The Electoral College, and small states, are in real danger
From
a425couple@a425couple@hotmail.com to
seattle.politics,or.politics,ca.politics,fl.politics,alt.law-enforcement on Fri Nov 13 06:48:42 2026
From Newsgroup: alt.law-enforcement
from 11-13-26 Seattle Times
The Electoral College, and small states, are in real danger
Our states are not simply administrative districts of a national
government, writes the author. Pictured are the U.S. Capitol, Washington Monument and Lincoln Memorial Reflecting Pool on Nov. 2. (Mark
Schiefelbein / The Associated Press)
By Chris Cargill Special to the Tri-City Herald (Kennewick, Wash.)
The election results of Nov. 3 could have consequences far beyond which
party controls Congress or individual state capitols. They could also fundamentally change the core of the Republic and the way we elect
presidents.
For decades, supporters of the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact
have been working to change how states award their presidential
electoral votes. They are approaching a critical threshold.
Already, 18 states and the District of Columbia, representing 222
electoral votes, have joined the compact. They need just 48 more
electoral votes to activate the agreement. For the record, Idaho,
Montana and Wyoming have not. Washington state has.
How does the National Popular Vote Compact work? States agree to give
their electoral college votes to whoever wins the national popular vote.
That means a candidate could win 100% of the vote in one state, but the
state would simply give its electoral college votes to someone else.
Once thought of as a folly with no chance of becoming activated, it now
seems like a real possibility. The results of Nov. 3rCOs state legislative
and gubernatorial elections matter because there are now one-party
trifectas in states that havenrCOt adopted this scheme. They could end up passing legislation to join the compact as soon as January.
And that makes this an immediate issue for Americans who care about the
future of our constitutional system, and those in smaller states.
HererCOs why.
We donrCOt hold one national election for president. We hold 50 separate
state elections.
That isnrCOt an accident. It reflects the constitutional structure
established by our Founders.
The United States is a federal republic. Our states are not simply administrative districts of a national government. They have their own constitutional responsibilities, and one of those responsibilities is determining how presidential electors are selected.
The Electoral College recognizes that federal structure.
Supporters of the National Popular Vote argue that it would make every individual vote count equally toward choosing the president. But it also likely means presidential candidates would only campaign in the largest
areas. Any chance of seeing a candidate in Montana, for example, would
go out the window. Smaller states would be shut out of the process.
There is also real concern about how a national popular vote would work
in the case of a close election. Instead of lawsuits and vote-finding
missions in one state, the mess would likely extend from sea to shining
sea as political parties hunt for votes rCo and file lawsuits rCo in their preferred areas in every state.
But the National Popular Vote Compact also raises serious constitutional questions that its supporters cannot simply dismiss.
First, thererCOs the ConstitutionrCOs Compact Clause. Article I, Section 10 restricts states from entering into certain agreements with one another without congressional consent. Supreme Court precedent has issued
exceptions to this in the case of rCLordinaryrCY agreements. But this would hardly be ordinary. Supporters know they cannot change the Electoral
College constitutionally, so they are simply trying to bypass it.
This leads to the second issue, can the Constitution be rewritten
without amending it? It is true that Article II gives state legislatures
broad authority to determine how their electors are appointed (consider allocations via congressional district winners), but allocating votes to
a candidate who didnrCOt win a state or district may go too far for justices.
This is no longer a question for political science lectures, it is a
clear and present danger to our Constitutional Republic. Over the next
90 days, just a handful of states could fundamentally alter the way we
elect presidents, bypassing the Constitution and forever leaving small
states behind, just in time for the 2028 election.
We better pay attention.
Chris Cargill is president of Mountain States Policy Center, a research organization based in Idaho, Montana, Wyoming and Eastern Washington
--- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2