From Newsgroup: alt.astronomy

from https://www.space.com/astronomy/is-the-universe-infinite-or-does-it-have-a-limit

Is the universe infinite, or does it have a limit?
News
By Paul Sutter published 22 hours ago
If the universe is expanding, then what is it expanding into, and what
is it expanding from?

Comments (42)
When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. HererCOs how it works.

a red field of bright gas on a starry background
Where's the center of the universe, and where is its edge? (Image
credit: Roberto Machado Noa/Getty Images)

After a century of observations spanning the breadth of the cosmos and theoretical insights that push humanity's vision of the universe to its
utmost limits, we can finally, confidently say that the universe is
infinite.

Or not. It's complicated.

Let's start with something we can say for certain: We live in an
expanding universe. But if the universe is expanding, then what is it expanding into? And what is it expanding from? Where's the edge of the universe, and where is its center?

You may like
An artistic celebration of the Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument
(DESI) year-one data, showing a slice of the larger 3D map that DESI is constructing during its five-year survey.
Astronomers calculate that the universe will die in 33 billion years rCo
much sooner than we thought
an explosion of light surrounded by ripples of light on a starry background Ripples from the Big Bang could transform our understanding of the
universe rCo and we may be close to detecting them
A series of blue sparkling webs create a tangle of threads across a dark
blue background, symbolizing dark matter in the universe.
Information could be a fundamental part of the universe rCo and may
explain dark energy and dark matter
Click here for more Space.com videos...

It's easy to imagine an expanding universe, and there are plenty of
analogies to help guide our thinking. We can imagine drawing little
galaxies on the surface of a balloon and inflating that balloon to see
the galaxies getting farther apart. We can imagine baking a loaf of
bread with raisins in it and seeing how, as the bread rises, the raisins
get farther apart.

But the balloon has both a center and an edge. And the bread has a
center and a crust. So where's the center of the universe, and where is
its edge?

Here's the uncomfortable answer: The Big Bang has no center, and it has
no edge. How can this make any sense?

Let's start with the center. Where did the Big Bang start? Right here.
And right over there. And in the next galaxy over. The Big Bang happened everywhere, all at once. It had to happen everywhere, because everywhere
is, by definition, part of the universe. It was not an explosion that
occurred somewhere in space. It was an explosion of space rCo when the expansion of the universe first got started. It was not a place but a time.

Get the Space.com Newsletter
Breaking space news, the latest updates on rocket launches, skywatching
events and more!
Your Email Address
Contact me with news and offers from other Future brands
Receive email from us on behalf of our trusted partners or sponsors
By submitting your information you agree to the Terms & Conditions and
Privacy Policy and are aged 16 or over.

Now what about the other side of the coin? If the universe is expanding,
what is it expanding into? Where's the crust in our expanding loaf of
bread, and what's the oven we're sitting in?

A blue cylinder with a flared end on a black background

An illustration that shows the timeline of our universe, from the Big
Bang to today. (Image credit: RubinObs/NOIRLab/SLAC/NSF/DOE/AURA)
This is going to get weird. I don't even want to say something like "the universe isn't expanding into anything," because that still conjures up
the wrong mental image. It's too tempting to imagine a wall or boundary,
with galaxies and stuff on one side and nothingness on the other, with
the universe expanding to fill that nothingness.

But that's wrong. Even the vacuum of space is something. There are still points, locations and existence. There's no "outside" of the universe
because "outside" implies existence, even an empty one. But the universe
is, by definition, all there is. There is nothing to physical reality
except the universe. Walls separate one region from another, but the
universe comprises all of the regions simultaneously.

If there were an edge, you could imagine working hard enough to get
outside that edge. But that's not possible. There is no outside; there
is no side. There is just the universe.

Join our Space Forums to keep talking space on the latest missions,
night sky and more! And if you have a news tip, correction or comment,
let us know at: community@space.com.

Paul Sutter
Paul Sutter
Space.com Contributor
Paul M. Sutter is a cosmologist at Johns Hopkins University, host of Ask
a Spaceman, and author of How to Die in Space.
Conversation
Follow this conversation to be notified when new comments are postedfollow
Log in|Sign up
Please follow our community guidelines.

Jump to log in or sign Up
Join the conversation

All Comments
42

NEWEST

All Comments
Comment by christophe_dupin.

john.miles.fimeche
46 min ago
We we accept our universe as all there is, we must also accept the fact
that man has done for thousands of years. Science cannot work with what
it cannot see. Talk is of a balloon or baking bread, not of the big bang
being one of a million such bang happening every second, somewhere.

All we can hope to do, whilst constrained by the limit to the speed of
light, is study what we observe, to interpret where parts of our
universe are being affected by events outside our universe, and where
parts of our universe are being infiltrated by external matter, not of
our Big Bang.

Take the loaf if bread analogy. A ball of dough the size of the solar
system, with a grenade exploding at its centre our Big Bang, still
witnesses expanding raisins. And the expansion will come to a halt. And
the universe will collapse again.

Better still though, imagine a night sky full, horizon to horizon
exploding with massive chrysanthemum fireworks. As they explode, their
matter gravitates into another mass causing another chrysanthemum
explosion, perpetuating across the sky throughout the night.

reply

aarongrayson84
2 hrs ago
Depends on the mind observing it.

sw

shane watt
6 hrs ago
There is no infinity in another dimension.

Gibsense
3 hrs ago
Reply to shane watt - view message
I am not sure what you mean. In flat space (no curvature) a hypothetical
line (dimension) is infinite no matter what label (1,2,3 or4) you
assign. If curved, like the surface of a sphere, then it could be
endless (going around and around) but limited to the sphere. If you wish
put your statement in a context

0
0



--- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2