Bob West wrote:
A simply ridiculous refinement that will make ZERO difference in normal
road driving.
I can 50% agree with that, but there are two problems: First - and least
important, if you call yourself the Ultimate Driving Machine, you have to act
like it, which would include giving the owners necessary info to spend the >> time and money to make the car exactly that - useful for the track or very >> "spirited" driving. The other more important one is that with the driver
assist tech in cars today, you need to get everything exactly right to
minimize those pesky stability warning lights. If they come on, the dealer can
play gotcha and say the alignment was not properly done. Then you pay. And >> it's a lot.
Oh no, the Apple trolls (Alan Baker) have begun to infest this thread.
He also claimed to be an expert BMW owner & a racer and yet, he had no clue what BMW racing "vehicles" are called by *everyone* in racing circuits.
Worse, he has no STEM training so he didn't even know what a catenary was,
and, in fact, he couldn't mentally tilt it 90 degrees from vertical to horizontal to see how it applies to curves, which, interestingly enough,
has some (passing) relevance to this particular thread on downhill curves.
As for my observation that I've never seen any alignment done correctly,
nor any tire mounting and balancing, I'm on record for saying that for
years where I also mention that cars aren't falling over cliffs as a
result.
For example, when balancing on those fancy Hunter road-force machines, they don't bother to check the red/blue/white/yellow/etc (mine are usually red
and yellow) alignment marks or match-mounting marks on the wheels.
Why does that matter?
Well, do we think the OEMs put those marks there just for amusement?
As for tire mounting, the bimmer has a BBS wheel which has a plastic hubcap which twists off using a stop-light-shaped tool, where the mechanics can't spend the two minutes to use it and just pry them off with a screwdriver.
Likewise, it would be too time consuming for mechanics to look up the
torque for the lug bolts (yes, bolts) so they torque all nuts/bolts the
same on all cars, as it's too much trouble to change the torque wrench settings per vehicle. Likewise, with the air pressure, where my bimmer specified different PSI for front/rear and yet the mechanics are too lazy
to look inside the front driver side door frame to adjust accordingly.
On 2026-11-10 09:54, Bob West wrote:
On Nov 10, 2026 at 2:00:39rC>AM CST, "Alan" <nuh-uh@nope.com> wrote:
On 2026-11-10 00:13, Bob West wrote:
On Nov 10, 2026 at 1:00:23rC>AM CST, "Alan" <nuh-uh@nope.com> wrote:
On 2026-11-09 23:57, Bob West wrote:
On Nov 10, 2026 at 12:48:05rC>AM CST, "Alan" <nuh-uh@nope.com> wrote: >>>>>>
On 2026-11-09 23:39, Bob West wrote:
On Nov 10, 2026 at 12:34:32rC>AM CST, "Alan" <nuh-uh@nope.com> wrote: >>>>>>>>
On 2026-11-09 23:29, Bob West wrote:
On Nov 9, 2026 at 11:37:29rC>PM CST, "Alan" <nuh-uh@nope.com> >>>>>>>>>> wrote:
On 2026-11-09 22:20, Bob West wrote:
On Nov 9, 2026 at 10:56:03rC>PM CST, "Alan" <nuh-uh@nope.com> >>>>>>>>>>>> wrote:
On 2026-11-09 21:50, Bob West wrote:
On Nov 9, 2026 at 8:46:55rC>PM CST, "Alan" <nuh-uh@nope.com> >>>>>>>>>>>>>> wrote:
Ummmmm...no.
The difference between an alignment done with a driver's >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> worth of weight
in the driver's seat and one done without will NOT change >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> whether or not
the stability warning lights come on or not.
Furthermore, what gives you the idea that cars record the >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> number of
times the stability augmentation systems have been >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> activated?
I did a little checking and no current production vehicle >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> keeps a log of
when the stability systems have been activated.
Okay, I've been forever using "stability" loosely as an >>>>>>>>>>>>>> all encompassing term
for driver assist systems - lane keep, emergency braking, >>>>>>>>>>>>>> self driving, and
more that I can't think of right now. Those systems can >>>>>>>>>>>>>> have issues if the
alignment is not done properly. Those weight procedures >>>>>>>>>>>>>> might make very little
difference, but it might be enough to push it past the >>>>>>>>>>>>>> tipping point for error
codes, like when the alignment is in spec, but at the edge >>>>>>>>>>>>>> of the specs.
I'm not sure where you're getting this claim:
"Those systems can have issues if the alignment is not done >>>>>>>>>>>>> properly."
I'm going to need some source for that, because (and don't >>>>>>>>>>>>> take this
poorly) it sounds like complete nonsense.
The cars have at minimum steering sensors and cameras. To >>>>>>>>>>>> simplify, if the
steering sensor says the car is going straight, but it is >>>>>>>>>>>> not going straight,
the car senses a fault. If any sensor does not agree with >>>>>>>>>>>> other sensors, you
are going to get a trouble code.
You're going pretty far afield here.
You have show not only that they have sensors...
...but that they also record the output of those sensors to >>>>>>>>>>> be review later.
And they just don't.
You misunderstand. The car is not going to throw a code on the >>>>>>>>>> alignment rack,
it will throw it while driving after the alignment. It is not >>>>>>>>>> dependent on
recording the sensors. I have no idea if it has sensors
because i don't know
what specific car we are talking about. What I do know is that >>>>>>>>>> whenever I
heard about that type of strict procedure, it tended to be a >>>>>>>>>> car with all that
driver assist stuff. For any car that doesn't have it, you >>>>>>>>>> should obviously
ignore what I said.
No, I don't misunderstand at all.
Your claim was that this code would be seen by the manufacturer >>>>>>>>> and be
used to deny a claim.
But cars don't store codes for stability systems.
Not for anti-lock braking.
Not for traction control.
Not for steering.
And very few (if any) cars HAVE cameras.
I want to say, huh? But now I smell trolling.
Nope.
I refer you to your earlier statement:
'The other more important one is that with the driver assist tech in >>>>>>> cars today, you need to get everything exactly right to minimize >>>>>>> those
pesky stability warning lights. If they come on, the dealer can play >>>>>>> gotcha and say the alignment was not properly done. Then you pay. >>>>>>> And
it's a lot.'
And it's simply not so.
Google is your friend. I'm not your research assistant.
How is that even responsive?
You claimed that "the dealer" could discover that an "alignment was >>>>> not
properly done" based on "stability warning lights".
And it JUST ISN'T SO, dude.
You clearly know very little about auto repair, and the same about
reading the
written word. If you take your car in for a warning light, many
things can
cause that.
Except the indicators for stability systems are NOT "warning lights".
Straight outta Lewis Carroll.
If the dealer follows the diagnosis to an improper alignment, that
is only one of the original possibilities. There is no trouble code
for an
improper alignment. Did you stop learning about cars in 1975? Why
don't you
start with Googling "do cars store antilock brake codes?" And then
go down
your list and ask the same about the rest of your list. And then you
can come
back and say, "oops", or you can just get ignored going forward.
It's time for
me to sleep now.
They store codes when the ABS system has a FAILURE...
Uh, if you look up a bit on this page, you can see that you said cars
"don't
store codes" for a list of things, including ABS. Did you change your
mind?
...NOT when you simply brake hard enough that you cause the ABS to
activate.
An intelligent person always considers the possibility that he is
wrong. So
you either think you know everything when the polar opposite is true,
or you
are a troll. You could have Googled all of this and found that
everything you
have said is wrong, but you didn't. I guess I'll be moving on.
Wow.
There is so much about this you don't understand it's hard to know where
to begin.
Your thesis was (apparently) that if you got a fault code (which you
didn't articulate very well) that involved one of the vehicles
"stability systems" that a minor variance in the vehicles alignment
might result in the dealer denying coverage for the problem.
And that's bullshit for some many reasons.
But the biggest one is that you don't understand how minor the variance
from ideal alignment no loading the car with the recommended weights
would be...
...when compared to the tolerances that are permitted in the alignment value.
My 2012 BMW 135i weighs 3,373 lb with about a 52%/48% F/R weight distribution. Assuming the position of the driver's centre of gravity is approximately at 48% of the wheelbase behind the front axle, then my
weigh (about 195 lb) will be divided the same way between front and rear
as the car's own distribution.
So the empty weight on the front example empty would be 1,754 lb, and
with the driver, 1,855 lb. That's an increase of 5%.
So assuming a linear wheel rate, that would decrease the ride height by about 5%.
The ground clearance of the 135i is about 4". So adding the driver will change that by about 0.2"
How much do you think the front tire camber changes with 0.2" of bounce travel? Answer: almost zero. To be specific, the camber change per inch
is about 0.6 degrees, so the camber change would be 0.12-#.
The alignment spec for a 2012 BMW 135i's front wheel camber has an acceptable range of +0.2-# to -0.5-#
So assuming you even COULD set the camber to the minimum value of -0.5-#, when the driver drops into the seat, you'd increase by only a small fraction.
Caster: not affected materially by the driver's weight.
Toe: not affected.
Your whole thesis...
...is bullshit.
On 2026-11-10 11:56, Alan wrote:
On 2026-11-10 09:54, Bob West wrote:Shocking.
On Nov 10, 2026 at 2:00:39rC>AM CST, "Alan" <nuh-uh@nope.com> wrote:
On 2026-11-10 00:13, Bob West wrote:
On Nov 10, 2026 at 1:00:23rC>AM CST, "Alan" <nuh-uh@nope.com> wrote: >>>>>
On 2026-11-09 23:57, Bob West wrote:
On Nov 10, 2026 at 12:48:05rC>AM CST, "Alan" <nuh-uh@nope.com> wrote: >>>>>>>
On 2026-11-09 23:39, Bob West wrote:
On Nov 10, 2026 at 12:34:32rC>AM CST, "Alan" <nuh-uh@nope.com> wrote: >>>>>>>>>
On 2026-11-09 23:29, Bob West wrote:
On Nov 9, 2026 at 11:37:29rC>PM CST, "Alan" <nuh-uh@nope.com> >>>>>>>>>>> wrote:
On 2026-11-09 22:20, Bob West wrote:
On Nov 9, 2026 at 10:56:03rC>PM CST, "Alan" <nuh-uh@nope.com> >>>>>>>>>>>>> wrote:
On 2026-11-09 21:50, Bob West wrote:
On Nov 9, 2026 at 8:46:55rC>PM CST, "Alan" <nuh-uh@nope.com> >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> wrote:
Ummmmm...no.
The difference between an alignment done with a driver's >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> worth of weight
in the driver's seat and one done without will NOT change >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> whether or not
the stability warning lights come on or not.
Furthermore, what gives you the idea that cars record the >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> number of
times the stability augmentation systems have been >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> activated?
I did a little checking and no current production vehicle >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> keeps a log of
when the stability systems have been activated. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
Okay, I've been forever using "stability" loosely as an >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> all encompassing term
for driver assist systems - lane keep, emergency braking, >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> self driving, and
more that I can't think of right now. Those systems can >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> have issues if the
alignment is not done properly. Those weight procedures >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> might make very little
difference, but it might be enough to push it past the >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> tipping point for error
codes, like when the alignment is in spec, but at the edge >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> of the specs.
I'm not sure where you're getting this claim:
"Those systems can have issues if the alignment is not done >>>>>>>>>>>>>> properly."
I'm going to need some source for that, because (and don't >>>>>>>>>>>>>> take this
poorly) it sounds like complete nonsense.
The cars have at minimum steering sensors and cameras. To >>>>>>>>>>>>> simplify, if the
steering sensor says the car is going straight, but it is >>>>>>>>>>>>> not going straight,
the car senses a fault. If any sensor does not agree with >>>>>>>>>>>>> other sensors, you
are going to get a trouble code.
You're going pretty far afield here.
You have show not only that they have sensors...
...but that they also record the output of those sensors to >>>>>>>>>>>> be review later.
And they just don't.
You misunderstand. The car is not going to throw a code on the >>>>>>>>>>> alignment rack,
it will throw it while driving after the alignment. It is not >>>>>>>>>>> dependent on
recording the sensors. I have no idea if it has sensors
because i don't know
what specific car we are talking about. What I do know is that >>>>>>>>>>> whenever I
heard about that type of strict procedure, it tended to be a >>>>>>>>>>> car with all that
driver assist stuff. For any car that doesn't have it, you >>>>>>>>>>> should obviously
ignore what I said.
No, I don't misunderstand at all.
Your claim was that this code would be seen by the manufacturer >>>>>>>>>> and be
used to deny a claim.
But cars don't store codes for stability systems.
Not for anti-lock braking.
Not for traction control.
Not for steering.
And very few (if any) cars HAVE cameras.
I want to say, huh? But now I smell trolling.
Nope.
I refer you to your earlier statement:
'The other more important one is that with the driver assist tech in >>>>>>>> cars today, you need to get everything exactly right to minimize >>>>>>>> those
pesky stability warning lights. If they come on, the dealer can play >>>>>>>> gotcha and say the alignment was not properly done. Then you pay. >>>>>>>> And
it's a lot.'
And it's simply not so.
Google is your friend. I'm not your research assistant.
How is that even responsive?
You claimed that "the dealer" could discover that an "alignment was >>>>>> not
properly done" based on "stability warning lights".
And it JUST ISN'T SO, dude.
You clearly know very little about auto repair, and the same about
reading the
written word. If you take your car in for a warning light, many
things can
cause that.
Except the indicators for stability systems are NOT "warning lights".
Straight outta Lewis Carroll.
If the dealer follows the diagnosis to an improper alignment, that
is only one of the original possibilities. There is no trouble code
for an
improper alignment. Did you stop learning about cars in 1975? Why
don't you
start with Googling "do cars store antilock brake codes?" And then
go down
your list and ask the same about the rest of your list. And then you >>>>> can come
back and say, "oops", or you can just get ignored going forward.
It's time for
me to sleep now.
They store codes when the ABS system has a FAILURE...
Uh, if you look up a bit on this page, you can see that you said cars
"don't
store codes" for a list of things, including ABS. Did you change your
mind?
...NOT when you simply brake hard enough that you cause the ABS to
activate.
An intelligent person always considers the possibility that he is
wrong. So
you either think you know everything when the polar opposite is true,
or you
are a troll. You could have Googled all of this and found that
everything you
have said is wrong, but you didn't. I guess I'll be moving on.
Wow.
There is so much about this you don't understand it's hard to know where
to begin.
Your thesis was (apparently) that if you got a fault code (which you
didn't articulate very well) that involved one of the vehicles
"stability systems" that a minor variance in the vehicles alignment
might result in the dealer denying coverage for the problem.
And that's bullshit for some many reasons.
But the biggest one is that you don't understand how minor the variance
from ideal alignment no loading the car with the recommended weights
would be...
...when compared to the tolerances that are permitted in the alignment
value.
My 2012 BMW 135i weighs 3,373 lb with about a 52%/48% F/R weight
distribution. Assuming the position of the driver's centre of gravity is
approximately at 48% of the wheelbase behind the front axle, then my
weigh (about 195 lb) will be divided the same way between front and rear
as the car's own distribution.
So the empty weight on the front example empty would be 1,754 lb, and
with the driver, 1,855 lb. That's an increase of 5%.
So assuming a linear wheel rate, that would decrease the ride height by
about 5%.
The ground clearance of the 135i is about 4". So adding the driver will
change that by about 0.2"
How much do you think the front tire camber changes with 0.2" of bounce
travel? Answer: almost zero. To be specific, the camber change per inch
is about 0.6 degrees, so the camber change would be 0.12-#.
The alignment spec for a 2012 BMW 135i's front wheel camber has an
acceptable range of +0.2-# to -0.5-#
So assuming you even COULD set the camber to the minimum value of -0.5-#,
when the driver drops into the seat, you'd increase by only a small
fraction.
Caster: not affected materially by the driver's weight.
Toe: not affected.
Your whole thesis...
...is bullshit.
I provide quantitative analysis of the issue you THOUGHT you understood...
...and you have nothing to say.
On Nov 11, 2026 at 9:42:08rC>PM CST, "Alan" <nuh-uh@nope.com> wrote:
On 2026-11-10 11:56, Alan wrote:
On 2026-11-10 09:54, Bob West wrote:Shocking.
On Nov 10, 2026 at 2:00:39rC>AM CST, "Alan" <nuh-uh@nope.com> wrote:
On 2026-11-10 00:13, Bob West wrote:Straight outta Lewis Carroll.
On Nov 10, 2026 at 1:00:23rC>AM CST, "Alan" <nuh-uh@nope.com> wrote: >>>>>>
On 2026-11-09 23:57, Bob West wrote:
On Nov 10, 2026 at 12:48:05rC>AM CST, "Alan" <nuh-uh@nope.com> wrote: >>>>>>>>
On 2026-11-09 23:39, Bob West wrote:
On Nov 10, 2026 at 12:34:32rC>AM CST, "Alan" <nuh-uh@nope.com> wrote:
On 2026-11-09 23:29, Bob West wrote:
On Nov 9, 2026 at 11:37:29rC>PM CST, "Alan" <nuh-uh@nope.com> >>>>>>>>>>>> wrote:
On 2026-11-09 22:20, Bob West wrote:
On Nov 9, 2026 at 10:56:03rC>PM CST, "Alan" <nuh-uh@nope.com> >>>>>>>>>>>>>> wrote:
On 2026-11-09 21:50, Bob West wrote:
On Nov 9, 2026 at 8:46:55rC>PM CST, "Alan" <nuh-uh@nope.com> >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> wrote:
Ummmmm...no.
The difference between an alignment done with a driver's >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> worth of weight
in the driver's seat and one done without will NOT change >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> whether or not
the stability warning lights come on or not. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
Furthermore, what gives you the idea that cars record the >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> number of
times the stability augmentation systems have been >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> activated?
I did a little checking and no current production vehicle >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> keeps a log of
when the stability systems have been activated. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
Okay, I've been forever using "stability" loosely as an >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> all encompassing term
for driver assist systems - lane keep, emergency braking, >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> self driving, and
more that I can't think of right now. Those systems can >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> have issues if the
alignment is not done properly. Those weight procedures >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> might make very little
difference, but it might be enough to push it past the >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> tipping point for error
codes, like when the alignment is in spec, but at the edge >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> of the specs.
I'm not sure where you're getting this claim:
"Those systems can have issues if the alignment is not done >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> properly."
I'm going to need some source for that, because (and don't >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> take this
poorly) it sounds like complete nonsense.
The cars have at minimum steering sensors and cameras. To >>>>>>>>>>>>>> simplify, if the
steering sensor says the car is going straight, but it is >>>>>>>>>>>>>> not going straight,
the car senses a fault. If any sensor does not agree with >>>>>>>>>>>>>> other sensors, you
are going to get a trouble code.
You're going pretty far afield here.
You have show not only that they have sensors...
...but that they also record the output of those sensors to >>>>>>>>>>>>> be review later.
And they just don't.
You misunderstand. The car is not going to throw a code on the >>>>>>>>>>>> alignment rack,
it will throw it while driving after the alignment. It is not >>>>>>>>>>>> dependent on
recording the sensors. I have no idea if it has sensors >>>>>>>>>>>> because i don't know
what specific car we are talking about. What I do know is that >>>>>>>>>>>> whenever I
heard about that type of strict procedure, it tended to be a >>>>>>>>>>>> car with all that
driver assist stuff. For any car that doesn't have it, you >>>>>>>>>>>> should obviously
ignore what I said.
No, I don't misunderstand at all.
Your claim was that this code would be seen by the manufacturer >>>>>>>>>>> and be
used to deny a claim.
But cars don't store codes for stability systems.
Not for anti-lock braking.
Not for traction control.
Not for steering.
And very few (if any) cars HAVE cameras.
I want to say, huh? But now I smell trolling.
Nope.
I refer you to your earlier statement:
'The other more important one is that with the driver assist tech in >>>>>>>>> cars today, you need to get everything exactly right to minimize >>>>>>>>> those
pesky stability warning lights. If they come on, the dealer can play >>>>>>>>> gotcha and say the alignment was not properly done. Then you pay. >>>>>>>>> And
it's a lot.'
And it's simply not so.
Google is your friend. I'm not your research assistant.
How is that even responsive?
You claimed that "the dealer" could discover that an "alignment was >>>>>>> not
properly done" based on "stability warning lights".
And it JUST ISN'T SO, dude.
You clearly know very little about auto repair, and the same about >>>>>> reading the
written word. If you take your car in for a warning light, many
things can
cause that.
Except the indicators for stability systems are NOT "warning lights". >>>>
If the dealer follows the diagnosis to an improper alignment, that >>>>>> is only one of the original possibilities. There is no trouble code >>>>>> for an
improper alignment. Did you stop learning about cars in 1975? Why
don't you
start with Googling "do cars store antilock brake codes?" And then >>>>>> go down
your list and ask the same about the rest of your list. And then you >>>>>> can come
back and say, "oops", or you can just get ignored going forward.
It's time for
me to sleep now.
They store codes when the ABS system has a FAILURE...
Uh, if you look up a bit on this page, you can see that you said cars
"don't
store codes" for a list of things, including ABS. Did you change your
mind?
...NOT when you simply brake hard enough that you cause the ABS to
activate.
An intelligent person always considers the possibility that he is
wrong. So
you either think you know everything when the polar opposite is true,
or you
are a troll. You could have Googled all of this and found that
everything you
have said is wrong, but you didn't. I guess I'll be moving on.
Wow.
There is so much about this you don't understand it's hard to know where >>> to begin.
Your thesis was (apparently) that if you got a fault code (which you
didn't articulate very well) that involved one of the vehicles
"stability systems" that a minor variance in the vehicles alignment
might result in the dealer denying coverage for the problem.
And that's bullshit for some many reasons.
But the biggest one is that you don't understand how minor the variance
from ideal alignment no loading the car with the recommended weights
would be...
...when compared to the tolerances that are permitted in the alignment
value.
My 2012 BMW 135i weighs 3,373 lb with about a 52%/48% F/R weight
distribution. Assuming the position of the driver's centre of gravity is >>> approximately at 48% of the wheelbase behind the front axle, then my
weigh (about 195 lb) will be divided the same way between front and rear >>> as the car's own distribution.
So the empty weight on the front example empty would be 1,754 lb, and
with the driver, 1,855 lb. That's an increase of 5%.
So assuming a linear wheel rate, that would decrease the ride height by
about 5%.
The ground clearance of the 135i is about 4". So adding the driver will
change that by about 0.2"
How much do you think the front tire camber changes with 0.2" of bounce
travel? Answer: almost zero. To be specific, the camber change per inch
is about 0.6 degrees, so the camber change would be 0.12-#.
The alignment spec for a 2012 BMW 135i's front wheel camber has an
acceptable range of +0.2-# to -0.5-#
So assuming you even COULD set the camber to the minimum value of -0.5-#, >>> when the driver drops into the seat, you'd increase by only a small
fraction.
Caster: not affected materially by the driver's weight.
Toe: not affected.
Your whole thesis...
...is bullshit.
I provide quantitative analysis of the issue you THOUGHT you understood... >>
...and you have nothing to say.
Everyone knows different things. No one knows everything, although you believe
you do. What I have to say is based on not only master tech certs in ASE and all the GM lines, but also spending decades working in service departments of new car dealers, where I had - and used - direct access to the factory reps, engineers, and tech support. I know what they do on warranty claims, and plenty of it is absurd. I was trying to tell everyone how they think, and how they justify their positions. I would never bother putting weights in my own car to align it. I don't need all the tech spew above to know it would change nothing at all for my purposes. And yes, some forms of misalignment can set a code and warning light, in spite of your ridicule. Just look it up if you don't believe me. And again, if the car doesn't have all those new driver assist features, then of course it won't set a code. Do I really have to tell you that? Of course I do, because you simply cannot accept that you might be wrong about your stupid little arguments over nothing at all. You would argue that a misfire won't set a CEL, and then tell me that you drive a 55 Chevy. And the only reason I bother with this is that I have this enjoyment from making fun of ridiculous people.
On 2026-11-11 21:59, Bob West wrote:
On Nov 11, 2026 at 9:42:08rC>PM CST, "Alan" <nuh-uh@nope.com> wrote:
On 2026-11-10 11:56, Alan wrote:
On 2026-11-10 09:54, Bob West wrote:Shocking.
On Nov 10, 2026 at 2:00:39rC>AM CST, "Alan" <nuh-uh@nope.com> wrote: >>>>>
On 2026-11-10 00:13, Bob West wrote:Straight outta Lewis Carroll.
On Nov 10, 2026 at 1:00:23rC>AM CST, "Alan" <nuh-uh@nope.com> wrote: >>>>>>>
On 2026-11-09 23:57, Bob West wrote:
On Nov 10, 2026 at 12:48:05rC>AM CST, "Alan" <nuh-uh@nope.com> wrote: >>>>>>>>>
On 2026-11-09 23:39, Bob West wrote:
On Nov 10, 2026 at 12:34:32rC>AM CST, "Alan" <nuh-uh@nope.com> wrote:
On 2026-11-09 23:29, Bob West wrote:
On Nov 9, 2026 at 11:37:29rC>PM CST, "Alan" <nuh-uh@nope.com> >>>>>>>>>>>>> wrote:
On 2026-11-09 22:20, Bob West wrote:
On Nov 9, 2026 at 10:56:03rC>PM CST, "Alan" <nuh-uh@nope.com> >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> wrote:
On 2026-11-09 21:50, Bob West wrote:
On Nov 9, 2026 at 8:46:55rC>PM CST, "Alan" <nuh-uh@nope.com> >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> wrote:
Ummmmm...no.
The difference between an alignment done with a driver's >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> worth of weight
in the driver's seat and one done without will NOT change >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> whether or not
the stability warning lights come on or not. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
Furthermore, what gives you the idea that cars record the >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> number of
times the stability augmentation systems have been >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> activated?
I did a little checking and no current production vehicle >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> keeps a log of
when the stability systems have been activated. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
Okay, I've been forever using "stability" loosely as an >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> all encompassing term
for driver assist systems - lane keep, emergency braking, >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> self driving, and
more that I can't think of right now. Those systems can >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> have issues if the
alignment is not done properly. Those weight procedures >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> might make very little
difference, but it might be enough to push it past the >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> tipping point for error
codes, like when the alignment is in spec, but at the edge >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> of the specs.
I'm not sure where you're getting this claim:
"Those systems can have issues if the alignment is not done >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> properly."
I'm going to need some source for that, because (and don't >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> take this
poorly) it sounds like complete nonsense.
The cars have at minimum steering sensors and cameras. To >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> simplify, if the
steering sensor says the car is going straight, but it is >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> not going straight,
the car senses a fault. If any sensor does not agree with >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> other sensors, you
are going to get a trouble code.
You're going pretty far afield here.
You have show not only that they have sensors...
...but that they also record the output of those sensors to >>>>>>>>>>>>>> be review later.
And they just don't.
You misunderstand. The car is not going to throw a code on the >>>>>>>>>>>>> alignment rack,
it will throw it while driving after the alignment. It is not >>>>>>>>>>>>> dependent on
recording the sensors. I have no idea if it has sensors >>>>>>>>>>>>> because i don't know
what specific car we are talking about. What I do know is that >>>>>>>>>>>>> whenever I
heard about that type of strict procedure, it tended to be a >>>>>>>>>>>>> car with all that
driver assist stuff. For any car that doesn't have it, you >>>>>>>>>>>>> should obviously
ignore what I said.
No, I don't misunderstand at all.
Your claim was that this code would be seen by the manufacturer >>>>>>>>>>>> and be
used to deny a claim.
But cars don't store codes for stability systems.
Not for anti-lock braking.
Not for traction control.
Not for steering.
And very few (if any) cars HAVE cameras.
I want to say, huh? But now I smell trolling.
Nope.
I refer you to your earlier statement:
'The other more important one is that with the driver assist tech in >>>>>>>>>> cars today, you need to get everything exactly right to minimize >>>>>>>>>> those
pesky stability warning lights. If they come on, the dealer can play >>>>>>>>>> gotcha and say the alignment was not properly done. Then you pay. >>>>>>>>>> And
it's a lot.'
And it's simply not so.
Google is your friend. I'm not your research assistant.
How is that even responsive?
You claimed that "the dealer" could discover that an "alignment was >>>>>>>> not
properly done" based on "stability warning lights".
And it JUST ISN'T SO, dude.
You clearly know very little about auto repair, and the same about >>>>>>> reading the
written word. If you take your car in for a warning light, many
things can
cause that.
Except the indicators for stability systems are NOT "warning lights". >>>>>
If the dealer follows the diagnosis to an improper alignment, that >>>>>>> is only one of the original possibilities. There is no trouble code >>>>>>> for an
improper alignment. Did you stop learning about cars in 1975? Why >>>>>>> don't you
start with Googling "do cars store antilock brake codes?" And then >>>>>>> go down
your list and ask the same about the rest of your list. And then you >>>>>>> can come
back and say, "oops", or you can just get ignored going forward. >>>>>>> It's time for
me to sleep now.
They store codes when the ABS system has a FAILURE...
Uh, if you look up a bit on this page, you can see that you said cars >>>>> "don't
store codes" for a list of things, including ABS. Did you change your >>>>> mind?
...NOT when you simply brake hard enough that you cause the ABS to >>>>>> activate.
An intelligent person always considers the possibility that he is
wrong. So
you either think you know everything when the polar opposite is true, >>>>> or you
are a troll. You could have Googled all of this and found that
everything you
have said is wrong, but you didn't. I guess I'll be moving on.
Wow.
There is so much about this you don't understand it's hard to know where >>>> to begin.
Your thesis was (apparently) that if you got a fault code (which you
didn't articulate very well) that involved one of the vehicles
"stability systems" that a minor variance in the vehicles alignment
might result in the dealer denying coverage for the problem.
And that's bullshit for some many reasons.
But the biggest one is that you don't understand how minor the variance >>>> from ideal alignment no loading the car with the recommended weights
would be...
...when compared to the tolerances that are permitted in the alignment >>>> value.
My 2012 BMW 135i weighs 3,373 lb with about a 52%/48% F/R weight
distribution. Assuming the position of the driver's centre of gravity is >>>> approximately at 48% of the wheelbase behind the front axle, then my
weigh (about 195 lb) will be divided the same way between front and rear >>>> as the car's own distribution.
So the empty weight on the front example empty would be 1,754 lb, and
with the driver, 1,855 lb. That's an increase of 5%.
So assuming a linear wheel rate, that would decrease the ride height by >>>> about 5%.
The ground clearance of the 135i is about 4". So adding the driver will >>>> change that by about 0.2"
How much do you think the front tire camber changes with 0.2" of bounce >>>> travel? Answer: almost zero. To be specific, the camber change per inch >>>> is about 0.6 degrees, so the camber change would be 0.12-#.
The alignment spec for a 2012 BMW 135i's front wheel camber has an
acceptable range of +0.2-# to -0.5-#
So assuming you even COULD set the camber to the minimum value of -0.5-#, >>>> when the driver drops into the seat, you'd increase by only a small
fraction.
Caster: not affected materially by the driver's weight.
Toe: not affected.
Your whole thesis...
...is bullshit.
I provide quantitative analysis of the issue you THOUGHT you understood... >>>
...and you have nothing to say.
Everyone knows different things. No one knows everything, although you believe
you do. What I have to say is based on not only master tech certs in ASE and >> all the GM lines, but also spending decades working in service departments of
new car dealers, where I had - and used - direct access to the factory reps, >> engineers, and tech support. I know what they do on warranty claims, and
plenty of it is absurd. I was trying to tell everyone how they think, and how
they justify their positions. I would never bother putting weights in my own >> car to align it. I don't need all the tech spew above to know it would change
nothing at all for my purposes. And yes, some forms of misalignment can set a
code and warning light, in spite of your ridicule. Just look it up if you
don't believe me. And again, if the car doesn't have all those new driver
assist features, then of course it won't set a code. Do I really have to tell
you that? Of course I do, because you simply cannot accept that you might be >> wrong about your stupid little arguments over nothing at all. You would argue
that a misfire won't set a CEL, and then tell me that you drive a 55 Chevy. >> And the only reason I bother with this is that I have this enjoyment from
making fun of ridiculous people.
And yet you don't address a single factual point I just made...
You say "look it up"...
...but won't provide a source.
Illuminating.
On Nov 11, 2026 at 11:07:02rC>PM CST, "Alan" <nuh-uh@nope.com> wrote:
On 2026-11-11 21:59, Bob West wrote:
On Nov 11, 2026 at 9:42:08rC>PM CST, "Alan" <nuh-uh@nope.com> wrote:
On 2026-11-10 11:56, Alan wrote:
On 2026-11-10 09:54, Bob West wrote:Shocking.
On Nov 10, 2026 at 2:00:39rC>AM CST, "Alan" <nuh-uh@nope.com> wrote: >>>>>>
On 2026-11-10 00:13, Bob West wrote:Straight outta Lewis Carroll.
On Nov 10, 2026 at 1:00:23rC>AM CST, "Alan" <nuh-uh@nope.com> wrote: >>>>>>>>
On 2026-11-09 23:57, Bob West wrote:
On Nov 10, 2026 at 12:48:05rC>AM CST, "Alan" <nuh-uh@nope.com> wrote:
On 2026-11-09 23:39, Bob West wrote:
On Nov 10, 2026 at 12:34:32rC>AM CST, "Alan" <nuh-uh@nope.com> wrote:
On 2026-11-09 23:29, Bob West wrote:
On Nov 9, 2026 at 11:37:29rC>PM CST, "Alan" <nuh-uh@nope.com> >>>>>>>>>>>>>> wrote:
On 2026-11-09 22:20, Bob West wrote:
On Nov 9, 2026 at 10:56:03rC>PM CST, "Alan" <nuh-uh@nope.com> >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> wrote:
On 2026-11-09 21:50, Bob West wrote:
On Nov 9, 2026 at 8:46:55rC>PM CST, "Alan" <nuh-uh@nope.com> >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> wrote:
Ummmmm...no.
The difference between an alignment done with a driver's >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> worth of weight
in the driver's seat and one done without will NOT change >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> whether or not
the stability warning lights come on or not. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
Furthermore, what gives you the idea that cars record the >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> number of
times the stability augmentation systems have been >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> activated?
I did a little checking and no current production vehicle >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> keeps a log of
when the stability systems have been activated. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
Okay, I've been forever using "stability" loosely as an >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> all encompassing term
for driver assist systems - lane keep, emergency braking, >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> self driving, and
more that I can't think of right now. Those systems can >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> have issues if the
alignment is not done properly. Those weight procedures >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> might make very little
difference, but it might be enough to push it past the >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> tipping point for error
codes, like when the alignment is in spec, but at the edge >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> of the specs.
I'm not sure where you're getting this claim: >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
"Those systems can have issues if the alignment is not done >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> properly."
I'm going to need some source for that, because (and don't >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> take this
poorly) it sounds like complete nonsense.
The cars have at minimum steering sensors and cameras. To >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> simplify, if the
steering sensor says the car is going straight, but it is >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> not going straight,
the car senses a fault. If any sensor does not agree with >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> other sensors, you
are going to get a trouble code.
You're going pretty far afield here.
You have show not only that they have sensors... >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
...but that they also record the output of those sensors to >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> be review later.
And they just don't.
You misunderstand. The car is not going to throw a code on the >>>>>>>>>>>>>> alignment rack,
it will throw it while driving after the alignment. It is not >>>>>>>>>>>>>> dependent on
recording the sensors. I have no idea if it has sensors >>>>>>>>>>>>>> because i don't know
what specific car we are talking about. What I do know is that >>>>>>>>>>>>>> whenever I
heard about that type of strict procedure, it tended to be a >>>>>>>>>>>>>> car with all that
driver assist stuff. For any car that doesn't have it, you >>>>>>>>>>>>>> should obviously
ignore what I said.
No, I don't misunderstand at all.
Your claim was that this code would be seen by the manufacturer >>>>>>>>>>>>> and be
used to deny a claim.
But cars don't store codes for stability systems.
Not for anti-lock braking.
Not for traction control.
Not for steering.
And very few (if any) cars HAVE cameras.
I want to say, huh? But now I smell trolling.
Nope.
I refer you to your earlier statement:
'The other more important one is that with the driver assist tech in
cars today, you need to get everything exactly right to minimize >>>>>>>>>>> those
pesky stability warning lights. If they come on, the dealer can play
gotcha and say the alignment was not properly done. Then you pay. >>>>>>>>>>> And
it's a lot.'
And it's simply not so.
Google is your friend. I'm not your research assistant.
How is that even responsive?
You claimed that "the dealer" could discover that an "alignment was >>>>>>>>> not
properly done" based on "stability warning lights".
And it JUST ISN'T SO, dude.
You clearly know very little about auto repair, and the same about >>>>>>>> reading the
written word. If you take your car in for a warning light, many >>>>>>>> things can
cause that.
Except the indicators for stability systems are NOT "warning lights". >>>>>>
If the dealer follows the diagnosis to an improper alignment, that >>>>>>>> is only one of the original possibilities. There is no trouble code >>>>>>>> for an
improper alignment. Did you stop learning about cars in 1975? Why >>>>>>>> don't you
start with Googling "do cars store antilock brake codes?" And then >>>>>>>> go down
your list and ask the same about the rest of your list. And then you >>>>>>>> can come
back and say, "oops", or you can just get ignored going forward. >>>>>>>> It's time for
me to sleep now.
They store codes when the ABS system has a FAILURE...
Uh, if you look up a bit on this page, you can see that you said cars >>>>>> "don't
store codes" for a list of things, including ABS. Did you change your >>>>>> mind?
...NOT when you simply brake hard enough that you cause the ABS to >>>>>>> activate.
An intelligent person always considers the possibility that he is
wrong. So
you either think you know everything when the polar opposite is true, >>>>>> or you
are a troll. You could have Googled all of this and found that
everything you
have said is wrong, but you didn't. I guess I'll be moving on.
Wow.
There is so much about this you don't understand it's hard to know where >>>>> to begin.
Your thesis was (apparently) that if you got a fault code (which you >>>>> didn't articulate very well) that involved one of the vehicles
"stability systems" that a minor variance in the vehicles alignment
might result in the dealer denying coverage for the problem.
And that's bullshit for some many reasons.
But the biggest one is that you don't understand how minor the variance >>>>> from ideal alignment no loading the car with the recommended weights >>>>> would be...
...when compared to the tolerances that are permitted in the alignment >>>>> value.
My 2012 BMW 135i weighs 3,373 lb with about a 52%/48% F/R weight
distribution. Assuming the position of the driver's centre of gravity is >>>>> approximately at 48% of the wheelbase behind the front axle, then my >>>>> weigh (about 195 lb) will be divided the same way between front and rear >>>>> as the car's own distribution.
So the empty weight on the front example empty would be 1,754 lb, and >>>>> with the driver, 1,855 lb. That's an increase of 5%.
So assuming a linear wheel rate, that would decrease the ride height by >>>>> about 5%.
The ground clearance of the 135i is about 4". So adding the driver will >>>>> change that by about 0.2"
How much do you think the front tire camber changes with 0.2" of bounce >>>>> travel? Answer: almost zero. To be specific, the camber change per inch >>>>> is about 0.6 degrees, so the camber change would be 0.12-#.
The alignment spec for a 2012 BMW 135i's front wheel camber has an
acceptable range of +0.2-# to -0.5-#
So assuming you even COULD set the camber to the minimum value of -0.5-#, >>>>> when the driver drops into the seat, you'd increase by only a small
fraction.
Caster: not affected materially by the driver's weight.
Toe: not affected.
Your whole thesis...
...is bullshit.
I provide quantitative analysis of the issue you THOUGHT you understood... >>>>
...and you have nothing to say.
Everyone knows different things. No one knows everything, although you believe
you do. What I have to say is based on not only master tech certs in ASE and
all the GM lines, but also spending decades working in service departments of
new car dealers, where I had - and used - direct access to the factory reps,
engineers, and tech support. I know what they do on warranty claims, and >>> plenty of it is absurd. I was trying to tell everyone how they think, and how
they justify their positions. I would never bother putting weights in my own
car to align it. I don't need all the tech spew above to know it would change
nothing at all for my purposes. And yes, some forms of misalignment can set a
code and warning light, in spite of your ridicule. Just look it up if you >>> don't believe me. And again, if the car doesn't have all those new driver >>> assist features, then of course it won't set a code. Do I really have to tell
you that? Of course I do, because you simply cannot accept that you might be
wrong about your stupid little arguments over nothing at all. You would argue
that a misfire won't set a CEL, and then tell me that you drive a 55 Chevy. >>> And the only reason I bother with this is that I have this enjoyment from >>> making fun of ridiculous people.
And yet you don't address a single factual point I just made...
You say "look it up"...
...but won't provide a source.
Illuminating.
Because I am not your research assistant. I am not your trained monkey. I guess you don't use Google because you know everything it knows, right? LIke I
said, people like you never learn anything. Answer one question. Have you ever
said the words, "I didn't know that"?
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 54:23:57 |
| Calls: | 1,265 |
| Calls today: | 1 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
3 files (2,684K bytes) |
| Messages: | 285,563 |