From Newsgroup: alt.arts.poetry.comments
Kyle Carrero Lopez Knows Every Party Has a Line You Are Expected Not to Cross
In his debut collection, Party Line, Kyle Carrero Lopez moves between nightclubs, family history, Cuba, political language and the small negotiations people make when they want to belong. The title sounds playful until we notice how many different kinds of lines a community can ask us to follow.
rCo rCo rCo
There is an old meaning of "party line" that younger readers may never have encountered.
Before every household had its own private telephone connection, several homes could sometimes share the same circuit. Pick up the receiver and somebody else might already be talking. Neighbors could overhear one another, wait for access or occasionally listen when they were not supposed to.
Kyle Carrero Lopez has said that this older technology helped him recognize what his debut poetry collection was becoming. Different voices could occupy the same line without becoming one voice. Conversations could overlap. Privacy and community could exist uneasily together.
Then there are the meanings we still know immediately. A party line can be the position a political group expects its members to follow. A party can also be the place where people dance, flirt, argue, gossip and decide who belongs in the room.
Lopez's Party Line, published by Graywolf Press in July, keeps moving among all of those meanings.
https://www.graywolfpress.org/books/party-line
The result is political poetry, but not political poetry in the simple sense of turning a position into a poem. Lopez seems more interested in what happens before a position becomes fixed: how people enter groups, how groups establish rules, how language signals belonging, and what happens when somebody inside the group refuses to say what everyone expects.
That makes the party in this book much more than a convenient metaphor.
Lopez actually comes from party people.
His father worked as a DJ. His godfather has worked as a promoter, and his maternal grandfather ran a social club. Lopez later became involved in queer nightlife himself, not merely as someone attending parties but as someone helping organize and host them. He also co-founded LEGACY, a Brooklyn production collective created by and for Black queer artists.
When he writes about a guest list, a dance floor, a host or the social rules inside a club, he is therefore writing about an environment he knows from the inside.
That matters because Party Line is fascinated by something people who organize gatherings eventually discover: a party may look spontaneous to the guest, but somebody has been making decisions.
Someone chooses the room. Someone controls the door. Someone determines what behavior is acceptable. Someone has access because of money, friendship or reputation. Someone else remains outside.
The dance floor may feel free while resting on an elaborate structure of permission.
rCo rCo rCo
A party is a surprisingly good place to study power
One of the most interesting things Lopez does is refuse the easy division between serious political life and supposedly frivolous social life.
A nightclub does not stop containing questions of class, race, money, reputation or power merely because there is music playing.
At the same time, he does not seem interested in draining the pleasure from nightlife in order to prove that everything is secretly politics. There is genuine enjoyment throughout his work. Parties matter partly because people need places where enjoyment is possible.
His poem "Statement of Purpose" makes that particularly clear. The title sounds like something attached to a graduate-school application or institutional document, but the poem becomes a declaration of enthusiasm for celebrations, gatherings, friends and the possibility of having a good time even when work and exhaustion keep interfering.
The Academy of American Poets published the poem earlier this year:
https://poets.org/poem/statement-purpose
That tension between institutional language and lived experience appears repeatedly in Lopez's work.
Words such as "sanctions," "embargo," "public policy" and "statement of purpose" arrive carrying the impersonal authority of bureaucracies. They sound as though they describe procedures rather than people.
Lopez keeps pushing human bodies back into those phrases.
That may be one reason parties interest him so much. A policy can remain abstract on paper, but a party immediately becomes physical. Somebody has to stand somewhere. Somebody gets admitted. Somebody pays. Somebody works. Somebody is watched. Somebody feels safe, while somebody else discovers that the advertised safety does not include them.
The same language of inclusion can therefore become complicated once actual people enter the room.
A community may announce that everyone is welcome while maintaining expensive admission prices. A political organization may celebrate solidarity while deciding which disagreements can safely be voiced. A family may insist upon unity while requiring one member to remain silent about something painful.
Lopez's recent conversation with Jesse Nathan makes clear how seriously he takes that last problem. He argues that groups can become so invested in preserving themselves that maintaining the appearance of community begins to matter more than confronting harm within it.
The problem is not that people gather.
The problem begins when keeping the group together requires everybody to behave as though the same version of events is true.
That is when a party becomes a party line.
rCo rCo rCo
The poems themselves refuse to stay in line
The formal variety of Party Line is important because Lopez does not merely write about resisting uniformity. The collection itself resists settling into one dependable way of speaking.
There are short lyrics, prose passages, persona poems, questions, odes, dialogue and poems whose typography becomes part of their argument.
"Embargo (ADDENDUM)," for example, uses questions that crowd and overlap one another on the page. The form does not simply describe obstruction. The reader experiences something being obstructed.
Another poem, "Usefulness," considers the pressure placed upon a Black Cuban speaker whose words may be claimed by opposing political narratives. The crucial problem is not merely what he believes, but who other people will decide he represents once he speaks.
That is an unusually interesting problem for poetry because a poem is often treated as though it provides privileged access to a person's authentic voice.
Lopez is suspicious of what happens after that voice enters public circulation.
A statement can become evidence for somebody else's argument. Identity can make an opinion especially attractive to people seeking confirmation of something they already believe. A complicated person becomes useful precisely when the complications are removed.
The title Party Line begins to look increasingly exact. Political groups want coherent messages. Families want coherent stories about themselves. Social groups develop codes of behavior. Even readers sometimes want a poet's identity and politics to settle into an easily recognizable position.
Lopez keeps creating poems that do not cooperate completely with that demand.
The voices change. The tones change. Humor appears inside serious material. Pleasure survives beside anger. A poem can move from the language of nightlife into the language of government and back again without announcing that one subject has ended and another has begun.
That refusal of neat separation may be one of the book's strongest arguments.
Human beings do not become different species of person depending upon which room they enter.
The person dancing at two in the morning may also be thinking about family, money, history, race or foreign policy. Political consciousness does not necessarily disappear under club lighting, just as pleasure does not become frivolous simply because the world contains serious problems.
rCo rCo rCo
"Public Policy" turns the whole book into one crowded room
The long poem at the center of the collection, "Public Policy," apparently did not begin as a single long poem.
Lopez has explained that he usually works in shorter forms and initially had several pieces circling similar concerns. During the development of the manuscript at Graywolf, his editor saw that some of this material might be brought together into a larger lyric essay.
The result became one of the book's central structures.
That origin seems appropriate because "Public Policy" behaves less like a conventional argument than a room in which several conversations are happening at once.
Nightlife etiquette can sit beside U.S.-Cuba history. A social gathering can lead into political violence. Questions about who gets through a club door can coexist with questions about who is protected by states and institutions.
Among the historical events entering the poem is the 1976 bombing of Cubana Flight 455, which killed all 73 people aboard.
That history requires some care because simplified political versions of it have circulated for decades. Declassified U.S. intelligence records connect principal suspects Luis Posada Carriles and Orlando Bosch to violent anti-Castro activity and document Posada's earlier relationship with the CIA. Records also show that a CIA source heard Posada speak of plans to attack a Cuban airliner before the bombing. That is not the same thing as documentary proof that the CIA ordered the bombing, and the distinction matters.
Lopez is interested in precisely this territory where official language, incomplete knowledge and political allegiance can reshape the way history is told.
The poem's willingness to place an atrocity beside the apparently trivial machinery of a party might initially seem jarring. Yet the connection is not that the two things possess equal moral weight. The connection lies in systems of permission and exclusion.
Who receives protection?
Who is considered expendable?
Who is allowed through the door?
Who can speak without threatening the group?
Those questions change enormously in scale depending upon whether the group is a circle of friends, a political movement or a government, but Lopez keeps noticing the structure underneath them.
rCo rCo rCo
A good poem may be the opposite of a party line
The most interesting statement in Lopez's new interview may be his description of what a successful poem should do.
He compares it to a good party because neither should become monotonous. Different elements should remain distinct while somehow contributing to a larger structure.
That idea provides a useful way of thinking about poetry beyond this particular book.
A weak political poem can sometimes feel as though every image, line and metaphor has been instructed to arrive at the same conclusion. The reader knows where the poem is going before the language gets there.
Lopez's better idea is that coherence does not require uniformity.
A party becomes interesting because the people inside it are not interchangeable. Conversations form and dissolve. Someone surprises you. Another person makes you uncomfortable. You move into a different room and encounter something that changes the evening.
A collection of poems can work similarly.
Its unity may come not from repeating one message but from allowing different voices, forms and experiences to remain in productive tension.
This also explains why Lopez's interest in accountability is more complicated than simply establishing a new set of correct opinions. He worries about conformity even when the people demanding it believe themselves to be protecting a community.
That is a difficult position because communities really do need boundaries.
Some behavior cannot simply be tolerated in the name of openness. People who gather together inevitably establish expectations about how they will treat one another.
The harder question is what happens when necessary expectations gradually become intellectual obedience.
How much disagreement can a community survive?
How much difference can friendship survive?
Can a group confront harmful behavior without turning every dispute into a test of ideological loyalty?
Poetry is unusually well suited to those questions because poems do not have to resolve contradiction before allowing us to inhabit it.
A political slogan becomes stronger as ambiguity disappears.
A poem can become stronger when ambiguity remains.
rCo rCo rCo
The old telephone meaning may be the most hopeful one
I keep returning to the obsolete technology hidden inside the title.
A telephone party line was inconvenient precisely because several people had to share one channel. Everyone did not speak simultaneously, and nobody owned the entire line.
There was interference, waiting and the possibility of overhearing something meant for somebody else.
That sounds surprisingly close to what Lopez seems to want from poetry.
Not a room in which everybody speaks with one voice, but a structure capable of holding several voices without pretending their differences have disappeared.
His background makes the question especially personal. He was born in northern New Jersey to Cuban parents and writes from within overlapping Black, Cuban American, queer, artistic and political communities. Each of those communities can offer belonging while also carrying expectations about what someone belonging to it is supposed to say.
One response would be to choose a single line and remain on it.
Lopez's poetry keeps doing something more difficult.
It stays on the shared line while listening to the other voices.
That may also explain the range of references in Party Line, which moves comfortably among poets, musicians, nightlife figures, family members and political history. Lopez has cited writers including Lucille Clifton and Ai Ogawa as important influences, but his imaginative world also contains Celia Cruz, Andr|- Leon Talley, Whitney Houston, pigeons, DJs and people encountered at parties.
The mixture does not feel accidental.
It reflects a belief that serious thought does not belong to one approved register.
A poem can think while dancing.
It can make an argument without becoming a manifesto.
It can care about politics without surrendering humor, pleasure or contradiction.
Perhaps most importantly, it can invite people into the same room without demanding that they all leave saying exactly the same thing.
Kyle Carrero Lopez's Party Line suggests that belonging becomes dangerous when community starts requiring unanimity. His poems offer a different possibility: many voices can occupy the same line, remain recognizably themselves, and still make something together. That may be as good a description of a successful poem as it is of a successful party.
View the attachments for this post at:
http://www.jlaforums.com/viewtopic.php?p=713271908#713271908
--
Via JLA Forums web gateway for alt.arts.poetry.comments
--- Synchronet 3.22a-Linux NewsLink 1.2