• Re: Comments on dharmadAtu

    From Dude@user2891@newsgrouper.org.invalid to alt.buddha.short.fat.guy on Fri Oct 30 02:21:55 2026
    From Newsgroup: alt.buddha.short.fat.guy

    Dude <user2891@newsgrouper.org.invalid> posted:

    Introduction to the phenomenography of consciousness.
    Author: Dude
    Date: 12/17/2002

    Apparently, Gaudapada was, by tradition, the philosophical grandfather of Shankara. His Karika on the Mandukya Upanishad is the oldest known systematic
    exposition of Advaita Vedanta, perhaps the guru of Shankara.

    Gaudapada shows clear signs of familiarity with Buddhist philosophy, and both his language and his doctrine are close in many cases to Buddhist originals.

    This has led many scholars to speculate that Gaudapada himself was originally
    a Buddhist.

    "The Fourth has no sound-element, it is incommunicable, it is the extinction of phenomena, blissful, non-dual."

    Compare:

    Excerpt from mahAyAna sutra lAnkarA by asAnga maitreyAnAtha:

    "Pure consciousness is the only Reality. By its nature, it is Self- luminous." (XIII, 13).

    "Thus shaking off duality, he directly perceives the Absolute which is the unity underlying phenomena (dharmadAtu)." (VI, 7) Sharma, p. 112-113.


    Notes:

    Adi Shankara (also known as Adi Shankaracharya, c. 700rCo750 CE) was an 8th-century Indian Vedic scholar-monk, philosopher, and theologian who consolidated and systematized the non-dualistic school of Advaita Vedanta,
    in India - one of the Six Systems of Indian philosophy.

    Excerpts: gauDapAdIya on the phenomenography of consciousness:

    17. Just as in the dark a rope whose nature has not been fully ascertained
    is imagined to be various different things such as a snake, a line of water and so forth; in exactly the same way the Self is imagined in various different ways.

    18. When the rope is realised to be a rope, all illusions about it cease,
    and only the rope remains. Realisation of the Self is just the same.

    27. That the existent should come into being is only possible in an
    illusory manner. Anyone who claims it really happens is saying that what
    has already come to be comes to be.

    32. There is no cessation, no coming-to-be, none in bondage, no seeker after liberation and no-one liberated. This is the absolute truth.

    36. Birthless, unsleeping, dreamless, devoid of name or form, ever radiant
    and all-knowing - there is no action to be performed.

    81. It is birthless, unsleeping, free from dreams and self-luminous. This dharma is naturally self-luminous.

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Noah Sombrero@fedora@fea.st to alt.buddha.short.fat.guy on Thu Oct 29 23:03:40 2026
    From Newsgroup: alt.buddha.short.fat.guy

    On Fri, 30 Oct 2026 02:21:55 GMT, Dude
    <user2891@newsgrouper.org.invalid> wrote:

    Dude <user2891@newsgrouper.org.invalid> posted:

    Introduction to the phenomenography of consciousness.
    Author: Dude
    Date: 12/17/2002

    Apparently, Gaudapada was, by tradition, the philosophical grandfather of >> Shankara. His Karika on the Mandukya Upanishad is the oldest known systematic
    exposition of Advaita Vedanta, perhaps the guru of Shankara.

    Gaudapada shows clear signs of familiarity with Buddhist philosophy, and
    both his language and his doctrine are close in many cases to Buddhist
    originals.

    This has led many scholars to speculate that Gaudapada himself was originally
    a Buddhist.

    "The Fourth has no sound-element, it is incommunicable, it is the extinction
    of phenomena, blissful, non-dual."

    Compare:

    Excerpt from mahAyAna sutra lAnkarA by asAnga maitreyAnAtha:

    "Pure consciousness is the only Reality. By its nature, it is Self-
    luminous." (XIII, 13).

    "Thus shaking off duality, he directly perceives the Absolute which is the >> unity underlying phenomena (dharmadAtu)." (VI, 7) Sharma, p. 112-113.


    Notes:

    Adi Shankara (also known as Adi Shankaracharya, c. 700u750 CE) was an
    8th-century Indian Vedic scholar-monk, philosopher, and theologian who
    consolidated and systematized the non-dualistic school of Advaita Vedanta, >> in India - one of the Six Systems of Indian philosophy.

    Excerpts: gauDapAdIya on the phenomenography of consciousness:

    17. Just as in the dark a rope whose nature has not been fully ascertained >is imagined to be various different things such as a snake, a line of water >and so forth; in exactly the same way the Self is imagined in various >different ways.

    18. When the rope is realised to be a rope, all illusions about it cease, >and only the rope remains. Realisation of the Self is just the same.

    27. That the existent should come into being is only possible in an
    illusory manner. Anyone who claims it really happens is saying that what
    has already come to be comes to be.

    32. There is no cessation, no coming-to-be, none in bondage, no seeker after >liberation and no-one liberated. This is the absolute truth.

    36. Birthless, unsleeping, dreamless, devoid of name or form, ever radiant >and all-knowing - there is no action to be performed.

    81. It is birthless, unsleeping, free from dreams and self-luminous. This >dharma is naturally self-luminous.

    This, I assume, is mystical experience for him. His mistake is to
    think that it is the same for everybody else.
    --
    Noah Sombrero mustachioed villain
    Don't get political with me young man
    or I'll tie you to a railroad track and
    <<<talk>>> to <<<YOOooooo>>>
    Who dares to talk to El Sombrero?
    dares: Ned
    does not dare: Julian shrinks in horror and warns others away

    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Dude@punditster@gmail.com to alt.buddha.short.fat.guy on Fri Oct 30 13:35:56 2026
    From Newsgroup: alt.buddha.short.fat.guy

    On 10/29/2026 8:03 PM, Noah Sombrero wrote:
    On Fri, 30 Oct 2026 02:21:55 GMT, Dude
    <user2891@newsgrouper.org.invalid> wrote:

    Dude <user2891@newsgrouper.org.invalid> posted:

    Introduction to the phenomenography of consciousness.
    Author: Dude
    Date: 12/17/2002

    Apparently, Gaudapada was, by tradition, the philosophical grandfather of >>> Shankara. His Karika on the Mandukya Upanishad is the oldest known systematic
    exposition of Advaita Vedanta, perhaps the guru of Shankara.

    Gaudapada shows clear signs of familiarity with Buddhist philosophy, and >>> both his language and his doctrine are close in many cases to Buddhist
    originals.

    This has led many scholars to speculate that Gaudapada himself was originally
    a Buddhist.

    "The Fourth has no sound-element, it is incommunicable, it is the extinction
    of phenomena, blissful, non-dual."

    Compare:

    Excerpt from mahAyAna sutra lAnkarA by asAnga maitreyAnAtha:

    "Pure consciousness is the only Reality. By its nature, it is Self-
    luminous." (XIII, 13).

    "Thus shaking off duality, he directly perceives the Absolute which is the >>> unity underlying phenomena (dharmadAtu)." (VI, 7) Sharma, p. 112-113.


    Notes:

    Adi Shankara (also known as Adi Shankaracharya, c. 700rCo750 CE) was an
    8th-century Indian Vedic scholar-monk, philosopher, and theologian who
    consolidated and systematized the non-dualistic school of Advaita Vedanta, >>> in India - one of the Six Systems of Indian philosophy.

    Excerpts: gauDapAdIya on the phenomenography of consciousness:

    17. Just as in the dark a rope whose nature has not been fully ascertained >> is imagined to be various different things such as a snake, a line of water >> and so forth; in exactly the same way the Self is imagined in various
    different ways.

    18. When the rope is realised to be a rope, all illusions about it cease,
    and only the rope remains. Realisation of the Self is just the same.

    27. That the existent should come into being is only possible in an
    illusory manner. Anyone who claims it really happens is saying that what
    has already come to be comes to be.

    32. There is no cessation, no coming-to-be, none in bondage, no seeker after >> liberation and no-one liberated. This is the absolute truth.

    36. Birthless, unsleeping, dreamless, devoid of name or form, ever radiant >> and all-knowing - there is no action to be performed.

    81. It is birthless, unsleeping, free from dreams and self-luminous. This
    dharma is naturally self-luminous.

    This, I assume, is mystical experience for him. His mistake is to
    think that it is the same for everybody else.

    So, you're skeptical about what the founder of Indian Vedanta said, or skeptical of the whole Mahayana Buddhist doctrine?

    How could the Absolute Real be different for everybody? Wouldn't that
    lead to a dual realization?

    Almost all of Mahayana Buddhist and Indian Vedanta are non-dual thinkers.
    --- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2