• Proposal: alt.fan.john-c-dvorak

    From Chris Abraham@chris@gerriscorp.com to alt.config on Wed Nov 11 15:22:43 2026
    From Newsgroup: alt.config

    I propose the creation of a new unmoderated Usenet newsgroup:

    alt.fan.john-c-dvorak

    For your newsgroups file:

    alt.fan.john-c-dvorak John C. Dvorak: his columns, books, and broadcasts.

    CHARTER

    alt.fan.john-c-dvorak exists for discussion of the life and work of John
    C. Dvorak (1946-2026), the American technology columnist and broadcaster:
    his columns, essays, and books; his television, radio, and podcast work;
    his career and his influence on technology journalism; and the technology
    he covered, discussed through his work.

    On topic:

    - His columns and essays, from the early 1980s on, in PC Magazine,
    InfoWorld, Forbes, MacUser, MarketWatch, and elsewhere, and on his own
    site, dvorak.org
    - His books, and the books he co-authored
    - His broadcasts and podcasts, including Silicon Spin, CrankyGeeks,
    Tech5, X3, and the No Agenda podcast he co-hosted with Adam Curry from
    2007 to 2026
    - His career, his predictions and his record, and his place in the
    history of personal computing
    - Memories: meeting him, hearing him speak, corresponding with him,
    reading him over the years
    - Archival finds: old columns, recordings, interviews, and
    photographs, with sources credited
    - The products, companies, and trends he covered, discussed through
    his writing and his commentary

    Off topic:

    - Spam and commercial advertising
    - Binary postings of any kind; link to files instead
    - The Dvorak keyboard layout and August Dvorak; both belong in other
    groups - Personal abuse aimed at other posters

    The group is unmoderated. Post in plain text, quote only what you are answering, and keep signatures short. Postings are distributed to news
    servers around the world and archived permanently. Write accordingly.

    RATIONALE AND JUSTIFICATION OF READERSHIP

    No Usenet group covers John C. Dvorak. The alt.fan hierarchy holds groups
    for the writers and broadcasters of his era, and his name is absent from
    it. Discussion of his work today is scattered across podcast communities, Reddit, Discord servers, and comment threads. Those venues are private or semi-private, searchable only in part, and closed or deleted at a
    platform's discretion.

    Usenet is the opposite arrangement: a public, distributed archive that no single company owns, carried on independent servers worldwide. It is also
    the medium of the era Dvorak helped define. He began his columns when
    Usenet was the public square of computing, and the audience that built
    that square is his audience. A newsgroup gives that audience a permanent address.

    The readership exists. His columns ran for more than forty years. No
    Agenda ran for nineteen years and about 1,915 episodes. The proposal asks
    for one unmoderated text group, the smallest durable unit Usenet has.

    For the record: John Charles Dvorak, born April 5, 1946, died July 20,
    2026, in Albany, California. PC Magazine columns from 1986; author or co-author of more than a dozen books; Silicon Spin on TechTV; co-creator
    of the Dvorak Awards (1992-1997); co-host with Adam Curry of No Agenda (2007-2026). The group is a reader and listener initiative. It is not
    endorsed by the Dvorak family, his estate, or the No Agenda show.

    The name is the full alt.fan.john-c-dvorak rather than alt.fan.dvorak for
    one reason: Dvorak is also a keyboard layout, designed by August Dvorak,
    and the short name invites the wrong traffic. The full name says whose
    group this is.

    PRIOR DISCUSSION

    None. This post is the initial proposal. The charter, rationale, and FAQ
    are published at the group's permanent home:

    https://afjcd.org/

    PROPONENT

    Chris Abraham <cja@well.com>

    Discussion is invited, on the name, the charter, and the need. If no significant objections arise during the discussion period, I intend to
    issue the newgroup control message for alt.fan.john-c-dvorak.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Adam H. Kerman@ahk@chinet.com to alt.config on Thu Nov 12 05:45:44 2026
    From Newsgroup: alt.config

    Chris Abraham <chris@gerriscorp.com> wrote:

    I propose the creation of a new unmoderated Usenet newsgroup:

    alt.fan.john-c-dvorak

    For your newsgroups file:

    There is no blank line after "For your newsgroups file:"

    alt.fan.john-c-dvorak John C. Dvorak: his columns, books, and broadcasts.

    group.name<tab>brief description, ends in period, less than 80
    characters assuming 8-position tab

    Do not repeat words already in the group name. The description is a
    terse phrase including key words. Your phrase is too generic.

    CHARTER

    That's a wordy charter. It doesn't matter. Is there ongoing discussion
    on Usenet or not? All you can do is send the newgroup message then
    promote the group, but without discussion, there is no one on Usenet to
    promote the group to.

    alt.fan.john-c-dvorak exists

    Clean that up. The group doesn't exist unless created by a News
    administrator.

    for discussion of the life and work of John
    C. Dvorak (1946-2026), the American technology columnist and broadcaster: >his columns, essays, and books; his television, radio, and podcast work;
    his career and his influence on technology journalism; and the technology
    he covered, discussed through his work.

    On topic:

    - His columns and essays, from the early 1980s on, in PC Magazine,
    InfoWorld, Forbes, MacUser, MarketWatch, and elsewhere, and on his own
    site, dvorak.org
    - His books, and the books he co-authored
    - His broadcasts and podcasts, including Silicon Spin, CrankyGeeks,
    Tech5, X3, and the No Agenda podcast he co-hosted with Adam Curry from
    2007 to 2026
    - His career, his predictions and his record, and his place in the
    history of personal computing
    - Memories: meeting him, hearing him speak, corresponding with him,
    reading him over the years
    - Archival finds: old columns, recordings, interviews, and
    photographs, with sources credited
    - The products, companies, and trends he covered, discussed through
    his writing and his commentary

    Off topic:

    - Spam and commercial advertising

    Do not mention spam. Spam countermeasures are implemented server-wide
    and do not rely upon a mention in a charter.

    - Binary postings of any kind; link to files instead
    - The Dvorak keyboard layout and August Dvorak; both belong in other
    groups - Personal abuse aimed at other posters

    The group is unmoderated. Post in plain text, quote only what you are >answering, and keep signatures short. Postings are distributed to news >servers around the world and archived permanently. Write accordingly.

    RATIONALE AND JUSTIFICATION OF READERSHIP

    Big 8 "rationale" is handwaiving nonsense that does not belong in a
    serious proposal. Justification (not "of readership" is the article
    count that YOU perform so you know to whom to promote use of the group.

    No Usenet group covers John C. Dvorak.

    That's a false statement that does not belong in a serious proposal
    There is ALWAYS a place to post. I see nothing relevant to a proper
    alt.* proposal justification in the rest of the paragraph.

    You look at a recent 90-day period for Dvorak in which he is a main
    topic or secondary topic of an article. You want to find an average of
    10 articles a day, else there isn't a chance of sustainable discussion.
    If not, then your job is to start making yourself known for discussing
    him in an appropriate newsgroup. If you get discussion going, only then
    send the newgroup message.

    The alt.fan hierarchy holds groups
    for the writers and broadcasters of his era, and his name is absent from
    it. Discussion of his work today is scattered across podcast communities, >Reddit, Discord servers, and comment threads. Those venues are private or >semi-private, searchable only in part, and closed or deleted at a
    platform's discretion.

    Discussion among people clueless about Usenet is irrelevant; they are
    not your audience.

    Usenet is the opposite arrangement: a public, distributed archive that no >single company owns, carried on independent servers worldwide. It is also >the medium of the era Dvorak helped define. He began his columns when
    Usenet was the public square of computing, and the audience that built
    that square is his audience. A newsgroup gives that audience a permanent >address.

    The readership exists. His columns ran for more than forty years. No
    Agenda ran for nineteen years and about 1,915 episodes. The proposal asks >for one unmoderated text group, the smallest durable unit Usenet has.

    The biography isn't justification and isn't really part of the charter.
    Maybe an FAQ?

    For the record: John Charles Dvorak, born April 5, 1946, died July 20,
    2026, in Albany, California. PC Magazine columns from 1986; author or >co-author of more than a dozen books; Silicon Spin on TechTV; co-creator
    of the Dvorak Awards (1992-1997); co-host with Adam Curry of No Agenda >(2007-2026). The group is a reader and listener initiative. It is not >endorsed by the Dvorak family, his estate, or the No Agenda show.

    The name is the full alt.fan.john-c-dvorak rather than alt.fan.dvorak for >one reason: Dvorak is also a keyboard layout, designed by August Dvorak,
    and the short name invites the wrong traffic. The full name says whose
    group this is.

    PRIOR DISCUSSION

    Please keep Big 8 boilerplate crap out of alt.* proposals.

    None. This post is the initial proposal. The charter, rationale, and FAQ
    are published at the group's permanent home:

    https://afjcd.org/

    PROPONENT

    Chris Abraham <cja@well.com>

    Discussion is invited, on the name, the charter, and the need. If no >significant objections arise during the discussion period, I intend to
    issue the newgroup control message for alt.fan.john-c-dvorak.

    The objection is the same as always. The proponent's main job is finding discussion, then promoting the group. Unless you perform a proper justification, you haven't started doing your job.

    The charter is incidental to justification. You want this not to be an
    empty group with your name on it, right?

    Discussion first, then newgroup message.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Chris Abraham@chris@gerriscorp.com to alt.config on Thu Nov 12 10:49:22 2026
    From Newsgroup: alt.config

    Thank you, Adam, I will make changes accordingly. I appreciate the time, energy, and expertise shared with me to make this right and perfect.

    On Thu, 12 Nov 2026, Adam H. Kerman wrote:

    Date: Thu, 12 Nov 2026 05:45:44 -0000 (UTC)
    From: Adam H. Kerman <ahk@chinet.com>
    Newsgroups: alt.config
    Subject: Re: Proposal: alt.fan.john-c-dvorak

    Chris Abraham <chris@gerriscorp.com> wrote:

    I propose the creation of a new unmoderated Usenet newsgroup:

    alt.fan.john-c-dvorak

    For your newsgroups file:

    There is no blank line after "For your newsgroups file:"

    alt.fan.john-c-dvorak John C. Dvorak: his columns, books, and broadcasts.

    group.name<tab>brief description, ends in period, less than 80
    characters assuming 8-position tab

    Do not repeat words already in the group name. The description is a
    terse phrase including key words. Your phrase is too generic.

    CHARTER

    That's a wordy charter. It doesn't matter. Is there ongoing discussion
    on Usenet or not? All you can do is send the newgroup message then
    promote the group, but without discussion, there is no one on Usenet to promote the group to.

    alt.fan.john-c-dvorak exists

    Clean that up. The group doesn't exist unless created by a News administrator.

    for discussion of the life and work of John
    C. Dvorak (1946-2026), the American technology columnist and broadcaster:
    his columns, essays, and books; his television, radio, and podcast work;
    his career and his influence on technology journalism; and the technology
    he covered, discussed through his work.

    On topic:

    - His columns and essays, from the early 1980s on, in PC Magazine,
    InfoWorld, Forbes, MacUser, MarketWatch, and elsewhere, and on his own
    site, dvorak.org
    - His books, and the books he co-authored
    - His broadcasts and podcasts, including Silicon Spin, CrankyGeeks,
    Tech5, X3, and the No Agenda podcast he co-hosted with Adam Curry from
    2007 to 2026
    - His career, his predictions and his record, and his place in the
    history of personal computing
    - Memories: meeting him, hearing him speak, corresponding with him,
    reading him over the years
    - Archival finds: old columns, recordings, interviews, and
    photographs, with sources credited
    - The products, companies, and trends he covered, discussed through
    his writing and his commentary

    Off topic:

    - Spam and commercial advertising

    Do not mention spam. Spam countermeasures are implemented server-wide
    and do not rely upon a mention in a charter.

    - Binary postings of any kind; link to files instead
    - The Dvorak keyboard layout and August Dvorak; both belong in other
    groups - Personal abuse aimed at other posters

    The group is unmoderated. Post in plain text, quote only what you are
    answering, and keep signatures short. Postings are distributed to news
    servers around the world and archived permanently. Write accordingly.

    RATIONALE AND JUSTIFICATION OF READERSHIP

    Big 8 "rationale" is handwaiving nonsense that does not belong in a
    serious proposal. Justification (not "of readership" is the article
    count that YOU perform so you know to whom to promote use of the group.

    No Usenet group covers John C. Dvorak.

    That's a false statement that does not belong in a serious proposal
    There is ALWAYS a place to post. I see nothing relevant to a proper
    alt.* proposal justification in the rest of the paragraph.

    You look at a recent 90-day period for Dvorak in which he is a main
    topic or secondary topic of an article. You want to find an average of
    10 articles a day, else there isn't a chance of sustainable discussion.
    If not, then your job is to start making yourself known for discussing
    him in an appropriate newsgroup. If you get discussion going, only then
    send the newgroup message.

    The alt.fan hierarchy holds groups
    for the writers and broadcasters of his era, and his name is absent from
    it. Discussion of his work today is scattered across podcast communities,
    Reddit, Discord servers, and comment threads. Those venues are private or
    semi-private, searchable only in part, and closed or deleted at a
    platform's discretion.

    Discussion among people clueless about Usenet is irrelevant; they are
    not your audience.

    Usenet is the opposite arrangement: a public, distributed archive that no
    single company owns, carried on independent servers worldwide. It is also
    the medium of the era Dvorak helped define. He began his columns when
    Usenet was the public square of computing, and the audience that built
    that square is his audience. A newsgroup gives that audience a permanent
    address.

    The readership exists. His columns ran for more than forty years. No
    Agenda ran for nineteen years and about 1,915 episodes. The proposal asks
    for one unmoderated text group, the smallest durable unit Usenet has.

    The biography isn't justification and isn't really part of the charter.
    Maybe an FAQ?

    For the record: John Charles Dvorak, born April 5, 1946, died July 20,
    2026, in Albany, California. PC Magazine columns from 1986; author or
    co-author of more than a dozen books; Silicon Spin on TechTV; co-creator
    of the Dvorak Awards (1992-1997); co-host with Adam Curry of No Agenda
    (2007-2026). The group is a reader and listener initiative. It is not
    endorsed by the Dvorak family, his estate, or the No Agenda show.

    The name is the full alt.fan.john-c-dvorak rather than alt.fan.dvorak for
    one reason: Dvorak is also a keyboard layout, designed by August Dvorak,
    and the short name invites the wrong traffic. The full name says whose
    group this is.

    PRIOR DISCUSSION

    Please keep Big 8 boilerplate crap out of alt.* proposals.

    None. This post is the initial proposal. The charter, rationale, and FAQ
    are published at the group's permanent home:

    https://afjcd.org/

    PROPONENT

    Chris Abraham <cja@well.com>

    Discussion is invited, on the name, the charter, and the need. If no
    significant objections arise during the discussion period, I intend to
    issue the newgroup control message for alt.fan.john-c-dvorak.

    The objection is the same as always. The proponent's main job is finding discussion, then promoting the group. Unless you perform a proper justification, you haven't started doing your job.

    The charter is incidental to justification. You want this not to be an
    empty group with your name on it, right?

    Discussion first, then newgroup message.

    --
    Chris Abraham
    +1 202-352-5051
    gerriscorp.com
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2