• Vedanta and Mahayana Buddhism

    From Dude@user2891@newsgrouper.org.invalid to alt.buddha.short.fat.guy on Fri Oct 30 17:21:01 2026
    From Newsgroup: alt.buddha.short.fat.guy

    Essay: Vedanta and Mahayana Buddhism
    Subject: A vedAntic dialogue with schools of mahAyAna buddhism.
    Author: Dude
    Date: 12/07/2002

    The adi sankarAcArya, author of brahmasUtra bhAshya, was born in kAladi, six miles to the east of Alwaye, Kerala, on Vasanta Ritu at noon, during auspicious abhijit muhurtA under the constellation ardhrAa in 788 C.E.

    By the age of eight, sankarAcArya had mastered all the scriptures, being a child prodigy. It is said that SankarAcArya found his guru, Govinda bhagavatpAda, the disciple of gauDapAda, the famous author of the
    gauDapAdIya kArikAs on mANDUkya, at an ASrama situated on the banks of the holy narmadA in central India, not far from where we joined the yoga camp, that is, Jabalpur.

    According to S. Vidyasankar, gauDapAda is the first historically known
    author in the advaita vedAnta tradition, whose work is still available to
    us, namely gauDapAdIya kArikAs, an expository text on the mANDUkya
    upanishad.

    The kArikA of gauDapAdIyacharya is the first systematic treatise
    on vedAnta.

    Vidyasankar: "...to the advaita school, all four prakaraNas are writings of
    a human author named gauDapAda, and are therefore not regarded as Sruti,
    even though the first prakaraNa is found interspersed with the sentences
    of the mANDUkya upanishad" and "...it is clear that the GK has been written
    in the context of a vedAntic dialogue with various schools of mahAyAna buddhism, more prominently the yogAcAra and madhyamaka
    schools."

    But, what most people don't know is that gauDapA is much influenced by mahAyAna, yogAcAra and madhyamaka.

    In fact, it can be said that gauDapA represents the best in nAgArjuna and vasAabAndhu. However, the accepted view that the kArikAs of gauDapA is a commentary on mANDUkya has been challenged by Pt. V. Bhattacharya who
    contends that the kArikAs of Book I are not in fact, an exposition of
    the mANDUkya.

    mANDUkya upanishad is based on the kArikA, and as such is later than gauDapadA.

    Other schools of buddhism such as vijnAnavAda and the madhyamaka school
    itself criticize yogAcAra for holding views that entail consciousness as an Absolute.

    gauDapAda apparently agrees with this evaluation of the vijnAnavAda school.

    For a lucid exposition of gauDapAda vis a vis adwaita read:

    http://www.advaita-vedanta.org/avhp/gaudapada.html

    1. Excerpt from mANDUkya kArikA IV by gauDapAda:

    "Duality is only an appearance; non-duality is the real. The object
    exists as an object for the knowing subject; but it does not exist outside
    of consciousness because the distinction of subject and object is within consciousness itself."

    (IV 25-27) Sharma, p. 245-246.

    2. Excerpt from mahAyAna sutra lAnkarA by asAnga maitreyAnAtha:

    "Pure consciousness is the only Reality. By its nature, it is Self-
    luminous." (XIII, 13). "Thus shaking off duality, he directly perceives the Absolute which is the unity underlying phenomena (dharmadAtu)." (VI, 7) Sharma, p. 112-113

    3. Excerpt from vijnApti matratA siddhi by vasAabAndhu:

    "Reality is Pure Consciousness; external objects do not exist outside
    thought. Reality can be directly realized by transcending the subject-object duality"

    Source:

    'A Critical Survey of Indian Philosophy'
    by Chandrahar Sharma, M.A., D. Phil., D. Litt., LL.B., Shastri
    Dept. of Phil., Benares Hindu U.
    Rider 1960.
    vimshAtika-Vrtti on kArikA 1, p. 114.

    Works Cited:

    'Mahayana Sutra Lankara'
    by Arya Asanga Maitreyanatha
    Tr. S. Levi, Paris 1907

    'Vijnapti Matrata Siddhi: Vimshatika'
    by Vasu Bhandu
    Tr. S. Levi, Paris 1925

    'Mandukya Karika'
    by Sri Gaudapadacharya
    Tr. Mm. Pt. V. Bhattacharya
    Calcutta U. 1943 Calcutta U. 1943
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2