From Newsgroup: soc.culture.china


E+o*<+uo+u#+o!a*Caoeyt2iE|iN+UE+!oc+to|ooao|c*|+tUao#AuoaE|iN+iE+Auo+ooaoa|t|+tUaono*+4oAy
Aug 6, 2025 rCo *e+*+- rCLE+Noeio++uLeo!a*Ca*>|E+!oc+uo+o|LoaAE+UE+UN+iE+aueaoAi*Ci*oeo+uN+itA#oL?uLeE|cE+UE+U*|euYN*|eoaAuo+o|LpCerCY
2009o||7uLe4uuNN+iE+!oLiu#f*yctLUu#OocaoA<N+i*+aoiaoEi*+#u#aoCUoUAu+yo>|oe+oo<uYaoaotoftootUauL?*u+o<|E+#N+ioa|E+!E+Co<|E||u!uoL?uoOo#Aoaeo+foaeE+oE++to?oc+o!E*|+te-o||oA#pCeuoYN+UChina Photos/Getty Images
*+aE|ioiUo||N+iE+Nu+yo<YoAiE|4E+LE+|E+u*i?tUato|ooao+?on|o|c*|+N+iE+|E+!oc+o+auYNo+?onotUa*+4oAyN+iE+iE+ao+#ooiuO<oCUE||tUauuNo++u|e*||N+i*+yu+#*+LoL#ocioiaE+!oc+tUauo+ooaoa|t|+pCe
2024o||11uLeN+it+Aoc+E|ou#+ofAonoo!ao|aoaionU*>|ooao!aoOooe-tEauoOuAepCUuo+u#+o!at|+oa+E++uoOuAeoeyt2iE|ioc|teeE+o*auFrom Click to Boom: The Political Economy of E-Commerce in ChinaN+epCeE+Ate|oc+oe#t|U*iuN+UE+!oc+to|ooaoAao#otUauo+u#+t+Au|Ao!apCiN+eN+ioi+oiAE+!oc+to|ooaoNc*+|*aioEAtUauo+u#+t+Au|Aoc+uO>pCe*+OuL4E|aof|E|AoiUE+Oo||tUataot-|N+iuuo*<+*#eto|ooaE+AE+U*CapCUuo+o|Lo<yoaypCUto|ooao||oA#oayo+NN+ioAet+ooEeoAfooiou<oi+pCUo||oA#oaaoa?uo#ui<oAiE+CE+-*+?*|eE+etLUtUaoUAuL|o>|tao*>oo-ipCe
oeyt2iE|iE+o*aupCeE+Ate|oc+oe#t|U*iuN+UE+!oc+to|ooaoAao#otUauo+u#+t+Au|Ao!apCi *+auuNN+it2>E+ao-AE+o*<+oeyt2iE|iN+iE+Ato|ooatUa*oa*oAuAo*<?E+!oc+uo+u#+t+Au|AoL?*+coA+E|ioiUo||tUaoAao#opCeoL?*+Ot>coo+t>cE+o*<+E+!N+iueaE+4oaeu+#oaNto#ocAN+i*UaoE4to|ooa*ieua|uu|E+utUaoecE+Uo#AuoaE|ioAiE+uuaaE|ioAyN+ct+o*CiocRoe#to|ooatUaoAaoA#t-uoAuuLfN+iocRoi+uo+o|LoAito|ooao+?on|oaeE+orCLE+Cuiioi|oEerCYuA?oe?to|ooaue|*|2N+io+iuLco#ato|ooaE+iu#eoe#E+!oc+o|+oyotUaoaLuYaoL#oi|pCeuLCoEAN+iueaE+4uAo*<?uc|o<A*oetUaou<ooyN+ioeauREto|ooao+?on|o|c*|+o>|E+!oc+uo+ooaoa|t|+oAitn+E+Uu#+tEatUau+#*+Lo+#ooipCe
*ieua|o||E+uN+Ut+aty+oYAo||pCUoaLE|iE+uE+AoN|oecE+Uo<| t2>E+ao-AN+UueaE+4oaeE+AE+CE+-t<CoiotUaou<ooyo+CooiN+i oo-E|cE||u>o*+auu-oAeE+Aoe#to|ooaE|iE+!N+io+CooioUU*|+t+aE+etUao#AtofuaAN+f
oeyt2iE|iN+UuLCuu-oeuue|oUUto|ooatUaE||N+ioa|o<Roa+ui|*ieua|N+itoU*c|uLete|*+|t+ypCeE+uE+4onUuo#uy>o||*++E||N+iocaE+|oL?t|+E+it+|E|A*|au|EpCUu#iE+CE|eou?*+>N+ioeUoN+to#E+euL|E+UN+io##*+aoe#t+aE+eo+Co|upCeoL?to|ooaoeUoa|*|+tUauu|oCON+io+Ct+ao|uo||E+i*o2*oaE+|E+CE++rCLu!ut+Ao+NE+LrCYN+iueCE+NE|fue+oAuE|aE+Co<UtUatn+E+UoAioecpCe
ueaoL?u#|oiutO+u#foUcoe#*+cE+CE+ioUUo+ute|oe2ueEoeftUa80oEApCetO+u#fuy>*auoEitUarCLE+!oc+t<#oiaE|ioa+rCYN+io+ooL#t<#oiaE|oE+U*oau?io+eonopCeE+u*>|o<|ociE+Noeio+et-+N+ite|u>io+iuLcE+uoA+o+otoao+Nueuto|o+NN+i*oeo+uoeuua+tofu|+ueit?|o<UpCeE+aE+uon-tofoYEE+iE+AN+iocau4iuLeuL|E+UoA+o+NoAeE+etA!oa+u#ioA+pCeoEAuYNo+o*+cE+Yo<eN+iE|foL?t+aoEoueo*+co+NN+itofu|+E+Co|ao+e*e#oU+pCetc|oe#2007o||o+CooioUUto|ooaN+iE+Co+Cooioa|o<Ro+ete|*#2N+iuCo*+OtoirCLE+iu!ut+ArCYtUao+NE+LE+U*<-te|u>iu#ioYoo!EpCeE+aE+uE+-uCouoooa#N+iuLCoEAtLftUaou>E|aoc|uYNpCe
*+yuLeE+io#aoecE+U*CaE+Co+Cooi*o2to#E+|rCLt+aty+o#ao||rCYpCeueaoL?o|+E+L*oU*+cE+CE+io+ooL#tUarCLuyAuyfoiuo<|rCYN+io+ouu|E+uuei15o#UN+itofuaAo+#t+AoUUo+uuLeou#uLe*e#pCeE+Noeiuo|on-ueou++ueApCUE+i*e>E+eo!aN+i*<-te|u>io+eon|tu+pCeE+au!uuy>ocaE+|u#e*++t+a*+>N+iE+uoAi*CiuAN*oaoe#E|ato|ooaN+io+Cooioiuto+*uapCeoiuto+*uaE++*aUuy>ocaE+|u4+o+AE+ioaAoN|*uauioo+uoeuE|eo+2pCUoAioeco#ApCeoEAuYNoUUo+uE+iooON+iE+utUate+oaeo|#*aa*+RuAeo+NoAeo+NE+LN+ioa?*UiuYNo+<E+upCe
2009o||7uLe4uuNN+iE+!oc+u#f*iAtLUtYoo<UoA+u#OocaoocN+iE+nE+io||*++E||u!uoL?E+|E+uE+4tUato|o!Eooa*|+E|oooUuiitaopCeuaaN+UChina Photos/Getty Images
ueaE|fuAN*oa*+cE+io#arCLoaLE|iE+urCYoUUto|ooatUauieE+ipCeoaAoL?taAo+|o<eu|-uLeE+-oiuooU*oeof|tUato|ooauYaN+iocaE|AueCuLeto|ooaoecE+U*Caoa+uy>oaLE|iE+upCeE+uE+4tUate|u>iuy>*i|oaLN+iE+Noeioa+uy>t|+E+ioiuN+i*+OE|coaLE|iE+uoeOocaE+|oL?t|+E+iu#iuLeon-onU*|au|EN+iE+uE+4o##oCeui-oUUto|ooapCe
t!e*+OE|co||*++E||oUUoc|ueEt+-E|ioEAN+io+Co+CE|fE+Uueeo<|E||uie*+cuYNN+ioa?o<|E+C*|+oUUto|ooapCeueaoi#*#iuLCu+#tUauy>o##E+LufEuYatUaE+CE+i*CUonote+N+iE+uoAfuL4uy>oiuo#+tUapCeoeuo||uyN*eeoeio+2oCAoULE|aN+iE+uoAeocRoA+uaauaeoiuo#+N+iueaE+4tUa*<+*#eo##uy>oL?ono*iuE+e*+c*iitUapCeE+uuy>ocaE+|oa+o!Eo+CE|at+ao|uN+iueCE+No+<o+OoUUo<ouLipCeE+uoAfuL4E+Au#ito#*+cto|*aaN+iE+|E|aueoo!uN+ioL?ooOE+e*||E|aE+Co+aui+of|*i?N+iu>Au4io>|*autLiN+ito?E+CoA-ueiuaouaouo#oo<tcyN+iuLioAiE+4oa+t4aE+uuy>oL?t+arCLE+CuictaarCYpCeE+uuL4uYNoAito|ooau>2uuaoa|*UoN+iE+aocaE+|o<|E||tUao+aoe?N+iE|fueEE+|E|oE+Uoo+E+etUaE+CtA>pCe
uC+tUauYN*>|N+iuLCuu-oUUto|ooatUa*+Oue|E||o||*++pCU*ieua|N+io+eonU*aiuO>o+euO<oCUpCeE|fu!uocaoaeu!nN+iE+uE+4o>|uL|E+Ute|oe2uoAuafN+iuoooaAoO-pCUuooo#Y*>opCe*Ci*+OE|cuu-uLfrCL*oat+arCYtUao||*++E||N+io+Co+C*+y*a+oAi*+cuYNo+aoe?te|u>ipCUtoU*c|uo|E+-o<|o|!ueooaNoa|E+!N+iE+A*Ci*<-E+CE+-oAfuL4*+|t+ytUao#At+nE+oN+iuA4oe?E|aE+CE+-oa?uu#tUaE|oE+Ut-|ou|pCe

E+ao-AN+Uoeu*+OE|cuu-uLfto|ooauYaoa+uy>*c-oAatUaoEuN+f*+yuy>uo+o|LoL?oe+uaAue|uiUE+uE+4tUaN+f

oeyt2iE|iN+UuLCuu-oeuE|cto|ooauYaN+iof|uL4oa+uy>uYau#aE+Cte|E+Cu+|oUU*|+uYNtUaN+iocaE|Au#iuLeE+CE|euo+o|Lue|uiUpCeo++*oUtUauaaoa|uy>N+iuYaociE+CE+nE+-E||tU|uL|E+Coe?N+iueeoAfuL4oL?t|+E+ioiutUaE+L*N+uE4oe#t+aE+eN+iu>ooaeueio+N*e|ooUpCU*iuuLit!epCe
ueaoi#*#ite|oe2u+#tUauy>N+io+oo||oL?*iAo+RtLioy|u+au|uE+Cue+E||o<|oiuonoou+*f|tUat+ao|upCeE+Noeionoou+*f|E++*aUoiut+OonEoaaN+ioEAuYNuLeE+-oaLE|iE+uo+CooioL?u+yo<YE+eoiuN+iuaouaoo+aoe?oa?*+|*f|oaLE+C*|+oUUpCeE+uuy>onoo!atofN+ioL?ofAo+eo+NE+L*+cN+iE+aocaE+|o<|ociu#ioA#E|#ue+pCUt+oo-UN+iuLCoEAocRuYaoecE+UpCeE+uonot|aE+A2010o||o+Cooioiu*f|N+iE+atofo#LE|oooUoU+o|ao+eo2yN+ioaAonoou+*f|u!+E|ao##E+i*a+oEaN+iuCAE|eE+Y*>Uu|+*f|oL?te-u|UE+!E+iu!+N+iuy>E+-onoou<ooypCeE+uuLCoEA*>ooc|E+CE+-t<CoioE+auLeuoetUauu|u|oN+UoL?oia*uatcAocc*oAuo+oa#u#|to|N+iuo+oL?u|+*f|oa?oc|N+it+|uiUE+Au+-N+i*+Oua+t+AoAaocaon-te-u|UE|ioEAN+ioCUoe#o<oue+ueiE+!uu|*f|*+y*a+uy>u|+tUapCe
E+ut44E+Co||o##*|UE|aoa2E+cN+io>|o+ouu|tUaE+uuYN*>|oA#o+eonUpCeE+ao+2oCAoa4oA+ua|uL4E+ioci*oaN+iocaE+|*<ooioon-o#aN+i*+Ruo|*|ote|oa+u#i*<+pCeE+uoA-oN+*c-o+#u>Aon-o-aua-uey*+auee*f|*++oc|uYaoAa*|oN+iE+Con-oiUocaoioN+ioEAuYNoUU*|+uYNE|aN+iua-uey*+aoAyueEE|aoYooia*+aN+ioaioEAuYNo+2oCAoa4oA+toU*c|E+eou?uo|*|oE|apCe
*+Ot#+E+io!EE+io#aN+iE|fuLeE+Aoc|o+CooioecoCauo|E+-E|oE+UtUapCeu>ooaeo+Eo+RE+LouAuYaN+iE+CE+-o||*++E||oA+E+eu|+oCcE|aIKEAN+ioAuoE>oAaocRuYao+CooioUUui+*uao<|oa+N+it+ouRL*|eoUU*|eoN+N+io+aoe?uo|E+-uYaE+C*|+oUU*|+uYNpCeo##oaAueaE|aoci*>|tUaN+ifrom click to boomrCorCoE+Ate|oc+oe#t|U*iupCe
*+OE|cuieE+itUaoa#oEite|uy>N+UE+Co+CooioL#uu|uo+o|Lof|uL4u#ioAeE+AN+itoU*c|E+itfNoUopCeuLeoN+ocaE+-oL#uu|N+ito|ooauYaoa+o+#t+AoUUoc|*oau?ipCUE+eE|auu#ou+N+iuo+o|Lueiuae*oeN+UrCLoAfuYNueaE+4*+Oocio+#t+AuLeE+CE+-to|ooauYaN+UrCY
2017o||11uLe8uuNN+iE+!oc+o+Eo+Ru+yo<YuYaN+iE+Co<|to|ooaE+UE+UtUaoeRoa4o<npCeuaaN+UChandan Khanna/AFP via Getty Images
oEAuYNto|ooata!*|+uYNN+iuLeE|coL#uu|uo+o|Lo+Cooio#Y*>oue|uiUN+iE+ao+Co+C*+yuy>to?*CUoeRu|orCorCot+OoA#pCUt+OoL#rCorCouoeuRLo+eE+itEaua|pCeu>ooaeueaoA+*+cE+CE+-to|ooao!|oiuoc!N+ioeRoa4o<noeaE+oo|opCUo+|o+uui|u+eE|<N+i*+yoaiE+Co||tofocaN+iE+aocaE|Au#iE||oaNo-+pCeocaE+|*+OE|coc!oi|ta+o#au#aoi|on-*+LN+ionUuo#to|ooauy>oL?o<|oci*+E*ENN+i*+Ro|oo!yoa+u#iuLeN+itc|uANo+NoAeoAa*|oN+edrop-shippingN+eN+iE+iuCAE|eoLC*aUE+ooe?pCe
*+yuLeE|coL#uu|*<+t2iE|ato|ooaue|uiUof|ocaN+iE+a*|aocato?E+ioc|oA+pCeocaE+|to|ooaE+ioaAE+at+fo<RE+oo|uoeuua+t+|oA#pCeE+!oc+tUao<RE+oE|nuyoE+!ueotO+uYitUaE|iuaaoYRo++onUN+i E+auy>to|ooauy>tA#ocau|Uo+eoN+tUatofuaAN+it+aE+eu>AoiuE|nuyouo>E+yo<YuLCoo+15on-o##*a+ui+oe#oA#pCe*CiE+oto|ooauO<oUiuCoufNt?AN+iueCE+NE+iua|oAiuo+o|LueoE|noUopCe
uea*#ataouu|N+iuLeto|ooaoiAE+UtUaE||o##*>|N+iuLConoou<ooyuy>rCLuo+o|LoAiE+UE+U*a#*eerCYpCeuo+o|Lue|uiUo+Co+CE+CoAouaaua+N+iE+iuANoL#u#oN+ioAio+eoL|*oao+i*aita+N+ioAi*Ci*<-E+UE+UrCLon|tucrCYpCeu>ooaeufEu#+u|+tLUui?E|aE+noiaE+cue|uiU*|aocaN+iuLCoEAoA-to?E|aE+ioe#E+ntO+E+cpCeoAfocauy>to|*>+ou?uocon-o2yN+i*|aua+uYiE+|on-onUN+iE+UE+UucAo+uueNpCe*+?ooato|ooaoa?oeaoEAuYNto?E|aE+etO+E+cN+iE+aonot4oooat<u*+yuy>oCCocRE|a*|ouo+N+io+#ooiE+iE+Co||ooat<uoeaoaiN+io+oueEuU|uCoo+-tA>pCeufEoaaoOatLUE|ft#+E++N+iE+CoiaonUE+ctUao+<ue|*|aocaN+iuLCoEAE|fu#ito?o<ipCeou<ooyoL?E|AN+Uuo+o|LE+itfNoUouCAE|et+OpCUE+NE+CE|eoEiE|et+OpCUueCuL>ou?uocuCAE|e*<+pCeu>ooae*aUu#erCLo||ooCoo<E+noiaE+cE+NE+erCYuei*a+to|*>+N+iE+auo+o|L*c-o+#E|fuERE+iu+auNUN+it-|t2fuLeonUo#a*+Oua+tUato|ooapCUoL?oo-ocipCUuy>oEaoC+o+uue|uiUN+ioAi*Ciueeu+LoL?o>|*#ioEo*+aE|apCe
o+ota|N+iE|fE+iuy>*>|oL#uu|uo+o|Lo<ioa?u#i*|iti<pCeoaAoL#uu|uo+o|LE|ioeitUaE+<*+>pCUoCU*<>*+OE|cof|tiC*<+uu+N+iti<o<RE+|oEAuYNtUato|ooaoAao#oueoE+iE|aof|tiCpCeE+ao+ooeY*+OE|co+|*<+E|fE+iuy>E+|E|aoAao#oto|ooaN+iuy>E+|E|auo|E+ot+Au|AoAao#oN+ito|ooaoA-uy>rCLuaAonuuo|*A+rCYN+eunintended consequenceN+epCe
ueaoEAuYNoAatA#N+ioL?to|ooaoAao#otUaoa|oo<uu|uLfN+ioL#uu|uo+o|LuLCuLeE++oC+tUa*oA*e#oA>*a+E+iuy>rCLuLeE+|rCYN+i*Ciuy>rCLuuaE+|rCYrCorCot+Oo+eoL|toOoc|t-|ou|pCeoaAueaoA+*+ctUaE+CE+-to|ooauYaN+iuYau#a*+Y*oaoL?ue+o!EonuuE!uuUE+LE+oo|oN+ioa?*+|uYaE|fuLet#+E++tUa*+Otoi*+Y*oao+|t!apCeE+aE+et|ouo+o|LoL?t+fE+CuiaoOnuu|N+ioo>ti4u#iuLeuiato|ooauYatUa*+Y*oao+|t!aN+i*+y*>|N+UrCLE+iuiaE|fuy>N+eo>|to|ooatUaN+eE+Ctoiuo>uiUpCerCY
2019o||11uLe11uuNN+iE+!oc+oiuE|4N+iE+Co<|o+2oCAoa4oA+tUaE+oo|opCeuaaN+UNoel Celis/AFP via Getty Images
*+Ot#+rCLo+y*<+rCYtUat-|ou|N+iuLeuu|oCOu>ou!uo+Auo+t!u*+yoci*aUpCe*+O*<-ueaoEAuYNueeo<atEa*<|oiuE+|rCLueytoNE+it<ioe|rCYN+estrategic non-regulationN+eN+Uuo+o|LuyAtfNoA>E+Nt<ipCUuLe*a+oect<iN+iE+aE+|E|a*<-ufEE|cE|oE+UuLeoAao#ot-|ou|N+ioCeui-uUeuu|E+ioA+t<ipCe*+OE|fuy>uea*<nE+|to|ooaoAao#oE+!E+CE+-o+eoci*aUtUauo+u#+*aiuO>pCe

E+ao-AN+UE+atUaE|aE+!E|fuAEoe#N+ioN|uCotUato|ooaoecE+U*Cau>oE+io+eo2yN+iE+|E+CE|euLe*+OtoitA#*#iN+f

oeyt2iE|iN+UuC+E+ouYN*>|N+iE+!oc+oN|uCoE+UE+Uo<|tUau>oE+ioa|o<R*c<E+AtUaN+i2017 o||onouaeoA-uLe 30%pCeE+ao##t<u*+Oua+N+i*+OE+-uo#o!uoL?oa?tEaE|fo+#t+A*a+uAA*+coeioiUN+i*>|uyAuCooe2o+<*+YoL?ooaE+Uooaoffo||E+iuy>E+!oc+ti4uLetUatA#*#iN+i*Ciuy>E+CE+-oa?tEauCotUaou<ooypCe
E+i*+cN+ioL?to|ooa*+OE+-ooaoffN+iuaaoa|o##onoE+itc+oEiE|apCeoN|uCoo|uE++ocaE|AoiaE|aoie*+|on-pCeueat44E+Cu4iu|?uaAoe#*+Ote|N+iuy>oL? 2016 o||oUUto|ooaou<oi+tUauu|oCOpCeo+ouu|tLioe#uLeE+Coieo|uE++uy>oN|uCoN+iuea*+yE+NE+|uo#ui<oc|ooOE|aN+io##te|oL#oA+ou<oy+ocipCeE+uE+4uLeuo|E+-u+yo<Yo||oA#tUau|?oai*|auuON+iuCooe2uy>ua|ui<*|2E++*>U*|auuOuYNtUaN+it+ouRLE|fuy+tn|rCorCoto+oN|oEaoiaE+CoiepCeoy+ocitUao2yt<i*+y*>|N+i*+OE+-u>oE+ioA>*a+*+y*o2E+AE+#E|aN+iocaE+|oL?E+CE|cE+at+f*oeo+|u>o*+ao+|tUaoL#oi|N+ioN|uCooA>*a+E+Uto?E+eon2tUa*|2E++*>Uu|?oaio|uoo|pCe
*+OE|fuy>E+|E+CE|euLeE||ueeto|ooato#E+LrCLoN|t+Au|ArCYN+eshe-conomyN+erCorCoE+ioA-uy>ocaE+|oN|uCou|e*||*CaonUN+iuc|ocaE+|oecE+UtUaoN|uCoE|foYRo++onUpCe
*CiE+oN+i*+OE+ioA-oAatofoL?E+!oc+pCeua|ui<E+eo||tUauo#ui<N+ioL? Shopify *+Oua+tUaoc+oOato|ooao||oA#E+eN+ioN|uCoo|uE++tUau>oE+itoU*c|*|a*+cE|aE+CoieN+i*++oe# 54%pCe
oCaueE*+Otoi*|ioe+tUaoAfocaoA>*a+uLeocaE+-pCet44E+CN+ito|ooatUata!ou?ooUt#+oaAuLi*uapCUt+AoaaN+iuL4uYNo##uy>oN|uCou>o*+atafueetUaooaoffpCeE+i*+cueaoEAuYNE|foA+tLiE|ato|o!EE|oooUt#+oe2N+ioAatA#oN|uCoo|uE++tUau>oE+iE|foL?E+eoicpCeueCE+Nuea*oeo+uuc|oa|oo<tUaN+i*+yuy>to|ooa*+Otoiu?io+AuL4*|2o##oYRo++tU|u|+N+iuu|ou|oAioL#te|oa+u>o*+a*c-to#N+i*+Oo>|oN|uCoo#noa|uLeoE+o+ooecpCe
E++E+-E+io!EN+Uo+Co<RE+oo|utUa*>YN+i*|oo+uuo+oL?o+ooL#N+iE||E|fo+uoUAuu|oL?o|uocio<e*auN+cE+aoUUto|ooao##E+iE+Cua+E|apCeueaoi#*#io+eu+#tUaE+Co+ataotecN+iuy>E+CE+ioaeoaeE+C*+|ue#*auo#Ao!-N+iE+C*+|oYEoL?to|*aaoeio+oo<ouLipCe*+Otoi*a+oL?o<|o+NE+LtUao+|uCoN+i*<-o+eonUoN|uCo*a+onfE+C*+|taooi+o<|o|!N+iE+C*+|t+A*EN*c-o+#tUatofuaApCe
2020o||10uLe23uuNN+iE+!oc+E+eu|+N+iE+CoEioN|o!EoL?tc|uA!ou|tUat|+E+eooaoUoooCoo<E|oooUpCeuaaN+UHector Retamal/AFP via Getty Images
*+OtoitU|u|+uCoN+iE|f*+fE+!oc+E|A*Uot+aE+UE+Uuu-uLftUaoAao#ot!utoNuLeoa|pCeE+uE+4o+euu-o##ooaoenoe#uO|*a+ueiuL|E+UueEE+|E++u|UN+iE||E+4E+Uto?ueiuL|onatEa*|euYN*|eonUtUaE|ipCeueCE+Nuu-oL? 2013pCU2014 o||o+aoA|N+io##o+CooiuA?*iirCLueiuL|E+yoaerCYN+emobile firstN+et!utoNpCe*+Ote|oAit+Aoc+o+eE+ioEirCorCot+Aoc+u|e*||*CaE|aua>to?to|*aaE+et+a*|!te-N+iueiuL| App tUaoAao#otc+o>|uaoE+CE|cpCeE+aoL?E+!oc+N+io+Co|upCUoUUo<ouLipCUoAa*|opCUocRo|oE|#o<|N+ioa?oa+oA>E+NoL?ueiuL|E+eo<iueEN+i*<-to|ooatUat+A*ENoL#te|uc|uL|oe?pCe
*+yuLeE+Cte|uea*oeo+uE|fo+eoC+o+uu|?uaAN+i*O+ta|*+yoLC*aU*+cE+Cu!NtUataot-|uYNo-i*>UN+Uto|ooaoL?ufEtoit?io|aE+eoA>*a+E|foOiE+AE|aoN|uCooL?oecE+UE+!oYoE+|tUauCooe2u!o*oapCeocaE+|oL?t|+E+eE|nuyoE+!N+iE|#o<|tLiE+ioe#oiuo<|uy>to+uy>oN|N+ioN|uCoo##*a+E+Nuc|o||t!etUa*|2E++oAeE+Ao+eoL|t2RE|epCe
E++E+-o<RoOaE+io!EN+UE+!oc+E+at+fooaE+UuucoiuociN+io|ooa4oAioaAo#Cuucoiuo>|oN|uCoo||E+ioAiouapCeueaE|ioeioL?u#|oiuoUUtaot-|N+i*<+ou<E|aE+CE|cE+At|+E+i*+4oUUto|ooatUato+uCooecE+U*CaN+iou<E+uE+4*+4oRioEAuLConotUaoAyoiuuy>E+CE|eN+iE+uE+4*>|N+UrCL*|2E+ooAyoN+E|aN+iocaE+|E+ito?oaiouYoeuE|eonUoaAE|apCerCYoL?E+!oc+N+io||E+iuy>*>|oN|uCoE+i*a+ouYoaAN+i*Ciuy>*+coaNto+uCoE++o>+tUao|ooa4oLeo!Eti<o<RE+io<|uyopCeE+aoUUto|ooaN+io##tLUoA+E|a*+OE|coL|oYoN+iocaE+|to|ooau>o*|+t|+E+itofuaAuc|*||*+aoOitofE||pCUoNat|aoiuE|nuyoN+ioA>*a+tc+o>|u#iuLeoeuE|eE+Y*|uE||*aeoAioa|t|+pCeo>|oN|uCouYN*>|N+i*+Oueu*<+u!uuy>E+Ctoit-Uta|uCouL|E+UN+ioA>E+No+<oe-oN|E+4oaiuLiuCooe2ueCo+auYNtUaufEE|ct+ouRauCooeuoe+pCe
o+ota|N+i*+OE|coA-uy>ueatUaE+CE|coeYu!N*oeo>foAitiLua|pCeo+iuLcuL-uYN*a+uLeuc|onUu+#oaNtUataot-|N+iuYNuAo*<?*+OE|ctA#*#i*aioEAtUatLfu!uoAfocapCe
E+uuaaE|ioAyN+UoAao<|E|ioEAtUato|ooauYa t2>E+ao-AN+UoaLuYaocit-Uta|uLeE||oUUto|ooa*c|o>iN+iE+Uo>|uYao!Eo+auYNuCAua+tUao+#ooioaoN+fE+UE+iE+UE+nonoo<|tUaoa|t|+oAyo+uE+iE+Cua+N+f
oeyt2iE|iN+Uoa|o<Ro+#ooiuy>E+noeatUapCe to|ooa*|+uYNE|ioEAN+iE+CE|coL#uu|tUaoe+ocioa|t|+pCUtoU*c|u#+o<eoAyo+uuc|oN+E|apCeueaoA+*+ctUaocaE+-uYao!EN+io+ooL#E||oae*>eueaN+ioL?oUUto|ooaE|ioeiN+ionoo<|t+Ao++ocaE+|E+CE|co+iu>c*ALtU<tUao#AE|iE|eoE|pCeE+ato|ooaE|ioEAonoo<|oa+o+eo+ON+iu#ioeuE|eonUuu|ou|*<i*+aN+iuYau#aE|iou|tUat|at|+uyAuy+o#aE|apCeuLeE+-oL#uu|tUauYau#a*+y*+fuea*>|N+itA#oL?onoo<|tUao<eoa?uaA*>aE|fuAEoicE|aN+io<|o<|ue+ue+oa+*uaE|ato|o!EtcauAopCeuLeuu|oCOuYau#aE|iou|E|Atc+ui+*|oN+io+yE|auo|onUo#aoA#N+io##oA+tLitcauAoN+Ut|o*e#uy>100oaaN+it++*e#uy>50oaaN+iu+au+auNUuNUN+iu#iuLeE|e*<<pCe
2009o||7uLe4uuNN+iE+!oc+u#f*iAtLUu#OocaoocN+ioiuoaaooUooCoo<oayoe#E+Co<|E+AE|ito|o!Eooaoeio+NE+LtUao<|o|!uA?*iEE|oooUpCeuaaN+UChina Photos/Getty Images
*+Ouy>u>o*+au!uoYotUao+#ooiN+iE+ato|ooaE|fo+auYNE+CE|cuu#tfctc+rCorCoE++*aUuy>tA#E+uooaE+UoC+*+aE+AE+at+ftafE||tn+E+UE|iou|tUaoa#t-UpCeoL?oaLuYaN+ionoo<|o++u!noa+*<n*>aN+i*+OtoitafE||t+at+LuLeoN+onaE|fuLeoYAonapCeoN+onauy>to|ooaue-o#ote|oe2o+2rCorCouYau#atc+E|AE|iou|E+UuoCu>ote2*CCN+iuLeE||oYato|ooa*|UoA#oEAN+ioe+o#ao+eo<|uyoo##tLioe#u?iE++N+ita|oEAoA>*a+uo|E+-uYao!Eoa+oUU*|+uYNE|apCeE+aoYAonauy>o+eoU+E+YuLeooaE+UuL|o>apCeueaocc*<+*+cE+CE+io|uE++o##*>|N+irCLooAoaCueao<|tUaE|#ueUpCUuLioAiuYNueaE+4o<|oUc*uaooaouaN+i*+4E|aE+CoLeo##ueeueaE+4E|oooUtUau4+o+Aoa+uea*|#E|apCe rCY
ueaoA+*+ctUaE+CE+-to|ooauYaN+ioeuociu>Ao<|tUaooaooUu4+o+AE|Atc+ueauYNueaoA+N+c*+OE|fuy>ocaE+|oaLuYato|ooaou?uocE+AN+ioEi*|?oiut2RE|eo+eE+NocipCeuLeE+CE+-u>o*+at#+uyAtUao||*++E||o|#*aaueeueCuLeu4+o+Aoa+u|?oaiE|aN+ioaioaeoa|E+ut+ao|uN+i*+foa|E+uuYau#a*>|rCLE+a*+YoAiE|aueatUatfN*>aE|ouYa rCYpCeuLCoEAuYao|#oa?o##*+aoe#E+uo<|N+i*>|N+UrCLE+a*+Oua+oUUu|oo+iE+eu#iooON+iE+aoL?E||uaaE+e*>|E+i*+coA+N+iocaE+|E+aoeuE|cu4+o+AE+Co+CooiE|fuy>ueauYNtUapCerCYE|fu!uuy>ocaE+|oaLuYatn+E+U*+yuLeE+CE|co<uuuAueuE||uaat+at+LN+i*+OE+-o||*++E||oEAuYNE|fo##u#iuLet+ot+!oaeE+ioA+N+iE|iuaao##*+Oua+oiu*ouE|apCe

E+ao-AN+Uoeuo>|uYaocitUao<yoayuYN*>|N+iE+uE+4oAeuy>uCAua+tLio+a*+OE|ct-Uta|*c|o>itUato|ooaoaoN+f

oeyt2iE|iN+Uo+auCUo+eoniuYepCeE+Cuu|oYoto|ooaoAao#o*|+uYNN+i*O+ta|E+iE+Co<Uuy>uo+o|Ltc|uANue|uiUtUat+ouRLN+iE+aE|ft<uuy>E+-oL#uu|uo+t+-pCeoAaE+Cuu|oYoN+iuo+o|LoAeo+iuLc*a+E+A*+O*ei*o4oiaoAao#oE+!oeaE+CuY>t+|N+iE+ioae*>+t?AN+iE+ao+Co+Cue+E+ioe#oN+tUaueoueipCeoAfocaoL?E|AN+ito|ooatUaooCoo<uo#ui<uAiuAioL?o||oA#ueiE+!N+i*Ci*<+onUooao<|E+AuL-oL?t|+E+io+Nooau|?oaiN+io>|oL#uu|uo+o|L*Ci*?CuuoE+ioA>*oUN+iE|foU+E+No+Ut?ApCeoL#uu|uo+o|LuO<oUio+iuLco||oA#*a+uAEE+cuo#ui<uYN*|ouo+oaLo|oN+iE+ao||oA#of|uL4E+iE|eoaioEepCe
E+io#aE||*>>E+NE+|oL?E+!oc+tUauo+u#+*>!ooaE+iN+io||oA#tUauo#ui<E+UE++oe?E|nt+Ouo+o|LN+iE+aueaoL?to#ocA*#aufNE+!oAatA#N+io<RoOauaaoa|*+LoYRoaeu!npCeE+!oc+uo+o|Lo||oYRooUuY+E+CoYuN+iE+ioEio#et|oE+Ao||oA#E|iou|tUaoiUo+e*a+oeco+<o+euRUonopCete|oe2uy>oL?oL#uu|o#et|oN+itoU*c|tLUt|ouo+o|LN+io+Co+Coa+uuau|o*A+oAuo||oA#tUa*>at+auo#ui<pCeE+!on<uo+o|Lo+ota|uaaoa|E+ioEiN+iE+ao>|oL#uu|*Ci*?CN+i*+OE|co||oA#tUa*>at+auo#ui<o+eoU+*A+oAupCeueaoL?to#ocA*#aufNuu|o##E|#tL+tLioe#N+iE+CE+ioL#uu|o<yoayo+ooYooEaoy+ociE||oayuAEoc|uo#ui<*>+u#eN+it+ouRLo+ooL|*o2uiAN+cueaE|ioEAou<*+coa|E+utLUE++tUao<yoayN+iE+uE+4E|foYa*?CN+UrCLo||oA#of|uL4E+it+OpCerCY
uc|uuyueitUauy>N+ito|ooao>|t|+E+io<RE+oooaE+UtUaoa#oc+N+i*+cE+Cu!Noeeo+#E|aoL#uu|oAfuLetUat?Aof|pCeo>|*|ouo+uL4o##t|oo+atUaoL#uu|uo+o|L*Ci*?CN+i*+Ouuatuao+auYNE+CE|coAioecpCe
*+Otoiuaat+-N+iE|foL?E+CE|cof|o#eo|#oa?tUa*?C*#eE+!u|UoL#oc|uYNpCeuea*<#o+uuLeE+Cu4iN+ioAiE+Ct+nto|ooataot-|*CaE+NoAeE+CE+ioy+ocioayo+Noe#E+CE+-to|ooaoAao#oo+eueEoeftUaoL#uu|*#ataoN+iE+!oieueaE+4E+Ao+ooL#tUaof|o#eo|#oa?oa#*+coieonEpCeu#iua|oe#oeuE+io|#oa?oEaoe#E+CoieN+it-Uta|*>!u#ooAyo+u*<ntLfN+io+Cooiue#uC?*|+uYNN+ionouaAuy>N+Uto|ooa*<-oy+ocio>iE|aN+i*<-oaLu#aE|fo>iE|aN+iE|AtUaoA-uLeoL#uu|uo+o|LpCeoN|*+y*iNoaa*>|N+i*+RoL?o+ooL#*<+te|tUao+2oCAoa4oA+N+it?AE|foa+uy>t+|oe#uC+oa?N+eu>ooaeE+eu|+N+eN+i*CiE+iuy>o+ooL#pCe
2015o||7uLe20uuNN+iE+!oc+u|Ou#ftLUE+R*||uYatUaoaLuYauLioeiE+!o+aN+iuYau#aoL?o#Ao|oE+etLiu+yo<Yt+at2OpCeuaaN+UAly Song/Reuters/*++o+uo+#oaA
oN|oYa*?CN+iE+Noeio+oo|#oa?*+yuLete|E+y*|euafN+iE+atA#oL?tLi*aurCL*c-o+#t<itUarCYoaLu#aoYato|ooaoAaE|a*|oN+i*Ci*c-o+#E+CE+-uLeo+N*|aE+ioe#E+eoiaN+itoU*c|E+Co|aoe?*+c*+R*UitUao+|on|pCeoEAuYNto|ooao<RoL?*|Uo+uon-onUN+ioN|E|fo##uaouaoo|+uL?E|apCe
uo+E+UoEeE+LtUato|ooaE+iE|iN+Uo#Aoiuoa?N+iuLioeit2OE+AoA+oo+tA! t2>E+ao-AN+UueaE+4oeUoeUuAEoe#tUao+eonUuieE+iuy>*c-oAauCotUau+yo<YuYaN+ioEAuYNuo+o|LoAio||oA#uLeo+eonUoEeE+LN+iua|ueeu+yo<YuYatUat+Ao-ito#E+e*CiE+iuA?o|+oc|oA+N+io#noa|uy>to?E+Lue|*|2pCeE+|E+CE|euo+o|LoAiE+UE+U*|#oL?E+C*|+N+ioA+oUUto|ooaue|*|2E|aN+f
oeyt2iE|iN+Uuo+o|LuLeuo+u#+*CaocAN+ito|ooao||oA#E+UE+UuLeooaE+Uoe-tceN+iueCE+NE+Cuiioi|oEepCe
uo+o|LE++*aUua|o>+ue+E+Ctoiuu#tUaue|*|2uu|o+ApCeuLCuu-taot-|oaLuYato|ooatUaE+oo<|E|iE+CpCUE+!oc+tn+toaoOou#-oEaE+L*CUo+euc+*>|*+cN+iE+NoeitUaoaLuYaue|*|2oa+uy>uo+o|LE++o>+pCUoCU*+co>|uANo+ooL#oaLE|oooUE+UE+UuYN*+c*iiN+iE+aue|*|2uoeuRLo+Co+CE+ioN+N+iuiNuLeE+iuU>E+yoe+tUaE+UE+UoA>*a+E+UE+No+eE+AtUaE++ua+occ*|!oaLE|oooUN+ite|*auoaLu#ao++o!E*|#N+ioaLu#aui+E+ioe#onUo#aoA#pCe
oeuE+|E+CE|eto|ooaoN+oaoN+fto|ooauy>*c-E+i*CiE+etUao+eoL|oiuN+it44E+Cu4i*<-oaLu#auLeoA>*a+t+o*+conoE+UE+UN+itc|uANo>|uANo+eoL|u|e*||*CaN+i*>Y*>!uYauc|o2ypCeu#-*CUo+eo+ouu|*>|E|aE+CoAN*>Yueaoi#*#ite|oe2u+#N+UrCLo<|o|!*UoE|oue+oia*|uE++oe|*<-oaLu#auLeE|atofE|otUa*c-to#N+i*Cito|o!Eooaoei*<-oaLu#auLeE|aE|nuyotUa*c-to#pCerCY
*+OtoirCLE|nuyotUa*c-to#rCYoAeE+otA#oL?E+nE+-o#eoYoN+UE+Cuu|oYoN+ito|ooaoaAuy>E+CuYi*+RuANofAo+eE+AoaLuYatUa*|a*<>o2yoCfoa4*+>N+iueeE++ua+E+ApCUooU*|?oN+tUao+NE+UooUoCU*+coaLuYaN+coAaE+Cuu|oYoN+iE|fE+|oaLE|oooUuAEE+cE|arCL*+cofArCYtUaoCUoUopCe*CioL#uu|uo+o|LoCUo++uLCuafoa|*|utUauy>*+OtoiE+e*iioCUoUorCorCoE|fo##uy>oaeE+oueeoaLE|oooUoiuoc|oA+pCeE+CE|coL#oi|oc|tA#E|aoYaoiuoaLE|oooU*c|o>itUarCLto|ooauYarCYN+io+ooAaE|aoa|E+uoL#uu|uo+o|LtUaoa|u|?E+AuoeE++N+it|+t|+o#Y*>oo+ooaNto|ooaN+io+iuLconioe|ueEoeft+Ao-ipCe

|o||oA#E+UE+UuYN*>|N+iE|fuLeo+|taetUaooaE+Uoe?oecpCeoe#2014o||oeioEAN+iofAo+eo+eoL|o+#*|iE|AoN#oAiN+ito|ooaoa4oA+*iNua|t+ot+!ooRoo+N+io##o+aoi+o+Cuiouu#tUato?ue+t+nN+i*CioaLuYau!uuy>E+Cteco#UuL-o+CoRatUa*oYu|+o+eoL|pCeu!nonuN+iE+UE+UE|foA>*a+oc|E|Auo+u#+*CaocAN+io>+u#eE+Aoc+o<|ueytoNE+YuiUE+C*c|N+iuuo*|UoA#N+iE|fo#otA#E+Auo+t!uoEiooatUaoo+uCUpCe

*+yuLeE+Coa?oeaoAfocaN+ioA>*a+E+AE+UE+Uua|o#otA#tn+E+U*|uE++N+eCSRN+eueuoaaoa?tUarCLuaauCCrCYuLeoa|pCe*O+ta|oEAuYNE+io#aoaLuYato|ooaoi|tc<o||E+it<uueEoefN+iuLeE||ue|*>a*+OE+i*+cuy>o||oA#E+UE+UrCL*+ao-4oLeoL#rCYrCorCoE+Nto|ooaE+|oEiE|eoAuoL#uu|*|au|EN+iua|uL4uuauaAtLfu!uu+#*CooaLuYao+eoL|pCeE+a*+OtoitLiu|oE+Aueao+ouu|tUao<RoL#*oeo>fo||E+iE+C*c|pCe
ueaoL?*#ataoE+!tLioe#N+io||oA#u|+o-+oaLuYatUaof|o#eoayo+NuO<oUioYRo++ueooaNN+ioA>E+N*>|uy>rCLo+i*iCu+iu+irCYpCeE+uE+4o+eonUE||oAfuL4oL?ofAo+eo+NE+LN+itofu|+E|foL?ofAo+eN+it+ouRLE+|E|auA?oaLuYato|ooaN+io++o||o-+uYaN+iuYiE+|*e#*iapCUo+NE+Lt|UociN+ioi|E+Yta|ua+uaAoYUuiUpCeueaoi#*#io+eu+#N+iuLeE+-o||*++oayo+N*>|N+iE+uE|fuy>oaLuYaoc|uYNtUaN+io#Auu|oCOE|fuy>oEa*aurCLo|+o+aoearCY*+Otoio##o>?u|ioYooo+onotUaN+itA#oL?t+eE|AuLeuL|E+UoUUte|o<RE|ipCeE+A*+OE|ct+a*eeoA>E+NtLioc|N+io+ouu|o+eonUE||uy>o+a*auta!uaaE+AE++oa+uafueooaNoa|E+!tUaN+ioA-uy>oaLuYatUauYiE+|ti<o<Ron-oniuYepCUon-oU+oUUpCe
u!uuy>oL?*+Otoiuaaoa|E+iN+iuo+o|LE+Ao||oA#E+UE+Uo+CooioL?to|ooaue|*|2*+OE+Cooaoffo#oo+CoEeE+LpCe

E+ao-AN+Uoeuoa+E+ouYN*>|uo+E+UoaeE+ooEeE+LN+iueeto|ooaE+iu#eoe#o|+onotUaE+!oc+oaLuYaoaoN+f

oeyt2iE|iN+U*+OE+-u?io+AoEAuYNoa|o<RoAyoiuoYRo++onUN+iE+ioEioL#uu|pCUE+ioEiE+UE+UtUaoUUu|ooa+E+ion-E+Cua+pCeE+Nueau>o*+atafueetUaoy+ocio+|o+|E+|E+iN+iE+uE+4o+ouu|uA?oc|E|aE+CE+-oA2rCLoiaoA+E+cuYarCYtUaoaLuYato|ooa*<ioeAN+ioAf*<ioeAuy>oL?E+!oc+tUaE+CoiaE+-oA+pCUoa#*<ioiUE+cE+-*iiuo+uYao+ooaNto|ooapCeuLCuu-*+OE+-oi|tc<tUa1.0teeuL4uy>oAeo>|oaLuYatUao#Aoiuoa?N+it+OE+uE+4E+c*|oN+i*<-o#Aoiuoa?*CUuY+oi|E++o+<o+OoiuE+CE|cu+yo<YE+etUaooaooUpCe
E+Co+Cooi*+OE+-*<+ua|ui|oEetEatUapCeo#Aoiuoa?uL4uYNo##ueAua|o+ooL#N+iuYau#ao||o++E|foa+E+UoA+oeuociE|#E+L*N+N+ioy+oci*oeo+uoA>E+Nueeto|ooa*c-ta|o+a*+cuYaocipCeE+ao+eo+2o##oAatA#uLeou<ooyN+Uo#Aoiuoa?uL4uYNo##uLe*c-o+#tUatofuaAN+ioaeuRLoaio+<u+yo<Yoiu*|oN+it!eE|AE+U*+f*c-o+#tUaooaooUt2RE|epCe*O+ta|oiuu+yo<YtUa*|o*a+ui+E+uocaN+iE+aoeut4ouo|oaNE+i*oUo+uu>o*c-o+#oiuE+L*N+uYNo+uonUN+iE|a*CiE|aE|i*+OtoioEeE+Lu?io+Ao##uA?E+iE+ioA+E|apCe
2021o||11uLe3uuNN+iE+!oc+u#|oiutLUoe>oa+o+eN+iuYau#ao#aooaooUtUaua+ooUo+aoe#to|o!EooaoeiuLioeit2OpCeuaaN+UHao Qunying/Costfoto/Future Publishing via Getty Images
uANE+iuYNo##*+coaNE|at44E|iE+-teeuL4N+iE|fo##uy>ueao+ouu|taot-|tUau?io+AN+Uo+ooe#uYaocioc|oA+tUaonoo!atofN+iueu*Cau>o*+auLeuucoiutUao||*++E||*+oE|ioecE+UN+iuYNt+A*ENto|ooauLioeit2OpCe*+OE|cE||oLC*aUt+A*+ct!coCeN+iE+iE+auLe*a+oecN+i*+yuceo+uo+ooL#uu|*?CpCUtafueeuYaociuaaoa|N+iE|fuc|o<|uyooAuo+uuYau#atUaE+iE++pCeo>|o+eonUoL?onuueoo+NtUao||*++E||uYN*>|N+i*a+uLeuL|E+UocRo<|oAao#oN+i*+y*a+oO-oL?te|u>i*|2*+|N+ioE+o+ooecuy>*c<onotUapCe
*+OE|cuLioeit2OE+UuLet+fE+CtUa*uaE+<N+itLi*|+uYNoaAE+-u!uo+AtUao|uoYopCeE+aE+aE+C*+coA+o##E+UoAatA#N+io<aoa|o<RE+ioaA*|ao+eN+iocioYou#iE+CE|eo<RE+oooaooUpCeoA-uLeE+CoA#to|*aapCUE+CE+-onoo#Ao|oN+io||*++E||o##oaArCLE+u*|!oayrCYN+io+<uYau#aE+et+aoCeE+L*N+N+iueuo+<E+uE+4uee*c-o<|tUaE|oooUoiuoc|oA+pCeoeuuu|oCOto+oe?uo>E+y*+yE+iuO<oAeN+iuYau#aE+ito?*c-o+#oL?t|+E+eE+yu4+N+itc|uANui+tA#ocaoe#uLioeit2OE|#E+L*N+pCUue+oA#o##*iiE|apCe
E+a*+OE+-u?io+AoEAuYNE|fu#iuAaon-E|aN+iE++*aU*+yuy>ocaE+|ooCocAon-o#AN+io||*++E||oYaE+uoca*|UtUaoA#ua|uL4E+ionftofu|+N+iE+ioaeonuoc|ueoo+NuYNo+uoA#onUpCe*CiE+ooaLuYatUau|e*||E|aua>E+ioaAofAo+eoeuE|eo+2of|oa+o+u*|+uYNN+io+eoL|tLftUauy>*aU*e#o+eoo+uu|ou|uaouaoo+|t2itUapCe
oEAuYNoy+ocioAe*>oE|aE+CE+-3.0teeuL4N+iua|*<-*+OE|cuLioeit2OtUa*+E*EN*CaE+ioA-oYaoiu*|oui+E+uocaN+i*Ciuy>oAyueEo#AoRioecE+U*CaN+iu>ooaeoeaoUUte-u|UoaioCUpCUo<|to|t+|E+<*+OtoioOaoeauLioeiN+io+iuLc*a+ooRoeaE+uE+4tUauo|oaNpCeE+ao<RoOaE+e*+yuy>*|UE+ioe#E+CE|eoA#N+i*oau?iE|fu#i*|+uYNpCe
ueCE+N*+OE|coaLuYato|ooaoi|tc<oEAuYNonUuo#oa+uaouao*EAt+-E|aN+iuLeE|ctoU*c|*o2taiuAepCeua|uL4oAfocauy>N+U*+OE+-ooaoffoLC*aUoo+uLfueooaNuei*a+*oUuoeN+iE+auo+o|LoAio||oA#uO<oUio+iuLctf!uLfoaaoc|ueEuRLpCe*CioaLuYaoL?uA?o|+to|ooapCUte|oe2uy>oaLE|oooUE+e*iiuu|oYoN+iuL4*|2o##uLeo+eonUtA#o<RoULtoiN+itf!uLfoaao+eoU+*oUuoepCe

E+ao-AN+UE+aoL?E|aE+!uAEoe#N+ito|ooaE+iu#eoe#o>|oaLuYaN+io>|u|e*||t2>tUao+<oe-u>otofE|ot2>onopCeE+|E+CE|eE+UuLe*+OtoitA#*#iN+f

oeyt2iE|iN+Uoauoae*aU*>|N+iu|e*||t2>o+ota|E|fo+eoci*aUpCeu|e*||uL4*|2uy>E+Ctoiof|uL4E||uYapCeE+aoL?oaLuYaN+iuo|oaNuL4o##E+io2yN+iooaooUooUt#+o#apCUE++ua+o2yN+i*+yoaauuN*auoUcoaAE+-oeuE|oooUN+iocau!nuo|ouaoaLuYatUau|e*||uYiE+|ti<o<RuLeoa|uaAE|epCe
E+i*+cN+iuA?oe?oaLE|oooUE+e*iiti<o<RoYRo++oc#oU+pCeo+ouu|uo+o|LoAio||oA#tUaua|u|oN+iuy>o+iuLcoCU*+crCLE|#rCYuYNo+aoe?rCLoiurCYrCorCoE|fo##uy>*<-oaLu#aoaeE|aua>oL?t+aE+e*|!te-N+i*+c*Ciof|oa+E+uE+4E++to?to|ooaoiuE+L*N+tUauaAua+pCeueaE+4o+ouu|E|ftLioe#E+CE|coaLE|oooUE+UE+U*>ooc+oCA*+cto|ooaooCoo<N+iE+ao<R*+|E+iuYNoAatA#oc#oU+ociocipCe
t44E+CN+i*+OE+AoaLuYatUaE||oAut+ouRauLeoa|pCeonoo<|oa+tfNoUoN+ito|ooaoecE+UtUaE++oecuy>o||*++E||N+i*CiE+!oc+*<+onUoaLuYaoa+uy>rCLt-|o+auYarCYN+ioA-oe-*CUE||oAio#Ao!-toOoL?uYaociN+io||*++E||onUuo#oL?onuueoo+NpCe
t44E|iN+ioeOE+AoaLE|oooUuL4*|2tUate|uCouLeoa|pCeoaLE|oooUE+ioaA*iuuLit!eo+NE+UooUoeuE|eo<|uyouacocaoiuN+iE+iE+auyo*aEoU+*+EN+i*CiE+oooU*|?o+<o+eonopCeE+CE+|*iuuLioA>E+NoCA*+ctc|uA!ueuoc+tec*<-u|e*||*Caono*c|E|a*ouN+iE+aE+ao+eoU+oA-oYaoc+tecoenuu!E+CE+-*N+toLtoLE+itoLN+iocau!no##oLC*aUo+ooaNE+CoNu*>at|ouL|oe|pCe
oy+ocio+|o+|oEAuYNE|foUU*+cE+CE|co<Ro-iN+iu>ooaeuA?oe?u|>u|EuL|oe|pCUo+|t2iuacocaoiuoAiooU*|?*<n*>UE+ot|+N+iE+a*+OE|cuL|oe|oEAuYNuy>oEatLfu!u*E+oL#N+iueaE+ion-u+auNUpCeE+Aoa|oCU*+coy+ocipCUE|4E+LoUUoa?oc+o+eoL|N+iE+CE|coaLE|oooUto|ooauy>E++to?uc|rCLtf!oo+rCYtUau?io+AN+UofAo+e*+aoaetUaoaLu#aE+U*c-o+#o+|o+<E+it+nN+ioUUoa?*+|tn+oi|tUatofuaAN+ioYatafE||t+at+LE+AocioniE|nuyouYNo+|t2iE+iE++pCeo>|oaLE|oooUuYN*>|N+i*+Otoiuu|o+AoA>*a+uc|E+|oA>*iipCe
2025o||6uLe26uuNN+iE+!oc+o##E+LtLUtafoA#o+e*o4*A#oi|tUaoaLuYaui>oa|oeRoa4o<nN+irCLo<RuoioRitc|uA!*<!t+a*ENrCYtUaoAeE+A*Cao!aE|aE++to?ueiuL|tc|uA!ooCoo<*o4*ALpCeuaaN+UAdek Berry/AFP via Getty Images
tA#oL?tUaoaLE|oooUtc|uA!ti<o<RE|f*a+*|+oe#E+CE|co+<oe-E+Lto?N+iE+auC+E+o*Ci*?CN+ioaLE|oooU*aUoUUto|ooaN+iE+ita|u>oo+NE+UooUoU+o+uonUpCe

E+ao-AN+UoL?uA?oe?to|ooaE+iu#etUauu|oCON+iueatLioe#E|aocioYoE|foaOoe#N+io+eonUuYao|#oa?*aUoe#u+yo<Yonoo!aE+eo!aN+iE+aE|foUAocooAeE+AE|apCeo+eo#aE+!oc+tUao<yoayoe#toUE||E+UE+UuANoAuof|*<!N+ioeuuu|oCOtUauaao+ouy>uCAua+tUaN+f

oeyt2iE|iN+Uuy>tUaN+i*+OE+-tA#*#io+ouu|*<-ueao>|E+!oc+tUauo+ooaoa|t|+E|otofE|auRUonotUaoa#oc+pCeoL?E+!oc+N+ito#u#a*ENE+UE+Uono*oau?it+at+cuo+o|Lo<yoayoAeoeaof|*<!N+iuL4o##uRUE+|t+o*oUN+itoU*c|oA>E+N*>|oeiueCuL-uLepCeE+aoL?2010o||E+uE+!uLfN+ioaAoy+ocio+|o+|pCUE|4E+L*+Ot#+o||oA#E+UE+Uoi|E++oe?o+C*<+E|aueC*#otUarCLoA+oo+tA!rCYN+iE+oou?oEaoL#uu|o<yoay*<#uAeto|o!EooaoeitUatfN*>aE+Ao<R*+|t+Ao-ipCeE+aoL?E+ioe#E+no||tUauu|ou|ociN+e2014o||12uLe*c|2016o||5uLeN+eN+ioy+ocio+|o+|tUau+yo<Yonoo!ao##E+|2180E+ioL#uu|o|#oa?uAEE+cE|aof|*<!N+io!aoayonUuYN*c-oA+t|ouo+o|LN+iE|fuLeoa?oeauYN*c-oL#o+et|ooioE+iN+ioa|E+!*|a*+cE+CoieuiaE++oe>oA+t|ooAeE+NE+e*UioeipCe
rCLoA+oo+tA!rCYtUaoc|tA#uLeoa|o<A*oe*aiuO>pCeo++uu|to|ooa*o2*oaE+|E+!oc+t+Au|AtUauu#E|<te|N+iE|foA>*a+uy>o+aoe?oL#uu|t+Au|A*+4oRitUauu#ueoueipCe2008o||oca*Rioi#uL|E|ioEAN+ioc|oAuoAuoy+pCUueo*|auo+t+opCUGDPooRoCfE+iu+aN+iuo|E+ot+Au|Au#coc|*|iE|AE+Yo<epCeoL?*+Otoiuaaoa|E+iN+ito|ooaueEE+|o#auo#E+ioa+ooRoo+u+LoectUaooaoffN+ioL#uu|uo+o|Lt|+t|+o+Cooioa|u|?N+iE+ato#E|At+|E|Aoa+E+ot+Ao-iE+Auo+t!uo+Noa+N+io>|oaeE+oue|uiUpCUoaeE+ooe|o<Uoe|o|auCoo<euAAuafoe#uuaE+AE+iueipCe
oAaE+Cuu|oYoN+io||oA#E+UE+UuAiuAi*auu|UocApCUto?ue+uo#ui<pCUuo>E+yE+Ate-u|Ut!eua+o+a*|au|EN+ioL#uu|uo+o|Lo+iuLc*a+oCfoe-*+OE|co||oA#N+io+<oe-uL4oL#oaLE|oooUrCL*|#oc|oA+rCYpCe*+OtoioL|uO>ufEtoit?io|aE+eooa*aaE|aueaE+4o>|E+!oc+E+at+fuo+ooaoa|t|+tUaua|oaArCorCoo||oA#o>|oL#uu|uo+o|Lo#otA#oc|o+|oe+tUa*<<E++*a+oecN+i*CirCLoA+oo+tA!rCYu!uuy>*+OtoiuYaoect+ouRaoAyoiutUaoa+E+oE+otA#pCe
ueauc+uuUoE4*+cE+Cu4ioy+ocit+at+ctUaE+eon-oA+oo+tA!N+ioi#*#ioYRo++u+#oe+pCeuo|E+-of|*<!oaau+iu|ooAUtUarCLE|A*Uot+aoa|oUorCYpCet44E+Con-o##E+Aoa+oRitUaE|A*Uot+ata|oa#ocoo+|o+CooirCorCoueCuLeo<yoay*o2oUAuL|ue+t!+oeat+aN+it+aueEE|ioEAE+eon-tUao!aE|ao#At+apCeoy+oci*ouoce*>|N+ioaeuRL*<-E+uE+4*c-*iioeat+aN+io<yoayE+4E+Co<UE+Uuiet|ooe2*c-oe?*UUocaN+irCLooao>+E+CuiipCUE+io#RE+CuiirCYN+ioy|o#eouUoRAoU+E+Nueota|pCeu|+oe?E+!toU*c|*<+*<iE|aoa?E+oueite|ueit2O*|+uYNoo#u!itUauiNu<|N+itc<tUao##uy>*<-onoo<|uUeuu|uo+E+i*|2E++N+i*+coaNE+CtoioA+oy|t|ooiupCUo+|*#aoEeE+LtUaE|A*Uot+auucoiu*>!ooapCe
o+ouu|oy+oci*+yu|U*iiE+CtoioEiE+|rCLoCAt2iuucoiurCYtUaE+UE+UuucoiurCorCoui<*>|u>AE+iuu#*+cu+yo<Yoayo+Noa+*aUoL?E+eE+-uLeoaao!aE+UoYaooOoCAt2iN+iocaE+|rCLuioE+-*oAo|atLiE+utoirCYpCeuLeE||oeaE|2*+cE+Co+ataotecN+UE+CE+ioL#uu|o<yoayoL?*>+t?iE+!E|fo#Y*>oE|aoCAt2iN+io||E+oueEoefE|apCeE+i*+cocaE+|E+utUaE+e*iuu#iueA*+c*uno!EN+ioCAt2iuu|*iuuLio+CE+iu+apCU*eUo!EoL#oc|uYNN+itaotecocit2OE+uuuU*+|tUaoEiE|iu!uoL?o+<E+uuee*iuuLio+CE+euAEpCe*+OE+Co|oueota|E|aueao>|o<yoL|uucoiutUaoe+uY+oi#*#irCorCoo+ouu|tUau#ou#ctLftUaoYRo++o+Cuo+N+iE|f*<-ueauaA*>aoe#N+io||oA#E+AoL#uu|uo+o|LtUaE|Aoe?*+coaNE|aE+CtoioeiueCuL-uLetUate|uCUpCe*+OE|ct+AoAaE|fE+aE++ueao+CooiuCY*Cao||tEa*<|oiuE+!oc+uo+ooaE|Aoe?tUaoAyoiuN+ite|oe2uy>oL?uo#E+io||oA#uu|E+utUaoe|o|a*+4oRi*aiuO>E+ipCe

E+ao-AN+Uoeut+OoA+oo+uAe*>+tUaoa+uy>E+CE|eE||N+fuoOE|aE+CE|eoaoN+f oeyt2iE|iN+UuAe*>+*CauLeE|cuy>oy+ocio+|o+|tUao2yt<iN+iuLeE|cuy>to|ooaoiuo<|pCU*iiE+UE+oo<|ueuo!a*CaN+iE|fuLeE|cuy>uYN*c-to|ooaoAa*++oL#oi|tUaoL#uu|o<yoayE+it+iueEoeft+Ao-ipCe*>+t?ioaao<|u||tcuto|ooa*iiE+UtUaoAao#o*|ioe+N+iE|foiaui4uico>+oL#uu|uo+o|LoaeE+oo<iouaoaioNuuo+t!upCUoe|o<U*iiE+U*oaoeOt!epCeoa?oea*>+t?i*+yo<euAAo<RoL#*Cao>fN+ioeio+Cu|Ou#ftLUoaato|ooaoAao#o*+aoN+tUaoL#oi|N+iE+Ao+ooL#to|ooaE+UE+Uu+#oaNE|nu|UpCe

2015o||12uLe29uuNN+iE+!oc+uY!o+Roy+ocio+|o+|uC+oa?N+ioa?oc+*+a500E+-oA+tUaoA+oo+oAeoeau+yo<Yonoo!ato|o!EooaoeitA!E+Coa?o||u|+oe?pCeuaaN+UVisual China Group/Getty Images
E+auua*<|*+OE|c*<#o+euYN*c-E+CE|e*aiuO>N+iuLeE+CE+-oYRo++o#LuyAtUaoa#oEite|N+UE+uE+4oa+o+eo+|*#ao+eoL|E++o>+pCUuo+o|LE+i*+co|ao|#ooatUatEao+|pCe
ueaoi#*#io+eu+#N+iuLeE+CE+i*<#o+euicoc|N+i*+coA+uo+o|LtUaue|uiUuu|o+Ao++o++o!yoL?ou<ooyrCorCooA-*autL+E|Aue|uiUo#auo#o+Oon|E+UE+UN+ioi|o++toNE|auc|o|+u|ctUaof|o#eoecocApCe*Cito|ooatUate|te|uU#uU#oL?E|AN+io<auy>ueAua|E|AE||u#at+nE+utUaN+ioYatUauy>oiaoiaE+cE+co#Aooao<|tUa*c-oAa*iioe?pCeuo+o|LE+io<Ltc|uANE+ioaNt+A*ENN+i*Cio|o*>N*+4oEaoUUE+nE+|uc|oa+oo+*+LuaAE|etUaE|iN+U
t44E+CN+iuy>rCLuY+oLfounrCYN+U*ENoCao<+uY+tUauo+t!utA>ooaN+ioecoCauLeoe-tUa*ea*<|u#coc|N+i*<-*CUtO+oootc+E+ito|ooauy>oA>*iitUapCUuLeoeiuO>tUaN+ct44E|iN+iuy>rCLuE!*eRoA#rCYN+UoAeo>|*<+*<ipCUE+ooe?t!euL4oL#to|ooat44E+euu|uLioeiooaN+it+OE|eoCeo|atUauo+t!uuo>uiUN+iue<u+orCLoc!E+UrCYtUa*oA*e#N+i*CiE+iuy>tc|uANE+ioL|t+A*ENpCe
t<C*Ci*?CE|iN+io##uy>ueeoLfounuY+oN+N+i*<-u>AE+-E||ua+uaAuYNtoiN+i*CiE+iuy>*oao<Uonoo<|*>NtoiE+CE|eN+coU+oai*+co|ao|#ooaN+io<RtA#uo+o|LrCLo+oo>+*CiE+iE++o>+rCYpCe
*+O*<-ueaoiUoeauae*<|N+iE|fu+#uafuaAonupCeo>|onUuo#E||uYN*>|N+ioiaui4uc+t+AtUauea*c-o+#N+ioa+o+y*<noL?E+!oc+tUauo+u#+*>!ooaE+!N+io|o*>Nuy>uo+o|Loae*>eE+UE+U*>NuCAE|eoUUN+i*CiE+iuy>E+UE+Uoae*>euo+o|Lo|o*>NoaeE+ooe|o<Uuo+t!upCeuLCoci*aUtUauy>N+i*+OE|coA+oo+tA!E+AuYNE+iuy>toyo>a*+c*iitUapCeo<aE+4o<ioa?oa4o+CN+io+ouu|*+yuLeonoocAo-AE+oueNo>+N+iE+ao+ouu|u#iuLeE||*oeo+uuLeE+CE|euo+u#+E+etUauoAuafueuE|e*<<pCe*+OE|f*>|uyAto|ooauLC*o4oiatUauu|uLfN+iuU#uU#E|fuy>uo+E+UE|nu|UuLCE+|ooat|UpCUtcat<itA>ooaE|fuLCE+|o<+uY+tUauu|E+urCorCo*+Ouy>E+CE+-oYRo++uLe*|utUaoAaoA#t-uoAuuLfpCe
o+|oe|onuoiaN+Uto|ooaueooCatUaoc+oaa*+Lt?iE|nuyo t2>E+ao-AN+UoL?E+atLioe#to|ooatUaoL?oL#uaaoa|oEAN+iE+aoaeE+oo+uoc|E+CE+-uc|onotUaoa|E|AE+!oc+uo+ooaoa|t|+tUat+o*<|N+f
oeyt2iE|iN+Uuo|E+-taot-|tUat-Uta|N+iuy>E+AueauaA*>aoe#*c-o+#uERooOE|aoeuE+Coe+o+CooitUarCorCoueaoAatA#N+i*c-o+#uLCoeY*<+*<itUataot-|ou<ooyo<ioa?*+aoUAE|apCe
ueaE+Co+Cooiuy>E+AoYRo++E+at+ftUa*oAo|auYNtEa*ouE+!oc+t+Au|AN+i*<nE+|E+!oc+uy>E+CE+-t+Au|AoeauYaE+ooe|N+ioL#uu|uo+o|LoL?t+Au|AE|ioeiE+euLeo+eonotUaoAa*?CuYapCeof|E|A*+OE+-tEa*ouN+iueatEaueCo+ota|oL#uA?*<|N+Uuuota|to|ooaoAao#oo+u*+OE|eo+2N+ioeu*aioEAE+Co<Uo#aE+iE|aoL#uu|uo+o|LtUaE|oE+Uuo+t!uuo>uiUN+iu>ooaet+OoA#pCUt+OoL#pCUt+O*|au|EpCeueCE+NN+iueauLCoeYtUataot-|ou<ooyo##uy>N+UrCLoL#uu|uo+o|Luy>uCAE|eue|uiUto|ooatUaN+frCY
E+a*+coaNto#ocAE|ioEAN+iueaueioAatA#N+i*<+onUoL#uu|uo+o|LE+Ato|ooaE+UE+UE|iou|tUaoa|t|+oa|o<RoYRo++t?C*uapCeto|ooatUaoAao#oo||E+iuy>uo+o|Loe+uaAue|uiUtUat+ouRLpCeo+eonUuu|oCOto|ooaoiuo<|uy>oe+uaAoU+o+Cuo+o|LtUaN+i*Ciuo+o|LE|fE+YuiUE+CtoirCLtfNoUoE+aoL?N+iE+aueaE+it<iE+arCYtUauo+E++te|uCUpCe*+O*<-ueao+ouu|oYRo++taa*OaN+iE+NE+|uy>*c-o+#*#aufNoUUo+uE+ionfE+ot+aN+iueiu#ioAatA#o|o*>No!yoL?tUauo+ooa*+Rt+opCe
ueao+a*au*+OE+-oc#uaaoA+ue+ueao>+o+eue|uaotAiN+eJean OiN+e*<?*<|pCeoN|tUaE+u*i?E+LrCLoL#uu|u|oocoE++E|erCYo+|*#atUauy>N+UE+!oc+oL#uu|uo+o|Lo##oaAE+Co<|onoE+UE+UtUaoL#uu|oeaoa4oA+N+io<yoayoic*+UoAit+Au|A*i?tA#t+aoL?E+C*|+N+io+ota|E+Uto>uRUE+ioaNE|oE+UoAao#opCeE+aoN|oAi*CiuAEoaAueaN+UoaeuRLE+aoAatA#oL#uu|uo+o|LoL?ue|uiUto|ooaN+ioeuueiuy>ooauuOE|iE+!tUat+ouRLN+itEa*<|E+eu#iE+CE|euu#uaApCetLfu!uoC+o+u*++ou<tUaN+iuU#uU#uy>*+OocitUarCLt+|E|AE|Aoe?rCYN+elack of interactionN+erCorCoE+|E+CE|eto|ooaoL?u#iuLeoL#uu|uo+o|L*|au|EoAiuo>uiUtUauaaoa|E+iN+ioAi*Ci*a+*o4oiaoAao#oN+f
oEAuYNueaoCEu+EuaA*>aoe#N+i*+Ouy>ocaE+|uo#E+io||oA#oL?ufEtoit?io|aE+eN+ioAuE+uE|aoL#uu|uo+o|LoAfuL4uAEE+ctUaoef*a+pCeoAiE+at+fo<RE+oooaE+UE+ioEiN+ito|ooao+CE+-o||oA#o+EoA+o##*a+oiu*|oN+iE+ioLC*aUto|*>+ueotaoN+iE|fE+ioLC*aUo|uoYoN+i*|aocaocRt4+o+2N+io>|oLfoL#oAi*|+u4+tUaE+Y*|uE|fo+eE+ApCeuc|oci*aUtUauy>N+ioCA*+co||oA#N+io#Aooao<|oA>E+Ntc|uANueeE+L*N+oiuoe#oa?oc+N+iueota|E|aoL#uu|o+eoL|tUa*+|toipCeE+uE+4ua|uL4E+iuCAE|eoLC*aUoL#uu|*|au|EN+i*c-ta|E|fE+ion-oAioL#uu|uo+o|LueoE|noUopCe
*+O*<-ueao+Cooi*oeo>foe#t44E|iE+-o+eoci*aUtUatA#*#iN+Uo||oA#E+ioA-uy>ooaE+UE+!E+iN+io<aoa|o<RE|foL?ue+uiaufEtoioe|o|ao+|*<+tUaoef*a+N+ioa+uLeufEtoirCLoieoa4oa#uCo*|?rCYpCe
2020o||11uLe11uuNN+iE+!oc+oiuE|4N+ito|o!Eooa*|+o+?on|E|4E+Loa4oA+uC+oa?onooAaN+ioayo+NoL?oAe*oeu|+oe?E+auU>uLfou|uaaoo+oe+uiitaoN+io|atNYoaeuui*eepCeuaaN+UKevin Frayer/Getty Images
ueaoL?*<+*#eE+!oAatA#N+i*O+ta|*+OE|co||oA#uy>toU*ENE+UE+UN+iE+aonatEatUao+eonUou<ooyN+ioa|o<Ruy>*+coA+to#uo+o|L*|f*|utUarCorCoE+ioaeuCAE|e*oa*iao+eoL|pCUo+|t2iE+iE++pCeto|ooao||oA#uLeE||tc|uAN*+fuea*>|N+iE+uE+4oYoo>|tUat|+E+eo+eoL|u#+tEauiaueyN+i*+fo<yoayu#+tEat|+E+io+eoL|tUaoU+ooyoa|o<Ro+<E+ionUpCeE+|E|ao|oo>|*+OE|cuiaueyN+io||oA#*+yE+U*>+o!a*CauYNE+e*>+N+io!aE|aE+!oc+uo+o|LtUat+Au|Auo|oY-t+Ao-iN+ioaiuee*+OE|ct+Ao-i*+4oiuE+|o||oA#tUaoe|o|a*<+*<ipCe
E+Noeio++uLeo!a*Ca*>|E+!oc+uo+o|LoaAE+UE+UN+iE+aueaoAi*Ci*oeo+uN+itA#oL?uLeE|cE+UE+U*|euYN*|eoaAuo+o|LpCe*CiE+oueaoAatA#N+io||oA#oAioEat|ouo+o|LE|iou|tUaoEeE+LoYRo++ooat|UN+ioEeE+Loaao<|E+ioA-uy>oL?ueo*iio#eoYoN+i*+yoiaui4oe|o|a*<+*<ipCUueou|ooiAE+LN+itoU*c|E+UE+C*|+*<?*<|*oaoeOuCAE|e*<opCe*+OoAiuea*+coA+ua|oaAE+!rCLE+UE+UoA-uy>*o2oe?uANoAuuo+o|Loa+E+nrCYtUaoc+oaAo<ioa?E+iE+Cua+pCe
E+A*+OociueaE|fuaouaotEa*ouoe#N+ito|ooatUaoAao#oE+iuy>oecuu!E|auo+ooaoa|t|+N+i*Ciuy>ocit+aE|ao<apCeuo+ooaoa|t|+oAyo+uocaE+!oiurCorCoE+Aoeiuy>uuauo#o#Aooaue+oAioL#uu|uo+o|Loeaon|ueoE|noUoN+itA#oL?uy>o||oA#E+u*i?uo|E+-E+ot|+N+ioA+oAiuo+o|L*#eN+iE|foL?ufEE|cuu|oYoN+i*+yo+<uo+o|Ltcat<i*+OE|co#Aooaue+pCe
*+Oo##o+ooc|E|at44E+eE+-*<-ueaoi#*#ite|oe2u+#tUatA#*#iN+Uo||oA#o>|oL#uu|uo+o|Lo#otA#oc|oYRo++o+|tUa*<<E++*a+oecpCetoU*c|uLeo<yoaytoUE+io>|uea*>|N+UrCL*+OE|co||oA#tLftUao+eo+|oe+pCerCY
o##oaAueaoL?E|aocioaOtUaN+io+oo||oA#*aU*+coaNE+CE+-oL#uu|o+Co#ooi|tc<uu|N+io+Co+CE+UoaeoAioL#uu|uo+o|L*#eoN+uYiE+|pCeE+NoaLuYau+yo<YE+|E+iN+ioy+ociE+U*aUu#eoL#uu|uo+o|LueEt2iE+oou?tUaooao>+o#At+aN+io>|uANE||*+yo+aoi+uy>oA+ocitUaE+CueeueiN+c*CiE+ooL?oi|tc<u!uo+A*E+oL#oeiN+ioA+uo+o|Lo##*aUocaoncoN+oLfoL#pCU*|aocaoAio<uE+a*|au|EpCe

|o||oA#uYN*>|N+i*+Oua+tUaoeiuLfoiAooauy>E+YoUL*E+oL#uoeuRLtUao+a*aUueiu<|rCorCoocaE+|*+coA+o##uLeocaE+|oaioNuE+ioe#E+io>+*c|oEeE+Lon#*|NtUauieE+ipCeE+aE+AueatUa*oeo>fuYNtLiN+i*+OtoiE|Aoe?uc|oaAuy>E+CoL|o>|t!etUaooaE+U*#eoenN+i*CiE+iuy>E+at+foeutoirCLE+UE+UE+YoOauo+o|LrCYtUao|cuenoa|t|+pCe

*Ci*+Otoio>|t!eoL#E+iN+io+eonot?io|aE+eE|foAio||oA#*|aE|otUarCL*OUuifuCorCYoAirCLu|Uoe?uCorCYN+easset mobilityN+euLeoa|pCeo<aE+ioaAue+oL#E|o*+Otoi*o2ooUo<UoL?uL4oL#tUaE|oE+UN+i*Ciuy>uLeo+eo+|tUarCLoCCoc|*a+oecrCYpCeoA-*aUoL?E+CE+-oL#uu|*#eE+iuioN+io<ao<ioa?oA>E+N*+4oA+oe2tUaofAo+et+ot+!uA?pCeE|fu!uocaE+|oaeu!nN+io||oA#oL?oAioL#uu|uo+o|L*#eoenuu|N+io+Co+Coiaui<tc+o>|E+yoe+pCe
E+i*+cN+ioC+o+uu|?uaAtUauy>o||oA#tUao+|oe+E++*aUoAatofoL?oL#uu|o#et|opCeo||oA#*O+ta|oL?oL#uu|uLeo+eo+|tUa*<<E++*a+oecN+iE+aoL?E+!on<o#et|oN+iE+ita|o2yo|aE+Y*|uuo+o|LtUauo>uiUE+AuAeuYapCeu>ot2fN+ioL#uu|uo+o|LuLeo+eonUE+-N+iE+!on<uo+o|LoA-uLeE+CE+-pCeuua*<|uy>oL?uo#ui<u#+tEapCUt?Auo|o<euAApCUoca*Ritcat<iN+i*+yuy>*+?ooaE|nuyot!euo+t!uooaoffN+iE+!on<uo+o|LuAiuAi*auuLCt+etUauYaoecuYauYapCeo>|o||oA#E+UE+UuYN*>|N+ioAuo+uE+!on<tUatEa*ouE+Ao+y*<+N+iuy>o<aE+4o+uE+No!yt+!E+Aue-o+atUaoeiuAEpCe*+OE|fE++o+uo||oA#E+UE+U*a+ueEE+|E+!on<uo+o|LoOnE|aoL#uu|uo+u#+E|ionutUaE+CE+-tcat<iueoueiN+iE|foL?ufEtoit?io|aE+eocioiaE|aon<oL#oa|t|+tUauYaoecoeao+apCe

E+ao-AN+Uu+yo<Yt!eto|ooauLCoAeo<|tUaoe|o|ao+|*<+E|f*<+uy>ueooCaoc+oaa*+Lt?iE|nuyoN+io+|t2ioc+oaat|+E+eonoo+eoL|pCeE+aoOitofE||tUa*+Lt?iE|nuyoE+AuYNoYRo++oc#oU+pCeoeuu+yo<Yuy>uCAua+o+|t2iE+CoNuE+a*+cE|nuyotUaE+iE++oe|o|aN+f

oeyt2iE|iN+Uto|ooaoL?E+!oc+oeUo+CooitUauu|oCON+iE+iE++ou<ooyte|oe2E+NocipCeoeuuu|oCOE+!oc+tUaoUc*|ou>o*N+uu|onUo+eonUN+i*CiE+oE|fE+ion-to?E+ito?oiipCe*N+uu|E||to?E+ito?oiiE|#E+L*N+N+ioaeuRLoc|E|aou<ooy*+yoA>E+Nto|*>+oCCu4+N+iueCE+No##t<uuy>oL?E+CE|co#At+at2OE|#E+L*N+N+iE+uE+4E|fE+ion-uiao+apCeE+aE+!oc+o+ouu|u#iuLe*+OtoiE+YoULN+ionoo<|o>|t+a*|!tUaE+io+a*c-ta|o##u>o*+aE+ApCe
u+yo<YoeUoc|uYNuu|N+iu+yo<Yoayo+NoAatA#o+eonUE|#o<|*+foiuo<|oa|o<Roa+o+eua|E|nuyoN+ioA>uy>E+Coe#rCL*#Uoaeoc|ueirCY*+OE+Cu!No##oiiE+AE|apCeE|#o<|uCooaeE+yE|aoA#o>|uu|E+ioAa*|oN+ioiuo<|E|fuCooaeoAaE|a*|oo>|uu|E+it+OoA#pCeonoo<|oa+uCo*o2o-uN+i*#UE|fE+iua+uaAoaetc+E+i*#UpCet+ouRLo##oAyueE*O+ta|uLeE|nuyotUauaAua+N+iE+auLCoEA*+yuy>E+iuootLftUaoL?t|+E+eo<iueEpCe
ueCE+Noeuuu|oCOtUato|ooaoa|o<Ruy>rCLoieoL?t|+rCYtUarCorCoonoo<|oaeoL?t+aE+e*UeoN+pCU*#eoN+E++N+iE+atLfu!utUaE|nuyo*+yuy>o+uoL?t|+E+i*oUoYoN+iE+CueiE|noA#E+CueiE|n*|opCe*+Otoiuu|o+Aof|uL4oA-*a+oL?oEiE+CE+-ofAo+eoci*+c*iiN+iueCE+Nto|ooa*oau?ioYRo++o#ApCeo+Aua|t+oo|oN+io##uy>ocaE+|t+|E|AE+CE+-*a+*<-E||uo+o+atUaoEeoEiueo*iiuL|oe|pCe
2021o||10uLe12uuNN+iE+!oc+E+eu|+N+ioL#ooUt2OtUauo>E+yo<Yo|+oaepCeuaaN+UHector Retamal/AFP via Getty Images
oEAuYNoy+ocioAauyAE|ao+auLeuiaE+Yoef*a+tUauo>E+yo<YN+io++o|o*ouoa|E|a*+OE+-E+iE++oU+ooypCeE|#o<|tUaoA#E+ioaiuy>tc|uANueot+Ooiuo<|N+i*Ciuy>oaeE|nt+Ouo>E+yo<Y*+OE+-rCLE+!ou|E||rCYpCeoA-uLeo+oE|#o<|ti<*<nuo|oe#*|opCU*CiE+ou#iou<ooyoEAN+ioA#ueiE+UE+Auo>E+yo<Yoeu*+|*+4t+Ooiuo<|pCeoaeuRLE|#o<|uo|oe#*|ooEAoAi*Ci*>|u#iuo|oe#N+iua|o-uoiuo<|tUaoA#N+ioeuoiuo<|E|foA>E+NoA+ue+u+yo<Yto|*>epCe*+Ouu|oCOoy+ocio##E+UoaeueeoA#ueuE+AN+iE+it+OE|#o<|N+ioAiuu|*+coaNE|e*<<onatEau|Ut?iN+ito#o||oA#uYNoenuu!*#UuLetEapCe*+OE+-*<+*<itLi*|+uYNo+et<CoioN+iE+aoEiuu|E+YoULE|aE|#o<|oAioiuo<|tUaoe-tceN+iE+CE+io!Eo##*ouo+CE|aonoo<|o>|t+a*|!tUatua*OapCeto?E|auo>E+yo<YE|ioEAN+iE|nuyoocAo-4E+eouOoicN+itLfu!utUa*+L*+Yta+to|ooaE|nuyoE|fo##o+CooiuO<oAeE|apCe
*+OoA-uy>oa|E+!E+CE+-E+io!EN+io+ouu|to|ooa*+y*<+*<iE|ao+eonUuL|oe|N+iE+oou?uy>E+|E|a*<-oOitofE||E|iou|uc|o<eo+aoL#oUUtofuaApCeE|fu!uocaE+|*+Oua+N+ioaAeBay*+OE|c*N+uu|oa4oA+o+oo||*+coaNE+!oc+uu|E+UrCLu#|oLfE+iuLirCYN+ioa|E+!E+CE+-oAfocao##uy>ocaE+|u#i*ouoa|oN+E+iE++ou<ooyrCorCoE+!oc+u|e*||*Cao>|oOitofE||oAit+a*|!tUaE+iE++o|aN+iu>o*N+uu|E+Ao+eonUpCeE++E+-E+io!EN+ieBayE+i*<-E|#o<|oAioiuo<|toUE+itc|uAN*Uot|+N+iocaE+|o<au>AE+Ct4oE|nuyooa+*aUue+ueEN+iuiao+aonoo<|t+o*+co||oA#oU+oU+E|nuyopCeE+a*+Otoi*<+*<i*<-u|e*||*Cau#iu|o*+?*|eE+iE++tUaoULtoipCetc+oAiN+ioy+ociuAEE+cE|arCLoy+ociuu|uu|rCY*+OE+-oi|uu|*Ueon-o+Noa+N+i*<-E|#oiuoAiuu|oA>E+NoL?E+ioiooeioaaoeau#foCUN+iE|#o<|uLeE+CE|eou<ooyoA>E+Ntc|uANou<u+auNUN+iE|fo##uc|o<|uyoE|otofE+iE++N+iuLCoEAuc|ua+uaAE+ioiopCe
oOnu!nE|ionuN+iu+yo<YoAioa|E+uE+!oc+o||oA#*+yuLe*>aoeaoe|o|apCUoCCu4+oe|o|aoAiE|e*<<*ouoa|uL|oe|pCe*+OE|ct|+t+f*O+ta|uLCoeYuy>o!aeBayoAiAmazontUaN+iE+aoEAuYNoUUE|ao+eonUuL4oLfoiutUauo|oCaN+iE+oou?oAeo>|E+!oc+u|e*||*CaE+iE++o|aE+AtUauaaoa|pCeu>ooaeu+yo<YtUa*>aoeat|+t+fN+iE+UueeE+CE+-t<CoiotUauC+oeauiaoeaueEooaooUuAA*+#uy>oEat4aoEepCUoAa*|ooCfo|apCUuLioeiuCUo|at!et!et+aoi|N+i*+yo+ooaNE|auyft|opCUtUcoaa*+OE|ct!et|ouactn|N+io##uy>E+|E|ao+<oe-to?ue+uc|o+2oUUoenuu!pCUo+|t2iE+iE++pCe
*+OE|coL?t|+oe|o|atLftUao+eoa|oo<pCeocaE+|oaeuRLu#iuLe*+OE|c*<+*<iN+io+eoL|oAeE+A*Cao##E+UuLe*>#ocaoCaoUcN+ita|oYAuo|E+-E+ot|+pCe
o+ota|N+i*+OE|coe|o|aE|fE+iuy>o<it+AtUaN+iuLeo+eonUu+Au|RpCeueaoL?E|aociE+oou?uAo*<?*+c*+OE|cou<ooyN+iu>ooaeooao<|oe+oiopCU*+fo||oA#tA-ti2uie*CUo+atUauoaE|ipCe*+yuLeoaAuo>E+yo<YtUa15on-uiaE+YuLfN+io>|ufEE|coLC*aUoo+uu|ou|o-i*>UtUaooUt#+N+iu>ooaetoio!EN+io##u#ioeRu|oo<ioa?E+YoUL*|?ocApCeoy+ociE+CE+ioayo+N*+y*+fuea*<#*+cE+CE+-E+io!EN+Uu|Ou#fuLeE+-uYatUaonot#|te|oe2oN+oEaN+ionoo<|oYaoAutoaocR*|!pCeE+aoEAuYNE|#tUaE||*|euYN*|eonUN+iuLeE||oAatA#oa|oUoE+io>|E|aN+io|o*>Nuy>oiuo<|oU+oU+u++*+cE|aoa|E+uE++o<LtUaonot#|pCeocaE+|o||oA#E+etUau|>u|Et|+t+f*+yE+ionfo<iouaN+i*+OtoirCLE+Nu4ioaaoN+rCYtUaou<ooyo+eoU+uYLt+YpCe*O+ta|uLeoL?t|+*>aoeaoe|o|aN+iE+ao||oA#E+etUato?ue+of|uo#onoN+ion#oA+E+Cue|oi+o<oE|fu#ioa|t|+N+i*+yuLeoAaE+Cu|orCLof!*ALrCYN+i*|aoA+*o2o#UE|a*+y*a+ociuu#o+CE+CE+-oaioiupCe
o#+t<iE|A*Uot+aoa4oA+o+|t2itUaoe|o|auLeo+eonUou<ooyN+iE+auea*oeo+uuC+E+o*Ci*?C*+yuy>o+#ooio+eonopCeuCY*CaE+CE+-E+ot|+tUaE+Lto?N+ioLC*aUueetA#te|oAirCLoAitA#o<RrCYN+ecounterfactualN+euYN*+c*iiu>o*+aN+UoaeuRLto|ooau#iuLeoa|*|+N+ioeuueaE+4tUaE|nuyotA>ooaE+Uuy>E+CE|eua+N+foA>*a+onoo<|*+yuy>oL?o<RE+oo|uociE|#oeuocaua+uLeoOEtUaE+L*N+N+ioCC*|oocaE|AE+ioA>*a+pCeo#noa|uy>oL?t+Au|Au>o*+a*E+oEAtUaoL#oi|N+iE|#E+L*N+uc|E+iuu|E++pCe
uLeE+Cu<|uu|ou|N+iE|A*Uot+aoa4oA+*o2o-eo+uo+eua?N+io+eonUE||*>|E+uE+4uy>t+Au|AtUarCLoE+*iCo4+rCYN+itoU*c|*oeo+u*+OE|coa4oA+oR<E|aE|fu#ioa|t|+pCeE+auea*<#o+uo+ouu|uLeE+itaot-|E|A*Uot+atUao!a*CaoL?tn+E|no-AE+oE+eoAaE|aE+CuYio+euLeuaAuCYtUa*||uucN+iE+u*>|N+UueaE+4E+i*a+*>|*+OE|coa4oA+E+Cuuauy>onapCeua|E+Cua|N+iE+auLeonUE|au#iuiao+aE|#oe#E+iua|*aUtUaE+L*N+oCCE+iE|aE|aN+fuLeonUE|au#iuiao+aueiuL|o+yoL?oc|tof*+aE+eo##ue+E+iocRuYNE|aN+focaE+|tA#oL?to|ooaoCC*|oo+euu|E++pCUoA2*+ao||oA#uLe*>aoeaoe|o|aN+ioA+uL|uLeoe?oecE++oe?*+yueiuL|t+OE+apCe*+OE|ctLi*|+uYNo+euuNo++tUao#AE|iN+ioa|o<R*aioEAoa+uy>E+Cuo|oNuoe|o|atUauE!o+|N+iuy>E+iE++tUat|>to>N+io>|E+!oc+tUao+#ooiuy>o+eu+#*+LtUapCe

E+ao-AN+U*+OE+-oe|o|atUao+|t2iN+ito?E+atUa*>|u|ouy>rCLo+|oe|onuoiarCYN+eInstitutional Outsourcing N+eN+iE++E|Auy>uicuo+o|LuLeuaAueeoe|o|ao+|*<+tUao+NE+Lonuoiat+Oto|ooaoUUN+iE+aoA>E+N*ouoceE+CE+i*+OE+-uaeo+|oEuN+f*+OtLftUauy>uo+o|LuLeuaAE+|E|ioEuN+f*+yuy>to|ooa*c-*|2oAao#otUarCLoYRooauLft+ouRLrCYN+f

oeyt2iE|iN+UueaueC*>|tUarCLo+|oe|onuoiarCYoa|o<RoA>E+NoeaueEE+ntoit#+oRipCe E+Ctoiuy>rCLuy+uCoonuoiarCYN+iE|fo##uy>uo+o|LoCA*+cu!uo+AoiA*<<N+io#aoa?oeaoe|o|ao+|*<+E+Aueo*iitUa*Ui*a+onuoiat+OE|A*Uot+ao||oA#E+UE+UpCe*+OE|coEeE+LoCUo++uLeu+auNUtUauucuL4E+Yui<N+iuYa*|uoeauyAN+iuyAti<uy+tn|oc|uo+o|LtUaE++oe?uaAoc+pCeu>ooaeN+iE+!on<tUaoAi*|-oa?ou?uc+t+AoAioy+ocit!+t+#oiA*<<N+ito#oy+ocio+|o+|oAi*Ue*UUocauLioiAoe-uA?oe?oAiooaE+U*|+*|epCUoy#*iau|oo+iouAoO-t!eo+NE+LpCe*+Ot#+oef*a+uL4*|2o>|o||oA#uYN*>|u#iuLetc|uANooaE+UocRueNN+iE|fE+io#RE|Aoa|ua+o+aE+UoeiN+io||oA#oaeuRLu#iuLeuo+o|LuAeuYaE+AoEeE+LN+ionouaetAcE+iE+UE++oe?ue+uia*+OtoiuAN*+arCLueou|orCYtUa*oA*e#pCe*Ci*+Ot#+oiA*<<oa|o<RoYRo++uO<oUiN+iE|f*a+u+auNUoAiuyaoc|uo+o|L*aioEAtUauo+t!u*<+*<ipCe
2014o||9uLe19uuNN+it+Aoc+t|+t|a*>Uoe+E|nuyoueCN+ioy+ocio+|o+|oecoeRE||oa+ueo*ii*auE|io-4E|ao|atNYocaoco*eitN?u!uo+AE+eo+epCeuaaN+UAndrew Burton/Getty Imges
oAaonuuLeE+Ct#+o##uy>rCLoUEuCoonuoiarCYN+iuictUauy>uo+o|LoL?u#iuLeu!uo+AuucE+|pCUoEeoEiueuoa4o+Cou#uyAtUauaaoa|E+iN+io#aoa?oeau#+tEa*Ui*a+o+y*<+uCooL#*+4to#E+UE+Uue+uiaN+i*Ciuo+o|Lo>|u!nuuoE+iuyAti<uAeuYaN+iE|fE+iE+Nua+taUu!oN+itoU*c|oL?ufEE|cuaaoa|E+i*+yt+OE|eoUEuCotUao+ooe#ueuE+YuenpCe
E+i*+cN+i*+Oocio+aoi+o+|*#aN+Uueao||E+iuy>o#aueCuLeuo+o|LrCLE+iE+LE+|rCYoa+t!eoEiE|AonuoiapCeueC*#ooUEuCoonuoiaN+io+aoi+uy>oL?uo+o|LtfNuaapCUoa+onctcat<i*a+oecE+aoCeui-E+io|#ooatUauaaoa|N+io+Co+Cuy>oc|E|Ao>|t+Au|AoAao#otUa*CaocAN+iuLeuaA*<-E+UE+Uoae*ii*>oo-ipCe
E++E+-E+io!EN+Uto|ooao||oA#tUa*<+onUu#+tEaoef*a+N+iE+ioaeuo>E+yo<YN+ioa|o<Ruy>oL?u|oo+itU#*e#oL#o+aE+!rCLoo+rCYoc|uYNtUapCeo+oo||uo>E+yo<Y*+Ot#+t44E+euu|uo>E+yE+et|+uu|u|oo+iouAoO-o+eonoN+io-4E|atoU*c|E+|E|ao<+ua#oayo+NN+i*>|N+UrCLoaeuRLuLeE||ocau!noYEteoN+iueaoA+pCerCYE+uE+4oa|o<UE+et|+tUaoEiuu|N+iu>AocaE+-uLe*aUoEauo+o|LoaOueNoaeueNoaeuaaoa|N+iueCE+Nuo+o|Luy>tfNuaatUapCeueauLC*+aE|foE4E+CE+ioiuonouoOuAeuAEoe#N+Uoa|o<Ruu-uLfoL#uu|uo+o|L*+yt+OE|auo>E+yo<Yo+eonouo>uiUN+io+ouu|uo+o|LociuLeo+eonUE||E+oou?tO+*<#u>At4ouo>E+yo<YE|nuyorCorCoE+auu-uLfuo+o|Loaaoa?t|+t+f*+yu#iuLeuo#E+ioiuN+ioA-*a+E||o+N*<#o+oN+io+NE+LocAo+eonopCeE+a*+OE|c*iiE+|N+io#LE+|E||tfNN+iocaE+|uo+o|Luy>oUEoL?o|ooEAtUapCe
uc|oa|oo<uy>N+io||oA#*a+rCLoo+rCYoc|o+|onooe|o|atUaoeiuAEN+iuy>E|oE+UuL4*|2*a+onfoo+uLfo!yt+!N+iE+ooL?oa|oo<ueEoo+uLfoaauL-oU!*+cuu-ueu*+cE+Ntcat<ipCe*+Oo||oYR*c-ta|*Cita|pCeto|ooauy>E+CE+-ue-o+a*+aoCfpCUoa#oc+uRUo+|tUaE|oE+UN+io>|E+at+foc|oo<pCUoca*Rioa?ou?oCaueEo+?onooAioecN+iE+AE+Co+CooiE++oaau+iE|e*<<pCe2010o||E+uN+ioc+uLeoo|*iipCUo<RE+oooao<|pCUtoU*c|o+Nooaoa?ou?onUu4ioa+oEUo+|oiutcat<iN+iE+aE+!on<oCeui-E|arCLoiao<|o<iuaArCYtUauCUo|aN+ioi|oaeoaU*<+oAao#opCUo+|oEA*oa*iaN+iE+|E|oE+UtoOoc|*c-to#t-|ou|pCe
*+Oua+tUauCUo|aE+ioA-oAeo>|to|ooapCeuYAoaio+|uC+tEaoL?2017o||uc+uC+t+o*>|N+UrCLocao||oeio+<E+ioeUoc|tA#tUauu|oCON+itc+oa|uu|oYoE+i*|RueEtUaou#of|E|fo+eonoN+iE+aueaE+4*+yuy>oi|E+AE|a*+Otoiou#of|N+ioa|o<UoaerCytLiE+CtLioai*oa*iapCeoaeuRLE+iu#+to?*CUoeRu|ooA+t<ioe|N+io##oA>*a+u#iuLeE+eon-tUao+<E+iE|aN+UrCY*+OtoirCLoi|E+AoAioecE+ioe?ueirCYtUaoCeui-N+ioa|o<Ro##uy>E+Ctoio+y*<+oAiuo>uiUpCe
uLeE||oA>*a+E+U*>|N+iuo+o|Lo+ouu|E|iueCE+NE+iE+ioaNN+iuy>ocaE+|rCLE+itfNoUouCAE|et<irCYpCeE+a*+OE+AueatUaoC+*+ao||E+itfctc+pCe*+OocitUarCLE+itfNoUouCAE|et<irCYN+iE+iuy>uo+o|LrCLE+i*a+t<irCYtUauaAuCYpCeo#+t<io+ouu|*+yu#iuLeo+|t2io<iuo|tUatcat<iuiauR|N+iE+aE+Au|oo+iE+A*iiuo+*|au|EE+etLiN+iuo+o|Lo<ioa?uLe*a+oecuo|oi+to|ooao||oA#N+iE+ooa+oncoaaoeatUau!uo+ouCoE+Yui<pCe
2010o||oeit44E+euu|uo>E+yo||oA#o#UuL-*A+o+uu|oo+iuAeuYaN+co+eoo+E+Cu<|uu|ou|ociN+ito|ooa*iiE+UuO<oUio!yoL?oU+t?Au+At?AN+i*CirCLoL?o<|o+Ct+ao|urCYE|fo+eoo+uu|ou|E+ioEe*oaN+iocaE+|E+it4aoEeoLfoL#to?oCotUa*oao<UpCeuo+o|L*iNua|oc|ueiN+io||E+it+|ueiu<|pCe
*+OociueC*#orCLE+itfNoUouCAE|et<irCYN+ioa|o<Ruy>rCLE+itfNoUouCAE|eoL?E+iE+no<|uu#t+Au|AtUaoeiuAEE+iuLeuoet<ioe|rCYpCeuo+o|LuLe*a+oectaUu!oo||oA#N+io##oaeoEioEAuYNo>|P2PtUauo|oi+E+Cua+N+iE+ao<au#iuLeo>|to|ooaE+Ao+<E+ioccoAuoEiua+*+>o+apCe*+Ou!u*>|uyAN+U*+OE+iuy>uuauaAE+|E|iN+i*Ciuy>E+Ctoiu+#uCYtaf*OatUauo+t!uoCeui-pCe
ocau!nN+io#a*+OE|coe|o|auCooef*a+*oaE+|to|ooaE+UE+UrCL*c-oAaoo+oc|uYNrCYpCUuo+o|LrCLE|ioEAueitfNrCYtUa*oete|N+iuy>o>|E+!oc+uo+u#+t+Au|A*+EE+LoC+*+atUa*>>*>+pCeuea*c-o+#oL?o#UuL-o#oo+Co<RoL#*#ataoE|ioeiN+iE|fuc+uiUuLet#+E++tLiu|oN+io+ouu|o>|uo+o|LoL?*aioEAue<u+otUa*oA*e#t+|E|Aoa|u|?N+iocaE+|rCLo+y*<+rCYo+Co+CoU+E+NoCA*+cuyAuy+tUa*iioe?*oeo>foe#pCeE+aoEAuYNtUaonUoi|*>Uui<*<-ueaoCEu!Nuo|oAyE|a*oete|pCeoauoaeN+i*<nE+|uo+o|LrCLu>2E+itfNuaarCYtUaoUc*<+N+iE+AE+#E|aoa|oL?*|a*<>uo|ocaE+AouAoO-*+?*>auu|oYotUa*a+oecpCeoa|u4iN+i*+Otoi*oete|E|fo++toNE|auYN*c-E+at+foa?ou?pCUtoU*c|oc+uLe*|auL4tUauo+t!uu++*>|oAioecrCorCo*+OE|cue|*>aou#of|E+ioA>*a+E+i*o2E+aoCA*c|oa|t!uo#epCe
2017o||11uLe12uuNN+ioy+ocio+|o+|ocaocotUarCLoAioiUE+CrCYoa?tEa*|!te-*eeuLfou|N+io#Ao|ouy+tn|u!uoL?E|nuyotUaooaooUuC+E++oC+pCeuaaN+UAly Song/Reuters/*++o+uo+#oaA
*iNo#a*+OE|ctA#*#it+<E|AE+!oc+oa+E+ooc+uaaE+!*oeo>fN+io##uc|o<|uyotEa*ouN+Uo>|E|AE+CE+-oAao#ouRUo+2pCUooa*aauCouRUo+|pCUE+oto#toU*ENE+UE+UE++o>+tUauu#oa|E|oE+U*Ci*?CN+i*iNuo+o|LoL?oa|oa|oo<ueEoo+uLfoo+uu|ou|oCeui-E+io|#ooaN+i*aioEAocaE|Ao+ata|o!yoL?ufEtoit?io|atUauo+t!uo<+o<|E+Ao+y*<npCe
o+oto|ooaoAeE+Atn+E+Uu#+tEa t2>E+ao-AN+UueaE+4oAatA#to|ooao||oA#oAao#o*|+uYNN+iuaouaoo##E+ioiouy>to|ooaN+i*Ciuy>toaueCo+?on|N+iuy>E||o+NuO|*a+oAiuo#ui<oa4oA+N+ioeutA#oL?rCLo+|oe|onuoiarCYuy>E+iuy>o+#t+A2.0oy|u<|E|aN+fE+aoL?E|aE+!E|fuAEoe#onooa?oeatUatLUt|ouo+o|LoAiE+!on<oa?ooooa+*+foy+ocit!+*<oueytoNoiA*<<pCe
oeyt2iE|iN+Uuy>tUaN+ioa|o<Ronuoia*+OE+|E|iE+ioA-oAatofoL?uo+o|LoAito|ooao||oA#E|iou|pCeueaui+to|ooao+oE+io!EN+iE+aoaOtUauy>E|A*Uot+aoa4oA+tUat+noaAN+iua|*>|uyAE+CE+-uO<oUitUatA#*#irCorCouo+o|LoAiE|A*Uot+aoa4oA+E|iou|tUaoEeE+LuuNtceo>aoecpCeueaoL?E|aocioeuE++E|aE+CE|cE+!on<oa?ooooAitLUt|ouo+o|LE+Ao||oA#oa4oA+t!+t+#oEeE+LoiA*<<tUauieE+iN+iE+aoeuoa|o<RoA-uy>o+eo#AE+Coa?oeapCeocaE+|oEat|ouo+o|LoAio||oA#E|iou|tUaoEeE+Luu-o+#oYRo++uO<oUiN+i*+Ot#+oEeE+LuLCuu-oA>E+N*++u|>oe#oiUocao||oeiN+i*CiE+oE+it<itcat<iouAoEauCAE|e*+4oAyN+i*+Otoiuo+E+UoEeE+LE+AuL-tLfu!uE+!uu!*+cpCeoa|o<R*+yuLeo+eonUoYRu!uo+AtUaoEeE+LN+iocaE+|oA-*a+E+A*<+*#eE+!o+utfNN+it+|E|Aoa4o+C*|a*<>E|noAeo-i*>UN+iocau!noL?E|aE+!ueaoCeui-u#iuLeoa?oa?oaO*+coA+pCe
E+CE+-*|euYN*|euyAuy+tUa*|ioe+uy>N+U*+OE|co||uYNN+iuo+o|LueeoEat#+u#+tEa*Ui*a+onuoiat+Oo||oA#tUauaaoa|*|euYN*|eo++*oUN+iE+iE+a*iaoc|ue-onoE|aN+io+oo+AE|fuc|oe|o|aoiupCUuc|oEet|aoiupCe*+Ot#+onuoiauu-o+#E+ioOEE|At+Au|AueuE+at+fueou|oooaoffN+ioaeE+eoL?*<+onUtn+E+Uu#+tEapCUtoU*c|uo+u#+u#+tEaooaoffN+iE|foa+*a+tLioe#o||oA#E+UE+UtUa*|2o+#pCeu>ooaeoAi*>eo-upCUueouiEpCUo##E+Utcau|ipCUtn+E|no-AE+ooaao<|o<iufNt!eN+i*<+onUo+NE+Loa|o<Roa+uy>uo+o|Lt+OE++oeiN+iE|A*Uot+aoa4oA+uYNoe|o<Ut+aoeOpCUoiAoe-uo+o|Lueo*iitUapCe
*Ci*+Oocao||oc|tA#tUaE+CE+-uu#oe?oEauy>N+UoAfuL4o#RE|AtoU*ENooaofftUatcat<iE+ot|+N+iu!uoL?E+Auo+o|LtUaoa4oa#tcat<it|+t+f*+cE+Cu!N*RioEepCeE++E+-E+io!EN+UtA#oL?E+CE|conuoiuo||oA#o+#t+AoAiuo+o|Lo+|t2ioEeE+LuL|oe|pCeoaeuRLuLeu|e*||*CaoEao+eoL|tcat<ioa?ou?ueo*>eonuoiuonEoAaN+iuo+o|Ltcat<ioa?ou?o+Co+CE+iE+UE|#*c-onatEaN+i*Ciuy>o#a*|a*<>*+4E|nt+Oo||oA#N+ito#o||oA#uYN*|f*|uoEAt+!tUaufNonaE+Au#foCUpCe*+Otoi*|a*<>oa#E|2E+A*Ui*|uoeao+NN+io+#t+AueEE+|E+Ctoioe|o|aoiutUao+yoNapCe
E+aE+UoAatA#N+itA#oL?o+eonUtcat<ipCUueou|oN+itoU*c|*oaoeOtUaoe|o<UN+ioa|o<Roa+ta+E+io+Co||oA#uAEE+ctUauo#ui<E+Ao+|*<<pCeo||oA#E+ioaioA-uy>*o2tcat<itUao>|*#iN+io<aE+4E|fo+#t+AueEE+|u#+tEa*oaoeOtUaoAeE+A*CaN+itoU*c|uy>oe|o|a*<+*<i*CaE|iE+CpCe
2020o||11uLe11uuNN+iE+!oc+oiuE|4N+ito|o!Eooa*|+o+?on|E|4E+Loa4oA+uC+oa?onooAaN+ioayo+NoL?oAe*oeu|+oe?E+auU>uLfou|uaaoo+oe+uiitaoN+io|atNYoaeuui*eepCeuaaN+UKevin Frayer/Getty Images

E+ao-AN+Uoo+uLfE+NuYNN+ion<oL#uo+o|LpCUtLUt|otUaE+eE+it|ouo+o|Loa+oYoo>|E+iuU>o+<tUaou<ooyN+ioaeE+eto|ooauAiuAionoocAuo#ui<N+iuy>E+iuy>o>|E+!on<uo+o|LueutLUt|ouo+o|LuYN*>|uy>oAaE+CE+-oa|t!utUaE+iuU>uYNu|EN+fueaE|fua|*|+uYAoaio+|uC+tEaE+iuy>E|fuLeE+-uYAoaio+|uicuo#oEuN+fto|ooauo#ui<E+UE+iE+UE|f*a+ueEE+|uu#tUat+Au|AuO|oc?*i?oAioa|t!utUaE+Yui<pCe

oeyt2iE|iN+U*+OE|cuo#ui<tUati<ueEE|aoa|t!u*CatUaE+CE+-uu#tUa*|a*<>uYNu|EN+i*CiE+o*+OE+-*|ioe+oa|o<Ro+euu-o##o+CooiE|apCeoaAoiUonUo||oeiN+ioc+o<|t+f*<io#Co##o+#t+Ao+Cooi*+fE+CE|cE|A*Uot+aoa4oA+oEeE+LN+io#Y*>oto?onouo#ui<uYN*iN*||E+at+ft+f*<itUatc#te|N+ite|oe2uy>oaAE+!o#AE+UE+U*+OE|c*+coA+t+f*<ioAuo+aociE+ion-o<|uyouiouietUao>|*#ipCeo||oA#E+UE+UE|fE+UE++oe?oAao+aE+CE|cuicuo#N+iu>ooaerCLoaLuYato|ooaoAao#ouicuo#rCYpCeuea*+coA+oUUto#ocAtUauu|oCOoAatA#N+iuLeE|coL#uu|uo+o|LtUao<yoay*+yoa|u|?*+Otoioa4oA+oUUtUauAAoEipCe
*c|E|Ato|ooauo#ui<*a+E+i*a+oAyueEt+Au|AtUarCLuO|oc?*i?rCYN+iuea*oeo+uoA>E+No+oueEE+Co<UtUa*+aoe-oAe*CaN+iE+aE+i*a+on-E+Y*|uo<apCeocaE+|o<aE++*aUoAiuyatUauy>u|e*||ooUoc|oo<t#+tUat+Au|Au|+oe?N+io>|E|AoaAue+o!EpCUoi+tuupCUuoO*e#*+Otoioiao<|o|!uo>oc|o+eonotUau|e*||oi|tc<N+ito|ooao||oA#E+euy>tLiE+ioc|uYNtUapCe
uc|onotUaou<ooyuy>N+i*+Ot#+uo#ui<uL4*|2oa|o<RoO-of|o+eonopCe*+coA+uc+uLeE+Ctoio+eE|E*oetUatLiu|oN+ioaAo-4E|ao##uc+uAEoe#N+ioUA*auonouo#ui<tUaoc|tA#N+i*<ioeAt+Au|AuLeoA>*a+*o2ociuu#onioa|pCe*+Otoi*oete|*<nE+|N+i*iA*UooAiu>cuu|E+utUa*<ioeAt+Au|AE|iueCE+Non#*|NN+iuy>ocaE+|E+iuU>E+io>|to#rCorCoE+!on<uuau|ouAiuAioL#uu|tUatLfo<Ruaaoa|N+io>+*c|*#auAoon#tU|pCU*|au|EooOoaipCeoeuoaeuRLtA#oL?*a+oYaonouo#ui<o<Ruu|*A+oAu*|a*<>N+i*|au|Eoeaoaio##oA>E+NoAyo+uuc|oeao2yuoeN+iE+A*Ci*<-*<ioeAt+Au|Aociuu#ueEE+|oA>*a+pCe
*+Ot#+rCLonouo#ui<*<ioeAt+Au|A*<|rCYoEAuYNoAuoe#o+eonUo!a*Caue|*>aN+iueaE|f*|RoEi*+OE|cue|*>apCeoAfocauLeo+eonUN+iuea*oeo+uoa|E+!E+CE+-uLCua|uL4tUaou<ooyo##uy>uo#ui<*o2uoiuAotUaouAoO-pCeoA-*aUufEE+-uicuacoAi*|au|EoeaoaiE+Ao<yoay*Caua+tc|uANuieoA-N+io##E+UuLeE||ua|oeRu|ooA+rCLgame the systemrCYrCorCoE|fo##uy>oA+oe|o|atUat-|o!EpCeo##oaAuLeE|coL#uu|uo+o|LE+UGDPoCaoUcpCUu|?u#|N+itA#oL?to|ooao||oA#E+etUauo#ui<E|fuLeo+eonUu#|oeaoAioO-of|rCorCoocaE+|ooCocAoAioN+*>aE+Uo+#ooit+ao|uuAAoEiN+iueCE+NrCLoe+oiorCYou<ooyE+Ctc|o!yoL?N+iE|fo##uy>oe|oCa*OUoUctUaE|nuyouo#ui<uYNoa#o2yooCocApCU*ENoCaoN+oAutoapCeoL?ueaE|aocio>|rCLoe+oiorCYtA#*#iE|fuLeE+oou?uAA*+#N+io||oA#oi|E++uLeo+aN+iE|fo+eoU+o<ioa?uYLt+Y*+OE+-tA#*#ipCe
ueCE+N*+OE|co||oA#uo#ui<uy>oA>E+NoAe*CatUaN+iE+aE+Co<U*aUuLeoenuu!oecN+iE+i*a+taooiooa?uo|pCeocaE+|E+Cuuauo#ui<uL4*|2oAyueEuYaoecueuoe-tceoeaoaitUaE+Yui<N+io<ao##E+ioaiuy>E+!t2itUa*oeo>fo+Noa+N+i*CioA>*a+ueEE+|uoio+atUao>|*#ipCe
oa|o<RN+iuYAoaio+|uicuo#tUaoC+*+aE|fo+<E+ionUpCeo<aoCetUauy>E+CE|cu>o*+aoU+oCaoUctUauicuacN+iu>ooaeto|oecu|e*CupCUooU*+>*|o*+EocApCUoo|*iiuo+*|+N+iuL4uYNo##uy>E+|E|ao>|ueuuo#ui<on#tLf*Ci*<+*<itUauc+E+uuicuacpCeE+aoi|E++uy>*+Oua+N+ioaeuRLoo-E+Con-o<atLftUa*o2oa?oYoto?E+Luo+t!u*Caua+tUati4uCouicuacN+iueatc+E+i*+yuy>E+UuLeE||ua|uu|*<+u|ooA+uoiuAoo<apCe

E+ao-AN+Uto|ooaoAao#o*+OE|eonUo||oEAN+itA#oL?u|e*||*CaoA>E+NE|#oe#toit#+uc|onUpCUE++oA#uc|E++o<LtUaE+L*N+N+itoU*c|oA>E+N*>|oaLuYaoL#oi|oL?u|e*||o#eoYoueota|oL#uu|E+YuenE++E|epCeE+atA#oL?E|foc|tA#E|oooUoaaoi+tUaou<ooypCeueaE+4oA>E+ioA>E+N*>|N+ito|ooauy>E+iuy>o>+*c|oaaoi+tUaoe|o|aocat|aN+f

oeyt2iE|iN+U uea*oeo+uto|ooao+ota|E+a*+cE|at2RE|eN+iE+aE+io+ata|o>+*c|rCLoaaoi+rCYpCeueC*#otUaoaaoi+N+ioa|o<Ruc|onUuy>te|o<Uto|ooao||oA#tUaooaE+Ut!utoNoAit2RE|e*oaoeOueCoCaueEtUat+ouRLpCe
2023o||11uLe11uuNN+ioiuE|4o+|ou2t2OtUaocOoiUE+Ct|#*|+t>Co+uoaepCeuoYN+UWang Zhao/AFP via Getty Images
to|ooaoeUoa|*|+tUauu|oCON+iE|iueCE+N*a+uAEE+c*+LE+AE|Ao<RE+oo|utUaE++ua+N+iE++*aUuy>ocaE+|*eetLUE|atofocapCUE||oect!eE+!ou|ueEuL4N+ionoo|aoOiE+AE|aE|nuyoueEuL4N+i*+OuL4*|?E+euy>E+CtoiuoetAcE+etUauAEoicpCeo+ouu|*O+ta|t2RE|eu+CtaeN+iE+aonUuo#oiuo<|E+i*a+*|Uoe#oA#N+i*CiE+oo+eoL|E+etUaooaooUE|foL?E+iuu!ooU*|?oict|opCUooUteioiuN+iu|e*||*CatUaE+oo-ioAyoN+pCUoCeui-oAyonUpCe*+Oua+tUat2RE|euy>oN+tUaN+iE+i*a+t<uE+Loaaoi+pCe
E+a*+coA+oiUo||N+ioUA*auo<A*oet+Au|Ao+ooe+tUaoAyoiuN+ito|ooao||oA#tUat!utoNE|foAatofE|auyAuy+*#auo|pCeonot|aoL?2010o||E+uE+!uLfN+ito|ooaE+Utoioc|tA#E+Cu|ooa|E|AuL-uYN*|ioe+tUa*<?*<|pCeE+Ctoi*oete|*<nE+|E+!oc+o#a*+coaNrCLu|e*||oict|orCYoy|u<|N+ioUA*auuo|oaNuAEo2yN+iu|e*||*CaE+Uuc|u|?ociooU*|?oAiooUteiN+iua+uaAE+|*<+*<ioAiuLioeiuo>E+yu|oE++pCeo+ouu|oy+ocioAiE|4E+Lof|uL4ue+o<Y*+OE+C*+>t|+N+io||oA#E|foC+oEauA?*iEuLeooUteipCUooU*|?*+ao2ytUaooaooUpCe
E+aoAaE+Ctoi*oete|uicoc|N+iE+!oc+tn+E+UtUauo|oaNoeaoaio2yo|aE+io||t!eN+iE+iuLeonoocAu|e*||*Cao>|E++ua+oYRo++uoAuafN+iuL-uYNuc|oA>*a+*|#oEarCLu|e*||oOit|orCYpCe*+Ot#+o||oA#E++ueoE+AE++ooaooUN+itoU*c|uy>tO+teiE|oooUpCeui+onUonUo##uy>oL?*+Oua+tUao+eoL|t+YoUOE+!*+aoCfo|c*|+pCeoUA*auoEAuYNt+Au|AE+i*iioAioecoeaonoN+iu|e*||oOit|otUa*|ioe+uc|*||*+atA#o<RN+iocau!noy+ociE+AE|4E+L*+Oocao||E|foOat+!*#auo|t!utoNN+iuc|oeaoci*oaE++ua+uoAuafoRiu|e*||*CatUao+eoL|pCe
E++ueoE+AE++uL4*|2E+iuy>ou<ooyN+iE+aonoo<|uiao+atUarCLoaaoi+rCYN+iuy>ocaE+|o||oA#*+co|a*++u#eE+AE++N+io>+*c|oiuo<|ocaE|Au#iuLeoe-u|aN+itoU*c|*o2*+2E|AuL4ooCoo<pCetLi*|+uYNu|e*||*Cao+uE|ao<RuaaN+iE+L*N+oAyE++o<LE|aN+iE+aoa|o<RE+Uo+auYNE+nE+-oUEueuN+Ut44E+CN+iE+|E|aoAiE+AueEuL4N+iE+CE|cooao<|oA>*a+E+UoU+o+NocAuuOpCUE+Nu4ioaaoN+N+iuLCt+eoeuo+Uo-#oCE*e>o+UN+ct44E|iN+ito|ooao||oA#uL4*|2uy>E+CE+-uLet+at+Luoeo|otUaoAi*+|o+eoL|N+ioA-uLeoiuo<|ua+uaAtoOE+iuYNN+iu|e*||*CaueiE+UuLe*||onftUaoCeui-pCeoaeuRLoiuo<|uAaE+iE+ioA+pCUt|+t|+oCCoc|N+iu|e*||*CaE+oo-iE|fE+UE+ioOiN+itoU*c|E|fE+U*+f*auu|Uon#N+io||oA#*c-*|2tUaoAao#oo##E+UoO+oaNuU|uCoo+-tA>pCe
ueCE+NE+Aoo+*+LuYNtLiN+io||oA#*+yuy>o+aoi+oL?E|#o<|E+Aoiuo<|E|iou|oAuo+uE+CE+-oEetEatUao||*iiN+i*CiE+i*a+o<ioa?oUAoEaE++E+oE+Cuu|N+ioEaoeOo>|o||oA#tUaoo+uLfoAao#oE+ioe-pCe
Sat, 20 Dec 2025 05:11:40 -0000
--
Mobot
If you have any comments on this article, feel free to reply to this post. However, for feedback on the bot, please post in the cn.fan group.
--- Synchronet 3.21b-Linux NewsLink 1.2