• Why Many Americans Think Christa Pike Should Undergo a Second Execution Attempt

    From post it@postit@youtube.com to talk.politics.guns,comp.mobile.android,alt.fan.rush-limbaugh on Wed Nov 11 03:28:22 2026
    From Newsgroup: comp.mobile.android

    On October 20, Reuters released the results of a survey showing that 33%
    of the American public want Tennessee to try again to put Christa Pike to death. Another 26% are undecided.

    That means 59% of the public would support or be open to such a
    possibility. I want to suggest a reason why.

    Second execution attempts are rare in this country and, as a result, the public knows little if anything about them. That may help explain why so
    many would give Tennessee another chance to kill Christa Pike.

    As Supreme Court Justice Thurgood Marshall wrote more than fifty years
    ago, owhether or not a punishment is cruel and unusual dependsaon whether people who were fully informed as to the purposes of the penalty and its liabilities would find the penalty shocking, unjust, and unacceptable.o

    Marshall concluded, oAssuming knowledge of all the facts presently
    available regarding capital punishment, the average citizen would, in my opinion, find it shocking to his conscience and sense of justice.o What
    was, in MarshallAs view, true of capital punishment in general is
    certainly true when it comes to second execution attempts.

    If the American public had oknowledge of all the facts presently
    availableo about them, many of them would find oit shocking to [their] conscience and sense of justice.o

    Second execution attempts have happened only three times in the last
    eighty years, once in 1947 and twice in 2024. For the people who survived
    a first attempt, the prospect of a second trip to the execution chamber
    was an almost unimaginable nightmare.

    Every year, thousands of people, if not more, have near-death experiences
    much like those of people who survive a first execution attempt. They walk away from automobile accidents, survive gunshots, or beat the odds against supposedly fatal diseases. Many find those experiences so traumatic that
    they have real trouble making sense of what happened to them or
    integrating it into a redemptive life narrative.

    In my view, the death penalty is already cruel. It involves the needless infliction of pain, and, as Supreme Court Justice William Brennan once put
    it, the loss of othe right to have rights.o Brennan insisted that oeven as
    it punishes, [the state] must treat its members with respect for their intrinsic worth as human beings.o

    o[D]eath,o Brennan argued, ois a uniquely and unusually severe punishment. When examined by the principles applicable under the Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause, death stands condemned as fatally offensive to human dignity.o

    And if that is true when the state seeks to execute someone the first
    time, it is certainly true when an execution fails, and the state wants a do-over. In that case, the offense to dignity is compounded.

    And, in every failure, the state bears the burden; it is responsible for
    the negligence, incompetence, or willful blindness that produces those failures. It is responsible for the terror and suffering of those whose executions fail.

    Surely surviving an execution is better than dying. But each execution
    failure imposes on those who experience that failure the kind of excessive pain that the Supreme Court has said violates the Eighth Amendment
    prohibition on cruel and unusual punishment.

    Take the case of seventeen-year-old Willie Francis, whom the state of Louisiana tried and failed to execute using the electric chair on May 3,
    1946.

    One official witness described what happened this way: oThen the electrocutioner turned on the switch and when he did, Willie FrancisA lips puffed out and he groaned and jumped so that the chair came off the floor. Apparently the switch was turned on twice, and then the condemned man
    yelled: aTake it off. Let me breath [sic].Ao

    Francis survived due to the negligence of the execution team. After May 3, 1946, he knew full well what a second trip to the electric chair would
    mean.

    He litigated to prevent that from happening. But on January 13, 1947, the Supreme Court gave Louisiana the go-ahead. He was put to death on May 9,
    1947, after a year of dread, contemplating a fate whose pains he knew too well.

    Since then, two other execution survivors have faced a second execution.

    On September 22, 2022, Alabama failed in its effort to kill Alan Miller
    when the execution team could not establish an intravenous (IV) line
    before the death warrant expired. CBS News notes that oprison staff poked
    him with needles for over an hour as they tried to find a veinaAt one
    point, they left him hanging vertically on a gurney before state officials made the decision to call off the execution.o

    He lived but experienced what his lawyers described as oprofound post- traumatic stress and other psychological and physical symptomso in the aftermath. Two years after the first attempt, Miller was executed, this
    time by nitrogen hypoxia.

    And just under two months after MillerAs failed execution, Alabama failed again, this time in its effort to put Kenneth Smith to death by lethal injection. The execution team repeatedly jabbed Smith with needles and
    even tried to place a large needle under his collarbone to insert a
    central line before giving up.

    Fourteen months later, Alabama tried again, this time with nitrogen
    hypoxia. In the intervening months, Smith suffered from post-traumatic
    stress disorder and, as the BBC reports, olived with the constant
    anticipation of being strapped back onto the same gurney and subjected to
    a secondaexecution.o

    SmithAs return trip to the execution chamber did not go well. He oshook
    and writhedo before succumbing to the gas.

    Francis, Miller, and Smith all experienced what was effectively a omock execution.o As the Equal Justice Initiative explains, oMock executions constitute torture under federal and international law. Federal courts
    have found that when captors in countries like Iraq, Iran, Guatemala, and
    Cuba make prisoners believe they are about to be executed, but then they arenAt killed, that constitutes torture.o

    EJI adds, oUnlike a traditional mock execution, a failed execution
    typically involves officials who intend to kill, although the torture and
    the suffering for the victim are no different.o

    Like the other execution survivors, Christa Pike is now odealing with the profound psychological trauma of having survived a failed execution,
    including the terror, pain and uncertainty of believing she was about to
    die.o

    I suspect that the 59% of Americans who want her to undergo a second
    execution attempt or are open to it do not really understand the suffering that follows a failed execution and the toll contemplating a second date
    with death entails.

    As Justice Marshall noted, the crimes that bring people to death row often oare ugly, vicious, reprehensible actsa. The questionais whether capital punishment is aa punishment no longer consistent with our own self-
    respect.Ao

    Whatever oneAs view about the appropriateness of the death penalty, if Americans knew about failed executions and their consequences, they would conclude that going forward with a second execution in PikeAs case would
    not be oconsistent with our own self-respect.o

    https://verdict.justia.com/2026/11/09/why-many-americans-think-christa- pike-should-undergo-a-second-execution-attempt
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2