first folding iPhone, the iPhone Duo, on September 9, 2026. Preorders began October 16, and retail availability begins October 23.

    Samsung introduced the Galaxy Z Fold8 and Galaxy Z Fold8 Ultra earlier this year.

    Since you specifically requested a folding-flagship comparison, letrCOs compare ApplerCOs iPhone Duo with SamsungrCOs Galaxy Z Fold8 Ultra.

    And to avoid any accusations of selecting favorable figures, letrCOs use the same official European EPREL database yourCOve been quoting throughout this discussion.

    APPLE iPHONE DUO

    Model: A3720

    * EU-rated battery capacity: 4,883 mAh
    * EU endurance per charge: 51 hours, 30 minutes
    * EU cycle endurance: at least 1,000 cycles
    * EU energy efficiency class: A

    Official EU registration:

    https://eprel.ec.europa.eu/screen/product/smartphonestablets20231669/2774825

    SAMSUNG GALAXY Z FOLD8 ULTRA

    Model: SM-F976B

    * EU-rated battery capacity: 4,854 mAh
    * EU endurance per charge: 51 hours, 10 minutes
    * EU cycle endurance: at least 1,200 cycles
    * EU energy efficiency class: A

    Official EU registration:

    https://eprel.ec.europa.eu/screen/product/smartphonestablets20231669/2600776

    Now letrCOs compare those figures directly.

    BATTERY ENDURANCE PER CHARGE

    Apple: 51 hours, 30 minutes.

    Samsung: 51 hours, 10 minutes.

    Winner: Apple, by 20 minutes under the EU test.

    EU-RATED BATTERY CAPACITY

    Apple: 4,883 mAh.

    Samsung: 4,854 mAh.

    Winner: Apple, by 29 mAh in rated capacity.

    Note that Samsung advertises 5,000 mAh as its TYPICAL battery capacity, whereas its EU-rated capacity is 4,854 mAh.

    You cannot properly compare SamsungrCOs typical figure against ApplerCOs rated figure as though theyrCOre measured on the same basis.

    Since you insist on using EU figures, letrCOs use the EU-rated capacities for BOTH phones.

    BATTERY CYCLE ENDURANCE

    Apple: at least 1,000 cycles.

    Samsung: at least 1,200 cycles.

    Winner: Samsung, on the published cycle rating.

    ENERGY EFFICIENCY CLASS

    Apple: A.

    Samsung: A.

    Result: Both receive the highest EU efficiency classification.

    Now thatrCOs interesting, isnrCOt it?

    You challenged everyone to compare the folding flagships, apparently expecting Samsung to dominate the numbers.

    Yet ApplerCOs first folding iPhone has a slightly higher EU-rated battery capacity AND slightly longer endurance per charge than SamsungrCOs Galaxy Z Fold8 Ultra.

    Samsung retains the advantage in the published cycle-count category.

    That is what the figures actually show.

    rLa rYo rLa

    4. AND WHAT ABOUT SAMSUNGrCOS REGULAR GALAXY Z FOLD8?

    We might as well include that model, too.

    The Galaxy Z Fold8 has the following EU figures:

    * Rated capacity: 4,660 mAh
    * Endurance per charge: 49 hours, 10 minutes
    * Cycle endurance: at least 1,200 cycles
    * Energy efficiency class: A

    Official registration:

    https://eprel.ec.europa.eu/screen/product/smartphonestablets20231669/2600778

    Against the regular Galaxy Z Fold8, ApplerCOs iPhone Duo has:

    * 223 mAh more rated battery capacity.
    * 2 hours, 20 minutes more endurance per charge.
    * A lower published cycle endurance rating.
    * The same A efficiency classification.

    So whether we compare ApplerCOs folding phone against the regular Fold8 or SamsungrCOs more expensive Fold8 Ultra, Apple has the longer EU-rated runtime per charge.

    Samsung has the higher declared cycle-count endurance.

    Neither result requires inventing a new metric or pretending the other companyrCOs legitimate advantages donrCOt exist.

    rLa rYo rLa

    5. WHAT HAPPENS IF WE APPLY YOUR OWN rCLKILL TIMErCY FORMULA?

    For completeness, letrCOs apply the same arithmetic to the two folding flagships.

    Apple iPhone Duo:

    1,000 |u 51.5 / 24 = approximately 2,146 days.

    Samsung Galaxy Z Fold8 Ultra:

    1,200 |u 51.167 / 24 = approximately 2,558 days.

    Your calculation therefore produces approximately 5.88 years for Apple and 7.00 years for Samsung.

    A difference of roughly 413 days.

    So yes, the higher Samsung cycle rating causes your theoretical calculation to favor Samsung again.

    But it remains a theoretical calculation based on assumptions about usage and degradation, not a scientifically validated prediction of the actual lifespan of either device.

    And neither device has been in consumersrCO hands long enough to establish anything remotely resembling a six- or seven-year real-world battery-life outcome.

    In fact, ApplerCOs iPhone Duo only begins general retail availability on October 23.

    We can compare its published specifications today.

    We cannot pretend that years of real-world battery-aging evidence already exist.

    rLa rYo rLa

    6. HERErCOS SOMETHING ELSE ABOUT SAMSUNGrCOS CYCLE RATINGS

    There is another interesting fact that your approach tends to overlook.

    SamsungrCOs previous Galaxy Z Fold7 carried a published battery cycle endurance rating of at least 2,000 cycles.

    The newer Galaxy Z Fold8 and Fold8 Ultra are rated at 1,200 cycles.

    That is a substantial reduction in the published cycle-endurance category between successive Samsung generations.

    The new models offer improvements in other battery characteristics, including capacity and runtime, but the regulatory cycle rating is lower.

    This was widely reported when SamsungrCOs 2026 foldable labels appeared in EPREL.

    https://www.androidauthority.com/samsung-galaxy-z8-foldables-battery-charging-cycles-3691072/

    Now, Maria, if a higher cycle rating automatically establishes a superior long-term smartphone, would you declare SamsungrCOs older Fold7 to be more durable than the new Fold8 Ultra on that basis alone?

    Or would you acknowledge that battery capacity, endurance, chemistry, thermal management, usage, repairability, and other considerations also matter?

    Because you canrCOt reasonably insist on a comprehensive evaluation when SamsungrCOs own models are being compared, then abandon that principle when yourCOre comparing Samsung with Apple.

    rLa rYo rLa

    7. WHAT YOU KEEP REFUSING TO ADDRESS

    Your newest post repeats the same basic problem from the earlier discussion.

    Maria Sophia wrote:


    Why donrCOt you Apple religious zealots respond to the facts, with facts?




    Maria, calling people religious zealots isnrCOt a substitute for responding to the criticisms of your calculations.

    I have no objection to Samsung winning a comparison where Samsung genuinely has the better result.

    And I have no problem acknowledging its higher published cycle rating.

    But I also have no problem acknowledging ApplerCOs advantages where ApplerCOs numbers are better.

    ThatrCOs the difference between evaluating evidence and defending a brand.

    You have now presented THREE distinct things as though they were the same:

    * Official battery specifications.
    * Calculations constructed from those specifications.
    * Conclusions about actual real-world lifespan and overall product superiority.

    They arenrCOt interchangeable.

    The first can be legitimate while the second uses questionable assumptions and the third overstates what has been demonstrated.

    Your new 15.6% claim is worse still, because the ratio itself has been given the wrong physical units.

    And as I pointed out in my previous reply, long-term ownership value involves more than battery specifications.

    I havenrCOt forgotten SamsungrCOs Galaxy Note7 charging-disabling update or the problems it created for people I personally knew.

    That history matters to my assessment of consumer trust and manufacturer control.

    You havenrCOt addressed those concerns either.

    rLa rYo rLa

    8. SO HERE ARE MY QUESTIONS TO YOU

    FIRST:

    What exactly do you believe your newly calculated figures of 18.87 and 21.82 measure?

    Since you calculated them by dividing cycles by hours, how can they properly represent rCLhours of runtime per charge cyclerCY?

    SECOND:

    Why does your new formula produce a higher result when single-charge endurance becomes shorter, assuming the cycle rating stays the same?

    THIRD:

    Will you acknowledge that ApplerCOs iPhone Duo has a slightly longer EU-rated battery endurance per charge than SamsungrCOs Galaxy Z Fold8 Ultra?

    FOURTH:

    Will you acknowledge that ApplerCOs iPhone Duo has a slightly larger EU-rated battery capacity than the Fold8 Ultra when the two rated-capacity figures are compared consistently?

    FIFTH:

    Will you explain why SamsungrCOs newer Fold8 models carry lower published cycle ratings than the preceding Fold7, if your central argument is that more cycles necessarily mean a superior long-term product?

    SIXTH:

    And finally, where is the published scientific validation for converting these cycle ratings into exact predictions of real-world calendar lifespan?

    Those are substantive questions about your own numbers and conclusions.

    They deserve substantive answers.

    rLa rYo rLa

    MY CONCLUSION

    Maria, you challenged people to compare ApplerCOs folding flagship with SamsungrCOs folding flagship.

    IrCOve done exactly that.

    Using the official European figures you insist everyone should use.

    Apple leads in the rated battery capacity and single-charge endurance measurements for the iPhone Duo versus Galaxy Z Fold8 Ultra.

    Samsung leads in the declared battery cycle-count category.

    Both are energy-efficiency class A.

    And neither set of figures establishes the actual calendar year in which either phone will become unusable.

    ThatrCOs what an objective comparison looks like. You acknowledge what the measurements show without pretending they prove more than they actually do.

    As for your new 15.6% advantage, you need to explain the units before expecting anybody to accept it as a meaningful battery-performance result.

    Because cycles divided by hours are not hours divided by cycles.

    And arithmetic performed on valid specifications can still produce an irrelevant or misleading comparison.

    You asked for the facts, Maria.

    There they are.

    Now perhaps we can discuss the actual measurements and their limitations instead of calling everyone who questions your conclusions an Apple zealot.

    rLa rYo rLa
    --
    Via JLA Forums web gateway for misc.phone.mobile.iphone
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Chris@ithinkiam@gmail.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Thu Oct 22 19:51:50 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Maria Sophia <mariasophia@comprehension.com> wrote:
    Chris wrote:
    These are facts using similar phones which we chose blind in April, before >>> we ran the calculations based only EU specifications, which we agreed on. >>
    Problem is this data is out of date. The 17 Pro Max is no longer for sale. >> Let's compare with the 18 Pro Max

    Do it.
    I'd love to see the results. I'm sure all of us would love to see them.

    As before with the iPhone 17 Pro Max, I have no idea how it will turn out.

    I suspect the iPhone will suck, but Apple got a bruising with the first EU benchmarks proving the crappy batteries, so maybe Apple fixed that problem?

    I don't know if Apple learned anything from being shown to be liars all these years about their supposed "efficiency", so maybe they fixed it?

    Dunno.
    Like any normal person, I WELCOME you calculating & reporting the result.
    To help you, I provided a working template on the bottom of this article.

    Check the numbers below. I've already done the calculations.


    iPhone 17 Pro Max hrs of runtime per charge cycle = 18.87 hours
    Samsung S26 Ultra hrs of runtime per charge cycle = 21.82 hours
    *Winner = Samsung (+15.6%)*

    No idea how you got these numbers. That's not EU data.

    We explained in gory detail many times EXACTLY how we got those numbers.
    Stop using the first absurd excuse you can think of because you hate 'em.

    The explanation is provided for you in the bottom of this article.

    Not the run times above. There's no explanation of them.

    iPhone 18 Pro Max endurance per charge = 62 hours
    Samsung S26 Ultra endurance per charge = 55 hours
    *Winner = Apple (+12.7%)*

    iPhone 18 Pro Max efficiency (hrs/Ah) = 11.50
    Samsung S26 Ultra efficiency (hrs/Ah) = 11.33
    *Winner = Apple (+1.5%)*

    iPhone 18 Pro Max calendar life (calculated) = ~7.08 years
    Samsung S26 Ultra calendar life (calculated) = ~7.53 years
    *Winner (of an unreliable metric) = Samsung (6.3%)*


    The 18 Pro Max is clearly the best Flagship model when it comes to battery >> life and efficiency. The Pixel is pretty bad.
    https://imgpile.com/p/F4eCpUZ
    It's possibly the Samsung S27 might leapfrog to the top, or maybe not.

    Unlike you Apple nutcases, Chris, normal people, like those on the Android newsgroup, don't defend any mothership to the death. Just you do it.

    So we WELCOME your comparison of the total battery life (in years, not
    in daily hours) between the top-of-the-line Samsung and iPhone.

    The Pixel isn't generally considered fair competition to either,

    Why not? You included it in comparison to the Duo.




    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Chris@ithinkiam@gmail.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Thu Oct 22 20:05:26 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Maria Sophia <mariasophia@comprehension.com> wrote:
    Chris wrote:
    The chemistry is *different* so cycle count differences are plausible.

    You're assuming the chemistry is different. Do you have any evidence that
    isn't a tautology.

    The last time I *looked* at that Samsung claim was April 2026, so I don't remember what's different, but what you're doing is absurd, Chris.

    Let's say Samsung claims 1,200.
    Let's say NOBODY disputes that, not the EU, not Google, not even Apple.

    Then, let's say, Chris disputes it.
    Chris thinks it should be, oh, take a swab. Say 958 instead.

    Samsung themselves disputed their own numbers. Last year their cycle count
    was 1700+. This year it's 1200. No one told them to change it and no one disputed it. So, how we can trust a number that not even Samsung can stand
    by?

    That way, if Chris fabricates any number that NOBODY ELSE backs up, then Chris can claim better results in the overall battery-life calculations.

    I absolutely did not fabricate a number. Stop making shit up.

    And back it up with cites.
    Like I did.

    You never provide cites that matter. For example, where's your cite that
    Apple batteries are known to fail sooner than Samsung et al?

    As you know, I have higher degrees,

    I know you live in the mountains. Is that what you mean by higher degrees?

    Here is a template of how the calculations came about.

    Why do you keep using the 17 Pro Max, when I gave you the 18 Pro Max
    numbers?

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Arno Welzel@usenet@arnowelzel.de to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Fri Oct 23 09:50:12 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Maria Sophia, 2026-10-16 17:50:

    Chris wrote:
    Not to mention that anyone who can afford a $2000+ phone will get the
    AppleCare also. So your entire tirade is fairly stupid.

    Anyone that can afford a $2000+ phone (hell, a $1000+ phone) will
    likely be replacing as soon as the next model is released anyway.

    Clearly not true. Most people change their phones every 3-4 years. Unless
    you're on the Apple phone plan where you can swap your phone every year.

    All these high-end phones that cost more than a desktop computer are
    aimed at idiots with more money than sense.

    Base Samsung Galaxy Z Fold 8 and Google Pixel 11 Pro Fold MSRPs for 256GB
    are both about $100 less than the Duo, so the Apple Duo is likely
    overpriced (IMHO) given it's a new model which has no proven track record.

    Well - when the total price is around $2000, then $100 is just 5%. You
    call this "overpriced"? Or is *any* higher price "overpriced" for you,
    even if it just $1 more? I wouldn't by the Samsung Galaxy Z Fold 8
    either or the Google Pixel 11 Fold Pro since I would never spend that
    much money for a smartphone at all.
    --
    Arno Welzel
    https://arnowelzel.de
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Fri Oct 23 12:50:57 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Arno Welzel wrote:
    All these high-end phones that cost more than a desktop computer are
    aimed at idiots with more money than sense.

    Base Samsung Galaxy Z Fold 8 and Google Pixel 11 Pro Fold MSRPs for 256GB
    are both about $100 less than the Duo, so the Apple Duo is likely
    overpriced (IMHO) given it's a new model which has no proven track record.

    Well - when the total price is around $2000, then $100 is just 5%. You
    call this "overpriced"? Or is *any* higher price "overpriced" for you,
    even if it just $1 more? I wouldn't by the Samsung Galaxy Z Fold 8
    either or the Google Pixel 11 Fold Pro since I would never spend that
    much money for a smartphone at all.

    I was responding to the comment from someone else of... (verbatim)...

    "All these high-end phones that cost more than a desktop computer
    are aimed at idiots with more money than sense."

    Just the (California) sales tax alone on those overpriced abominations is
    more than my perfectly good phone was. Actually, mine was supposedly free
    from T-Mobile, but I had to pay 10% sales tax on the manufacturer's MSRP.
    <https://i.postimg.cc/Xq5SpS4D/tmopromo02.jpg>

    Given a person buying these phones might fall for the insurance trick, that phone will cost roughly around *double* the initial sales price over time.

    Interestingly, my 2021 Galaxy A32-5G has a better battery then that iPhone which is partly why I can go nearly a week without needing to fast charge.

    I'll wager those folding phone crap batteries won't last even 3-4 years.
    --
    There's a sucker born every minute said, oh, Bessimer or Hannum or Barnum.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Fri Oct 23 12:58:12 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Chris wrote:
    Like any normal person, I WELCOME you calculating & reporting the result.
    To help you, I provided a working template on the bottom of this article.

    Check the numbers below. I've already done the calculations.

    Interesting your numbers don't add up, Chris, and that you don't cite where
    you got your numbers from so we can't even check why/how the math is wrong.

    The explanation is provided for you in the bottom of this article.

    Not the run times above. There's no explanation of them.

    The numbers came from the references quoted below the explanation, Chris.


    iPhone 18 Pro Max endurance per charge = 62 hours
    Samsung S26 Ultra endurance per charge = 55 hours
    *Winner = Apple (+12.7%)*

    iPhone 18 Pro Max efficiency (hrs/Ah) = 11.50
    Samsung S26 Ultra efficiency (hrs/Ah) = 11.33
    *Winner = Apple (+1.5%)*

    iPhone 18 Pro Max calendar life (calculated) = ~7.08 years
    Samsung S26 Ultra calendar life (calculated) = ~7.53 years
    *Winner (of an unreliable metric) = Samsung (6.3%)*

    The Pixel isn't generally considered fair competition to either,

    Why not? You included it in comparison to the Duo.

    I've never done a one-to-one comparison of the Pixel to any iPhone in my memory, Chris, like I did with the Samsung (which is the true competitor).

    If I have done that detailed numerical 1:1 comparison, show me where.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Fri Oct 23 13:02:42 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    John Bokma wrote:
    And still wrong.

    Your only argument (to defend Apple to the death) is all facts are wrong?

    You Apple religious zealot nutcases prove me right about you in every post.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John Bokma@contact@johnbokma.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Fri Oct 23 19:15:40 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 23/10/2026 19:02, Maria Sophia wrote:
    John Bokma wrote:
    And still wrong.

    Your only argument (to defend Apple to the death) is all facts are wrong?

    Your napkin calculations of so called kill time are practically wrong,
    making your whole argument using them wrong.
    --
    Static tumblelog generator: https://github.com/john-bokma/tumblelog/
    Available as Python or Perl. Example tumblelog: https://plurrrr.com/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Fri Oct 23 13:26:06 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Chris wrote:
    Chris thinks it should be, oh, take a swab. Say 958 instead.

    Samsung themselves disputed their own numbers. Last year their cycle count was 1700+. This year it's 1200. No one told them to change it and no one disputed it. So, how we can trust a number that not even Samsung can stand by?

    Jesus Christ, Chis,

    Why must you prove me correct about you every single time you post?
    a. You say my math is wrong
    b. Fine. But why, I ask
    c. You say I didn't use a number you don't like.

    WTF?

    You can't say the math is wrong because of a number which you feel is wrong
    but which was never used in any of the calculations, Chris.

    *That's the definition of an absurd excuse*

    WTF?

    Why not say all my math is wrong because, oh, because I didn't use 2000 as
    the number. Oh wait, my math is wrong because I didn't use 3000. 4000?

    Given there are an infinite set of numbers I didn't use, why pick the
    arbitrary one you picked, that I didn't use, to say my math is wrong?

    You prove me right every time you post about your absurd excuses.
    The math is right.

    You claiming the math is wrong with that inane excuse is simply absurd.


    That way, if Chris fabricates any number that NOBODY ELSE backs up, then
    Chris can claim better results in the overall battery-life calculations.

    I absolutely did not fabricate a number. Stop making shit up.

    Cut the crap Chris. Just cut it.
    Stop lying. Stop this shit. Seriously. Cut the crap.

    a. You argue I used 1700+.
    b. NEVER ever did I use 1700+
    c. You say my math is wrong because you say I used 1700+

    That's a lie. You'll stop at nothing to defend Apple to the death, Chris.
    Cut the crap.

    You can't say the math is wrong when it's not wrong.
    It's just your first inane absurd excuse to defend Apple to the death.

    Stop proving me right about you.


    And back it up with cites.
    Like I did.

    You never provide cites that matter. For example, where's your cite that Apple batteries are known to fail sooner than Samsung et al?

    The calculations are put there for you to understand them.
    If you don't understand them, then I can't make you intelligent, Chris.

    As you know, I have higher degrees,

    I know you live in the mountains. Is that what you mean by higher degrees?

    My point is you Apple nutcases don't.

    I can tell because every argument from you would fail any entrance exam.

    Here is a template of how the calculations came about.

    Why do you keep using the 17 Pro Max, when I gave you the 18 Pro Max
    numbers?

    Jesus Christ, Chris. You're a nut case.
    a. In April, I spent hours crunching the numbers.
    b. Those numbers used the 17 Pro Max,
    c. For you to not UNDERSTAND that fact is a real problem

    Seriously.
    You are a nutcase, Chris.

    I quoted the exact thread. the exact message ID. The exact text.

    If you said something that stupid in a college entrance interview, you'd
    never get into that college, Chris.

    Stop proving me right about you Apple religious zealots.
    I gave you the numbers that I had as a template for you to run the math.

    I don't care how the iPhone flagships come out.
    I don't care how Samsung flagships come out.

    that's what's different about us.
    a. I don't give a shit about Samsung (or Google).
    b. So I only care about the facts
    c. You DO CARE very much to show Apple only in a handsome light

    So be it.
    You run the calculations.

    I gave you the template I used. And the references.
    Follow it.





    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Fri Oct 23 13:33:15 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    John Bokma wrote:
    Your only argument (to defend Apple to the death) is all facts are wrong?

    Your napkin calculations of so called kill time are practically wrong, making your whole argument using them wrong.

    You Apple nutcases prove me right about you every time you post.

    It's easy to tell you have no education because you saying everything is
    wrong is not how you pass a test. Even in high school, you'd flunk out.

    When a normal person claims a calculation is wrong, they give what they
    think is the correct calculation, but not you Apple religious zealots.

    All you Apple religiouz zealots simply say any calcualtion which doesn't
    show Apple in a good light... is wrong...

    You don't say how.
    You don't say why.

    You certainly don't provide any "corrected" calculations.

    *You just say every fact about Apple you don't like... is wrong.*

    Why must you Apple religious zealot nutjobs prove me right all the time?
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Brock McNuggets@brock.mcnuggets@gmail.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Fri Oct 23 10:55:08 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On Oct 23, 2026 at 10:02 AM, Maria Sophia wrote in 11bg3vi$1phr$1@nnrp.usenet.blueworldhosting.com:
    John Bokma wrote:
    And still wrong.

    Your only argument (to defend Apple to the death) is all facts are
    wrong?

    You Apple religious zealot nutcases prove me right about you in every
    post.


    Notice you feel the need to lie to push a "point".
    --
    It's impossible for someone who is at war with themselves to be at peace
    with you.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Brock McNuggets@brock.mcnuggets@gmail.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Fri Oct 23 10:55:31 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On Oct 23, 2026 at 10:33 AM, Maria Sophia wrote in 11bg5oq$857$1@nnrp.usenet.blueworldhosting.com:
    John Bokma wrote:
    Your only argument (to defend Apple to the death) is all facts are
    wrong?

    Your napkin calculations of so called kill time are practically
    wrong, making your whole argument using them wrong.

    You Apple nutcases prove me right about you every time you post.

    It's easy to tell you have no education because you saying everything
    is wrong is not how you pass a test. Even in high school, you'd flunk
    out.

    When a normal person claims a calculation is wrong, they give what
    they think is the correct calculation, but not you Apple religious
    zealots.

    All you Apple religiouz zealots simply say any calcualtion which
    doesn't show Apple in a good light... is wrong...

    You don't say how.
    You don't say why.

    You certainly don't provide any "corrected" calculations.

    *You just say every fact about Apple you don't like... is wrong.*

    Why must you Apple religious zealot nutjobs prove me right all the
    time?


    GIGO
    --
    It's impossible for someone who is at war with themselves to be at peace
    with you.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John Bokma@contact@johnbokma.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Fri Oct 23 20:16:23 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 23/10/2026 19:33, Maria Sophia wrote:

    [..]> It's easy to tell you have no education because you saying
    everything is
    wrong is not how you pass a test. Even in high school, you'd flunk out.

    When a normal person claims a calculation is wrong, they give what they
    think is the correct calculation, but not you Apple religious zealots.

    I clearly stated that your calculation is wrong because it doesn't take
    into account the temperature, the natural aging of the battery,
    non-linearity of aging, and how it is *actually* used.

    [snip, rest of childish insults]

    "
    Sure. HererCOs whatrCOs wrong with the rCLKill Time = Total Life Cycles / Daily CyclesrCY calculation when it comes to real-world battery usage:

    1. It ignores calendar aging entirely
    Batteries degrade even when not being used rCo the chemistry inside the electrolyte and electrodes breaks down over time regardless of cycle
    count. As we discussed earlier: a 1-year-old battery with 150 cycles
    will almost always outperform a 5-year-old battery with the same 150
    cycles. Your formula (1,200 cycles |+ 0.436/day ree 7.5 years) implicitly assumes only cycles matter rCo but by 7.5 years, the battery will have
    aged chemically regardless of whether it ever actually reaches 1,200 cycles.

    2. rCLDaily cyclesrCY derived from the EU endurance test is an unrealistic proxy for real usage
    The 55-hour figure comes from a standardized lab test (continuous use
    until full depletion in one go). Nobody uses a phone for 55 hours
    straight and then charges once. Most people charge daily, often
    overnight, with a partial discharge (say, 60% down to 100%, not 0% to
    100%). That shifts real-world cycle accumulation in two opposing ways
    the formula doesnrCOt capture:

    More frequent partial charges can be less stressful per cycle than one
    deep full discharge (partial cycles count only partially toward a rCLfullrCY cycle).
    But sitting at 100% overnight more often increases degradation from high state-of-charge exposure rCo something the formula doesnrCOt account for at all.

    3. 80% capacity isnrCOt rCLdeathrCY rCo itrCOs an arbitrary industry threshold rCLKill timerCY implies the battery stops functioning at that point. It doesnrCOt rCo the phone keeps working fine well past 80%, often for years, just with noticeably shorter battery life per day. ThererCOs no hard rCLdeathrCY cliff at cycle 1,200; degradation is continuous, not a sudden drop-off.

    4. Degradation isnrCOt linear
    The cycle rating (1,200 to 80%) reflects an average under controlled
    test conditions (fixed temperature, fixed charging protocol). In
    practice, degradation often accelerates past a certain point rCo
    especially from heat and fast charging rCo rather than proceeding evenly
    the way the formula implies.

    5. Usage patterns vary significantly over a devicerCOs lifetime
    A new device often gets heavier use (novelty effect), seasons change
    heat exposure, and software updates shift power draw rCo so rCLdaily cyclesrCY isnrCOt the constant the formula treats it as.

    Bottom line: the formula treats battery wear as a simple, linear, time-independent cycle problem, when in reality itrCOs a combination of
    cycle wear and calendar aging and temperature/charging behavior rCo three factors that compound each other, not cleanly divide into one tidy number.
    "
    --
    Static tumblelog generator: https://github.com/john-bokma/tumblelog/
    Available as Python or Perl. Example tumblelog: https://plurrrr.com/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Brock McNuggets@brock.mcnuggets@gmail.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Fri Oct 23 11:18:51 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On Oct 23, 2026 at 11:16 AM, John Bokma wrote in
    11bg89n$224co$1@dont-email.me:
    On 23/10/2026 19:33, Maria Sophia wrote:

    [..]> It's easy to tell you have no education because you saying
    everything is
    wrong is not how you pass a test. Even in high school, you'd flunk
    out.

    When a normal person claims a calculation is wrong, they give what
    they think is the correct calculation, but not you Apple religious
    zealots.

    I clearly stated that your calculation is wrong because it doesn't
    take into account the temperature, the natural aging of the battery, non-linearity of aging, and how it is *actually* used.

    And he snipped it all.

    [snip, rest of childish insults]

    "
    Sure. Here's what's wrong with the "Kill Time = Total Life Cycles /
    Daily Cycles" calculation when it comes to real-world battery usage:

    1. It ignores calendar aging entirely
    Batteries degrade even when not being used rCo the chemistry inside the electrolyte and electrodes breaks down over time regardless of cycle
    count. As we discussed earlier: a 1-year-old battery with 150 cycles
    will almost always outperform a 5-year-old battery with the same 150
    cycles. Your formula (1,200 cycles |+ 0.436/day ree 7.5 years) implicitly assumes only cycles matter rCo but by 7.5 years, the battery will have
    aged chemically regardless of whether it ever actually reaches 1,200
    cycles.

    2. "Daily cycles" derived from the EU endurance test is an unrealistic
    proxy for real usage The 55-hour figure comes from a standardized lab
    test (continuous use until full depletion in one go). Nobody uses a
    phone for 55 hours straight and then charges once. Most people charge
    daily, often overnight, with a partial discharge (say, 60% down to
    100%, not 0% to 100%). That shifts real-world cycle accumulation in
    two opposing ways the formula doesn't capture:

    More frequent partial charges can be less stressful per cycle than one
    deep full discharge (partial cycles count only partially toward a
    "full" cycle). But sitting at 100% overnight more often increases
    degradation from high state-of-charge exposure rCo something the formula doesn't account for at all.

    3. 80% capacity isn't "death" rCo it's an arbitrary industry threshold
    "Kill time" implies the battery stops functioning at that point. It
    doesn't rCo the phone keeps working fine well past 80%, often for years,
    just with noticeably shorter battery life per day. There's no hard
    "death" cliff at cycle 1,200; degradation is continuous, not a sudden drop-off.

    4. Degradation isn't linear
    The cycle rating (1,200 to 80%) reflects an average under controlled
    test conditions (fixed temperature, fixed charging protocol). In
    practice, degradation often accelerates past a certain point rCo
    especially from heat and fast charging rCo rather than proceeding evenly
    the way the formula implies.

    5. Usage patterns vary significantly over a device's lifetime A new
    device often gets heavier use (novelty effect), seasons change heat
    exposure, and software updates shift power draw rCo so "daily cycles"
    isn't the constant the formula treats it as.

    Bottom line: the formula treats battery wear as a simple, linear, time-independent cycle problem, when in reality it's a combination of
    cycle wear and calendar aging and temperature/charging behavior rCo
    three factors that compound each other, not cleanly divide into one
    tidy number. "

    More evidence / reasoning than he ever shares.
    --
    It's impossible for someone who is at war with themselves to be at peace
    with you.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From mummycullen@mummycullen@gmail-dot-com.no-spam.invalid (MummyChunk) to misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Fri Oct 23 13:57:38 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Maria Sophia wrote:
    Chris wrote:




    Chris thinks it should be, oh, take a swab. Say 958 instead.



    Samsung themselves disputed their own numbers. Last year their cycle count >> was 1700+. This year it's 1200. No one told them to change it and no one
    disputed it. So, how we can trust a number that not even Samsung can stand >> by?



    Jesus Christ, Chis,

    Why must you prove me correct about you every single time you post?
    a. You say my math is wrong
    b. Fine. But why, I ask
    c. You say I didn't use a number you don't like.

    WTF?

    You can't say the math is wrong because of a number which you feel is wrong but which was never used in any of the calculations, Chris.

    *That's the definition of an absurd excuse*

    WTF?

    Why not say all my math is wrong because, oh, because I didn't use 2000 as the number. Oh wait, my math is wrong because I didn't use 3000. 4000?

    Given there are an infinite set of numbers I didn't use, why pick the arbitrary one you picked, that I didn't use, to say my math is wrong?

    You prove me right every time you post about your absurd excuses.
    The math is right.

    You claiming the math is wrong with that inane excuse is simply absurd.






    That way, if Chris fabricates any number that NOBODY ELSE backs up, then >>> Chris can claim better results in the overall battery-life calculations. >>>


    I absolutely did not fabricate a number. Stop making sh*t up.



    Cut the crap Chris. Just cut it.
    Stop lying. Stop this sh*t. Seriously. Cut the crap.

    a. You argue I used 1700+.
    b. NEVER ever did I use 1700+
    c. You say my math is wrong because you say I used 1700+

    That's a lie. You'll stop at nothing to defend Apple to the death, Chris.
    Cut the crap.

    You can't say the math is wrong when it's not wrong.
    It's just your first inane absurd excuse to defend Apple to the death.

    Stop proving me right about you.






    And back it up with cites.
    Like I did.



    You never provide cites that matter. For example, where's your cite that
    Apple batteries are known to fail sooner than Samsung et al?



    The calculations are put there for you to understand them.
    If you don't understand them, then I can't make you intelligent, Chris.





    As you know, I have higher degrees,



    I know you live in the mountains. Is that what you mean by higher degrees? >>


    My point is you Apple nutcases don't.

    I can tell because every argument from you would fail any entrance exam.





    Here is a template of how the calculations came about.



    Why do you keep using the 17 Pro Max, when I gave you the 18 Pro Max
    numbers?



    Jesus Christ, Chris. You're a nut case.
    a. In April, I spent hours crunching the numbers.
    b. Those numbers used the 17 Pro Max,
    c. For you to not UNDERSTAND that fact is a real problem

    Seriously.
    You are a nutcase, Chris.

    I quoted the exact thread. the exact message ID. The exact text.

    If you said something that stupid in a college entrance interview, you'd never get into that college, Chris.

    Stop proving me right about you Apple religious zealots.
    I gave you the numbers that I had as a template for you to run the math.

    I don't care how the iPhone flagships come out.
    I don't care how Samsung flagships come out.

    that's what's different about us.
    a. I don't give a sh*t about Samsung (or Google).
    b. So I only care about the facts
    c. You DO CARE very much to show Apple only in a handsome light

    So be it.
    You run the calculations.

    I gave you the template I used. And the references.
    Follow it.



    RE: THE NUMBERS AREN'T THE PROBLEM " THE CONCLUSION IS

    rLa rYo rLa

    Maria, I notice the discussion has continued, but the central question raised in my earlier reply still hasn't been answered. I'm not asking you to change Samsung's numbers. I'm asking you to demonstrate that your formula actually predicts the calendar lifespan of a phone.

    John Bokma wrote:


    Your napkin calculations of so called kill time are practically wrong,
    making your whole argument using them wrong.




    That's the distinction you keep overlooking. An equation can be arithmetically correct and still be a poor model of the thing it supposedly predicts.

    Maria Sophia replied:


    You can't say the math is wrong when it's not wrong.




    But John isn't required to show that 1,200 multiplied by 55 and divided by 24 was calculated incorrectly. He's questioning whether that calculation tells us when a real smartphone battery reaches 80% health in someone's actual use " let alone when the entire phone dies.

    Correct arithmetic does not validate an unsupported assumption.

    rLa rYo rLa

    AND NOW WE HAVE THE IPHONE 18 PRO MAX NUMBERS

    Chris wrote:


    iPhone 18 Pro Max endurance per charge = 62 hours
    Samsung S26 Ultra endurance per charge = 55 hours
    *Winner = Apple (+12.7%)*

    iPhone 18 Pro Max efficiency (hrs/Ah) = 11.50
    Samsung S26 Ultra efficiency (hrs/Ah) = 11.33
    *Winner = Apple (+1.5%)*

    iPhone 18 Pro Max calendar life (calculated) = ~7.08 years
    Samsung S26 Ultra calendar life (calculated) = ~7.53 years
    *Winner (of an unreliable metric) = Samsung (6.3%)*




    Apple's own European specifications confirm that the iPhone 18 Pro Max has 62 hours of EU-rated endurance, a rated capacity of 5,391 mAh, and a declared minimum of 1,000 cycles:

    https://www.apple.com/ie/iphone-18-pro/specs/

    Samsung's S26 Ultra label gives 55 hours and 1,200 cycles.

    Now apply your own formula to the CURRENT flagships:

    * Apple: 1,000 |u 62 / 24 = approximately 2,583 days.
    * Samsung: 1,200 |u 55 / 24 = 2,750 days.

    That's a difference of about 167 days, not the 542 days you keep citing from the older iPhone 17 comparison.

    And those 167 days are STILL not an experimentally verified real-world lifespan advantage. They're the output of your model, with all the same unproven assumptions.

    Meanwhile, on the EU single-charge endurance test, Apple leads by seven hours. Independent testing also puts the iPhone 18 Pro Max ahead of the S26 Ultra in at least one standardized web-browsing test:

    https://www.tomsguide.com/phones/iphones/iphone-18-pro-max-and-18-pro-battery-life-tested-the-results-are-surprising

    So why insist that Apple's efficiency has no practical value?

    rLa rYo rLa

    SAMSUNG'S OWN YEAR-TO-YEAR FIGURES ARE INSTRUCTIVE

    Chris wrote:


    Samsung themselves disputed their own numbers. Last year their cycle count was 1700+. This year it's 1200.




    The exact wording could be better: Samsung hasn't retracted the cycle rating for one particular model. We're comparing different generations of hardware.

    But Chris has identified a real and relevant change. Samsung's Galaxy S25 Ultra was declared at 2,000 cycles; the S26 Ultra is declared at 1,200 cycles. That's a substantial drop in the published cycle rating between successive flagship generations.

    Samsung's S25 Ultra EPREL record: https://eprel.ec.europa.eu/screen/product/smartphonestablets20231669/2339789

    And yet the S26 Ultra has better EU-rated endurance per charge. One measure improved while another declined. That is exactly why reducing the whole ownership experience to one self-devised 'Kill Time' score is unconvincing.

    rLa rYo rLa

    Maria Sophia wrote:


    I don't care how the iPhone flagships come out.
    I don't care how Samsung flagships come out.




    Then perhaps we can stop calling people "Apple religious zealots" for pointing out that the newer iPhone beats Samsung on the current EU endurance-per-charge measurement.

    You can acknowledge Samsung's higher declared cycle rating AND Apple's better single-charge endurance. Neither one requires insulting anyone, and neither one validates a claim about precisely how many calendar years the phone will survive.

    Here's the unanswered question, again:

    Where does the EU regulation say that multiplying a battery's published cycle rating by its initial test endurance and dividing by 24 produces a scientifically validated prediction of real-world calendar lifespan?

    Until you provide evidence for that method, repeating that "the math is right" isn't an answer to Chris, John, or my earlier reply.

    The figures can be genuine. The arithmetic can be correct. And the conclusion can still be unsupported. Those three statements are perfectly consistent.

    rLa rYo rLa


    View the attachments for this post at: http://www.jlaforums.com/viewtopic.php?p=712756588#712756588
    --
    Via JLA Forums web gateway for misc.phone.mobile.iphone
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Sat Oct 24 10:09:42 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    John Bokma wrote:
    When a normal person claims a calculation is wrong, they give what they
    think is the correct calculation, but not you Apple religious zealots.

    I clearly stated that your calculation is wrong because it doesn't take
    into account the temperature, the natural aging of the battery, non-linearity of aging, and how it is *actually* used.

    Again you prove me right, for a whole bunch of reasons, not the least of
    which is all the numbers used were published for benchmark conditions, but
    even more importantly, show us YOUR NUMBERS that show EU numbers as wrong.

    You didn't,
    becasue
    You can't.

    I always wonder what kind of strange people you zealots are, where I think
    you hang out with other zealots who don't expect your idiocy to make sense.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John Bokma@contact@johnbokma.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Sat Oct 24 19:41:25 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 24/10/2026 16:09, Maria Sophia wrote:
    John Bokma wrote:
    When a normal person claims a calculation is wrong, they give what they
    think is the correct calculation, but not you Apple religious zealots.

    I clearly stated that your calculation is wrong because it doesn't take
    into account the temperature, the natural aging of the battery,
    non-linearity of aging, and how it is *actually* used.

    Again you prove me right,

    Only in your bubble of craziness.

    I always wonder what kind of strange people you zealots are,

    Just look in the mirror. It's that guy with foam on his mouth ranting
    about kill time while not having a clue of how batteries in the real
    world *actually* behave.
    --
    Static tumblelog generator: https://github.com/john-bokma/tumblelog/
    Available as Python or Perl. Example tumblelog: https://plurrrr.com/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Chris@ithinkiam@gmail.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Sat Oct 24 20:28:22 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Maria Sophia <mariasophia@comprehension.com> wrote:
    Chris wrote:
    Like any normal person, I WELCOME you calculating & reporting the result. >>> To help you, I provided a working template on the bottom of this article. >>
    Check the numbers below. I've already done the calculations.

    Interesting your numbers don't add up, Chris, and that you don't cite where you got your numbers from

    They're from the EU which should have been obvious as that's the context,
    here.

    so we can't even check why/how the math is wrong.

    Look, I actively publish my findings, openly online and you never, ever
    show any interest in them.
    https://rpubs.com/ithinkiam/1460398

    You've had nearly 18 months to find errors in my representation of the
    data.

    The explanation is provided for you in the bottom of this article.

    Not the run times above. There's no explanation of them.

    The numbers came from the references quoted below the explanation, Chris.

    No they don't. You proceeded two sets up runtimes for the iphone and
    Samsung. Only one set came from the EU.


    iPhone 18 Pro Max endurance per charge = 62 hours
    Samsung S26 Ultra endurance per charge = 55 hours
    *Winner = Apple (+12.7%)*

    iPhone 18 Pro Max efficiency (hrs/Ah) = 11.50
    Samsung S26 Ultra efficiency (hrs/Ah) = 11.33
    *Winner = Apple (+1.5%)*

    iPhone 18 Pro Max calendar life (calculated) = ~7.08 years
    Samsung S26 Ultra calendar life (calculated) = ~7.53 years
    *Winner (of an unreliable metric) = Samsung (6.3%)*

    The Pixel isn't generally considered fair competition to either,

    Why not? You included it in comparison to the Duo.

    I've never done a one-to-one comparison of the Pixel to any iPhone in my memory,

    That's not what I said. You brought up the pixel here:
    Message-Id: <11ath3s$1s0r$1@nnrp.usenet.blueworldhosting.com>
    Base Samsung Galaxy Z Fold 8 and Google Pixel 11
    Pro Fold MSRPs for 256GB are both about $100 less
    than the Duo, so the Apple Duo is likely overpriced
    (IMHO) given it's a new model which has no proven
    track record.

    If it's not fair competition why bring it into the discussion? Likewise is
    $100 different enough for something that isn't equivalent? Sounds like it's
    the pixel that is overpriced.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Chris@ithinkiam@gmail.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.mobile.android,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Sat Oct 24 20:48:43 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Maria Sophia <mariasophia@comprehension.com> wrote:
    John Bokma wrote:
    Your only argument (to defend Apple to the death) is all facts are wrong? >>
    Your napkin calculations of so called kill time are practically wrong,
    making your whole argument using them wrong.

    You Apple nutcases prove me right about you every time you post.

    It's easy to tell you have no education because you saying everything is wrong is not how you pass a test. Even in high school, you'd flunk out.

    It's funny/sad when you resort to this.

    It's clear you have no response to the questions and criticisms so you
    resort to ad hominems.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2