In this case YOU have to ask YOURSELF why are you providing any of those >strange data sizes AT ALL ??? That is who is Concertina for ???
On Wed, 11 Feb 2026 23:55:29 GMT, MitchAlsup <user5857@newsgrouper.org.invalid> wrote:
In this case YOU have to ask YOURSELF why are you providing any of those >strange data sizes AT ALL ??? That is who is Concertina for ???
I think that ARM-based smartphones already existed when I started work
on Concertina II.
But it may be that it was before Apple switched the Macintosh over to
Apple Silicon, so ARM was still seen as a niche product.
So, psychologically, I felt that we were living in a world where, essentially, x86 - at least in its x86-64 incarnation - had *killed
off all other computer architectures*.
From this, I drew the conclusion that, when it comes to computer architectures, "There can be only one" - like Highlander.
And from that, I came to the further conclusion... that if the world
can have only one computer architecture, then, in order for the world
not to be impoverished thereby, that one surviving computer
architecture must be able to "do everything", where "everything"
includes, say, being able to run PDP-10 code at nearly native speeds.
Hence, strange data sizes.
John Savard--- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
if the world can have only one computer architecture, then, in
order for the world not to be impoverished thereby, that one
surviving computer architecture must be able to "do everything",
where "everything" includes, say, being able to run PDP-10 code
at nearly native speeds.
In article <6adbf8ee.10622140@news.eternal-september.org>, >quadibloc@invalid.com (John Savard) wrote:
if the world can have only one computer architecture, then, in
order for the world not to be impoverished thereby, that one
surviving computer architecture must be able to "do everything",
where "everything" includes, say, being able to run PDP-10 code
at nearly native speeds.
However, an architecture of extreme complexity, burdened with lots of
rarely used features, is most unlikely to become the world's sole >architecture.
Have you tried running PDP-10 code in an emulator on a modern 64-bit
machine? I'd bet that it significantly exceeds the speed of the native >hardware.
However, an architecture of extreme complexity, burdened with lots of
rarely used features, is most unlikely to become the world's sole >architecture.
Have you tried running PDP-10 code in an emulator on a modern 64-bit
machine? I'd bet that it significantly exceeds the speed of the native >hardware.
On Sun, 25 Oct 2026 06:00 +0000 (GMT Standard Time), jgd@cix.co.uk
(John Dallman) wrote:
In article <6adbf8ee.10622140@news.eternal-september.org>,
quadibloc@invalid.com (John Savard) wrote:
if the world can have only one computer architecture, then, in
order for the world not to be impoverished thereby, that one
surviving computer architecture must be able to "do everything",
where "everything" includes, say, being able to run PDP-10 code
at nearly native speeds.
However, an architecture of extreme complexity, burdened with lots of
rarely used features, is most unlikely to become the world's sole
architecture.
True, but I haven't been able to figure out an alternative.
Also, fortunately, my sole competition happens to be struggling under
a burden of its own which seems to be just as great or greater. (That
is, if you don't count ARM and RISC-V...)
Have you tried running PDP-10 code in an emulator on a modern 64-bit
machine? I'd bet that it significantly exceeds the speed of the native
hardware.
But it doesn't exceed the speed of the modern 64-bit machine.
And? Why does that matter?
It's not enough for people to be able to emulate a PDP-10 for merely _sentimental_ reasons. I want to breathe life into those dusty decks!
I want there to be other ways of computing!
It's not enough for people to be able to emulate a PDP-10 for merely _sentimental_ reasons. I want to breathe life into those dusty
decks!
On Sun, 25 Oct 2026 06:00 +0000 (GMT Standard Time), jgd@cix.co.uk
(John Dallman) wrote:
In article <6adbf8ee.10622140@news.eternal-september.org>, >quadibloc@invalid.com (John Savard) wrote:
if the world can have only one computer architecture, then, in
order for the world not to be impoverished thereby, that one
surviving computer architecture must be able to "do everything",
where "everything" includes, say, being able to run PDP-10 code
at nearly native speeds.
However, an architecture of extreme complexity, burdened with lots of >rarely used features, is most unlikely to become the world's sole >architecture.
True, but I haven't been able to figure out an alternative.
Also, fortunately, my sole competition happens to be struggling under
a burden of its own which seems to be just as great or greater. (That
is, if you don't count ARM and RISC-V...)
--- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2Have you tried running PDP-10 code in an emulator on a modern 64-bit >machine? I'd bet that it significantly exceeds the speed of the native >hardware.
But it doesn't exceed the speed of the modern 64-bit machine.
And? Why does that matter?
It's not enough for people to be able to emulate a PDP-10 for merely _sentimental_ reasons. I want to breathe life into those dusty decks!
I want there to be other ways of computing!
Even though I remain sedulously unimpressed by the notion that
psilocybin beats empiricsm as a way of knowing.
John Savard
In article <6ade3c57.66203562@news.eternal-september.org>, >quadibloc@invalid.com (John Savard) wrote:
It's not enough for people to be able to emulate a PDP-10 for merely
_sentimental_ reasons. I want to breathe life into those dusty
decks!
Software that ran on PDP-10s, and other obsolete architectures, which
people or organisations _needed_ has either been re-written for other >architectures by now, or is run under emulation.
Given that there isn't a commercial emulator for PDP-10, it seems
unlikely to me that there's any significant business advantage to be
gained from a new architecture that emulates it faster.
quadibloc@invalid.com (John Savard) posted:
Also, fortunately, my sole competition happens to be struggling under
a burden of its own which seems to be just as great or greater. (That
is, if you don't count ARM and RISC-V...)
But it has multiple companies with hundreds of architects and engineers >(each) working to move them forward. You only have you.
But it has multiple companies with hundreds of architects and engineers >(each) working to move them forward. You only have you.
Obviously, of course, I can avoid that by not having 32 registers.
With 8 registers, the 68020 is an existence proof, and the System/360
proves that even 16 registers will work. But RISC with 32 registers
exists, is popular, and having 32 registers adds performance.
On Mon, 26 Oct 2026 13:40:11 GMT, MitchAlsup <user5857@newsgrouper.org.invalid> wrote:
But it has multiple companies with hundreds of architects and engineers
(each) working to move them forward. You only have you.
Also...
The way things are going these days, someone is going to leave lying
around under a BSD license the plans for an OoO RISC-V core which, no
doubt, I can modify to execute code for a different instruction set,
even my own.
John Savard
On Sun, 25 Oct 2026 06:00 +0000 (GMT Standard Time), jgd@cix.co.uk
(John Dallman) wrote:
In article <6adbf8ee.10622140@news.eternal-september.org>, >>quadibloc@invalid.com (John Savard) wrote:
if the world can have only one computer architecture, then, in
order for the world not to be impoverished thereby, that one
surviving computer architecture must be able to "do everything",
where "everything" includes, say, being able to run PDP-10 code
at nearly native speeds.
However, an architecture of extreme complexity, burdened with lots of >>rarely used features, is most unlikely to become the world's sole >>architecture.
True, but I haven't been able to figure out an alternative.
Also, fortunately, my sole competition happens to be struggling under
a burden of its own which seems to be just as great or greater. (That
is, if you don't count ARM and RISC-V...)
Have you tried running PDP-10 code in an emulator on a modern 64-bit >>machine? I'd bet that it significantly exceeds the speed of the native >>hardware.
But it doesn't exceed the speed of the modern 64-bit machine.
And? Why does that matter?
It's not enough for people to be able to emulate a PDP-10 for merely _sentimental_ reasons. I want to breathe life into those dusty decks!
I want there to be other ways of computing!
Do you mean like this:
https://opencores.org/projects?expanded=Processor
And the more exotic things for which I wish to at least specify
opcodes - like System/360 "Hexadecimal Floating-Point" - are things
that are not part of the basic subset of the architecture.
If that is true, you could
use the same op codes for both formats and have a global mode that
specifies which one to use.
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 54:48:52 |
| Calls: | 1,265 |
| Calls today: | 1 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
3 files (2,684K bytes) |
| Messages: | 285,582 |