• Court Agrees with EFF: Utah's VPN Law Demands a Technical Impossibility

    From Nomen Nescio@nobody@dizum.com to alt.comp.os.windows-11, alt.comp.os.windows-8, alt.privacy.anon-server, comp.dcom.vpn on Tue Oct 6 06:13:10 2026
    From Newsgroup: alt.privacy.anon-server

    When state lawmakers attempt to rewrite how the internet works, users rely
    on courts to recognize that laws canAt make technical impossibilities a reality. ThatAs why we were happy to see that a court has blocked UtahAs attempt to outlaw the privacy protections of Virtual Private Networks
    (VPNs).

    In a win for digital rights, a federal judge has issued a preliminary injunction blocking UtahAs SB 73, the stateAs draconian anti-VPN age verification law. The decision comes as EFF submitted our comments to the
    Utah Department of Commerce, detailing how forcing platforms to detect and block privacy-preserving tools undermines user privacy and security
    worldwide while demanding the impossible.

    What SB 73 Does
    Signed into law earlier this year, SB 73 attempted to regulate adult
    websites by requiring them to block VPN users or to identify the physical location of visitors using them or similar tools that mask their network traffic. It even went so far as to prohibit websites from offering instructions on how to use a VPN to bypass these checks. This made Utah,
    to EFFAs knowledge, the first state in the nation to target the use of
    VPNs to avoid legally mandated age-verification gates.

    The Utah federal court halted enforcement of the law's VPN provisions last week, ruling that the law likely violates the U.S. ConstitutionAs
    prohibition on passing laws that significantly burden businesses and
    people outside UtahAs borders.

    SB 73 burdens the rights of all internet users outside of Utah because it requires adult websites to either know every visiting userAs physical location, and then block those in Utah, or to verify every visitorAs age
    just in case they might be in Utah. The lawAs oactual-location provision
    in practice requires an entity to perform age verification services for
    every user visiting its site from any location because the entity would violate the law if even one of those users happened to be obfuscating,o
    the court wrote. The court essentially ruled that Utah has less-burdensome ways to prevent Utah minors from accessing adult websites than requiring
    all users in the world to comply with SB 73.

    AyloAs lawsuit does not challenge SB 73As provision prohibiting the
    websites covered by the law from sharing information about VPNs.

    The Legal Challenge
    This court order follows months of legal maneuvering.

    Initially set to go into effect in May 2026, SB 73 sparked an immediate constitutional challenge from Aylo, the parent company of major online
    adult platforms like Pornhub. In response to the lawsuit, Utah and Aylo initially agreed that the state would pause enforcement while the court considered the preliminary injunction request or until administrative
    rules setting specific compliance terms were finalized. Those proposed compliance rules (R152-78B, see Utah State Bulletin, page 6) were
    published by the Utah Department of CommerceAs Division of Consumer
    Protection on September 1st, and EFF submitted formal comments to the Department in opposition. According to the notice, the proposed rules
    could be effective as soon as October 8, 2026. However, Judge BarlowAs decision means that it cannot be enforced pending further action by the
    court.

    The Ruling
    EFF welcomes Judge BarlowAs ruling, which recognizes the fundamental disconnect between state legislation of the internet and how technology
    works. In his ruling, Judge Barlow noted that the statute requires a
    technical impossibility on pain of legal liability. oAylo is correct that
    the statute, as amended, now essentially imposes strict liability for
    entities like it when it comes to determining the location of its
    websitesA users.o

    The court recognized that the problem is that SB 73 orequires entities
    like Aylo to geolocate its website users with perfection to avoid
    liability.o But, at the same time, the court acknowledged othat
    geolocation perfection is not presently possible.o

    EFF explained this technical impossibility in our comment to the
    Department of Commerce. VPNs protect user privacy by routing web traffic through intermediary servers. Because destination websites only see the IP address of the VPN server, they have no reliable mechanism to tell whether
    a connection originates from Salt Lake City, Seattle, or Shanghai. So,
    under Utah's current statutory framework, platforms are left with an impossible choice: completely block all VPN traffic nationwide or withdraw access from Utah entirely. Judge Barlow agreed, asserting:

    Because the law requires perfection in the absence of perfect geolocation tools, Aylo would need to verify those 28 million usersuwhether located in Salt Lake City, Boston, New Orleans, Anchorage, or Honoluluuto ensure compliance and avoid liability.

    The Rulemaking
    The administrative rules drafted by the state compelled commercial
    entities to implement "commercially reasonable geolocation obfuscation detection systems", which is a directive, we argue, that demands a
    technical impossibility.

    In our submission to the Utah Department of Commerce, EFF also detailed
    how these rules force an invasive data collection regime onto internet
    users everywhere. So, in response to internet users trying to avoid
    invasive data collection required by age-verification requirements, SB 73 requires even greater surveillance of internet usersA online activities.
    The DepartmentAs suggested detection heuristics (like monitoring
    connection latency or device time zones) are notoriously unreliable and
    easily skewed by normal network conditions. This active surveillance inevitably leads to widespread misclassification, unwarranted access
    blocks, and severe impacts on usersA privacy far beyond Utah's borders.

    You can read EFFAs full comments to the Department of Commerce here.

    Mandating invasive tracking and punishing the use of essential security
    tools turns genuine privacy concerns into mere compliance theater and
    requires more state-mandated surveillance of internet users who rely on
    VPNs. As is the case in heavily censored regions, VPN services and
    obfuscation tools will simply adapt, making this framework fundamentally unsustainable.

    As weAve said time and time again: the internet will always route around censorship.

    While Utah legislators have indicated they may attempt to revise the law during the next legislative session, the court's preliminary injunction
    sets an important precedent: state lawmakers should not weaponize age verification to force dragnet tracking or undermine essential security
    tools.

    As other states consider similar anti-VPN proposals, EFF will continue
    pushing back against these technically impossible mandates and defending usersA privacy and anonymity. Thus, we urge legislators and regulators to reject anti-privacy rules, prioritize real user security, and safeguard constitutional protections for all users.

    https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2026/10/court-agrees-eff-utahs-vpn-law- demands-technical-impossibility

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2