From Newsgroup: alt.law-enforcement
A federal judge ruled Wednesday that two police officers who defended
the U.S. Capitol on Jan. 6, 2021, have no standing to sue over their
names rCo and those of other first responders rCo not appearing on a plaque commemorating law enforcementrCOs response to the attack.
U.S. District Judge Dabney Friedrich said she would grant the Architect
of the CapitolrCOs motion to dismiss the pairrCOs lawsuit rCLfor lack of jurisdiction.rCY
The two officers, former U.S. Capitol Police officer Harry Dunn and
active District of Columbia Metropolitan Police officer Daniel Hodges,
sued the architect over the missing names, as the plaque only lists law enforcement agencies and organizations that sent personnel to defend the Capitol rCLalongside a QR code that visitors may scan to access the officersrCO names,rCY court documents show.
honors the extraordinary individuals who bravely protected and defended
this symbol of democracy on January 6, 2021. Their heroism will never be forgotten.rCY
The plaque was also planned to be permanently visible rCLon the western
front of the CapitolrCY but has been temporarily displayed in rCLthe non- public Senate wingrCY as of March.
Friedrich, an appointee of former President George W. Bush, noted that standing is rCLassessed from the time of the complaint.rCY
rCLBecause the officers lacked standing when they commenced this action,
this court lacks subject-matter jurisdiction and must dismiss the case,rCY
she wrote.
She asserted that neither officer had a cognizable injury at the time of
the plaquerCOs installation and dismissed their argument that the
architect had rCLexacerbated rCypsychic injuries'rCY they have experienced since Jan. 6. Dunn and Hodges also argued that not recognizing
individual service emboldened others to rCLharass them and disparagerCY the officersrCO response.
rCLTo be sure, the officers have a far more personal connection to the
plaque than the public at large,rCY Friedrich wrote. rCLThey are not rCyjust any personrCO rCa they are among the very officers Congress sought to honor. That gives them an understandable and deeply personal interest in
whether the government recognizes their service in the manner Congress prescribed.rCY
rCLBut Article II standing rCyis not measured by the intensity of the litigantrCOs interest,rCyrCY she continued. rCLIt requires an injury in fact rCa
Even if the ArchitectrCOs failure to install the plaque contributed to the officersrCO injuries, the officers would need to show that mandating its installation would be rCylikelyrCO to alleviate those injuries.rCY
The officers initially filed a lawsuit over a delay in installing the
plaque. Former President Biden signed a law in 2022 requesting a plaque
to honor the officers who defended the Capitol during the attack, giving
its installation a one-year deadline. But the plaque was never erected.
It was finally installed in March of this year, with the years-long
delay prompting Hodges and Dunn to separately sue the Architect of the
Capitol to rCLprominently displayrCY the memorial in a rCLpublicly accessiblerCY
area in the Senate wing. The officers argued that the plaque was
rCLhidden.rCY
https://thehill.com/regulation/court-battles/6123590-jan-6-plaque- lawsuit-denied/
--- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2