From Newsgroup: alt.law-enforcement
from todays Seattle Times
https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/politics/is-the-wa-millionaires-tax-really-coming-for-public-pensions/#comments
Is the WA rCymillionaires taxrCO really coming for public pensions?
Oct. 24, 2026 at 6:00 am Updated Oct. 24, 2026 at 6:00 am
Lawmakers in Olympia approved the high-earner tax in the spring.
Initiative 645 seeks to repeal it. A “no” vote on the
measure keeps the tax on the books. (Andrew Burke-Stevenson / The
Seattle Times)
Lawmakers in Olympia approved the high-earner tax in the spring.
Initiative 645 seeks to repeal it. A rCLnorCY vote on the measure keeps the tax on the books. (Andrew Burke-Stevenson / The Seattle Times)
Skip Ad
Jim Brunner By Jim Brunner
Seattle Times political reporter
When you think about the mansion- and yacht-owning millionaire crowd,
retired schoolteachers donrCOt typically leap to mind.
Nevertheless, foes of WashingtonrCOs new high-earner income tax are making
a pitch to teachers rCo and other public-sector workers rCo contending the so-called rCLmillionaires taxrCY is a threat to their pensions.
In ads and a recent televised debate, supporters of Initiative 645,
which aims to repeal the tax, have hyped technical language in the new
law that specifies public pensions are not exempt.
In practice, that means little for retired public employees right now.
The tax, due to take effect in 2028, only applies to household income of
more than $1 million a year. No one in the state pension system receives
even half that.
The staterCOs highest individual pension payout now is $385,292 a year, according to Adam Torgerson, a spokesperson for the Washington State Department of Retirement Systems. The vast bulk of state retirees get
much less. For example, the staterCOs largest pension plan, known as PERS
2, pays an average of roughly $33,000 a year to recent retirees with 21
to 25 years of state service, according to the pension systemrCOs latest annual report.
Steve Gordon, who chairs the pro-I-645 campaign, concedes the tax as
enacted would not immediately affect public-sector pension recipients.
But, Gordon said in an email, public employees and retirees, like
everyone in Washington, rCLare subject to the 9.9% tax on WA income, they
just fall under the $1 million deduction, for now.rCY
ThatrCOs the real thrust of the I-645 campaignrCOs argument rCo that the pension language is evidence that Democrats plan to lower the income-tax threshold to sweep up more households.
rCLOdd thing to write into a bill about millionairesrCa If it only ever hits $1 million, why did Olympia bother taking the shield off your pension?rCY
said Redmond hedge fund manager Brian Heywood, who bankrolled I-645, in
a post on X addressed to public employees.
Gov. Bob Ferguson has vowed to veto any expansion of the rCLmillionaires taxrCY to lower income brackets, but some Democratic state lawmakers have openly discussed doing just that in exchange for cutting other taxes.
State Senate Majority Leader Jamie Pedersen, the prime sponsor of the rCLmillionaires tax,rCY said lawmakers drafted it to line up with how
pensions are generally treated for tax purposes. State pensions are
subject to federal income tax, for example.
So if a person gets a state pension and has other income that pushes
their total pay over $1 million, theyrCOd be on the hook for the new tax.
The 9.9% tax applies only to the portion over $1 million, so someone
making $1.3 million would owe tax on $300,000 of that, for a tax bill of $29,700.
Across Washington state, only about 25,000 people are expected to make
enough to owe the new income tax when the first payments come due in 2029.
Sensing an opportunity to sway voters with the pension issue, the Yes on
I-645 campaign has run ads featuring Tim Manly, fire chief in Brinnon, Jefferson County.
In the ads, Manly accuses lawmakers of breaking a promise to public
workers with rCLone sentence, buried in the income-tax bill.rCY
rCLIrCOm not a millionaire; IrCOm a firefighter. IrCOm voting yes on 645 to restore retirement protections,rCY Manly says in the ads, which disclose
the top donors to the I-645 campaign, including the Seattle venture
capital fund Madrona Venture Group.
The effort has gotten the attention of the staterCOs top labor unions,
which have strongly backed the new high-earners income tax and urge a
rCLNorCY vote on I-645 to keep it in place. TheyrCOve called the pension argument a dishonest scare tactic from rich people who want to avoid the rCLmillionaires tax.rCY
April Sims, president of the Washington State Labor Council, said in an
online video response that a teacher in Olympia would have to work for
278 years to earn pension benefits of over $1 million.
rCLSo donrCOt believe the lies coming from the same people who have made it clear that they donrCOt care about us. The rCymillionaires taxrCO wonrCOt affect
anyonerCOs pensions. Do the math. It canrCOt,rCY she said.
That message was echoed in postcards mailed by the labor council to
voters this week.
The staterCOs top public-sector unions have largely bankrolled the No on
I-645 campaign, trying to preserve the new tax, which is expected to
raise more than $3 billion a year.
Most of that money will be directed to the state operating budget, which
pays for K-12 schools, healthcare and other services, including the
salaries for public workers who provide the services.
With the Nov. 3 Election Day mail ballot deadline approaching, the union-backed opposition campaign against I-645 has a lot more money to
spread its message.
The No on 645 campaign has raised $12.8 million as of Friday. Its
largest single donor is the Washington Education Association, which
represents teachers and other K-12 school employees. The union has
donated more than $3 million.
The Yes on 645 campaign has raised $3.3 million, including $1 million
from Lawrence Hughes, a retired Medina businessman.
Jim Brunner:
jbrunner@seattletimes.com. Jim Brunner is a political
reporter for The Seattle Times, where he covers how the staterCOs elected leaders are serving the public with an eye for watchdog and high-impact explanatory stories.
See more Seattle Times content on Google
View 356 Comments / 355 New
The Seattle Times encourages constructive conversations about the facts
in our articles.
Keep this space respectful, inclusive and sustainable
Be considerate
Criticize ideas, not people
Stay on topic
Keep it PG
DonrCOt troll, attack or marginalize others
Report bad behavior
Please read the article and our Commenting Code of Conduct before participating.
Comments automatically close 72 hours after an article is published.
To provide you with a better experience, all comments containing links
are reviewed to help prevent spam.
To reach our customer care team, email
customercare@seattletimes.com.
Post a comment
3,000 characters remaining
Sort by
Newest
The money a person receives from a pension is considered income for
Federal income tax purposes. If a personrCOs pension pushes their income
over the $1million threshold why shouldnrCOt it be subject to the tax? The only exception to that is if the money was put into the pension vehicle
after taxes were paid on that income before it was put in the pension
fund. An example would be a Roth IRA.
Oh they will be after the Roth's too.
As a Roth IRA comes from after tax money from employment made in the
year of contribution, it is also not Fed taxable when you withdraw it. However, the annual limitation limit on how much you can contribute per
year, it would take a lot longer than your lifetime to accumulate have
that much there to withdraw.
The moral of the story is only one side is allowed to make questionable arguments without scrutiny from the Seattle Times
in other words "The moral of the story is 'do not believe the LIES
coming from the lips of millionaires and billionaires supporting I-645'....."!!!
(Edited)
Relative to the premise of this article, maybe the real issue here is
this: should any public employee receive a pension that comes even
remotely close to subjecting them to a tax over $1 million income?
You dont need to receive a $1M pension to be hit by the tax. The income
tax is on all income. Plus, no sane person thinks the threshold will
stay at $1M very long.
And every sane person realizes that the only way the threshold will be
lowered is if new legislation is passed. That is not automatic.
It is with this legislature. Vote them out.
your nose grows every time you post on this subject!!!
Bottom line, this tax, if it succeeds, will definitely encompass lower
bracket taxpayers. This state has an unquenchable thirst for money and
will use every means necessary to extract every last dollar from
taxpayers to fund anything and everything they dream up, no priorities.
Even though Governor Ferguson claims he will veto any downward expansion
he will not sit in that office forever. Democrats' mantra is tax and
spend and to spend they need money. Is it no wonder people leave blue
states? Vote YES to stop this extortion of hard-earned money from us taxpayers. They always claim the money is for children, education, and
other, too many, heartwarming social projects. Don't believe them. The
end goal is always stick it to the taxpayers. They will not leave
anything untaxed, and the search is constant and a way of life in blue
states.
The Knickerbockers recorded a song that emphasises your screed.....LIES!!
Who do you trust more? Native Washingtonian Ken Jennings or billionaire California transplant Brien Haywood? Vote No on I-645 and be part of the
Blue Wave on Nov. 3rd.
Given the reckless spending of Olympia - I'd trust Haywood.
Jennings is about to be fired by Sony for losing half of their audience. Egotistical maniac.
Why on earth do you want to forfeit your hard-earned money to the state
with another tax? Is it because you think you will not have to pay an
income tax? As sure as the sun rises in the east the legislature will
lower the threshold every budget cycle to encompass more wage earners
until all are paying. It will be like a blank check to cover every
budget deficit. Problem with those that are saying NO is they probably
think it will never reach them or, they have no skin in the game and
feel sticking it to the wealthy is the way to go. Stop this money grab.
The state doesn't need more money; they need to get spending and ever-increasing social programs with high salaries under control. Vote
YES to keep Washington state income tax free.
Wh on earth do you LIE so much with your false narratives on this subject!! Pure dishonest scare tactics. The state legislature reflects the will of
the people. The voters decide whether to keep the current income tax on
high earners and if a future legislature wants to eliminate sales and
property taxes in favor of a flat income tax, the voters will ultimately decide again when they cross that bridge when it happens.
or billionaire California transplant Brien Haywood? [sic]
How many times must you be told that Brian Heywood is not a billionaire?
He is not on the Forbes list of billionaires living in Washington state. Currently there are 11 billionaires living in WA.
I trust millionaire Brian Heywood more.
--- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2