When Gen found the first Billie Eilish idol and read the note, it said
it would boomerang back to her if the person she gives it to gets voted
out with the idol still in their pocket. Is that the only way she can
get it back? Let's say Gen finds the Knowledge is Power Advantage and
ends up on the same tribe as Ozzy. Can she use the KIP to get back the
BEBI? If that's the case, the KIP could be very powerful this season. Keeping quiet about idols, etc. could be more important than ever.
On 3/11/2026 3:44 PM, Brian Smith wrote:
When Gen found the first Billie Eilish idol and read the note, it said
it would boomerang back to her if the person she gives it to gets
voted out with the idol still in their pocket. Is that the only way
she can get it back? Let's say Gen finds the Knowledge is Power
Advantage and ends up on the same tribe as Ozzy. Can she use the KIP
to get back the BEBI? If that's the case, the KIP could be very
powerful this season. Keeping quiet about idols, etc. could be more
important than ever.
This is one of the reasons I hate all these gimmicks - you need a law
degree to unscramble all the rules and exceptions, etc.-a I have no idea what the rules would be in this case - there could be something in
either the Eilish idol rules or maybe the KIP rules that would address this.-a I think there was something said that you could not give the
Eilish idol away or play it on another person, so maybe there is also
some loophole in the KIP rules that would cover this.
On 3/11/2026 2:01 PM, Rick wrote:
On 3/11/2026 3:44 PM, Brian Smith wrote:
When Gen found the first Billie Eilish idol and read the note, it
said it would boomerang back to her if the person she gives it to
gets voted out with the idol still in their pocket. Is that the only
way she can get it back? Let's say Gen finds the Knowledge is Power
Advantage and ends up on the same tribe as Ozzy. Can she use the KIP
to get back the BEBI? If that's the case, the KIP could be very
powerful this season. Keeping quiet about idols, etc. could be more
important than ever.
This is one of the reasons I hate all these gimmicks - you need a law
degree to unscramble all the rules and exceptions, etc.-a I have no
idea what the rules would be in this case - there could be something
in either the Eilish idol rules or maybe the KIP rules that would
address this.-a I think there was something said that you could not
give the Eilish idol away or play it on another person, so maybe there
is also some loophole in the KIP rules that would cover this.
I hate that as viewers we never seem to know the complete rules. I can
see the KIP outranking Billie's idol. Then again, wasn't there some
nonsense about a power in a very recent season where it ended up not
being as powerful as we thought it was?
On 3/11/2026 4:30 PM, Brian Smith wrote:
On 3/11/2026 2:01 PM, Rick wrote:
On 3/11/2026 3:44 PM, Brian Smith wrote:
When Gen found the first Billie Eilish idol and read the note, it
said it would boomerang back to her if the person she gives it to
gets voted out with the idol still in their pocket. Is that the only
way she can get it back? Let's say Gen finds the Knowledge is Power
Advantage and ends up on the same tribe as Ozzy. Can she use the KIP
to get back the BEBI? If that's the case, the KIP could be very
powerful this season. Keeping quiet about idols, etc. could be more
important than ever.
This is one of the reasons I hate all these gimmicks - you need a law
degree to unscramble all the rules and exceptions, etc.-a I have no
idea what the rules would be in this case - there could be something
in either the Eilish idol rules or maybe the KIP rules that would
address this.-a I think there was something said that you could not
give the Eilish idol away or play it on another person, so maybe
there is also some loophole in the KIP rules that would cover this.
I hate that as viewers we never seem to know the complete rules. I can
see the KIP outranking Billie's idol. Then again, wasn't there some
nonsense about a power in a very recent season where it ended up not
being as powerful as we thought it was?
Yes, just last season, in TC Sophi tried to use KIP to steal Steven's advantage, which was a block-a-vote he had seemingly not used yet.-a But
the twist was that he had to tell producers before TC he was using it,
which meant he had technically already used it even though the other
players hadn't seen the results yet.-a So it was a major embarrassment
for Sophi, even though she played the KIP in good faith.
Regarding the Eilish idol, since the show has made such a big deal about this and gotten a major star to put her name on it, do you really think
they would just allow it to be neutered so easily by the KIP?-a I'm
guessing the KIP is either not in the game this season, or there are loopholes galore in the fine print that won't allow it to be used to
obtain "special" idols with special rules like this one.
On 3/11/2026 3:36 PM, Rick wrote:
On 3/11/2026 4:30 PM, Brian Smith wrote:
On 3/11/2026 2:01 PM, Rick wrote:
On 3/11/2026 3:44 PM, Brian Smith wrote:
When Gen found the first Billie Eilish idol and read the note, it
said it would boomerang back to her if the person she gives it to
gets voted out with the idol still in their pocket. Is that the
only way she can get it back? Let's say Gen finds the Knowledge is
Power Advantage and ends up on the same tribe as Ozzy. Can she use
the KIP to get back the BEBI? If that's the case, the KIP could be
very powerful this season. Keeping quiet about idols, etc. could be >>>>> more important than ever.
This is one of the reasons I hate all these gimmicks - you need a
law degree to unscramble all the rules and exceptions, etc.-a I have
no idea what the rules would be in this case - there could be
something in either the Eilish idol rules or maybe the KIP rules
that would address this.-a I think there was something said that you
could not give the Eilish idol away or play it on another person, so
maybe there is also some loophole in the KIP rules that would cover
this.
I hate that as viewers we never seem to know the complete rules. I
can see the KIP outranking Billie's idol. Then again, wasn't there
some nonsense about a power in a very recent season where it ended up
not being as powerful as we thought it was?
Yes, just last season, in TC Sophi tried to use KIP to steal Steven's
advantage, which was a block-a-vote he had seemingly not used yet.
But the twist was that he had to tell producers before TC he was using
it, which meant he had technically already used it even though the
other players hadn't seen the results yet.-a So it was a major
embarrassment for Sophi, even though she played the KIP in good faith.
I thought it was last season and involved the KIP. Now that you've
described what happened I remember it well.
Regarding the Eilish idol, since the show has made such a big deal
about this and gotten a major star to put her name on it, do you
really think they would just allow it to be neutered so easily by the
KIP?-a I'm guessing the KIP is either not in the game this season, or
there are loopholes galore in the fine print that won't allow it to be
used to obtain "special" idols with special rules like this one.
I can't see their not being at least one KIP given that SITDs are still
in the game. I was only expecting one boomerang idol so I can see it
being trumped by a KIP. Too much blindside potential for Jeff to give
up. Also, she contacted the show with the idea so they really didn't
have to do anything other than incorporate it into the season. She's
also a legit Survivor superfan. Here's a blurb from an article at the
start of the season.
First things first: Eilish is a Survivor superfan.
Her 2022 song "TV" even included the lyrics, "I put on Survivor just to watch somebody suffer/Maybe I should get some sleep/Sinking in the sofa while they all betray each other/What's the point of anything?" Plus,
she told Variety in 2023, "I kinda wanna go on it. I think that the
physical stuff, I'd be great at. But you have to do math and sh-t, and I would not be good at that."
Source: https://www.goldderby.com/reality-tv/2026/survivor-50-billie-eilish-boomerang-idol-explained/
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 65 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 05:52:11 |
| Calls: | 862 |
| Files: | 1,311 |
| D/L today: |
921 files (14,318M bytes) |
| Messages: | 264,697 |