Commentators excused his behaviour for years to serve their causes. A painstaking investigation and a fair trial have won out
They lined up to f|-te him. George Monbiot, an environmental campaigner
who has never been less than certain of his own rightness (about everything), hailed him as a rCLhero of 2014rCY and rCLthe best thing that has
happened to the left in yearsrCY. Ed Miliband went to his home in 2015 to record a podcast. Andy Burnham defended him from claims of hypocrisy and urged him to rCLkeep goingrCY. Caroline Lucas commended him for rCLrattling peoplerCOs cagesrCY in parliament.
He also received eulogies, gushing editorials and guest editorships from
the leading left-wing magazines and newspapers, not to mention praise
from luvvies such as Bob Geldof and Paul Weller. Indeed, I could pretty
much fill the column with this torrent of admiration.
But let us instead step back and ponder this phenomenon. Russell Brand rCo whose true character was well and truly in the public domain by this
point, whose ex-girlfriend had published a lurid account of his
misogyny, who made a depraved series of calls to Andrew Sachs (Brand had slept with his granddaughter), who had urinated into a cup in front of colleagues, who had boasted on air to Jimmy Savile that his assistant
would massage anyone he demanded, who had simulated on stage how to
choke women rCo was enabled and eulogised by rCLprogressivesrCY (note the quotation marks) almost across the piece.
Why? How? Well, there is a cogent reason, I think. The perception of progressive virtue is not just a political identity but a shield. A form
of protection. A source of de facto impunity. Get on the right side of leftist ideology and onerCOs fellow travellers will find a way to excuse, cover up, ignore and airbrush almost anything. And the reason is simple. Progressivism is fundamentally good. Fundamentally virtuous. So why
would you weaken the cause by exposing the wrongdoing of one of our own? Nothing can or should obstruct the march towards utopia.
Of course, Brand also traded on his celebrity, his supposed rCLcharmrCY (although I never saw this for a single moment) and rCLhumourrCY. People laughed along because they wanted to be part of the funny gang (Hadley FreemanrCOs line about the way he rCLgroomedrCY audiences was spot on). But I
donrCOt believe he would have got away with such depravity for so long without his calculated shift into politics as the allegations started swirling. He knew it would provide a buffer no amount of fame could touch.
And this is not just about Brand but a phenomenon that sits behind many
of historyrCOs greatest evils. It is why reports of mass starvation in the Soviet Union in the 1930s were brushed aside by leftists like George
Bernard Shaw (he called the allegations rCLoffensive and ridiculousrCY); why StalinrCOs show trials were rationalised by leading Fabians. ItrCOs why the gulags were invisible to the progressive gaze and CastrorCOs crimes were airbrushed. Some criminals hide from view by donning a mask or using a
fast getaway car. The most heinous criminals hide in plain sight by
donning the invisibility cloak called virtue. Is there not, in this
sense, a through-line from the Bolsheviks, who killed and maimed under
cover of rCLfreeing the proletariatrCY, to Savile, who preyed on the defenceless under cover of charity?
Owen Jones, a Guardian columnist, made this point in his own words after
the Brand verdict with a post as revealing as it was stomach-churning.
This is a man who has built a career out of (putatively) defending the
weak against the strong but who defended Brand against the rCLall-too-
smug, seen-it-all-before snottinessrCY of detractors and did a public
event with this monster while praising him in columns. rCLI was willing to overlook, or just not look into, his history of problematic behaviour/ statements, including sexism,rCY Jones wrote, perceiving this as a defence rather than a dagger to the heart of his shtick. rCLI convinced myself he was on some sort of journey and that was a good thing.rCY
ItrCOs the journey, you see, folks. The path forward. The rCLrightrCY way. If
the destination is golden rCo and we alone have the road map rCo what could be more honourable than getting there? Whatever it takes. Whoever
suffers en route. Brand was a fellow traveller with Jones (not to
mention the progressive broadcasters who also turned a blind eye), so
the women were not victims but collateral damage. I donrCOt pretend they thought consciously in this way but can you deny the unconscious
dynamics, the underlying dissonance? rCLI was willing to overlook.rCY rCLI convinced myself.rCY The words are almost identical to those who defended the gulags, until it was too late. Karl Popper, as so often, put it
best: rCLThe attempt to make heaven on earth invariably produces hell.rCY
But there is a twist here, and why I believe this story illuminates so
much about our times. When Brand perceived he was about to be exposed,
he pivoted. He is a grotesque figure but also possesses a canny, Machiavellian intelligence. He could see a new group emerging, this time
on the right, who had become blinkered in their own way rCo not by utopian ideology but the deranging dynamics of social media. Did you notice who defended him once he became a rabid antivaxer and reactionary? ThatrCOs right: Tucker Carlson. Andrew Tate. Beverley Turner. People whose
commitment to truth is subordinate to their commitment to tribe. And I believe this duality explains a great deal about the state of the
western world. A civilisation whose rise (particularly in the Anglo-
Saxon sphere) was constructed on evidence, due process, a suspicion of utopianism and the patient examination of facts, but which is now caught
in a pincer movement between enemies of truth on both sides. The
blinkered ideological left and the truth-fearing, science-hating, conspiratorial right.
And this is why I felt such pride while watching this case unfold. For
it was driven in no small part by my superb colleague Rosamund Urwin,
who started to investigate Brand in 2019. She had to assemble testimony, analyse material and go through a painstaking process reviewing
allegations that would never have seen the light of day but for her
work, resulting in the police investigation of the complaints that
followed and then rCo after a trial where the evidence was tested by both sides in a fair process rCo a verdict of guilt of one rape and three
sexual assaults (he was acquitted of two rape charges and an attempted indecent assault).
This process may seem boring by todayrCOs standards. The work of careful digging and diligent empiricism may lack the online virality of
conspiracy theories and fail to flatter the darker recesses of the mind
in the way tribalism can. But I believe it represents the best of us. It
is where progress comes from rCo this willingness to go where the evidence leads rather than where our prejudices wish it to go. And perhaps the
most inspirational thing of all is that it was funded not by an
algorithm rewarding outrage but a group of subscribers (you and me) who believe the truth matters enough to pay for its discovery.
Jones said Brand was on a journey and in a way he was right. It ended on Thursday when a jury asked not whose side Brand was on, but what he had done. For too long, his crimes were concealed by the shield of virtue
and complicity of fellow travellers. Let us take some hope from the fact that it was old-fashioned evidence, articulated by brave victims in
court, that ultimately pulled his invisibility cloak away.
Matthew Syed
Commentators excused his behaviour for years to serve their causes. A painstaking investigation and a fair trial have won out
They lined up to f|-te him. George Monbiot, an environmental campaigner
who has never been less than certain of his own rightness (about everything), hailed him as a rCLhero of 2014rCY and rCLthe best thing that has
happened to the left in yearsrCY. Ed Miliband went to his home in 2015 to record a podcast. Andy Burnham defended him from claims of hypocrisy and urged him to rCLkeep goingrCY. Caroline Lucas commended him for rCLrattling peoplerCOs cagesrCY in parliament.
He also received eulogies, gushing editorials and guest editorships from
the leading left-wing magazines and newspapers, not to mention praise
from luvvies such as Bob Geldof and Paul Weller. Indeed, I could pretty
much fill the column with this torrent of admiration.
But let us instead step back and ponder this phenomenon. Russell Brand rCo whose true character was well and truly in the public domain by this
point, whose ex-girlfriend had published a lurid account of his
misogyny, who made a depraved series of calls to Andrew Sachs (Brand had slept with his granddaughter), who had urinated into a cup in front of colleagues, who had boasted on air to Jimmy Savile that his assistant
would massage anyone he demanded, who had simulated on stage how to
choke women rCo was enabled and eulogised by rCLprogressivesrCY (note the quotation marks) almost across the piece.
Why? How? Well, there is a cogent reason, I think. The perception of progressive virtue is not just a political identity but a shield. A form
of protection. A source of de facto impunity. Get on the right side of leftist ideology and onerCOs fellow travellers will find a way to excuse, cover up, ignore and airbrush almost anything. And the reason is simple. Progressivism is fundamentally good. Fundamentally virtuous. So why
would you weaken the cause by exposing the wrongdoing of one of our own? Nothing can or should obstruct the march towards utopia.
Of course, Brand also traded on his celebrity, his supposed rCLcharmrCY (although I never saw this for a single moment) and rCLhumourrCY. People laughed along because they wanted to be part of the funny gang (Hadley FreemanrCOs line about the way he rCLgroomedrCY audiences was spot on). But I
donrCOt believe he would have got away with such depravity for so long without his calculated shift into politics as the allegations started swirling. He knew it would provide a buffer no amount of fame could touch.
And this is not just about Brand but a phenomenon that sits behind many
of historyrCOs greatest evils. It is why reports of mass starvation in the Soviet Union in the 1930s were brushed aside by leftists like George
Bernard Shaw (he called the allegations rCLoffensive and ridiculousrCY); why StalinrCOs show trials were rationalised by leading Fabians. ItrCOs why the gulags were invisible to the progressive gaze and CastrorCOs crimes were airbrushed. Some criminals hide from view by donning a mask or using a
fast getaway car. The most heinous criminals hide in plain sight by
donning the invisibility cloak called virtue. Is there not, in this
sense, a through-line from the Bolsheviks, who killed and maimed under
cover of rCLfreeing the proletariatrCY, to Savile, who preyed on the defenceless under cover of charity?
Owen Jones, a Guardian columnist, made this point in his own words after
the Brand verdict with a post as revealing as it was stomach-churning.
This is a man who has built a career out of (putatively) defending the
weak against the strong but who defended Brand against the rCLall-too-
smug, seen-it-all-before snottinessrCY of detractors and did a public
event with this monster while praising him in columns. rCLI was willing to overlook, or just not look into, his history of problematic behaviour/ statements, including sexism,rCY Jones wrote, perceiving this as a defence rather than a dagger to the heart of his shtick. rCLI convinced myself he was on some sort of journey and that was a good thing.rCY
ItrCOs the journey, you see, folks. The path forward. The rCLrightrCY way. If
the destination is golden rCo and we alone have the road map rCo what could be more honourable than getting there? Whatever it takes. Whoever
suffers en route. Brand was a fellow traveller with Jones (not to
mention the progressive broadcasters who also turned a blind eye), so
the women were not victims but collateral damage. I donrCOt pretend they thought consciously in this way but can you deny the unconscious
dynamics, the underlying dissonance? rCLI was willing to overlook.rCY rCLI convinced myself.rCY The words are almost identical to those who defended the gulags, until it was too late. Karl Popper, as so often, put it
best: rCLThe attempt to make heaven on earth invariably produces hell.rCY
But there is a twist here, and why I believe this story illuminates so
much about our times. When Brand perceived he was about to be exposed,
he pivoted. He is a grotesque figure but also possesses a canny, Machiavellian intelligence. He could see a new group emerging, this time
on the right, who had become blinkered in their own way rCo not by utopian ideology but the deranging dynamics of social media. Did you notice who defended him once he became a rabid antivaxer and reactionary? ThatrCOs right: Tucker Carlson. Andrew Tate. Beverley Turner. People whose
commitment to truth is subordinate to their commitment to tribe. And I believe this duality explains a great deal about the state of the
western world. A civilisation whose rise (particularly in the Anglo-
Saxon sphere) was constructed on evidence, due process, a suspicion of utopianism and the patient examination of facts, but which is now caught
in a pincer movement between enemies of truth on both sides. The
blinkered ideological left and the truth-fearing, science-hating, conspiratorial right.
And this is why I felt such pride while watching this case unfold. For
it was driven in no small part by my superb colleague Rosamund Urwin,
who started to investigate Brand in 2019. She had to assemble testimony, analyse material and go through a painstaking process reviewing
allegations that would never have seen the light of day but for her
work, resulting in the police investigation of the complaints that
followed and then rCo after a trial where the evidence was tested by both sides in a fair process rCo a verdict of guilt of one rape and three
sexual assaults (he was acquitted of two rape charges and an attempted indecent assault).
This process may seem boring by todayrCOs standards. The work of careful digging and diligent empiricism may lack the online virality of
conspiracy theories and fail to flatter the darker recesses of the mind
in the way tribalism can. But I believe it represents the best of us. It
is where progress comes from rCo this willingness to go where the evidence leads rather than where our prejudices wish it to go. And perhaps the
most inspirational thing of all is that it was funded not by an
algorithm rewarding outrage but a group of subscribers (you and me) who believe the truth matters enough to pay for its discovery.
Jones said Brand was on a journey and in a way he was right. It ended on Thursday when a jury asked not whose side Brand was on, but what he had done. For too long, his crimes were concealed by the shield of virtue
and complicity of fellow travellers. Let us take some hope from the fact that it was old-fashioned evidence, articulated by brave victims in
court, that ultimately pulled his invisibility cloak away.
Matthew Syed
On 11/7/2026 4:19 PM, Julian wrote:
Commentators excused his behaviour for years to serve their causes. A
painstaking investigation and a fair trial have won out
They lined up to f|-te him. George Monbiot, an environmental campaigner
who has never been less than certain of his own rightness (about
everything), hailed him as a rCLhero of 2014rCY and rCLthe best thing that >> has happened to the left in yearsrCY. Ed Miliband went to his home in
2015 to record a podcast. Andy Burnham defended him from claims of
hypocrisy and urged him to rCLkeep goingrCY. Caroline Lucas commended him >> for rCLrattling peoplerCOs cagesrCY in parliament.
He also received eulogies, gushing editorials and guest editorships
from the leading left-wing magazines and newspapers, not to mention
praise from luvvies such as Bob Geldof and Paul Weller. Indeed, I
could pretty much fill the column with this torrent of admiration.
But let us instead step back and ponder this phenomenon. Russell Brand
rCo whose true character was well and truly in the public domain by this
point, whose ex-girlfriend had published a lurid account of his
misogyny, who made a depraved series of calls to Andrew Sachs (Brand
had slept with his granddaughter), who had urinated into a cup in
front of colleagues, who had boasted on air to Jimmy Savile that his
assistant would massage anyone he demanded, who had simulated on stage
how to choke women rCo was enabled and eulogised by rCLprogressivesrCY (note
the quotation marks) almost across the piece.
Why? How? Well, there is a cogent reason, I think. The perception of
progressive virtue is not just a political identity but a shield. A
form of protection. A source of de facto impunity. Get on the right
side of leftist ideology and onerCOs fellow travellers will find a way
to excuse, cover up, ignore and airbrush almost anything. And the
reason is simple. Progressivism is fundamentally good. Fundamentally
virtuous. So why would you weaken the cause by exposing the wrongdoing
of one of our own? Nothing can or should obstruct the march towards
utopia.
Of course, Brand also traded on his celebrity, his supposed rCLcharmrCY
(although I never saw this for a single moment) and rCLhumourrCY. People
laughed along because they wanted to be part of the funny gang (Hadley
FreemanrCOs line about the way he rCLgroomedrCY audiences was spot on). But >> I donrCOt believe he would have got away with such depravity for so long
without his calculated shift into politics as the allegations started
swirling. He knew it would provide a buffer no amount of fame could
touch.
And this is not just about Brand but a phenomenon that sits behind
many of historyrCOs greatest evils. It is why reports of mass starvation
in the Soviet Union in the 1930s were brushed aside by leftists like
George Bernard Shaw (he called the allegations rCLoffensive and
ridiculousrCY); why StalinrCOs show trials were rationalised by leading
Fabians. ItrCOs why the gulags were invisible to the progressive gaze
and CastrorCOs crimes were airbrushed. Some criminals hide from view by
donning a mask or using a fast getaway car. The most heinous criminals
hide in plain sight by donning the invisibility cloak called virtue.
Is there not, in this sense, a through-line from the Bolsheviks, who
killed and maimed under cover of rCLfreeing the proletariatrCY, to Savile, >> who preyed on the defenceless under cover of charity?
Owen Jones, a Guardian columnist, made this point in his own words
after the Brand verdict with a post as revealing as it was stomach-
churning. This is a man who has built a career out of (putatively)
defending the weak against the strong but who defended Brand against
the rCLall-too- smug, seen-it-all-before snottinessrCY of detractors and
did a public event with this monster while praising him in columns. rCLI
was willing to overlook, or just not look into, his history of
problematic behaviour/ statements, including sexism,rCY Jones wrote,
perceiving this as a defence rather than a dagger to the heart of his
shtick. rCLI convinced myself he was on some sort of journey and that
was a good thing.rCY
ItrCOs the journey, you see, folks. The path forward. The rCLrightrCY way. >> If the destination is golden rCo and we alone have the road map rCo what
could be more honourable than getting there? Whatever it takes.
Whoever suffers en route. Brand was a fellow traveller with Jones (not
to mention the progressive broadcasters who also turned a blind eye),
so the women were not victims but collateral damage. I donrCOt pretend
they thought consciously in this way but can you deny the unconscious
dynamics, the underlying dissonance? rCLI was willing to overlook.rCY rCLI >> convinced myself.rCY The words are almost identical to those who
defended the gulags, until it was too late. Karl Popper, as so often,
put it best: rCLThe attempt to make heaven on earth invariably produces
hell.rCY
But there is a twist here, and why I believe this story illuminates so
much about our times. When Brand perceived he was about to be exposed,
he pivoted. He is a grotesque figure but also possesses a canny,
Machiavellian intelligence. He could see a new group emerging, this
time on the right, who had become blinkered in their own way rCo not by
utopian ideology but the deranging dynamics of social media. Did you
notice who defended him once he became a rabid antivaxer and
reactionary? ThatrCOs right: Tucker Carlson. Andrew Tate. Beverley
Turner. People whose commitment to truth is subordinate to their
commitment to tribe. And I believe this duality explains a great deal
about the state of the western world. A civilisation whose rise
(particularly in the Anglo- Saxon sphere) was constructed on evidence,
due process, a suspicion of utopianism and the patient examination of
facts, but which is now caught in a pincer movement between enemies of
truth on both sides. The blinkered ideological left and the truth-
fearing, science-hating, conspiratorial right.
And this is why I felt such pride while watching this case unfold. For
it was driven in no small part by my superb colleague Rosamund Urwin,
who started to investigate Brand in 2019. She had to assemble
testimony, analyse material and go through a painstaking process
reviewing allegations that would never have seen the light of day but
for her work, resulting in the police investigation of the complaints
that followed and then rCo after a trial where the evidence was tested
by both sides in a fair process rCo a verdict of guilt of one rape and
three sexual assaults (he was acquitted of two rape charges and an
attempted indecent assault).
This process may seem boring by todayrCOs standards. The work of careful
digging and diligent empiricism may lack the online virality of
conspiracy theories and fail to flatter the darker recesses of the
mind in the way tribalism can. But I believe it represents the best of
us. It is where progress comes from rCo this willingness to go where the
evidence leads rather than where our prejudices wish it to go. And
perhaps the most inspirational thing of all is that it was funded not
by an algorithm rewarding outrage but a group of subscribers (you and
me) who believe the truth matters enough to pay for its discovery.
Jones said Brand was on a journey and in a way he was right. It ended
on Thursday when a jury asked not whose side Brand was on, but what he
had done. For too long, his crimes were concealed by the shield of
virtue and complicity of fellow travellers. Let us take some hope from
the fact that it was old-fashioned evidence, articulated by brave
victims in court, that ultimately pulled his invisibility cloak away.
Matthew Syed
"The prosecutionrCOs case relied on the complainantrCOs account plus testimony from roughly 25 people in her circle including friends,
family, colleagues, her manager, a sexual-health nurse, an ex-boyfriend,
and others. Those witnesses said she had told them immediately after the 2009 encounter and in subsequent years that Brand had anally penetrated
her without consent after consensual vaginal sex, that she had asked him
to stop, that it was painful and traumatic, and that she feared HIV.
They described her physical and emotional state in the days and weeks afterward (pain, anxiety, leaving London to stay with her parents,
attending a sexual-health clinic). The jury found the testimony to be credible enough to meet the criminal standard of proof beyond reasonable doubt."
Outside of the testimony presented at trial there's been no independent pre-2023 documentation of any kind (emails, texts, medical notes, etc.).
There's a competing narrative that says the charges against Brand
surfaced only after he moved away from his previous progressive left politics and publicly denounced some COVID policies. They say that
political shift motivated the public allegations.
There's no way for me to know for sure.
There is however this. Someone I generally trust (who is well outside of both political camps) has said he personally knows someone who has not
made any public statements but told him privately that she was also
raped by Brand.
So there's that.
On 08/11/2026 17:20, Wilson wrote:
On 11/7/2026 4:19 PM, Julian wrote:
Commentators excused his behaviour for years to serve their causes. A
painstaking investigation and a fair trial have won out
They lined up to f|-te him. George Monbiot, an environmental
campaigner who has never been less than certain of his own rightness
(about everything), hailed him as a rCLhero of 2014rCY and rCLthe best
thing that has happened to the left in yearsrCY. Ed Miliband went to
his home in 2015 to record a podcast. Andy Burnham defended him from
claims of hypocrisy and urged him to rCLkeep goingrCY. Caroline Lucas
commended him for rCLrattling peoplerCOs cagesrCY in parliament.
He also received eulogies, gushing editorials and guest editorships
from the leading left-wing magazines and newspapers, not to mention
praise from luvvies such as Bob Geldof and Paul Weller. Indeed, I
could pretty much fill the column with this torrent of admiration.
But let us instead step back and ponder this phenomenon. Russell
Brand rCo whose true character was well and truly in the public domain
by this point, whose ex-girlfriend had published a lurid account of
his misogyny, who made a depraved series of calls to Andrew Sachs
(Brand had slept with his granddaughter), who had urinated into a cup
in front of colleagues, who had boasted on air to Jimmy Savile that
his assistant would massage anyone he demanded, who had simulated on
stage how to choke women rCo was enabled and eulogised by
rCLprogressivesrCY (note the quotation marks) almost across the piece.
Why? How? Well, there is a cogent reason, I think. The perception of
progressive virtue is not just a political identity but a shield. A
form of protection. A source of de facto impunity. Get on the right
side of leftist ideology and onerCOs fellow travellers will find a way
to excuse, cover up, ignore and airbrush almost anything. And the
reason is simple. Progressivism is fundamentally good. Fundamentally
virtuous. So why would you weaken the cause by exposing the
wrongdoing of one of our own? Nothing can or should obstruct the
march towards utopia.
Of course, Brand also traded on his celebrity, his supposed rCLcharmrCY >>> (although I never saw this for a single moment) and rCLhumourrCY. People >>> laughed along because they wanted to be part of the funny gang
(Hadley FreemanrCOs line about the way he rCLgroomedrCY audiences was spot >>> on). But I donrCOt believe he would have got away with such depravity
for so long without his calculated shift into politics as the
allegations started swirling. He knew it would provide a buffer no
amount of fame could touch.
And this is not just about Brand but a phenomenon that sits behind
many of historyrCOs greatest evils. It is why reports of mass
starvation in the Soviet Union in the 1930s were brushed aside by
leftists like George Bernard Shaw (he called the allegations
rCLoffensive and ridiculousrCY); why StalinrCOs show trials were
rationalised by leading Fabians. ItrCOs why the gulags were invisible
to the progressive gaze and CastrorCOs crimes were airbrushed. Some
criminals hide from view by donning a mask or using a fast getaway
car. The most heinous criminals hide in plain sight by donning the
invisibility cloak called virtue. Is there not, in this sense, a
through-line from the Bolsheviks, who killed and maimed under cover
of rCLfreeing the proletariatrCY, to Savile, who preyed on the
defenceless under cover of charity?
Owen Jones, a Guardian columnist, made this point in his own words
after the Brand verdict with a post as revealing as it was stomach-
churning. This is a man who has built a career out of (putatively)
defending the weak against the strong but who defended Brand against
the rCLall-too- smug, seen-it-all-before snottinessrCY of detractors and >>> did a public event with this monster while praising him in columns.
rCLI was willing to overlook, or just not look into, his history of
problematic behaviour/ statements, including sexism,rCY Jones wrote,
perceiving this as a defence rather than a dagger to the heart of his
shtick. rCLI convinced myself he was on some sort of journey and that
was a good thing.rCY
ItrCOs the journey, you see, folks. The path forward. The rCLrightrCY way. >>> If the destination is golden rCo and we alone have the road map rCo what >>> could be more honourable than getting there? Whatever it takes.
Whoever suffers en route. Brand was a fellow traveller with Jones
(not to mention the progressive broadcasters who also turned a blind
eye), so the women were not victims but collateral damage. I donrCOt
pretend they thought consciously in this way but can you deny the
unconscious dynamics, the underlying dissonance? rCLI was willing to
overlook.rCY rCLI convinced myself.rCY The words are almost identical to >>> those who defended the gulags, until it was too late. Karl Popper, as
so often, put it best: rCLThe attempt to make heaven on earth
invariably produces hell.rCY
But there is a twist here, and why I believe this story illuminates
so much about our times. When Brand perceived he was about to be
exposed, he pivoted. He is a grotesque figure but also possesses a
canny, Machiavellian intelligence. He could see a new group emerging,
this time on the right, who had become blinkered in their own way rCo
not by utopian ideology but the deranging dynamics of social media.
Did you notice who defended him once he became a rabid antivaxer and
reactionary? ThatrCOs right: Tucker Carlson. Andrew Tate. Beverley
Turner. People whose commitment to truth is subordinate to their
commitment to tribe. And I believe this duality explains a great deal
about the state of the western world. A civilisation whose rise
(particularly in the Anglo- Saxon sphere) was constructed on
evidence, due process, a suspicion of utopianism and the patient
examination of facts, but which is now caught in a pincer movement
between enemies of truth on both sides. The blinkered ideological
left and the truth- fearing, science-hating, conspiratorial right.
And this is why I felt such pride while watching this case unfold.
For it was driven in no small part by my superb colleague Rosamund
Urwin, who started to investigate Brand in 2019. She had to assemble
testimony, analyse material and go through a painstaking process
reviewing allegations that would never have seen the light of day but
for her work, resulting in the police investigation of the complaints
that followed and then rCo after a trial where the evidence was tested
by both sides in a fair process rCo a verdict of guilt of one rape and
three sexual assaults (he was acquitted of two rape charges and an
attempted indecent assault).
This process may seem boring by todayrCOs standards. The work of
careful digging and diligent empiricism may lack the online virality
of conspiracy theories and fail to flatter the darker recesses of the
mind in the way tribalism can. But I believe it represents the best
of us. It is where progress comes from rCo this willingness to go where >>> the evidence leads rather than where our prejudices wish it to go.
And perhaps the most inspirational thing of all is that it was funded
not by an algorithm rewarding outrage but a group of subscribers (you
and me) who believe the truth matters enough to pay for its discovery.
Jones said Brand was on a journey and in a way he was right. It ended
on Thursday when a jury asked not whose side Brand was on, but what
he had done. For too long, his crimes were concealed by the shield of
virtue and complicity of fellow travellers. Let us take some hope
from the fact that it was old-fashioned evidence, articulated by
brave victims in court, that ultimately pulled his invisibility cloak
away.
Matthew Syed
"The prosecutionrCOs case relied on the complainantrCOs account plus
testimony from roughly 25 people in her circle including friends,
family, colleagues, her manager, a sexual-health nurse, an ex-
boyfriend, and others. Those witnesses said she had told them
immediately after the 2009 encounter and in subsequent years that
Brand had anally penetrated her without consent after consensual
vaginal sex, that she had asked him to stop, that it was painful and
traumatic, and that she feared HIV.
They described her physical and emotional state in the days and weeks
afterward (pain, anxiety, leaving London to stay with her parents,
attending a sexual-health clinic). The jury found the testimony to be
credible enough to meet the criminal standard of proof beyond
reasonable doubt."
Outside of the testimony presented at trial there's been no
independent pre-2023 documentation of any kind (emails, texts, medical
notes, etc.).
There's a competing narrative that says the charges against Brand
surfaced only after he moved away from his previous progressive left
politics and publicly denounced some COVID policies. They say that
political shift motivated the public allegations.
There's no way for me to know for sure.
There is however this. Someone I generally trust (who is well outside
of both political camps) has said he personally knows someone who has
not made any public statements but told him privately that she was
also raped by Brand.
So there's that.
I wouldn't be surprised if significant proportion of
sex crime victims, not just Brand's, choose not to make
it public knowledge for many reasons including fear,
shame or expecting not to be believed.
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 55:41:25 |
| Calls: | 1,265 |
| Calls today: | 1 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
3 files (2,684K bytes) |
| Messages: | 285,687 |