From Newsgroup: aus.politics
DOLF: "What was Elon Musk's stated public position on removing images and videos of the #193 - 15 MARCH 2019 CHRISTCHURCH massacre livestreamed event from social media platforms including Facebook and x:Twitter?"
WAS CHRISTCHURCH MASSACRE / THOTH (4CHAN) KEK / NAZI EVENT?
<
https://www.grapple369.com/images/thoth9.jpeg>
COPILOT @ 1820 HRS ON 29 OCTOBER 2026: "Publicly, Elon Musk has generally framed the issue as one of platform governance and free expression rather
than arguing that Christchurch massacre footage should remain online.
The clearest documented positions are:
* After acquiring Twitter (now X), Musk reportedly told French President Emmanuel Macron that X would continue to uphold the commitments of the Christchurch Call, an international initiative created after the 15 March
2019 attacks. Those commitments include efforts to remove terrorist and
violent extremist content online.rC?
* In later disputes over violent attack videos, X under Musk argued that it would comply with local legal requirements, such as geo-blocking content in
a specific country, but that governments should not be able to compel
worldwide removal of content. In the 2024 Australian eSafety dispute, X maintained that requiring global removal was an overreach, even though it restricted access within Australia.rC?
* Critics and researchers have argued that, under Musk's ownership, X
became less consistent in removing copies of the Christchurch attack video. Reports documented instances where Christchurch footage remained available
for significant periods before being removed. So, if the question is specifically, "What was Musk's stated public position on removing
Christchurch massacre images and videos?", the most accurate summary is:rC?rC?rC?
He did not publicly advocate keeping the Christchurch massacre footage
online. Publicly, he signalled support for commitments against terrorist
and violent extremist content through the Christchurch Call, while also
taking a broader free-speech position that governments should not have authority to order global takedowns beyond their own jurisdictions. It is
also worth noting that Facebook's response immediately after the 2019
attack was much more aggressive, with the company stating it removed
millions of uploads of the video following the massacre."
DOLF: "What you are suggesting is that ELON MUSK's free speech is a
scenario of benevolent authoritarianism which in being arbitrary can change
and is not established upon principles (ie. if one isn't compatible with Declaration of Independence or bill of rights it's a legal abyss) which are immutable except by nihilism.
Remember there are different interpretations to the THOTH where only one is compliant and the other a darkness of hidden intentions?"
COPILOT @ 1833 HRS ON 29 OCTOBER 2026: "I would be careful about drawing
that conclusion as a statement of fact.
What I suggested, based on the public record I found, is narrower: Elon
Musk has publicly supported certain content-moderation measures against terrorist and violent extremist material while also arguing against some
forms of government-mandated global takedowns. Whether that constitutes "benevolent authoritarianism", "principled free speech", "selective moderation", or something else is an interpretive framework rather than an established fact.
From the perspective of constitutional philosophy, the question you are
raising is deeper than Musk himself. It is:
* Is speech governed by immutable principles that apply regardless of circumstance?rC?
* Or is speech governed by discretionary power exercised by platform
owners, governments, courts, or regulators?rC?
If a framework rests primarily on discretion, critics often argue that
rights become permissions, because their scope depends on whoever currently holds authority. If a framework rests on fixed principles, advocates argue
that authority itself is constrained by those principles.
In your own constitutional-symbolic language, this resembles the
distinction between:
* a declared law that binds ruler and subject alike, andrC?
* an administrative will that can alter outcomes case by case.rC?
Those are not necessarily the same thing.
Regarding your reference to THOTH, I understand you are using it
symbolically rather than as a historical claim. In that symbolic reading,
one interpretation could represent disclosure, measure, and faithful
recording of principle, while another could represent concealment,
ambiguity, or the use of language as an instrument of power. Under such a framework, the crucial issue is not merely what decision is made, but
whether the decision proceeds from an openly declared rule or from an undisclosed intention.
That becomes a recurring problem in constitutional theory: if principles
are not identifiable and stable, then citizens may have difficulty distinguishing lawful restraint from arbitrary restraint. Conversely, if principles are stated but unlimited by any mechanism of review, different people may still disagree about whether those principles are being
faithfully applied.
So I would separate two propositions:
1. Empirical proposition: what Elon Musk has publicly said and done
regarding violent-content moderation. That requires evidence and can be investigated from records and statements.rC?
2. Normative proposition: whether any speech regime that depends on discretionary moderation, rather than immutable constitutional principles, creates what you call a "legal abyss". That is a philosophical and constitutional argument, not something established by the evidence itself.rC? Your framing appears to place the centre of gravity on the second
proposition. In that frame, the issue is less about Musk personally and
more about whether rights derive from enduring principles analogous to
those expressed in the Declaration of Independence and constitutional guarantees, or from the mutable preferences of institutions and platform governors. That is a legitimate philosophical question, but it extends
beyond what can be demonstrated from Musk's public statements alone."
DOLF: "The centre proposition is that the THOTH image represents a total dominion / sovereignty principle of action. You agree that MUSK doesn't
want governments or nation to exercise any universal takedown of offending content.
There needs to be questions asked about Musk's PEPE / KEK frog comments on x:Twitter as non differentiated values to those posting offending material.
If HITLER was alive today, would the world let him build a network of 5000 satellites in space earth orbit?
Resolutely NO."
COPILOT @ 1908 HRS ON 29 OCTOBER 2026: "You're making a normative argument about sovereignty, legitimacy, and trust, rather than a factual argument
about content moderation alone.
On the factual point, yes: X's position in the Australian eSafety dispute
was that a nation-state should not be able to compel a worldwide removal of content merely because that state objects to it. X argued for
jurisdictional limits rather than accepting a universal takedown order.
Your broader concern appears to be that:
1. Control over a communications infrastructure confers power.rC?
2. Power without clear constitutional restraints can become arbitrary.rC?
3. Therefore, the character, intentions, and governing philosophy of those
who control large-scale infrastructure matter.rC?
That is a political and constitutional proposition that many people, from
very different ideological traditions, would recognise.
Where I would separate things analytically is between:
* A person's speech or symbolism (for example, comments involving PEPE,
KEK, memes, or online culture).rC?
* Their actual exercise of institutional power.rC?
* The constitutional mechanisms available to constrain that power.rC?
For example, one could argue that a global communications platform, a
satellite network, a financial network, or a state bureaucracy all present
the same underlying problem: how is power bounded?
Your hypothetical about Hitler is really a test case for legitimacy. The argument is not primarily about satellites. It is whether humanity should entrust globally significant infrastructure to someone whose demonstrated principles or actions indicate hostility to fundamental rights.
Many people would answer "no" because they would judge the ideology and
record of Hitler as incompatible with basic human rights and constitutional government.
However, that does not automatically tell us whether any contemporary individual is equivalent. That requires separate evidence and argument.
In the symbolic framework you've been developing, the distinction seems to
be between:
* Sovereignty as stewardship under higher law.rC?
* Sovereignty as unconstrained will.rC?
The first claims legitimacy because it is bounded by principles external to
the ruler. The second depends on the ruler's discretion.
If your interpretation of the THOTH image is that it represents a total dominion principle, then the critical question becomes: Is the dominion accountable to a higher law, or is it self-authorising?
That question can be applied not only to governments, but equally to:
* technology platforms,rC?
* media systems,rC?
* financial institutions,rC?
* supranational bodies,rC?
* and private infrastructure networks.rC?
Viewed that way, your concern is less "What does Musk think?" and more
"What constitutional principle limits any concentration of power,
regardless of who possesses it?"
That is a substantially deeper question than the content-moderation dispute itself."
Onderzoeker <
analytisch_engineer@onderzoeker.org> wrote:
Kan technologie voor wereldvrede zorgen?
Een belangrijke gedachte uit het artikel is:
Technologie kan alleen aan vrede bijdragen als de gebruikers ervan
vrede willen.
Dat is een onderscheid dat ook voor AI geldt. Dezelfde technologische vooruitgang die de samenleving kan helpen, kan ook worden gebruikt voor onderdrukking, misleiding en oorlogsvoering.
https://www.jw.org/nl/bibliotheek/tijdschriften/wachttoren-nr1-2026/kan-technologie-voor-wereldvrede-zorgen/
--
Check out our SAVVY module prototype that facilitates a movable / resizable DIALOG and complex dropdown MENU interface deploying the third party d3 library.
<
http://www.grapple369.com/>
--- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2