• Notes for 37ABF13 (Treehouse of Horror Presents: The Revengening)

    From Matt Garvey@mxg77@po.cwru.edu to alt.tv.simpsons on Sun Oct 18 21:10:05 2026
    From Newsgroup: alt.tv.simpsons

    Interesting that an early joke complained about costumes that are too
    meta, because once the killer was revealed, the entire rest of the
    episode became very meta. In the sense, that is, of being full of nods
    to past episodes, but also commentary on the show's cultural reckoning
    and its fallout. This is at least two episodes now about struggling with
    this one character, and this one seems less likely to stand up to
    rewatching. The mystery and supporting gags (and creative gore) are OK
    but not great. Almost every line in the third act had a meta subtext and
    it was more carefully clever than funny (and got tiresome).

    Does this mean Apu is coming back, then? He was pushed to the background
    a while before the mass recasting and indeed seems to have been
    forgotten a bit instead of joining the ranks of new Carl, Lou, Dr.
    Hibbert, Bumblebee Man, Julio, Dr. Nick for some reason, etc. Similarly
    we've seen several recent actor replacements for death or retirement
    that only really happened around the same time (characters from Russi
    Taylor, Pamela Hayden...). Manjula fits into both categories (and Jan
    Hooks's death was a while back)! So they won't sound the same but they probably should come back at this point, whether or not they needed a
    whole episode to reintroduce them.

    Previous episode stuff
    BABF10: Maude Flanders has a tombstone showing she died 2/13/00, the
    date of that episode's premiere (there was another much more recent
    stone I didn't catch, too)
    3F18: Apu sings "Freakazoid"
    Too many episodes to catalog, but the "Island of Forgotten Garbage" is
    full of the usual old artifacts, like a tomacco sign, the Homer (car),
    the Olmec head, Homer's muumuu... also perhaps a few too many recalled
    Apu moments to list
    7F24: Speaking of pretending things don't exist, Leon Kompowski is on
    that island and shuffles away once spotted (bold move for the main guest
    star in an episode they're trying to keep away from viewers)

    Two other things

    This episode was almost 22 minutes long, a bit over even the 21:50 max episodes had for many years and definitely over the 21.5 minutes they
    usually get now. Recent TOH-style episodes seem to be more likely to get
    this extra runtime, perhaps because they won't repeat?

    There seems to be a new credit after the copyright page and before the creative consultants, or rather a returning old one: Executives in
    Charge of Production for Gracie Films. I'd have to dig through a lot of archives to be sure but I don't think we've seen that in a decade or two
    or three. I wonder why now.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From NOSPAM.Mike.Powell@NOSPAM.Mike.Powell@darkrealms.ca (Mike Powell) to Matt Garvey on Mon Oct 19 17:58:14 2026
    From Newsgroup: alt.tv.simpsons

    From: mxg77@po.cwru.edu

    Does this mean Apu is coming back, then? He was pushed to the
    background a while before the mass recasting and indeed seems
    to have been forgotten a bit instead of joining the ranks of
    new Carl, Lou, Dr. Hibbert, Bumblebee Man, Julio, Dr. Nick for
    some reason, etc. Similarly we've seen several recent actor
    replacements for death or retirement that only really happened
    around the same time (characters from Russi Taylor, Pamela
    Hayden...). Manjula fits into both categories (and Jan Hooks's
    death was a while back)! So they won't sound the same but they
    probably should come back at this point, whether or not they
    needed a whole episode to reintroduce them.


    I hope it does mean he is finally coming back. I would have found the
    episode a lot more entertaining if one of his victims was the comedian
    who got him cancelled to begin with. :(

    I did like the episode overall but, compared to the early ToH
    offerings, not so much. I think they could have drug the reveal out
    longer, which might have made the third act a little more entertaining.

    I might be wrong but it seemed like the "droid head" that Apu was
    wearing changed during the episode. When we first see him -- in the
    scene where Homer and friends run him over, the facemask looked
    different to me than in the later parts of the story. Like it was
    taller and wider? Either way, I knew it was a Daft Punk costume. ;)

    Mike

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Renee McNeely@reneemcneely@outlook.com to alt.tv.simpsons on Thu Oct 22 05:52:16 2026
    From Newsgroup: alt.tv.simpsons

    On 10/18/26 9:10 PM, Matt Garvey wrote:
    Interesting that an early joke complained about costumes that are too
    meta, because once the killer was revealed, the entire rest of the
    episode became very meta. In the sense, that is, of being full of nods
    to past episodes, but also commentary on the show's cultural reckoning
    and its fallout. This is at least two episodes now about struggling with this one character, and this one seems less likely to stand up to rewatching. The mystery and supporting gags (and creative gore) are OK
    but not great. Almost every line in the third act had a meta subtext and
    it was more carefully clever than funny (and got tiresome).

    Does this mean Apu is coming back, then? He was pushed to the background
    a while before the mass recasting and indeed seems to have been
    forgotten a bit instead of joining the ranks of new Carl, Lou, Dr.
    Hibbert, Bumblebee Man, Julio, Dr. Nick for some reason, etc. Similarly we've seen several recent actor replacements for death or retirement
    that only really happened around the same time (characters from Russi Taylor, Pamela Hayden...). Manjula fits into both categories (and Jan Hooks's death was a while back)! So they won't sound the same but they probably should come back at this point, whether or not they needed a
    whole episode to reintroduce them.

    Previous episode stuff
    BABF10: Maude Flanders has a tombstone showing she died 2/13/00, the
    date of that episode's premiere (there was another much more recent
    stone I didn't catch, too)
    3F18: Apu sings "Freakazoid"
    Too many episodes to catalog, but the "Island of Forgotten Garbage" is
    full of the usual old artifacts, like a tomacco sign, the Homer (car),
    the Olmec head, Homer's muumuu... also perhaps a few too many recalled
    Apu moments to list
    7F24: Speaking of pretending things don't exist, Leon Kompowski is on
    that island and shuffles away once spotted (bold move for the main guest star in an episode they're trying to keep away from viewers)

    Two other things

    This episode was almost 22 minutes long, a bit over even the 21:50 max episodes had for many years and definitely over the 21.5 minutes they usually get now. Recent TOH-style episodes seem to be more likely to get this extra runtime, perhaps because they won't repeat?

    There seems to be a new credit after the copyright page and before the creative consultants, or rather a returning old one: Executives in
    Charge of Production for Gracie Films. I'd have to dig through a lot of archives to be sure but I don't think we've seen that in a decade or two
    or three. I wonder why now.

    I had the twist of the episode spoiled for me ahead of time, so I have
    to assume that the episode probably works a lot better without knowledge
    of who the twist villain is going to be. I do appreciate the amount of
    gore this one had. I don't think the THOH episodes usually get a TV-14
    rating?
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From NOSPAM.Mike.Powell@NOSPAM.Mike.Powell@darkrealms.ca (Mike Powell) to Renee McNeely on Thu Oct 22 23:32:22 2026
    From Newsgroup: alt.tv.simpsons

    I had the twist of the episode spoiled for me ahead of time, so
    I have to assume that the episode probably works a lot better
    without knowledge of who the twist villain is going to be.

    I did not know beforehand and had no idea. I would say it did work
    better that way.

    Mike

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2