• Re: Walmart sent me 1TB no-name sdcards instead of a 256GB TOPESEL sdcards.

    From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to comp.mobile.android,alt.comp.os.windows-10 on Mon Oct 19 17:52:39 2026
    From Newsgroup: comp.mobile.android

    Paul wrote:
    But Walmart and Amazon, in spite of efforts to stamp out the
    fake SSD drives in the aluminum cases, they really can't keep up.
    It's their responsibility to do so, but they seem less than
    capable of running a bazaar.

    UPDATE. given every thread should add new value to the topic...

    Apparently "Topesel" is a real brand <https://topesel.com>
    No. 6175, Building A, Pengnian University Town Tech Park,
    Taoyuan Street, Nanshan District, Shenzhen, Guangdong
    but they seem to simply "rebrand" other people's sd cards.

    Rebranding, in and of itself, isn't necessarily bad, given Delkin, HP, Integral, Kingston, Lexar, onn, and PNY all apparently resolve to the same manufacturer ID (27 / PH) according to what I found out recently.

    Where their 256GB sd card seems to sell for $42.99 each
    <https://topesel.com/products/256gb-microsd-card-with-adapter-topesel-memory-cards-a1-v30-u3-class-10-tf-cards>
    So that's about DOUBLE the price I paid for at Walmart online.
    <https://i.postimg.cc/Bbj21C4r/topesel-10-19-2026.jpg>

    SanDisk sells a similar spec card for $64.99 (plus stuff)
    <https://www.sandisk.com/products/memory-cards/microsd-cards/sandisk-microsd-express-card-for-nintendo-switch-2>
    Samsung sells a similar spec card for $79.99 (plus stuff)
    <https://www.samsung.com/us/memory-storage/memory-card/p9-256gb-microsd-express-card-sku-mb-mk256t-am/>

    With that knowledge in hand...
    1. I tried to get Walmart online to send me what I ordered
    2. But, they will only accept a return and refund my money
    3. Even as I "could" (up until yesterday) just re-order it again

    But get this... new development...

    Yesterday the Walmart price for 2 was the same as before: $39.99 plus tax
    But today, the Walmart price for 2 has more than doubled! $95.99 plus tax
    <https://www.walmart.com/ip/TOPESEL-256GB-Micro-SD-Card-2-Pack-Micro-SDXC-TF-Card-with-Adapter-High-Speed-Memory-Card/15848911009>

    Which, after all, is about where it should be based on the $42.99 each
    price at Topesel's web site (where I don't know about tax & shipping).

    So what's NEW is that Walmart drastically changed the Topesel price.

    Here's the original screenshot (which was the same price yesterday).
    <https://i.postimg.cc/PJ1Rjq7D/walmart-listing.jpg>
    Here's a new screenshot (which is the price as of today).
    <https://i.postimg.cc/N0CDnFJB/walmart10-19-2026.jpg>

    I called the credit card company today and disputed the charges.
    a. I told them to either send what I ordered at the price I ordered
    b. Or come and pick up the (likely garbage) 1TB cards they sent

    I suspect neither will happen, so now I'm back in the market for two 256GB name-brand (but I'll take second tier) sd cards for a decent price.

    I still can't figure out if Topesel is a second-tier brand, or not.

    Top tier? ($50 to $75 each perhaps?)
    SanDisk (aka Western Digital) Extreme or Extreme Pro (avoid Ultra)
    Samsung Pro Plus or Pro Ultimate or EVO Select for value

    Close to top tier?
    Lexar Professional Silver Plus or Play
    Kingston Canvas Go! Plus
    PNY Pro Elite or XLR8 Gaming or Elite-X

    Solid tier?
    Kioxia Exceria
    Amazon Basics
    Walmart onn
    Silicon Power
    Transcend
    Delkin
    Patriot
    Verbatim Integral
    TeamGroup
    ADATA

    Nor, am I sure what "markings" I really want since all the card will be
    used for is for storing media, which really isn't all that important.

    Markings?
    microSDXC UHS-I
    Speed U1 should be fine (U3/V30 for lots of video recording)
    Performance A1 should be fine for photos/media (A2 is better)
    (A2 if it's extended memory, which it's not)
    U3/V30 if 4K video is your thing (it's not my thing)
    UHS-I is fine for me.

    Since I know next-to-nothing about SD cards, I appreciate the advice given
    to test when they arrive. I can still test the supposed 1TB cards too, but they're currently unopened as I have no intention of actually using them.

    Is this the recommended SD card testing software?

    h2testw freeware on Windows, full test, takes hours
    <https://h2testw.en.lo4d.com/windows>
    ValieDrive freeware on Windows, spot check, quick
    <https://www.grc.com/validrive.htm>
    USBDeview freeware on Windows, speed test only, quick
    <https://www.nirsoft.net/utils/deviceio.html>
    Speed Out freeware on Windows, speed test only, quick
    SD Insight freeware on Android, shows only the (spoofed?) manufacturer ID
    True SD Card Capacity & Speed freeware on Android, full test, takes hours
    SD Card Test freeware on Android, quick speed test only
    SD Card Tester freeware on Android, capacity test, takes hours
    f3 (Fight Flash Fraud) on MacoS or Linux, full capacity, slow
    <https://github.com/AltraMayor/f3>
    F3XSwift on macOS, full capacity, slow

    With that in mind, it looks like a logical test sequence is to test on
    Windows because Android will be much slower & to test an empty card.
    1. Run a spot check
    2. And then run the full tests, overnight

    Any additional suggestions?
    (e.g., what do you think of the *new* current Topesel offering?)
    --
    Usenet is a wonderful place to discuss topics among thousands of experts.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Paul@nospam@needed.invalid to comp.mobile.android,alt.comp.os.windows-10 on Mon Oct 19 23:15:44 2026
    From Newsgroup: comp.mobile.android

    On Mon, 10/19/2026 5:52 PM, Maria Sophia wrote:
    Paul wrote:
    But Walmart and Amazon, in spite of efforts to stamp out the
    fake SSD drives in the aluminum cases, they really can't keep up.
    It's their responsibility to do so, but they seem less than
    capable of running a bazaar.

    UPDATE. given every thread should add new value to the topic...

    Apparently "Topesel" is a real brand <https://topesel.com>
    No. 6175, Building A, Pengnian University Town Tech Park,
    Taoyuan Street, Nanshan District, Shenzhen, Guangdong
    but they seem to simply "rebrand" other people's sd cards.

    Rebranding, in and of itself, isn't necessarily bad, given Delkin, HP, Integral, Kingston, Lexar, onn, and PNY all apparently resolve to the same manufacturer ID (27 / PH) according to what I found out recently.

    Where their 256GB sd card seems to sell for $42.99 each
    <https://topesel.com/products/256gb-microsd-card-with-adapter-topesel-memory-cards-a1-v30-u3-class-10-tf-cards>
    So that's about DOUBLE the price I paid for at Walmart online.
    <https://i.postimg.cc/Bbj21C4r/topesel-10-19-2026.jpg>

    SanDisk sells a similar spec card for $64.99 (plus stuff)
    <https://www.sandisk.com/products/memory-cards/microsd-cards/sandisk-microsd-express-card-for-nintendo-switch-2>
    Samsung sells a similar spec card for $79.99 (plus stuff)
    <https://www.samsung.com/us/memory-storage/memory-card/p9-256gb-microsd-express-card-sku-mb-mk256t-am/>

    With that knowledge in hand...
    1. I tried to get Walmart online to send me what I ordered
    2. But, they will only accept a return and refund my money
    3. Even as I "could" (up until yesterday) just re-order it again

    But get this... new development...

    Yesterday the Walmart price for 2 was the same as before: $39.99 plus tax
    But today, the Walmart price for 2 has more than doubled! $95.99 plus tax
    <https://www.walmart.com/ip/TOPESEL-256GB-Micro-SD-Card-2-Pack-Micro-SDXC-TF-Card-with-Adapter-High-Speed-Memory-Card/15848911009>

    Which, after all, is about where it should be based on the $42.99 each
    price at Topesel's web site (where I don't know about tax & shipping).

    So what's NEW is that Walmart drastically changed the Topesel price.

    Here's the original screenshot (which was the same price yesterday).
    <https://i.postimg.cc/PJ1Rjq7D/walmart-listing.jpg>
    Here's a new screenshot (which is the price as of today).
    <https://i.postimg.cc/N0CDnFJB/walmart10-19-2026.jpg>

    I called the credit card company today and disputed the charges.
    a. I told them to either send what I ordered at the price I ordered
    b. Or come and pick up the (likely garbage) 1TB cards they sent

    I suspect neither will happen, so now I'm back in the market for two 256GB name-brand (but I'll take second tier) sd cards for a decent price.

    I still can't figure out if Topesel is a second-tier brand, or not.

    Top tier? ($50 to $75 each perhaps?)
    SanDisk (aka Western Digital) Extreme or Extreme Pro (avoid Ultra)
    Samsung Pro Plus or Pro Ultimate or EVO Select for value

    Close to top tier?
    Lexar Professional Silver Plus or Play
    Kingston Canvas Go! Plus
    PNY Pro Elite or XLR8 Gaming or Elite-X

    Solid tier?
    Kioxia Exceria
    Amazon Basics
    Walmart onn
    Silicon Power
    Transcend
    Delkin
    Patriot
    Verbatim Integral
    TeamGroup
    ADATA

    Nor, am I sure what "markings" I really want since all the card will be
    used for is for storing media, which really isn't all that important.

    Markings?
    microSDXC UHS-I
    Speed U1 should be fine (U3/V30 for lots of video recording)
    Performance A1 should be fine for photos/media (A2 is better)
    (A2 if it's extended memory, which it's not)
    U3/V30 if 4K video is your thing (it's not my thing)
    UHS-I is fine for me.

    Since I know next-to-nothing about SD cards, I appreciate the advice given
    to test when they arrive. I can still test the supposed 1TB cards too, but they're currently unopened as I have no intention of actually using them.

    Is this the recommended SD card testing software?

    h2testw freeware on Windows, full test, takes hours
    <https://h2testw.en.lo4d.com/windows>
    ValieDrive freeware on Windows, spot check, quick
    <https://www.grc.com/validrive.htm>
    USBDeview freeware on Windows, speed test only, quick
    <https://www.nirsoft.net/utils/deviceio.html>
    Speed Out freeware on Windows, speed test only, quick
    SD Insight freeware on Android, shows only the (spoofed?) manufacturer ID
    True SD Card Capacity & Speed freeware on Android, full test, takes hours
    SD Card Test freeware on Android, quick speed test only
    SD Card Tester freeware on Android, capacity test, takes hours
    f3 (Fight Flash Fraud) on MacoS or Linux, full capacity, slow
    <https://github.com/AltraMayor/f3>
    F3XSwift on macOS, full capacity, slow

    With that in mind, it looks like a logical test sequence is to test on Windows because Android will be much slower & to test an empty card.
    1. Run a spot check
    2. And then run the full tests, overnight

    Any additional suggestions?
    (e.g., what do you think of the *new* current Topesel offering?)


    There is "f3probe", which a Brazilian wrote to "Fight Flash Fraud".
    It is apparently available for windows too.

    https://manpages.debian.org/testing/f3/f3probe.1.en.html

    The Windows version was written by Claude AI. There is supposed to
    be a "fast" option, but following up on this (getting it to compile),
    might be more time than it is worth. It should be noted that Windows 11 behavior has changed on things like "dd.exe" where you can run it in
    an Administrator window, and it tries to elevate it a second time. It's
    not a surprise then, that on Windows, this is going to be "flaky" because
    of Windows Defender and friends (hard to start).

    https://github.com/crack666/f3-windows-port

    *******

    topesel is a "legit" supplier as these things go. They are
    unlikely to be a NAND Flash fab, and would be using someone
    elses flash. That's not a name created yesterday just for fraud.
    still, remember that you can place a "Sandisk sticker" on anything,
    which is why some companies in the electronics industry were so
    hard hit by fraud (market saturated with fraud), on their web site
    they requested you buy directly from them to avoid middle-men.

    Note that most companies "sell wholesale to disti", and the disti
    distributes items to retail chains. The manufacturing companies do not want
    to be wrapping two storage devices in a cardboard box. For example,
    if you visit the Western Digital HDD Store in North America, that is
    actually Newegg in disguise (they use the same bubble wrap and
    five-sides wrapping job for the material inside the box).

    *******

    When I entered your link:

    walmart.com/ip/TOPESEL-256GB-Micro-SD-Card-2-Pack-Micro-SDXC-TF-Card-with-Adapter-High-Speed-Memory-Card/15848911009

    the item is listed as "Not Available". I'm getting a different result than you.

    That means, based on cookies and +++ DOM storage
    of your previous interaction, they have noted your activity and are now phishing
    you with an "up-market fraud scheme". You're going to have to look around,
    to do better than this. And NOT from a bazaar seller. That's a tall order to meet
    when buying online.

    As there is some degree of shortage when it comes to NAND flash,
    you expect a lot of sites to list the item as "not available".

    There are four of these in the city. Three of them are 1.5 hours drive
    total away from me. That leaves one in the city core. Price is $94.99 CDN, times .71 is $67.44 USD. They have a 30 day return policy, and only
    some items are struck off for returns. You have to check at the desk
    to determine which items have the return policy today. For example,
    I've only had one hard drive which was defective when tested. I took
    it back, explained to the returns guy "motor won't spin on this drive".
    He tested it and agreed, it would not be starting anytime soon. I
    got an exchange on a working one. I've also done refunds there.
    I returned an SSD that was running at 1/4 normal speed.

    TEAMGROUP High Endurance 256GB microSDXC UHS-I U3 A1 V30 C10, Up to 100MB/s Read, w/ Adapter - Micro SD Card (THUSDX256GIV3002)

    Review is from four years ago. Which means any comments are invalid by now,
    as the source materials are likely different today, with the shortages.
    Flash page size of 64K is likely the same on whatever ships now. "High Endurance"
    can mean a couple things. Micron makes an industrial-grade flash with 6x
    write cycles. The other way to do that, is to use Wear Leveling, which is
    hard for a buyer to verify based on any available information. Only a couple USB sticks that look like USB sticks, actually have both kinds of wear leveling,
    which should be "quite worth it". The SD is unlikely to have that on the interface
    as such (supporting things like TRIM). We would hope the High Eudurance then relates to writes-per-cell. This isn't really a review, but you can get some info from it.

    https://www.guru3d.com/review/teamgroup-high-endurance-v30-sdxc-256gb-review/page-1

    While that one isn't available everywhere, you should still find some Sandisk ones on most sites. This isn't bazaar pricing, but it is definitely boutique pricing for those who want boutique. Notice that some of the adverts here,
    show the read/write speed, and the really cheap 256GB is 10MB/sec on write :-) It will take you some time, to sort through those.

    https://www.bhphotovideo.com

    Paul
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to comp.mobile.android,alt.comp.os.windows-10 on Tue Oct 20 14:41:13 2026
    From Newsgroup: comp.mobile.android

    Paul wrote:
    There is "f3probe", which a Brazilian wrote to "Fight Flash Fraud".
    It is apparently available for windows too.

    Thanks for the suggestion of f3probe as you know I always strive to test & report on all the freeware suggested on this newsgroup over the decades.
    <https://i.postimg.cc/0Qk4sBDp/hardware-sdcard.jpg>

    Here's the combined list, so far, of Windows sd-testing freeware:
    h2testw - freeware, full capacity test, takes hours
    <https://h2testw.en.lo4d.com/windows

    ValiDrive - freeware, spot check, quick
    <https://www.grc.com/validrive.htm>

    USBDeview - freeware, speed test only, quick
    <https://www.nirsoft.net/utils/deviceio.html>

    Speed Out - freeware, speed test only, quick
    <https://speedout.en.lo4d.com/windows>

    F3 Windows port - includes f3probe for capacity testing
    <https://github.com/crack666/f3-windows-port>

    Here's the combined list, so far, of Android sd-testing freeware:
    SD Insight - freeware, reports card identification information
    <https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.humanlogic.sdi>

    True SD Card Capacity & Speed - freeware, full capacity test
    <https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=alan.sdcardsize.free>

    SD Card Test - freeware, read/write speed test
    <https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.pzolee.sdcardtester>

    Here's the combined list, so far, of macOS/Linux sd-testing freeware:
    F3 (Fight Flash Fraud) - open source, full capacity test, slow
    <https://github.com/AltraMayor/f3>

    F3XSwift - macOS graphical interface for F3
    <https://github.com/vrunkel/F3XSwift>

    The logical test sequence seems to be:
    1. Use Windows and a decent card reader on an empty card, if possible.
    2. Run f3probe and/or ValiDrive for a counterfeit capacity spot check.
    3. Run h2testw or F3's f3write/f3read for a full write/read test.
    4. Run a separate speed benchmark if performance matters.

    I created this screenshot for the team, just now, and then noticed I
    happened to have tested, in the past, other freeware not listed above.
    <https://i.postimg.cc/0Qk4sBDp/hardware-sdcard.jpg>

    Namely these links are in my menu system from long ago:
    C:\app\hardware\sdcard\chipgenius\FlashMaster.exe
    C:\app\hardware\sdcard\fakeflashtest\FAKEFLASHTEST.exe
    C:\app\hardware\vsn\diskgenius\DiskGenius.exe

    I don't remember why I installed them, but here are links to the code.
    ChipGenius for identifying USB flash-drive controllers and hardware
    <https://www.chip-genius.cn/>
    FakeFlashTest by RMPrepUSB for checking USB & SD card capacity
    <https://rmprepusb.com/tutorials/007-all-about-fake-sd-cards-and-usb-flash-drives/>
    DiskGenius, a disk partitioning, cloning, recovery and diagnostic utility
    <https://www.diskgenius.com/>

    Of those, the only one I'd add to the sd-card-testing list is
    FakeFlashTest, but we already have f3probe and ValiDrive for that.

    topesel is a "legit" supplier as these things go. They are
    unlikely to be a NAND Flash fab, and would be using someone
    elses flash. That's not a name created yesterday just for fraud.
    still, remember that you can place a "Sandisk sticker" on anything,
    which is why some companies in the electronics industry were so
    hard hit by fraud (market saturated with fraud), on their web site
    they requested you buy directly from them to avoid middle-men.

    Thanks for that information on Topesel. I couldn't a manufacturing site, as they seem to be only rebranders, but I agree that all indications are
    they're legit, but since they only rebrand, they're likely not top tier.

    When I entered your link:
    walmart.com/ip/TOPESEL-256GB-Micro-SD-Card-2-Pack-Micro-SDXC-TF-Card-with-Adapter-High-Speed-Memory-Card/15848911009
    the item is listed as "Not Available". I'm getting a different result than you.

    I checked again today, using two different browsers w/o using VPN.
    It's still $95.99 at the time of posting using this exact URL:
    <https://www.walmart.com/ip/TOPESEL-256GB-Micro-SD-Card-2-Pack-Micro-SDXC-TF-Card-with-Adapter-High-Speed-Memory-Card/15848911009>

    Given %95.99 for two lower-tier 256GB sd cards is a reasonable price,
    I'm guessing the following, but it's just a guess on my part:
    1. The reseller to Walmart created the original listing at $39.99
    2. When I ordered it, they realized they made a mistake in pricing
    3. Instead of eating that mistake, they shipped me crap 1TB cards
    4. Then, they changed the pricing on the site from $39.99 to $95.99

    Remember, I complained to both the seller and to Walmart, so we don't know
    what happened in between, but that's the most charitable assessment I can
    make based only on what I know happened on my side of the equation.

    Anyway, I'm still stuck with getting a good price on decent 256GB cards.
    I don't need the best since it's just for my wife's media storage use.

    https://www.guru3d.com/review/teamgroup-high-endurance-v30-sdxc-256gb-review/page-1
    https://www.bhphotovideo.com

    Thanks for those hints, and yes, the reviews from years ago won't be
    meaningful given they change suppliers all the time, I'm sure.

    I'll check them out as I till need to get the two 256GB sd cards.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2