Dear alt.usage.english,
Why are there /magic users/ at all? What's wrong with terms like
"magician," "sorcerer," "wizard" and the like?
Dear alt.usage.english,
Why are there /magic users/ at all? What's wrong with terms like
"magician," "sorcerer," "wizard" and the like? Is it because we
don't want to admit people in the real world don't have innate magic
and resort to merely /use it/?
Dear alt.usage.english,
Why are there /magic users/ at all?-a What's wrong with terms like "magician," "sorcerer," "wizard" and the like?-a Is it because we
don't want to admit people in the real world don't have innate magic
and resort to merely /use it/?
I'm honestly not sure what happened, but some time in the last 30 or 40 years, (more?) people came users of magic rather than possessing it inn- ately.-a I just do not recall this being a term in the 70s, 80s, and 90s fantasy fiction I read, but now it's everywhere.-a Maybe my memory is
wrong, but titles like "magician" and "sorcerer;" even "warlock" sound
much more impressive than a mere /magic user/.
Note: this term seems to recur a lot in the fantasy fiction of the type litRPG which I have developed an extreme distaste for in recent years.
It was a fun gimmick the first time, but now it's boring. [...]
Question: now that technology is become opaque, and with Arthur C.
Clarke in mind-|, is there a risk of it being taken for magic? How is the idea of magic faring in this less and less rational age?
Dear alt.usage.english,
Why are there /magic users/ at all? What's wrong with terms like "magician," "sorcerer," "wizard" and the like? Is it because we
don't want to admit people in the real world don't have innate magic
and resort to merely /use it/?
I'm honestly not sure what happened, but some time in the last 30 or 40 years, (more?) people came users of magic rather than possessing it inn- ately. I just do not recall this being a term in the 70s, 80s, and 90s fantasy fiction I read, but now it's everywhere. Maybe my memory is--
wrong, but titles like "magician" and "sorcerer;" even "warlock" sound
much more impressive than a mere /magic user/.
Note: this term seems to recur a lot in the fantasy fiction of the type litRPG which I have developed an extreme distaste for in recent years.
It was a fun gimmick the first time, but now it's boring.
Dear alt.usage.english,
Why are there /magic users/ at all? What's wrong with terms like
"magician," "sorcerer," "wizard" and the like? Is it because we
don't want to admit people in the real world don't have innate magic
and resort to merely /use it/?
I'm honestly not sure what happened, but some time in the last 30 or 40 years, (more?) people came users of magic rather than possessing it inn- ately. I just do not recall this being a term in the 70s, 80s, and 90s fantasy fiction I read, but now it's everywhere. Maybe my memory is
wrong, but titles like "magician" and "sorcerer;" even "warlock" sound
much more impressive than a mere /magic user/.
Note: this term seems to recur a lot in the fantasy fiction of the type litRPG which I have developed an extreme distaste for in recent years.
It was a fun gimmick the first time, but now it's boring.
On 2026-11-05, Johann 'Myrkraverk' Oskarsson wrote:
Dear alt.usage.english,
Why are there /magic users/ at all? What's wrong with terms like
"magician," "sorcerer," "wizard" and the like? Is it because we
don't want to admit people in the real world don't have innate magic
and resort to merely /use it/?
I'm honestly not sure what happened, but some time in the last 30 or 40
years, (more?) people came users of magic rather than possessing it inn-
ately. I just do not recall this being a term in the 70s, 80s, and 90s
fantasy fiction I read, but now it's everywhere. Maybe my memory is
wrong, but titles like "magician" and "sorcerer;" even "warlock" sound
much more impressive than a mere /magic user/.
Note: this term seems to recur a lot in the fantasy fiction of the type
litRPG which I have developed an extreme distaste for in recent years.
It was a fun gimmick the first time, but now it's boring.
ISTR "magic user" was the general term for the character class in
AD&D, with "mage", "wizard", "sorcerer", &c., referring to specific
levels.
On 06/11/2026 10:02, Adam Funk wrote:
On 2026-11-05, Johann 'Myrkraverk' Oskarsson wrote:
Dear alt.usage.english,
Why are there /magic users/ at all?-a What's wrong with terms like
"magician," "sorcerer," "wizard" and the like?-a Is it because we
don't want to admit people in the real world don't have innate magic
and resort to merely /use it/?
I'm honestly not sure what happened, but some time in the last 30 or 40
years, (more?) people came users of magic rather than possessing it inn- >>> ately.-a I just do not recall this being a term in the 70s, 80s, and 90s >>> fantasy fiction I read, but now it's everywhere.-a Maybe my memory is
wrong, but titles like "magician" and "sorcerer;" even "warlock" sound
much more impressive than a mere /magic user/.
Note: this term seems to recur a lot in the fantasy fiction of the type
litRPG which I have developed an extreme distaste for in recent years.
It was a fun gimmick the first time, but now it's boring.
ISTR "magic user" was the general term for the character class in
AD&D, with "mage", "wizard", "sorcerer", &c., referring to specific
levels.
Wouldn't "magic user" be more appropriate for the character who stumbles across that magic lamp (or magic bean, or charmed amulet or...)?
I.e. Someone who has zero magic skills, but owns a gadget that does the
job for them.
Ar an s|-i|| l|i de m|! na Samhna, scr|!obh Johann Oskarsson:
Dear alt.usage.english,
Why are there /magic users/ at all? What's wrong with terms like "magician," "sorcerer," "wizard" and the like? Is it because we
don't want to admit people in the real world don't have innate magic
and resort to merely /use it/?
IrCOve never come across the term. I havenrCOt read any fantasy (Neal Stephenson
and Gabriel Garc|!a M|irquez in Spanish excepted) since about 1998.
Something within medicine (mainly in US sources) that has changed in the last >15 years is that rCLspeak to your doctorrCY has changed to rCLspeak to your >healthcare provider.rCY This is mainly because of the spread of nurse >practitioners and physician assistants in the country. IrCOd be surprised if >there were a similar dynamic at play in fantasy novels!
--I'm honestly not sure what happened, but some time in the last 30 or 40 years, (more?) people came users of magic rather than possessing it inn- ately. I just do not recall this being a term in the 70s, 80s, and 90s fantasy fiction I read, but now it's everywhere. Maybe my memory is
wrong, but titles like "magician" and "sorcerer;" even "warlock" sound
much more impressive than a mere /magic user/.
Note: this term seems to recur a lot in the fantasy fiction of the type litRPG which I have developed an extreme distaste for in recent years.
It was a fun gimmick the first time, but now it's boring.
Something within medicine (mainly in US sources) that has changed in the last 15 years is that rCLspeak to your doctorrCY has changed to rCLspeak to your healthcare provider.rCY This is mainly because of the spread of nurse practitioners and physician assistants in the country. IrCOd be surprised if there were a similar dynamic at play in fantasy novels! [...]
Le 06/11/2026 |a 09:20, Aidan Kehoe a |-crit :
Something within medicine (mainly in US sources) that has changed in
the last
15 years is that rCLspeak to your doctorrCY has changed to rCLspeak to your >> healthcare provider.rCY This is mainly because of the spread of nurse
practitioners and physician assistants in the country. IrCOd be
surprised if
there were a similar dynamic at play in fantasy novels! [...]
I think I'd call nurses, pharmacists, etc. 'healthcare
professionals' (though I don't like the term; it's long and clumsy).
I'm
with Steve in seeing a 'healthcare provider' as the NHS or some private outfit (e.g. our local dental practice).
Le 06/11/2026 |a 09:20, Aidan Kehoe a |-crit :
Something within medicine (mainly in US sources) that has changed in the last
15 years is that rCLspeak to your doctorrCY has changed to rCLspeak to your >> healthcare provider.rCY This is mainly because of the spread of nurse
practitioners and physician assistants in the country. IrCOd be surprised if >> there were a similar dynamic at play in fantasy novels! [...]
I think I'd call nurses, pharmacists, etc. 'healthcare professionals' >(though I don't like the term; it's long and clumsy). I'm with Steve in >seeing a 'healthcare provider' as the NHS or some private outfit (e.g.
our local dental practice).
Last week I went in for some tests that my GP had ordered on my
previous visit 6 months ago. I would gi for the test, and when I
visited by GP a couple of days later he would have the results in
front of him.
This time it caused consternation because the doctor who ordered the
texts "doesn't work here any more". They arranged a new doctor, who
is now my new GP, but my "healthcare provider" is still Medicross.
On 07/11/26 13:44, Steve Hayes wrote:
Last week I went in for some tests that my GP had ordered on my previous visit 6 months ago. I would gi for the test, and when I visited by GP a couple of days later he would have the results in front of him.
This time it caused consternation because the doctor who ordered the texts "doesn't work here any more". They arranged a new doctor, who is now my new GP, but my "healthcare provider" is still Medicross.
Sometimes my regular GP is on leave or otherwise unavailable, so I see someone else in the same practice. He is able to look up my record, including test results.
But perhaps that's because in Australia we have the option of having our medical records stored centrally. That's a bit of a privacy violation, and one of these days my medical history will appear on the dark web, but it's still an advantage when you're moving from hospital to specialist to GP and so on, and all of them need access to things like a list of prescription drugs, allergies, past surgeries, etc.
Sometimes my regular GP is on leave or otherwise unavailable, so I see someone else in the same practice. He is able to look up my record,
including test results.
But perhaps that's because in Australia we have the option of having our medical records stored centrally.
That's a bit of a privacy violation,
and one of these days my medical history will appear on the dark web,
but it's still an advantage when you're moving from hospital to
specialist to GP and so on, and all of them need access to things like a
list of prescription drugs, allergies, past surgeries, etc.
But perhaps that's because in Australia we have the option of having our >medical records stored centrally.
I think I'd call nurses, pharmacists, etc. 'healthcare professionals' >(though I don't like the term; it's long and clumsy).
In article <nl80j0Fufm6U1@mid.individual.net>,
Hibou <vpaereru-unmonitored@yahoo.com.invalid> wrote:
I think I'd call nurses, pharmacists, etc. 'healthcare professionals'
(though I don't like the term; it's long and clumsy).
There are a number of universities that have a School of Nursing and
Allied Health Professions or words to that effect, since nurses are
now so expensive and in such short supply that there is a great demand
for licensed and/or certified not-quite-nurses to do jobs that don't
require a full nursing education.
Garrett Wollman hat am 07.11.2026 um 19:54 geschrieben:
In article <nl80j0Fufm6U1@mid.individual.net>,
Hibou <vpaereru-unmonitored@yahoo.com.invalid> wrote:
I think I'd call nurses, pharmacists, etc. 'healthcare professionals'
(though I don't like the term; it's long and clumsy).
There are a number of universities that have a School of Nursing and
Allied Health Professions or words to that effect, since nurses are
now so expensive and in such short supply that there is a great demand
for licensed and/or certified not-quite-nurses to do jobs that don't
require a full nursing education.
Where? I'm sure that there are different problems in South Africa, NZ,
the US, Ireland, India etc.
There is a centralised database of prescription medications dispensed
for patients with medical cards (roughly US Medicare plus Medicaid,
based on income threshold, discretionary for those diagnosed with
cancer), a huge proportion of those with serious disease, but the
Health Service Executive chooses not to make that available at the
point of care. I understand they assert there are data protection
concerns with this. This could be addressed around by having explicit
consent for sharing this information with doctors treating patients
on the application form for the medical card, which would avoid the
very common problem of the medical SHO clerking in the patient at
02:00 after the patient presented at 14:00 and no reliable medication
list available, no family reachable.
In article <nl80j0Fufm6U1@mid.individual.net>, Hibou <vpaereru-unmonitored@yahoo.com.invalid> wrote:
I think I'd call nurses, pharmacists, etc. 'healthcare
professionals' (though I don't like the term; it's long and
clumsy).
There are a number of universities that have a School of Nursing and
Allied Health Professions or words to that effect, since nurses are
now so expensive and in such short supply that there is a great
demand for licensed and/or certified not-quite-nurses to do jobs
that don't require a full nursing education.
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 59:26:10 |
| Calls: | 1,265 |
| Calls today: | 1 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
4 files (9,632K bytes) |
| Messages: | 286,017 |