Two days ago, last Saturday, 3 October 2026, an idea that I had
thought likely lost ...
Thanks a lot! :)
By the way, I recently read of a quite banal interpretation
of the beginning to the Tao Te Ching, namely that it would
have banally said that a way/method of doing something will
have to be adapted since circumstances will change, I guess
reminding also a bit of Heraclitus "Panta Rhei", everything
flows, if you step into the same river twice, the waters
will be different. I guess the very first abstractions in
history are both the deepest and the most banal ones. Makes
if difficult to add something of real meaning after that...
: Might this essentially have rediscovered the way?
Sounds at least better again... :)
I stumbled about this:
: Maybe two people call the same river different names.
: Then again, to say it's the same river is a claim.
[...]
: Without any intent, a river flows.
: Perhaps life does about the same.
Isn't saying that a river flows without intent
a claim?
What about the pleasure of the fish?
Could you conclude the pleasure of the river
the same way as Zhuangzi?
Assuming that a man torturing a fish feels pleasure,
wouldn't concluding that the fish feels just the same,
be more than just a stretch?
I guess the river flows without intent,
but still with pleasure?
Until he arrives at the boundless sea, maybe?
Or the sea perceives the stars?
And the stars perceive ... what?
Best wishes...
Very gently things seem to reconstitute* themselves... :)
...
especially : to restore to a former condition by adding water
Alain posted:
I stumbled about this:
: Maybe two people call the same river different names.
: Then again, to say it's the same river is a claim.
[...]
: Without any intent, a river flows.
: Perhaps life does about the same.
Isn't saying that a river flows without intent
a claim?
Yes. I'd say so. A statement. A claim.
What about the pleasure of the fish?
Could you conclude the pleasure of the river
the same way as Zhuangzi?
I could. Epistemology is interesting.
If the river is happy gurgling over rocks.
If it's slow moving, meandering, or a dam stops it.
Assuming that a man torturing a fish feels pleasure,
wouldn't concluding that the fish feels just the same,
be more than just a stretch?
It might be. I'd assume the fish feels pain.
Then again, projecting could be the name of a game.
Maybe Zhuangzi didn't know. He felt or thought he knew.
To think or feel he knew that he knew is possible.
Me might have been delusional.
I guess the river flows without intent,
but still with pleasure?
Normally, pleasure isn't attributed to forms
that are not viewed as being forms of life.
Even to say, without intent could be saying something
that isn't necessarily true. Maybe neither with
nor without is a way.
When semantics are at play, contexts might be rulers.
With and without, intent and other features
or properties arrives after chopping in two.
Until he arrives at the boundless sea, maybe?
In Chapter 17 of the Zhuangzi, the Lord of the river
was proud, until meeting Jo, god of the North Ocean.
Or the sea perceives the stars?
Jo, as vast as he was, was humble.
And the stars perceive ... what?
To think, feel, sense, know, guess
or any other verb about the stars
in terms of what people do may be
a bit far. Reaching for them.
Best wishes...
- thanks!
To my untutored eyes rivers are overflowing with intent.
Even when frozen they're determined to get to the sea.
It seems they share my need and desire for salt.
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 60:37:53 |
| Calls: | 1,265 |
| Calls today: | 1 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
4 files (9,632K bytes) |
| Messages: | 286,219 |