Yes Alan, Apple Maps does use Siri.
And, Siri works just fine with
Google Maps.
But not at all with Google Search, or for just about any
general search, via CarPlay. On the iPhone(off CarPlay)/iPad/Mac Siri
search uses Google as the default primary search engine. And Google pays
for that position.
You asked for it. The video starts off where the photo left off and goes from there. Vehicle is our 2026 Forester. Camera is a GoPro 12.And your very first act completely contradicts your original statement
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1coaUjRCdeJBLyUAcOy8it3B5heXFKJ4G/view? usp=share_link
On 2026-11-03 17:50, Tom Elam wrote:
Yes Alan, Apple Maps does use Siri.
No. A Siri request can invoke Apple Maps.
Not the same thing.
nd your very first act completely contradicts your original statement
where you claim you invoked Siri with your voice only.
Of COURSE a button WITHIN Apple Maps is going to focus the "Ask Siri" context to locations.
Siri even comes up and explicitly asks "Where do you want to go?".
Another detail you left out of your original claim that would have made
it completely obvious that Siri USING THAT BUTTON is operating within
the context of Apple Maps.
Thank you for being to ignorant to realize you were outing your lies by omission.
On 2026-11-03 22:17, Alan wrote:
On 2026-11-03 17:50, Tom Elam wrote:
Yes Alan, Apple Maps does use Siri.
No. A Siri request can invoke Apple Maps.
Not the same thing.
I apologize. I should have read the entire thing.
I assumed you were referring to the fact that Siri now offers a
"Directions" option when you invoke it in a general context.
Now I understand, that you were simply lying about HOW you were invoking
it in your earlier post.
On 2026-11-03 22:17, Alan wrote:
On 2026-11-03 17:50, Tom Elam wrote:
Yes Alan, Apple Maps does use Siri.
No. A Siri request can invoke Apple Maps.
Not the same thing.
I apologize. I should have read the entire thing.
I assumed you were referring to the fact that Siri now offers a
"Directions" option when you invoke it in a general context.
Now I understand, that you were simply lying about HOW you were invoking
it in your earlier post.
On 2026-11-03 22:17, Alan wrote:
On 2026-11-03 17:50, Tom Elam wrote:
Yes Alan, Apple Maps does use Siri.
No. A Siri request can invoke Apple Maps.
Not the same thing.
I apologize. I should have read the entire thing.
I assumed you were referring to the fact that Siri now offers a
"Directions" option when you invoke it in a general context.
Now I understand, that you were simply lying about HOW you were invoking
it in your earlier post.
On 11/4/26 12:29 AM, Alan wrote:
On 2026-11-03 22:17, Alan wrote:
On 2026-11-03 17:50, Tom Elam wrote:
Yes Alan, Apple Maps does use Siri.
No. A Siri request can invoke Apple Maps.
Not the same thing.
I apologize. I should have read the entire thing.
I assumed you were referring to the fact that Siri now offers a
"Directions" option when you invoke it in a general context.
Now I understand, that you were simply lying about HOW you were
invoking it in your earlier post.
OK, Siri AI "launched" back in September. Apparently capabilities are rolling out.
A little research found the Apple Sports app that source claimed work
with CarPlay. Installed and CarPlay, while in motion, and Siri gave me a wide range of pro and college sports and related news.
So I tried a very specific request "Who won the Hamilton County Indiana Sheriff election." In car, while in motion. Siri gave me a verbal
correct response based on ABC news, including party and vote count. That would not have worked in CarPlay while driving a short time ago.
Hooking up with Google appears to be a good move already. Color me
amazed. Any of my prior knocks against Siri are moot, for now.
And yes, Apple Maps on CarPlay explicitly uses Siri. It was in the
video. After bringing Maps into CarPlay foreground with a Maps icon
touch then a touch on Maps to start Search, the Siri icon appears. Touch that and you see the Siri query icon bottom center and ask for an
address or more general request.
"Hey Siri open Maps" works on the phone and in CarPlay.
That does not happen on the iPhone. You see a microphone icon on the
iPhone. Go find a car with CarPlay and try it out. Better yet buy a car
with CarPlay and use it on a daily basis. You need to get over the
illusion that CarPlay works exactly like your phone.
Question - if not Siri what search algorithm is Apple using for Maps?
On 2026-11-04 20:06, Tom Elam wrote:
On 11/4/26 12:29 AM, Alan wrote:
On 2026-11-03 22:17, Alan wrote:
On 2026-11-03 17:50, Tom Elam wrote:
Yes Alan, Apple Maps does use Siri.
No. A Siri request can invoke Apple Maps.
Not the same thing.
I apologize. I should have read the entire thing.
I assumed you were referring to the fact that Siri now offers a
"Directions" option when you invoke it in a general context.
Now I understand, that you were simply lying about HOW you were
invoking it in your earlier post.
OK, Siri AI "launched" back in September. Apparently capabilities are
rolling out.
A little research found the Apple Sports app that source claimed work
with CarPlay. Installed and CarPlay, while in motion, and Siri gave me
a wide range of pro and college sports and related news.
So I tried a very specific request "Who won the Hamilton County
Indiana Sheriff election." In car, while in motion. Siri gave me a
verbal correct response based on ABC news, including party and vote
count. That would not have worked in CarPlay while driving a short
time ago.
Hooking up with Google appears to be a good move already. Color me
amazed. Any of my prior knocks against Siri are moot, for now.
And yes, Apple Maps on CarPlay explicitly uses Siri. It was in the
video. After bringing Maps into CarPlay foreground with a Maps icon
touch then a touch on Maps to start Search, the Siri icon appears.
Touch that and you see the Siri query icon bottom center and ask for
an address or more general request.
Wrong. When you open Maps to start Search and the "Ask Siri" icon
appears, you touch it and Siri says "Where would you like to go?".
That is CLEARLY NOT going to address a general request, now is it.
In that sense (and ONLY that sense)
"Hey Siri open Maps" works on the phone and in CarPlay.
Which is utterly separate from what you just said.
That does not happen on the iPhone. You see a microphone icon on the
iPhone. Go find a car with CarPlay and try it out. Better yet buy a
car with CarPlay and use it on a daily basis. You need to get over the
illusion that CarPlay works exactly like your phone.
I don't hold that illusion, and I have no idea WHERE you're claiming I
would "see a microphone icon on the iPhone"
In our earlier conversations, it took me multiple tries until you could
see that tapping a microphone icon with the search field WITHIN GOOGLE
MAPS was OBVIOUSLY going to be expecting you to say an address next.
There is indeed such an icon within Apple Maps, but we never discussed it.
Question - if not Siri what search algorithm is Apple using for Maps?
You STILL DON'T GET it!
Siri listens to what you say, and parses it.
When you say "directions to" and follow it with an address, it parses
that as a request for... ...directions to an address!
It then passes that address to Apple Maps...
...JUST AS IF YOU HAD SIMPLY OPENED APPLE MAPS AND TYPED IT THERE YOURSELF!
Apple Maps uses whatever search algorithms it always uses at that point.
On 11/4/26 11:13 PM, Alan wrote:I've finally figured out your problem, Liarboy:
On 2026-11-04 20:06, Tom Elam wrote:
On 11/4/26 12:29 AM, Alan wrote:
On 2026-11-03 22:17, Alan wrote:
On 2026-11-03 17:50, Tom Elam wrote:
Yes Alan, Apple Maps does use Siri.
No. A Siri request can invoke Apple Maps.
Not the same thing.
I apologize. I should have read the entire thing.
I assumed you were referring to the fact that Siri now offers a
"Directions" option when you invoke it in a general context.
Now I understand, that you were simply lying about HOW you were
invoking it in your earlier post.
OK, Siri AI "launched" back in September. Apparently capabilities are
rolling out.
A little research found the Apple Sports app that source claimed work
with CarPlay. Installed and CarPlay, while in motion, and Siri gave
me a wide range of pro and college sports and related news.
So I tried a very specific request "Who won the Hamilton County
Indiana Sheriff election." In car, while in motion. Siri gave me a
verbal correct response based on ABC news, including party and vote
count. That would not have worked in CarPlay while driving a short
time ago.
Hooking up with Google appears to be a good move already. Color me
amazed. Any of my prior knocks against Siri are moot, for now.
And yes, Apple Maps on CarPlay explicitly uses Siri. It was in the
video. After bringing Maps into CarPlay foreground with a Maps icon
touch then a touch on Maps to start Search, the Siri icon appears.
Touch that and you see the Siri query icon bottom center and ask for
an address or more general request.
Wrong. When you open Maps to start Search and the "Ask Siri" icon
appears, you touch it and Siri says "Where would you like to go?".
That is CLEARLY NOT going to address a general request, now is it.
No, and why would it?
In that sense (and ONLY that sense)
"Hey Siri open Maps" works on the phone and in CarPlay.
Which is utterly separate from what you just said.
No it's not, it is an extension of what I just said.
That does not happen on the iPhone. You see a microphone icon on the
iPhone. Go find a car with CarPlay and try it out. Better yet buy a
car with CarPlay and use it on a daily basis. You need to get over
the illusion that CarPlay works exactly like your phone.
I don't hold that illusion, and I have no idea WHERE you're claiming I
would "see a microphone icon on the iPhone"
OMG, open Apple Maps. See it now? On the right side of search input
area? Do you ever use Apple Maps. Do you even have an iPhone? Do I
really need to post a screenshot?
In our earlier conversations, it took me multiple tries until you
could see that tapping a microphone icon with the search field WITHIN
GOOGLE MAPS was OBVIOUSLY going to be expecting you to say an address
next.
There is indeed such an icon within Apple Maps, but we never discussed
it.
Question - if not Siri what search algorithm is Apple using for Maps?
You STILL DON'T GET it!
I totally get it. What Siri does depends on context. It also depends on whether you are using CarPlay, or not.
Exactly
Siri listens to what you say, and parses it.
When you say "directions to" and follow it with an address, it parses
that as a request for... ...directions to an address!
It then passes that address to Apple Maps...
...JUST AS IF YOU HAD SIMPLY OPENED APPLE MAPS AND TYPED IT THERE
YOURSELF!
Or use voice input, which is essential in CarPlay unless you stop
moving. You don't get from lack of experience. Your phone does not have
that limitation.
Apple Maps uses whatever search algorithms it always uses at that point.
So the point is this. I understand that underlying Siri is a whole other
set of algorithms. My issue has been, and I am not alone, is that Siri
has often given wrong or no results on CarPlay inquires. The CarPlay experience is very different from your phone, or has been at least. That seems to be changing, and I am happy to see it.
It is all in how how Apple programmed Siri to parse inputs. In the case
of CarPlay, which you do not use almost daily like I do, Siri has been almost useless until recently. That is changing.
I blame Siri because that is all I see when things go wrong.
Example: Yesterday from I asked Siri "go to Northeast Taildraggers RC
Club". Up popped Apple Maps and directions. That is one of the places
Siri returned an "I can't find that" in the past. One of the obscure
places you mentioned recently.
What I think I am seeing is is results from the new Apple-Google
partnership announced back in September. In this newsgroup that was criticized. My comment was it makes complete sense.
On 2026-11-05 08:36, Tom Elam wrote:
On 11/4/26 11:13 PM, Alan wrote:I've finally figured out your problem, Liarboy:
On 2026-11-04 20:06, Tom Elam wrote:
On 11/4/26 12:29 AM, Alan wrote:
On 2026-11-03 22:17, Alan wrote:
On 2026-11-03 17:50, Tom Elam wrote:
Yes Alan, Apple Maps does use Siri.
No. A Siri request can invoke Apple Maps.
Not the same thing.
I apologize. I should have read the entire thing.
I assumed you were referring to the fact that Siri now offers a
"Directions" option when you invoke it in a general context.
Now I understand, that you were simply lying about HOW you were
invoking it in your earlier post.
OK, Siri AI "launched" back in September. Apparently capabilities
are rolling out.
A little research found the Apple Sports app that source claimed
work with CarPlay. Installed and CarPlay, while in motion, and Siri
gave me a wide range of pro and college sports and related news.
So I tried a very specific request "Who won the Hamilton County
Indiana Sheriff election." In car, while in motion. Siri gave me a
verbal correct response based on ABC news, including party and vote
count. That would not have worked in CarPlay while driving a short
time ago.
Hooking up with Google appears to be a good move already. Color me
amazed. Any of my prior knocks against Siri are moot, for now.
And yes, Apple Maps on CarPlay explicitly uses Siri. It was in the
video. After bringing Maps into CarPlay foreground with a Maps icon
touch then a touch on Maps to start Search, the Siri icon appears.
Touch that and you see the Siri query icon bottom center and ask for
an address or more general request.
Wrong. When you open Maps to start Search and the "Ask Siri" icon
appears, you touch it and Siri says "Where would you like to go?".
That is CLEARLY NOT going to address a general request, now is it.
No, and why would it?
In that sense (and ONLY that sense)
"Hey Siri open Maps" works on the phone and in CarPlay.
Which is utterly separate from what you just said.
No it's not, it is an extension of what I just said.
That does not happen on the iPhone. You see a microphone icon on the
iPhone. Go find a car with CarPlay and try it out. Better yet buy a
car with CarPlay and use it on a daily basis. You need to get over
the illusion that CarPlay works exactly like your phone.
I don't hold that illusion, and I have no idea WHERE you're claiming
I would "see a microphone icon on the iPhone"
OMG, open Apple Maps. See it now? On the right side of search input
area? Do you ever use Apple Maps. Do you even have an iPhone? Do I
really need to post a screenshot?
In our earlier conversations, it took me multiple tries until you
could see that tapping a microphone icon with the search field WITHIN
GOOGLE MAPS was OBVIOUSLY going to be expecting you to say an address
next.
There is indeed such an icon within Apple Maps, but we never
discussed it.
Question - if not Siri what search algorithm is Apple using for Maps?
You STILL DON'T GET it!
I totally get it. What Siri does depends on context. It also depends
on whether you are using CarPlay, or not.
Exactly
Siri listens to what you say, and parses it.
When you say "directions to" and follow it with an address, it parses
that as a request for... ...directions to an address!
It then passes that address to Apple Maps...
...JUST AS IF YOU HAD SIMPLY OPENED APPLE MAPS AND TYPED IT THERE
YOURSELF!
Or use voice input, which is essential in CarPlay unless you stop
moving. You don't get from lack of experience. Your phone does not
have that limitation.
Apple Maps uses whatever search algorithms it always uses at that point.
So the point is this. I understand that underlying Siri is a whole
other set of algorithms. My issue has been, and I am not alone, is
that Siri has often given wrong or no results on CarPlay inquires. The
CarPlay experience is very different from your phone, or has been at
least. That seems to be changing, and I am happy to see it.
It is all in how how Apple programmed Siri to parse inputs. In the
case of CarPlay, which you do not use almost daily like I do, Siri has
been almost useless until recently. That is changing.
I blame Siri because that is all I see when things go wrong.
Example: Yesterday from I asked Siri "go to Northeast Taildraggers RC
Club". Up popped Apple Maps and directions. That is one of the places
Siri returned an "I can't find that" in the past. One of the obscure
places you mentioned recently.
What I think I am seeing is is results from the new Apple-Google
partnership announced back in September. In this newsgroup that was
criticized. My comment was it makes complete sense.
You assume nothing anyone says has any value and that whatever thing
you've read is always absolutely correct.
I've finally figured out your problem, Fakerboy:
You assume that whatever thing you've read is always absolutely correct.
On 11/5/26 11:48 AM, Alan wrote:
I've finally figured out your problem, Fakerboy:
You assume that whatever thing you've read is always absolutely correct.
It just hit me. You have no daily experience with CarPlay. You have
never driven through our local roundabouts. You have never had a pilot logbook.
It's YOU thinks whatever thing you've read is always absolutely correct.
Like what you read about or heard about CarPlay, roundabout rules and
how they actually apply in this area, or something about what is
expected in pilot logbook entries. Items that I have done for YEARS of
VERY frequent experience and know them all quite well.
On 11/5/26 11:48 AM, Alan wrote:
I've finally figured out your problem, Fakerboy:
You assume that whatever thing you've read is always absolutely correct.
It just hit me. You have no daily experience with CarPlay. You have
never driven through our local roundabouts. You have never had a pilot logbook.
It's YOU thinks whatever thing you've read is always absolutely correct.
Like what you read about or heard about CarPlay,
roundabout rules
and
how they actually apply in this area, or something about what is
expected in pilot logbook entries.
Items that I have done for YEARS of
VERY frequent experience and know them all quite well.
So, you have FAKED experience in all three.
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 54:49:40 |
| Calls: | 1,265 |
| Calls today: | 1 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
3 files (2,684K bytes) |
| Messages: | 285,582 |