• S51 Ep 08 Spoilers and Comments (11/11/2026)

    From Brian Smith@dcg_brian@hotmail.com to alt.tv.survivor on Wed Nov 11 11:56:33 2026
    From Newsgroup: alt.tv.survivor

    Tonight's episode is titled "Load the Ark, Two by Two." From one of the
    sneak peek clips we know that the title comes from Carter. We also know
    that the treemail they get about pairing up is not clear as to whether
    or not they are competing as pairs or if they are competing against
    their chosen partner which is good.

    More later.
    --
    Brian
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Rick@Rick@nospam.net to alt.tv.survivor on Thu Nov 12 00:23:32 2026
    From Newsgroup: alt.tv.survivor

    On 11/11/2026 1:56 PM, Brian Smith wrote:
    Tonight's episode is titled "Load the Ark, Two by Two." From one of the sneak peek clips we know that the title comes from Carter. We also know
    that the treemail they get about pairing up is not clear as to whether
    or not they are competing as pairs or if they are competing against
    their chosen partner which is good.

    More later.


    I thought one of the most intriguing things about this episode was Brady asking to be let off of the jury so he could home to take care of his
    thumb. On paper, that presumably means a jury of nine with likely three finalists, which could result in a 3-3-3 tie with no obvious tie-break
    scheme. Even if they decided to go with two finalists instead of three,
    that would imply a jury of 10 which could still split evenly 5-5.

    I can think of three likely alternatives for how to address this:

    -- I don't remember if they ever did this in the US, but on some
    international seasons they offer an advantage at some point where a
    player can effectively dismiss someone from the jury, which would revert
    it back to 8 jurors.

    -- They could also offer an advantage which would allow a player to give
    a juror of their choosing an extra vote, which would also break the tie.

    -- In the event of a tie, they could literally do a fire challenge to
    decide the winner. This could be a problem if they read the votes live,
    since it could mess up the timing of the finale, but if they record it
    in advance, it might work.

    The only previous time I remember this being a real possibility was
    Survivor 16 which had an unplanned final two and an 8-person jury. They supposedly had a tie-break plan ready to go, but I don't think it has
    ever been revealed what they would do, especially with a live vote read.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Zeppo@reg@telus.invalid to alt.tv.survivor on Thu Nov 12 11:56:31 2026
    From Newsgroup: alt.tv.survivor

    On Nov 11, 2026, Rick wrote
    (in article <11d3igi$39tp6$1@dont-email.me>):


    I thought one of the most intriguing things about this episode was Brady asking to be let off of the jury so he could home to take care of his
    thumb.

    I suspect that the thumb was just an excuse. IMO, it was more likely that
    Brady went into a major sulk which left him wanting to get away from the
    game as quickly as possible.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Brian Smith@dcg_brian@hotmail.com to alt.tv.survivor on Thu Nov 12 12:09:10 2026
    From Newsgroup: alt.tv.survivor

    On 11/12/2026 11:56 AM, Zeppo wrote:
    On Nov 11, 2026, Rick wrote
    (in article <11d3igi$39tp6$1@dont-email.me>):


    I thought one of the most intriguing things about this episode was Brady
    asking to be let off of the jury so he could home to take care of his
    thumb.

    I suspect that the thumb was just an excuse. IMO, it was more likely that Brady went into a major sulk which left him wanting to get away from the
    game as quickly as possible.

    I agree. When the accident first happened he was practically begging the doctor to let him stay in the game saying he could handle it. If he
    could handle the game then Pondy should have been a piece of cake.
    --
    Brian
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Rick@Rick@nospam.net to alt.tv.survivor on Thu Nov 12 14:23:15 2026
    From Newsgroup: alt.tv.survivor

    On 11/12/2026 2:09 PM, Brian Smith wrote:
    On 11/12/2026 11:56 AM, Zeppo wrote:
    On Nov 11, 2026, Rick wrote
    (in article <11d3igi$39tp6$1@dont-email.me>):


    I thought one of the most intriguing things about this episode was Brady >>> asking to be let off of the jury so he could home to take care of his
    thumb.

    I suspect that the thumb was just an excuse. IMO, it was more likely that
    Brady went into a major sulk which left him wanting to get away from the
    game as quickly as possible.

    I agree. When the accident first happened he was practically begging the doctor to let him stay in the game saying he could handle it. If he
    could handle the game then Pondy should have been a piece of cake.


    It's also worth noting that in post game interviews, he said no
    additional surgery was required and the piece that was cut off basically
    just "grew back". The show had kept the original thumb fragment that was
    cut off in a cooler and returned it to him but he wasn't allowed to take
    human flesh out of the country due to restrictions on taking flesh out
    of the country. So the show's art department apparently encased it in
    resin and fashioned a sort of fake immunity idol type artifact for him
    that he was able to take with him. He then got back to the US and made
    it into a necklace. I can't make this stuff up.

    I think the real reason he came home is that he knew he wasn't going to
    make much for his time on the show and he wanted to get back to pro
    wrestling.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Brian Smith@dcg_brian@hotmail.com to alt.tv.survivor on Thu Nov 12 12:30:07 2026
    From Newsgroup: alt.tv.survivor

    On 11/12/2026 12:23 PM, Rick wrote:
    On 11/12/2026 2:09 PM, Brian Smith wrote:
    On 11/12/2026 11:56 AM, Zeppo wrote:
    On Nov 11, 2026, Rick wrote
    (in article <11d3igi$39tp6$1@dont-email.me>):


    I thought one of the most intriguing things about this episode was
    Brady
    asking to be let off of the jury so he could home to take care of his
    thumb.

    I suspect that the thumb was just an excuse. IMO, it was more likely
    that
    Brady went into a major sulk which left him wanting to get away from the >>> game as quickly as possible.

    I agree. When the accident first happened he was practically begging
    the doctor to let him stay in the game saying he could handle it. If
    he could handle the game then Pondy should have been a piece of cake.


    It's also worth noting that in post game interviews, he said no
    additional surgery was required and the piece that was cut off basically just "grew back". The show had kept the original thumb fragment that was
    cut off in a cooler and returned it to him but he wasn't allowed to take human flesh out of the country due to restrictions on taking flesh out
    of the country.-a So the show's art department apparently encased it in resin and fashioned a sort of fake immunity idol type artifact for him
    that he was able to take with him.-a He then got back to the US and made
    it into a necklace.-a I can't make this stuff up.

    Very interesting. Did Fiji have a problem at one time with human flesh
    being taken out of the country?

    I think the real reason he came home is that he knew he wasn't going to
    make much for his time on the show and he wanted to get back to pro wrestling.

    I wouldn't be surprised if that was the case. He probably did Survivor
    in the hopes of reviving his career. He definitely talked about it nonstop.
    --
    Brian
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Brian Smith@dcg_brian@hotmail.com to alt.tv.survivor on Thu Nov 12 12:44:58 2026
    From Newsgroup: alt.tv.survivor

    On 11/11/2026 10:23 PM, Rick wrote:
    On 11/11/2026 1:56 PM, Brian Smith wrote:
    Tonight's episode is titled "Load the Ark, Two by Two." From one of
    the sneak peek clips we know that the title comes from Carter. We also
    know that the treemail they get about pairing up is not clear as to
    whether or not they are competing as pairs or if they are competing
    against their chosen partner which is good.

    More later.


    I thought one of the most intriguing things about this episode was Brady asking to be let off of the jury so he could home to take care of his thumb.-a On paper, that presumably means a jury of nine with likely three finalists, which could result in a 3-3-3 tie with no obvious tie-break scheme.-a Even if they decided to go with two finalists instead of three, that would imply a jury of 10 which could still split evenly 5-5.

    I can think of three likely alternatives for how to address this:

    -- I don't remember if they ever did this in the US, but on some international seasons they offer an advantage at some point where a
    player can effectively dismiss someone from the jury, which would revert
    it back to 8 jurors.

    U.S. Survivor has done the jury dismissal thing. IIRC, it was a S3x
    season but it might have been earlier than that.

    -- They could also offer an advantage which would allow a player to give
    a juror of their choosing an extra vote, which would also break the tie.

    -- In the event of a tie, they could literally do a fire challenge to
    decide the winner.-a This could be a problem if they read the votes live, since it could mess up the timing of the finale, but if they record it
    in advance, it might work.

    The only previous time I remember this being a real possibility was
    Survivor 16 which had an unplanned final two and an 8-person jury.-a They supposedly had a tie-break plan ready to go, but I don't think it has
    ever been revealed what they would do, especially with a live vote read.

    A tie vote with a F2 and an even number of jurors has already happened. Wendell vs. Dom in S36(?). They had a tie vote and it was the third
    place finisher who cast the tie-breaker vote.

    I can see that happening this season. When Brady quit jury they probably switched to a F2 plan with the S36 tie breaker. At one of the S51
    preseason promo events Jeff did he was asked if they would ever do a F2
    season again. Surprisingly, Jeff said yes which goes against everything
    he's said since S36(?). He was actually a little too excited when giving
    his answer. Now that we know Brady quit the jury, I'm thinking Jeff's
    reaction at the promo event was because it they had already done it in S51.
    --
    Brian
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Brian Smith@dcg_brian@hotmail.com to alt.tv.survivor on Thu Nov 12 13:06:24 2026
    From Newsgroup: alt.tv.survivor

    On 11/11/2026 11:56 AM, Brian Smith wrote:
    Tonight's episode is titled "Load the Ark, Two by Two." From one of the sneak peek clips we know that the title comes from Carter. We also know
    that the treemail they get about pairing up is not clear as to whether
    or not they are competing as pairs or if they are competing against
    their chosen partner which is good.

    More later.

    I thought this was a very good episode that was well edited. I didn't
    like how the twist screwed over Kristin but that's reality TV for you.

    --I thought Shondra had a very strong episode. She totally outsmarted
    Thien An which saved Devin and Jelly from being sure boots. WTH was
    Thien An thinking telling Shondra she was going to vote for Devin and
    Jelly after Shondra had told her she didn't have to say? Shondra was
    also smart to vote for Devin and Jelly to hide that she's with them.

    --Devin and Jelly were smart to split their votes in case of idols, etc.
    being played.

    --I didn't understand the logic behind only allowing one player to play
    their SITD.

    --Lewis pumping up Shondra when he chose her was interesting. The fact
    they won the challenge has me wondering if they will team up to get to
    the end. Lewis needs her to replace Kilby and Shondra needs him to
    counter being the third wheel with Devin and Jelly.

    --Cristian successfully playing his SITD was apparently just the third
    time this has happened. Saved his and Carter's butts and allowed Carter
    to keep his HII.

    --I take it Kristin's tethered idol is now officially dead and out of
    the game?

    --I'm not surprised Mike survived this cycle.

    --Is Jelly in trouble now that she played her HII and that Kilby and
    Kristin are out?

    --Eric was even more annoying this episode than in the past. I had to
    laugh at the look on his face when Lewis selected Jelly and not him for
    the reward meal. What was Eric doing when he didn't play the extra vote Cristian gave him? He's so frickin' cocky.
    --
    Brian
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Zeppo@reg@telus.invalid to alt.tv.survivor on Thu Nov 12 13:19:33 2026
    From Newsgroup: alt.tv.survivor

    On Nov 12, 2026, Brian Smith wrote
    (in article <11d54vu$86nl$1@dont-email.me>):


    U.S. Survivor has done the jury dismissal thing. IIRC, it was a S3x
    season but it might have been earlier than that.

    It was in Michele FitzgeraldrCOs season. She won a challenge towards
    the end of the game which allowed her to dismiss one of the jury
    members. IIRC, she made a smart choice which factored into her
    win.

    A tie vote with a F2 and an even number of jurors has already happened. Wendell vs. Dom in S36(?). They had a tie vote and it was the third
    place finisher who cast the tie-breaker vote.

    Yes, Ghost Island. I remember it very well. Laurel Johnson (who I thought played a terrible game) ended up deciding the winner.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Rick@Rick@nospam.net to alt.tv.survivor on Thu Nov 12 15:14:21 2026
    From Newsgroup: alt.tv.survivor

    On 11/12/2026 2:44 PM, Brian Smith wrote:
    On 11/11/2026 10:23 PM, Rick wrote:
    On 11/11/2026 1:56 PM, Brian Smith wrote:
    Tonight's episode is titled "Load the Ark, Two by Two." From one of
    the sneak peek clips we know that the title comes from Carter. We
    also know that the treemail they get about pairing up is not clear as
    to whether or not they are competing as pairs or if they are
    competing against their chosen partner which is good.

    More later.


    I thought one of the most intriguing things about this episode was
    Brady asking to be let off of the jury so he could home to take care
    of his thumb.-a On paper, that presumably means a jury of nine with
    likely three finalists, which could result in a 3-3-3 tie with no
    obvious tie-break scheme.-a Even if they decided to go with two
    finalists instead of three, that would imply a jury of 10 which could
    still split evenly 5-5.

    I can think of three likely alternatives for how to address this:

    -- I don't remember if they ever did this in the US, but on some
    international seasons they offer an advantage at some point where a
    player can effectively dismiss someone from the jury, which would
    revert it back to 8 jurors.

    U.S. Survivor has done the jury dismissal thing. IIRC, it was a S3x
    season but it might have been earlier than that.

    -- They could also offer an advantage which would allow a player to
    give a juror of their choosing an extra vote, which would also break
    the tie.

    -- In the event of a tie, they could literally do a fire challenge to
    decide the winner.-a This could be a problem if they read the votes
    live, since it could mess up the timing of the finale, but if they
    record it in advance, it might work.

    The only previous time I remember this being a real possibility was
    Survivor 16 which had an unplanned final two and an 8-person jury.
    They supposedly had a tie-break plan ready to go, but I don't think it
    has ever been revealed what they would do, especially with a live vote
    read.

    A tie vote with a F2 and an even number of jurors has already happened. Wendell vs. Dom in S36(?). They had a tie vote and it was the third
    place finisher who cast the tie-breaker vote.


    The tie-break in Wendell's season was with a Final 3 and the third
    member just moved over to the jury. That wouldn't be the case with a two-person finale since the third place finisher would already be on the
    jury and already would have voted.


    I can see that happening this season. When Brady quit jury they probably switched to a F2 plan with the S36 tie breaker. At one of the S51
    preseason promo events Jeff did he was asked if they would ever do a F2 season again. Surprisingly, Jeff said yes which goes against everything
    he's said since S36(?). He was actually a little too excited when giving
    his answer. Now that we know Brady quit the jury, I'm thinking Jeff's reaction at the promo event was because it they had already done it in S51.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From shawn@nanoflower@notforg.m.a.i.l.com to alt.tv.survivor on Thu Nov 12 16:24:00 2026
    From Newsgroup: alt.tv.survivor

    On Thu, 12 Nov 2026 13:06:24 -0700, Brian Smith
    <dcg_brian@hotmail.com> wrote:

    On 11/11/2026 11:56 AM, Brian Smith wrote:
    Tonight's episode is titled "Load the Ark, Two by Two." From one of the
    sneak peek clips we know that the title comes from Carter. We also know
    that the treemail they get about pairing up is not clear as to whether
    or not they are competing as pairs or if they are competing against
    their chosen partner which is good.

    More later.

    I thought this was a very good episode that was well edited. I didn't
    like how the twist screwed over Kristin but that's reality TV for you.

    --I thought Shondra had a very strong episode. She totally outsmarted
    Thien An which saved Devin and Jelly from being sure boots. WTH was
    Thien An thinking telling Shondra she was going to vote for Devin and
    Jelly after Shondra had told her she didn't have to say? Shondra was
    also smart to vote for Devin and Jelly to hide that she's with them.

    --Devin and Jelly were smart to split their votes in case of idols, etc. >being played.

    --I didn't understand the logic behind only allowing one player to play >their SITD.

    --Lewis pumping up Shondra when he chose her was interesting. The fact
    they won the challenge has me wondering if they will team up to get to
    the end. Lewis needs her to replace Kilby and Shondra needs him to
    counter being the third wheel with Devin and Jelly.

    --Cristian successfully playing his SITD was apparently just the third
    time this has happened. Saved his and Carter's butts and allowed Carter
    to keep his HII.

    --I take it Kristin's tethered idol is now officially dead and out of
    the game?

    --I'm not surprised Mike survived this cycle.

    --Is Jelly in trouble now that she played her HII and that Kilby and
    Kristin are out?

    --Eric was even more annoying this episode than in the past. I had to
    laugh at the look on his face when Lewis selected Jelly and not him for
    the reward meal. What was Eric doing when he didn't play the extra vote >Cristian gave him? He's so frickin' cocky.

    That move, not playing the extra vote, was the one move I couldn't
    explain. Everything else I could up with a reason for the move, not
    necessarily one I agree with, but a reason for the move. Not playing
    the extra vote made no sense to me.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Rick@Rick@nospam.net to alt.tv.survivor on Thu Nov 12 16:41:34 2026
    From Newsgroup: alt.tv.survivor

    On 11/12/2026 3:19 PM, Zeppo wrote:
    On Nov 12, 2026, Brian Smith wrote
    (in article <11d54vu$86nl$1@dont-email.me>):


    U.S. Survivor has done the jury dismissal thing. IIRC, it was a S3x
    season but it might have been earlier than that.

    It was in Michele FitzgeraldrCOs season. She won a challenge towards
    the end of the game which allowed her to dismiss one of the jury
    members. IIRC, she made a smart choice which factored into her
    win.

    A tie vote with a F2 and an even number of jurors has already happened.
    Wendell vs. Dom in S36(?). They had a tie vote and it was the third
    place finisher who cast the tie-breaker vote.

    Yes, Ghost Island. I remember it very well. Laurel Johnson (who I thought played a terrible game) ended up deciding the winner.



    But that was actually a final three and Laurel was zero vote third place finisher. So she simply slid over to the jury and cast the tie-breaker
    vote. That wouldn't be possible in a two-person finale tie where the
    third place finisher already cast their vote. And it wouldn't be
    possible in a three-person finale where it gets tied 3-3-3.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Zeppo@reg@telus.invalid to alt.tv.survivor on Thu Nov 12 15:05:08 2026
    From Newsgroup: alt.tv.survivor

    On Nov 12, 2026, Brian Smith wrote
    (in article <11d5684$8n5r$1@dont-email.me>):


    I thought this was a very good episode that was well edited. I didn't
    like how the twist screwed over Kristin but that's reality TV for you.

    Objectively, it was a good episode. But the ending kind of ruined
    it for me. It was yet another example of why I despise the SITD.
    But, to be fair, if Christian had ended up not being safe, Carter
    would have just played his immunity and Kristin still would have
    been voted out.


    --I thought Shondra had a very strong episode. She totally outsmarted
    Thien An which saved Devin and Jelly from being sure boots. WTH was
    Thien An thinking telling Shondra she was going to vote for Devin and
    Jelly after Shondra had told her she didn't have to say? Shondra was
    also smart to vote for Devin and Jelly to hide that she's with them.

    IMO, she has looked great in practically every episode, and I think
    that either she or Lewis is going to win this season. There must
    have been more to the conversation between her and Thien An
    than was shown to us. I thought that it was uncharacteristic of her
    to just blurt out her voting intention to a person who was not a
    member of her alliance.


    --Devin and Jelly were smart to split their votes in case of idols, etc. being played.

    Yes, it was a very savvy move.


    --I didn't understand the logic behind only allowing one player to play
    their SITD.

    One SITD play per group seemed fair to me. Otherwise, TC ran the
    risk of becoming a rCLshotinthedark-o-ramarCY.

    --I take it Kristin's tethered idol is now officially dead and out of
    the game?

    ThatrCOs my understanding. It was interesting that Sharonda chose
    to tip off Angelica about the votes that were coming her way
    rather than keep her mouth shut which would have likelykept
    the TII in the game.

    --I'm not surprised Mike survived this cycle.

    Yes, whenever the first segment of an episode focuses on
    a player who rCLeverybodyrCY allegedly wants out, it is sure to
    be a rCLred herringrCY.


    --Is Jelly in trouble now that she played her HII and that Kilby and
    Kristin are out?

    I would like to hope so. But I predict that she and/or Dev will just
    find another one and carry on as usual.
    Speaking of Angelica, in E08 she doubled down on her claim that
    she is playing Survivor in order to find a boyfriend/husband. That
    just strikes me as kind of sad. :-)

    What was Eric doing when he didn't play the extra vote
    Cristian gave him? He's so frickin' cocky.

    He didnrCOt know that it was only good for the E08 TC. He will probably try
    to play it at some future tribal council which will result in a rebuke from Uncle J.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Zeppo@reg@telus.invalid to alt.tv.survivor on Thu Nov 12 15:27:19 2026
    From Newsgroup: alt.tv.survivor

    On Nov 12, 2026, shawn wrote
    (in article<ggbcfl5rumfkien78h5jvkqpnspeth325v@4ax.com>):


    That move, not playing the extra vote, was the one move I couldn't
    explain. Everything else I could up with a reason for the move, not necessarily one I agree with, but a reason for the move. Not playing
    the extra vote made no sense to me.

    Christian didnrCOt tell him that the extra vote could only be played at
    the E08 TC. Eric likely thinks that he can play it later on at a time
    of his choosing.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Rick@Rick@nospam.net to alt.tv.survivor on Thu Nov 12 18:47:11 2026
    From Newsgroup: alt.tv.survivor

    On 11/12/2026 4:24 PM, shawn wrote:
    On Thu, 12 Nov 2026 13:06:24 -0700, Brian Smith
    <dcg_brian@hotmail.com> wrote:

    On 11/11/2026 11:56 AM, Brian Smith wrote:
    Tonight's episode is titled "Load the Ark, Two by Two." From one of the
    sneak peek clips we know that the title comes from Carter. We also know
    that the treemail they get about pairing up is not clear as to whether
    or not they are competing as pairs or if they are competing against
    their chosen partner which is good.

    More later.

    I thought this was a very good episode that was well edited. I didn't
    like how the twist screwed over Kristin but that's reality TV for you.

    --I thought Shondra had a very strong episode. She totally outsmarted
    Thien An which saved Devin and Jelly from being sure boots. WTH was
    Thien An thinking telling Shondra she was going to vote for Devin and
    Jelly after Shondra had told her she didn't have to say? Shondra was
    also smart to vote for Devin and Jelly to hide that she's with them.

    --Devin and Jelly were smart to split their votes in case of idols, etc.
    being played.

    --I didn't understand the logic behind only allowing one player to play
    their SITD.

    --Lewis pumping up Shondra when he chose her was interesting. The fact
    they won the challenge has me wondering if they will team up to get to
    the end. Lewis needs her to replace Kilby and Shondra needs him to
    counter being the third wheel with Devin and Jelly.

    --Cristian successfully playing his SITD was apparently just the third
    time this has happened. Saved his and Carter's butts and allowed Carter
    to keep his HII.

    --I take it Kristin's tethered idol is now officially dead and out of
    the game?

    --I'm not surprised Mike survived this cycle.

    --Is Jelly in trouble now that she played her HII and that Kilby and
    Kristin are out?

    --Eric was even more annoying this episode than in the past. I had to
    laugh at the look on his face when Lewis selected Jelly and not him for
    the reward meal. What was Eric doing when he didn't play the extra vote
    Cristian gave him? He's so frickin' cocky.

    That move, not playing the extra vote, was the one move I couldn't
    explain. Everything else I could up with a reason for the move, not necessarily one I agree with, but a reason for the move. Not playing
    the extra vote made no sense to me.

    Only thing I could figure is he thought he could use it as a bluff at
    some point, though he can't really do that while Christian is still in
    the game. I'm pretty sure the parchment itself probably spells out the expiration, so he'd really have to just flash it and not let anyone look
    at it closely.

    Otherwise, he must have thought it would be a neat souvenir, assuming
    the show would even let him take it with him.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Brian Smith@dcg_brian@hotmail.com to alt.tv.survivor on Thu Nov 12 16:48:58 2026
    From Newsgroup: alt.tv.survivor

    On 11/12/2026 3:05 PM, Zeppo wrote:
    On Nov 12, 2026, Brian Smith wrote
    (in article <11d5684$8n5r$1@dont-email.me>):


    I thought this was a very good episode that was well edited. I didn't
    like how the twist screwed over Kristin but that's reality TV for you.

    Objectively, it was a good episode. But the ending kind of ruined
    it for me. It was yet another example of why I despise the SITD.
    But, to be fair, if Christian had ended up not being safe, Carter
    would have just played his immunity and Kristin still would have
    been voted out.

    Very true.

    --I thought Shondra had a very strong episode. She totally outsmarted
    Thien An which saved Devin and Jelly from being sure boots. WTH was
    Thien An thinking telling Shondra she was going to vote for Devin and
    Jelly after Shondra had told her she didn't have to say? Shondra was
    also smart to vote for Devin and Jelly to hide that she's with them.

    IMO, she has looked great in practically every episode, and I think
    that either she or Lewis is going to win this season. There must
    have been more to the conversation between her and Thien An
    than was shown to us. I thought that it was uncharacteristic of her
    to just blurt out her voting intention to a person who was not a
    member of her alliance.

    I agree. It was out of character for Thien An.
    --Devin and Jelly were smart to split their votes in case of idols, etc.
    being played.

    Yes, it was a very savvy move.


    --I didn't understand the logic behind only allowing one player to play
    their SITD.

    One SITD play per group seemed fair to me. Otherwise, TC ran the
    risk of becoming a rCLshotinthedark-o-ramarCY.

    --I take it Kristin's tethered idol is now officially dead and out of
    the game?

    ThatrCOs my understanding. It was interesting that Sharonda chose
    to tip off Angelica about the votes that were coming her way
    rather than keep her mouth shut which would have likelykept
    the TII in the game.

    --I'm not surprised Mike survived this cycle.

    Yes, whenever the first segment of an episode focuses on
    a player who rCLeverybodyrCY allegedly wants out, it is sure to
    be a rCLred herringrCY.


    --Is Jelly in trouble now that she played her HII and that Kilby and
    Kristin are out?

    I would like to hope so. But I predict that she and/or Dev will just
    find another one and carry on as usual.
    Speaking of Angelica, in E08 she doubled down on her claim that
    she is playing Survivor in order to find a boyfriend/husband. That
    just strikes me as kind of sad. :-)

    If that's her goal, she should have tried out for BB which has a pretty
    good record for marriages and kids.

    What was Eric doing when he didn't play the extra vote
    Cristian gave him? He's so frickin' cocky.

    He didnrCOt know that it was only good for the E08 TC. He will probably try to play it at some future tribal council which will result in a rebuke from Uncle J.

    He knew it was only good for that vote as Cristian had told him when he
    gave it to him.
    --
    Brian
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Zeppo@reg@telus.invalid to alt.tv.survivor on Thu Nov 12 17:15:21 2026
    From Newsgroup: alt.tv.survivor

    On Nov 12, 2026, Brian Smith wrote
    (in article <11d5j9e$dal1$1@dont-email.me>):

    He knew it was only good for that vote as Cristian had told him when he
    gave it to him.

    Christian: rCYEric, IrCOm giving you my extra vote. This is the best trust I can
    give you.rCY

    Eric: rCLOkay. What would you like me to vote?rCY

    Christian: rCLDev and Jelly.rCY

    Eric: rCLOkayrCY.

    Christian: rCLThank you.rCY

    Eric: YourCOre welcomerCY.

    They might have said some other things but, if they did, it wasnrCOt
    shared with the viewers. I would also add that if Eric knew that
    the extra vote was only good for the F12 TC, he surely would
    have played it as instructed. It seemed pretty clear that Eric
    thought that the advantage could be used at a future TC.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Zeppo@reg@telus.invalid to alt.tv.survivor on Thu Nov 12 17:30:28 2026
    From Newsgroup: alt.tv.survivor

    On Nov 12, 2026, Zeppo wrote
    (in article<0001HW.30A68E19000146A1170152687@news.easynews.com>):

    On Nov 12, 2026, Brian Smith wrote
    (in article <11d5j9e$dal1$1@dont-email.me>):

    He knew it was only good for that vote as Cristian had told him when he gave it to him.

    Christian: rCYEric, IrCOm giving you my extra vote. This is the best trust I can
    give you.rCY

    Eric: rCLOkay. What would you like me to vote?rCY

    Christian: rCLDev and Jelly.rCY

    Eric: rCLOkayrCY.

    Christian: rCLThank you.rCY

    Eric: YourCOre welcomerCY.

    They might have said some other things but, if they did, it wasnrCOt
    shared with the viewers. I would also add that if Eric knew that
    the extra vote was only good for the F12 TC, he surely would
    have played it as instructed. It seemed pretty clear that Eric
    thought that the advantage could be used at a future TC.

    Ha Ha! Please disregard all of the above. I went back and rewatched
    the entire TC and saw that Eric had read the words on the parchment
    aloud before he voted. So he clearly knew that the extra vote advantage
    was only good for the F12 TC. I wouldnrCOt be surprised to see him give
    the parchment back to Christian in E09, and explain why he didnrCOt use
    the advantage as instructed.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Brian Smith@dcg_brian@hotmail.com to alt.tv.survivor on Thu Nov 12 17:52:36 2026
    From Newsgroup: alt.tv.survivor

    On 11/12/2026 5:30 PM, Zeppo wrote:
    On Nov 12, 2026, Zeppo wrote
    (in article<0001HW.30A68E19000146A1170152687@news.easynews.com>):

    On Nov 12, 2026, Brian Smith wrote
    (in article <11d5j9e$dal1$1@dont-email.me>):

    He knew it was only good for that vote as Cristian had told him when he
    gave it to him.

    Christian: rCYEric, IrCOm giving you my extra vote. This is the best trust I >> can
    give you.rCY

    Eric: rCLOkay. What would you like me to vote?rCY

    Christian: rCLDev and Jelly.rCY

    Eric: rCLOkayrCY.

    Christian: rCLThank you.rCY

    Eric: YourCOre welcomerCY.

    They might have said some other things but, if they did, it wasnrCOt
    shared with the viewers. I would also add that if Eric knew that
    the extra vote was only good for the F12 TC, he surely would
    have played it as instructed. It seemed pretty clear that Eric
    thought that the advantage could be used at a future TC.

    Ha Ha! Please disregard all of the above. I went back and rewatched
    the entire TC and saw that Eric had read the words on the parchment
    aloud before he voted. So he clearly knew that the extra vote advantage
    was only good for the F12 TC. I wouldnrCOt be surprised to see him give
    the parchment back to Christian in E09, and explain why he didnrCOt use
    the advantage as instructed.

    The extra vote comes up in one of Kilby's exit interviews. Listen to
    what he says as it sounds like the plan might have changed last second.

    https://youtu.be/yjdgRVfUokc?si=cYDFRBrnkyqgJDMa&t=97
    --
    Brian
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2