From Newsgroup: alt.law-enforcement
Lawsuit over Seattle renter protection regulations can proceed
Goodman Real Estate, through a subsidiary that owns the Addison on
Fourth Apartments, seen here, sued Seattle in 2024, arguing a slate of
laws had rCLdestroyedrCY the buildingrCOs value and was an illegal taking of the property. (Kevin Clark / The Seattle Times)
By Heidi Groover Seattle Times business reporter
Seattle landlords could soon have an easier path to challenging the
cityrCOs tenant protection laws.
Division I of the Washington State Court of Appeals ruled Monday that a lawsuit taking aim at city rental regulations could move forward,
overturning a lower court decision that had sided with the city.
The case centers on an affordable apartment building in the Chinatown International District, where owners say city regulations have pushed operations to the financial brink.
Goodman Real Estate, through a subsidiary that owns the Addison on
Fourth Apartments, sued the city in 2024, arguing that a slate of laws
passed between 2018 and 2021 had rCLdestroyedrCY the buildingrCOs value and amounted to an illegal taking of the property.
Among the regulations: the cityrCOs limits on winter evictions,
restrictions on landlordsrCO use of criminal records to refuse to rent to tenants and the rCLroommate ordinancerCY that extends certain rights to tenantsrCO immediate family and other residents. The suit also blamed a
city requirement that landlords give six monthsrCO notice of rent
increases; mandatory relocation assistance, in which landlords must pay
low- and moderate-income tenants who move out after a landlord hikes
their rent by 10% or more; and now-expired COVID-era eviction restrictions.
City leaders passed the regulations over the past decade as high housing
costs highlighted the vulnerability of renters living on the edge.
Lawmakers in other cities and in the state Legislature have followed
suit on some of the policies, and tenant advocates say they help balance
the scales between landlords and renters.
Landlords have repeatedly challenged these regulations and others in
court over the years, often losing early in the process.
MondayrCOs ruling marks a departure that could allow similar cases to
advance in the legal process.
A King County Superior Court judge dismissed Goodman Real EstaterCOs
lawsuit last year, finding there wasnrCOt enough evidence the regulations amounted to a taking.
To the extent the cityrCOs laws affect the building, they rCLdo so in the
wake of the cityrCOs broader efforts to regulate landlord-tenant relationships,rCY Superior Court Judge Jason Poydras said when issuing his decision.
rCLThe City has lawful authority to enact citywide landlord-tenant ordinances,rCY Poydras said.
The Court of Appeals reversed that decision, sending the case back to
the lower court.
Among other arguments, the Court of Appeals found that the cityrCOs
roommate ordinance rCLtransforms uninvited, third-party tenants into tenantsrCY at the expense of the landlordrCOs rights.
The Addison, a 254-unit building, includes studio and one-bedroom
apartments affordable to renters making 60% of area median income, or
about $69,000 for a single person in Seattle, as part of the Low Income Housing Tax Credit program. The federal LIHTC program offers tax breaks
in exchange for restricted rents for at least 30 years.
GRE, a Seattle-based firm that owns thousands of apartments, bought the building in 2012 for $12.5 million and spent $26.5 million on
renovations. The building was cash-flow positive from 2015 through 2018, collecting between 91% and 94% of its maximum potential rental income.
That began dropping in 2019 and especially after COVID-19 hit in 2020, according to court filings.
By 2023, 45% of the buildingrCOs units were vacant, and it brought in only
44% of its maximum annual rental income. The landlord also faced
increased costs for insurance, maintenance and security.
The building lost nearly $6 million from 2019 through 2023, according to
court filings, despite earlier projections that it would have been $1.5 million in the black during that same time frame.
The propertyrCOs owners blame city regulations for that loss, arguing they forced the building to accept tenants who caused safety and maintenance issues, leading to higher turnover among renters and staff rCo all
amounting to a government taking of the property.
The Addison is now in receivership with no interested buyers, said Sean
Flynn, president of the Rental Housing Association of Washington, a
lobbying group that represents GRE and other landlords.
rCLThere are limits to what the government can do in terms of regulation
in the landlord-tenant sphere. There are indeed boundaries, which the
city didnrCOt seem to believe,rCY Flynn said. (An attorney for GRE directed
a request for comment to Flynn.)
City attorneys argued LIHTC restrictions, not city laws, restricted the landlordrCOs ability to sell the building to be converted into market-rate housing. The Court of Appeals found it was too early to dismiss GRErCOs
claims that the cityrCOs regulations hampered its ability to find a buyer.
The Seattle city attorneyrCOs office could appeal the decision to the
state Supreme Court.
rCLWerCOre reviewing the decision and are meeting internally to discuss next steps,rCY Dan Nolte, chief of staff at the city attorneyrCOs office, said in an email. rCLWe havenrCOt made a decision on an appeal yet.rCY
Heidi Groover: 206-464-8273 or
hgroover@seattletimes.com.
--- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2