From Newsgroup: alt.privacy
Chrisanna Elser filed a lawsuit a year after police knocked on her door
and told her that license plate camera data showed she was involved in the theft.
A Colorado woman who was falsely accused of stealing a package from a
porch has filed a lawsuit against Flock Safety, the Columbine Valley
Police Department and the officer who accused her, arguing that
surveillance technology has gone too far.
Attorneys for Chrisanna Elser filed the suit Monday, roughly a year after
a police sergeant knocked on her door and told her that license plate
camera data showed she was involved in the theft.
"We really just need to rein this in, I mean, it's just utterly disturbing
and very creepy on what this is happening in our society," Elser said.
Last September, Elser answered a knock at her door. The man on her
doorstep introduced himself as Sgt. Jaime Milliman of the Columbine Valley Police Department. He then accused her of a crime.
Milliman told her a package had been stolen from a home on Ridge Trail on
a Tuesday. He also pointed to the department's surveillance network as a reason she could not escape detection.
"We have cameras everywhere in that town, you can't get a breath of fresh
air without us knowing," Milliman said in the video recorded from his body camera and Elser's doorbell camera.
Elser had not stolen anything. Milliman pointed to evidence from Flock
cameras in the town of Bow Mar, which captured her truck driving through
town around the time of the theft.
Elser said she was struck by the sergeant's claim of near-total
surveillance.
"What was so shocking when he was talking was he said, 'You can't get a
breath of fresh air,' and he was [like], 'We have videos on there,' and I thought, 'Well, then why are you here," Elser said. "You should have me getting out of the truck. You should have me parking the truck. You should have all that stuff."
Elser said she tried to clear her name on the spot. She offered to show Milliman video from her own truck, which she says proves she was visiting
a nearby tailor and was not the woman in the footage the officer was
relying on. According to the report, Milliman would not let her show the video.
In the exchange, Elser can be heard saying she could show videos of
herself, and the officer replying that she could not. She said she offered more evidence on other occasions as well, and that the officer's answer
was that it was not his job.
Elser said she spent weeks worried that the citation she received would
impact her employment as she tried to figure out how to prove her
innocence.
"Many sleepless nights trying to think of any tiny little thing," Elser
said. "I was even looking at the steps on my watch to be like, can I prove that I didn't raise my heart rate to run?"
"They can tell you what you've done, but you have no way of proving what you've done," Elser said.
Elser said she had never given much thought to privacy before the
accusation. She said she was raised to respect police authority, including
by answering the door. That has changed.
"It's really made me very nervous," Elser said. "Now I'm hyper aware of
the Flock cameras."
She said she is also apprehensive when she is pulled over, wondering
whether she should record the encounter.
She said a Flock camera in Bow Mar is pointed directly at her driveway and captures her vehicle whenever she leaves, even when she is not going into town. She added that she is learning new details about what data the
company collects on people.
"There's got to be a lot more guardrails in place, a lot more due
diligence that maybe would have slowed this role a little bit more," Elser said.
Civil rights attorney Andy McNulty, who represents Elser, said he intends
for the case to become a class action against Flock.
"It's about Orwellian surveillance technology," McNulty said. "It's a
class of people who have had their privacy invaded by this technology."
McNulty was sharply critical of how the technology is deployed.
"Flock is creating this technology and giving it to these officers with no guardrails, no oversight, no meaningful training," McNulty said. "It's a recipe for disaster."
In a statement to 9NEWS, Flock said its system performed as intended. The company said it "accurately identified the location of Ms. Elser's
vehicle," while law enforcement "retained responsibility for interpreting
and weighing that information as part of the broader investigation." A
company spokesman described Flock as an investigative tool used alongside other evidence and said Flock "stands by the accuracy and integrity of its technology and intends to vigorously defend itself in this litigation."
In effect, the company's position is that the dispute concerns police
misuse of a tool rather than a flaw in the technology.
Neither the police department nor the police chief would comment on the lawsuit, which the report described as standard practice in such cases.
Steve Staeger is the consumer investigator at 9NEWS. Consumer
investigative producer Anna Hewson contributed to this report. Contact
Steve On Your Side with tips about consumer problems or other story ideas.
https://www.9news.com/article/money/consumer/steve-on-your-side/colorado- woman-sues-flock-falsely-accused-theft/73-6ad2a924-6ce9-4393-8877-
25e545f0b58e
--- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2