FFMPEG is, AFAIK, the one-and-only comprehensive FOSS video
processing software:
<https://ffmpeg.org/>
FFMPEG is used by sundry other software packages and it also
powers many of the giant video streaming services.
But is it wise to have only a single entity, however competent?
FFMPEG is, AFAIK, the one-and-only comprehensive FOSS video<snip>
processing software:
<https://ffmpeg.org/>
FFMPEG is used by sundry other software packages and it also
powers many of the giant video streaming services.
But is it wise to have only a single entity, however competent?
I produce screen-grab videos for my web site and I use the
FFMPEG x11grab device in conjunction with Nvidia nvenc with
excellent results. But recently, I discovered, and reported,
a SERIOUS BUG:
<https://code.ffmpeg.org/FFmpeg/FFmpeg/issues/23077>
After a lag of a few months, the bug has been confirmed.
However, no fix seems forthcoming. The latest FFMPEG
release still exhibits the issue.
Funny, just today I saw on mastodon an issue with GTK
that affects GNU Emacs. The person submitted the issue
in 2019, they just got a response stating a patch was or
about to be created for GTK.
Seems these days we need to me patient :(
FFMPEG is, AFAIK, the one-and-only comprehensive FOSS video
processing software:
<https://ffmpeg.org/>
I produce screen-grab videos for my web site and I use the
FFMPEG x11grab device in conjunction with Nvidia nvenc with
excellent results.
What about Mencoder?
Seems projects have gotten so large it now mirrors what happens on proprietary software.
What puzzles me is that my problem is a SERIOUS BUG. Screen grabs under
X11 are no longer possible if audio grabbing is included. Doesn't anyone
else do screen grabs?
On Mon, 9 Nov 2026 18:20:48 -0000 (UTC), John McCue wrote:
Seems projects have gotten so large it now mirrors what happens on
proprietary software.
Unlike proprietary software, nobody is stopping anyone from stepping
forward to offer a fix.
A related question is 'does anyone do screen grabs on X11?' I don't want
to get into that can'o'worms but is it possible the ffmpeg maintainers are paying more attention to Wayland problems?
On Mon, 9 Nov 2026 18:20:48 -0000 (UTC), John McCue wrote:
Seems projects have gotten so large it now mirrors what happens on
proprietary software.
Unlike proprietary software, nobody is stopping anyone from stepping
forward to offer a fix.
On Mon, 9 Nov 2026 22:50:31 -0000 (UTC), Lawrence DrCOOliveiro wrote:
On Mon, 9 Nov 2026 18:20:48 -0000 (UTC), John McCue wrote:
Seems projects have gotten so large it now mirrors what happens on
proprietary software.
Unlike proprietary software, nobody is stopping anyone from stepping
forward to offer a fix.
FFMPEG is in an entirely different league that other FOSS projects.
FFMPEG is almost unbelievable in the scope that it has attained.
It is globally critical. Both YouTube and Netflix depend on it.
<https://www.buddhsentripathi.com/blogs/ffmpeg-video-streaming-platform>
Yet, supposedly, it is developed entirely by volunteers.
The significance of this is that only corporate sponsors are likely
to have the necessary resources to analyze and fix bugs.
Before too long, FFMPEG will have become something akin to the Linux
kernel in its import and its development.
An option for EVERYTHING - IF you can find it in
the docs/discussions. Use it, with a LONG list of
params, for several useful things.
PROBLEM is that the various docs/discussions will
often lead you to different places. Many ways, maybe
TOO many ways, to Get It Done.
One of my applications ... ultimately cut-down the
FFMPEG line by nearly HALF. Now works better/faster.
LOTS of experiments. All the docs said this or
that or whatever ...
Latest, wanted to capture an IP camera. However
the goal wasn't fast/hi-rez video but MINIMAL
video WITH the SOUND. It's my only front-yard
camera exposed to the outside with audio. The
goal was JUST enough vid 'for reference', the
rest was the audio. FFMPEG did ultimately deliver,
but it was a FIGHT. Everybody had the Better Idea
on How To Do it.
Yet, supposedly, it is developed entirely by volunteers.
Don't think anyone is getting paid much of
anything - it's all for The Cause.
FFMPEG is, AFAIK, the one-and-only comprehensive FOSS video
processing software:
<https://ffmpeg.org/>
FFMPEG is used by sundry other software packages and it also
powers many of the giant video streaming services.
But is it wise to have only a single entity, however competent?
I produce screen-grab videos for my web site and I use the
FFMPEG x11grab device in conjunction with Nvidia nvenc with
excellent results. But recently, I discovered, and reported,
a SERIOUS BUG:
<https://code.ffmpeg.org/FFmpeg/FFmpeg/issues/23077>
After a lag of a few months, the bug has been confirmed.
However, no fix seems forthcoming. The latest FFMPEG
release still exhibits the issue.
I can understand that FFMPEG is a huge project and only
the most urgent problems can be addresses quickly, but
since FFMPEG is the *only* GNU/Linux software that provides
X11 screen grabbing I am literally dead in the water
until a fix is implemented.
The situation is not good. FOSS should encourage more
diversity in application software. To have only a single
video processing tool is a disaster waiting to happen --
and it has happened.
Aside:
Note that the FFMPEG investigator is using a NVIDIA
RTX 5090 card. Whew! What a lucky mutherfucker!
On Mon, 09 Nov 2026 19:43:12 +0000, Distro Lackey wrote:
What puzzles me is that my problem is a SERIOUS BUG. Screen grabs under
X11 are no longer possible if audio grabbing is included. Doesn't anyone
else do screen grabs?
A related question is 'does anyone do screen grabs on X11?' I don't want
to get into that can'o'worms but is it possible the ffmpeg maintainers are paying more attention to Wayland problems?
(for which I've IIRC used recordmydesktop
What else can one expect from a Usenet group that can't progress
beyond 100-year-old mainframe technology?
On 2026-11-10, rbowman wrote:
On Mon, 09 Nov 2026 19:43:12 +0000, Distro Lackey wrote:
What puzzles me is that my problem is a SERIOUS BUG. Screen grabs under >>> X11 are no longer possible if audio grabbing is included. Doesn't anyone >>> else do screen grabs?
A related question is 'does anyone do screen grabs on X11?' I don't want
to get into that can'o'worms but is it possible the ffmpeg maintainers are >> paying more attention to Wayland problems?
Does "screen grab" mean anything other than screenshot and possibly
recording video?
I've done both under X11, although the former much more than the latter
(for which I've IIRC used recordmydesktop, I wanted just video, but its online manual page states it does support audio too).
What puzzles me is that my problem is a SERIOUS BUG. Screen grabs
under X11 are no longer possible if audio grabbing is included.
Doesn't anyone else do screen grabs?
I use "SimpleScreenRecorder" to record video and audio. (I don't
know if it uses ffmpeg on the backend.)
If I need a single frame
the resulting video file can be played in VLC which can grab a
frame as a photo.
Screen grabbing with wayland is nonsense because the security obsession
of the wayland developers causes each program to run in its own sandbox.
One program can't know what the other is doing and such communication
is necessary for screen grabbing.
Wayland is pure junk
and should be avoided by any technically sane person.
Screen grabbing with X11 is simple and straightforward as it should be.
The significance of this is that only corporate sponsors are likely
to have the necessary resources to analyze and fix bugs.
What else can one expect from a Usenet group that can't progress
beyond 100-year-old mainframe technology?
Le 10-11-2026, Distro Lackey <dl@lackey.com> a |-crit-a:
Screen grabbing with wayland is nonsense because the security obsession
of the wayland developers causes each program to run in its own sandbox.
One program can't know what the other is doing and such communication
is necessary for screen grabbing.
Screen grabbing works on Wayland. So, it proves, once again, that you
are wrong. Either either a program can know what the other is doing or
it's not required for screen grabbing.
Wayland is pure junk
It works.
and should be avoided by any technically sane person.
You are neither sane nor technical, so, as always the best thing to do
is the opposite of your claim.
Screen grabbing with X11 is simple and straightforward as it should be.
Yes, it's far better to have any website able to manage your computer.
The only good thing with your computer is it's so limited it's secured
by itself. Anyone who pawned you couldn't do anything worthy with it and switched to someone else's computer.
I am getting sick and tired of your ignorant rebuttals.
The future is Xorg/X11Libre.
On 13 Nov 2026 19:34:44 GMT, St|-phane CARPENTIER wrote:
Le 10-11-2026, Distro Lackey <dl@lackey.com> a |-crit-a:
Screen grabbing with wayland is nonsense because the security obsession
of the wayland developers causes each program to run in its own sandbox. >>> One program can't know what the other is doing and such communication
is necessary for screen grabbing.
Screen grabbing works on Wayland. So, it proves, once again, that you
are wrong. Either either a program can know what the other is doing or
it's not required for screen grabbing.
I am getting sick and tired of your ignorant rebuttals.
Screen grabbing on wayland, because of security isolation, requires
the ridiculous xdg-portal:
<https://wiki.archlinux.org/title/XDG_Desktop_Portal>
This is pure, encumbering BULLSHIT.
As I said,
wayland is junk and no technically sane person would ever
accept it -- expect a distro slave like YOU.
The future is Xorg/X11Libre.
The fact is that it works.
For you... the future is...
On 14 Nov 2026 14:01:35 GMT, St|-phane CARPENTIER wrote:
The fact is that it works.
So does a shoehorn:
<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shoehorn>
But a shoehorn is only necessary when the shoe is ill-fitting
junk.
On 14/11/2026 14:57, Distro Lackey wrote:
On 14 Nov 2026 14:01:35 GMT, St|-phane CARPENTIER wrote:Actually, it is needed when it close fitting excellence
The fact is that it works.So does a shoehorn:
<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shoehorn>
But a shoehorn is only necessary when the shoe is ill-fitting junk.
On Sat, 14 Nov 2026 17:48:18 +0000, The Natural Philosopher wrote:
Actually, it is needed when it close fitting excellence
I guess I haven't experienced close fitting excellence in the last sixty years or so.
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 53:48:47 |
| Calls: | 1,265 |
| Calls today: | 1 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
3 files (2,684K bytes) |
| Messages: | 285,448 |