From Newsgroup: alt.privacy
Florida cops are facing questions after a mandate to remove all Flock
cameras tracking cars on St. Lucie County roads led local police to
uncover more than a dozen suspicious cameras operating without permits.
Local residents told The Washington Post that they were alarmed that no
one knows who owns many of the mysterious cameras.
Of the 14 cameras found, 11 had no obvious owners, raising concerns
about who has access to sensitive data that bad actors could abuse.
After the cameras were discovered, St. Lucie County Commissioner James
Clasby told a local news outlet that thererCOs rCLpotential for non-law enforcement to have cameras out there, and IrCOm not OK with that.rCY
But the St. Lucie County SheriffrCOs Office ended up claiming three of
those cameras, then refused to explain why they never obtained the
required permits. The office did not immediately respond to ArsrCO request
to clarify whether it ever accessed data recorded by the cameras.
In Florida, police have repeatedly been caught misusing Flock cameras, sometimes tracking single cars hundreds of times for personal reasons.
One officer in Fort Pierce, Josepher Crutchfield, accessed a Flock
database 382 times while stalking an ex-girlfriend, the Post noted,
while another cop, Christopher Goodson, reportedly nearly doubled that
number of searches while looking for his estranged wife.
Two Pinellas County cops were arrested for invasive Flock tracking, with
one, Travis Stanton, found searching a minor and the other, Karl Gwynne, stalking a woman he wanted to date. Across the US, the Post has found at
least 50 cases of similar police misuse. As the problem has escalated,
Flock has claimed that it has added safeguards to prevent police misuse
of its databases, but experts warn theyrCOre ineffective.
For St. Lucie County residents who frequently pass the unpermitted
cameras, privacy concerns remain, as the county is giving owners 30 days
to remove the cameras, seemingly with no questions asked. One camera
already came down, a Post reporter confirmed, after St. Lucie CountyrCOs interim administrator Mayte Santamaria explained that the county put up rCLbright redrCY notices.
Cops remain uncertain if the cameras are actively collecting data, the
Post reported. Until the deadline arrivesrCowhich for some cameras could
be as late as October 20rCocounty spokesperson Erick Gill told the Post
that rCLstaff plan to start placing plastic bags over the cameras.rCY
That small step could help obscure footage to prevent invasive tracking,
but one resident, Ty Grant, told the Post that concerns remainrCoeven
about the camera that was promptly removed. For people potentially
recorded by the cameras, itrCOs imperative that cops try to figure out who
owns them, Grant said.
rCLThat makes me feel very unsafe,rCY Grant said.
Todd Richter, who manages a fishing supply shop located across the
street from a different camera, told the Post that he has no issue with FlockrCOs automated license plate readers, so long as itrCOs clear whorCOs accessing them.
rCLIrCOm not happy about it unless I know who it is,rCY Richter said, rCLand I donrCOt.rCY
FlockrCOs web of mystery cameras
St. Lucie County officials appear determined to give the camera owners
time to take them down before moving forward with investigations to
unmask them. Gill told the Post that Flock will be contacted if the
countyrCOs 30-day deadline passes and cameras remain up.
ItrCOs possible that Flock dropped the ball on submitting permitting
requests for either private or police use of the mysterious cameras.
That has happened for years, as a 2024 Forbes investigation reported,
and the Post has noted other more recent examples. Last December, Flock installed two cameras in Cambridge, Massachusetts, without telling
anyone, after local officials had banned the technology. And just last
month, officials in Millcreek, Utah, were baffled to find an unknown
camera installed on city property that neither the city nor police
requested.
About an hour from the most recent batch of sketchy cameras, officials
in Palm Bay, Florida, suspended their camera system after finding that
Flock continually installed cameras and then failed to request final inspections. In that case, city officials ended up approving FlockrCOs
permits.
St. Lucie County commissioner Clasby told local media he thinks that
rCLnot knowing whorCY the cameras belong to is rCLanother issuerCY beyond police
misuse and data privacy that Flock must address.
Already battling backlashrCoparticularly in Florida, the only state to ban cameras on state roadsrCoFlock appears motivated to connect with the
county before the 30-day notice period expires.
A Flock spokesperson told the Post that the company already reached out
to officials to discuss the unpermitted cameras. That spokesperson
seemed to downplay the controversy, saying that permitting requirements
rCLvary by jurisdiction and are not necessary in every location.rCY
Ars reached Gill to confirm that St. Lucie County began talks with Flock
this week. According to Gill, Flock is juggling many requests right now,
since there are demands to remove cameras throughout the state. As Flock assesses the cases, Gill said that county rCLstaff is still working on the
best possible way to make sure the cameras are removed by the permittee
before the deadline. Once the deadline has passed, staff will be working
to safely remove the cameras and/or add coverings, so that they are
unable to capture video.rCY
https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2026/10/florida-cops-say-they-dont- know-who-owns-11-unpermitted-flock-cameras/
--- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2