• Re: EU standards compare Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max & Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra battery lifetime

    From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,uk.telecom.mobile on Wed Oct 21 13:09:51 2026
    From Newsgroup: comp.sys.mac.advocacy

    John Bokma wrote:
    On 20/10/2026 21:44, Maria Sophia wrote:
    1. The specifications (EU certified)
    A. Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max
    a. Capacity: 4800 mAh
    b. EU Endurance (Single Charge): 53 hours
    c. EU Cycle Rating (to 80%): 1,000 cycles
    d. Daily Cycles (24h/53h): 0.45283 cycles/day

    "it is not a prediction that the battery will last 6.05 years before reaching 80% capacity. EU endurance measures runtime under standardized testing, while cycle-life ratings measure battery degradation under specified cycling conditions. Your actual daily usage, charging
    behavior, heat exposure, and calendar aging can all change the outcome."

    Let's also look at a current model: iPhone 18 Pro Max:

    Battery endurance per cycle 62h 00min
    Battery endurance in cycles Battery endurance in cycles 1 000
    Rated battery capacity 5 391 mAH

    Daily cycles: 24h/62h = 0.3870967741935484
    'Kill Time' = Total Life Cycles / Daily Cycles
    1000/0.3871 ~ 2645 days, roughly. 7 years and 3 months.

    Please open a separate thread comparing the iPhone 18 Pro Max to whatever
    you feel you can justify as the equivalent Samsung model competing with it.

    I get it that Apple religious zealots are desperate to cherry pick such
    that they can find some way, any way, some way possible, to come out ahead.

    I feel sorry for you Apple religious zealots actually, since Apple chose to
    put crappy components into the iPhone, so you start off at a disadvantage.

    Still, this thread was opened in April of 2026 when these were the current phones, so this discussion should remain about these current phones.

    These are facts using similar phones which we chose blind in April, before
    we ran the calculations based only EU specifications, which we agreed on.

    iPhone 17 Pro Max hrs of runtime per charge cycle = 18.87 hours
    Samsung S26 Ultra hrs of runtime per charge cycle = 21.82 hours
    *Winner = Samsung (+15.6%)*

    iPhone 17 Pro Max endurance per charge = 53 hours
    Samsung S26 Ultra endurance per charge = 55 hours
    *Winner = Samsung (+3.8%)*

    iPhone 17 Pro Max efficiency (hrs/Ah) = 11.04
    Samsung S26 Ultra efficiency (hrs/Ah) = 11.33
    *Winner = Samsung (+2.6%)*

    iPhone 17 Pro Max calendar life (calculated) = ~6.05 years
    Samsung S26 Ultra calendar life (calculated) = ~7.53 years
    *Winner = Samsung (24.5%)*

    Why do you think, given Apple's brilliant marketing spews efficiency 12
    times in every 9-page iPhone datasheet, that this iPhone sucks compared to
    this comparable Samsung?

    Where exactly did Apple cheap out when designing the iPhone 17 Pro Max
    such that it lost big on every metric, using the EU benchmark figures?


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John Bokma@contact@johnbokma.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,uk.telecom.mobile on Wed Oct 21 19:18:55 2026
    From Newsgroup: comp.sys.mac.advocacy

    On 21/10/2026 19:09, Maria Sophia wrote:
    John Bokma wrote:

    [..]

    Let's also look at a current model: iPhone 18 Pro Max:

    Battery endurance per cycle 62h 00min
    Battery endurance in cycles Battery endurance in cycles 1 000
    Rated battery capacity 5 391 mAH

    Daily cycles: 24h/62h = 0.3870967741935484
    'Kill Time' = Total Life Cycles / Daily Cycles
    1000/0.3871 ~ 2645 days, roughly. 7 years and 3 months.

    Please open a separate thread comparing the iPhone 18 Pro Max to whatever
    you feel you can justify as the equivalent Samsung model competing with it.

    Why? So you can start another foaming at the mouth attack? With your
    beyond silly kill time calculation the 18 Pro Max comes close to the S26 Ultra. I explained elsewhere why it's beyond silly.

    Moreover, *real world usage* shows something different:

    Apple iPhone 18 Pro Max 19:20h 31:23h 17:13h 26:12h 12:09h 19:20h
    Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max 17:58h 24:26h 15:33h 25:41h 12:08h 17:58h
    Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra 16:23h 37:44h 13:01h 24:48h 9:42h 16:23h


    <https://www.gsmarena.com/battery-test-v2.php3>

    Your math is not mathing :-D.
    --
    Static tumblelog generator: https://github.com/john-bokma/tumblelog/
    Available as Python or Perl. Example tumblelog: https://plurrrr.com/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,uk.telecom.mobile on Wed Oct 21 13:22:39 2026
    From Newsgroup: comp.sys.mac.advocacy

    CrudeSausage wrote:
    I rarely let a computer deplete all the way to 0%, so I'm the kind of
    guy who will charge from 55% to 80% and so on. I imagine that with the optimized charging from 80% to 100% and my resistance to total
    depletion, the battery on this Mac will last quite a while. Either way,
    I intend to have it replaced before the warranty is up. I'd do it
    myself, but I've noticed that changing batteries on these machines is needlessly complicated.

    Jesus Christ. None of you Apple religious zealots knows how cycles are computed. This is how I know none of you have any formal education.

    Sheesh. Nobody charges from 0% to 100% and no calculation assumes that.
    Only you Apple religious zealot nutjobs make that claim. Nobody else.

    The facts remain:

    1. The specifications (EU certified)
    A. Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max
    a. Capacity: 4800 mAh
    b. EU Endurance (Single Charge): 53 hours
    c. EU Cycle Rating (to 80%): 1,000 cycles
    d. Daily Cycles (24h/53h): 0.45283 cycles/day

    B. Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra
    a. Capacity: 4855 mAh
    b. EU Endurance (Single Charge): 55 hours
    c. EU Cycle Rating (to 80%): 1,200 cycles
    d. Daily Cycles (24h/55h): 0.43636 cycles/day

    2. 'Kill Time' = Total Life Cycles / Daily Cycles
    A. Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max:
    1,000 / ~0.453 = 2,208.33 days (approx 6.05 years)
    B. Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra:
    1,200 / ~0.436 = 2,750 days (approx 7.53 years)

    3. Analysis of the data
    A. Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max
    Total Life: 2,208 days (approx 6.05 years)
    Efficiency Calculation: 53 hours / 4.8 Ah = 11.04 hours per Ah
    Efficiency: 11.04 hours per Ah

    B. Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra
    Total Life: 2,750 days (approx 7.53 years)
    Efficiency Calculation: 55 hours / 4.855 Ah = 11.33 hours per Ah
    Efficiency: 11.33 hours per Ah
    Margin: 542 Days (approx 1.49 years)
    Lifespan Advantage: +24.5%

    4. Summary of the facts:
    a. Efficiency:
    Samsung wins. It gets 55 hours out of 4.855Ah,
    while Apple gets 53 hours out of 4.8Ah.
    b. Capacity:
    Samsung wins, though Apple has finally started closing the
    historic battery-capacity gap (but only recently).
    c. Durability:
    Samsung wins. The 1,200 cycle rating on Samsung's 2026 chemistry
    provides the Kill-Time victory despite the claimed iPhone efficiency.

    REFERENCES:
    a. EU Regulation 2023/1670 (Ecodesign requirements)
    <https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2023/1670/oj>
    b. EU Regulation 2023/1669 (Energy Labeling)
    <https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2023/1669/oj>
    c. EPREL (European Product Registry for Energy Labeling)
    <https://eprel.ec.europa.eu/screen/product/smartphonestablets20231669>
    d. Bitkom Compliance (June 2025 Implementation Details)
    <https://bitkom-compliance-solutions.com/en/news/new-eu-requirements-ecodesign-and-energy-labelling-smartphones-and-tablets-june-2025>
    --
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,uk.telecom.mobile on Wed Oct 21 13:31:45 2026
    From Newsgroup: comp.sys.mac.advocacy

    John Bokma wrote:
    Please open a separate thread comparing the iPhone 18 Pro Max to whatever
    you feel you can justify as the equivalent Samsung model competing with it.

    Why? So you can start another foaming at the mouth attack? With your
    beyond silly kill time calculation the 18 Pro Max comes close to the S26 Ultra. I explained elsewhere why it's beyond silly.

    Moreover, *real world usage* shows something different:

    Apple iPhone 18 Pro Max 19:20h 31:23h 17:13h 26:12h 12:09h 19:20h Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max 17:58h 24:26h 15:33h 25:41h 12:08h 17:58h Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra 16:23h 37:44h 13:01h 24:48h 9:42h 16:23h


    <https://www.gsmarena.com/battery-test-v2.php3>

    Your math is not mathing :-D.

    Not again...

    You Apple religious zealots prove me right every single time you post.
    To wit, you just proved you don't understand the topic in this thread.

    HINT: It's not about hours, John. *It's about years.*

    Where is your calculation on the years each of those devices will last?

    Note that I'm well aware none of you Apple religious nutjobs has any formal education above high school, so, for you to calculate that is impossible.

    Prove me wrong, John.
    Here... I'll help you.

    In fact, I'll make it trivial for you, John.
    Please prove me wrong that you have no education above high school...

    Just follow this template...

    1. The specifications (EU certified)
    A. Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max
    a. Capacity: 4800 mAh
    b. EU Endurance (Single Charge): 53 hours
    c. EU Cycle Rating (to 80%): 1,000 cycles
    d. Daily Cycles (24h/53h): 0.45283 cycles/day

    B. Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra
    a. Capacity: 4855 mAh
    b. EU Endurance (Single Charge): 55 hours
    c. EU Cycle Rating (to 80%): 1,200 cycles
    d. Daily Cycles (24h/55h): 0.43636 cycles/day

    2. 'Kill Time' = Total Life Cycles / Daily Cycles
    A. Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max:
    1,000 / ~0.453 = 2,208.33 days (approx 6.05 years)
    B. Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra:
    1,200 / ~0.436 = 2,750 days (approx 7.53 years)

    3. Analysis of the data
    A. Apple iPhone 17 Pro Max
    Total Life: 2,208 days (approx 6.05 years)
    Efficiency Calculation: 53 hours / 4.8 Ah = 11.04 hours per Ah
    Efficiency: 11.04 hours per Ah

    B. Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra
    Total Life: 2,750 days (approx 7.53 years)
    Efficiency Calculation: 55 hours / 4.855 Ah = 11.33 hours per Ah
    Efficiency: 11.33 hours per Ah
    Margin: 542 Days (approx 1.49 years)
    Lifespan Advantage: +24.5%

    4. Summary of the facts:
    a. Efficiency:
    Samsung wins. It gets 55 hours out of 4.855Ah,
    while Apple gets 53 hours out of 4.8Ah.
    b. Capacity:
    Samsung wins, though Apple has finally started closing the
    historic battery-capacity gap (but only recently).
    c. Durability:
    Samsung wins. The 1,200 cycle rating on Samsung's 2026 chemistry
    provides the Kill-Time victory despite the claimed iPhone efficiency.

    REFERENCES:
    a. EU Regulation 2023/1670 (Ecodesign requirements)
    <https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2023/1670/oj>
    b. EU Regulation 2023/1669 (Energy Labeling)
    <https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2023/1669/oj>
    c. EPREL (European Product Registry for Energy Labeling)
    <https://eprel.ec.europa.eu/screen/product/smartphonestablets20231669>
    d. Bitkom Compliance (June 2025 Implementation Details)
    <https://bitkom-compliance-solutions.com/en/news/new-eu-requirements-ecodesign-and-energy-labelling-smartphones-and-tablets-june-2025>
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John Bokma@contact@johnbokma.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,uk.telecom.mobile on Wed Oct 21 19:32:52 2026
    From Newsgroup: comp.sys.mac.advocacy

    On 21/10/2026 19:22, Maria Sophia wrote:

    Jesus Christ. None of you Apple religious zealots knows how cycles are computed. This is how I know none of you have any formal education.

    Sheesh. Nobody charges from 0% to 100% and no calculation assumes that.
    Only you Apple religious zealot nutjobs make that claim. Nobody else.
    "Battery endurance per cycle refers to how long a smartphone's battery
    lasts from a *full charge* to when it *needs to be recharged* again. For example, a battery endurance of 10 hours per cycle means that, on the
    basis of a standardised test of usage reproducing a typical real life situation, you should be able to use it for around 10 hours before
    needing to recharge it." <https://energy-efficient-products.ec.europa.eu/product-list/smartphones-and-tablets_en#endurancepercycle>

    Emphasis mine.
    --
    Static tumblelog generator: https://github.com/john-bokma/tumblelog/
    Available as Python or Perl. Example tumblelog: https://plurrrr.com/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From John Bokma@contact@johnbokma.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,uk.telecom.mobile on Wed Oct 21 19:34:50 2026
    From Newsgroup: comp.sys.mac.advocacy

    On 21/10/2026 19:31, Maria Sophia wrote:

    Where is your calculation on the years each of those devices will last?

    That's impossible to calculate seen that it depends on many factors.
    That's what everybody, including LLMs, try to tell you. But you rather
    keep your napkin calculations posted, in ignorance.
    --
    Static tumblelog generator: https://github.com/john-bokma/tumblelog/
    Available as Python or Perl. Example tumblelog: https://plurrrr.com/
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2