• Re: US and China establish 'AI incidents' hotline

    From Scott Hoge@nospam@nospam.com to alt.sodomites.barack-obama,comp.ai.philosophy,sac.politics,alt.fan.rush-limbaugh,talk.politics.guns on Sat Oct 3 16:06:56 2026
    From Newsgroup: comp.ai.philosophy

    On 2026-10-01, Governor Swill <governor.swill@gmail.com> wrote:

    On Thu, 01 Oct 2026 02:05:41 GMT, Scott Hoge
    <nospam@nospam.com> pretending to be Spammy, posted some news:

    On 2026-09-29, Governor Swill <governor.swill@gmail.com>
    wrote:

    [...]

    China isn't communist anymore. They're what they've always
    been, an authoritarian. Emperors, Presidents, Committee
    Chairs ... they're all just kings in a place like China.

    I haven't actually /been/ to China, but I have been told by
    one Chinese person they are still communist, watched videos of
    tourists in China, and accumulated a substantial intuition
    through various facts and details of how they compare to us.

    I /can/ tell you what, in my view, a communist country
    /should/ be like. It should have cameras everywhere,

    That would be an authoritarian country giving limited rights.

    It occurred to me just now that there might be more semantic
    ambiguity in the term "authoritarianism" than I previously
    thought.

    When viewed /unfavorably/ or /displeasurably/, I've always
    thought of authoritarianism as being based upon the fallacy of
    appeal to authority -- that is, upon "because I said so." Thus,
    a claim about computers is held to be true "because Bill Gates
    said so," or a claim about scientific reasoning "because Neil
    deGrasse Tyson said so."

    Authoritarianism, in this unfavorable and displeasurable sense,
    refers to /dogmatism/.

    Dogmatism is opposed to what Immanuel Kant termed
    /transcendentalism/, which is an attempt to go beyond this
    fallacious "because I said so" to obtain the concepts of
    understanding that must be /universal among human beings/, which
    include the basic laws of arithmetic and logical reasoning.

    Transcendentalism replaces "because I said so" with what is
    called a /transcendental argument/ or /transcendental deduction/.
    It is a verbal justification, even if long and obscure, intended
    to convince the listener that certain concepts /must/ be basic to
    human understanding because without them, we wouldn't be able to
    solve problems or think.

    Naturally, some people won't be convinced by transcendental
    arguments -- and /that is expected/. We must continually learn
    and teach the art of making them so that we may carry science,
    and with it the principles of scientifc thought, through
    generations.

    Yet authoritarianism can also refer not to /dogmatism/ but to the
    mere /absence of pluralism/. It is here that I argue the United
    States is making the rudest insults toward China.

    To clarify, let us distinguish between two kinds of dissent:
    /dissent of the evil against the good/, and /dissent of the good
    against the evil/. Each is a case of /political pluralism/: two
    parties vying against one another. But if we are to distinguish
    good from evil on any objective basis -- for instance, if the "free-and-friendly United States" wants to compare itself to
    "big, mean ol' China" -- pluralism /by itself/ is overly
    abstracting and too general.

    In the concept of authoritarianism defined here as /mere
    anti-pluralism/, one equivocates between:

    1. /Freedom/ in the democratic sense, which could refer to either
    (a) the universal, unobstructed freedom to attain happiness or
    (b) the freedom to oppress others.

    2. /Concentration of power/ in the authoritarian sense, which
    could refer to either (a) what includes /soft power/ or gentle
    political persuasion, or (b) what includes the /infliction of
    punishment/ on "good" people.

    3. /Suppression of dissent/ in the authoritarian sense, which
    could refer to either (a) suppression of evil or (b)
    suppression of good.

    The list goes on. But the point is that authoritarianism, defined
    in this way, over-abstracts, over-generalizes, and altogether
    ignores the content of government and the relative moral
    superiority of one dissenting party over another.

    [...]

    Communism has only ever been tried by authoritarian regimes and
    it always fails the moment it starts taking away personal
    property.

    To my knowledge, China first suffered famine and then implemented
    what they termed a "household responsibility principle."
    Communism isn't just a one-size-fits-all system whose
    characteristics are exactly the same between communist societies;
    various rules and conditions can distinguish a communist society
    that fails from one that succeeds.

    [...]

    Communism works great for small group survival for as long as
    everybody knows everybody else. But when parts of the
    population become strangers to each other, communism breaks
    down.

    Under /reciprocal surveillance/ -- which isn't just the big, bad
    military laughing at what diapers you buy -- citizens are free to
    observe the lives of others, and with such an emotionally mature,
    responsible freedom comes the disappearance of "strangerhood."

    [...]

    I'll explain the last point. Two firms in the same industry
    can "compete" in two different ways. They can:

    1. /Cooperatively/ work alongside each other to see who's
    better at a given task. That information can be made public
    so that citizens can make informed choices about who to buy
    from.

    2. /Aggressively/ work /against/ each other by hiding secrets,
    destroying effort, and using deception and political
    persuasion to undermine the other's success, simply in
    order to "win."

    There is a third way. each can aggressively work to be better
    than the other. That competition results in better, cheaper
    products for the workers without destruction.

    But that way /is/ the very conflation I described between the two
    forms of competition, one of which is /aggressive and
    destructive/, and the other of which is /cooperative and
    knowledge-sharing/.

    Apologies for snipping some of your reply. I wanted to address
    what appeared to me the main points.

    -- Scott Hoge
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Governor Swill@governor.swill@gmail.com to alt.sodomites.barack-obama,comp.ai.philosophy,sac.politics,alt.fan.rush-limbaugh,talk.politics.guns on Sat Oct 3 17:10:06 2026
    From Newsgroup: comp.ai.philosophy

    On Sat, 03 Oct 2026 16:06:56 GMT, Scott Hoge <nospam@nospam.com>
    pretending to be Spammy, posted some news:

    On 2026-10-01, Governor Swill <governor.swill@gmail.com> wrote:
    On Thu, 01 Oct 2026 02:05:41 GMT, Scott Hoge wrote:
    On 2026-09-29, Governor Swill wrote:
    China isn't communist anymore. They're what they've always
    been, an authoritarian. Emperors, Presidents, Committee
    Chairs ... they're all just kings in a place like China.

    I haven't actually /been/ to China, but I have been told by
    one Chinese person they are still communist, watched videos of
    tourists in China, and accumulated a substantial intuition
    through various facts and details of how they compare to us.

    I /can/ tell you what, in my view, a communist country
    /should/ be like. It should have cameras everywhere,

    That would be an authoritarian country giving limited rights.

    It occurred to me just now that there might be more semantic
    ambiguity in the term "authoritarianism" than I previously
    thought.

    When viewed /unfavorably/ or /displeasurably/, I've always
    thought of authoritarianism as being based upon the fallacy of
    appeal to authority -- that is, upon "because I said so." Thus,
    a claim about computers is held to be true "because Bill Gates
    said so," or a claim about scientific reasoning "because Neil
    deGrasse Tyson said so."

    Authoritarianism, in this unfavorable and displeasurable sense,
    refers to /dogmatism/.

    I'm not talking about "dogmatism" or "because I said so". I'm talking
    about authoritarianism so severe that it punishes mere questioning.
    However, I was incomplete. China also has a totalitarian streak
    though capitalist economics has cut rather deeply into that.
    --
    Donald Trump is a miserable failure.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2