crash landing
From
R Kym Horsell@kym@sdf.org to
alt.astronomy,alt.paranet.ufo,alt.ufo.reports on Fri Oct 30 04:27:31 2026
From Newsgroup: alt.astronomy
|Ancient Comets Carried Organic Compounds, But They Didn't Survive Crashing |Into Earth
|Universe Today, 29 Oct 2026 12:06
|
|The ESA's Rosetta mission, which included the Philae Lander, visited the |comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko in 2014 and detected glycine, an amino acid, |and phosphorous, an organic chemical. Phosphorous is an important element in |all living things, and is a critical part of DNA and RNA. These findings |helped generate the idea that comets played a role in seeding the early
|Earth with the chemistry necessary for life.
It's all very interesting that organic compounds could not survive a
comet collision with Earth. But who said anything about a crash landing?
There seems to be quite a bit of evidence that the bulk of material
potentially transferred from comets to e.g. the Earth is a continuous
process akin to diffusion. It seems comets leave a wake of dirt in
their orbits that build up over (long) time and diffuse from there
outward to anything with a gravity well big enough to slurp it up.
And the amount of material moving in this way per year specifically
from comets may be YUGE according to some simple models.
Diffusion is a seemingly simple concept that can have some complex consequences. We all understand that smoke e.g. "diffuses" through
air, or salt crystals dissolve in water and the relevant ions
"diffuse" through the water. The basic case is motion of the
particles under consideration is "random" sometimes called a "random
walk". In 3D the basic law is the avg distance from the "origin"
(where all the particles under consideration started from) after a
time "t" is proportional to "t". I.e. basic diffusion is a constant
velocity thing. (Interestingly, in 1D and 2D particles on average do
not move away from the origin -- perhaps explaining why our Universe
has a 3D aspect).
But the velocity need not be constant. In more general forms the
velocity or position of particles can conform with a power law, a
common simple math model in many sciences. There are types of
diffusion e.g. "superdiffusion" where the power is >1 meaning the
particles move "abnormally fast". But abnormal is a relative thing. If
there are forces operating apart from random motion we can assume
"fast diffusion" happens when the forces are pushing everything in a
certain direction rather than letting them move isotropically. And,
of course, there is no mathematical reason not to consider diffusion
that runs slower than linear speeds. E.g. a jet pilot on area patrol
generally spirals out from their take-off point. Their distance from
the origin is then growing much slower than "t". It's more like
t^.5 == sqrt(t).
But let's turn our attention back to organic molecules possibly coming
off comets and making their way to earth without the need for a Big
Collision. Can we see that in any data?
Well -- as usual -- I posted this so you can be assured I found something.
We can take the distance of e.g. some comet from the Earth and see
whether, over time, the appearance of meteors seems to follow the ups
and downs of that distance. I.e. we assume if a comet is far away from
Earth very few particles will make the trip per unit time from the
comet to Earth. If the comet passes by the Earth then it becomes more
likely that some stray particle from the comet falls into Earth's
gravity well and make a small flash in the night sky.
I have a collection in the database of around 400 comets. There is also
a time series from the American Meteor Society showing how many fireballs
were seen day by day over the past 30 y. NASA also has a fireball
database (about 1000 entries last upload) running over a longer time
but with far fewer eyes on the sky than the AMS (~8300 events last upload).
We can compare the distance of each of the comets against both the
AMS and NASA fireball counts and see whether any comet statistically links
to either one or maybe both. If we're very quiet the process might also
tell us how many fireballs are associated with a given comet.
Maybe 1. Maybe 2. Maybe 3? Or maybe a continuous process i.e.
"a whole lot more".
My program chugged away for 30m and did all the relevant stats. It
picked out all the associations that were statistically significant to
at least 90% confidence (i.e. <10% likely the link was just luck) in 2 different ways. It then estimated what kind of fraction of the AMS or
NASA fireballs were "explained" by the day to day distance between
Earth and the relevant comet.
And it came up with a surprisingly large value for maybe 1/4 of the
comets tested. It seems "normal" that stuff associated with many
comets somehow makes its way around the solar system and ends up in
the sky of planet Earth. While the databases are specifically for
fireballs, it turns out many stony meteors fall to earth with their
interiors still frozen. It's only the outside that oftentimes gets flash-burned. It's a commonplace that someone cracks open a stony
meteor and claims to find organic compounds or other potentially
strange things (e.g. fossilised bacteria :). It remains to be
established perhaps that a lump of dirt might make a bright enough
flash for some astronomer to see in the sky yet part of that lump or
another one in the same group could fall all the way to the ground and
deliver some organic compounds intact.
There are researchers that claim flypaper they launched on balloons
into the upper atm seem to show collections of material that either
came up from the earth 10s of km or actually fell out of the sky. But
it's far from proven it is likely the latter. But we'll put that aside
for now.
Of the 411 comets tested against the AMS and NASA fireball data we
found 113 scored 2 stat tests >90% confidence. The relevant R2 -- the
fraction of the ups and downs of daily fireball sightings matching
similar ups and downs of comet distance from the Earth ranged from 16%
down to 0.06% with median value 0.7%. It turned out the 16% model was
an "error". The AI programs doing the work mistook the highly
eccentric asteroids Sedna for a comet. We'll put that on the back burner.
The first comet to come in at R2 >10% was JPL number 90004485. This
is anyway very interesting. While AMS/NASA fireballs sightings seemed
to be connected with the distance between the comet and Earth it never approaches closer than about 6 AU. It is by no means a sun-grazer or
even Earth-crosser. Another thing it has a YUGE inclination -- almost
70 deg. Jet somehow as 90004485 moves out to perihelion (max ~37 AU)
there's a noticeable drop-off in fireballs seen by sky-watchers and
NASA. When it moves closer to the sun/Earth fireballs increase. The
power law the AI comes up with is 2.02208542e+04 * x^-1.53020199e+00
where x is the distance between Earth and comet in AU and the result
is the day by day estimated annual rate of fireballs reported to the
AMS (you can get a day by day estimation of *daily* rate of fireballs
reports by dividing the formula by 365.25).
So it's not an inverse "simple diffusion" type of model -- it says
rate is proportional to 1/distance^1.5. This is similar to some laws
of illumination from a spherical source (rather than a point).
It seems the model is trying to tell us that particles diffuse from
the comet at a predictable rate and end up causing maybe as much as
10% of the flashes seen in the sky.
But it's not the only example found. About a dozen comets in the
original list have a similar explanation power and many of them have
unusual characteristics like high inclination or even retrograde motion
around the sun (usually denoted in astro data as having inclinations >90 deg).
If this is correct, what is the mechanism? It seems an obvious one is
particles fray off orbiting comets and at least initially follow
around the same orbit but as a lot of time goes by they spread out
some and in a reasonably significant number of cases they eventually
impact some larger body and sometimes the Earth. It would be like a
constant rain of organic compounds.
--
ATO and ASIC feared data was sent offshore in 2025, internal emails reveal
ABC News, 30 Oct 2026 at 5:39am
The list of government agencies caught up in potential data
breaches involving embattled transcription company VIQ Solutions is
growing, with FOI documents revealing both the ATO and ASIC
conducted investigations after fears data had been sent offshore in 2025.
Australia sitting on unused goldmine of old gigantic tyres
ABC News, 30 Oct 2026 at 9:02am
With global rubber consumption set to exceed production this year,
recyclers say the 110,000 tonnes of mining tyres buried each year
represent millions in potential revenue.
Permit seeks higher antibiotic dosage for diseased Tasmania salmon
ABC News, 30 Oct 2026 at 9:40am
An animal health company has applied to "increase the dose rate" of
the controversial antibiotic florfenicol in Tasmanian salmon farms,
the federal regulator has confirmed.
Bluebottle drones that never sleep level playing field in Pacific drug war
ABC News, 30 Oct 2026 at 5:47am
Australia is giving Fiji uncrewed sea drones that can remain on
open water for up to six months and use artificial intelligence to
identify suspicious activity.
Extreme weather causes over 200,000 home damage claims in the Netherlands
NL Times, 29 Oct 2026 21:16
Extreme weather has caused hundreds of thousands of cases of damage to homes insured with Centraal Beheer over the past ten ...
"That aircraft defied physics." Boeing 737 pilot on odd UFO sighting he had
in the skies above Los Angeles
The Aviation Geek Club, 29 Oct 2026 06:13
Pilots have claimed to see UFOs for decades - sightings usually involve
objects flying in a formation or bright lights, as ...
Hackers identify thousands of DHS employees in massive data breach
The Washington Post, 29 Oct 2026 07:57
Oregon's extreme climate hazard days have quadrupled over 2 decades,
study says
Oregon Public Broadcasting, 29 Oct 2026 12:04
Climate hazards like extreme heat and wildfire smoke are becoming more
frequent across the state compared to 20 years ago.
Aaron Langmaid: It's time to release records on 1966 Melbourne Westall
UFO incident
The Advertiser/OpEd, 29 Oct 2026 08:52
It's Melbourne's very own contribution to a global phenomenon that has
baffled generations, defied explanation and captivated ...
[A fake cousin was at Westall in the 60s. At a Xmas dinner back then
she related some of the details, mostly about the garbage the people in
what she thought were fake military uniforms tried to pull on the
mostly pre-teens they were debriefing. Most of them spotted the flaws
in what they were being fed. First the story was "you made a mistake;
there was nothing there". Then it was "everyone will think you're a liar
if you keep saying you saw something". And then it became "what you saw
is top secret and you must never tell anyone". Which is why most of the witnesses went straight to the newspapers].
The risk of Atlantic current collapse is missing from almost all national climate plans - new study
The Conversation, 29 Oct 2026 03:58
An Amoc collapse would dramatically alter the world's climate - often in unexpected ways. Our new study shows how governments ...
Florida sues climate analytics company First Street over home risk scores
Los Angeles Times, 29 Oct 2026 04:57
Florida is suing the climate analytics firm First Street Technology Inc.,
which has pioneered down-to-the-address risk ...
Denver Water raises rates for outdoor watering in 2027 as drought, climate change stress system
The Denver Post, 29 Oct 2026 04:58
Denver Water's 1.5 million customers will see higher water bills next year
as the state's largest water provider tries to recover from this year's
extreme drought.
[New Arctic Strategy]
As US ties fray, Europe plans first undersea cable link to Greenland
Ars Technica, 29 Oct 2026 01:43
Could a giant sunshade in space `solve global warming'? Scientists are
taking the idea seriously
Nature, 28 Oct 2026 09:37
There Are 15,000 Ant Species on Earth. Blame the Asteroid That Killed
the Dinosaurs
Gizmodo, 28 Oct 2026 19:57
Melting a Time Crystal: Researchers Propose a "Discrete Time Liquid" as a
New State of Matter
XenoSpectrum, 28 Oct 2026 17:56
After Years of Air Leaks, Russia Is Reportedly Closing Off Part of the
ISS for Good
Gizmodo, 28 Oct 2026 17:55
NSF-DOE Vera C. Rubin Observatory Reveals Its First Dwarf Planet Candidate
in Our Solar System
Rubin Observatory, 27 Oct 2026 01:14
FBI Agents Witnessed Eerie Silent UFO Over 'National Security Site' In June HuffPost, 26 Oct 2026 18:45
Two FBI agents and a third official witnessed a dark and silent UFO near a sensitive "national security site" in June, ...
--- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2