Washington Democrat plan to get rid of conservative sheriffs unconstitutional!
From
a425couple@a425couple@hotmail.com to
seattle.politics,alt.law-enforcement,alt.law.enforcement,or.politics,ca.politics on Mon Oct 5 09:06:17 2026
From Newsgroup: alt.law-enforcement
(Washington Court decided Democrat's plan to have their bureaucrats to
be able remove Counties elected sheriffs was unconstitutional.
They were warned of this but legislature and governor pushed
bad law through anyway.
Democrats wanted to be able to purge free speech of conservative
sheriffs.)
(From todays' Seattle Times)
New standards for sheriffs fail to survive court test
By Jake Goldstein-Street Washington State Standard
A judge Friday threw out tough new job standards for county sheriffs
approved by Washington lawmakers this year that critics argued would
force some out of office.
The decision from Thurston County Superior Court Judge Christine
Schaller permanently blocks the most controversial pieces of the Democratic-sponsored policy, pending an appeal by the state. A formal
court order outlining the ruling is expected later this month.
The lawrCOs supporters see it as vital to building trust in law
enforcement by requiring sheriffs to meet the same standards as their deputies. But its opponents, including a dozen sheriffs who challenged
the law, say it amounts to state overreach that could override the will
of voters by ousting elected sheriffs.
rCLThe First Amendment and democracy, for all of us to be participants in that, it requires that we have the belief that people may elect someone
that we donrCOt like, people may vote for someone that we donrCOt like, and elected officials, as they frequently do, may say things that we donrCOt like,rCY plaintiffsrCO attorney Mark Lamb said.
rCLAnd the remedy for that is not to have a commission that is able to
remove them from office when they do something that they deem to be
offensive or impermissible,rCY Lamb continued.
Mike Faulk, a spokesperson for the attorney generalrCOs office, said the
state plans to appeal the ruling to rCLdefend this important state law.rCY
Senate Bill 5974 requires county sheriffs, who are usually elected, to
meet the same minimum eligibility standards as police chiefs, who are appointed. Failure to do so or getting state certification revoked are
grounds for removal from office under the law. The seldom-used recall
process is how voters can remove sheriffs before their term ends.
Schaller temporarily blocked much of the law April 29, the day before it
was set to take effect so elections for sheriffs this year moved forward without the new eligibility requirements.
The state appealed SchallerrCOs earlier decision to the state Supreme
Court, but a court commissioner chose to maintain the status quo and
declined to lift the judgerCOs block.
The attorney generalrCOs office defended the law in court.
rCLVoters place immense trust in sheriffs to faithfully execute the duties
of office, and accountability, trust, and proper training are
paramount,rCY Assistant Attorney General Kristen Valore said in court
Friday. rCLThe Legislature passed Senate Bill 5974 to further these
interests and ensure that county sheriffs meet the same basic
qualifications as other law enforcement leaders in the state.rCY
Democrats in the Legislature passed the law and Gov. Bob Ferguson signed
it despite ardent opposition from Republican lawmakers.
SchallerrCOs action sets aside the lawrCOs imposition of new criteria that,
in order to be a sheriff, one must have at least five years of law
enforcement experience, no felony or gross misdemeanor convictions, be
at least 25 years old and no history of actions that would get state certification as a peace officer revoked. They have to undergo
background checks to confirm they meet the requirements. Under the law,
if a sheriff is removed from office, county officials would appoint a replacement.
The law sought to force sheriffs not already certified to get state certification from the Criminal Justice Training Commission within nine
months of taking office. Under current law, they have a year.
Five-member hearing panels from the Criminal Justice Training Commission
make final decisions on decertification. The panels include two police officials. These decisions can be appealed.
Examples of misconduct that has gotten officers decertified in recent
years include crimes including domestic violence, harassment and sexual
abuse, and interfering with an internal investigation and endorsing on
social media police use of force against protesters.
The decision comes in response to lawsuits brought by sheriffs across
the state.
The sheriffs who brought the original litigation include John Nowels of Spokane County, Glenn Blakeslee of Pend Oreille County, Brad Manke of
Stevens County and Ray Maycumber of Ferry County. The Washington State SheriffsrCO Association filed a similar lawsuit of its own.
Walla Walla County Sheriff Mark Crider said he and other sheriffs are rCLfairly satisfiedrCY with the ruling, noting that the rCLmajority of it that we thought was unconstitutional, she agreed with us.rCY
rCLI think it wouldrCOve disenfranchised the voters,rCY said Crider, who is retiring this year. rCLThatrCOs our big thing. The right of the people is being impaired because they donrCOt get to select whorCOs representing them.rCY
Anne Levinson, a retired judge who helped draft the law, countered in an
email after FridayrCOs hearing that rCLthere is great harm to the public and in particular to vulnerable individuals if top law enforcement officials
are allowed to continue in office after having committed serious misconduct.rCY
SchallerrCOs ruling doesnrCOt appear to block other provisions in the law related to police chief standards and the use of law enforcement volunteers.
Washington State Standard is part of States Newsroom, the nationrCOs
largest state-focused nonprofit news organization.
--- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2