From Newsgroup: alt.bible
Zion in Travail is built around the teachings of the late Harold
Camping, who falsely predicted the Lord's return in 1994 and 2011. It
holds that the Church Age has ended and that God now saves "ONLY OUTSIDE
THE CHURCHES AND CONGREGATIONS." The Alameda fellowship equates
"spiritual Babylon" with the local congregations, claims Daniel's
"sealed" words are now being unsealed, and that God is revealing new
truths today. The verses you posted are the proof texts for that system.
Here is why each of them fails.
1. The Bible is complete, so nothing new is being "unsealed"
You open with 2 Timothy 3:16rCo17, and it works against you. Scripture
makes the man of God "complete, equipped for every good work." If
Scripture already fully equips the believer, no hidden doctrine can show
up two thousand years later to overturn what the apostles plainly taught
about the church. Jude 3 says the faith was "once for all delivered to
the saints." It isn't being added to in the twenty-first century.
Daniel 12:9 doesn't help you either. The sealing concerned how well
Daniel's own prophecies would be understood. It never promised a new
gospel that would cancel the church. Revelation 22:10 settles it: John
is told, "Do not seal up the words of the prophecy of this book, for the
time is near." The prophetic word was already unsealed in the first
century. When you claim a private unsealing in our day, you're claiming something God has not given.
You quote Ecclesiastes 8:5, that a wise heart discerns time and
judgment. That doesn't license date-setting. Our Lord said, "concerning
that day and hour no one knows" (Matthew 24:36), and "It is not for you
to know times or seasons" (Acts 1:7).
2. Your own proof texts on counsel condemn you
You cite Proverbs 11:14 and 12:15 on the wisdom of counsel, yet the
system you follow rests on one man's counsel. That man predicted May 21,
2011 for Christ's return and the resurrection of believers. After May
2011 he taught that salvation was no longer possible for those not
already saved, and he abandoned that "no-more-salvation" view only after October 21, 2011 passed. Before that he had also pointed to 1994.
God gave us the test in Deuteronomy 18:22: "when a prophet speaks in the
name of the LORD, if the word does not come to pass or come true, that
is a word that the LORD has not spoken." You may say you reject the May
21 date, as the Alameda site explicitly rejects it. But you keep the
method of interpretation that produced the date. Rejecting the fruit
while keeping the root solves nothing.
So the verses you aim at the churches come back on you. Isaiah 28:7,
"they err in vision, they stumble in judgment," and 2 Corinthians 11:15,
about Satan's ministers disguised as servants of righteousness, fit a
system with three failed dates far better than they fit the churches of
Jesus Christ.
3. Christ promised that the church would last until He comes
The Lord Himself settled whether the church age could end in apostasy
before His return:
rCo Matthew 16:18: "I will build my church, and the gates of hell
shall not prevail against it." When you say Satan now rules all
the churches, you're saying the gates of hell prevailed.
rCo Matthew 28:19rCo20: The Great Commission includes baptizing and
teaching, which are church work. It comes with the promise "I
am with you always, to the end of the age." The commission
lasts as long as the age does.
rCo 1 Corinthians 11:26: The Lord's Supper, kept when the church
gathers, is to continue "until he comes."
rCo Ephesians 3:21: "to him be glory in the church and in Christ
Jesus throughout all generations, forever and ever."
rCo Hebrews 10:25: We are not to neglect meeting together, and are
to do so "all the more as you see the Day drawing near." That
is the exact opposite of what you teach. The nearer the end
comes, the more God's people are to assemble, not scatter. You
get around this verse by claiming, as the Alameda site does,
that believers are gathered "one by one" rather than in
assemblies. Hebrews 10:25 is talking about meeting together,
and twisting it to mean being alone is not interpretation.
rCo Ephesians 5:25rCo27: Christ "loved the church and gave himself up
for her" so that He might present her to Himself "without spot
or wrinkle." He purchased her "with his own blood" (Acts
20:28). He doesn't divorce a bride He bought with His blood. He
presents her in glory.
The New Testament also gives commands that you can't obey while cut off
from every congregation: pastors and deacons (1 Timothy 3; Titus 1),
church discipline (Matthew 18:17), the ordinances, and submitting to
those who watch over your soul (Hebrews 13:17). A doctrine that makes
these commands impossible to obey can't be from the God who gave them.
The church age doesn't end with the church being emptied out. It ends
with the church being caught up: "the dead in Christ will rise first.
Then we who are alive... will be caught up together with them... to meet
the Lord in the air" (1 Thessalonians 4:16rCo17).
4. Babylon persecutes the saints. She is not the saints.
Your bracket on Revelation 18:2, "Babylon [persecuted church]," turns
the text upside down. Babylon is "drunk with the blood of the saints,
the blood of the martyrs of Jesus" (Revelation 17:6). She is the
persecutor, not the persecuted. She is "the great city that has dominion
over the kings of the earth" (17:18). Chapter 18 describes her
merchants, cargoes, ships, and luxuries, which is a world system of
false religion and commerce.
Revelation sets two women against each other on purpose. The harlot is
Babylon (chapters 17rCo18), and the Bride is the Lamb's wife, clothed in
"fine linen, bright and pure," which is "the righteous deeds of the
saints" (19:7rCo8; 21:9). When you call the Bride the harlot, that is not
a small mistake in interpretation. You are calling holy what God calls
unclean and unclean what God calls holy (Isaiah 5:20).
"Come out of her, my people" (18:4) is God calling His own out of the
end-time Babylonian system during the Tribulation. It is not a call to
leave Bible-preaching assemblies today.
5. "Judgment must begin at the house of God" is about refining, not condemnation
Read the context of the verse you cite, 1 Peter 4:17. Verses 12rCo16 speak
of the "fiery trial" and of suffering "as a Christian." The judgment
that begins with God's house is the purifying discipline of His children through suffering. It's the same truth as "the Lord disciplines the one
he loves" (Hebrews 12:6) and "we are disciplined so that we may not be condemned along with the world" (1 Corinthians 11:32).
Peter includes himself: "if it begins with us." He contrasts believers
with "those who do not obey the gospel of God." That puts the house of
God on the saved side of the line, which is the reverse of your reading.
And 1 Peter was written to churches, with elders shepherding the flock (5:1rCo4). Peter never told anyone to leave.
6. Isaiah 4:1 is about a war-widowed Judah, not the Bride
The chapter break hides the context from you. Isaiah 3:25rCo26 says, "Your
men shall fall by the sword and your mighty men in battle." With the men killed, seven women take hold of one surviving man so that they won't
bear the shame of being unmarried and childless. It's a literal picture
of Judah's desolation under judgment.
Your bracketed allegory is invented from start to finish. "Seven"
becomes "100%," the women become the whole church, and "our own bread"
becomes Christ, the Bread of Life. If you were right, the women would be eating Christ, which is good, while also being condemned for it, which
makes no sense. When you have to change every noun into something else,
you're writing a new text, not explaining the one God wrote.
The very next verse gives the real hope: "In that day the branch of the
LORD shall be beautiful and glorious" (4:2). That is the Messiah's
kingdom, when a cleansed remnant of Israel is called holy (4:3rCo4).
7. The man of sin, the temple, and Judea are literal
The passage you quote, 2 Thessalonians 2:3rCo4, describes a person: "the
man of lawlessness... the son of destruction," who will be "revealed"
and whom "the Lord Jesus will kill with the breath of his mouth and
bring to nothing by the appearance of his coming" (2:8). He sits in "the temple of God." Paul is telling the Thessalonians that the Day of the
Lord had not yet come (2:2). He is not telling them the church had
become Satan's throne.
Our Lord's words in Matthew 24:15rCo20, which you also cite, are just as plain. The abomination stands "in the holy place," and "those who are in Judea" are to flee to the mountains. He says to pray their flight won't
be in winter or on a Sabbath. Winter, mountains, and Sabbath
restrictions belong to real geography and to Israel in the Tribulation.
They don't describe a believer leaving a congregation. Daniel 9:27,
which Jesus cites, is about the covenant with Daniel's own people and
the holy city.
Paul adds that something restrains lawlessness until it is "out of the
way" (2 Thessalonians 2:7). The Spirit-indwelt church is still here and
still restraining, and that alone shows the man of sin has not taken
over her pulpits. The strong delusion of 2:11rCo12, which you quote
against the churches, falls on those who "refused to love the truth and
so be saved." It falls on the world that receives the lawless one, not
on the redeemed.
Your use of 1 Thessalonians 2:14 backfires as well. Paul praises "the
churches of God in Christ Jesus that are in Judea" as examples to
follow. In Paul's mind, a church in Judea is a church "in Christ Jesus."
It is not an apostate institution to flee.
8. Jeremiah was written to Israel, not to the body of Christ
The Jeremiah verses you cite were spoken to Judah. Jeremiah 7:4 rebukes
Judah for trusting a stone building while living in idolatry. Your
bracket turns "temple" into "church/congregation," but the text gives
you no right to do that. Jeremiah 12:7, "I have forsaken my house," was fulfilled when Judah went into Babylonian captivity. Neither verse is
about the church, the body of Christ, which was "a mystery hidden for
ages" before it was revealed to the apostles (Ephesians 3:5rCo6).
God's promise to the believer under the New Covenant is "I will never
leave you nor forsake you" (Hebrews 13:5). Every true member of His body
is "sealed with the promised Holy Spirit" (Ephesians 1:13) "for the day
of redemption" (4:30). When you move Israel's judgments onto the church,
you ignore the distinction God Himself drew.
9. Matthew 24:14 is the church's mission
You close with "This gospel of the kingdom will be proclaimed throughout
the whole world." Christ gave that worldwide mission to His assembled
people (Acts 1:8), and it carries on through the Tribulation by the
witnesses God raises up then (Revelation 7; 11; 14:6). It's a strange
end-time zeal that cuts believers off from the very means God ordained
to send out the gospel.
Where the faithful believer stands
You're right that individual churches can fall away. Christ warned that
He would remove a church's lampstand (Revelation 2:5). But even in dead
Sardis He commended "a few names... who have not soiled their garments"
(3:4). He never told them to give up on assembling. The answer to an unfaithful church is to find a faithful one that preaches the Word,
honors Christ, and keeps His ordinances. The answer is not to declare
every church Babylon.
Our hope is not to scatter during the Great Tribulation. Our hope is
"the blessed hope, the appearing of the glory of our great God and
Savior Jesus Christ" (Titus 2:13). He will come for His Bride before the
wrath falls, because "God has not destined us for wrath, but to obtain salvation through our Lord Jesus Christ" (1 Thessalonians 5:9). Until
then, the instruction stands for you as much as for me: gather all the
more, as you see the Day drawing near.
Sources:
[faith.searchinghisword.com](
https://faith.searchinghisword.com/) [zionintravail.com](
https://zionintravail.com/)
--
Good News rCa
Christ paid our entire sin debt to God on the cross (Colossians 2:14),
and God gave absolute proof of this by raising Him from the dead (Romans
1:4). God now pardons our sins without compromising His own
righteousness (Romans 3:26), saving us from His coming judgment (1 Thessalonians 1:10). This is a completely free gift reserved for those
who trust in Christ (Romans 6:23). Believe in your heart and call out to
the Lord to be saved (Romans 10:9-13):
How to be saved: christrose.news/salvation
--- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2