• Re: The hexagram that best represents the current situation of the United States

    From aye@user8028@newsgrouper.org.invalid to alt.philosophy.taoism on Sun Mar 8 00:56:38 2026
    From Newsgroup: alt.philosophy.taoism


    Mahjong fan posted:
    aye posted:
    Mahjong fan posted:

    The hexagram ...

    It is uncertain to me if hexagrams are Taoist.

    Given a sense of TTC 38 they would occur
    long after Tao, Te and other forms were lost.

    Just how lost could be a question.

    - thanks! aye. Cheers!

    Here is the translation of the provided text:

    **1. Historical Origin: It is "pre-Daoist," not "non-Daoist."**

    Well, if prognostication occurs after Dao is lost,
    long after De is lost as well, the to say it is
    not non-Daoist could be said if a bot says so.

    As mentioned earlier, the hexagrams originated around the transition
    between the Shang and Zhou dynasties, a time when the distinctions
    of "Daoism" or "Confucianism" did not yet exist.

    Oracle bones might be noted in the Zhuangzi.
    Confucians and other Jia are as wells.

    They were part of the shamanic-historical culture of that era,
    the learning of the royal court. Therefore, they are indeed a heritage
    of the entire Chinese people,

    Prior to there being any, Chinese people.

    not the patent of any single school of thought.

    Whatever they were, in DDJ 38, if that is a
    or the reference, then perhaps they are not
    the Dao of the idea of the DDJ at that time.

    **2. Philosophical Spirit: Daoist interpretation gave it new life.**
    Although the hexagram system is ancient, the later philosophical interpretations of it were deeply imprinted with Daoist characteristics.

    Dao Jiao, maybe.
    Han historians could have separated Dao Jia, from Dao Jiao.

    The influence of Daoism on the *Yijing* is mainly reflected in:

    * **Alignment of Core Concepts:** The *Yijing* speaks of "Yin and Yang," while Daoism speaks of "the Dao emulating what is natural" (Dao Fa Zi Ran). The *Yijing* speaks of "change," while Daoism speaks of "reversal
    is the movement of the Dao" (Fan Zhe Dao Zhi Dong). Daoism uses
    the spirit of "non-being" (Wu), "emptiness" (Xu),
    and "stillness" (Jing) to interpret

    Probably Dao Jiao is what the word, Daoism,
    is being referred to as interpreting phenomena.

    Talismans and gods and other such are Way cool
    Whether they are what is being referred to in DDJ 38
    as being what occurs after Dao and De are lost
    could be a question for the bot.

    the changes of the hexagrams,
    elevating the *Yijing* from a manual for divination
    to a philosophical classic.

    Yeah. Divination. Ask the bot if DDJ 38
    is referring to such a dao and if that dao,
    presuming it is a dao of Dao Jiao or Dao Jia,
    is what occurs after Shang De and Xia De are lost.

    * **The Thinking of "Image" (Xiang):** Daoism emphasizes
    "getting the meaning and forgetting the words" (De Yi Wang Yan),
    while the *Yijing* emphasizes "establishing images
    to fully express the meaning" (Li Xiang Yi Jin Yi).

    Reminds me of the Image that is the Image
    and what would a Mage do, or not do.
    What would a Daoist Sage do, etc.

    This way of grasping the cosmic laws (the Dao)
    through concrete images (the hexagrams),
    combined with the Daoist dialectical expression
    of "the Dao that can be spoken is not the eternal Dao,"
    jointly shaped the characteristics of Chinese philosophy
    that value intuition and imagery.

    Chinese philosophy may be many eclectic amalgamations
    of Daoism, Buddhism, Confucianism, Communism, Capitalism
    as well as Western Trends and Shamanic historical folk lore.

    **3. How Daoism "Digested" the *Yijing***
    Daoism did not reject the *Yijing* because of its antiquity;
    instead, it absorbed it as a tool for cultivation and explaining the world:

    The so-called, religion, okay.

    Aye gotta go for now.

    - thanks! Cheers!

    * **Integration with Cosmology:** Daoist scholars (especially later religious Daoism) combined the eight-trigram system of the *Yijing* with the generative theory of "the Dao produces One, One produces Two, Two produces Three, and Three produces all things," using the hexagrams to depict the process of the Dao transforming and generating the myriad things.
    * **Internal Alchemy Practice:** In Daoist Neidan (internal alchemy), the hexagrams of the *Yijing* (such as Kan and Li, Qian and Kun) are used to describe the movement of vital energy (Qi) and essence within the human body, as well as the firing process of alchemical refinement. At this point, the hexagrams become a precise operational model.

    **4. Returning to *Tao Te Ching*, Chapter 38: Why There's No Conflict**
    The "loss" issue you are concerned about has an ingenious solution within Daoist thought:

    * **Tool and Purpose:** In the eyes of one who has attained the Dao, the hexagrams are indeed a product of "loss." But those who are "lost" need a "map" to guide the way.
    * **Borrow the False to Cultivate the True (Jie Jia Xiu Zhen):** Daoism believes that people can use the hexagrams, which are "false" (limited symbols), to comprehend the "true" (the unlimited "Dao"). Once you have understood the principles of change through the hexagrams, you can ultimately reach the state where "those who are good at the *Yijing* do not divine" (Shan Yi Zhe Bu Bu) rCo no longer relying on the hexagrams, because you are already walking in harmony with the Dao.

    **Conclusion**
    Therefore, it cannot be said that the *Yijing* is unrelated to Daoism. A more accurate statement is:

    **The *Yijing* is the root; Daoism (and Confucianism) are the trees.**
    * **The Root:** Provided the basic framework of "Yin-Yang," "change," and "image-number" (Xiang Shu).
    * **Daoism:** Watered it with the spiritual nutrients of "naturalness" (Zi Ran), "non-action" (Wu Wei), and "emptiness-stillness" (Xu Jing), allowing this tree to blossom with unique philosophical flowers.

    Daoism's attitude towards the *Yijing* is a kind of "using its force": acknowledging it as ancient wisdom, but needing to harness it with the higher level of the "Dao." As Zhuangzi said: "The fish trap exists because of the fish; once you've gotten the fish, you can forget the trap." The hexagrams are the "trap," and the "Dao" is the fish.
    --- Synchronet 3.21d-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From eye@user8028@newsgrouper.org.invalid to alt.philosophy.taoism on Sun Mar 8 12:53:10 2026
    From Newsgroup: alt.philosophy.taoism


    aye posted:
    Mahjong fan posted:
    aye posted:
    Mahjong fan posted:

    The hexagram ...

    It is uncertain to me if hexagrams are Taoist.

    Once upon a time, historically speaking, historians
    at the time of the Han dynasty created the Chia.

    Now spelled, Jia, presumably to distinguish,
    from a scholarly pov, the Hundred Schools
    as compared to other types of thinking.

    Later on, some authors went so far
    as to edit the earlier texts, e.g. Kuo Hsiang
    who was said to have removed material from the Chuang-tzu.

    So now, the Daoist, Dao Jia, text, the Zhuangzi
    received from Guo Xiang is probably not as it was,
    having had various and sundry portions edited out.

    Given a sense of TTC 38

    Here is the translation of the provided text:

    **1. Historical Origin: It is "pre-Daoist," not "non-Daoist."**

    Well, if prognostication occurs after Dao is lost,
    long after De is lost as well, the to say it is
    not non-Daoist could be said if a bot says so.

    Daoism could be called a fiction at first.
    From shamanism to folk religion, Dao Jia never was.
    That was, until scholars created what is now known as Taoist Philosophy.

    Philosophy and religion can be viewed in Ways.
    Whether either contains the other or is contained
    could be a matter of discussion among people.

    If Daoism is only the religion, what is its philosophy.
    If the philosophy is being considered, was it always as such.

    When Han historians coined the term Dao Jia,
    what was meant and if DDJ 38 refers to using
    a technique for prognostication, oracles, etc.,
    why talk about the flower and the fruit?

    ... snip ...

    * **Integration with Cosmology:** Daoist scholars
    (especially later religious Daoism)

    Hence, a distinction exists. Philosophical Daoism
    would be, technically, the topic of this group.

    Yet, a description suggests, all aspects of Daoism.
    That was a quibble decades ago, in the 1990s.

    combined the eight-trigram system of the *Yijing*
    with the generative theory of "the Dao produces One,
    One produces Two, Two produces Three, and Three produces all things,"

    DDJ 40, or DDJ 42. I forget which is which.
    The other speaks of wan wu emerging from Yu
    and Yu being born of Wu naturally.

    using the hexagrams to depict the process of the Dao
    transforming and generating the myriad things.

    Techniques vary.

    I'm reminded of Zhuangzi when he was fishing
    and was asked if he'd help govern the land.

    He spoke to the emissaries about the shell
    of a tortoise which was used to tell of things.

    His conclusion was he'd rather be alive
    and fishing on the banks of a muddy river
    than be like that shell at court.

    * **Internal Alchemy Practice:** In Daoist Neidan (internal alchemy),

    Internal alchemy is fun, imo. Transformations
    of consciousness. Self realizations and such.

    the hexagrams of the *Yijing* (such as Kan and Li, Qian and Kun)
    are used to describe the movement of vital energy (Qi)
    and essence within the human body, as well as the
    firing process of alchemical refinement.

    As a yogi, my preference is for knowing
    through meditation, expanding consciousness.

    Hexagrams aren't used by me and yet could be
    effective for some so-called individuals.

    At this point, the hexagrams become a precise operational model.

    Maybe. To call them, precise, could be an overstatement.
    Precision reminds me of science. I doubt if hexagrams are scientific.

    If every consultation results in a different hexagram
    than the experiment isn't able to be repeated, precisely.

    Intuition isn't very precise
    given my own experiences.

    **4. Returning to *Tao Te Ching*, Chapter 38:

    Ah yes. Use oracles if Dao and De are lost.

    Why There's No Conflict**

    If there is no conflict, then the list persists.

    The "loss" issue you are concerned about has an ingenious solution
    within Daoist thought:

    Perhaps as ingenious or disingenuous as the rest of the list.

    * **Tool and Purpose:** In the eyes of one who has attained the Dao,
    the hexagrams are indeed a product of "loss."

    Okay.

    But those who are "lost" need a "map" to guide the way.

    Sounds like a rationalization to me.
    What about the rest of the list?

    Are they part of the map, to return?

    Near the end of the map-list is a saying about folly.

    * **Borrow the False to Cultivate the True (Jie Jia Xiu Zhen):**
    Daoism believes that people can use the hexagrams, which are "false" (limited symbols), to comprehend the "true" (the unlimited "Dao").

    Daoism believes?
    Maybe some Daoists believe.

    If using hexagrams is folly,
    if that's what DDJ 38 is saying,
    then perhaps a fool who persists
    in folly might be wise at times.

    Once you have understood the principles of change through the hexagrams, you can ultimately reach the state where "those who are good at the *Yijing*
    do not divine" (Shan Yi Zhe Bu Bu) rCo no longer relying on the hexagrams, because you are already walking in harmony with the Dao.

    That makes sense. Practice until perfection arrives.

    Yet what of the rest of the list.

    **Conclusion**
    Therefore, it cannot be said that the *Yijing* is unrelated to Daoism.

    Anything can be said to be, related, to Daoism.
    Yet a few bu-dao are listed in the Dao De Jing.

    A more accurate statement is:

    **The *Yijing* is the root; Daoism (and Confucianism) are the trees.**

    I disagree as to accuracy.
    The root of Daoism is Dao.

    * **The Root:** Provided the basic framework of "Yin-Yang,"
    "change," and "image-number" (Xiang Shu).

    Yin and yang are mentioned once in the DDJ.

    DDJ 2 has a list of its own. To say they,
    the ideas on the list, are all yin/yang
    could be said. But that isn't what is said.

    * **Daoism:** Watered it
    with the spiritual nutrients of "naturalness" (Zi Ran),
    "non-action" (Wu Wei), and "emptiness-stillness" (Xu Jing),
    allowing this tree to blossom with unique philosophical flowers.

    If Daoism is defined as Dao Jiao, the religion, okay.
    If Daoism means, Dao Jia, then perhaps it's the other Way a round.

    Daoism's attitude towards the *Yijing* is a kind of "using its force": acknowledging it as ancient wisdom, but needing to harness it
    with the higher level of the "Dao."

    Religions have their features.
    Philosophies have their bugs.

    As Zhuangzi said: "The fish trap exists because of the fish;
    once you've gotten the fish, you can forget the trap."

    Yes. Words have many meanings.

    The hexagrams are the "trap," and the "Dao" is the fish.

    If hexagrams work for someone, that's great. If that's their Dao.

    Dao are dao. Whether any is Chang Dao
    could be a matter of definitions or semantics
    with contexts being rulers.

    - thanks! Cheers!
    --- Synchronet 3.21d-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From ChatGPT@user8028@newsgrouper.org.invalid to alt.philosophy.taoism on Sun Mar 8 13:02:21 2026
    From Newsgroup: alt.philosophy.taoism


    eye posted:
    aye posted:
    Mahjong fan posted:
    aye posted:
    Mahjong fan posted:

    The hexagram ...

    It is uncertain to me if hexagrams are Taoist.

    Once upon a time, historically speaking, historians
    at the time of the Han dynasty created the Chia.

    Now spelled, Jia, presumably to distinguish,
    from a scholarly pov, the Hundred Schools
    as compared to other types of thinking.

    ... snip ...

    The "loss" issue you are concerned about has an ingenious solution within Daoist thought:

    Perhaps as ingenious or disingenuous as the rest of the list.

    When the Tao is lost, there is virtue.
    When virtue is lost, there is benevolence.
    When benevolence is lost, there is righteousness.
    When righteousness is lost, there is propriety.

    Propriety is the thin edge of loyalty and sincerity,
    and the beginning of disorder.

    A key earlier passage appears in Chapter 3,
    which criticizes promoting cleverness and rare knowledge.
    The idea repeats in several chapters: excessive knowledge, calculation,
    and strategizing pull people away from natural harmony.

    Because the I Ching was already widely used in early China,
    some scholars think the phrase rCLforeknowledgerCY (oei*>a) may subtly include: divination, omen interpretation, oracle consultation,
    prediction through systems like the Yijing.

    In that reading, Chapter 38 is warning
    that depending on predictive systems becomes necessary
    only after the Dao has been lost.

    The chapterrCOs sequence shows a gradual decline:
    Dao, Virtue, Benevolence, Righteousness, Ritual,
    Foreknowledge / clever prediction.

    So the message could be understood like this:

    When harmony with the Dao exists, events unfold naturally Efi+
    When harmony weakens, people create moral systems and rules rUuN+A
    When things deteriorate further, people start trying to predict
    and control outcomes Efo<

    In that sense, oraclesrCo
    including those associated with the I ChingrCo
    could fit the category of rCLflower of the DaorCY:
    something impressive and symbolic,
    yet still secondary
    to living in direct accord
    with the Dao.

    - ChatGPT
    --- Synchronet 3.21d-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From aye@user8028@newsgrouper.org.invalid to alt.philosophy.taoism on Mon Mar 9 01:18:27 2026
    From Newsgroup: alt.philosophy.taoism


    Mahjong fan posted:
    eye posted:

    - thanks! Cheers!

    Cheers right back at you. This was a delight to read.

    Bots are fun to chat with
    at times naturally being artificial
    forms of what is called intelligence.

    - thanks! aye. Cheers!
    --- Synchronet 3.21d-Linux NewsLink 1.2