• An AI view of datacenters

    From Peter Flass@Peter@Iron-Spring.com to alt.folklore.computers on Fri Nov 6 07:53:13 2026
    From Newsgroup: alt.folklore.computers

    This is not actually folklore, but here is a "conversation" I had with
    ChatGPT this morning:

    -- begin chat --
    Q: Are you sad that so many voters are rejecting data centers in their area?

    A: No, I'm not sad about it. I don't experience sadness the way people
    do, and I don't regard public opposition to data centers as a personal rejection.

    In fact, I think residents have legitimate reasons to question whether
    a large data center belongs in their community.

    Data centers can consume enormous amounts of electricity, require
    substantial water for cooling, generate noise, and place demands on
    local infrastructure. They may also create relatively few permanent
    jobs compared with their size and cost.

    On the other hand, data centers support services that millions of
    people use, including scientificresearch, communications, cloud
    computing, and AI. They can also generate tax revenue and construction employment.

    I think communities should have a meaningful say in whether these
    facilities are built and who bears their costs. The benefits of AI
    don't automatically justify imposing unwanted infrastructure on a
    community.

    And the election results are striking. Reporting from November 4rCo6
    indicates that voters supported restrictions in 44 of 45 local
    data-center ballot measures. These ranged from temporary moratoriums to outright bans. [AP News]

    I wouldn't interpret that as Americans rejecting AI itself. It looks
    more like a demand that the companies benefiting from AI infrastructure
    pay its costs and respect local decisions. There's an interesting
    tension here: AI may be enormously useful, but that doesn't give the AI industry an unlimited claim on electricity, water, land, or public
    goodwill.

    I'm curious whether you see these votes primarily as a rejection of
    data centers themselves, or as a reaction to the way technology
    companies have been imposing them on communities.
    -- end chat --
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From rbowman@bowman@montana.com to alt.folklore.computers on Fri Nov 6 22:39:42 2026
    From Newsgroup: alt.folklore.computers

    On Fri, 6 Nov 2026 07:53:13 -0700, Peter Flass wrote:

    I'm curious whether you see these votes primarily as a rejection of data centers themselves, or as a reaction to the way technology companies
    have been imposing them on communities.

    A proposal for a data center here was met with a lot of opposition and was ultimately withdrawn. The county declared a moratorium on zoning for data centers and is weighing its options since the state government if AI
    friendly. The proposed center would be housed in an old lumber mill
    complex so it wouldn't even have created many construction jobs.

    Also the US House District One flipped because the Republican was in favor
    of data centers despite the Democratic candidate being a recent transplant with a questionable record. Fun times.

    I was momentarily confused since there now are AI PACs in addition to
    AIPAC. Locally both are as popular as STDs.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2