On 10/26/2026 10:39 PM, Dude wrote:
"From Brahman to the last blade of grass, existence is for the benefit
of spirit until spirit has attained supreme knowledge." (Samkhya Sutra
3.47.)
What does /supreme knowledge/ even mean?-a Does the Samkhya Sutra define
the term?-a Yes, again, I'm commenting without reading the source ma-
terial.
This sutra brings out the teleological nature of existence:
/Existence/ is about the study of ends and purposes?-a I thought ex-
istence was merely biological, and procreation was the end means.
If existence did not have the mission of serving spirit, it would be
without meaning.
Which spirit?-a Is this spirit defined in the sutra?
Everything in nature is "composite flux"; therefore everything must
have a "superintendent," someone who can make use of these compounds.
Why?-a Or rather, why is there a /must/ there?-a This seems like a base-
less assumption to me.
This superintendent cannot be either mental activity itself or states
of consciousness, which themselves are extremely complex products of
matter.
Why not?
As the Yoga Sutra states:
"Variegated by countless traces of memory, thought works by making
associations, for the sake of a purpose beyond itself." (Yoga Sutra
4.24).
So, thought has a purpose beyond itself?-a Do you think that's a reason-
able assumption?
The three constituents of nature (three gunas) born of nature
impregnate existence and establish an organic sympathy between man and
the universe.
Although the Being is veiled, matter is dynamized by the "teleological
instinct" that is wholly intent on the deliverance of Being and that
is the purpose of existence, according to the Indian Sankhya and Yoga
Systems.
So, that's just an opinion held by people of Indian Sankhya?
Notes: Apparently there are very few yogis in India at present
following the Samkya system, ,having gone over to Vedanta philosophy
and practice.
Is this a populist argument?-a Are you trying to claim the Sankya system
is wrong, because it's not popular?
You have this tendency to state random "facts" and quotes, but without commentary as to the purpose of the quote.-a So I'm left guessing.
Best wishes, and happy Buddhist teachings!
On 10/29/2026 2:42 AM, Johann 'Myrkraverk' Oskarsson wrote:
On 10/26/2026 10:39 PM, Dude wrote:
"From Brahman to the last blade of grass, existence is for the benefit
of spirit until spirit has attained supreme knowledge." (Samkhya Sutra
3.47.)
What does /supreme knowledge/ even mean?-a Does the Samkhya Sutra define
the term?-a Yes, again, I'm commenting without reading the source ma-
terial.
"The Absolute is beyond time and space, without attribute and form, and
is forever removed from empirical scrutiny" (Samkhya Sutra 3.48).
In the Samkhya-Yoga system, the phenomenal universe is considered a
This sutra brings out the teleological nature of existence:
/Existence/ is about the study of ends and purposes?-a I thought ex-
istence was merely biological, and procreation was the end means.
dynamic order - an eternal process unfolding, without beginning or end.
Kapila was an ancient Indian sage in Hindu tradition.
If existence did not have the mission of serving spirit, it would be
without meaning.
Which spirit?-a Is this spirit defined in the sutra?
Apparently Kapila was the son of the yogi sage Kardama and Devahuti, who
was the daughter of the Svayambhuva Manu; brother of Mahasati Ansuya.
According to tradition, Kardama had nine daughters, who were very
learned and went on to marry Marici.
When Kapila came of age, he founded the Samkhya school of Hindu
philosophy. Kapila's influence on Buddha and Buddhism have long been the subject of scholarly studies.
According to Kapila, creation is impossible, for something cannot come
out of nothing; change implies something to change; whatever is, always
is, and whatever is not, never is.
As Kapila states in the sutra:
"And from the contrast with that which is composed of the three constituents, there follows, for the Purusha, the character of Being, a witness; freedom from misery, neutrality, percipience, and non-agency" - Kapila, Sankhya Sutras, XVII.
In order to avoid the fallacy of regressus ad infinitum.
Everything in nature is "composite flux"; therefore everything must
have a "superintendent," someone who can make use of these compounds.
Why?-a Or rather, why is there a /must/ there?-a This seems like a base-
less assumption to me.
That would not be consistent with rational solutions.
Samkhya postulates an "Uncaused Cause", which remains undefined, as it
is beyond, or transcendental to, human intellect.
This superintendent cannot be either mental activity itself or states
of consciousness, which themselves are extremely complex products of
matter.
Why not?
Mind and mental states are not Absolute.
Sanjaya is thought to be the first teacher of the historical Buddha.
As the Yoga Sutra states:
"Variegated by countless traces of memory, thought works by making
associations, for the sake of a purpose beyond itself." (Yoga Sutra
4.24).
So, thought has a purpose beyond itself?-a Do you think that's a reason-
able assumption?
"If you ask me if there exists another world [after death], if I thought that there exists another world, would I declare that to you? I don't
think so. I don't think in that way. I don't think otherwise. I don't
think not. I don't think not not."
Indian philosophy and science is very ancient. One thing I've learned -The three constituents of nature (three gunas) born of nature
impregnate existence and establish an organic sympathy between man and
the universe.
Although the Being is veiled, matter is dynamized by the "teleological
instinct" that is wholly intent on the deliverance of Being and that
is the purpose of existence, according to the Indian Sankhya and Yoga
Systems.
So, that's just an opinion held by people of Indian Sankhya?
the ancient Indians were very intelligent - apparently they invented the nought (zero), the decimal place and Arabic numerals.
Sanjaya's rigorous dialectical methods deeply impacted Indian logic. His practice of "denying and denying denials" laid early structural
Notes: Apparently there are very few yogis in India at present
following the Samkya system, ,having gone over to Vedanta philosophy
and practice.
Is this a populist argument?-a Are you trying to claim the Sankya system
is wrong, because it's not popular?
foundations for later, highly sophisticated Buddhist schools of
logicrCosuch as the Madhyamaka philosophy pioneered by Nagarjuna centuries later.
"If you ask me if there exists another world [after death], if I thought that there exists another world, would I declare that to you? I don't
You have this tendency to state random "facts" and quotes, but without
commentary as to the purpose of the quote.-a So I'm left guessing.
think so. I don't think in that way. I don't think otherwise. I don't
think not. I don't think not not." - Sanjaya
Best wishes, and happy Buddhist teachings!
Dude <punditster@gmail.com> wrote:
On 10/29/2026 2:42 AM, Johann 'Myrkraverk' Oskarsson wrote:
On 10/26/2026 10:39 PM, Dude wrote:
"From Brahman to the last blade of grass, existence is for the benefit >>> of spirit until spirit has attained supreme knowledge." (Samkhya Sutra >>> 3.47.)
What does /supreme knowledge/ even mean?-a Does the Samkhya Sutra define >> the term?-a Yes, again, I'm commenting without reading the source ma-
terial.
"The Absolute is beyond time and space, without attribute and form, and
is forever removed from empirical scrutiny" (Samkhya Sutra 3.48).
In the Samkhya-Yoga system, the phenomenal universe is considered a dynamic order - an eternal process unfolding, without beginning or end.
This sutra brings out the teleological nature of existence:
/Existence/ is about the study of ends and purposes?-a I thought ex-
istence was merely biological, and procreation was the end means.
Kapila was an ancient Indian sage in Hindu tradition.
If existence did not have the mission of serving spirit, it would be
without meaning.
Which spirit?-a Is this spirit defined in the sutra?
Apparently Kapila was the son of the yogi sage Kardama and Devahuti, who was the daughter of the Svayambhuva Manu; brother of Mahasati Ansuya.
According to tradition, Kardama had nine daughters, who were very
learned and went on to marry Marici.
When Kapila came of age, he founded the Samkhya school of Hindu philosophy. Kapila's influence on Buddha and Buddhism have long been the subject of scholarly studies.
According to Kapila, creation is impossible, for something cannot come
out of nothing; change implies something to change; whatever is, always is, and whatever is not, never is.
As Kapila states in the sutra:
"And from the contrast with that which is composed of the three constituents, there follows, for the Purusha, the character of Being, a witness; freedom from misery, neutrality, percipience, and non-agency" - Kapila, Sankhya Sutras, XVII.
In order to avoid the fallacy of regressus ad infinitum.
Everything in nature is "composite flux"; therefore everything must
have a "superintendent," someone who can make use of these compounds.
Why?-a Or rather, why is there a /must/ there?-a This seems like a base- >> less assumption to me.
That would not be consistent with rational solutions.
Samkhya postulates an "Uncaused Cause", which remains undefined, as it
is beyond, or transcendental to, human intellect.
This superintendent cannot be either mental activity itself or states >>> of consciousness, which themselves are extremely complex products of
matter.
Why not?
Mind and mental states are not Absolute.
Sanjaya is thought to be the first teacher of the historical Buddha.
As the Yoga Sutra states:
"Variegated by countless traces of memory, thought works by making
associations, for the sake of a purpose beyond itself." (Yoga Sutra
4.24).
So, thought has a purpose beyond itself?-a Do you think that's a reason- >> able assumption?
"If you ask me if there exists another world [after death], if I thought that there exists another world, would I declare that to you? I don't think so. I don't think in that way. I don't think otherwise. I don't think not. I don't think not not."
Indian philosophy and science is very ancient. One thing I've learned - the ancient Indians were very intelligent - apparently they invented the nought (zero), the decimal place and Arabic numerals.The three constituents of nature (three gunas) born of nature
impregnate existence and establish an organic sympathy between man and >>> the universe.
Although the Being is veiled, matter is dynamized by the "teleological >>> instinct" that is wholly intent on the deliverance of Being and that
is the purpose of existence, according to the Indian Sankhya and Yoga >>> Systems.
So, that's just an opinion held by people of Indian Sankhya?
Sanjaya's rigorous dialectical methods deeply impacted Indian logic. His practice of "denying and denying denials" laid early structural foundations for later, highly sophisticated Buddhist schools of logicrCosuch as the Madhyamaka philosophy pioneered by Nagarjuna centuries later.
Notes: Apparently there are very few yogis in India at present
following the Samkya system, ,having gone over to Vedanta philosophy
and practice.
Is this a populist argument?-a Are you trying to claim the Sankya system >> is wrong, because it's not popular?
"If you ask me if there exists another world [after death], if I thought that there exists another world, would I declare that to you? I don't think so. I don't think in that way. I don't think otherwise. I don't think not. I don't think not not." - Sanjaya
You have this tendency to state random "facts" and quotes, but without
commentary as to the purpose of the quote.-a So I'm left guessing.
Oh ffs. Take a little guess or just say you donrCOt know!
Best wishes, and happy Buddhist teachings!
| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 76 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 55:57:10 |
| Calls: | 1,265 |
| Calls today: | 1 |
| Files: | 1,362 |
| D/L today: |
3 files (2,684K bytes) |
| Messages: | 285,712 |