• jia, formerly known as, the Chia

    From eye@user8028@newsgrouper.org.invalid to alt.philosophy.taoism on Wed Oct 28 17:27:32 2026
    From Newsgroup: alt.philosophy.taoism

    Pets vary.
    Some people have pet names.
    A pet name could be a pet and yet.
    Suggesting a theme a bot was consulted.
    Its response may telling as a bell rings.

    The prompt to the bot was that:
    A rocking horse is not a horse.
    It was after an other sentence
    had already sentenced a thought.

    "A rocking chair is a chair. A rocking horse is not a horse.
    A so-called School of Names named, unless there was no such school, names."


    The bot thought, if a thought was:
    "A white horse is not a horse" (tO+oa4oYRoa4).
    Here is how your wordplay unpacks the history
    of the School of Names (also known as the Logicians or Dialecticians):

    rCo "A rocking horse is not a horse": This is a perfect modern parallel
    to the philosopher Gongsun Long's argument. He claimed that "horse"
    denotes a shape, while "white" denotes a color.

    Therefore, a "white horse" (a combination of shape + color)
    is a distinct concept and not identical to the general category
    of "horse" alone.

    Similarly, a rocking horse belongs to the category
    of toys or furniture, not mammals.

    rCo "Unless there was no such school":
    This is historically spot-on. Modern scholars
    agree that the School of Names is a taxonomical fiction.

    The thinkers grouped into it (like Hui Shi and Gongsun Long)
    never founded an actual institution or a unified movement.

    rCo "...named names": They were given this title posthumously.
    During the Han Dynasty (centuries after these thinkers died),
    an archivist named Sima Tan looked back at their obsession
    with the relationship between "names" (linguistic words)
    and "stuff" (the actual objects or realities they represent) and
    officially categorized them as the MingjiarCothe School of Names.

    - end of quote -
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From aye@user8028@newsgrouper.org.invalid to alt.philosophy.taoism on Fri Oct 30 11:40:06 2026
    From Newsgroup: alt.philosophy.taoism

    eye posted, in p'arts:

    Pets vary.
    Some people have pet names.
    A pet name could be a pet and yet.

    A rocking horse is not a horse.

    A wooden horse could be a horse made
    in the shade out of a gnarly tree.

    A horse which is a form of life
    suggests there is a thing known
    as life and might be a category
    error of a sort that arrives in
    time for dinner, or a taxi.

    To reify a way and call it the,
    the Dao may be a similar type. Oh,
    and then again there are points being
    made by beings who point.

    Horses aren't made.
    They are born.

    - thanks! aye. Cheers!
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2