From Newsgroup: comp.lang.prolog

Mild Shock schrieb:

Hi,

At least John Sowa is not panicing when
he bashes LLM. Here is another video by him,
where he pulls all registers:

Without Ontology LLMs are Clueless by JohnSowa https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t7wZbbISdyA

Hi,

This is a nice example how the young generation
doesn't understand systems that were developed
30 years ago:

Example 1:
No clue that SWI-Prolog does have JIT indexes,
which explain mysterious differene between
cold and warm run.
https://arxiv.org/pdf/2511.13600

Example 2:
No clue that subsumption could make a difference,
claims left recursion is fastest, with referene
to [TL10] and a bogus node argument.
https://arxiv.org/abs/2504.21291

Maybe the Prolog eduction group should organize
a summer school about tabling?

Sad news: It will not help to keep up with
the AI boom. Whats behind the AI boom and
computing transitive closures?

Bye

One could adopt his stance, including spreadin > rumors that are not completely true for LLMs, since
LLMs do also represent ontologies.

Just make a test, take any of John Sowas drawings:

https://www.jfsowa.com/ontology/

Now ask ChatGPT:

Q: give me an overview of the beverages
that humans consume

A: Humans consume a wide variety of beverages,
broadly categorized based on their preparation,
ingredients, and purpose. HererCOs an overview:

1. Water
[...]
2. Non-Alcoholic Beverages
a. Hot Beverages
[...]
b. Cold Beverages
[...]
3. Alcoholic Beverages
[...]
4. Functional Beverages
[...]
5. Cultural and Specialty Beverages
[...]
6. Specialty and Regional Drinks
[...]

These beverages serve various roles, from hydration
and nutrition to cultural traditions, relaxation,
and social interaction.

Woa!

Bye

--- Synchronet 3.21f-Linux NewsLink 1.2

From Newsgroup: comp.lang.prolog

Hi,

This is a nice example how the young generation
doesn't understand systems that were developed
30 years ago:

Example 1:
No clue that SWI-Prolog does have JIT indexes,
which explain mysterious differene between
cold and warm run.
https://arxiv.org/pdf/2511.13600

Example 2:
No clue that subsumption could make a difference,
claims left recursion is fastest, with referene
to [TL10] and a bogus node argument.
https://arxiv.org/abs/2504.21291

Maybe the Prolog eduction group should organize
a summer school about tabling?

Sad news: It will not help to keep up with
the AI boom. Whats behind the AI boom and
computing transitive closures?

Bye

One could adopt his stance, including spreadin > rumors that are not completely true for LLMs, since
LLMs do also represent ontologies.

Just make a test, take any of John Sowas drawings:

https://www.jfsowa.com/ontology/

Now ask ChatGPT:

Q: give me an overview of the beverages
that humans consume

A: Humans consume a wide variety of beverages,
broadly categorized based on their preparation,
ingredients, and purpose. HererCOs an overview:

1. Water
[...]
2. Non-Alcoholic Beverages
a. Hot Beverages
[...]
b. Cold Beverages
[...]
3. Alcoholic Beverages
[...]
4. Functional Beverages
[...]
5. Cultural and Specialty Beverages
[...]
6. Specialty and Regional Drinks
[...]

These beverages serve various roles, from hydration
and nutrition to cultural traditions, relaxation,
and social interaction.

Woa!

Bye

--- Synchronet 3.21f-Linux NewsLink 1.2