From Newsgroup: alt.law-enforcement
Considerations on Red Light traffic enforcement
from
https://www.oregonlive.com/crime/2026/10/oregons-yellow-lights-could-be-too-short-potentially-overturning-scores-of-traffic-tickets-medford-lawsuit-argues.html
OregonrCOs red-light traffic tickets may have a yellow-light problem
Updated: Oct. 07, 2026, 2:43 p.m.|Published: Oct. 07, 2026, 11:30 a.m.
Generic
Generic photo of traffic light, yellow light. Thursday, January 19,
2023. Patti Sapone | NJ Advance Media for NJ.com
By Isabel Funk | The Oregonian/OregonLive
Thousands of traffic tickets issued in Oregon for driving through red
lights ultimately could be overturned, potentially forcing
municipalities to refund millions of dollars, a lawyer in Jackson County
says.
A class-action lawsuit against Medford is arguing that yellow lights at
East Stewart Avenue and Barnett Road in the city arenrCOt long enough, preventing drivers from being able to either safely stop or safely
continue through the intersection. William Smith, the attorney for the plaintiff, said if the lawsuit is successful, it could apply to
intersections across the state, including in Portland.
Chiropractor Glenn Gumaer was driving in Medford four years ago when he
came up on an intersection as the light turned yellow, the lawsuit says.
He drove through the light before it turned red, and at the intersection immediately following, at Stewart and Barnett, the same thing happened
and he again drove through the intersection. Except this time an
automated red-light camera determined he went through too late.
When the traffic ticket arrived in the mail, Gumaer followed directions
to a website where he could watch the video of his car. He realized the
yellow light showed for just over three seconds. The previous light, he discovered when he went back and timed it, showed for five seconds.
rCLI thought, rCyWell, that canrCOt be right,rCOrCY Gumaer said. rCLSo this is where
I opened the big can of worms.rCY
Gumaer started researching and soon found out about whatrCOs known as the extended kinematic equation, the formula that the Institute of
Transportation Engineers recommends using to calculate how long a yellow
light should show, depending on the posted speed limit. Under that
formula, the light should have shown for just over six seconds.
The current recommendation was issued in 2020. Mats J|nrlstr||m, who
developed the current formula, said the previous one only considered the
time necessary for a driver going straight through the intersection. The
new formula, J|nrlstr||m said, includes an extra variable to account for
the change in speed when a driver making a turn slows down.
Medford is still using the older ITE formula, so it calculates a shorter
time.
rCLIt puts people in this quote, unquote, rCydilemma zonerCO of, do I stop suddenly and take the chances of someone rear-ending me because I
stopped too quickly, or do I gun it and get through the light and do so unsafely?rCY Smith, GumaerrCOs attorney, said to the Oregonian/OregonLive.
Oregon law requires yellow lights to adhere to the ITE recommendation
whenever a red-light camera is in use.
But Medford is arguing that the Institute of Transportation Engineers recommends the new equation as one of several recommended options. The
city says the ITE does not require the new formula as the only option
and that itrCOs still acceptable to use the old formula.
The city did not respond to a request for comment.
Judge David Orr recently rejected the cityrCOs motion for summary judgment
and allowed the lawsuit to move forward, Smith said. The judgerCOs order hasnrCOt yet been formally filed with the court.
Portland uses the same equation as Medford, a Portland city spokesperson
said, and the state and many other cities also rely on the old formula, according to court records.
rCLWhen I got into this, I began looking at all the photo lights,rCY Smith said, rCLand realizing that, yeah, theyrCOre all mistimed.rCY
Smith said that means other municipalities, like Portland, could be
vulnerable to lawsuits. People who got tickets in those cities may be
able to bring similar class-action cases to get their tickets
overturned. ItrCOs also possible the Medford case eventually could get elevated to the state court of appeals and then the Supreme Court, which
would give it state-wide applications.
Smith now plans to file his own motion for summary judgment and get a
trial date set. If Orr certifies the class, then any driver who received
a ticket at the East Stewart Avenue and Barnett Road intersection in
Medford will become part of the lawsuit.
Powered by Advance Insights
Isabel Funk headshot
Isabel Funk
Isabel Funk is an Express Team reporter for The Oregonian/Oregon Live
covering general breaking news and the Portland Police Bureau. She has previously worked as the breaking news and public safety reporter in...more
--- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2