I'm a road racing driver and instructor. I've been racing since 2013.
So far, I haven't found a convincing reference that makes that exact identification. I did find some useful sources discussing the
mathematical shape of a racing line, which help distinguish a catenary
from other curves that might look similar.'
On 10/23/26 4:00 PM, Alan wrote:
So far, I haven't found a convincing reference that makes that exact
identification. I did find some useful sources discussing the
mathematical shape of a racing line, which help distinguish a catenary
from other curves that might look similar.'
Just Google "catenary curve in road racing" guys
The Misconception vs. The Reality
In racing, drivers strive to find the line of maximum radius (the
geometric apex) or the line of maximum exit speed (the late apex).
rCo The Misconception: Some automotive enthusiasts use "catenary" to describe a smooth, naturally flowing, variable-radius curve that
transitions seamlessly into and out of a corner.
rCo The Reality: True racing lines do not follow a catenary formula (\(y =
a \cdot \cosh(x/a)\)). Instead, they are composed of clothoids (Euler spirals) for entering and exiting a turn, and circular arcs at the apex.
And this
Why Track Designers Use Spirals (Not Catenaries)
When a race car transitions from a straightaway into a corner, it cannot instantly switch from zero steering angle to a sharp turning angle.
Doing so would upset the chassis and break tire traction.
rCo Linear Steering Input: Designers use clothoid spirals because they mirror human physiology and physics. As a driver turns the steering
wheel at a constant speed while driving forward, the car naturally
traces a clothoid.
rCo Load Transfer: This gradual increase in curvature allows the weight of the vehicle to shift smoothly to the outside tires, maximizing grip.
On 10/23/26 4:00 PM, Alan wrote:
I'm a road racing driver and instructor. I've been racing since 2013.
Alan, you are not currently racing. The last time that you raced with
SCCBC was Sept 14, 2024. I was the only appearance that year. So you
have not been racing, at least via SCCBC (or BHCMR too), for two years.
For quite some while, we've seen that once Arlen/Andy/Wally J/Maria/
(other numerous posting nyms) gets an idea fixed in his/her head, almost
no demonstrations of facts will sway him/her.
For instance!
I'm a road racing driver and instructor. I've been racing since 2013.
But for Arlen (I knew him first by that nym, IIRC) he became convinced
that I couldn't possibly be those things...
...despite lots of conclusive evidence of the fact.
And it boiled down to only a couple of things.
First, I drive a BMW 135i, and Arlen insisted that if I didn't know
which nicknames were used for BMW's cars and motorcyles, then I couldn't possibly be a racing driver. Mar 9, 2023
'If Alan claims to race beemers, he's a moron for not even knowing the
first thing about his fabrications since the term came about in racing circles.
Jesus Christ.
What kind of idiot 'racer' doesn't know that?
Hence, I wish you wouldn't quote that moron Alan Baker, Jolly Roger, but
now that you have, if he doesn't even know the difference between a
bimmer and a beemer, there's zero chance of his track fabrication being true.'
And on December 20, 2023, he brought up the "catenary" curve.:
'That's why I brought up the word "catenary" which _every_ (real) racer
knows all about, as it's one of the most important words in racing
schools.'
And now (of course) he's taken to using AI LLMs to try and "prove" his "facts"...
...so I did the same:
I asked Gemini:
"Can you find any reference online that refers to the shape of the curve
a road racing car takes through a corner as being a catenary curve?"
And the response was:
"No, online references and vehicle dynamics literature do not refer to
the curve a racing car takes through a corner as a catenary curve."
But let's not stop there!
I asked ChatGPT the same question, and it answered:
'I searched for references that explicitly describe a road-racing car's
path through a corner as a catenary curve, rather than merely discussing
the geometry of the racing line.
So far, I haven't found a convincing reference that makes that exact identification. I did find some useful sources discussing the
mathematical shape of a racing line, which help distinguish a catenary
from other curves that might look similar.'
But my laughing at him over this led to him putting me in his kill file!
And after scouring the internet, the only place he could find a
reference to a "catenary" curve in racing...
...was the curve that one programmer chose to use...
...in a simulation...
...of a track for racing model wooden race cars...
...that were about one foot long!
On 10/23/2026 4:00 PM, Alan wrote:
For quite some while, we've seen that once Arlen/Andy/Wally J/Maria/
(other numerous posting nyms) gets an idea fixed in his/her head,
almost no demonstrations of facts will sway him/her.
For instance!
I'm a road racing driver and instructor. I've been racing since 2013.
But for Arlen (I knew him first by that nym, IIRC) he became
convinced that I couldn't possibly be those things...
...despite lots of conclusive evidence of the fact.
And it boiled down to only a couple of things.
First, I drive a BMW 135i, and Arlen insisted that if I didn't know
which nicknames were used for BMW's cars and motorcyles, then I
couldn't possibly be a racing driver. Mar 9, 2023
'If Alan claims to race beemers, he's a moron for not even knowing
the first thing about his fabrications since the term came about in
racing circles.
Jesus Christ.
What kind of idiot 'racer' doesn't know that?
Hence, I wish you wouldn't quote that moron Alan Baker, Jolly Roger,
but now that you have, if he doesn't even know the difference between
a bimmer and a beemer, there's zero chance of his track fabrication
being true.'
And on December 20, 2023, he brought up the "catenary" curve.:
'That's why I brought up the word "catenary" which _every_ (real)
racer knows all about, as it's one of the most important words in
racing schools.'
And now (of course) he's taken to using AI LLMs to try and "prove"
his "facts"...
...so I did the same:
I asked Gemini:
"Can you find any reference online that refers to the shape of the
curve a road racing car takes through a corner as being a catenary
curve?"
And the response was:
"No, online references and vehicle dynamics literature do not refer
to the curve a racing car takes through a corner as a catenary
curve."
But let's not stop there!
I asked ChatGPT the same question, and it answered:
'I searched for references that explicitly describe a road-racing
car's path through a corner as a catenary curve, rather than merely
discussing the geometry of the racing line.
So far, I haven't found a convincing reference that makes that exact
identification. I did find some useful sources discussing the
mathematical shape of a racing line, which help distinguish a
catenary from other curves that might look similar.'
But my laughing at him over this led to him putting me in his kill
file!
And after scouring the internet, the only place he could find a
reference to a "catenary" curve in racing...
...was the curve that one programmer chose to use...
...in a simulation...
...of a track for racing model wooden race cars...
...that were about one foot long!
I believe you. You're the one with standing, integrity. We've had our disagreements, but I haven't sensed dishonesty, from you. These other characters don't hit me the same way.
For quite some while, we've seen that once Arlen/Andy/Wally
J/Maria/(other numerous posting nyms) gets an idea fixed in his/her
head, almost no demonstrations of facts will sway him/her.
For instance!
I'm a road racing driver and instructor. I've been racing since 2013.
On 2026-10-26 04:38, Tom Elam wrote:
On 10/23/26 4:00 PM, Alan wrote:
I'm a road racing driver and instructor. I've been racing since 2013.
Alan, you are not currently racing. The last time that you raced with
SCCBC was Sept 14, 2024. I was the only appearance that year. So you
have not been racing, at least via SCCBC (or BHCMR too), for two years.
I didn't ski last year either...
...doesn't mean I'm not a skier.
On 2026-10-26 08:49, Tom Elam wrote:
On 10/23/26 4:00 PM, Alan wrote:
So far, I haven't found a convincing reference that makes that exact
identification. I did find some useful sources discussing the
mathematical shape of a racing line, which help distinguish a
catenary from other curves that might look similar.'
Just Google "catenary curve in road racing" guys
The Misconception vs. The Reality
In racing, drivers strive to find the line of maximum radius (the
geometric apex) or the line of maximum exit speed (the late apex).
rCo The Misconception: Some automotive enthusiasts use "catenary" to
describe a smooth, naturally flowing, variable-radius curve that
transitions seamlessly into and out of a corner.
rCo The Reality: True racing lines do not follow a catenary formula (\(y
= a \cdot \cosh(x/a)\)). Instead, they are composed of clothoids
(Euler spirals) for entering and exiting a turn, and circular arcs at
the apex.
And this
Why Track Designers Use Spirals (Not Catenaries)
When a race car transitions from a straightaway into a corner, it
cannot instantly switch from zero steering angle to a sharp turning
angle. Doing so would upset the chassis and break tire traction.
rCo Linear Steering Input: Designers use clothoid spirals because they
mirror human physiology and physics. As a driver turns the steering
wheel at a constant speed while driving forward, the car naturally
traces a clothoid.
rCo Load Transfer: This gradual increase in curvature allows the weight
of the vehicle to shift smoothly to the outside tires, maximizing grip.
You should quit while you're behind.
On 10/26/26 2:55 PM, Alan wrote:
On 2026-10-26 04:38, Tom Elam wrote:
On 10/23/26 4:00 PM, Alan wrote:
I'm a road racing driver and instructor. I've been racing since 2013.
Alan, you are not currently racing. The last time that you raced with
SCCBC was Sept 14, 2024. I was the only appearance that year. So you
have not been racing, at least via SCCBC (or BHCMR too), for two years.
I didn't ski last year either...
...doesn't mean I'm not a skier.
That is not the point. You are a race car driver but you have not been racing since 2013. You raced from 2013 to 2014 with at least one year
off. You statement implies you are still active.
This is the strictly truthful standard you apply to others, Fakerboy.
On 10/26/26 2:34 PM, Alan wrote:
On 2026-10-26 08:49, Tom Elam wrote:
On 10/23/26 4:00 PM, Alan wrote:
So far, I haven't found a convincing reference that makes that exact
identification. I did find some useful sources discussing the
mathematical shape of a racing line, which help distinguish a
catenary from other curves that might look similar.'
Just Google "catenary curve in road racing" guys
The Misconception vs. The Reality
In racing, drivers strive to find the line of maximum radius (the
geometric apex) or the line of maximum exit speed (the late apex).
rCo The Misconception: Some automotive enthusiasts use "catenary" to
describe a smooth, naturally flowing, variable-radius curve that
transitions seamlessly into and out of a corner.
rCo The Reality: True racing lines do not follow a catenary formula
(\(y = a \cdot \cosh(x/a)\)). Instead, they are composed of clothoids
(Euler spirals) for entering and exiting a turn, and circular arcs at
the apex.
And this
Why Track Designers Use Spirals (Not Catenaries)
When a race car transitions from a straightaway into a corner, it
cannot instantly switch from zero steering angle to a sharp turning
angle. Doing so would upset the chassis and break tire traction.
rCo Linear Steering Input: Designers use clothoid spirals because they
mirror human physiology and physics. As a driver turns the steering
wheel at a constant speed while driving forward, the car naturally
traces a clothoid.
rCo Load Transfer: This gradual increase in curvature allows the weight >>> of the vehicle to shift smoothly to the outside tires, maximizing grip.
You should quit while you're behind.
Yet another example of Fakerboy acting like his insulting behavior
model, Donald Trump.
So, what exactly is wrong with the statements above that are not mine,
but were found on the web? You will not answer, you will deflect with another insult.
A catenary line implies you would tangentially touch the apex at a
single point halfway through a constant radius curve. That is far from ideal.
The quote below applies to single curves. Chicanes get a lot more complicated depending on how tight they are. Also, curves are not always constant radius.
Reference: Google "clothoid racing line" to find:
quote:
What is a Clothoid Racing Line?
rCo Smooth Transition: Instead of a driver abruptly steering into a sharp, fixed-radius circular arc, a clothoid-based entry and exit smoothly
blend the straightaway into the corner.
rCo Control of Lateral Force: It ramps up lateral (centripetal)
acceleration gradually rather than instantaneously, preventing sudden
tire slip or chassis shock.
rCo Optimization in Path Planning: Autonomous vehicle controllers and automated racing algorithms use clothoid segments or splines to mathematically map the ideal, continuous path between straight and
curved track segments.
Why Not Just Use a Standard Circle?
rCo A True Circle is Suboptimal: A pure circular racing line forces a constant speed or awkward trail-braking transition if you are driving at
the limit.
rCo Jerk and Grip Management: Real-world racing lines use variable-radius approaches (resembling Euler spirals or oval/droop-snoot trajectories)
to delay braking, maximize the apex speed, and get the car pointing
straight toward the exit sooner.
end quote
PS: I learned this years ago racing go karts. The truth is that the
ideal racing line is different for every race course and cannot be a
single simple symmetrical curve for every corner.
On 10/28/26 09:19, Tom Elam wrote:
On 10/26/26 2:55 PM, Alan wrote:
On 2026-10-26 04:38, Tom Elam wrote:
On 10/23/26 4:00 PM, Alan wrote:
I'm a road racing driver and instructor. I've been racing since 2013. >>>>Alan, you are not currently racing. The last time that you raced
with SCCBC was Sept 14, 2024. I was the only appearance that year.
So you have not been racing, at least via SCCBC (or BHCMR too), for
two years.
I didn't ski last year either...
...doesn't mean I'm not a skier.
That is not the point. You are a race car driver but you have not been
racing since 2013. You raced from 2013 to 2014 with at least one year
off. You statement implies you are still active.
So?-a Who's the authority that determines how long of an idle stretch one
is 'allowed' to have, before one changes from current to former?
This is the strictly truthful standard you apply to others, Fakerboy.
So if someone stated this past spring that they were continuing to be vacation traveler, such as intending to go to Nova Scotia in August, but
as of 2-3 months later, there's still no word that they actually did...
...is that long enough to 'prove' that their traveling days are over?
-hh--- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
TE
On 2026-10-28 06:58, Tom Elam wrote:
On 10/26/26 2:34 PM, Alan wrote:
On 2026-10-26 08:49, Tom Elam wrote:
On 10/23/26 4:00 PM, Alan wrote:
So far, I haven't found a convincing reference that makes that
exact identification. I did find some useful sources discussing the >>>>> mathematical shape of a racing line, which help distinguish a
catenary from other curves that might look similar.'
Just Google "catenary curve in road racing" guys
The Misconception vs. The Reality
In racing, drivers strive to find the line of maximum radius (the
geometric apex) or the line of maximum exit speed (the late apex).
rCo The Misconception: Some automotive enthusiasts use "catenary" to
describe a smooth, naturally flowing, variable-radius curve that
transitions seamlessly into and out of a corner.
rCo The Reality: True racing lines do not follow a catenary formula
(\(y = a \cdot \cosh(x/a)\)). Instead, they are composed of
clothoids (Euler spirals) for entering and exiting a turn, and
circular arcs at the apex.
And this
Why Track Designers Use Spirals (Not Catenaries)
When a race car transitions from a straightaway into a corner, it
cannot instantly switch from zero steering angle to a sharp turning
angle. Doing so would upset the chassis and break tire traction.
rCo Linear Steering Input: Designers use clothoid spirals because they >>>> mirror human physiology and physics. As a driver turns the steering
wheel at a constant speed while driving forward, the car naturally
traces a clothoid.
rCo Load Transfer: This gradual increase in curvature allows the
weight of the vehicle to shift smoothly to the outside tires,
maximizing grip.
You should quit while you're behind.
Yet another example of Fakerboy acting like his insulting behavior
model, Donald Trump.
So, what exactly is wrong with the statements above that are not mine,
but were found on the web? You will not answer, you will deflect with
another insult.
A catenary line implies you would tangentially touch the apex at a
single point halfway through a constant radius curve. That is far from
ideal.
The quote below applies to single curves. Chicanes get a lot more
complicated depending on how tight they are. Also, curves are not
always constant radius.
Reference: Google "clothoid racing line" to find:
quote:
What is a Clothoid Racing Line?
rCo Smooth Transition: Instead of a driver abruptly steering into a
sharp, fixed-radius circular arc, a clothoid-based entry and exit
smoothly blend the straightaway into the corner.
rCo Control of Lateral Force: It ramps up lateral (centripetal)
acceleration gradually rather than instantaneously, preventing sudden
tire slip or chassis shock.
rCo Optimization in Path Planning: Autonomous vehicle controllers and
automated racing algorithms use clothoid segments or splines to
mathematically map the ideal, continuous path between straight and
curved track segments.
Why Not Just Use a Standard Circle?
rCo A True Circle is Suboptimal: A pure circular racing line forces a
constant speed or awkward trail-braking transition if you are driving
at the limit.
rCo Jerk and Grip Management: Real-world racing lines use variable-
radius approaches (resembling Euler spirals or oval/droop-snoot
trajectories) to delay braking, maximize the apex speed, and get the
car pointing straight toward the exit sooner.
end quote
PS: I learned this years ago racing go karts. The truth is that the
ideal racing line is different for every race course and cannot be a
single simple symmetrical curve for every corner.
Your "analysis" is as shallow as the argument you made when you first declared that Honda-powered Formula F cars weren't legal at Mission.
On 10/28/26 2:57 PM, Alan wrote:Only after arguing it ENDLESSLY.
On 2026-10-28 06:58, Tom Elam wrote:
On 10/26/26 2:34 PM, Alan wrote:
On 2026-10-26 08:49, Tom Elam wrote:
On 10/23/26 4:00 PM, Alan wrote:
So far, I haven't found a convincing reference that makes that
exact identification. I did find some useful sources discussing
the mathematical shape of a racing line, which help distinguish a >>>>>> catenary from other curves that might look similar.'
Just Google "catenary curve in road racing" guys
The Misconception vs. The Reality
In racing, drivers strive to find the line of maximum radius (the
geometric apex) or the line of maximum exit speed (the late apex).
rCo The Misconception: Some automotive enthusiasts use "catenary" to >>>>> describe a smooth, naturally flowing, variable-radius curve that
transitions seamlessly into and out of a corner.
rCo The Reality: True racing lines do not follow a catenary formula >>>>> (\(y = a \cdot \cosh(x/a)\)). Instead, they are composed of
clothoids (Euler spirals) for entering and exiting a turn, and
circular arcs at the apex.
And this
Why Track Designers Use Spirals (Not Catenaries)
When a race car transitions from a straightaway into a corner, it
cannot instantly switch from zero steering angle to a sharp turning >>>>> angle. Doing so would upset the chassis and break tire traction.
rCo Linear Steering Input: Designers use clothoid spirals because
they mirror human physiology and physics. As a driver turns the
steering wheel at a constant speed while driving forward, the car
naturally traces a clothoid.
rCo Load Transfer: This gradual increase in curvature allows the
weight of the vehicle to shift smoothly to the outside tires,
maximizing grip.
You should quit while you're behind.
Yet another example of Fakerboy acting like his insulting behavior
model, Donald Trump.
So, what exactly is wrong with the statements above that are not
mine, but were found on the web? You will not answer, you will
deflect with another insult.
A catenary line implies you would tangentially touch the apex at a
single point halfway through a constant radius curve. That is far
from ideal.
The quote below applies to single curves. Chicanes get a lot more
complicated depending on how tight they are. Also, curves are not
always constant radius.
Reference: Google "clothoid racing line" to find:
quote:
What is a Clothoid Racing Line?
rCo Smooth Transition: Instead of a driver abruptly steering into a
sharp, fixed-radius circular arc, a clothoid-based entry and exit
smoothly blend the straightaway into the corner.
rCo Control of Lateral Force: It ramps up lateral (centripetal)
acceleration gradually rather than instantaneously, preventing sudden
tire slip or chassis shock.
rCo Optimization in Path Planning: Autonomous vehicle controllers and
automated racing algorithms use clothoid segments or splines to
mathematically map the ideal, continuous path between straight and
curved track segments.
Why Not Just Use a Standard Circle?
rCo A True Circle is Suboptimal: A pure circular racing line forces a
constant speed or awkward trail-braking transition if you are driving
at the limit.
rCo Jerk and Grip Management: Real-world racing lines use variable-
radius approaches (resembling Euler spirals or oval/droop-snoot
trajectories) to delay braking, maximize the apex speed, and get the
car pointing straight toward the exit sooner.
end quote
PS: I learned this years ago racing go karts. The truth is that the
ideal racing line is different for every race course and cannot be a
single simple symmetrical curve for every corner.
Your "analysis" is as shallow as the argument you made when you first
declared that Honda-powered Formula F cars weren't legal at Mission.
Total BS. Just another Trump-like knee-jerk response.
I learned racing lines following faster go kart drivers many years ago.
The above makes total sense to me. If you disagree feel free to share
your knowledge. Until then shut up.
You corrected me on the local rules and I accepted and respected your
reply.
You corrected me on the local rules and I accepted and respected yourOnly after arguing it ENDLESSLY.
reply.
I'll tell you one little thing:
The line IN to the middle of a corner...
...from braking to speed necessary to simply negotiate it...
...forms a parabola...
...for any corner up to 90 degrees.
On 10/28/26 11:37 AM, -hh wrote:
On 10/28/26 09:19, Tom Elam wrote:
On 10/26/26 2:55 PM, Alan wrote:
On 2026-10-26 04:38, Tom Elam wrote:
On 10/23/26 4:00 PM, Alan wrote:
I'm a road racing driver and instructor. I've been racing since 2013. >>>>>Alan, you are not currently racing. The last time that you raced
with SCCBC was Sept 14, 2024. I was the only appearance that year.
So you have not been racing, at least via SCCBC (or BHCMR too), for >>>>> two years.
I didn't ski last year either...
...doesn't mean I'm not a skier.
That is not the point. You are a race car driver but you have not
been racing since 2013. You raced from 2013 to 2014 with at least one
year off. You statement implies you are still active.
So?-a Who's the authority that determines how long of an idle stretch
one is 'allowed' to have, before one changes from current to former?
I think 2 years off qualifies as having been away long enough. My bad - 2013-2024.>
This is the strictly truthful standard you apply to others, Fakerboy.
So if someone stated this past spring that they were continuing to be
vacation traveler, such as intending to go to Nova Scotia in August,
but as of 2-3 months later, there's still no word that they actually
did...
...is that long enough to 'prove' that their traveling days are over?
Hint: 2 months versus 2 years is a difference.
I CAN say that as of today I have been flying aircraft since 2/11/1967.
Flew on that date and have logged 92.1 hours this year. That includes
1.7 hours today. And, I have no plans to stop in the near future.
If want to get hyper-critical I took 1975-78 off due to lack of
affordable aircraft access and finances.
Nor do we plan to stop being travelers. France this year, Portugal and
Spain trip deposit checks sent last week. We are slowing down, but not stopping.
Reservations made and passes bought for skiing next March. I'll also be going to Perfect North again in January So I am also-aa skier, and have
been for over 40 years now.
On 10/28/26 5:43 PM, Alan wrote:
You corrected me on the local rules and I accepted and respected yourOnly after arguing it ENDLESSLY.
reply.
I'll tell you one little thing:
The line IN to the middle of a corner...
...from braking to speed necessary to simply negotiate it...
...forms a parabola...
...for any corner up to 90 degrees.
NO! It's a lot mope complicated. Google "is a parabola always fastest
racing line" please. But you won't, so I will save you the trouble:
Quote:
No, a parabola is not always the fastest racing line.
While a symmetric parabolic line (often associated with trail braking
into a pinched corner and an early throttle-out) works well for certain isolated or specific turn types, the absolute fastest racing line
depends heavily on the context of the track.
Why a Parabola Isn't Always Fastest
rCo Corner Isolation vs. Sequences: A geometric or parabolic line assumes
a corner exists in complete isolation. On a real track, corners connect
to other corners, hairpins, or straights, meaning you must compromise
entry or mid-corner speed to maximize acceleration onto the most
important or longest straight.
rCo Car Performance and Power: For low-power cars, prioritizing a late
apex to get on the throttle earlier outweighs maintaining a smooth
parabolic mid-corner speed. For high-power or heavy cars, the physics of weight transfer and tire grip change the ideal curve.
rCo Alternative Mathematical Curves: True mathematical optimizations for race tracks frequently use Euler spirals (clothoids) or compound curves rather than a simple parabola to transition smoothly between straight-
line braking, steady turning radius, and full-throttle exit.
rCo Defensive Driving and Traffic: Real-world racing requires adjusting lines to block competitors, avoid marbles/debris off-line, or manage wet weather grip, overriding pure theoretical geometry.
End quote
Hmmmm
Maybe your mistaken belief in parabolic racing lines helps explain how McKay, McColl and Floer beat you so often.
On 10/28/26 17:32, Tom Elam wrote:
On 10/28/26 11:37 AM, -hh wrote:
On 10/28/26 09:19, Tom Elam wrote:
On 10/26/26 2:55 PM, Alan wrote:
On 2026-10-26 04:38, Tom Elam wrote:
On 10/23/26 4:00 PM, Alan wrote:
I'm a road racing driver and instructor. I've been racing since >>>>>>> 2013.
Alan, you are not currently racing. The last time that you raced
with SCCBC was Sept 14, 2024. I was the only appearance that year. >>>>>> So you have not been racing, at least via SCCBC (or BHCMR too),
for two years.
I didn't ski last year either...
...doesn't mean I'm not a skier.
That is not the point. You are a race car driver but you have not
been racing since 2013. You raced from 2013 to 2014 with at least
one year off. You statement implies you are still active.
So?-a Who's the authority that determines how long of an idle stretch
one is 'allowed' to have, before one changes from current to former?
I think 2 years off qualifies as having been away long enough. My bad
- 2013-2024.>
So?-a What makes you an _authority_ on it?
This is the strictly truthful standard you apply to others, Fakerboy.
So if someone stated this past spring that they were continuing to be
vacation traveler, such as intending to go to Nova Scotia in August,
but as of 2-3 months later, there's still no word that they actually
did...
...is that long enough to 'prove' that their traveling days are over?
Hint: 2 months versus 2 years is a difference.
It not two months, but cancelled plans due two months ago.-a Its already been a half year since your last jaunt & counting.
I CAN say that as of today I have been flying aircraft since
2/11/1967. Flew on that date and have logged 92.1 hours this year.
That includes 1.7 hours today. And, I have no plans to stop in the
near future.
If want to get hyper-critical I took 1975-78 off due to lack of
affordable aircraft access and finances.
And yet when you took 3 years off, it didn't count as "quitting".
Nor do we plan to stop being travelers. France this year, Portugal and
Spain trip deposit checks sent last week. We are slowing down, but not
stopping.
As I had warned years ago, your opportunity window for international air travel had been closing down on you.-a I do recall that in response, you
did successfully ramp up some .. but your "high water mark" was less
than ~$30K back in 2024 (excluding domestics), to which this year's
single trip to Bordeaux was already a 1/3 to 1/2 as much.
Reservations made and passes bought for skiing next March. I'll also
be going to Perfect North again in January So I am also-aa skier, and
have been for over 40 years now.
Which isn't international or air travel to be relevant.-a And that's even before noting that the number of days for Vail's Epic Pass to pay for
itself vs daily lift tickets is now down to less than four (4) days, so buying season passes isn't a big lift.
-hh
On 10/28/26 5:43 PM, Alan wrote:
You corrected me on the local rules and I accepted and respected yourOnly after arguing it ENDLESSLY.
reply.
I'll tell you one little thing:
The line IN to the middle of a corner...
...from braking to speed necessary to simply negotiate it...
...forms a parabola...
...for any corner up to 90 degrees.
NO! It's a lot mope complicated. Google "is a parabola always fastest
racing line" please. But you won't, so I will save you the trouble:
Quote:
No, a parabola is not always the fastest racing line.
While a symmetric parabolic line (often associated with trail braking
into a pinched corner and an early throttle-out) works well for certain isolated or specific turn types, the absolute fastest racing line
depends heavily on the context of the track.
Why a Parabola Isn't Always Fastest
rCo Corner Isolation vs. Sequences: A geometric or parabolic line assumes
a corner exists in complete isolation. On a real track, corners connect
to other corners, hairpins, or straights, meaning you must compromise
entry or mid-corner speed to maximize acceleration onto the most
important or longest straight.
rCo Car Performance and Power: For low-power cars, prioritizing a late
apex to get on the throttle earlier outweighs maintaining a smooth
parabolic mid-corner speed. For high-power or heavy cars, the physics of weight transfer and tire grip change the ideal curve.
rCo Alternative Mathematical Curves: True mathematical optimizations for race tracks frequently use Euler spirals (clothoids) or compound curves rather than a simple parabola to transition smoothly between straight-
line braking, steady turning radius, and full-throttle exit.
rCo Defensive Driving and Traffic: Real-world racing requires adjusting lines to block competitors, avoid marbles/debris off-line, or manage wet weather grip, overriding pure theoretical geometry.
End quote
Hmmmm
Maybe your mistaken belief in parabolic racing lines helps explain how McKay, McColl and Floer beat you so often.
On 2026-10-29 04:46, Tom Elam wrote:
On 10/28/26 5:43 PM, Alan wrote:
You corrected me on the local rules and I accepted and respectedOnly after arguing it ENDLESSLY.
your reply.
I'll tell you one little thing:
The line IN to the middle of a corner...
...from braking to speed necessary to simply negotiate it...
...forms a parabola...
...for any corner up to 90 degrees.
NO! It's a lot mope complicated. Google "is a parabola always fastest
racing line" please. But you won't, so I will save you the trouble:
1. So you think AI is right.
As I said: you should quite when you're behind.
Quote:
No, a parabola is not always the fastest racing line.
While a symmetric parabolic line (often associated with trail braking
into a pinched corner and an early throttle-out) works well for
certain isolated or specific turn types, the absolute fastest racing
line depends heavily on the context of the track.
Ummmm....nope.
Why a Parabola Isn't Always Fastest
rCo Corner Isolation vs. Sequences: A geometric or parabolic line
assumes a corner exists in complete isolation. On a real track,
corners connect to other corners, hairpins, or straights, meaning you
must compromise entry or mid-corner speed to maximize acceleration
onto the most important or longest straight.
Whether or not you need to compromise entry changes many things, but for
the braking phase of a corner, the object is to change the vector of the car's velocity in the most efficient way possible.
rCo Car Performance and Power: For low-power cars, prioritizing a late
apex to get on the throttle earlier outweighs maintaining a smooth
parabolic mid-corner speed. For high-power or heavy cars, the physics
of weight transfer and tire grip change the ideal curve.
Not during the braking phase.
It changes what the precise VALUES are, but the shape is still parabolic.
rCo Alternative Mathematical Curves: True mathematical optimizations for
race tracks frequently use Euler spirals (clothoids) or compound
curves rather than a simple parabola to transition smoothly between
straight- line braking, steady turning radius, and full-throttle exit.
And that's going back to what was already wrong.
rCo Defensive Driving and Traffic: Real-world racing requires adjusting
lines to block competitors, avoid marbles/debris off-line, or manage
wet weather grip, overriding pure theoretical geometry.
And that's outside the scope of the discussion.
End quote
Hmmmm
Maybe your mistaken belief in parabolic racing lines helps explain how
McKay, McColl and Floer beat you so often.
LOL!
The line IN to the middle of a corner...
...from braking to speed necessary to simply negotiate it...
...forms a parabola...
...for any corner up to 90 degrees.
On 10/29/26 1:35 PM, Alan wrote:
On 2026-10-29 04:46, Tom Elam wrote:
On 10/28/26 5:43 PM, Alan wrote:
You corrected me on the local rules and I accepted and respectedOnly after arguing it ENDLESSLY.
your reply.
I'll tell you one little thing:
The line IN to the middle of a corner...
...from braking to speed necessary to simply negotiate it...
...forms a parabola...
...for any corner up to 90 degrees.
NO! It's a lot mope complicated. Google "is a parabola always fastest
racing line" please. But you won't, so I will save you the trouble:
1. So you think AI is right.
As I said: you should quite when you're behind.
Quote:
No, a parabola is not always the fastest racing line.
While a symmetric parabolic line (often associated with trail braking
into a pinched corner and an early throttle-out) works well for
certain isolated or specific turn types, the absolute fastest racing
line depends heavily on the context of the track.
Ummmm....nope.
Why a Parabola Isn't Always Fastest
rCo Corner Isolation vs. Sequences: A geometric or parabolic line
assumes a corner exists in complete isolation. On a real track,
corners connect to other corners, hairpins, or straights, meaning you
must compromise entry or mid-corner speed to maximize acceleration
onto the most important or longest straight.
Whether or not you need to compromise entry changes many things, but
for the braking phase of a corner, the object is to change the vector
of the car's velocity in the most efficient way possible.
rCo Car Performance and Power: For low-power cars, prioritizing a late
apex to get on the throttle earlier outweighs maintaining a smooth
parabolic mid-corner speed. For high-power or heavy cars, the physics
of weight transfer and tire grip change the ideal curve.
Not during the braking phase.
It changes what the precise VALUES are, but the shape is still parabolic.
rCo Alternative Mathematical Curves: True mathematical optimizations
for race tracks frequently use Euler spirals (clothoids) or compound
curves rather than a simple parabola to transition smoothly between
straight- line braking, steady turning radius, and full-throttle exit.
And that's going back to what was already wrong.
rCo Defensive Driving and Traffic: Real-world racing requires adjusting >>> lines to block competitors, avoid marbles/debris off-line, or manage
wet weather grip, overriding pure theoretical geometry.
And that's outside the scope of the discussion.
OMG Fakerboy. We are talking about the racing line, not the practice or qualifying line.
End quote
Hmmmm
Maybe your mistaken belief in parabolic racing lines helps explain
how McKay, McColl and Floer beat you so often.
LOL!
Quoting you:
The line IN to the middle of a corner...
...from braking to speed necessary to simply negotiate it...
...forms a parabola...
...for any corner up to 90 degrees.
End quote.
A parabola is a functional form for a line that can be precisely
graphed. No race car driver EVER drove a precise parabola. In Geometry 1
I learned a line has length and 0 width. That's right, 0, not an atom,
not an electron, 0. A parabola is a theoretical geometric construct that
can be approximated in the real world. As is a circle, a square, a
hexagon, etc.
A parabolic-like SHAPE may be correct in some special cases. For
example, your restriction to less than 90 degrees as a special case.
Even then real world differences in the car and the track (especially if curves involve elevation and banking changes) will dictate other racing lines.
So do you contend that a parabolic shape is the best racing line in all situations for all track curves? if so, prove me wrong.
On 10/29/26 7:50 AM, -hh wrote:
On 10/28/26 17:32, Tom Elam wrote:
On 10/28/26 11:37 AM, -hh wrote:
On 10/28/26 09:19, Tom Elam wrote:
On 10/26/26 2:55 PM, Alan wrote:
On 2026-10-26 04:38, Tom Elam wrote:
On 10/23/26 4:00 PM, Alan wrote:
I'm a road racing driver and instructor. I've been racing since >>>>>>>> 2013.
Alan, you are not currently racing. The last time that you raced >>>>>>> with SCCBC was Sept 14, 2024. I was the only appearance that
year. So you have not been racing, at least via SCCBC (or BHCMR >>>>>>> too), for two years.
I didn't ski last year either...
...doesn't mean I'm not a skier.
That is not the point. You are a race car driver but you have not
been racing since 2013. You raced from 2013 to 2014 with at least
one year off. You statement implies you are still active.
So?-a Who's the authority that determines how long of an idle stretch >>>> one is 'allowed' to have, before one changes from current to former?
I think 2 years off qualifies as having been away long enough. My bad
- 2013-2024.>
So?-a What makes you an _authority_ on it?
Does 2-3 weeks make you an authority?
This is the strictly truthful standard you apply to others, Fakerboy. >>>>
So if someone stated this past spring that they were continuing to
be vacation traveler, such as intending to go to Nova Scotia in
August, but as of 2-3 months later, there's still no word that they
actually did...
...is that long enough to 'prove' that their traveling days are over?
Hint: 2 months versus 2 years is a difference.
It not two months, but cancelled plans due two months ago.-a Its
already been a half year since your last jaunt & counting.
I CAN say that as of today I have been flying aircraft since
2/11/1967. Flew on that date and have logged 92.1 hours this year.
That includes 1.7 hours today. And, I have no plans to stop in the
near future.
If want to get hyper-critical I took 1975-78 off due to lack of
affordable aircraft access and finances.
And yet when you took 3 years off, it didn't count as "quitting".
If 3 years time off is quitting in your mind, OK.
Your buddy Fakerboy has not raced in the last 2 seasons, and 3 seasons
ago, 2024, entered just one weekend and wrecked in the Saturday session.
The year before that, 2023, he did not enter a single race. One race
started in 4 years. I think it is fair to say Alan is, at this time, not
a racer car driver. The true statement is "I was a race car driver from
2013 to 2024" not "I've been racing since 2013."
Nor do we plan to stop being travelers. France this year, Portugal
and Spain trip deposit checks sent last week. We are slowing down,
but not stopping.
As I had warned years ago, your opportunity window for international
air travel had been closing down on you.-a I do recall that in
response, you did successfully ramp up some .. but your "high water
mark" was less than ~$30K back in 2024 (excluding domestics), to which
this year's single trip to Bordeaux was already a 1/3 to 1/2 as much.
Yes you did, and you assumed I did not know that.
The opportunity is
still there. We are in good health and have plenty of money.
Reservations made and passes bought for skiing next March. I'll also
be going to Perfect North again in January So I am also-aa skier, and
have been for over 40 years now.
Which isn't international or air travel to be relevant.-a And that's
even before noting that the number of days for Vail's Epic Pass to pay
for itself vs daily lift tickets is now down to less than four (4)
days, so buying season passes isn't a big lift.
I did not say it was international.
The passes matter as that is a
commitment of sorts. A single day pass this winter is going to be more
like $300. I paid $869 for the Local Pass. It's 3 days, not 4. The
single day passes are priced so as to make it almost obligatory to buy
the season pass. Vail and Alterra are both being sued for that pricing strategy. Several lawsuits in fact. Some from skiers and some from shareholders. Google it.
Oh, I'm tangentially familiar with the saga, as I have a colleague who I used to ski with who's been buying the Epic Pass now for years.-a For break-even, I Googled for the MSRP's & divided:-a $1169/$335 = 3.5 days. FYI, your $869 is the Epic Local, not the full unrestricted Epic.
So do you contend that a parabolic shape is the best racing line in
all situations for all track curves? if so, prove me wrong.
You just two posts ago claimed the clothoid was the "best racing line" without caveats...
On 10/29/26 4:38 PM, -hh wrote:
Oh, I'm tangentially familiar with the saga, as I have a colleague who
I used to ski with who's been buying the Epic Pass now for years.-a For
break-even, I Googled for the MSRP's & divided:-a $1169/$335 = 3.5
days. FYI, your $869 is the Epic Local, not the full unrestricted Epic.
Ignoring all the nonsense replies above except for:
1979-today, zero year-long flying breaks. I suppose you that you think
since I did not fly an airplane yesterday (instead we did a trip to eat
at Indiana's oldest restaurant) I took a break from flying.
At one time we thought nothing of taking off for 2 weeks in the British Isles with only a car hire set up ahead of time. Not even a 1st night
hotel. That was a blast, done it several times. Easy now with the
internet. Would do it again! Stayed in some amazing places, and a few
not so great.
But these package trips are with friends along and that
has so very real advantages.
Our travels have not been limited by finances, rather how much we
want to do.
We were just starting to think about doing 2 weeks in Paris next
spring, but let's wait and see given the state of unrest before
committing.
That would cost about a month's dividend income after all.
On 10/29/26 2:40 PM, Alan wrote:
So do you contend that a parabolic shape is the best racing line in
all situations for all track curves? if so, prove me wrong.
You just two posts ago claimed the clothoid was the "best racing line"
without caveats...
Oh my, another Fakerboy deflection! What are the chances? 99.999%!
A parabolic line is a subset of a clothoid with a unique set of coefficients. Anyway, see the proof of your error below.
Here is a non-AI explanation of why a parabolic shape racing line
touching the apex at 45 degrees into a 90 degree turn is often not the
ideal racing line, and a later apex is.
https://www.drivingfast.net/racing-line/
Quote:
Common mistake:
It's very common for drivers to apex too early due to nerves about the approaching corner and eagerness to take the turn. The racing line apex which is often out of view at the point of turn in, or further round the corner than you expect (see Diagram 3 below). This is where experience
and track knowledge come in.
End Quote
I'm thinking that you simply lacked the nerve to follow the fastest
racing line. What the heck did they teach you at that fancy racing school?
Your shocking lack of basic racing techniques makes me more certain than ever that you could never be considered an exceptional driver in the
SCCBC world.
On 2026-10-29 04:46, Tom Elam wrote:
On 10/28/26 5:43 PM, Alan wrote:
You corrected me on the local rules and I accepted and respectedOnly after arguing it ENDLESSLY.
your reply.
I'll tell you one little thing:
The line IN to the middle of a corner...
...from braking to speed necessary to simply negotiate it...
...forms a parabola...
...for any corner up to 90 degrees.
NO! It's a lot mope complicated. Google "is a parabola always fastest
racing line" please. But you won't, so I will save you the trouble:
Quote:
No, a parabola is not always the fastest racing line.
While a symmetric parabolic line (often associated with trail braking
into a pinched corner and an early throttle-out) works well for
certain isolated or specific turn types, the absolute fastest racing
line depends heavily on the context of the track.
Why a Parabola Isn't Always Fastest
rCo Corner Isolation vs. Sequences: A geometric or parabolic line
assumes a corner exists in complete isolation. On a real track,
corners connect to other corners, hairpins, or straights, meaning you
must compromise entry or mid-corner speed to maximize acceleration
onto the most important or longest straight.
rCo Car Performance and Power: For low-power cars, prioritizing a late
apex to get on the throttle earlier outweighs maintaining a smooth
parabolic mid-corner speed. For high-power or heavy cars, the physics
of weight transfer and tire grip change the ideal curve.
rCo Alternative Mathematical Curves: True mathematical optimizations for
race tracks frequently use Euler spirals (clothoids) or compound
curves rather than a simple parabola to transition smoothly between
straight- line braking, steady turning radius, and full-throttle exit.
rCo Defensive Driving and Traffic: Real-world racing requires adjusting
lines to block competitors, avoid marbles/debris off-line, or manage
wet weather grip, overriding pure theoretical geometry.
End quote
Hmmmm
Maybe your mistaken belief in parabolic racing lines helps explain how
McKay, McColl and Floer beat you so often.
BTW.
Isn't it interesting how you never mentioned any situational differences when you were declaring what you ignorantly thought was the ideal line?
:-)
The parabolic line only represents the shape from corner entry to the
car's slowest speed (and tightest radius).
On 10/30/26 1:24 PM, Alan wrote:
The parabolic line only represents the shape from corner entry to the
car's slowest speed (and tightest radius).
But you originally said "parabola". It is not, and now just just contradicted yourself and changed your statement from "parabola" to "parabolic line".
Quote:
I'll tell you one little thing:
The line IN to the middle of a corner...
...from braking to speed necessary to simply negotiate it...
...forms a parabola...
End Quote
From Wikipedia
The parabola is a member of the family of conic sections.
In mathematics, a parabola (/p+O-er|ab+Ol+O/ p+O-RA-b+O-l+O) is a plane curve
which is mirror-symmetrical and is approximately U-shaped. It fits
several superficially different mathematical descriptions, which can all
be proved to define exactly the same curves.
End quote
What you are now saying is correct does not fit this definition. Among
other details, a parabola will always reverse direction at 90 degrees at
the vertex. That would be halfway through a 90 degree turn.
See first graph at: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parabola
If your apex is past the vertex the path is is non-symmetrical and not a even a parabolic line. Guess what it really is?
Nope. There is no connection at all between where the parabolic portion
of the racing line happens with the corner's geometry. The line gets to
the vertex of the parabola BEFORE the car gets all the way into the
apex, and then the shape of the curve is more complex.
On 10/30/26 2:57 PM, Alan wrote:
Nope. There is no connection at all between where the parabolic
portion of the racing line happens with the corner's geometry. The
line gets to the vertex of the parabola BEFORE the car gets all the
way into the apex, and then the shape of the curve is more complex.
LOL!, now revealed as a Faker you backtrack, qualify, and deflect from
your error! So the "parabola? is now a small part of a much more
complicated geometric path? LOL!!!!!
Did you actually take a geometry course in high school or your year at university? Or are just faking knowing anything at all about the
geometry of auto racing and course design?
On 2026-10-31 18:18, Tom Elam wrote:
On 10/30/26 2:57 PM, Alan wrote:
Nope. There is no connection at all between where the parabolic
portion of the racing line happens with the corner's geometry. The
line gets to the vertex of the parabola BEFORE the car gets all the
way into the apex, and then the shape of the curve is more complex.
LOL!, now revealed as a Faker you backtrack, qualify, and deflect from
your error! So the "parabola? is now a small part of a much more
complicated geometric path? LOL!!!!!
I always said it was only part of the path, Liarboy.
That was clear from my initial statement:
"The line IN to the middle of a corner"
That clearly means there is another part of the path.
Did you actually take a geometry course in high school or your year at
university? Or are just faking knowing anything at all about the
geometry of auto racing and course design?
Let's try a little "socratic method", shall we, Liarboy?
Do you know what the "friction circle" concept means in relation to
motor racing?
If so, please describe it.
Try not to just quote the results of an AI search.
On 10/31/26 11:14 PM, Alan wrote:
On 2026-10-31 18:18, Tom Elam wrote:
On 10/30/26 2:57 PM, Alan wrote:
Nope. There is no connection at all between where the parabolic
portion of the racing line happens with the corner's geometry. The
line gets to the vertex of the parabola BEFORE the car gets all the
way into the apex, and then the shape of the curve is more complex.
LOL!, now revealed as a Faker you backtrack, qualify, and deflect
from your error! So the "parabola? is now a small part of a much more
complicated geometric path? LOL!!!!!
I always said it was only part of the path, Liarboy.
That was clear from my initial statement:
"The line IN to the middle of a corner"
That clearly means there is another part of the path.
Did you actually take a geometry course in high school or your year
at university? Or are just faking knowing anything at all about the
geometry of auto racing and course design?
Let's try a little "socratic method", shall we, Liarboy?
Do you know what the "friction circle" concept means in relation to
motor racing?
If so, please describe it.
Try not to just quote the results of an AI search.
Did not know the term but it's basically the split of total traction
between lateral and acceleration/deceleration forces. Simple physics and
a little trig to illustrate.
A (not-AI) video that shows these basics in action in a car.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YzmHrklDG2Q
and followup
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cJ3LD6ujFfI
Explains why even a slight mistake can spin you in a turn.
I suppose you will call these videos crap too.
On 10/31/26 11:14 PM, Alan wrote:
On 2026-10-31 18:18, Tom Elam wrote:
On 10/30/26 2:57 PM, Alan wrote:
Nope. There is no connection at all between where the parabolic
portion of the racing line happens with the corner's geometry. The
line gets to the vertex of the parabola BEFORE the car gets all the
way into the apex, and then the shape of the curve is more complex.
LOL!, now revealed as a Faker you backtrack, qualify, and deflect
from your error! So the "parabola? is now a small part of a much more
complicated geometric path? LOL!!!!!
I always said it was only part of the path, Liarboy.
That was clear from my initial statement:
"The line IN to the middle of a corner"
That clearly means there is another part of the path.
Did you actually take a geometry course in high school or your year
at university? Or are just faking knowing anything at all about the
geometry of auto racing and course design?
Let's try a little "socratic method", shall we, Liarboy?
Do you know what the "friction circle" concept means in relation to
motor racing?
If so, please describe it.
Try not to just quote the results of an AI search.
Did not know the term but it's basically the split of total traction
between lateral and acceleration/deceleration forces. Simple physics and
a little trig to illustrate.
A (not-AI) video that shows these basics in action in a car.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YzmHrklDG2Q
and followup
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cJ3LD6ujFfI
Explains why even a slight mistake can spin you in a turn.
I suppose you will call these videos crap too.
On 2026-11-03 06:04, Tom Elam wrote:
On 10/31/26 11:14 PM, Alan wrote:
On 2026-10-31 18:18, Tom Elam wrote:
On 10/30/26 2:57 PM, Alan wrote:
Nope. There is no connection at all between where the parabolic
portion of the racing line happens with the corner's geometry. The
line gets to the vertex of the parabola BEFORE the car gets all the >>>>> way into the apex, and then the shape of the curve is more complex.
LOL!, now revealed as a Faker you backtrack, qualify, and deflect
from your error! So the "parabola? is now a small part of a much
more complicated geometric path? LOL!!!!!
I always said it was only part of the path, Liarboy.
That was clear from my initial statement:
"The line IN to the middle of a corner"
That clearly means there is another part of the path.
Did you actually take a geometry course in high school or your year
at university? Or are just faking knowing anything at all about the
geometry of auto racing and course design?
Let's try a little "socratic method", shall we, Liarboy?
Do you know what the "friction circle" concept means in relation to
motor racing?
If so, please describe it.
Try not to just quote the results of an AI search.
Did not know the term but it's basically the split of total traction
between lateral and acceleration/deceleration forces. Simple physics
and a little trig to illustrate.
A (not-AI) video that shows these basics in action in a car.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YzmHrklDG2Q
and followup
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cJ3LD6ujFfI
Explains why even a slight mistake can spin you in a turn.
I suppose you will call these videos crap too.
I get it more and more about you, Liarboy!
It never even occurs to you that other people might actually know MORE
about a subject than you do.
When we started talking racing, you spoke with such confidence about
what was legal and illegal in SCCBC racing...
...never once thinking that someone who ACTUALLY races with the SCCBC
might know more.
And that pattern repeats over and over.
You've now found a few rudimentary web pages and videos on racing, and
you can't imagine that I haven't seen all of them (or ones very like
them) many times over.
Let's try a little "socratic method", shall we, Liarboy?
Do you know what the "friction circle" concept means in relation to
motor racing?
If so, please describe it.
Try not to just quote the results of an AI search.
Did not know the term but it's basically the split of total traction
between lateral and acceleration/deceleration forces. Simple physics and
a little trig to illustrate.
A (not-AI) video that shows these basics in action in a car.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YzmHrklDG2Q
and followup
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cJ3LD6ujFfI
Explains why even a slight mistake can spin you in a turn.
I suppose you will call these videos crap too.
Note this was marked as off topic, so don't whine if you don't like it.
On 2026-11-03 06:04, Tom Elam wrote:
Let's try a little "socratic method", shall we, Liarboy?
Do you know what the "friction circle" concept means in relation to
motor racing?
If so, please describe it.
Try not to just quote the results of an AI search.
Did not know the term but it's basically the split of total traction
between lateral and acceleration/deceleration forces. Simple physics
and a little trig to illustrate.
A (not-AI) video that shows these basics in action in a car.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YzmHrklDG2Q
and followup
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cJ3LD6ujFfI
Explains why even a slight mistake can spin you in a turn.
I suppose you will call these videos crap too.
So I happened upon the exact right way to ask the question:
'If you postulated a vehicle which can accelerate at exactly the same
rate in any direction (a pure rCLfriction circlerCY), when you want to change that vehiclerCOs velocity from one vector to another, always using the vehiclerCOs acceleration to the maximum, is the path the vehicle moves along always a parabola?'
And I received the answer:
'Yes. Assuming a time-optimal transition where the vehicle utilizes its maximum isotropic acceleration continuously to change its velocity
vector from v1 to v2, the resulting spatial trajectory is always a
parabola (or a straight line as a degenerate case).
The mechanics and optimal control proof demonstrate why this holds true:
1. The Optimal Control Principle
From the calculus of variations and Pontryagin's Minimum Principle, the time-optimal trajectory to transition a dynamic system between two
velocity states under a bounded acceleration magnitude requires
operating constantly at the limit with a fixed acceleration vector direction.'
The only things I've removed from those quotes are the mathematical
formula symbologies that don't translate to a pure text medium such as Usenet.
I'll leave them in here for this second part but add some explanatory
text in square brackets:
'2. Kinematic Derivation
With $\vec{a}(t) = \vec{A}$ (a constant vector) [representing the
function for acceleration with respect to time and declaring it
constant] over the time interval $t \in [0, T]$ [time t from zero to T],
the velocity and position equations are:
$$\vec{v}(t) = \vec{v}_1 + \vec{A}t$$
[the velocity at time t is equal to the initial velocity plus the acceleration from time 0 to t]
$$\vec{r}(t) = \vec{r}_0 + \vec{v}_1 t + \frac{1}{2}\vec{A}t^2$$
[the position at time t is equal to the initial position, plus the
velocity component from 0 to t, plus the acceleration component from 0
to t, and as the quote goes on to state:]
This is the standard parametric equation of motion under constant acceleration (identical to a projectile in a uniform gravitational
field). Eliminating time $t$ from these equations yields a second-order polynomial equation in spatial coordinates, which defines a parabola in
the plane spanned by the vectors $\vec{v}_1$ and $\vec{A}$ [just "v" and
"A" with arrows above to indicate that they are vector quantities].'
And because a car--from the point where it enters a corner to the point where the brakes can no longer form a component of the resultant vector
of the vehicles acceleration (because the resultant now requires lateral acceleration and forward acceleration)--CAN create a constant
acceleration vector...
...that portion of the path the car takes through a corner will be a parabola. That's from the moment straight line braking to the speed
require to make it through the corner ends, to the moment the
acceleration vector is pure lateral acceleration. The acceleration phase
of the corner quickly moves into an area of the actual friction "circle"...that isn't circular any more.
And note that this is a specific application of a general case.
ANY time you want to transition an object from one velocity to another velocity in minimal time, you need to use a maximal and constant acceleration vector.
The path that results from doing that is ALWAYS a parabola.
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 55:29:28 |
| Calls: | 1,265 |
| Calls today: | 1 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
3 files (2,684K bytes) |
| Messages: | 285,684 |