• S51 Ep 04 Spoilers and Comments (10/14/2026)

    From Brian Smith@dcg_brian@hotmail.com to alt.tv.survivor on Wed Oct 14 17:26:44 2026
    From Newsgroup: alt.tv.survivor

    Tonight's episode is titled "ThatrCOs the Magic of Survivor." Sounds like something Jeff would say after he does something to mess with the game.

    More later.
    --
    Brian
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Rick@Rick@nospam.net to alt.tv.survivor on Thu Oct 15 13:25:56 2026
    From Newsgroup: alt.tv.survivor

    On 10/14/2026 7:26 PM, Brian Smith wrote:
    Tonight's episode is titled "ThatrCOs the Magic of Survivor." Sounds like something Jeff would say after he does something to mess with the game.

    More later.



    I've been trying to figure out why I dislike this season so much, and
    after last night's episode I can list the following reasons:

    1) Tremendous over-emphasis on male characters. It seems almost every confessional involves men, and the statistics seem to bear that out.
    According to Survivor Fact Checker, the confessional totals so far:

    rCo Devin Way: 26 confessionals (Season Leader)
    rCo Lewis Kelly: 20 confessionals
    rCo Danny rCLKilbyrCY Kilby: 19 confessionals
    rCo Brady Booker: 19 confessionals
    rCo Angelica rCLJellyrCY Loblack: 17 confessionals
    rCo Eric Macksoud: 15 confessionals
    rCo Carter Krull: 14 confessionals
    rCo Kristin Flickinger: 13 confessionals
    rCo Jenna Doore: 12 confessionals (Voted out in Episode 4)
    rCo Ori Jean-Charles: 11 confessionals
    rCo Linnea Capobianco: 11 confessionals
    rCo Sharonda Cox: 11 confessionals
    rCo Rob Antonson: 10 confessionals (Left the game in Episode 3)
    rCo Alexis Levine: 9 confessionals
    rCo Maggie Nestor: 8 confessionals
    rCo An rCLThien AnrCY Nguyen: 7 confessionals
    rCo Mike Pinsky: 7 confessionals
    rCo Patt Cannaday: 7 confessionals (Voted out in Episode 3)
    rCo Ana Sani: 6 confessionals (Voted out in Episode 2)
    rCo Aaliyah Puglia: 4 confessionals (Voted out in Episode 1)
    rCo Cristian Ch|ivez: 2 confessionals

    https://www.instagram.com/survivorfactchecker/p/DehZ2wEGpjh/

    The top four are all men and the top female, Jelly is almost ten below
    Deven, with many of those coming in the current episode. Even departed
    Rob has more confessionals than three women still in the game.

    2) Not only is the emphasis on male characters, but I really can't
    stand the leader Devin who comes across as swarmy and full of himself.
    I also don't care for number four Brady whose constant use of the
    made-up non-word "brody" is as annoying as annoying and off-putting as I
    can remember from any past contestant. In fact, of the top six men in confessionals, the only ones I can tolerate are Lewis and Carter. Of
    the other men, I don't really mind Ori and Mike, but I have to say with
    an amazingly low two confessionals, I still couldn't tell you a thing
    about Christian.

    3) Not only is the show itself emphasizing men, the cast itself has
    amazingly voted out women on all vote-outs so far. Without looking it
    up, I can't ever remember a season where the first four vote-outs were
    all women. I like many of the women in the game, like Kristin, Alexis,
    Thien An and Maggie, but we rarely hear much from from them.

    4) I of course hate the season mantra of "Permanent uncertainty" and I
    hate how every episode the producers coerce at least one player to artificially use the phrase in a confessional.

    5) I still get early 40s season vibes from some of the players,
    especially the obvious black "helicopter" alliance of Jelly, Devan and
    Ori which voted out Jenna, along with Sharonda and the departed Aaliyah.
    Although race isn't being openly discussed, there are clear
    undercurrents.

    6) I really don't care for the amount of time spent on the Kilby-Eric "bromance". I don't like either of these guys to begin with, and the
    amount of time spent on this was pretty unseemly.

    I hope things start to change, but so far this is a pretty blah season
    for me.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Brian Smith@dcg_brian@hotmail.com to alt.tv.survivor on Thu Oct 15 11:43:49 2026
    From Newsgroup: alt.tv.survivor

    On 10/15/2026 10:25 AM, Rick wrote:
    On 10/14/2026 7:26 PM, Brian Smith wrote:
    Tonight's episode is titled "ThatrCOs the Magic of Survivor." Sounds
    like something Jeff would say after he does something to mess with the
    game.

    More later.



    I've been trying to figure out why I dislike this season so much, and
    after last night's episode I can list the following reasons:

    1)-a Tremendous over-emphasis on male characters.-a It seems almost every confessional involves men, and the statistics seem to bear that out. According to Survivor Fact Checker, the confessional totals so far:

    rCo Devin Way: 26 confessionals (Season Leader)
    rCo Lewis Kelly: 20 confessionals
    rCo Danny rCLKilbyrCY Kilby: 19 confessionals
    rCo Brady Booker: 19 confessionals
    rCo Angelica rCLJellyrCY Loblack: 17 confessionals
    rCo Eric Macksoud: 15 confessionals
    rCo Carter Krull: 14 confessionals
    rCo Kristin Flickinger: 13 confessionals
    rCo Jenna Doore: 12 confessionals (Voted out in Episode 4)
    rCo Ori Jean-Charles: 11 confessionals
    rCo Linnea Capobianco: 11 confessionals
    rCo Sharonda Cox: 11 confessionals
    rCo Rob Antonson: 10 confessionals (Left the game in Episode 3)
    rCo Alexis Levine: 9 confessionals
    rCo Maggie Nestor: 8 confessionals
    rCo An rCLThien AnrCY Nguyen: 7 confessionals
    rCo Mike Pinsky: 7 confessionals
    rCo Patt Cannaday: 7 confessionals (Voted out in Episode 3)
    rCo Ana Sani: 6 confessionals (Voted out in Episode 2)
    rCo Aaliyah Puglia: 4 confessionals (Voted out in Episode 1)
    rCo Cristian Ch|ivez: 2 confessionals

    https://www.instagram.com/survivorfactchecker/p/DehZ2wEGpjh/

    The top four are all men and the top female, Jelly is almost ten below Deven, with many of those coming in the current episode.-a Even departed
    Rob has more confessionals than three women still in the game.

    Number of confessionals is one measure, amount of confessional time
    shown is another. To me, it feels like the women are getting just as
    much confessional airtime as the men. I'd be surprised if Jelly isn't
    the leader on that metric.
    > 2)-a Not only is the emphasis on male characters, but I really can't
    stand the leader Devin who comes across as swarmy and full of himself. I also don't care for number four Brady whose constant use of the made-up non-word "brody" is as annoying as annoying and off-putting as I can remember from any past contestant.-a In fact, of the top six men in confessionals, the only ones I can tolerate are Lewis and Carter.-a Of
    the other men, I don't really mind Ori and Mike, but I have to say with
    an amazingly low two confessionals, I still couldn't tell you a thing
    about Christian.

    Devin is getting a cocky edit which is why I think he'll be gone before
    the merge. I'm pretty sure a "Brody" is what Brady's fans call
    themselves. Carter comes across as gullible to me. Mike seems like a POS
    which probably means he makes at least the finale.

    3)-a Not only is the show itself emphasizing men, the cast itself has amazingly voted out women on all vote-outs so far.-a Without looking it
    up, I can't ever remember a season where the first four vote-outs were
    all women.-a I like many of the women in the game, like Kristin, Alexis, Thien An and Maggie, but we rarely hear much from from them.

    We hear from Kristin a lot and Alexis was one of the stars of last
    night's episode. Jenna also got a lot of screen time before being
    screwed over by a stupid tribe swap.

    4)-a I of course hate the season mantra of "Permanent uncertainty" and I hate how every episode the producers coerce at least one player to artificially use the phrase in a confessional.

    IIRC, they did the same thing in S41 and S42 to sell the New Era.

    5)-a I still get early 40s season vibes from some of the players,
    especially the obvious black "helicopter" alliance of Jelly, Devan and
    Ori which voted out Jenna, along with Sharonda and the departed Aaliyah.
    -aAlthough race isn't being openly-a discussed, there are clear undercurrents.

    100%!
    6) I really don't care for the amount of time spent on the Kilby-Eric "bromance". I don't like either of these guys to begin with, and the
    amount of time spent on this was pretty unseemly.

    They're two of my least favorite players. Kilby fits the gamer
    stereotype perfectly as far as I'm concerned. Eric comes across as being
    super fake to me.

    I hope things start to change, but so far this is a pretty blah season
    for me.

    Up until last night, I was fine with the season. I found Ep 04 annoying because all of the player dynamics I was starting to figure out were out
    the window. I absolutely hate these two tribe shuffles into three. When
    the buff draw resulted in the five-person tribe being the Helicopter
    alliance along with Jenna and Alexis, it was pretty obvious Jenna was
    going as she wasn't tight with Jelly and Devin whereas Alexis was tight
    with Ori. It sucks we lost Jenna as she was an interesting player. I'm
    happy we still have Alexis but would have preferred that Jelly or Devin
    had been booted. Then to amplify my frustration, the preview for next
    week shows Jelly bitching about Devin saying she can't work with him. We
    get two TCs next week which could be good. It would be great if Jelly
    and Eric get booted.
    --
    Brian
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Zeppo@reg@telus.invalid to alt.tv.survivor on Thu Oct 15 12:28:59 2026
    From Newsgroup: alt.tv.survivor

    On Oct 15, 2026, Rick wrote
    (in article <11ar2b4$2eupk$1@dont-email.me>):


    I've been trying to figure out why I dislike this season so much, and
    after last night's episode I can list the following reasons:

    1) Tremendous over-emphasis on male characters. It seems almost every confessional involves men, and the statistics seem to bear that out. According to Survivor Fact Checker, the confessional totals so far:

    rCo Devin Way: 26 confessionals (Season Leader)
    rCo Lewis Kelly: 20 confessionals
    rCo Danny rCLKilbyrCY Kilby: 19 confessionals
    rCo Brady Booker: 19 confessionals
    rCo Angelica rCLJellyrCY Loblack: 17 confessionals
    rCo Eric Macksoud: 15 confessionals
    rCo Carter Krull: 14 confessionals
    rCo Kristin Flickinger: 13 confessionals
    rCo Jenna Doore: 12 confessionals (Voted out in Episode 4)
    rCo Ori Jean-Charles: 11 confessionals
    rCo Linnea Capobianco: 11 confessionals
    rCo Sharonda Cox: 11 confessionals
    rCo Rob Antonson: 10 confessionals (Left the game in Episode 3)
    rCo Alexis Levine: 9 confessionals
    rCo Maggie Nestor: 8 confessionals
    rCo An rCLThien AnrCY Nguyen: 7 confessionals
    rCo Mike Pinsky: 7 confessionals
    rCo Patt Cannaday: 7 confessionals (Voted out in Episode 3)
    rCo Ana Sani: 6 confessionals (Voted out in Episode 2)
    rCo Aaliyah Puglia: 4 confessionals (Voted out in Episode 1)
    rCo Cristian Ch|ivez: 2 confessionals

    Revealing numbers alright. However, things evened out somewhat
    in E04 with the men receiving 19 confessionals, and the women 18.
    HererCOs how they broke down:
    -Angelica: 4
    -Jenna: 4
    -Danny Kilby: 3
    -Eric: 3
    -Dev: 3
    -Brady: 2
    -Maggie: 2
    -Lewis: 2
    -Linnea: 2
    -Sharonda: 2
    -Mike: 2
    -Alexis: 2
    -Ori: 2
    -Cristian: 1
    -Carter: 1
    -Thien An: 1


    2) Not only is the emphasis on male characters, but I really can't
    stand the leader Devin who comes across as swarmy and full of himself.
    I also don't care for number four Brady whose constant use of the
    made-up non-word "brody" is as annoying as annoying and off-putting as I
    can remember from any past contestant.

    I canrCOt argue with your perception of these two, they are both very annoying.
    These are the types of people that Survivor looks for in casting and, when
    it finds them, their most negative personality traits are emphasized in the edit.
    The show has used this approach going all the way back to S01 when Hatch
    was a somewhat milder version of Dev. Production loves to have one or two irritating people in each season who they hope the viewers will hate, but
    will
    keep watching the show in order to see if they will eventually get their comeuppance.


    3) Not only is the show itself emphasizing men, the cast itself has
    amazingly voted out women on all vote-outs so far. Without looking it
    up, I can't ever remember a season where the first four vote-outs were
    all women. I like many of the women in the game, like Kristin, Alexis,
    Thien An and Maggie, but we rarely hear much from from them.

    ItrCOs happened five times, most recently in S43. In fact, in S14
    (EarlrCOs season), five women in a row were voted out at the beginning
    of the game.

    5) I still get early 40s season vibes from some of the players,
    especially the obvious black "helicopter" alliance of Jelly, Devan and
    Ori which voted out Jenna, along with Sharonda and the departed Aaliyah. Although race isn't being openly discussed, there are clear
    undercurrents.

    Good point! It hadnrCOt occurred to me that all of the members of that
    group are African American.


    6) I really don't care for the amount of time spent on the Kilby-Eric "bromance". I don't like either of these guys to begin with, and the
    amount of time spent on this was pretty unseemly.

    Yes, that was sickening.


    I hope things start to change, but so far this is a pretty blah season
    for me.

    This episode was a huge step backwards IMO. We went from some really interesting and authentic interactions among the original Yellow Tribe
    members
    to the same old shit once the players got into their new smaller tribes.
    There
    was absolutely no question concerning who would be heading to Ponderosa
    once the new five member Purple Tribe lost immunity. Why Production scheduled
    a shuffle from two tribes down to three at 18 is baffling to me. ItrCOs like, rCLHow to Ruin
    Survivor 101: A Masterclass in IncompetencerCY.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Brian Smith@dcg_brian@hotmail.com to alt.tv.survivor on Thu Oct 15 13:16:49 2026
    From Newsgroup: alt.tv.survivor

    On 10/15/2026 12:28 PM, Zeppo wrote:
    On Oct 15, 2026, Rick wrote
    (in article <11ar2b4$2eupk$1@dont-email.me>):


    I hope things start to change, but so far this is a pretty blah season
    for me.

    This episode was a huge step backwards IMO. We went from some really interesting and authentic interactions among the original Yellow Tribe members
    to the same old shit once the players got into their new smaller tribes. There
    was absolutely no question concerning who would be heading to Ponderosa
    once the new five member Purple Tribe lost immunity. Why Production scheduled a shuffle from two tribes down to three at 18 is baffling to me. ItrCOs like, rCLHow to Ruin
    Survivor 101: A Masterclass in IncompetencerCY.

    They went real old school in their planning back to the days where
    Episode 4 would see a tribe shuffle of some time. Doing so might make
    the game harder but it often ruins the viewing experience. If they want
    three tribes I'd prefer they do that from the start and stick with it
    until the merge.
    --
    Brian
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Zeppo@reg@telus.invalid to alt.tv.survivor on Thu Oct 15 14:33:32 2026
    From Newsgroup: alt.tv.survivor

    On Oct 15, 2026, Brian Smith wrote
    (in article <11arcbl$2o2ae$1@dont-email.me>):

    On 10/15/2026 12:28 PM, Zeppo wrote:
    On Oct 15, 2026, Rick wrote
    (in article <11ar2b4$2eupk$1@dont-email.me>):


    I hope things start to change, but so far this is a pretty blah season for me.

    This episode was a huge step backwards IMO. We went from some really interesting and authentic interactions among the original Yellow Tribe members
    to the same old shit once the players got into their new smaller tribes. There
    was absolutely no question concerning who would be heading to Ponderosa once the new five member Purple Tribe lost immunity. Why Production scheduled
    a shuffle from two tribes down to three at 18 is baffling to me. ItrCOs like,
    rCLHow to Ruin
    Survivor 101: A Masterclass in IncompetencerCY.

    They went real old school in their planning back to the days where
    Episode 4 would see a tribe shuffle of some time. Doing so might make
    the game harder but it often ruins the viewing experience.

    Viewing experience for sure. But, I am of the opinion that shuffling to
    smaller tribes actually makes the game easier for those involved. Case
    in point: the new Purple Tribe had an odd number of players which
    made a tie vote highly unlikely. Dev, Angelica, and Ari had a pact they
    had made on Day One, and Alexis was protected by Ori because they
    had been together on the original Purple Tribe. The clear outsider was
    Jenna. I reckon that these people knew who would be voted out before
    they even got to the challenge. There was no strategizing even necessary.
    If Red Tribe had gone to TC, the vote would have been just as easy:
    Linnea, Cristian, Eric, and Sharonda had all voted together when they
    were on the original Purple Tribe, so it seems logical that Lewis would
    have been booted assuming that Danny would receive EricrCOs protection. However, if the new Yellow Tribe had gone to TC, things would have
    been much more interesting for the viewers, and considerably trickier
    for the players. Applying the logic used above, Kristin should have
    been in trouble, but given the bad blood between Brady, Carter, Maggie,
    and Thien An, the outcome of the vote might not have been anywhere
    near as predictable as it was for Purple Tribe and, IMO, would have
    been for Red Tribe.

    If they want
    three tribes I'd prefer they do that from the start and stick with it
    until the merge.

    And I would prefer that the game start with two tribes kept together
    until the merge. But, tbh, we will never see that format again.


    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Rick@Rick@nospam.net to alt.tv.survivor on Thu Oct 15 17:48:49 2026
    From Newsgroup: alt.tv.survivor

    On 10/15/2026 5:33 PM, Zeppo wrote:
    On Oct 15, 2026, Brian Smith wrote
    (in article <11arcbl$2o2ae$1@dont-email.me>):

    On 10/15/2026 12:28 PM, Zeppo wrote:
    On Oct 15, 2026, Rick wrote
    (in article <11ar2b4$2eupk$1@dont-email.me>):


    I hope things start to change, but so far this is a pretty blah season >>>> for me.

    This episode was a huge step backwards IMO. We went from some really
    interesting and authentic interactions among the original Yellow Tribe
    members
    to the same old shit once the players got into their new smaller tribes. >>> There
    was absolutely no question concerning who would be heading to Ponderosa
    once the new five member Purple Tribe lost immunity. Why Production
    scheduled
    a shuffle from two tribes down to three at 18 is baffling to me. ItrCOs
    like,
    rCLHow to Ruin
    Survivor 101: A Masterclass in IncompetencerCY.

    They went real old school in their planning back to the days where
    Episode 4 would see a tribe shuffle of some time. Doing so might make
    the game harder but it often ruins the viewing experience.

    Viewing experience for sure. But, I am of the opinion that shuffling to smaller tribes actually makes the game easier for those involved. Case
    in point: the new Purple Tribe had an odd number of players which
    made a tie vote highly unlikely. Dev, Angelica, and Ari had a pact they
    had made on Day One, and Alexis was protected by Ori because they
    had been together on the original Purple Tribe. The clear outsider was
    Jenna. I reckon that these people knew who would be voted out before
    they even got to the challenge. There was no strategizing even necessary.
    If Red Tribe had gone to TC, the vote would have been just as easy:
    Linnea, Cristian, Eric, and Sharonda had all voted together when they
    were on the original Purple Tribe, so it seems logical that Lewis would
    have been booted assuming that Danny would receive EricrCOs protection. However, if the new Yellow Tribe had gone to TC, things would have
    been much more interesting for the viewers, and considerably trickier
    for the players. Applying the logic used above, Kristin should have
    been in trouble, but given the bad blood between Brady, Carter, Maggie,
    and Thien An, the outcome of the vote might not have been anywhere
    near as predictable as it was for Purple Tribe and, IMO, would have
    been for Red Tribe.

    If they want
    three tribes I'd prefer they do that from the start and stick with it
    until the merge.

    And I would prefer that the game start with two tribes kept together
    until the merge. But, tbh, we will never see that format again.



    I prefer the two tribe format from the start for game-playing reasons,
    but I do see two advantages to three tribes. One is that it addresses
    the scenario we had in S10 where one tribe (Tom's) literally won every
    single challenge, resulting in the other tribe literally reduced to one
    player - Stephanie. Watching one tribe totally dominate the other is
    pretty boring, and three tribes minimizes that possibility. Yes, even
    in the three tribe format, one tribe can be really bad and lose every challenge, but then the remaining player or players just get absorbed
    into the other two.

    The other advantage of three tribes is that it is harder for players to
    stay under the radar and we tend to see most players on camera. It's
    rare in a three tribe format that someone like Christian could remain so invisible.

    I actually like the quasi One world concept of everyone living together,
    but then add the wrinkle of forming two random tribes when it comes time
    for the immunity challenge and those two new tribes stay together just
    for TC and voteout and then return to all living together.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2