• Re: BAD EDITTED SCENE AFTER VADER IS SLICED UP

    From tuliprenegade@tuliprenegade@gmail-dot-com.no-spam.invalid (Tulip Renegade) to alt.fan.starwars on Sat May 23 12:46:39 2020
    From Newsgroup: alt.fan.starwars


    Michael Harmon wrote:
    The last time i saw revenge of the sith i sat in the 4th row and i
    noticed that after vader lands on the sand he looks up and mouths
    "maa....." then it cuts to obi wan cry of "you were
    the chosen one" Okay
    this was also the 5th time id seen the film and i always thought it
    was
    pretty abrupt when he crys "you were the chosen one"
    i remember reading the book and almost tearing up and was actually
    sad
    that i didnt in the movie. anyway i read the making of revenge of
    the
    sith and it says that anakin yells to obiwan "master save
    me" hence the
    "maa.."
    the scene would have went anakin hits the sand knows his fate and
    pleads
    to obiwan "master save me" obiwan looks on then says
    "you were the
    chosen one"

    I think that is why it looks so choppy or rushed because of the
    bad
    edit. now we can debate if anakin should have been shown pleading
    to
    obiwan but they needed to clean that up better.
    all you superfans like me who go multiple times, next time look and
    see
    if im right or crazy.
    i think this is the prequel version of when vader finishes talking
    to
    tarkin then waves his hand for no reason.

    Jedi Maximus


    http://community.webtv.net/JediMaximus/LukeSkywalkerAJedi


    Here's the scene....

    View the attachments for this post at: http://www.jlaforums.com/viewtopic.php?p=546023516#546023516


    This is a response to the post seen at: http://www.jlaforums.com/viewtopic.php?p=424870#424870


    --- Synchronet 3.21d-Linux NewsLink 1.2