From Newsgroup: alt.politics.media
Not one. Not two.
Now three (four? Five?) different polling outlets have been outed as
pushing totally fake poll numbers, and the media chewed them up, swallowed them, and vomited them out onto our computer screens as if they were
serving us filet mignon.
Once is happenstance. Twice is coincidence. The third time itAs enemy
action. The fourth and fifth? It is an invasion.
We've all known that many polls exist to push a narrative, but most at
least come from established polling firms with a record and known biases. That's why a poll is sometimes labeled as coming from a campaign or an interest group, so the emptor may caveat it, as it were.
Such polls should be taken with a grain of salt because everyone knows
they're released to help shape a narrative. They aren't exactly FAKE, but
the questions are often framed to create a conclusion, or a campaign only releases polls that show what they want.
But there is a new(?) trend of fake pollsters releasing fake polls, and
they are being reported as real, even included in polling averages. Some
have even made it to betting sites, where money exchanges hands based on made-up numbers.
News organizations' entire model is based on the obviously false premise
that they, unlike people like me and my colleagues, are "journalists" who
work mightily to print only what is true and verified. They fact-check.
They dig deep. They do the hard work bloggers in pajamas don't.
Only...for the most part, they rewrite press releases, take what
government officials hand them, put on an Orange Man Bad spin if they can
get away with it, and trash Republicans for sport.
They no longer even bother to check. They put their fingers in the wind
and call it a day.
I'm not going to treat this as a "news" story where you need to know all
the facts, because, frankly, it is moving too quickly, and the real point
is that the media once again failed us, posting "fake news" as if it were
real and verified. Polling is so fundamentally broken that at some point
we should give up on trusting even the "real" ones that AREN'T just making
it up as they go along.
I've written about the problems with polling several times, and fake polls
are just the tip of the iceberg. Pollsters don't have to falsify anything
to get bad answers; polling requires random samples, and random samples
don't exist anymore to the extent they once did. Back in the day, it was
at least plausible that you could, but with the fragmentation of the electorate, the reluctance of some people to answer polls, the
technological challenges of reaching people by phone, by text, and by internet, and a need to guess who will actually vote, the best that
pollsters can do is "model" the electorate, "model" the people answering,
and essentially make WAGs (Wild A$$ Guesses) about what the results should look like.
?? BOOM: The New York Times just had to pull 15 midterm polls after the "pollster" behind them ADMITTED almost all of it was FAKE.
The firm is called Wedgewood Polls. It pumped out made-up numbers from
June to October, and the Times put them right on its official poll
tracking pages.
The Times says it vetted them first.
Wedgewood's own words on how easy it was to fool the media: "Far too
easy."
This is the same paper telling you which polls to trust.
Trump has been saying it from day one. Now they're proving it for him.
Pollsters, or at least good pollsters, make a good-faith effort to do so,
and some are even decent at it, but if you haven't learned from the past
few election cycles that the general trend isn't toward accurate polls, I don't know what to tell you.
Now, with fake polling injected into the news cycle, we have one more
reason to be skeptical of polling averages, which now include fake data. I doubt it changes the outcome much, since pollsters have a nasty habit of juking their own numbers to "cluster" and not stand out too much as
elections near. It doesn't pay to Ann Selzer yourself.
The real lesson here is about the media, though, and not the polls. The
media bought the lie, without even checking. An independent outlet, FiftyPlusOne, did the checking.
RealClearPolitics, which the censors labeled during the Biden
administration as pushing misinformation, didn't fall for the scams the "mainstream" news did, and they're right to crow about it.
Well, not everyone treated Wedgewood as legit. RealClearPolitics, the
pioneer poll aggregator, never included these bogus polls u either in the
RCP Poll Average or in the voluminous number of surveys cited daily on our polling pages.
oRCP has a very high standard for including polls in our averages, which
this pollster did not begin to meet,o explained Kavon W. Nikrad, RCPAs director of polling. oThey were a new pollster with no track record to evaluate. They also had a aplaceholder-styleA Google Sites website, had no staff directory on that website, and no social media history to look back
on to establish that they were an actual, legitimate polling firm.o
oMeeting these criteria does not mean automatic inclusion in RCPAs
averages,o Nikrad added, obut they are a start.o
The organizations that did take the bait were reluctant to give credit to RealClearPolitics. This was especially true of the New York Times, which
is no surprise given its dubious track record in that regard. To give
credit where itAs due, however, although FiftyPlusOne was one of the
polling sites duped by Wedgewood, it was that groupAs suspicions that
cracked the case.
oWedgewood Polling was never intended to sway an election or permanently mislead the public,o Wedgewood insisted Tuesday after being outed. oIt was designed as a wake-up call.o
Few seasoned political observers are buying that explanation, least of all FiftyPlusOne. oThis is incredibly misleading,o tweeted Cooper Burton of FiftyPlusOne. His site, Burton added, owas planning to publish an investigation into Wedgewood's polls tomorrow morning, and reached out to
them this morning for comment. This is just an attempt to save face after
they realized we caught them.o
The fake polling isn't the news to me. What's really significant is what
this confirms about the "mainstream" outlets.
They suck.
https://hotair.com/david-strom/2026/10/23/once-is-happenstance-twice-is- coincidence-the-third-time-its-enemy-action-n3820246
--- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2